Skip to main content
Loading video...

Everdell Board Game Review - By Board Of It

Transcript 10:58

hi welcome to board of it i'm farrell and i'm tally and today we're going to review everdel evidel is a one to four player work placement game with a nice soothing woodland theme it'll instantly remind you of classic book series such as watership down or the red wall series but whereas those novels are much more like

evidel is actually like you'll be competing to build the best critter city and as the game goes on you'll be filling the table in front of you with cards showing colorful characters and buildings you'll be placing workers on the board mainly to gather resources or cards and then you'll use those resources to play said cards to get more resources or to unlock new actions you'll end up at the end of the game with a city full of buildings and critters in front of you which you then score for victory points and while it's a simpler more family-friendly game there's actually a hidden depth here and that will keep you coming back to it and to be honest it's actually just pretty damn fun and before we get into it we just want to say a massive thanks to everyone that's watched our reviews so far we really appreciate it especially for all the kind comments about our last review on mars and we'd really love it if you guys would subscribe to our channel so we know that you guys are still enjoying our reviews now back to evidence the game takes place over four rounds or seasons beginning in winter and it's one of those games that's super easy to just pick up and play or to teach to your friends others only three actions available those actions are play a

worker play a card or prepare for the next season and preparing for the next season is essentially saying that you've done all you can do in this season and allows you to take back your workers gain new workers or trigger other game effects depending on the season most of the gameplay comes through the playing of the cards which clearly and plainly tell you their effect there are only about five or six symbols to learn in this game making it really simple to know what a card is telling you so as the game goes on it actually becomes a little bit of an engine builder because as the seasons go on you have more actions available to you through the cards you play at the start you probably won't be doing much because you start with two workers and a handful of cards and this won't get you very far i mean your workers won't help you much and the cards cost resources which you don't have but as a game goes on you start to fill up your city what happens is you start to chain actions together so for example you might play a card and then that card gives you resources you use those resources to build a building then that building allows you to play a connected critter for free then that critter allows you to take cards and so it goes with each season taking longer and longer till the end of the game we think this is quite a deceptive game as we've heard people believe that it's all show with minimal substance due to the giant tree and the kickstarter style components also due to the woodland theme and the cute critters it may seem like it's a simple

game aimed at families but we're pleased to say neither of these are true and there is some hidden depth here and the bonus is that the tree is dope and the components are novel and aesthetically pleasing one thing we don't like is how big the dog meeples are they totally take over the board even though they look pretty cute this game looks so cool when it's set up but unfortunately this comes at a cost it's stylish but to the point of not being practical as an example you have all these resources here that are there little spaces and zones on the board to put them but in practice what this what actually happens is it makes the board crowded and messy and things are wrestling out for space so for example the event tiles and the resources and the work placement spaces all kind of get lost together and there's always a worry that if you knock the resources you're covering up one or more of them and also like these cars on top of the tree here they get hidden and like under shadow you can't read them and you've got to go over and pick them up and and the thing is i think it looks cool and it fits the theme that the resources are on the board but it would have just been better if they're just giving you little plastic trays to hold them in like wingspan for example and i mean come on like you've got one of the resources it's plastic rubber berries whenever you touch them they roll everywhere

as a side note about the components how the hell does this look like a turtle everdell is a points buffet game and you're going to be scoring points in about 10 different ways you're going to spend quite a few minutes at the end of the game checking and double checking that you've calculated your score correctly and whilst it's great to have different options we're kind of in two minds about the scoring we sort of wish that they provided a scoring booklet like many other games do telling you what to count in what order and allowing you to write it down although that's not that great for the environment alternatively they could have just had a points tracker around the outside of the board but without either what tends to happen is that people will count the points up and then when they recheck them they'll get an entirely different number than they did the first time and this really isn't something that should be happening in a modern board game it's just because of the system point scoring very easy to miss a few points here and there and it just becomes a bit tedious after a while most of your points are going to come from playing cards or from the effects from cards there are also event tiles that are worth points at the end of the game there are basic event tiles which require you to have a certain number of a type of card in your city and when you fulfill those criteria you will place a worker on that event tile blocking it off from other players and then also the special event cards which are more complicated and require you to have specific buildings and specific critters in your city and also to have completed an objective in order to claim them such as trading wood for victory points

this leads into evidence main problem the randomness of the cards has quite a big deck i think around 128 and in one aspect this is good because it introduces variability and keeps the game fresh play off to play but on the other hand it means that often you won't see half the cards in the deck in the single game particularly at lower play accounts well this means that these special events become pointless to be honest because a lot of the time you might not see some of the cards needed for any of them and in another aspect the buildings are linked to critters and i mean this in that buildings allow you to play critters for free so what might happen is that turn off the turn your opponent is playing free critters whereas you're not getting any critters that match your buildings the game negates this with the melo which is the central space of the board containing eight cards that can be used by any player as long as they pay the cost and this means that you always have access to eight more cards than are in your hand but at the risk that another player might sweep under your nose and steal the card you want but all together this makes everdel a game where you kind of have to work more with what you have and what's available to you as opposed to building a long-term strategy and trying to follow through on it in short this is a game you'll win by using strategy and planning your next few turns well however the chance is there for the cards you draw to put you in a worse position

than your opponents one interesting mechanic in aberdell is that all seasons play concurrently usually in these type of games when a player will pass and finish the round or prepare for season here they would then wait for the other players to do the same and then all players would go into the next round together that's not what happens here here after your turn when you prepare for the next season it's the next season and then you start playing again this means that one player can be in spring and another player can be in autumn it gets a bit crazy as suddenly one player takes all of their workers off the board opening up valuable resource spaces as a side note this is definitely not very clearly explained in the rules especially if you're a seasoned veteran of board games used to the pass and weight system yeah i think i only found it out by accident when i was looking up another rule on a board game geek now when it comes to the price surprisingly it really does vary from store to store at the lower prices i would definitely say it's worth it because you know you've got the custom resources you've got the artwork you've got the boards you've got the giant tree and you've got the gameplay but at the higher costs i wouldn't say it's worth it because you can get games of deeper gameplay with more components for similar or less price so just be careful with that this is a quick fire review comment it's a simple game but it gives you the feel of a big board game and it clogs in at under an hour quick

simple terms that keep the game moving at a good pace it's easy to explain and you can get someone involved right away amazing components and 3d board really contribute to nailing the theme the randomness of the cards can negatively affect you playing while also benefiting other players at the same time there's a terrific sense of progression as your city goes and starts to provide for you it's also a surprisingly friendly work placement game and doesn't descend into the bare knuckle brawls that some of the other games do look in a new barrage but in summary this isn't the deepest or the best euro work placement game but damn if it isn't fun there's definitely a hidden depth and strategy underneath the friendly woodland animal by it's a great game to use to lure people into board gaming and it will look great on your table it's a solid recommendation from us and if you enjoyed this video we'd love it if you could give it a like and please subscribe to our channel using the red button down below the dogs will be sad if you don't

you

Progress saved