Skip to main content
Loading video...

Paradox Island Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel

Transcript 2:55

And then we have Paradox Island. So, Paradox Island has a really cool theme. It's called uh it's from Hobby World. It's designed by Stepan Opalev. It's an adventure deduction game which all players except one will be exploring the island that only one player can see. By moving blindly across the island, players will be recreating the map and try to complete their missions. So, one person in this game is the omnipotent paradox, the OP. And that person has an island out here and everyone else is kind of just stagger around this island. They're going to have a sheet of paper and they're moving around this island trying to find different things. But, there's all kinds of bad things out there that can get them. Each person is something a paradox. Like, for example, one of these people is Theseus, uh a robot. And then instead of being the ship of Theseus, he's the a human Theseus. You know, being Is he still the same guy at the beginning? He's been replaced all his parts. And that's that's what this is. There's all kinds of these paradox things. And that's a really fun theme.

But, that theme is barely there. Each person has very It's like Oh, it's a asymmetrical game. Each person has very strict you know, like a very specific goal that they have to do. But, it's mostly go here, collect these, get this. And not one point does it ever really feel like your theme come to life.

And so, you're a captive on this island. You've been sent here cuz you're a paradox. And one person's controlling it. So, the OP is sort of a dungeon master in this game. And I just found it Again, this might just be me, but I found it to be overpowered. And I felt like even though he's playing against the players, you have to pull your punches or they're never going to win because you can win, too. The OP can win the game. And everyone else has to do a a certain condition maybe five times or whatever, and whoever completes their mission first wins. And the pieces for the game aren't particularly great. It's kind of confusing what everything is. There's a bit of deduction, which is interesting. Um but it's it's both too open and too closed at the same time. It feels too restrictive, but also you have no idea where anything is beginning. You're just moving randomly, and you can move into bad things or spots when you hit them, then you you move across the tile to another spot, and I never felt like the the players who are the paradoxes um are making really strong informed decisions.

So, this game for me is another five out of 10. I really wanted to like the concept of the game. I think the art on the front is fun. The theme is so cool. But the theme doesn't really translate into the gameplay. It's nah, I just don't like it.

Progress saved