Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond the Horizon: Discussion

Transcript 32:49

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. Brian and I are doing a discussion over Beyond the Horizon. Now, I have a perfect I I'm glad I remembered because I have a perfect meme for my feelings on this game because this will come out after our discussion over Beyond the Sun where I gave Beyond the Sun a seven. Uh that thought was good, but nothing to be like, whoa. I think I gave it an eight. Seven or an eight. Yeah, I gave it an eight, which is fine. Um, my meme is the Thanos meme of like looking at Beyond the Sun and going, "Perhaps I treated you too harshly." Because this game is just somehow worse. It's somehow worse, even though it's basically the same game. And I think there's something to be said, and I think we brought it up about Beyond the um Beyond the Sun. The simplicity of Beyond the Sun when compared to this really shows the elegance of it because sometimes more is not better. And this game for some reason is worse. Even though, like I said, what you do and if you were to teach this game after coming off Break Beyond the Sun is almost on a onetoone basis, but the cadence and the extra stuff that they added on top of somehow taking away the graphic design, even though it's

just almost a pale imitation that I do not have a good time while playing this game. Like even though I gave Beyond the Sun a seven, which I thought was good, I was still invested and I was still, you know, methodically planning here. Like every time I've played this, I've just gone through the motions. I'm just whatever, whatever, whatever. These extra construction tiles, it's just like I don't give a [ __ ] I don't care. Like, because I don't really care about that. These are just a means to an end. This is like the the tile thing is only there to, you know, that to replace the space theme, but somehow make it more convoluted, more fiddly, and worse. I mean, they could have done the exact same if they're if they're making a reskin of Beyond the Sun, they could have put like just a board that was had villages and did the same thing with put cards out. Yeah. And do almost the ex identical thing with the with like they did on the planets. That's true.

You know, you went there, you settled the planet, and if somebody else went there with more power, then you got bounced. Yeah. And then you took, you know, it's like, and then you g you gathered planets. Yeah. Down here that were victory points and gave you stuff. Maybe it was like a damned if you do, damned if you don't where I people would have bitched if it was literally beyond the sun just with a civilization theme. But now since they tried to do something different, it's it's inherently worse. So it's like and and I would say oh like if you want the more realistic theme cuz I mean I love the civilization idea of going from you know basic human you know civilization all the way to now we have internet but they took away graphic design and stuff. So it's like okay every single of these construction tiles are boring.

There's the the cheapest art behind it. So, none of it is exciting. The leader cards are virtually blank with two icons on it and a and a a picture that they got off, you know, Google images of some It's like awful awful generic art. I just I just have a a worse time. It's not very often that I'm angry after playing a game because, you know, I get beat a lot. But like, are you okay? Do we have to talk? But but like these things are so out of whack. Yeah. It's like like I could have been playing the best game of my life and I still wouldn't even come close.

Yeah. Because your ability where you just have I mean that's to me that is the crux of a tech building game. Yeah. Is to work up to get the the prerequisites. Yeah. To move on. And then that ability you had, mind you, it was just randomly dealt out and you could It's not like I was like I want this one. No, I know. And and it was randomly and it's not going to be in every game. Yeah. But you literally could just pop pop. Yeah. So, the ability we're talking about and like I assume that cuz in Beyond the Sun, they have the expansion or not the expansions, but like the you have the base corporations and then you have the different ones with all the unique actual abilities. They don't have that here. They have these government cards essentially that are double-sided that go from desperatism, theocracy, monarchy, and democracy. Um, and everyone has a starting ability and then as you upgrade on a uh on a on the whatever the gear track, you unlock your A ability, your B ability. So your A ability is like another passive you have. The B ability is almost an instant. And then the C ability is uh endgame scoring.

So, the one that I had in this last game we played was you only need one prerequisite when you research technologies. Now, I scoured that rule book to make sure maybe I'm misunderstanding prerequisites. Maybe I'm misunderstanding the starting ability. Maybe it's a one-time use. Nope. And first of all, this rule book is awful. I hate games that hide rules in the component section. That [ __ ] is awful where it's like, man, I don't know. Like, I remember the first time I was trying to figure out what these I'm like, what the hell are those tokens? Where? Like, what do those even mean? And it's like, oh, they find it in the component section. It's horrible. But yeah, no, exactly. This last game we played was so wildly unfair.

And the main reason why is again all that because whenever all I need is one out of two prerexs or one out of three prerexs, I'm at threes while you're barely getting into twos. Well, and then not to compound that, that also that made this last game crazy was two of the in-game deals dealt with getting level three uh level two or level three deals. And you I mean you just flew down and Right. Yeah. research. So you had two of them like just like that, right? Um and then it's like because I mean Beyond the Sun and Beyond the Horizon is methodically increasing these tracks so that when you go to your production phase, you got a little bit more money. The game is not supposed to be rampant with money or with people. But when you don't have to work so hard on technologies, um then you just are getting there before everyone else. you then get the instant bonus before everyone else. So that's why I was constant like oh look tech. Oh look, you know production production people. So then by the time your money money yeah like money and then oh because of all that it compounds into me being able to settle quicker. So then I just have my track filled up almost immediately so that while you're like woo finally I can get two money.

I'm like I'm going to spend I'm going to spend three money to do this. Get four. spend three, get four. That I'm just swimming in money. And then it's like, oh, look, Adam Smith came out. Lucky me. I'm going to take even four more money cuz of course I got here before you. So, I'm going to take four money. And oh, at the end of the game, everyone gets a point for every four coins they have. Oh, did you give him my two points? I did. I I did. Yep. Yep. Um, actually, no, I didn't. I lied. I lied. I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. You actually won. No, no, it's a It's 110 to 58. Um, and people are like 110? with an amateur. So, I like I don't care. Um, but that just constantly just expands upon itself to where one person's just running away with the game and the game cannot end quick enough because it's not fun for me or challenging for me whenever I'm like, "Okay, I'm clearly only doing well because I have the most busted ability." Which would be fine if it was like uh Voyages of Marco Polo.

Oh, yeah. Where every ability was busted. Yeah. But when when you have that one and then mine or my soldiers are one stronger. Yeah. I mean that's Yeah, it's it's nice. But how many times did I overshoot cuz like that last time I had I I settled the last two I settled I had five. Right. Anyway, so it's like I didn't even need that ability to to do it. So it was just like if it makes you feel any better, you did get more points on settling and uh and fortifications. Yeah. Um, so I mean, so yeah. So the the starting game abilities are clearly busted because the other side of this is not I mean it's still better than that, but it's like you pay one less coin when you research technologies. Okay. I mean because money is supposed to be tight that that helps, but it's not I mean that's more comparable to the [ __ ] plus one soldier um thing. It's like I pay one less, but you have one more strength. But then the second ability, you always use inactive pawns instead of active pawns when you research technologies. That's huge. That means I don't have to stress about having people. I can just go, "Oh, okay."

And both of my sides were just about fortifying. That's all this was was fortifying. Yeah. In a tech tree game, being able to research technologies easier than other players is the biggest advantage in the world because again, anything that could have been great over there, I now have abilities that allow me to do that better than you or easier than you. Um, the the the strength of the tech tree should be you're researching and you're making your way further and you're getting stuff that I can't use. Yes. to get better at stuff, not not racing, being able to race to the end, you know. Um, and like we said in our Beyond the Sun review, uh, you know, everything you do about the tech tree is a means to an end in the space exploration. That's where a lot of it comes from. Um, and that's that's still the case here, but the fact that it's so much easier to or with the ability to run rampid on this is is awful. Um, now we get to this monstrosity uh of just making it more convoluted. I thought I thought that these putting the the these things on top of the stupid wheels was going to be the thing I hated worst about this game. And it's not.

It's still awful though, just from a game design standpoint. You have these strength tokens and Beyond the Sun, it was just dice you just flipped in. That was the strength. It was they went away from that because they just need because the major difference is Dennis Chan I I hope that's how it's Chan was the sole designer on Beyond the Sun. This is too many goddamn cooks in the [ __ ] kitchen. You have four designers on a reskin. Yeah. Are you kidding me? Did they just need to get work? Did they are like, "Hey, Dennis, uh we did three sisters. That was a big hit. Uh you need us in your game." Well, they're generally rolling right people, too. So, it's like that was what was kind of weird because their general their pedigree is making rolling right games, right? And I don't know why. Stick to [ __ ] rolling rights because that's the bread and butter. because they're like, "hm, what if we made what if we made this system where we have these horrible horrible pawns that you flip over and you balance tokens that you move quite frequently on the map and then it's like, oh, I I promise you I wasn't even trying to make that fall off and it just did because the tokens are slightly larger than even the widest base. Yeah, they are supposed to flip over. It is.

It It's just gobsmackingly fiddly. And it's been a long time since I played like a fiddly game that wasn't like mechanically fiddly. It was like components fiddly. This is awful. So now you have to compete for this settle thing and then you have to be like turn around and then now you have to fortify it. Um, but like you explore and you get a bonus for exploring and then you settle, you get a bonus for settling. And if you don't even want to settle, you can reduce the strength of them and pay money to put in these boring ass constructions that give you some points, but only give you extra points if someone else goes on there. This is meant to be the higher point games, higher player point, higher player count games, as well as ways to get more of your tracks. Yeah. Out because we weren't even going to I mean we went separate ways. So if even if you did that I was never going to use them for No. I mean you have like the wheel gives you four movement. If you ever get up on the one you get plus one. So it's not impossible to run all the way over and and jump on here. But it's so expensive and it's not really worth it.

Uh I actually find the constructions to be unless it unless it's a goal uh which in the last game I played this it was. Um, these are ass because the benefits you get for this is just is better as well as you don't have to spend money to do it. So, it's just ignore these. These are not even interesting or fun in any way. I think the leaders, the upgrades are somehow worse. I recognize some of the names, not all of them, but uh yeah, like and it's almost like these leaders don't even really feel like they're they just put them in a randomizer and they're like, "Hey, here's someone who is popular. Here's Isaac Newton. He gives you two coins. Why?" Right? Like, "Hey, I guess he lets me research a level two, but why aren't these to more tied to the people that existed?

Um, this game single-handedly made me appreciate Beyond the Sun a lot more. Way way more. Yes. And it's so bizarre because whenever like I was teaching you this game, I was like, you you know how to play. Here's the minor differences, but like it's it's basically Beyond the Sun. But I don't know. I I I'm I'm surprised that there are people who prefer this one and I don't know why. I I don't I maybe they just don't like the space theme at all. Yeah, maybe in this or or if this is the first one they played and they never played Beyond the Sun. Yeah, that could be it. You know, like if this was their first step into the system, maybe. But just from a inherently mechanical standpoint, the flipping of these pieces and putting on the different tokens is aggravating.

I guess the area control, but Beyond the Sun had the area control element, too. That's what I was saying. Like it was so much easier. It was just a board with cards and you move your dice off here to there. And they were even like even like conquering um planets gave you like endgame special abilities. That was actually more exciting. You don't get that from these. You just if you fortify a city, it's just more points. Yeah. If it ain't broke, don't fix it, man. Pretty much. That's That's If they want to do a reskin, they should have just kept the dice. Kept the dice. I think they should have leaned way more into the civilization theme. Um, while we were playing this, I was telling you, even if it was a graphical overhaul, now again, Beyond the Sun is not a pretty game by any means. It looks like an Excel spreadsheet tech tree.

Um, but that one almost works because I just kind of envisioned the digitization of a tech tree, like a video game, right? Um, like you look at a skill tree like Path of Exile and it's just a grid of just [ __ ] nonsense. Um, but if if this because this is centered and based in reality, if this actually had a castle on it, if this actually had an institute on it, a monastery on it, a workshop on it, an amphitheater on it, that would somewhat help with the immersion, but instead of having literally the exact same background art. I don't I don't know this for a fact. This is just a total guess, so I may be way off on this, but it's like they were just trying to put out a cheap like they're trying to go cut as many corners as they could to put this out. Like I mentioned, the card quality isn't great.

Yeah, they stick together. Um, dice are probably more expensive than wooden deals. Little wooden tiny little cubes. You think so? Oh, you're talking about Yeah. The whole the whole dice that was out here. You had dice instead of wood. Dice is going to be plastic is more expensive than than wood bits. Yeah, right. Um, they didn't do tons of art. They didn't have to pay a bunch of art. That's true. You know, the cards are I mean, well, the cards are pretty much the same. I mean, right. But, but that's the thing. I think they're charging whatever it was 60 70 bucks for this game. And it's like I think they just cut a lot of corners on stuff, you know. And then this is a nitpick, but it drives me crazy. There's three different fonts in the title. Oh, yeah. On the box, dude. That's what I'm saying. Like and so Dennis Chan is on here because this Beyond the Sun was his original design and I think the other three designers uh contributed to the three different fonts like it's Adam, Matt, and Ben. That was all their different the cover art of Beyond a Sun was that whole classic space. Yeah. You know, theme and the box cover really did a good job even though the game inside was analytical and and stuff that it was neat. This one I I had such high hopes for this one too because I liked Beyond the Sun and I was like it's colorful.

They're going to go civ. Mhm. And then I I almost It's It's funny like I get more theme out of Beyond the Sun than this one and that one's completely made up and this one is based around real [ __ ] I think cuz these cards make more sense like the the weird technologies like the cryo cryostasis whatever whatever drives and stuff like that. You know, it's cuz it was one guy who had a vision to make a game and he tried to make it as thematic in in in the tech tree game as possible. Four guys were like, "Hey, we just need money." Yeah. I'd be curious what each one of them did, like like how much Dennis Chan did any of it or if it was just his system that those other three. How many games do you know with four designers tagged on it? Well, I know. But well, those three, Adam, Matt, and Ben, they worked they're they're a trio. They work together on Got a lot of their like a lot of their games. Oh, I thought you said it was just Matt and Ben. No, Adam Hill works with them too. Not on all of them, but he he works with him as well.

But it's like so those three worked together on a lot of games. Um, so I'm wondering if they did the whole game and with Dennis Chan being like they they had to credit him because it was based on I don't know that. I know. The interesting thing about that whole system though is it's not like the tech tree is a small part and then they they completely changed it and it's like oh I kind of see the skeleton of beyond the sun but man there's this whole this is this it's not like they made through the ages with a tech tree you know they made beyond the sun so it's like what the [ __ ] did you guys contribute that's what I'm saying I think that's why his name's on there Jan is because this I mean this is the game but I think all this extra stuff was brought in by the other guys.

Yeah. It's it's the equivalent of when you go to watch a movie and you're like, "This movie is bad. What the [ __ ] It's all over the place." And you look and there's like 18 writer credits. It's like, "Oh, there was not a single vision here." Right. Uh that's exactly what this game brings. But it's even worse because they they had they had the game. The game's made for them. They had the biggest layup possible and they [ __ ] the bed. Yeah. I mean, I'd be curious what like I'm gonna look and see what BGG has it rated. It's going to be like a [ __ ] eight right now. I'm just curious. It's gonna It's going to be an eight and or a seven and it's going to make me throw up cuz BGG ratings like the the the bar is a seven. Beyond the Horizon is a 7.2.

You know, funny enough, I was just bitching about it being a seven. 7.2 in BGG rank is actually not great. The sun. I want to see it. But it is it beyond? Yeah, beyond the sun. Oh, there it is. Beyond the sun's a 7.9. Wow. So, and what's actually what's interesting about that? So, beyond Oh, pull up. Um, beyond the beyond the sun. Okay, got it. Um, tell me how many rankings there are. So, in the stars, the star 16,000. So, that's a 7.9 with 16,000 reviews. So therefore, the average of that should actually be lower, meaning people are rating it high, right? Yes. Beyond the horizon as lower as 7.2 with 837. So that means people are ranking it way lower. Um, now I know I was just bitching rankings and and numbers are all [ __ ] arbitrary anyway. But for people who are coming into a gaming and they want a general like, oh, what do most people think of the game? Um, I personally believe that five fives fives are my average. No one does that.

No one. BG about seven and sevens are people's average and it goes up or down. Like people are like if you rank a game of five, a lot of people are like, "Oh, so you hate it." It's like school like the C average is a That's exactly it. And that's why I think the Dice Towers kind of coined that where it's like if you if they rank it lower than a seven, they really didn't like it because they do that grading school thing. I definitely don't do that. Um, so fives are average for me. If it's below a five, I really didn't like it. Yep. So, sevens to me are are good, like flat good. Yeah. Uh, and then eights, nines, and tens uh are like it's like good uh very good, great per, you know, perfect. Anyway, all that is to say that if a newer game like this is coming out, you know, you know, off rip at a 7.2, that's not a great sign. Especially if I believe that most people like that that probably I don't know that that clearly means that most people don't like it especially better. Dennis Chan just needs to come out with another expansion for Beyond the Sun by himself.

Just Beyond the Sun. I don't even know if he does. I think the what from what you showed me with the leaders and stuff that's a lot of gameplay. Yeah, that's a solid like one and done. Yeah. Um I mean at most cuz did it add more text? It did. Yeah, it added it added more operations, more text. I think if this just had Dennis Chan's name uh on it, it would have been better. The text would have made more sense. The the the leaders and the events would have been more thematic. Uh yeah, this wouldn't have been as convoluted and messy. You probably just would have had one type of worker. Um I would have enjoyed if it was Beyond the Sun Civ themed. Oh yeah, like that would have I probably would have enjoyed that more. hell. A pure reskin like that I would have liked because I like this theme more than space. Yeah. So, if they he would have just done a total reskin. The player boards look almost identical. Only there's just it's just, you know, uh Civ themed. Yeah. I would have bought it and loved it because it's still this the game that I like but in the theme I like a little more a little better. Yeah. I can overlook the space because that's such a solid Yeah. you know, and even though it doesn't look great, it somehow like you said with the technologies and stuff was a was like it's like oh that ability makes sense to the to the title.

Uh but then I did just say something that I actually would like more through the ages with a tech tree. Like I would have liked that uh like significant. Although does Through the Ages have a tech tree? It doesn't have a tech tree, so I don't know. I don't remember. It's been a long time. Yeah. Uh, all that is to say like if you are looking at Beyond the Beyond the Horizon, Beyond the Sun, uh, don't look any further and just get Beyond the Sun. I am retro I can't do it because we've already done a review for Beyond the Sun. I am retroactively giving Beyond the Sun an eight. Now, if you played the expansion, I bet it would bump up. It probably would bump up to an eight. Um, but this game made me appreciate cuz I I have Beyond the Sun still. I know we keep looking like I kept it. Thank god this is not my game and it's yours. It's not going to be mine.

But I remember playing it and I think I texted you immediately the and I was like it's worse, dude. It's worse. I can't explain it, but it's worse. And I thought again it was mainly the fiddliness of that. No, it's not. It's just it's it's like the cash grabbiest of cash grab games. This almost feels like it was like a co game. It was designed during COVID behind Zoom. They had Zoom meetings to come up with a game that they needed so they could pay their rent or mortgage. So yeah, it's it's uh it's Oh, wait, dude. The development. This is actually insane. He's not even on the on the cover. Development is Simone Luciani.

Really? for the solo maybe. Um, there's not any solo rules in here. If there's a solo, I mean, it plays well. It says two. It says two to four. Oh, there's not solo. No. No. Yeah. Right here. Game designers, Adam Hill, Matt Riddle, Ben Pinchback, and Dennis John. And then development, Simone Luciani. So, he helped develop it. My heroes. They're They're What are they doing? Yeah, cuz he's on that one, isn't he? Uh, that one is Sorry. Uh, he is. Oh, it's Daniel Tassini. Daniel Tini. That's it. Simone is is uh is it Simone or Simon? I thought it was Simone. Simone. Simone. Luciani. He did a lot of those. Zulan, Darwin's Journey, Voyages, Marco Polo, Lorenzo. He's done so many great Euros. I guess this is what you do. You come in. It's kind of like Gilmo Del Toro on movies. It's like, did what do you do with it? He produced it. Why did they put his Cuz his name would be sold. You know what it is? Okay. Are we sure that these are real people? Cuz you know how like people don't want their people? I listen to them like every two weeks on podcast.

I'm sorry. Um but you know how like if someone doesn't want like a writing credit or an acting credit, they come up with like a fake name. So like cuz they have to put on there. It's like it's like a standard name that you if you you'll see it on a bunch of credits. It's the same name because they're like I don't want to be on recognized for this. Maybe that's it. Maybe like he's like he's like guys just just put me on the cover. You don't have to. No, dude. No one's going to look at the credit section on the back. The game doesn't start with a T. I can't be on I can't be on it anyway. Yeah. So, and they're like, well, we have something special here. We'll put their names on the cover. Uh, and I I I I want to ver I want to stress very much this is not actually a personal dig on these designers. I wish them no ill will. I like those their those guys and their own rights and stuff. I have played three sisters. It was good. Um this is more it's like you open yourself up to the public when you produce any type of art or game. So you are subject to ridicule if what you produce is bad. Um in in our opinion. Um so it's not like I'm sitting here going, "Well, I [ __ ] wish the worst on these guys." Because we've harped on the designers way more than we do in other videos. But yeah. Yeah. I mean, I will say um for the theming of our our game day, it is appropriate that the final score was what it was. Yes. Exactly. It would have been weird had you won by We weren't even going to play the whole game. We know we weren't. Yeah. Uh you just you

won it so fast. I mean, you just boom boom. And then like it was so funny because like there was a time when it's your turn and you're like looking at the board and you're like you finally did an action. I'm like I'm gonna go there do this. I got my money. Your turn. Yeah. Cuz there was nothing for me to do. Anyway, on a scale of 1 to 10, what are you giving beyond the horizon? Which is technically again a weird one because it's like it's still beyond the sun. It is. There's too many glaring things that that kill me on this. that part, the the unbalanced deals. To be fair, I have not played the expansion of Beyond the Sun, so I don't know. I'm hoping those player powers are balanced. It it does a lot. It's solid.

Okay. I mean, it's it's it's definitely better than there isn't anything like that. Okay. There's not there's not research technologies for free. Well, but that's the thing. So, so that the unbalanced abilities, these being worthless, um the stupid component quality of those things. I'm not even hesitating on this. I'm giving this a three. I'm serious. Like, because I mean, why why this did not there was zero reason why this needed to be made. I know. Like, in a in a world where Beyond the Sun exists, right, this does not even need to be made. Yeah. No. Um, I mean I completely agree and and I I've done really well every time I play this game, but the from from the like from go I'm like it's like as soon as I place like I'm like I'm going to go here to get a level one tech and I wish I was playing beyond the sun. Like there's nothing here that is an improvement on on the other game. It's more expensive. I'm assuming actually I think well I got Beyond the Sun for like 20 bucks I think basic it's roughly probably about the same but you can get Beyond the Sun secondhand so cheap now it's been out long enough that it's been out so long so I didn't get the game whenever it originally came out so I guess I I don't know I got it and the expansion for 25 bucks off a guy right you know so I didn't get the expansion but I mean I'm sure I can find on Amazon for for dirt cheap maybe. I don't know. Uh, I I want

the expansion now because I enjoy that game. It's just so I like, dude, I've never Maybe I have. Usually when I go back and alter a score that I give, it's usually the drop it, you know? It's like, I gave this a nine on, you know, it's probably an eight now. This was a 10, I don't play it anymore. It's a nine. I very rarely, if at all, ever go back and bump a score up because of how bad it successor was. Yeah. Um, I agree. It's it's a three. Like it's it's in it's and most people are like, "Well, why is Beyond the Sun an eight and this is a three even though like we've covered that." Yeah, I know. Exactly. It's it's it's everything else outside. Rewind the video. It's the same reason why Dark Quarter mechanically is not a three that we give it. It's all the extenduating circumstances that surround games that should be taken into account when giving a a arbitrary number to a game. So, three out of 10. This is bad.

It's not worth it. So, just get beyond the sun and have a much better time and forget this existed. And if any game has four designers on it, skip it. So, uh that's it everyone. That's our thoughts on Beyond the Horizon. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved