Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 7 Board Wargames | With Designer Hermann Luttmann | Part 1

Transcript 49:16

Hi everybody, I'm Solitaire Blitz and welcome to another episode in Top Seven Wargames. This is the series where we bring in designers and other historical game notables and ask them what their top seven favorite games are. Not the games that they have designed or worked on, but the games that they enjoy playing. In this episode, we're joined by Herman Luttmann who is one of the most prolific and prestigious historical game designers out there. He's designed such things as A Most Fearful Sacrifice, Dawn of the Zeds, as well as being the creator of the Blind Swords Civil War series. I'm also happy to say as part of this episode, we're going to be giving away a copy of A Plum Island Horror plus the expansion. Now, there are two caveats. Caveat number one is this contest this drawing is open to the lower 48 states of the United States. Sorry to all the international viewers. And the second thing is our interview went quite ranging over a number of topics including a lot of the games that Herman

is working on. So, I've cut this up into two parts, which means information on how to enter the drawing will be at the end of part two, which will be posted a little while after this one goes up. One final word before we start, this episode is sponsored by Noble Knight Games who is a board game retailer that ships across the planet. Herman is going to talk about a number of games in this episode. If you're looking for any of those to pick up either new or used, there are links down below in the video description. And if you use those, thank you very much as it could help out the channel. Herman, thank you so much for joining the channel today. I am very excited to have you on this top seven interview. It's been something I've I've you've been a guest I've been thinking about for a long time and I know we've communicated a lot outside of this about

[clears throat]

the various games you're working on, but thank you so much for joining the channel and and for being willing to talk about your games and and your interests in gaming.

Well, thank you thank you so much for having me. As you say, we we've actually communicated for a couple years now, I would think.

Yes.

Uh

Yeah, for sure.

We've never met, we've never spoken, so this is a true honor for me. Thank you.

Yeah, likewise, too. I know you're a very busy designer and thank you for taking the time out of your day to join us, but shall we jump

I am I am retired, but I'm more busy now than when I worked for a living, so

Right.

But judging by the number of games you produce, that does not surprise me and we'll we'll get to that in a little bit, I think too. All right, so let's jump in then with with number seven, your top seven war game and again, this is that you enjoy playing, not that you've particularly designed yourself.

That I enjoy playing and not in any particular order, by the way.

Okay, that's good to know. So this is top seven games and they're not necessarily one to seven. These are just your top seven games on a whole.

So number seven is Frederick the Great, the Campaigns of the Soldier King.

Okay. Now this is this is an older game, right?

Quite old from the '70s. It was SPI originally and then Avalon Hill did a boxed version of it.

Okay, cuz as I was looking I I got a chance to see this before and too I actually have this one. There was a long time ago I had a a strategy and tactics subscription and I was looking at it and when I was looking at it it's like it shows up it's in my collection. I've never played this one. Those games used to pile up pretty quickly. Um but maybe you could speak a little bit more about why this is your one of your favorites.

Well, first of all, I was well, I've been a military history geek since I was a little kid, so been reading a lot of military history and I stumbled upon Christopher Duffy's The Military Life of Frederick the Great. I was just instantly fascinated with Frederick the Great and read all about him and that whole period of history, the Age of Reason. And this particular board game one thing you'll note it one similar factor you'll see in all my list is that these games are relatively simple games.

Okay.

there's a reason behind my madness is that I actually appreciate clever simple games rather than big complex overly designed games.

Right.

So this Frederick the Great captured for me what the Seven Years War it in Frederick's genius and during the game you're feeling like you're just you're zooming around Europe trying to demoralize different armies to buy time so you could then march across Europe and demoralize another army while the other one's gathering together. That's exactly how the war went.

Right. And this doesn't cover the wars of the Austrian the war of the Austrian Succession, right? This is after that, right? It's more 1750 later. Yeah, right. For sure.

It's just done in such a beautifully simple manner. The They're the leaders are rated by ranking so you your number one ranked leader has to be your main leader. You can't pick a guy who's down the the hierarchy who's better, right? They would go in the order of rank. And they command stacks of troops and your leader has to lead them around and the combat system's pretty simple. Sieges are done simply but beautifully. Supply is handled. All All major factors in the war, by the way, important to have in the game but they're all done so cleanly and simply. You just don't get bogged down in rules. You you get bogged down in the strategy of it.

Right, which is what you want, right? You want You want people trying to make the decisions, yeah.

So to me it was just again another typical elegant design for effect type of game game design.

Right. It's interesting you mentioned that too because I I've been studying design a little bit more too and one of the things I stumbled across I've been reading a book called Inside the Box, which is talking about designing with constraints. And one of the things they mention is that often times when humans try to usually by default when humans try to solve a problem they add something. And that the true genius to design is that the best designers subtract something to solve the problem, which gets at your whole idea of simplicity and

It's really hard to do that, right? I always argue that it's easier to write a 100-page rulebook than it is to write a 25-page rulebook, right?

Yes. Yeah. For like

everything in there. Oh, another modifier, another condition, another rule to cover all this stuff. Holding all that down and getting that same effect for 10% of the verbiage is is the real is the real skill or challenge, I should say, cuz I'm not saying that I've always been successful at doing it. It's hard to do.

Yeah.

Right?

And it's the same I mean, this is a little off topic, but it's the same thing for creating videos. Like people will say, "Okay, you know, if you want a 10-minute video about a game, I can do that in a day." Right? "If you want a 2-minute video about a game, I need much more time." You

That's a that's a good point. That's a good point.

Let's jump on to uh number six, shall we?

Yeah, number six, I got to get my old man glasses on cuz I forgot what number six is. Oh, it's the World War One game from SPI, right?

Yes, another This is in the same category. This was also uh Strategy & Tactics magazine game.

Yes, you you Yes, it's interesting. They had some really designs back in the day. They really did. I mean, these are these are the forefathers to all the other war games in the future, right? These are the building blocks, the foundation. And for for me personally, again, another simple design for effect, clever game that gets across the period of history it's trying to simulate in a very playable, simple way, right? So, this particular game, which has been is a deluxe edition now. There was a There's been a couple of deluxe-ified editions, but for me the original version is the one that really really does it the best. And it's I World War One for me is a much more interesting period of history even than World War Two. I I tend to go towards World War One, which you'll see in another title down the line.

Right. And you have a lot of World War One designs now, too.

I do. I do. I I just I just find the whole situation so interesting. And and the tech Now, the development of the technology through the war is just fascinating. Uh but this particular game design captured the ability to to simulate the attrition of World War I in one simple mechanic. Which is the the Crips. And the Crips are just a way of uh recording the manpower input of each of these powers throughout the war. And as your Crips decrease as you're retreating your armies, at some point you have to choose to actually give ground because you can't take any more casualties. So, it manages to get all that attritional feel of World War I in this one simple mechanism.

And, you know, it has all the nations, all the fronts. It has a very simple little rule for how to do the tank armies. Every every country's units are rated for their offensive and defensive ability, so you could even fine-tune that a little bit, and it works out great. I mean, the stormtroopers are in there. Again, all playable in an hour hour or two, you know.

Right. Yeah, this one I've I've actually played this one. So, I had I had a span where I was playing wargaming and then married, family, kids, coaching, all those types of stuff where I drifted away for a number of decades, and now I've been back for about 5 years. But this is one I played back in that time. I really like this game. I remember all the things that you're talking about in terms of just the simplicity of play. And for me, it was my first experience even just learning about World War I, but that whole attritional nature where you've got these armies grinding against each other. It felt like the the game really captured that very well.

So, you can you can simulate that aspect of the war without having to roll 8,000 dice and 42 CRTs and all that, you know. This is just a such a simple way of making those tough decisions. Do I do I risk more men, or do I give a little bit of ground, and try to rebuild my Crips, and it's just it's just a fascinating experience. I love it.

Yeah, yeah, right. Well, let's shift gears now a little bit if we could because one of the things I want to talk about today is some of the work that you're doing and yeah, I mentioned this to pretty much everyone that I talked to about yourself. You know, people say when I think of prolific game designers, I I think you're you know, one of the people that comes right to mind right away because it seems like every time I turn around there's something new coming out from somewhere about some topic and both your you know, your breadth of design in terms of handling different topics and just the volume and quality has always been something that's been incredibly impressive. And so I guess uh sorry. Yeah.

I was just going to say thank you. I don't know if that's by design or bad bad manager time management on my part. [clears throat and laughter]

It's yeah, I know. It's but it's just great to see and the games of course are such a fantastic addition to the hobby and people love to play them, too. But I do have a question for you about that, too, in terms of

Um what are some games that you've got coming out soon that people should hear about? You know, things that you've worked on that are at the cusp of release. I think I know a couple, but I'll let you run with it.

Right. Well, the two most uh immediate designs are uh Forlorn Hope which I know you've played at one of the conventions. Ryan Heilman and Wes Crawford of War Paint Games, that's their first design. Uh that I believe you can still pre-order at BackerKit if anybody's interested. It's it's it's a trench war it the story quickly they asked me once on an interview uh about In Magnificent Style which is the uh solitaire push your luck of Pickett's Charge and they asked me about the history of that game. And originally it was envisioned as a trench warfare game, but at the time Victory Point Games didn't think trench warfare would necessarily sell. It's not very romantic, right? So we came up with Pickett's Charge. Everybody knows about Pickett's Charge, etc.

So they asked me they it you would you ever want to do an actual World War I the way the game was originally intended. I said absolutely. I would love to do that, you know.

Yeah.

So, they said let's let's give it a shot. So, we came up with the Forlorn Hope. It's a it's a push-your-luck across no-man's-land. There's multiple scenarios, so it's not the same scenario each time. Every scenario is designed differently, so you get a different feel. We even have one for the Lost Battalion, uh with the famous Lost Battalion in the United States Army in in World War I. And so, we have a scenario for that. We have to rescue these guys. Um there's there's scenarios that are actually multiple games that connect. So, it's kind of like a mini campaign. So, we put a lot of work into making the design variable and unique and and something that, you know, you can play through and you won't get bored playing it. So, that's the Forlorn Hope by War Fray Games. And then, of course, Dawn of the Zeds,

my Every If anybody knows me about any game, it's Dawn of the Zeds. I mean, it's been around

This has a cult following for this one.

It's been around for a while.

it on one of the upcoming war game I mean

Yeah.

I mentioned it in one of the upcoming war game videos, and since then, you know, I'm just seeing all the comments about it.

many people will argue whether it's really a war game or not, but it it's based in the States of Siege system, which is a war game system.

Right.

Yeah.

I I'm the one who who started going off on a different And it's it was done innocently, by the way. I'm not a particularly big zombie fan or anything like that. I mean, I enjoy all the zombie movies that everybody enjoys, but it's not a particular cult thing with me or you know, but I was playing Zulu's on the Ramparts, which was a States of Siege game back in the VPGs on the Battle of Rorke's Drift, and I was playing it. And the vibe I got was just I think I had just seen Day of the Dawn of the Dead or whatever it was One of one of the old zombie movies at the time, and I go, "Boy, this this kind of feels like a mall under siege by zombies, right?" So, I I I I remember writing to Alan Emrich and I said, "I know somebody's already thought of this, but just in case nobody has, you know, what about zombies doing this?" And he goes, "Well, nobody's thought of that. Why don't you just run with it?" So, I did. And it's it's uh it's been through three editions over 15 years. This is the my what I call a designer edition.

And this is coming out from Blue Panther. It's on pre-order now, right?

It is on pre-order now from Blue Panther Games. Um I've changed some of the mechanics cuz 15 years ago, I'm a different designer today than I was 15 years ago. So, I've I've fixed some things that have bothered me for a long time. Most primarily the uh the combat system. It was very [clears throat] wargaming in its original state cuz that's all I knew. Uh since then, I've played, like you, and this is what I appreciate about your channel, too, is I've played a lot of different games. Dungeon crawlers, uh dudes on a map, uh the whole thing, right?

Yeah.

And uh I've learned, right? I've learned that there's other ways to do things. So, I've for this particular uh new edition of Dawn of the Zeds, we're using now custom combat dice with that trigger special abilities and do all sorts of other fun things rather than looking at a CRT. So, that's changed. I've added some more heroes and units and all that. We've cleaned up a lot of mechanics. It's easier to play. Um it's just it's it's a it's a it's the same game narratively, thematically, but it's a different game mechanically. And I and I feel like I've always want I the the one thing I didn't like about third edition was that it just became too bloated in my opinion and too long to play at five rulebooks, if if people remember. So, I said, "No, we're getting this down to one rulebook. I want people to be able to play this in an hour and a half, 2 hours on a game night, and not require an entire weekend to play it. Uh I wanted to make it more accessible to the general gaming public rather than a you know, a smaller group of people that are more more gamey or that had a long time to play. I wanted this to be more of a family night type of game. So, that's what that's the way we've designed it.

So, you can still pre-order that. Um it looks really cool. Uh and it

Yeah, I was looking at it, too, and just you know, you've mentioned some of the changes, too, but as I was reading through that, this does not look like just a regurgitation of previous editions. It looks like this is really the definitive edition that you've taken all of your design experience over the past decade or so and reapplied it.

Exactly the word I use is regurgitate. I'm not just going to regurgitate another version of this. This This was re- reworked. Let's put it this way. Uh underneath the hood and everywhere. So, we're we're hoping that this will be the definitive the way I wanted it if I knew better.

Right, right, right, right, right, right. Yeah, which is I'm sure fun to do. And I've as you mentioned, I've had a chance to sample Forlorn Hope. I've just played one scenario. So, I'm looking forward to exploring

Yeah, you probably played the first one, the Neuve Chapelle, the the introductory scenario, which is basically

Yeah, you're just trying to get to the other side. Yeah, yeah, it's trying not to get killed.

Yeah. Yeah, well, that that those are I think again two great additions. And Forlorn Hope has done incredibly well in its

Yeah, it's done very well. Yes, I thank everybody [clears throat] for their support. I mean, it's it's Wargame Vault, it's a new company. They took a big risk on me, and I appreciate that. And I My biggest fear was I would fail them. So, I was like, I was nervous during the whole thing. Uh I'm glad it's been successful. So, that's good.

I I do think there's something to be said though for you know, we've talked one of the themes that's running through this already is the the simplicity and elegance of design, right? And capturing a lot of good gameplay elements with an accessible type of game format. And I think more and more as people you know, people are busy. I think people really appreciate what I tend to call single-sitting war games where you can pick up the game, learn the game, play the game in a single evening in the middle of the week in 2 to 3 hours. You know, that that's a very desirable game experience. But sometimes as you say when we design particular games about military history, we tend to go beyond that. You know, it's I've played a lot of games where I kind of half learn a game in an evening and then it's another sitting to actually try to play it and then even then it's a four or five hour experience and so you don't quite make it all the way through. But these ones that are focused and tight, I think people really appreciate those.

And importantly for me anyway and I've and I've said many people have mentioned this, you know, for some of my game. But I say, "Look, if you're playing a game and not having fun, you're doing it wrong." So for me fun is if you got to be cheering and laughing and having a good time when you're playing a game.

Yeah.

And so I try to inject that. There's one game that taught me that by the way that's not on the list but it's an honorable mention is Combat Commander. Combat Commander taught me that inadvertently kind of I guess. I guess I didn't consciously think of it but now I think back on it and I said, "Hey, you know what? Chaos is fun. Chaos is also highly realistic in military realm, okay?"

Yeah.

So you get two what? And this is this has been like the guiding principle for Blind Swords, Black Swan, most of my games is that if you do chaos right and I call it historically weighted chaos, right? So it's chaotic but it's not like Martians are going to land and and shoot your guys. It's it's chaos that would have happened in real in military terms in real life, okay?

Mhm.

And if you can inject that, that's actually not only a realistic element but it's a fun element.

I that I agree with me.

I remember playing Combat Commander specifically Pacific and just burst into out laughing when certain things happened but I knew they could happen cuz I know I read a passage in a history book somewhere where that did happen. And so you got the two combo, you know, fun and and historically accurate. How How can you How can you beat that, right?

Yeah. Yeah. Can I ask you a follow-up question about that in terms of So, how closely do you think narrative connects to that element of chaos?

Hugely. Hugely. Again, going back to Combat Commander, I would when I was playing and you know, some guys get and then I understand get a little frustrated cuz they get a bad hand of cards or you know, something happens that doesn't seem right. I will I would fill in the narrative for them

Yeah.

about what just happened on the battlefield, right?

Right.

And again, you talk about Don of the Zeds, Don of the Zeds is its strength. It The reason people love it is because of the narrative.

Right.

It it You are creating a story as you play. And that aspect has has bled into Blind Swords. It's If you're playing Blind Swords, all the event cards and the chit pulls and all that, eventually you're going to be able to tell and and again, these are my favorite reviews on BoardGameGeek that I get from people is when they just relate the story of their turn without mentioning rules, without mentioning die rolls. They're just narratively telling me what the game produced for them and how they felt about it. And that to me is the most rewarding review I could get.

Yeah, and I and I do think I would I would I would also want I I would imagine there's a very great design challenge to that because getting that degree of chaos right so that the player because if there's too much, the player feels like they have no control.

Oh, absolutely. You can't let the game play you.

Right.

Yes. Yeah. Yeah. But getting that level of chaos right

It is that fine line of weird things are going to happen, but do I have a plan B? I always say you need a plan B and a plan C

Yeah.

when you play my games, right? So, you have to expect things to go wrong. And it's the people who come up with a good plan B and plan C that can get through it.

Yeah.

And I really love I mean, that's the I love narrative in games. And so that's why I think I kind of enjoyed playing the games that you design is that I love when things go sideways and you're like, okay, well, let's just deal with it, you know, stuff happens. Like deal with it. Let's go, you know.

Exactly right. How do you deal with it? In Combat Commander, how do you deal with getting a bad hand of cards? You know, eventually those good cards are going to come up. So how do you how do you manage your turn in the meantime?

Yeah. Outstanding. Yeah. Well, let let's jump back into our list if we could. Should we slide up to number five, which if it's helps I could I Yeah. I'll let you run with it.

That's World at War by originally by Lock 'n Load Publishing back in the day when Mark Walker was there. So this game So this is one of my This is one of my geeky designer experiences. I was at WBC working for Victory Point Games at the time running the booth or helping run the booth. And I glanced across the way and there was the Lock 'n Load booth and Mark Walker was standing there and I was like, oh my god, that's Mark Walker.

Such a fanboy, right? So I crawl across over there and I go, hi Mr. Walker. My name's Herman. I love your World at War. He still laughs today. In the meantime, he's one of my publishers now and one of my best friends too at the same time. And but every time I tell him that story he starts laughing.

Oh, that's funny.

World at War to me I I was interested in modern warfare, but all the modern warfare games back in the day and to a certain extent even today were just either way too simplistic that they didn't really capture the feel at all. Could have been any period.

[clears throat]

Or most likely way too complicated, right? Where you're tracking a missile second by second across the board and it you know, the wind's pushing it and all this other nonsense.

[clears throat]

World at War for me it was able to make me play an operational level or grand title level, how you want to describe it, modern warfare game and as we just said previously, not only did it feel right historic you know realistically, but it was fun because it had a it had a chip pull system. It had a variable turn end, which I just loved, right? It had two turn end chips in there and you picked the first one, when the second one came out that turn was going to end. So now all of a sudden your brain's got to go, uh-oh, I don't know how much time I have left. I got to do what I need to do or risk it, you know, and take my time. I don't know. But

[clears throat]

the the game looked great, the tanks looked all great. They had a very simple system of kind of a bucket of dice system, but it still worked. It was like you depending on the range you were at and which weapon system you're using, you just roll a bunch of D6s and you're looking for a certain hit number. Right? And but it was all different depending on, you know, whether it was close combat, what range you were at, what weapon you were using. So it was complex in that these each of these units had a very unique very unique unique uh and I thought I didn't know that much about a little tank, but it felt right. Yet to to run them to to to fight with them was just simple. It was just you're rolling a bunch of D6s, but you just still felt like this is exactly how this weapon was going to act on the battlefield.

Yeah.

So um that with the the chip pull and I man, I just I remember just laughing out loud a lot of times playing that game and just making felt right and it I I really did appreciate that.

And I've had similar experience. I haven't played the original one, but I played the they have a World at War 85 based on the way that you're talking about it. I think they use cards now instead of chits on for activations. But, you know, as you describe the gameplay at it's connecting to the newer version that I've played and a lot of the same feelings. I feel like you know, modern warfare sometimes it's a lot to hold a game sometimes ask you to hold a lot of stuff in your head. And so, you I found myself rules diving and processing and and trying to work it out. And I'm not too familiar with well, at least post World War combat systems. So, there's that element of just understanding what's going on with certain types of armor and missiles and

I mean, you're talking about missile systems and and

Yes.

I mean, just all sorts of stuff.

Yeah, and you've got helicopters and aircraft and everything's going on. The game and yet it felt manageable. Yes, and that's the when I I got a chance to play last summer with the designers on the Lock 'n Load channel for the World at War 85 one. And it was it finished like, "Wow, this is so accessible for a complex for complex combat situation." They've managed to do what you've been talking about, which is distill it down into something that yeah, it's still a little bit complex, but it's very elegant and very playable. I've really enjoyed that one, too. So,

And especially that scale where you're talking about the possibility of off-board artillery, missile systems, helicopters, uh airborne troops, all in there, right? And yet never felt overwhelming. It was like, okay, I can do this.

Yeah, yeah. And we were I you know, as I'm playing it's Oh, yeah, didn't really need to look at the rule book after about half an hour. It's like, oh, wow, this is such an elegant system.

So, yeah, this is this goes back to Mark's system. The new system is is is good, too. I'm just saying, but it was built off the you know, off of the

Yes. Yeah, work with

Mark's work. Yeah.

Yeah, for sure. Shall we jump up to number four, which is very I've seen this list before. So, this is like, whoa, this is like one of these games is not like the others.

Yeah, yeah. One of these games is not like the others. So, I'll let you talk about number four.

I got to throw a curveball in somewhere, right? I can't

yeah. the 1970s.

So, this is this is a game that uh Oh, I'll I'll say that uh hmm All right, yeah. I would I I would say it's a controversial pick. I don't know. It It's It's the only game that Tom Vassal and I probably agree on. Let's put it that way.

Okay, okay. This is your list, so you don't have to apologize for your own list, Joe.

So, the game called Summoner Wars. And if people look it up, some people are already familiar with it, but if you look it up, you'll find out hidden under hidden under all that is a tactical fantasy war game.

Mhm.

I mean, that's what it is. It uses cards for units. Every unit has a distinct power or special ability, whatever you want to call it. Has distinct ratings. Um the the race that you pick has its own deck of special events, special abilities that you're picking. Um God, there were man, I think 24 different races you could pick in this game and and fight against one another. It has a magic system

expansions now, too, I think, if I'm not I'm not mistaken.

Right. Well, the one I played was the actually the first edition. It's been since then they've re- re-released it as a second edition, but they always had expansions with new So, again, that's another great part of it is you never got to bored of it cuz you're always getting new factions.

Right.

It has really clever magic system where you have a hand of cards with events and and units and stuff like that. But, to use your magic, you had to actually spend magic cards. Well, how do you get magic cards? You actually had to discard cards in your hand, valuable cards, and put them face down in a magic pile where it would just sit there. And when you wanted to issue whatever magic it is, you'd have to discard those cards off the magic pile. So, you actually had to set up your own magic pile and risk dumping, you know, valuable cards. Very very very interesting strategic choices in the game.

Right.

And just plain fun. I mean, it was you moved it on. It was a um a a grid board. And the units were face up, all had unique artwork and all that. Every every every race started differently, too. You had a setup card. They'd start in different places. So, whatever all all the matchups were always different. And you'd actually move the cards around on the gridded map, have combats against one another, very simple dice rolls, but it was

And it's a great

combat.

Is it limited to a two-player game? Is it a dueling game?

an option where you could take two sets and and stick them together and play two on two and have them have them cross over. Yeah.

Okay. Right. And I'm a little So, I have a story I have a connected story with Summoner cuz there is a There's an app for Summoners Wars. And I'm not sure if that's where it started from, but the the embarrassing story

Yeah, that came out

Okay. Okay. Okay, it did. Because I I That was my first experience with the game was probably I'm going to say about eight or nine years ago where a friend was playing it on their phone and I looked at it and said, "Oh, I'll give that a try." And then a month later, I was completely addicted to it. So, I finally I mean, I was It's like one of those games where you it like it recharges, so you have to check your phone every like 15 minutes. So, I got after like a month, I'm like, "Okay, I I'm going to go insane. I just have to delete this because it was too addictive for me. So, I And then I saw it recently as I got back into board gaming, I saw the board And the board game is very highly regarded. It gets great reviews. So, you're not alone in saying that you're someone who's really appreciated the gameplay for this. It's got a

I Well, like I said, its strength is somebody like me who's a wargamer by, you know, by tradition. And a guy like Tom Vasel who's a well, plays everything, right?

Yeah. Yeah.

It's in his top 10 list of all-time games as of favorites, too. So, to me, it's just one of my

It's been in my wanted list at Noble Knight Games for quite a while. I might have

Oh, has it?

to explore this one, yeah. I've held off cuz I'm like, I don't want to get addicted to the app version again. It's like

Right. I prefer the original version, the artwork. The I I feel like the new artwork's a little too cartoony for me. The original one had a had an edge to it that I really liked.

Oh, interesting. Okay, well, I might look for that one, then.

But, when you boil it down, it is a fantasy war miniatures war game. That's what it is. It's just presented differently.

Yeah. No, I I would based on what I've seen of it and what you've talked about it, yes, that that sounds But, it you know, the the interesting about that is this does stand out on your list. This is like, oh, I

Well, I I figure I can't give you a boring list. I got to throw something controversial in there.

Yeah.

No, yeah, this is we'll see it in the comments down below.

All right.

Um

Somebody will support me. Somebody will.

I'll support you. I'm there. I mean, it's your list. You get to Like we said, this is all about fun with your list, so. Um but, [clears throat] speaking of stuff that you're doing, let's Can we slide over a little bit to another question about things that you're working on? Because, you know, as a designer, I'm sure you you know, you've got We've talked about Dawn of the Zeds, A Forlorn Hope, which are games that are done and in production and going forward. So, there's probably not much design work. But, I imagine you have a number of games that you're working on right now as well that are, you know, further back in the process that are going to be a little bit more out in the distant future. And I'm wondering if you have a couple that you might want to talk about with those.

Oh, I have a couple couple couple.

Okay, let's dig in.

I have about 10 right now that are in some some form of production or soon-to-be-released. Yeah. A Hell So Terrible is on the GMT P500 right now. Uh it's at four I think just shy of 480. So, I just

Al- almost there.

need 20 more people to order this thing.

There you go. Want to make Herman happen happy? Down below, I'll put a link to it.

Thank you. Unfortunately, um it has only my artwork right now, right? So,

Okay.

this is this is something I I have a hard time doing, you know, I I go on paint, you know, and I try to create, you know, I do my own playtest kits, um

Yeah.

as much as I can possibly do it. So, the TTS mod that I've been playtesting on is all my own artwork and it's downloaded clip art and just things, right? So, unfortunately, when they do the P5 art page, that's what that's what's up there.

Yeah.

And I'm like begging people like don't pay attention to the artwork, okay? This is not what the game's going to look like, I promise.

Right.

So, I don't know if that's holding it back or whatever, but um it's it's a new system uh on the Battle of Verdun. It does use tracks, so it's quite manageable, but it uses, again, um from adventure gaming that I've played, one of my favorite mechanics now has become dice assignment because I like I like the randomness of rolling the bucket of you know, the group of dice, but then the strategy of how do I apply those dice to do different things. So, this this system uses that, right? So, you're you're you're assigning a move die and a casualty die to each of your German units for that turn and that kind of determines how they how much casualty how many casualties are they taking and how well are they moving. So, you have to strategize on your dice that you're rolling and what kind of dice you can actually change the type of dice to roll for your units. If you have stosstruppen, you can use a different more efficient die, but you got to pay for it in command points.

So, anyway, that's the system for that. That's a Hell's So Terrible on

And Hell's So Terrible, just a follow-up on that, that this is Is it the same scale as a For the People? Or it's a larger scale? And it sounds like based on what you're talking the mechanics are very different.

this is This is all over done. So, this is a much larger scale, yeah.

Much larger scale, okay, right.

Um we are in playtesting for a Primitive Madness, which is the next Black Swan game that's on the Battle of Antietam. You and I discussed that before. We know that Antietam's one of your favorite favorite battles to study. Um we've we've uh we're doing play testing right now. It's working really well, and as I was explaining to Mike before, getting McClellan right for an Antietam battle is the real challenge.

And for people that aren't familiar with this is the third game in the Black Swan series, right? The first is

is most of the games

Sacrifice, Rock of Chickamauga, and then now this primitive

Primitive Madness.

Primitive Madness.

Bruce Catton quote, yeah.

Okay.

Uh about Antietam. Um it's a slightly more tactical scale, so the game's going to actually play a little bit differently. All right? I I put a little too I don't like I don't like just producing the same thing. I've got to got to change something in there, right, to make it interesting. So, we have that. Um it's it's an So, the way we solved the McClellan problem, we think I mean it's working, is we have a set of cards, special commander-in-chief cards called McClellan Hesitates. So, the Union player will be feeding these in as the battle goes on, and if the Union casualty get too high, you put some more cards in. And what happens when you draw these cards, it puts some kind of problem up for the Union player. So, it'll say like McClellan stalls. You can no longer issue any more attack orders, or McClellan uh vacillates. Uh you can no longer issue any more maneuver orders. So, and then every turn these cards go back It's kind of like a deck destruction type of mechanism where they go into the deck now, and the Union player Now, you might pull them all early, you might pull them all late. And this is what you and I were talking about before the show is that you don't want to permanently strap the Union player by scripting him, or just saying you can't do this. The card mechanism um allows you to manipulate the deck a little bit so that the possibilities in there that something bad's going to happen. But, if it comes later, the Union player's got free reign at the beginning, right? If

the If the If the card was seated to the back, you don't know. So, it's a it it's a it's definitely a challenge for the Union player, but at least it's not a a permanent scripting effect where you just feel hemmed off the entire game.

And I since it it almost it's tapping a little bit into that chaos element that you're talking about to the unpredictability of

Well, the beauty of the cards is that, you know, I don't have to write hard and fast fast rules that people have to study and memorize. As the cards come up, you're just you you're utilizing the card's effect. So, there's nothing for you to remember. The card's pulled and here's what happens, all right?

Yeah. Well, that and that was also my experience that, you know, as I was looking at just a on a related in that, you know, as I was looking at A Most Beautiful Sacrifice, I thought, "Wow, this is kind of daunting." Uh, but it's an actually very easy system to pick up and play. You know, the it it took me much less

say that about Blind Swords, too. Like, you know, it's it's uh, deceptively easy to play.

Yeah. Yeah, I was expecting it

It's it's different than the traditional I I don't think I've ever designed a game with a ZOC. There's only control.

[clears throat]

You know, it's it they're just different. And that's half the fight is to get through what's what's different about them than your than the games you have been playing.

Yeah. Well, I'm Death Primitive Madness is on my list. I'm excited about that one.

So, the other the other big design that's uh, in the middle of playtesting now is a game called They March Against Us, which is about the Battle of Leipzig in 1813. It is the first Blind Swords Napoleonic design for Revolution. Uh, Revolution's posted up some pictures of it in action. Uh, it's the entire Battle of Leipzig. It's a brand new system that's based in Blind Swords, but it's particularly Napoleonic warfare.

People who [clears throat] aren't familiar with the Blind Swords system, could you give maybe a just a overview of what that is and how it works?

The Blind Swords system is essentially it it's based in a chit pull mechanism, but you're not only drawing chits to activate your units, you're also drawing random events that occur throughout and the manipulation and how you handle those events when you use them, when you don't, when you use the default event, that's all part of the decision making in the game. So, it's not an I go, you go. It is a constant flowing back and forth and you have to manage your side based on the chits that have been pulled, the chits you think are coming up. Um so, it is again, it's it's that historical chaos.

Yeah.

Where you're never quite sure what's going to happen and and how you're going to handle it.

Yeah. And so, what's against us is what's against us is going to take that same system

Same

Except it uses cards. And it uses cards like Black Swan. So, you're you're you're feeding events and and activations into a common deck and drawing the cards and you're just going in that order. The difference in this game is in uh in Blind Swords and Black Swan is you can just issue an order when you draw the card, you're activating second core, I'm going to decide to attack. In this game, the card you feed in for a formation has an order on it. So, you're committing to the orders ahead of time.

Oh, okay.

Yeah. So, when you draw So, if uh Ney is allowed to issue two orders and maybe he you decide, well, I'm going to maneuver and then I'm going to attack. The maneuver and attack cards go in the deck and they get mixed up in there and everything and if you draw the attack order first, you do have the option to hold it to wait till later cuz you're waiting for your maneuver card cuz you have in your brain I'm going to maneuver these guys and attack. The problem is there's also other mechanisms in there where you can lose a card that you're holding.

Oh, okay.

So, it's it's to just again we're talking about design for effect to simply um simulate the the more um the older more time delayed order mechanism in the Napoleonic Wars. You have sending couriers out and the whole the whole process is same as the Civil War but even still a little bit more a little slower, right? Um this simple mechanism of you having to commit the card with the order on it just changes that up. It doesn't give you the option to change it till the last second. You got it when the card's pulled that's the order you got.

Right. Oh, I'm excited for this cuz I'm rather new I have I've got limited experience with Napoleonic games but I've seen that order system in there and there's a couple of experiences I've had where it it it it was a little tedious in some games. It was like this is not so much fun or it's not there. Um and and so getting that aspect of making that element of gameplay fun and interesting

Right.

Some of them some of them make you actually trace couriers out and things like that or or write your orders. Yeah, this is just a a simpler way to do it and then the net effect again the design for effect is that that's the way it feels.

Right.

Yeah. Oh, exciting stuff.

Uh I'll I'll bet I'll make this a lot faster. Um there's a we have a push your luck science fiction game with Flying Pig called Kill All Frenchmen. Frenchmen are named after Frenchmen are named after Enrico Fermi. That's why they're Frenchmen, okay?

Okay. Okay.

That's that's a lot of fun. It used to be called Volts Lead the Way and this is kind of a second edition of it.

Okay.

Um I'm doing a new edition of At Any Cost with Hexasim Games. So, I'm going to redesign that a little bit um and they're going to publish it. It was on the GMT P500 for a long time and it just wasn't getting any traction and I just asked them, "Let me let me redo it a little bit, go to a French company which they love the Franco-Prussian War in France, right?" And they like this game, so we're going to do it.

do great stuff. I've just been playing La Bataille de Dede. Um their World War I game.

Oh yes, by Arnaud. Yes.

Yeah. Yeah. And they they do great stuff. Great production and

He's actually uh the developer uh over there. He he helped me with the 12th Battle of Caporetto game I did for them and he's uh they're going to publish Dawn of the Zeds, the French version of it.

Oh nice.

Um and then yes, they're going to do the editing cost.

Yeah.

Real fast, I got a hint. This is the first time I'm mentioning this. This is a newsflash.

Newsflash.

I'm doing uh GMT asked me to do something similar to Plumm Island Horror, but something that maybe played in half the time, right? And and that was less complex. So I said, "All right, I'll do that." So I have a game I'm working on right now. We've got the initial stages going. It's called Heavy Metal Thunder. It's uh I can't help myself. Um this is actually like a post-apocalyptic um um type of theme, right? And the reason it's called Heavy Metal Thunder is all the gangs out in the wasteland arrive and their motorcycles lead the way, of course. It's all it's all raiders and mobsters on on motorcycles.

Okay. Will this be a solitaire game then, too, like Plumm Island Horror or cooperative?

it can be it's both. It it can it'll play up to five uh cooperatively or you can play it solo if you want. Yeah.

Ah. Awesome.

And and there will be a

simpler? Is it going to be simpler as well than Plumm Island Horror or just faster?

It's going to be simpler and faster.

Okay. Cool.

So I'm going to take some of the lessons I learned from I know one of the criticisms of Plumm Island Horror is that it's a little bit too crunchy and it all takes a little bit too long to play. So I've learned Learn lessons.

Learned those lessons

it would

a strength to some of us, right?

Well, this this one's aimed at more like you know, an hour and a half to two hours.

Right. Right. Yeah.

And I have I have of course many heavy metal thing references in the game. So

Yeah.

Yeah, it'll be a lot of fun. Um What else I got? I got a game called More Brains which is a zombie push your luck game much like in Magnificent Style and A Fortnight

Hope and Crowbar Um

and I'm doing that for Jackal Games which is Randy Lynn's new non-wargame company. So he's

bit familiar with that. Yeah.

Legion Legion War Games and he's doing new company and this is going to be I think the third game for him.

Oh, fantastic. I'm actually meeting him for lunch in two days.

Oh, are you really?

Yeah, I'm really excited.

Yeah, he's a great guy.

Yeah, I've never met him before. So we live close by actually. Well, he's moved

He did a good job with Miracle at Dunkirk for me for Legion War Games. Beautiful production is fantastic.

They do great work.

I was only too happy to help him with Jackal Games and I said, "Well, I do have this game that that Ryan Heilman and I worked on it together.

Yeah.

And it's it's basically zombie A Fortnight Hope. But

Okay.

One thing I will say as a side note, in Magnificent Style, Crowbar, Fortnight Hope Kill All Frenchmen and now More Brains, all use the basic concept of a push your luck system that I developed in Magnificent Style. However none of the five actually use the same activation system. I I use a different activation for every one of them.

Right.

dice roll, some are cards, some are other things. I just can't help myself. I just like creating new systems. So

Right.

I did that. Yeah. So if you're in if you're worried that all these games are going to be exactly the same

[clears throat]

excuse me, they're not. They're they're all they all actually mechanically are a little bit different. But the concept is how far do you push and when do you lay off? It's it's basically that. Yeah. And then finally, yes, finally, I have a game um with Nuts Publishing that they've had for about a year now. It is a game that I called Assault on Zultar. It is a giant cooperative science fiction war game where you can play with up to four players together as mercenaries at going out into space and conquering a planet for its resources. And it had geomorphic that has geomorphic boards, multiple factions, and fighting these these aliens. And they're going to do it. They're actually hired artists at New Narrative. They're actually building a whole sci-fi world around this little game.

Wow.

And creating basically a basically a a soap opera a space opera out of this. And

This sounds like a big production.

It is. It's been going on for a year and a half. I keep writing them going, "Well, how things going over there?"

So, hopefully they'll they'll send something to me soon and let me know. But that that will be

will this be a again solitaire cooperative type of

Either way. I I always wanted to do a cooperative war game. I mean, how many cooperative war games are there out there now? Not very many. So, I wanted to do that. It's hard to do it with a historical game system. So, I said, "Well, let's do it with a sci-fi game system." That's it's a little bit more malleable that way. And and it worked out great. It's been play testing great. Fred and I played it for a year before we turned it over to them. So.

Oh, very nice.

I do think it's going to look like

I do feel like that's that's an opportunity, you know, there's a there's a lot of games out there. But I do feel like that's an opportunity in war game is that solitaire cooperative that cooperative mode of war game that is a category that I think is underrepresented.

I mean, I don't know how you feel about it, but I know when I was in New York and I we had our gaming group, my my favorite games to play were big cooperative games. I you know, it there's something about cooperative play that just it's just a different vibe that amongst the guys when you're actually strategizing together to to beat something, right?

Yeah. I and I love that collaboration and the ideation and coming [clears throat] up with ideas and teamwork and I feel like that's a a side of gameplay that there's a lot of opportunities in war gaming even any kind of tactical strategy gaming to really take advantage of and do it do it well. You know, and the bonus is that you can always take that then and play it solitaire.

Exactly, right? Every every cooperative game can be played solo.

Right. Right. Yeah. Exciting stuff. Well, thank you

[clears throat]

so much for sharing this. This is

now, so

And with that we've reached the halfway point in our interview with Herman Luttmann. In the second half we'll be talking about his top three historical board games as well as a couple of other side questions. And at the end of that video, I'll have details on how to enter the drawing for a Plum Island tour and the expansion. Link to that video will be right here as soon as it is ready. Thanks for watching everybody.

Progress saved