Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Crew: The Quest for Planet Nine Review - By Board Of It

Transcript 11:12

hello farrell and tally here from board of it and today we're going to review the crew the quest for planet nine and from here on out we're just gonna refer to it as the crew because there's no way we're gonna keep saying that long ass title the whole review and the crew has been everywhere over the last few months and it recently went into board game geek's top 100 and it's just been rocketing upwards see what i did there ever since and since the hype hasn't died down yet we gave in and decided to i think the reason that we're so initially resistant was that the crew is a cooperative trick-taking game and that term literally zilch to us luckily trick taking isn't that hard a concept to understand and the term isn't actually as scary as other terms in board games such as engine building or network building economic game the short version is that a trick is where every player plays a card the first player decides what suit to play with their first card and then the player who plays the highest number card takes all of the card and therefore thus wins the trip and what the crew does different is it takes a genre that's otherwise ultra competitive made it cooperative this game plays with between two and five players and it added a little story and it added some variants for you to work through making things much more exciting

so the game's theme is based on a space mission to an undiscovered ninth planet beyond pluto and this provides the framework for the trick taking you'll be doing one of 50 missions every game you play and these will have a little narrative description at the start so you might be astronauts undergoing team building or you might be trying to repair damage to your ship the game comes with five suits pink blue green yellow and rocket and then these are all shuffled into one deck and then the entire deck is dealt between all of the players equally the pink green blue and yellow cards are just normal numbered cards whereas the rocket suit has a special ability if a rocket card is played it will always win the trick unless a rocket card of a higher value is then played however you can only play a rocket card as the starting card of a trick or if you have no cards that match the current color of the trick this also applies to the normal cards for example if the current trick is blue you have to play a blue card unless you have no blues available in which case you can then play another color to lose the trick or a rocket card to win the trick then you'll pick a mission which will provide you with further setup details once you've picked a mission you'll find out who the commander is which is the player with the number four rocket card the commander then gets first pick of the task cards and will also start the trick the missions will

usually tell you to have a number of task cards and the task cards will match a card in the deck and the goal is to win a trick that includes the card on your task card in this example i would need to win a trick that includes a blue five the difficulty increases as you move through the missions usually with the addition of these tokens which for example might force the players to complete the tasks in a particular order or complete one specific task dead last you are not allowed to discuss your cards or talk about the game as you play but each player is given a communication token to help your team this can be used once per round if you place it at the top of a card it indicates that it's the highest value of that color you have at the bottom that it's the lowest value and in the middle that it's the only card of that color you have and that's pretty much it it's so easy to pick up you could teach it to a dog

well maybe not then now before going through what we like and dislike about this game we should just declare that we are trick taking noobs so we're not sure we were the game's target audience that being said let's get into it what we like is that it's quick to teach and to learn because it's a simple concept given a twist now the concept of missions allows the developers to pack in a lot of variety in this small box and what i'm really impressed by is how a deck of cards and all these tokens well a few tokens can really alter the game play and find new challenges game to game and mission to mission also what we find really intriguing about the crew is the amount of strategy it generates from just three simple ideas number one being the fact that you can win any trick with a rocket card number two being that you know who has the number four rocket card and number three being the communication tokens when you combine these all together it allows the players even though you're working silently to do the mission to come up with a strategy to best win the mission also you just it just leaves you feeling like you have just enough information in any one situation to be able to overcome the difficulty and beat the mission unless you get shafted the one thing that the crew can't control is the run of the cards and this is kind of an obvious problem with this type of game sometimes a mission that should be super

tough is actually piss easy and other times you deal out the cards and the task cards and just know you're going to fail almost instantly but this is a pros and cons situation as the randomness is also as to the almost infinite replayability of this game and it's definitely a game that you could be breaking out for years to come another thing that we very much enjoy about the crew are the concepts of missions and this is because they're breaking the gameplay into these little bite-sized pieces and it makes a really nice change of pace when usually you're playing two to four hour epic sessions but the reason that this is so i don't know pleasing is that it creates little breaks in the gameplay organically when you have to reshuffle and set up the next mission so then you can chat to your friends organically have a chance to go and grab a drink like get the snacks and you know it's a nice change compared to usually if you're playing a longer game and you know you decide to go break for whatever reason and then you've got to keep your strategy in your head for the next five or ten minutes the concept of the missions really helps with the difficulty and as these missions go on they get more and more difficult you're probably gonna be trying and failing over and over but because no mission should last more than five minutes and it'll be even less when you fail it makes you want to keep trying on the face of it this game has very simple mechanics which trick you into thinking i'll get it next time and because you all you need to do to

restart the game is shuffle the deck and redo all the cards out it makes the crew uber addictive one thing to note is that the difficulty is going to scale with the number of players now the rule book addresses this and it kind of states that three players is going to be easier than five players but it actually gives you uh some tips on either how to make five players less difficult or three players more difficult which is appreciated also we tried out the two player variant and it's a little different than the main game but it's still good but we did find it quite easy but i'm pretty sure that i've read somewhere that on board game geek there's variants to make it a bit more difficult so we might have to look into that uh now unfortunately the the story in terms of you know it frames all the missions it's pretty it's pretty pointless it's it doesn't add anything and the game would be the same without it it's just a bunch of space jargon to make it sound exciting and impressive so i mean for example the control modules are indicating a malfunction in the drive you'll need to perform a thrust test and it doesn't mean it's just a normal trick it doesn't it's not a particularly exciting mission and in fact this could be any other theme and it would be played precisely the same just off the top of my head you could do each suit is a dog breed the rocket cards would be dog trainers and doing a trick is teaching a dog a trick and this wouldn't change the game or the mechanics at all and it would be

exactly the same so it makes it kind of kind of surprising to me that they've like leaned a really leaned heart into the story and i don't really see the point of like pushing so hard on it so the crew doesn't really have any hard negatives but to us and as we said like this probably isn't maybe the game for us we just find it a little a little dry like at the end of the day all you're doing is playing cards like that's it and i know it's fresh and it's a twist but you are just playing cards so you know i think it's quite a nice game for like like sessions or to maybe get like get people into gaming as like a first step but this is only a minor issue because there's gonna be people that you know they love this this is what it's for so this is just our personal opinion on it we think the biggest pro besides the gameplay that pushes the crew in the direction of a must-have is the price point it is very cheap relative to other board games we've seen it for around 10 pounds or 15 and that in itself makes it a game worth considering and now for the final conclusion the crew is a bit dry but it's also engaging it's a game that you're going to be constantly resetting and going again every time you fail a mission until you emerge victorious also if you beat it first time you're still going to be high-fiving everyone around the table knowing that you've beat the game and

you can feel smug about it whilst we wouldn't personally dedicate an entire gaming session to this it is a really fun game to play as a warm-up to a bigger gaming session or to play on more chill evenings or with family and we don't personally think that it's a must-own game but the low low cost of this box combined with the variety that it provides demands you to add it to your collection and if you liked this video we'd love it if you could give it a thumbs up and please subscribe to our channel for regular board gaming content and doggos and if you have any questions about the crew please let us know in the comments and we'll get back to you bye

Progress saved