Skip to main content
Loading video...

Episode 172: Xoe Allred on Non-Hierarchical Games

Transcript 49:17

it's ad brick time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations 500-year old vampire Jason Cox's Cooperative role playing game is now shipping and even better there is a Halloween sale for orders placed before the end of the month clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con and the next one starts today October 14th veteran instructor aloy Lanta will be teaching when world's meet mechanics turning fiction into games it's going to be a great class and there may still be time to sign up so check it out also if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com onol and help me keep the lights on but for now let let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson be on solitier and this we get a PO of a very special guest uh Zoe alled uh it is a game designer who designs interesting semi-cooperative games and games that I would say are non-traditional in terms of their parameters and I really want to explore that today how you doing Zoe I'm doing great thank you for having me on yeah I'm super excited to have you on so for people who might not know your work uh what are some board games that you would like people to know you for so they can go look them up oh um well well the one I'm most known for is persuasion um that's my relationship game um inspired by PR and Prejudice where you're um sending letters to each other and trying to figure out who to marry and um maybe catfishing somebody um and another game that's um um might be self-publishing soon is a game called bread where you're

building uh an engine for sustenance and a famine that where there might not be enough bread for everyone oh that's really interesting okay I want to play that now um so I I kind of want to start from the very beginning so you've mentioned in a couple of your YouTube shorts and stuff that you were initially more interested in video games than in board games so what was your past with video games like and what kind of led to that shift well um I've been playing video games for like a very long time like ever since I was like uh three years old um my parents got me on it as a way of building confidence because I wasn't talking um but I was just very into indie games and I um and I just think that the games as the art form was like very appealing to me and I feel like Indie video games kind of hit like that stuff like more publicly first um and so that's where a lot of my attention was captured and where I thought I would have to go if I was to start making games and it wasn't really till like I started um uh plain um like route that I started seeing like the story telling like capacity of like board games like I know ttrpgs are very great for that but like um I I craved something a little bit more structured and I saw that in rot and I was like wait I could um my experience would actually work really well on this platform in this medium and

and things kind of spiraled from there that's awesome did you work on any video games before becoming a board game designer or I I have worked on a couple of prototypes that like I play tested like a tiny bit but like it's so hard to iterate on video games um it's and also it's just yeah it's just a lot of work there's so much that has to go into making like even just a Bare Bones prototype functional and then you test it it's like well I got overhaul a bunch of stuff and that takes so long I'm also really interested you mentioned that um you liked root because of its structure like I will admit that I see the potential ttrpgs but I also have a really hard time committing to them because I feel like it requires vulnerability of me and creativity from me that I don't necessarily want to express on the fly yeah yeah I so I I don't I I love ttrpgs don't get me wrong but like I feel like there's something very different from like um a game like a ttrpg like asking you directly to explore like certain topics emotionally and narratively like with your imagination and a game sort of I don't know tricking you into that with like a structured like framework of like mechanics where it's like okay well I'm moving these bits and Bops but um suddenly I find myself having to make decisions that are narratively like

heavy all right perfect so this is actually just where I was hoping we would go we got we got went right away perfect um so you know I guess that makes me want to ask then so what is it about the structure of games that you find that you like to manipulate to get people to go in a certain place I I think um I I think the thing that is most interesting to play with are like Victory conditions um because like a lots of the designers have talked about how like the uh like how you win is like um like is more important than like the actual winning or something like that and um and I very much believe in that but I feel like in that vein single Victor games are like incredibly narrow in that respect and that it's almost always like a contest of like comparative strength or um comparative domination and um even if like narratively the game is saying that you're doing some collaborative effort like if it's a single Victor game then it's telling a very narrow story of like of like Triumph of like a single person and then if it's a Cooperative game it's a similarly narrow like story of like a collaborative effort succeeding or failing so when you start playing with like the victory conditions that are like kind of like between that space that's about like where it's more malleable of like like um I could win

but that's an independent thing from you winning then you start getting into like to storytelling spaces of like like I I have everything I need from the get-go so do I spend the rest of this time securing my like self and ensuring that I have a very solid future or do I spend that this opportunity to help like the other players also win like there's like suddenly more like social space to explore with that because like in the single Victory game it's like you're in the lead and it's like well you're just going to keep getting in the lead you're not going to help somebody else get in the lead so am might making sense yeah and it also leads to so how do you do that in a way I guess that helps a game stay compelling and that incentivizes players in the right way because I kind of feel like you choose a victory condition and then you design the whole game around what it is that you're trying to get players to do and so you set a goal and then you work backwards from it and everything in the game is depending on that goal so like without that kind of through line in a game design what do you do yeah yeah it's It's tricky because it's like important that you give like clear goals and motivations to the players um because then they might just like they don't they have trouble engaging if you're just sort of like here's a system um go do whatever in it like um surprisingly people are pretty good at figuring out how to do stuff in those kind of environments but I don't feel like it tells us a compelling a

story if there's um a lack of clear like motivations that you're providing on like a narrative level um so um so to keep that tension you you you do want like I like this is why like I um drawn towards like these situations that are still have like a lot of conflict like I'm not like compelled to work on games that are just about like collaborative efforts like because um like projects where everybody wants the same thing and is able to win together is not as interesting to me as like projects where like multiple people want things that are in some way conflicting with each other and there's potential for collaboration but there's also like potential for people to just go their own ways and only one person is toed so um I like situations where like your Victory is maybe a little fragile like um I think a a common thing that a common problem I have with play testing is that um people are used to games where once you achieve your your win state the game ends so a lot of times people will be play tesma games and they're like okay I have the bread so the game ends now right and it's like no you actually have to survive the entire famine event you can't just uh um you you have to be able to keep that bread the whole time and uh and then people sort of realize oh well this is actually incredibly fragile because there are people could take that bread from me um so those are the kind of situations I think are like make for a

tense like experience where it's like it's multiv Victor and that everybody can win but like while you're in a Winning State and the game timer is still taking down it's possible for that game state to change really fast and for somebody to like upset your like stable your like um your cozy situation all right so like let's talk about bread since that was just brought up an example how exactly does that game work in its current form so in that game you You're Building like infrastructure and that infrastructure is either trucks for like exploring and Gathering resources uh factories for building more infrastructure um and then bakeries which is how you like qu your unrest which is like the thing that every like player needs um there's also some like weird infrastructure it's it's like in the same uh category but it's it's a little different weird it's there's unrest which is like the thing that you need to remove from your like your base in order to survive the famine and then there's walls which make it harder to interact with the other players so in that game you're you're kind of um like using your truck to gather cards from the main deck and as you gather from that deck you uncover more unrest that has to get played to other people so more and more unrest comes up as you're playing through the game and near the B of the deck there's like a cataclysm

that triggers the end of the game so the game is like trying to find bed bread and build it and try to hold on to it for um long enough that you're able to qu yourr and um and yeah so there's an Impulse that a lot of play players have to kind of play it like because like uh uh it doesn't really look like a Forex game but a lot of the like actions are kind of in that similar vein of like exploring expanding exploiting um there's not really Exterminating um but uh in a systemic sense there is um so uh there's an Impulse to sort of Follow That same tradition of like find the stuff to build an efficient engine to become more powerful and um and and then uh secure your Victory condition near at in the very end but in doing that you're likely to have um but in like centralizing all of your resources individually you kind of have a inefficient engine and that ends up kind of accelerating the game end State and so the like actual optimal strategy is to like collaborate with the other players and like specialize and and kind of make very vulnerable decisions were instead of delivering Goods to yourself you're delivering

Goods to somebody else and hoping they follow through and deliver back to you so I take it it is possible within the game for everyone to win and to have it yes it was very important to me that I maed out that like no M like on the with the exception of some very specific like um deck structure Randomness like everybody would be able to win so there's a small chance that you would not be able to win um but it requires like extremely calculated decisions and doing things that you would not normally want to do an engine builder like sacrifice part of your engine so somebody else could have a slightly more efficient turns oh that's really interesting so if players do players know going in that they could all win yeah yeah the or at least the game tells them that they should in theory be able to all win so you tell them that upfront does that how does that influence their behavior do you find that players do actually try to cooperate or do people find themselves getting greedy even though they know perfectly well they don't have to well when I first started um testing the game I was less upfront about that and people would play very selfishly but as I've been doing unguided tests where that's is stated clearly up front I'd say that the percentage of people that play collaboratively has increased significantly and I've actually had to balance the game a bit for that oh

that's really interesting but it's not guaranteed like I guess it seems to me maybe I'm just a care Bearer but I'm just like oh yeah I mean obviously if we can all win we should all be trying to help each other right like that seems so obvious then I look around at like the news or whatever I'm like wait maybe that's not obvious yeah because like maybe three people in your group are playing collaboratively but maybe one person is like well that seems stupid I'm going to make sure I have bread and I'm going to take from you to make sure that I secure bread and that one person is enough to kind of throw a wrench in everybody and then all of a sudden you have this additional problem that you have to account for like do we build walls on them do we do we try to disarm them by giving them bread even though they're playing selfishly like um creates so yeah oh god um what about watching play test of this game has surprised you or maybe just not surprised you like what do you what have you learned about human behavior from from from observing them play your game um I I really love watching play tests because like sometimes things will come up in conversation where like somebody will be like wow this game is really mean and then somebody El be like um I I I I have been able to play without being mean a lick like I I think you are choosy to be so people are choosing violence oh like like people people like

project stuff onto the game like like like this it seems like like a because like a lot I usually I play Tesla with a lot of designers so sometimes the will be like I think you've made like this game that's like kind of in the middle and I think you should just make it fully cooperative and like or are people who are like like like I thought we were all going to be doing a Cooperative thing but in the end it's like it's actually really competitive I think it should be a competitive single player game single Victor game and it's like U but the fuzziness between those two is what I think is most interesting but like people kind of project like oh I think this is supposed to be a competitive experience and therefore and the tools that this game gives me are extremely like like aggressive and like uh and hostile and so um this game is hostile but it's like the game also gives you tools to help somebody at no benefit of yourself and so it's like it's it's open-ended enough that people find things in it and project that onto the game is and saying that the game is like this but it's really there like this okay that's actually that's a very interesting way to think about this so you know um I feel like a lot of game designers put their work into the world and kind of hope somebody will see them and kind of understand what they were trying to say through their work do you feel that your work gets misread or do you deliberately enjoy like watching

other people's different readings I enjoy watching The People's different readings um I'm reluctant talk about this but like um then throw um may they uh like analyze my game persuasion and um he saw it that it was like an extremely like toxic kind of relationship game and um and I thought that was fascinating because like I have like I have like kind of borderline toxic like I'm a romantic and I found myself pushed into like relationships and so I've have like a very like jaded like negative view of relationships and so part of me was wondering like was that shining through is that like what was getting picked up because like in the end I kind of wanted it to be a game that was like about like like showing people that like how important being being vulnerable was TOS making relationships work so when he's when he released that review about how it was so beautifully toxic I was like was that is that me did I did I do that on purpose but now that we've had that conversation I'm like well is it though because now I want to see if the game can be played like almost sweetly yeah well like because most the time most of the time when I played persuasion like like almost everybody except for one or two people and up winning um so like uh I can't I can't remember if he said in that review how like how it played out but I I vaguely

remember the review saying that like like very like only a couple people would end up winning his games I was like how are his games playing out so differently from way I've seen them play out and thinking that was like really fascinating no that actually is extremely fascinating um and I kind of want to bring it another kind of concept you talk about a lot on on your channel and in your shorts so you mentioned that you kind of reject Victory conditions you also really like to talk about nonh hierarchical games what exactly does that mean and then how does that play out in your work so when I say non-h hierarchical I mean that like in a lot of ways games kind of um are structur than the way to imply that there's like that there is a like best outcome or a Best Best Line like um best way to play um and that's where the metrics and the critiques of single Victor stuff all comes into play that like that the player who played the most correctly is the one that amassed the most points more than everybody else and um in that way it's like a hierarchy like that player played better than everyone else they deserve to be ranked higher so um when I'm like pushing the idea of non-h hierarchical games like these horizontally structured games they're games where you it's about like achieving like like a goal perhaps like and sometimes people

will like get like uh what's the word the pantic about this where it's like well if you're saying that there's like a individual goal you're saying that there's like a better worse thing and it's like a binary like hierarchy and like I I guess if you want to fle with it that way but the idea is not so much that like that's um these people who achieve their goal are better than the people who didn't achieve their goal is the the emphasis is that everybody is able to achieve their goal and that there isn't one person who somehow achieved it better than everybody else it's just about giving everybody the opportunity to like Thrive and not placing a judgment of like who thrived better um so I guess that's what I mean when I say like a non-h hierarchical game um and then yeah my video talks about about how there's even ways to like deconstruct that as there should be um so I guess when we talk about wanting to like prioritize non-h hierarchical work and work without victory conditions how does that play in with the games that you personally like to play like you've mentioned that you enjoy a lot of coly work but Cole likes really intensely competitive kind of nasty games and like that is his bread and butter in terms of what he likes to play and what he likes to make so how do you I guess reconcile what you enjoy playing uh with what you enjoy making well um the way I see it is that

if there were more multifactor games I would enjoy playing them like um like there's um when um my God I'm blink his name Jamie um it invited me on to um his channel um we were talking about some of our favorite multiv Victor games and at first it was like a struggle for me because I was like well how many are there um and then like and then the and then like as we were as I was brainstorming with my community and he was like sending me suggestions it was like okay there actually are a few like um like a fog of Love is one that's like that I like really a lot it's just kind of awkward to play with people it's a little more of a ttrpg kind of thing but he also introduced this game called we're doomed to me which um I really like it's a it's like a through and through multiv Victor game where people are potentially like where there's a lot of prisoner dilemma stuff where everybody could be working towards making more seats for everybody but also people are kind of backstabbing each other to make sure they get the first seat and stuff like that and so like and I really like that game but a lot of my friends thought it was just okay so I thought that was curious but I I think that if there were more multiv Victor games then I would like enjoy playing them more but I guess that doesn't really mean that I don't I don't enjoy

the competitive games sometimes like um yeah some I I I like the games that are like incredibly socially like that really Center that social conflict and Cold War these games are incredibly like like socially like uh has a lot of social friction in them and I like exploring those Dynamics I guess yeah I guess kind of push the other end of things it also sounds like you don't necessarily love purely Cooperative games I mean you know in terms of what you make not in terms of what you play yeah yeah so yeah I that one is like something that like I feel like I need to do some like I feel like I need to like do some soul searching to figure out exactly why that is but um there was a um there was a sit down and shut up video recently that was like saying something about how like Cooperative games are like cive in a way in that you're it they're they're forcing you all to work together the the base assumption is that there is no conflict between you and the other players um and like there actually are a lot of Cooperative games that I do enjoy but they're the ones that like forcibly insert a layer of social friction usually like communication restrictions or things like that and those are the games that I really love where you're trying to navigate this like like

communication like problem together and so those are the ones I really love like space team is one of my favorite games and that's a game that's just chaotic trying to solve a problem in a short time time frame and with lots of like social wrenches being thrown into the mix so there are a lot of Cooperative games I like it's just a specific type that I like I guess no that makes a lot of sense actually and so just to kind of go to one thing that you also said on your channel I thought was super interesting uh you mentioned that you felt that very specific Victory conditions were patriarchal yes so uh could you elaborate on that and like was it a great troll do you mean it is it somewhere in the middle I I kind of want to pursue all right this is look like I don't know how to say this but like gender is like a social construct right like so like in a sense it's it's all Vibes and so the Vibes of patriarchy is that is like domination um and at least to me like the sense that I get from patriarchy is like like tough men proving they're the strongest and like like um and like contest of strength um be like being at the competition and stuff like that so when I look at like and another reason I think this is that there was like this um I've watched a

few videos about like girl games like in terms of video games like Girl Games and the kind of games that are not that were not popularized because they were categorized as games for girls a lot of those games did not have like the traditional like Victory conditions a lot of them were like paper doll type games um things like Animal Crossing um those kind of games and and when my kid plays games on her tablet she also plays games like that and I remember like teasing my kid one day being like like hey da are you winning and my like kid rolls her eyes at me and she's like mom this game doesn't have winning and like so to me like I feel like this predominant this predominant attitude that games have to have like like a victory condition that they have to that most of them have like a single Victor and even that there's like a single goal that you work towards to complete is a patriarchal one where problems have to be solved or somebody has to be proven as like the dominant one and um and that everything has to be like a contest and then like if we were in a flip world where we were predominantly like fandom games they would be like games of like expression and our like artistic creation and not necessarily like stomping out each other

but just like like collaborate like communicating and supporting and nurturing each other um again all Vibes like gender is a construct it's all made up it's a Calvin Ball but like that's when I said that that's what I was thinking yeah no I'm I'm really happy to like hear and think about this right like you know however you want to label it I think you're right that a lot of games are censored around dominance there's a lot of games like fewer by the day but still the dominant thing is fighting like I play a lot of War games you know pew pew um yeah yes uh but yeah I mean so much of our even non fighty games are really about being the best at something and I get it but I also doubt sometimes um yeah yeah it's sort of like how um they say that like if you like one of the like frustration points of like bring your problem to a man versus a woman is that a man immediately wants to solve it and like if you bring a problem to a woman sometimes they'll do the thing you actually need and just listen to you and hear you and be there for you and to me it's like the same kind of thing like games are a puzzle that must be solved as opposed to an experience that you just like listen to and receive yes yes okay so how does that relate to I saw some tests and some images of a game that you have coming up called conviction ah yes which is about having an argument and I feel like this is the

perfect time to talk about it so what uh what is the premise of conviction a game and like could you say something about the game's possible endings yes so conviction is a game where you're having a quarrel with like your significant other with your partner and the game centers is uh it's supposed to take the Aesthetics of like a fairy tale like like relationship um and the the way the game could possibly end is either with one partner dominating the other or with um both players like separating cuz they can't figure out resolution or both players mean like are collaborating cooperating I mean like a mutual resolution and the the way the game plays that out is like it's a bit of a deck builder um the cards have either your suit or your partner's suit and the more cards of um your partner suit that in your deck the more your mind has changed to favor your partner's position and the more card s of your own suit there in your deck is more how much more like adamant that you are that your position is right so if you're both able to like reach a balance in your decks where like you both change your mind about the same amount then you could reach like this collaborative goal but if you both don't change at all then you go your separate ways and then if one person manag to just like dominate the relationship like just all most mostly

their cards in their deck and their own deck then that's a relationship where one player has gotten what they want and I find that framing it that way most people view the dominant the Dominate ending to be a bad one and but that's kind of what most games Prime us for yeah so again like in in play testing you know do you see people attempting to like make the relationship work and I mean I'm assuming that all possibilities are in play like from the the beginning of the game you could get any of the endings so I guess what decisions do you make along the way that lead you to I guess either the breakup or compromise versus ending up dominating somebody is it yeah how do you build into that so like so you mean like in as a player or as like well both actually like what are you doing that gets them to do something so like as a player um I I used to have the approach of playing where I would try to reach a mutual ending no matter what um and I realized after playing some of my some of the some games this way that sometimes people will just take advantage of it and so now I've adopted the strategy of like trying to trying to sus out if

the art player is also trying to cooperate with me and then um if they're not just work towards a separation like uh like if if I get the sense that they're like putting they're they're rejecting my cards and they're trying to take opportunities to like make things really unbalanced like like removing my cards from the game and like deliberately um then refusing to hear like like I put cards in their deck and they immediately throw them away they I'm like okay this isn't going to work and I tried to do my my best to be like really defensive and throw their cards back to them and what not that's fantastic I I really want to try this game now um so if the domination ending is considered the worst ending like what is your perspective on that as the designer like in a non-h hierarchical sense like do you feel that all endings are equally valid or do you have personal preferences for how the game turns out I did think that all those endings are valid because it's not like it's not like every single conflict that a relationship has is one where both parties need to be met there are there are arguably times when one person has the point like one person is does have like the better like like idea like the the framing of the game is that one player is like an idealist that wants like Adventure and change and the other person is the St war that wants things

like safe being like stable and like um and the game like when it starts like some of the cards are like removed from the game at the very beginning and some of the cars are like um like start in the player's hands and it's deliberately it's intentionally like unbalanced where one player will have more cards than the other no matter what one player will have like start will have a starting advantage and to me like there's some situations where like the the fiction of the game is that one person has a point and the other person is being stubborn and not like hearing that at all um and like so I guess um like yeah there are times where I could imagine the dominant ending being like the the like so and so better one um yeah what about your play testers like do they seem to work for particular endings outside of gameplay like for ideological reasons or um do they just kind of get into the play somehow and something different happens a a lot of the times I see a similar thing where people read over it and they think well I've seen like a couple things happen one is where like people read over the rules and then they're like so we're working for a mutual Cooperative ending right and their person's like right right right and then they kind of play it more like a puzzle than like a like a actual

conflict where they're like okay I I handed you this m cards okay I think you need hand any more of these cards and that's why I had to add a rule that you can't talk about numbers because that was like breaking like the fiction of the game um and then another thing that might happen is like one player is like so we're working towards a Cooperative game right and the other person is like let's let's see how it plays out and then they're like oh okay

oh man so you mentioned before right that you get people kind of bring a bit of themselves to your games or at least they bring their presuppositions about what a game is supposed to be like they might read competition in where it isn't there or they might read cooperation in but there's actually some pretty spicy stuff that can happen do you think that oh how do I ask this I guess the question is so do you think that your games bring something out of people that happens specifically in game space like they feel uninhibited or do you think that your games get people to tell more of the truth about themselves than they might have intended I think a little both um I think because I've definitely seen people who are playing them and they're like and they actually say like normally I would be hyper competitive and I would screw over another person this but because we could both win I find myself wanting to not do that like Optimal screw you over move and I think that's really cool in liberan that's that's what I want to see I want to see more people think like think this is my normal programming but what if I did that instead but at the same time I've had lots of experiences playing my games where I'm like um and also like other people's multiv Victor games where I'm like oh my God like I have like these really self-destructive people pleasing Tendencies and I need to stop and it's like that's not a thing I could explore in a single Victor game where I'm like where the game is just like you want to

get the most okay but like um like I was playing play testing David M's game um like um he took his game roommates and is turning it into this multiv Victor like game spell week and like I had this experience of like doing everything to help like all the other players like with their household chores and trying to uplift them and them not reciprocating at all and like and like at the end I was like I'm like actually mad why am I actually mad I don't know I within games I actually do get like a little bit heated I I usually don't get heated like like maybe I'll joke like oh I rolled like like five zeros in a roll I'm incredibly upset like but like but like it's like what a game whatever but like for some reason I got really emotional in that game oh man no I'm emotional in all my games like I forget immediately after if that makes sense like always forgiven once the game is over but like within the game I'm heated up so I feel like I feel like you could have chosen a lot of art forms to express kind of ambiguity and Nuance like I feel like when I want to most of my artistic experiences of nuanced or ambiguous things or like people having like kind of varied viewpoints on something come from like a novel or from

from a painting so what is it about games that makes this the best venue for you to kind of Express and also like bring these like different reactions out of people well like I well like At first I I was like drawn towards like video games because like to me video games was like the ultimate medium like it's like the audio visual like the interactive like it's like you could be so fully immersed in it like but I found myself like really enjoying the tabletop space because it kind of allows me to focus on the social aspect like I feel like more than video games than like it allows me to Center the social aspect because like you could bring like a board game to somebody and you could even forget like the mechanical of it and just be like um we're going to make Parkplace give you money right like you could decide to break the rules of it and establish a new social construct on top of that and I think that's really fascinating and sometimes I try to make games that try to push the players to do that and um I think that's like such a fascinating like space to play in it's like the art of like like social interactions and agency and how people interact with each other um I feel like games more than and the iron medium um play in that space and tabletop games

especially that's an interesting way to put it and then if somebody was like going to play all of your games I feel so the way that people play games I do think is revealing about them in some way but kind of I'm starting to feel like now that I make games myself and really play people's games even more attentively than I did when I was a reviewer I think you learned things about designers by playing their games so if somebody to look at your work and draw conclusions about you what do you think that you're telling us about yourself in your work you know this was like a question that break my game Discord like yesterday and I gave the joke answer that like I'm a very submissive and infertile person uh but I think but like uh but joking aside like um most of my games are about like being like intentionally vulnerable um so I don't know maybe somebody might look at them like look at my games and be like this is a person that wants to like that wants to help people like potentially at the cost of themselves I don't know or or wants to play in a space where that is a point of expression I don't know yeah I also I find it very very interesting that you really enjoy subverting mechanical expectations so I feel like the world of gaming is a world where you play a certain kind of game and you expect something from it like people expect brutal competition depending on the mechanisms that you give them right um so do you think that

that is part of the appeal of games for you specifically like you like rule sets that you can then subvert or you can bring something unexpected out of uh like almost like a cultural system for which there are expectations yeah yeah I definitely I definitely enjoy looking at how those things could be subverted um I sometimes worry that I like enjoyed a little too much because like um eventually if you do that enough then I don't know like when I watch Like The Muppet Show as a kid and they like break the fourth wall so many times after a while it's sort of like well this is just the show right like it's just always like breaking there is no fourth wall anymore they've done it so many times that it's just expected um so like I do worry that like perhaps I I I I think about even that aspect of it because like um yeah I don't know it's it's a thing that I think about a lot I mean like if you get a surprise birthday party every year is it really a surprise kind of thing yeah yeah and I joked about it in like the um the thing that I um like uh when the L Rapture got published with Fallen Spiel maybe that's the game I should have mentioned at the very beginning cuz that one 's actually published but like when um emel asked me to send some videos for the promotion of that um I made the I made a skit where

like I was talking about the game being subversive and then um the camera switching to like another view of me recording that saying like ah it's not subversive if you say it's subversive oh man that's awesome so actually tell you what take a moment to plug veloc Rapture since we're here okay and more questions and then some sof yeah veloc Rapture is a game where you're playing as a dinosaur is playing human games until the apocalypse and it's really a game about the wrong uh slri way to play games because that's a game with no Victory conditions it has like motivations that you give to the players of what they're the ways they cope during the their last few minutes on the planet and all those ways kind are ways that they engage with the game some players want to cheat some players want to win some players want to help others win and um and I tried to make it so that's the there's a good mix of some that would want to take the game seriously and some that would want to disrupt them and so the tension is in how those players interact the players who want to play seriously and the ones that want to disrupt things um but um yeah that's a very silly silly game on doomsday which dinosaur are you are you the play seriously or are you the disrupt everything I I I think that

I'm the um I'm the there's one that's just a throwaway that's just like play games with your friends that's like you could do literally anything and I feel like I'm that dinosaur sometimes it's just like whatever sure we could we could play like you roll the three instead of a zero I don't care so um speaking of games what are some games that have delighted and maybe even surprised you recently um can I talk about like the games that are not like games I play tested yeah as long as the designer wouldn't care I'm here for it okay um I uh uh Maya Tom uh Thomas had like made this game this cursed VHS game where like like some teenagers are making a summoning Circle to like get their souls out of a cursed VHS and um and like that like she made that game like and then an a whim brought it to protos Spiel and like in the very first play test I was like oh this game is already really good like um and she's just made it even like better over time I that one like really caught me by surprise like because like normally like the first play test you're kind of like like I I enjoyed like the very early play test because there's so much potential and

things that are so wacky and but like from the GetGo that game had like has like so much potential and it was already like a great experience So like um yeah that was surprising cuz usually there's like there's a lot of like schoppy stuff in there but that one was already great so that surprised me um uh and then yeah uh and delighted um uh Mila uh Mila Matilda's game uh m mat's game uh tax Penning like it really Delights me that's a game that I wish I could get to the table more often that one's also a multiv Victor game actually that one's a published multiv Victor game and it's great um I really like the way that she handled like the um the coalitions in that game yeah awesome and then you mentioned that for you like the ultimate first dream of high art was to make a video game so if you're gonna play a video game and have what you would consider to be like an artistically life-changing experience what video game would that be um like a one that exists that's higher to me um like one of my favorites is got be papers please uh that g game like uh Lucas Pope's like work is just like very inspiring like to me um so yeah I would say papers please fantastic and if people want to follow your work online where can you be found uh you can find me at knife bunny.com that's where I

link all the other social medias that I'm on like Discord and blue sky and YouTube which is where I'm probably most active out the well no Discord is where I'm most active then YouTube was where I give all my updates fantastic uh Zoe thank you so much for coming on this has been a really fun conversation and I'm just really looking forward to more of your work yeah thank you so much for talking with me this is awesome all right every we out there if you want to find me online I'm terminally online at Beyond Solitaire everywhere uh and please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved