Skip to main content
Loading video...

Playthrough + Review | Cave-In

Transcript 41:45

let me just have a cup of tea before that so um I would have at least something nice to drink before I fail hey everyone this is effectas today I'm bringing you my playthrough and review of Caven a game I featured on my channel already but now the designer Michael ersek has provided me with a physical production copy thank you very much for that Kevin is a solitaire game about operating a mining business which takes place over 12 turns or months from July 1602 to June 1603 so just for one year exactly each month you move to a new location attempt to safely activate works there then ultimately sell your Goods at the market you need to make calculate decisions along the way and reckon with the effects of weather and pursuit of your financial goal alright I will structure today's video like this I will show you how to play the game play through completely then and then give you my detailed review feel free to use the timestamps to jump to the part that interests you the most though you'll receive full points if you watch the entire video alright let's get started with the setup and my playthrough oh the tea is still a little bit too hot but I will have enough time for it to cool all right so let me just start with this setup first um and then I can show you how to play the game

all right and that is the setup of the game so you can see um it's really cool because this was a printed play project at the beginning right and now we don't have cards anymore but we have tiles also we had cards that tracked our inventory and all our money and everything but now we actually really have like really cool cardboard money here um which looks really cool as well and also we have like these sheets that help us and we have these little tokens so everything is like this really is a quality of life upgrade seriously so I really enjoy that um because um there were actually two videos I had on my channel um the first one was the first spring Play version the second one had already this design or very similar one I think and now that is now the um probably the last video I will make about this game because I've already made three videos about it but I had to show you like the reduction copy that you can get at gamecrafter but I would say something regarding that um later on all right so let's just start Play okay so what is our goal we are in death so we actually need to raise money to repay that debt um by the end of the game by the end of one year right so we will start out in July and at the end of June next year we will have to have like 200 pounds to pay off our loan um this is the win condition um if we at any time have the 200 pounds and we can pay it off then the game ends we don't have to continue playing until June but it usually takes that long for me at least I'm still not really good at

the game also it's a pushy luck game so it is quite tough actually to win um also very luck dependent and you know my luck in games is not the best um we will lose if we don't have the if we don't have the 200 pounds by the end of June so by the end of the 12th month and um or if we at any time have zero pounds at the moment we have 50 so that is our starting Capital so to speak and a round always starts with laying out the 12 cards here in the middle just like I did here putting the 13th to the side that will be the market price for later on um and then we have here our calendar we will go to July take to the next month it will start in July now which is um a month with good weather conditions that becomes important in just a second and then we take five pounds and pay the bank that is um what we have to do every month paying the bank because we are on that loan right so and that is the upkeep phase and now we go into these drilling phase as you can see here so this also kind of reminds you of what you need to do drilling costs five pounds each and you could do that twice a month if you have good weather conditions and only once if you have bad weather conditions right so we have good weather conditions now we can drill twice drilling means that we can um take like we um can drill like three cards in a row and um just like all the way down from the very top to the very Department like this would work or that or this

right and we could then um see what is under that right drilling does not mean that and we are Excavating that will be later so if we actually discover a cave in that will not be triggered also we will not mind the resources drilling it's just for kind of seeing what lies underneath kinda uh helping us with that luck aspect we have right so um I would definitely pay five pounds I would actually pay 10 pounds because I want to do it twice um so I will just roll down right yeah I will turn down here so that's dirt and copper and copper okay and then I will also drill down here okay copper I would have liked to see a cave in there is one there's another cave in some place it could also be that car so we don't know there are only two cabins in the game and maybe the one is over there we don't know so now we can excavate excavate Works a little bit differently when we excavate we actually buying resources that we need to sell to get money right and we can also like discover cave-ins and then that um that excavation effort is ended and we need to pay a penalty of either 20 pounds in good weather or 30 pounds in bad weather right so that is something that we do really don't want to do um and we can drill like three up to three cards you see here for one two or three types excavated we pay five eight

or ten pounds um so and but we can we can actually like no we don't have to Rhythm like we don't have to activate like this all the way from the top to the bottom we can also just have we just need to find three cards in a row you need to be sequential so we need to start with one and then go to the next one and the next one and we need to continue so these need to be adjacent details right and also stable so I cannot um activate this one here because there's still two at the top first I need to excavate these two in order to be evading that one and those are the three rules for Excavating um I would definitely pay 10 pounds oh I don't have a whole lot anymore right so if I if I discover a cave in now I would almost lose the game right so let's excavate three tiles just hope that this one here is not a cave in so we'll start here and then go down here so this one and then this one here two okay and then this one three so these are the things that are excavated that works so and now I'm not 100 sure what I should do um if I if we only activate one tile I can just pay five I could actually just push my luck and just activate another three times and just hope that there's not a cave in there right um so that is one thing that I will have to hope but let me just have a cup of tea before that so um I would have at least something nice to drink before I fail all right okay so

um you know what let's risk it um I will just exchange these for four fives here like this and then I will actually excavate three more tiles so regarding excavation um so I know that this one is worthless already there is a cave in some place I'm pretty sure well no Maybe not maybe Kevin is also there we don't know so um what I think I will do is um I don't know let's just dig up here someplace so let's go here here and then down there because I want that copper because I know this is something good so I only have like a one-third of a chance that this is actually no I don't have one third of it I can't do math at the moment it was a long working day so I'm not done doing math but I'm gonna activate these three so oh that's actually tin that's good and then that dirt and also that copper so and now I would have enough to excavate again but if I now discover a cave in then uh I lose because I only have 15 I couldn't pay a cave in so I already was very risky so I'm just gonna leave it like this I'm just going to leave it the way it is know the market phase the cat is also kind of the cleanup so we take all these coins here on the monthly expense and we will just put this right here right put that back for next round and then we will flip over that tire that we put aside at the beginning because that will

give us the market prices so if you just turned over like this and now we see we get five pounds for each Copper 10 pounds for each tin and 45 for each bronze and that works in such a way that we um can sell five copper and one tin for that money and you see that's more right so five carbon 110 would be 35 but here it's 45 and that's these are actually all really good prices so I would definitely sell everything I have so let's just see how much we have we have two copper we have one tin another four copper so we had six another four copper with ten another one copper so we have 11 copper and one tin which is not too bad actually wait but that was not a cave it so there must have been a cave in here at some point at some place no cave in no oh that was the cave in actually okay so wow that was pretty close that was really close okay so um I would definitely sell one bronze so that's five copper and one tin and I will gain 45 for that so let me just gain a 20 and then another actually no let me just get small stuff so that is 10 20 30 35 45 is that all right looks like it all right um so we do have a bit of money now we actually have like 60 or something that's not too bad we have more than we started with right we had like 50 at the beginning now we have 16 that is good but then the month will be bad whether

these are really gonna screws over and then I have six more copper I will sell all of that and that's six times five that's Thirty so that's 10 here and another 20 here so we are now at 90. we almost doubled it so we already have 90. now you might think well that's easy just do another round like that and you're almost done yeah well I was lucky with the Kevin right I will experience probably and that will not be too great all right so and what we do now we should start a new rounds right so we just do it like before we are taking all the tiles here there we go I will just give them a shuffle like this that's fine um also maybe just give them a cut here okay and then we will just put all the stuff in here again so that is three four five and then we'll just build a little Tableau here again like this and there's always one left over you will just put that here um later on for the market prices like this then we go to August and we also pay our five pounds for each month all right so we are able to draw twice again I will definitely do that I will do it twice again so let me just pay these uh these 10 pounds here um so

I think I want to draw these three here okay these are all good I could also just throw these and then I would have already well except for that one but then I would be kinda safe kind of depending on what is there we don't know that right but you know what let me just do that oh okay okay wow no cavings then the caveens must be here probably at least one cave and is going to be there maybe one is over here I don't know um all right so these are all tutorials now we can excavate we can excavate up to well three times um so I would definitely pay 10 to excavate these three towels here I mean they can see those that's fine so for copper is not too bad so if that is not a cave in I could just excavate these so that's what I'm going to do start here oh that's good that's a tin then the dirt and also the copper okay nice so but what am I going to do now I could push my luck and excavate here but if I activate here as I have the I have to like turn over at least two of those and that's a pretty high chance I will turn over a cave and so I think I'm gonna leave it like this for now I could also push my neck because this round is only 20 pounds opaque per Kevin so I could

actually risk it if I wanted to I don't know what I am going to do all right I've come to a conclusion I will risk it and that is a dumb idea because risking things is not something that I should do but let's do that so I'm gonna pay the ten full 10 pounds because it could actually pay for caving and I will activate these three because I have a smaller chance that I will um I will uncover Kevin because I already know that one so okay good ah Embassy Kevin okay so now I've just stopped the excavation immediately because I discovered the cave-in and I have to pay oh no from not from there and I have to pay 20 pounds as a penalty okay but we got the copper and maybe we can sell it for that 20 pounds and at least and lose anything right so that could be possible okay and that was it so um now we because I accelerated three times that's all we can do so let's turn it over five pounds for a copper so I didn't actually lose anything right I was able to risk that that's fine okay so let's see we have eight copper one ten and then we have wait no and another copper another three copper and another tin and oh we don't get too much for bronze this time as you can see so bronze is not very good this time but the other stuff is pretty good so um I don't know but we don't have a whole

lot so I would definitely have to sell some stuff um let's say one tin for ten and 10 cup of 50. yeah that's 60 at least oh I should have well 10 20 30 40 50 60 and also I need to put these in here I always kind of miss that um so and then I still have one copper and one tin uh so that's 10 20 30 40 50 60 65 85 let me tell that one copper then I'm at 90 so I'm I didn't I didn't gain well I gained 110 I had 90 last round I have 96 round but I have one tin more I could sell the tin but I think it will be better later if I want to actually smelt bronze so I think I will just leave it like this yeah I think that's fine all right let me collect all the cards again almost the other cave in then up there at the top okay well that's yeah well that's bad oh no wait what am I doing like this all right so let's Shuffle these up again like that I think like that it works and then we'll order to be cut and then we are fine so one two three four five

seven eight nine ten eleven twelve like this and now we are actually entering September which is a month with bad weather conditions and that is not too great so let's go to September I will pay my five pounds here for the bank and then let's get started so this is a month with bad weather conditions so we can only drill once uh let me just roll right down here the middle pretty much I think yeah copper copper copper okay oh man oh man oh man because I would really like to get this one here right I would excavate uh but now if we have a cave in it's like 30 pounds right but okay let's give it once I will activate these three here I will start with that one so in case that's a caveat I don't have to stop like um I at least get that one copper it's dirt okay and it's copper so I lost 20 pounds so far um five copper could potentially be like 25 25 pounds so I didn't really win a whole lot yet so I think I will have to continue I am a little bit afraid to be honest what if I just take these here that could be possible you know what

let's just take this one row and just hope that okay Tim that's good dirt that is better than a cave-in and Tin wow that was good I'm gonna stop now I'm not gonna push my luck any further because there's gonna be there's bound to be at least one cave in here maybe even two so I'm just gonna leave it that was lucky that was really lucky Okay so then we will put all of these in the back I won't forget now and that was actually a Haven okay so um we have good prices for bronze okay so we have two tin and we have five copper that's a whole lot but I can actually smell five copper and one tin for one bronze which is 45. so let me just look here that is 30 40. oh that's not quite enough okay then let's do let's do it differently then then let's take 20 and then here like this that's 45. okay so we now have 40 50 60 70 80 90 105 so we're actually now over that um eight pertin is not that great so I'm just gonna leave it for now I'm gonna save it for when there's a month that gives me better rewards for that but once you have a cave in then no no there okay well that's one way that's one way to do it okay so let's just Shuffle those up

just a little bit like this okay so then we can start getting mixed around one two three four five and then the next row with four and three as usual all right so we're now entering October which is a month with better weather conditions weather conditions again that's that's good that is good and you have to pay five for the bank here take that leave me alone all right we will be able to draw twice again which I will definitely do so let me pay Tim to draw twice ah let me let me do like what I did in the first round copper copper that looks nice you know what no let me also drill down here okay wow you know what I just need this not to be Kevin all right so I will excavate I will activate twice so I will put these 20 here already right um let me do the first excavation these three here surprise surprise no caving wonderful and now I will excavate down here no Kevin please no oh come on okay well that costs me 20.

uh but I will do another excavation because I need these two at least but I'm not able to dig a33 because these are not stable because I need to go up there first so I will just pay uh I think it's eight right it's eight for like two times activation excavation I mean so let me just um exchange these for like small stuff which I can't really do only four there should be a fifth in there shouldn't there um well let's do it like this let me just take two back yeah let me just do it like this that's fine that works okay um and just activate these two and that's it I'm gonna stop that is it what was under this card please no cave in nope it was dirty um where was the other cave in oh oh up there I wouldn't have excavated there so I could have gotten another tin Maybe yeah but it would have been the same pretty much okay so um bronze gives us 45 okay let's first we have four copper another tin another four copper which is then here and another three copper nice nice we can get some cash together here by the way if you ever exceed 25 copper or 510 you have to sell the excess amount immediately just by the way right just say okay so um we can definitely smell two or two bronze because they

give us 45 each that's great so 2 and 10 here so that is 90 that we get let me put all that back into the bank 90 okay so that's 10 20. 30 50 70 90. okay good good I like that we are really getting some serious money here 10 20 30 40 50 60 70. 90 once 110 130 I think we no wait I think we have 130. that is not too bad we just need a little bit more to actually win the game okay we still have one team which is this has ten that's a lot as well and copper gives us 15. so we could also do that right you know what let's just sell all of that off no let's not do that let's leave the well actually but no no let's let's not do that let's get some copper and smelled some some prawns at some point okay so we are doing the next round oops so we're actually doing pretty well at the moment I think that might be one of the best games I have played so far but now I've probably jinxed it and I would probably lose now that is the price you have to pay for jinxing things like that especially when you know how unlucky you are and games

Okay so we're going to November I would have to pay five bucks there you go all right so um I will definitely drill once I can only draw once because of bad weather conditions we will have like four months of bad weather conditions now so I would be very careful from now on I'm gonna just roll down here right the middle to the left okay okay okay actually drilling doesn't help me at all because I never uncover any any cave-ins that's really bad I lost all that money for drilling uh I will activate once at least I don't know how much further I will go I will excavate these three here so dirt thanks and then copper and another copper so I could stop now right that's six copper I spent 20 pounds that'll be okay I'm covered and I would have like 10 pounds plus I could just leave it right but there is like that tin here so if I just went down here I would have that tin and that would be really really good to a risket if it goes bad then I lose 30 pounds is it worth it I don't really think so to be honest I don't really think it's worth it I have a lot of money at the moment I just need to go get through this month and then I have like the good month and I expect in March I can try to win the game so I think I'm Gonna Leave This one out I'm gonna be careful I'm going to be really careful but no one I know no

but also there would have only been one tin one copper so it's not that horrible okay so then let's see oh no good prices here at the moment I don't know so that's six copper we get oh these prices are not that great I think well the copper is quite okay actually so I could sell to Copper which I will do um for 10. I always forget to put those back like this and I will leave those here the five copper and one tin for a good bronze month because this one is not a good one at the moment okay there would have been the two Caverns there yeah of course okay uh then next round yeah something really enjoyed this game but I will tell you a little bit more about it in my review okay come on there we go okay and then we go into December I have to pay five pounds pay oh and I have to pay pay five pounds for these blood suckers here all right so I would definitely draw it once I can only do it once because of bad weather conditions and it will just dig uh throw it away down here again copper and thin again okay that is not too bad

okay let me excavate once at least and I will activate these three here again so getting some dirt getting some tin and the copper I could stop now already again I definitely have that money's worth back again plus like potentially 10 pounds more I could risk it now I could risk it but I don't think I will do it maybe I should risk it once at least you know because then I can say you know what I actually took the risk if I risk it then I will have some issues but I do have quite a lot of money so I could actually cover it hmm I don't know but maybe I will do it actually you know what this is I can't always just play safe right so you probably want to see me fail or want to see me take some risks so you know what I would do it I will actually isolate once more which is a really bad idea probably but I will just do it once more because I want that tin but then again well not too late because I think it's only worth 10 and I just spent 10. there needs to be at least one copper in here all right let's start there's actually one copper okay and this now more copper please at least no caving okay okay and now we'll stop it will be stupid to continue here I'm not gonna continue all right so so first of all these need to go back to the back I always forget and the prices are good for copper great so one Tim

two tin and five copper so I would definitely sell to 10 and 10 copper for two bronze which is 90. it's 10 20 30 40 50. 1790. oh wait do we no I think we don't have quite enough money yet but let's see 20 40 60 80 that's 100 10 20 30 wait 10 20 30 40 50. 60 70 80. we have 182 pounds we just need to make 18 the next round and then we actually win the game and that would be the quickest game ever and now jinx it again and it will probably not win but we are in a really good position I think I will really now start playing a little bit more carefully so I will not risk something like this round again because it wasn't 100 worth it right not really but well okay so because I have like the other try two times I played the game I'm pretty sure I lost both games so you know what I really want to show Michael that I am actually able to win the game which I really am I have wanted before and I want to show it on the channel so let's just hope this works oh there's already my 10th recording today of this game just hoping I will win for once no just kidding it's still my first recording okay because otherwise I would

not be as Jolly as I am now all right so um we go to January I will pay five pounds okay now we don't need to get 18 we need to get 23. oh no not there there okay so come on come on we can draw once I will drill once you know what that's my lucky spot you oh wait 10 at the top oh and it's in at the bottom oh that's really tempting these two teams will actually push me over the edge with these two things I would win you know what let's activate twice here again as usual so one two one third another turret so um the 110 is definitely not enough to actually cover the expenses I had so I should not do it I shouldn't do it but I will go on here again I want that team

or copper two copper that's good that's gonna stop that good yeah okay did I actually gain more than I spent I don't think so 10 20 30. I'm about even but that's okay I'm just waiting for that I'm just waiting for March right okay that is actually not a good month to sell so I think I'm not going to sell anything so I have one ten three copper and another tin and I think I have enough money to actually cover expenses so I will not um I will not sell anything because that's a bad month for selling okay and you see I'm really lucky right I'm really lucky I had like one cable I think uh in six rounds which is really not a lot I'm really lucky and I'm still not winning yet this is a really tough game to win seriously so if you ever played which I highly suggest you do um it is tough to win but it's really tightly designed it's not unfair or anything right I mean it's a push it again right so of course you will have to be a little bit lucky to be able to win because if you never take any chances I don't know if you can actually win I think you will have to take chances at some point Okay so so um we go to February I pay five pounds

and we can still only draw it once but next month is the it's the month where I hope that I can win okay so uh what did I want to do drugs right I can only throw it once and I would read the same spot again you know what I will just continue I'm always hoping to maybe like uncover one of the cave-ins okay so now I spend 10 pounds and this is just dirt so if I actually want to get something I would have to probably activate these three here promise that one or two cave-ins here I can also go to the right for once all right um okay what am I going to do you know what I will uncover here because I can always activate then that here and get like four copper for sure right and that would be more than I spent so you know what I spent I would spend 10 here to dig these I have to activate these three I will start here one copper okay and for copper yes okay let me spend a note 10 here to also excavate these three because I want that copper here and I think I will stop for now I spent 30 and I got more than that back yeah I got more back and that's it I'm gonna stop because there is gonna be one or two cables in here and I want to wait for March okay

so let's remove all of those and we have a decent month month to sell but I rather want to sell that sell it bronze so we get another four copper another four another copper and another tin okay I would have to sell very soon because I don't I can't hold Too Much Anymore wait actually let's just count all that up maybe I can already win so I have I have 20 40 60. that's still 100 120 I need 80. I can get 40 here and 12 times 5 that's 60 that's enough that's enough so that is 60 right here um and then I can get 40 for that tin and I think we got it that is 20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 that's 200 200 pounds 220 pounds 222 pounds 222 isn't it isn't that an amazing amazing score so you know what bank here you can have your 200 pounds um I'm loan free um and I actually won the game in February after 246 after eight rounds eight of 12 rounds that is the fastest

ever won this game I was really lucky here um and that worked really well it looked kind of boring I guess because I was only thinking on the left side almost all the time but you know what it worked out I don't know I don't know it somehow worked out okay well that's my playthrough of caving but how do I like it well let me tell you again this time in more detail than the other two videos first of all I have to say that the theme of the game is fascinating and very unique um which is not something you come across often to design a micro Earth egg was a geotechnical engineer uh it's all like written at the back of the rulebook here and it shows in the execution of this game's theme the game really does create the feeling of mining every month avoiding cave-ins and earning money and integration of the theme is seamless in my opinion the artwork in this game is really nice I mean like the copper and the tin are in the the caves are really nicely Illustrated I like that the worn look of the calendar inventory and the monthly expense the coins work really well as well too you have like these uh these heads here at the back of the coins so really nice attention to detail the talents are now more durable than the cards used to be before and the tones and coins an excellent replacement for this car tracking system overall the components are designed really well and the game provides a great quality of live Improvement the game is extremely fun with a great push effect mechanism that always keeps you on the edge of your seat however the game's High difficulty can make it quite

brutal especially in bad weather conditions and there are severe penalties for cavings as you could see keep this in mind while playing the game this game would look really easy but just check out my other two videos and you see how bad you can actually lose I do have some reservations about the game's repair ability as it essentially offers the same gameplay each time but if you enjoy this type of gameplay and this push your lack mechanism you will undoubtedly get a lot of it here all in all I totally enjoyed playing this game it is unique theme great components and offers a challenging and fun experience if you don't mind the high difficulty and what you saw on this review interests you you should definitely check out cave in on game crafter one last thing I want to mention this is specific to gamecrafter um so I'm actually done with this review if you just wanted to see how Kevin works then well I'm pretty much through but that's one thing I need to say about gamecrafter um and that is when this package arrived you will be greeted by this message here that the towers have residue on their sides after punching them out and that is a grave understatement it was quite a mess you'll need a slightly wet cloth to clean everything off these tokens here after cleaning the towels and coins everything is perfect um so you can just see here just take a look here how dirty all of that is I kept all the towels in the cloth so you can see how much that was just for these few coins right just a few coins and these few tiles here um these look really nice now right because I cleaned them all off but it

was a mess it really was a mess everything was dirty I was happy that I did not do it on on the play mat otherwise I would have probably destroyed it and um so here I could probably show it to you but I don't want to right now because I'm like I don't want to make everything anything dirty but this year is still all dirty um you should see the difference here quite clearly actually or maybe not on camera but this is all really dirty still and um it will show if you just punch them out so after cleaning the thousand coins everything is perfect in my opinion this game is definitely worth it displayed this slight inconvenience um so if you so I want to play the game and I really encourage you you do because it's a really well made game I really enjoy it but just keep this in mind right just make sure to use a surface that you can actually make dirty and that you have like a wet cloth you can wipe everything off like not a not a really wet not any not too much water because it's still cardboard right but just wet enough that you can clean all that off um it will take a while but it's worth it and this is just a game crafter thing I don't know if all of the tones are like that I haven't ordered that often um like game crafter things yet um there is actually a package that will be arriving well when this video is published um so I will probably have picked up the package yesterday so to speak um so I would actually have a game crafter package coming in because I finally ordered something there so I don't know

maybe um I will see if that is the same for each for each game don't let that hinder you from buying this game because it's a really good one and if you want to try it first um I think there should still be the free um print and play files online for the old version I'm pretty sure that they are still accessible and that's it my playthrough and review of the game Kevin as usual I'd like to thank you all for your support that means the world to me I especially want to thank my patrons who are generously supporting me on patreon the biggest thanks called rutheno who's currently my biggest supporter I'm so grateful for that seriously if you would like to support me as well check out the link to my patreon in this video's description and take a look at the tears I have come up with there but as usual I'm always thankful for any likes comments and especially subscriptions by the way you can also join my Discord server if you'd like to hang out with me and my community all right thank you so much for watching I will see you in the very next video or America server take care everyone stay safe and cheers

man

Progress saved