Skip to main content
Loading video...

Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest Board Game Review

Transcript 11:28

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings and we generally like to talk a load of bollocks by tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a reprint of a game that was released 10 years ago we're going to be talking about libertaria the winds of girl crest and in this game you'll be playing characters onto an island you'll be taking actions in the daytime during dusk and in the night time that will allow the loot booty to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we tell you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back and tell you whether or not libertarian the winds of gail crest is worth playing today and in the future so remember if you knew it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit like button all right see you after this bollocks so libertarian of the windsor girl quest how'd you play this game so the first thing you're going to do is going to stick the ball down the center of the table you'll put the reputation markers randomly in their respective slots it don't matter how many players are going to be playing this game you'll put all the reputation markers out this game takes place over three voyages and each voice will have a different number of days right first footage we'll have four days the second voice will have five days and the final voice will have six days what you do you dig into the bag of booty tokens and you'll place one booty token per player in each of the boxes depending on what voyage you're

sailing in one player is going to take their deck they'll draw six character cards and the rest of players will draw the exact same character cards to form a deck you'll look at your position on a reputation track and then you will get that many doubloons so when you actually start playing a game are you going to do everybody's going to choose one character from their hand they'll put it face down in front of them and then in unison everyone will reveal their character card each character has a number from 1 to 40 and what you do you place these in ascending order with the lowest character on the left hand side of the island space and then the highest character on the furthest space on the right hand side ties are broken through reputation right the further to the right you are on the reputation track the further to the right on the island track you're going to place your character so the next one you're going to do from left to right you will activate any daytime symbols you work your way through the characters until you get to the character with the highest number and then what you do the player with the highest number will then pick one of the boo tokens for the day that you're sailing on right then what you do you'll activate any dusk symbols that are on either the character or the boogie token going from right to left once you've done that if your character is still on the island you will place them in your ship which is good to blow in front of it and then you'll activate any night effects that are on the character cards in your ship if you're ever instructed to discard one of your character cards you will take it from your ship or from the island and you'll dump it in your graveyard which is the weird looking tile thing like the final scene out of goonies so once you've gone through all the days of the voyage when you get to the end of the voyager and

you'll activate any anchor symbol no not wankers them anchor symbols right yeah you activate any anchor symbols and then you will add all of the balloons that you made in that voyage and you'll alter your treasure chest dials then you'll discard all the loot tokens that you got you'll get rid of all the characters in your ship and then you'll draw another six cards and you'll add the characters that you didn't use in the previous voyage to your hands you will have a bigger and a character cast right again you'll look at your reputation track you'll get that many doubloons and you'll keep doing this for three voyages and then a player with the most doubloons on their treasure chest for the winner of libertalia wins the gail quest so what do we like but libertaria wins of gail crist so the first thing that we like about this game is the huge amount of characters in the game right that's 40 in this iteration again the older one had 30 but this has got 40. so you got 10 more right so you might end up playing d scale and it says for the daytime phase discard the scale immediately choose another character from your end and place it on the island according to its rank shifting the other characters as needed right you might end up with the exploring in the dust phase you gain a map token and you gain two reputation map token is a booty tile and all booby tiles have different special abilities right so for instance you might have picked up a chest and that will at the end of a voyage give you five doubloons you might have picked up a hook and this at the end of a voyage allows you to keep the character in your ship for the next voyage or gain the balloons you might have picked up a saber and this allows you to discard another player's character from john you

can kick him off the island right since you can kill him but you're not allowed to say that these days i you might have a barrel and in the dust phase it gives you one reputation at the end of the voyage it will give you one doubloon or you might have the really nasty relic and this says you have to lose three doubloons at the end of a voyage right so a lot of these cards are dependent on what booty tiles you pick up right so you might have the top man rather go to john collier's myself but there you go you have no excuse then i mean and it says in the night phase gain four doubloons and then lose wonderbloom for each character in your ship or you might end up drawing the governor and it says in the day phase discard all characters from your ship gain one reputation for each character discarded in this way right so there's a plethora of choice and variation in these character cast right so the next thing that we like about libertalia the winter gold quest is the component quality is off the charts and this is a hallmark now for stone mild games they always push the boat out with the quality of the components and if you look at the booty tokens in the original they were just cardboard cut out tokens but these are really nice chunky plastic tokens the cardstock is really really nice you've got those dials which stop you from using the scoring track right it might be a little bit easier it might not be a little bit easier because my maths is complete and i buggered it up a couple of times with these right but all in all you cannot fault the attention to detail and the way the stone mild games produces their games is it's absolutely astonishing so the final thing we like about this and this is a really simple but yet clinical idea for me they've printed the booty's holes on

the board right in the original you had to sort of remember what all the booty tiles did and me being one of those thick idiots could never remember what they did but now they are printed on the board and hey presto this gives rise to something else they've included other booty tile tiles to put over the top you've got two sides of the board so not only have you got variation on the board but you've got a variation on what booty tiles you could put out right and this makes the prospect of an expansion for this even more tasty so what don't we like about libertaria the winds of gale crest so the first thing that we don't like about this game and this is a contradiction of one of our other points the fact that we celebrate the fact it was more characters is that in giving you more characters not only is there going to be less chance of the original characters coming out but a lot of the new characters are reliant on the new reputation system and it's not always the case that reputation is going to be important because if you are ahead on the reputation track and you draw a lot of characters like the captain for instance who in the day phase says advance to the right most space on the reputation try to lose one doubloon for his position going this way or another example of the cards that rely on reputation is the officer that says in the day phase if you have 12 or more doubloons going two reputation otherwise gained the balloons until you have a title with 12 right so a lot of these new cards are dependent on the reputation track and reputation isn't really that important a lot of times when i played this a lot of people don't really even pay attention to the reputation then you might end up with a load of cards that refer to it when you don't really want it and whilst there's

more cards in the deck having a lot of them that rely on reputation as a bit of a bummer so the second thing that we don't like about this game is that the artwork in this new version isn't in keeping with the theme right what they've done is they've removed all of the grittiness and the raw nature of the graphics in the original and they've transplanted it with anthropomorphic animals so you've got a rat as a beggar right you've got a horse as a bandit you've got a turtle or a tortoise as a preacher and you've got a walrus as the smuggler right so i don't know whilst the artworks alright it's got the same type of artwork as that flicking game catacombs right i just much preferred the gritty nature and the aesthetics in the original they've managed to suck the life out of this game right it's like looking at your favorite painting in monochrome yeah it's the same painting but there's just no life to it and it just looks too clinical right i don't know why they chose to remove the priority theme and put this sort of crap in here but i just don't like it at all so the final thing that we don't like about this one is that when you kill or discard a character right you have to discard it from the island right whereas in the original you discard it from your ship and in doing so that means that the person who has their character discarded doesn't get to take a booty type or at least that's the way i interpret it in the rulebook and this means that you are going to miss out by quite a bit you're not going to be able to get that money you're not going to be able to kill any other characters i just prefer the rule in the original where you get to kill somebody from your ship and this

makes more sense because the characters in your ship are going to activate in the knight faces really no point in killing characters on the island they might not be activated in a dust phase it's just really frustrating that they had to change such a basic but important rule so to summarize is libertarian a winter gale crest worth your time on bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes and that is because this is the only version of the game you're going to be able to get your hands on unless you trawl the internet for a secondhand copy of the original that means if you really really want to play libertarian today then you're gonna have to put up with the dog's dinner that they have made of this version i like the game libertaria i really do love it but they've managed to rip the guts out of this game and just splash a load of sterile paint all over here they've taken the gritty nature the wonderful artwork the risks that mara bundler took with the original gamer and they've removed everything that made the game a modern classic i really wish i'd never played the original libertarian and then played this because then maybe i wouldn't know what i was missing but then even if i hadn't played it i probably would pass over this one because i said before the game itself is really really good and this is a wonderful example of how much theme can make the difference between a good game and a mediocre game yeah because the theme in this one for me anyway is largely absent and that makes and breaks a game for me so whilst i do recommend libertaria if you do have the option between this one

and the original i would definitely go for the original if you can't get all the original and you like that sort of sterile washed out stripped back nature of this one then by all means go for it otherwise maybe part with a few extra quid and go through the original game so there you go that is libertarian wins the gal quest remember if you're new in and please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button subscribe and all that and we'll see you next time

you

Progress saved