Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lacrimosa - Board Game Review - Written Well, But Played A Little Off-Key

Transcript 30:48

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm taking a look at the expensive lacrimosa and I say expensive because it was 70 Euro to buy the thing thank you patreons for your support so that I can put out content like this but wow yeah not the cheapest game in the world but this is from deviator games and this is another one of their sort of bigger Euros in their lineup the last time they did it was batoku and you might want to check out a little video I did to understand my thoughts on that one you and the chosen one not so good that one so it wasn't like I was really buzzing to sort of jump into this one based on reputation but to follow it let's give it a go because it is delving

in a theme that's not really been done before the idea that you are you know trying to complete one of the Lost works of Mozart and that's as far as I'm going with the theme because that's pretty much as far as the theme goes frankly because this is a fairly dry Euro game but it's a Midway Euro game mid to heavy Euro game where you are essentially moving around a map you're buying cards and you're doing area control on a funky little music track down here but the Crux of the game revolves around cards so you have these cards with the various actions on them you'll start with some basic ones but you can upgrade to better ones and what you do on your turn four times in a round is you take two of your cards and you decide where you're gonna put them in terms of top or bottom so one will go in the top which represents the action that you're doing and the other one slides in the bottom and represents a bonus that you will get at the end of the round to prepare you for the next round you'll do this four more times always having four except four cards to pick from except for the last time when you have three and then at the end of the round you'll have a little maintenance phase where you'll get some income based on your Finance track all the cards that you've placed at the bottom will generate story points which is kind of like a universal currency used to do various actions on the board and you'll rinse and repeat for another four rounds of the game there's only five rounds in total at which point you'll then total up all your victory points and of course the one with the most of course the actions that you're doing involve the purchasing of cards two types in fact you have Opus cards which allow you to gain more money and

also victory points but also upgraded action cards so that you start off with the starter versions then go oh I can find something to Disney two actions or this one gives me money as well as the action you know more powerful cards of what you already have you only ever have nine cards it's in your deck you never get any more you just replace ones that you already had so you buy a new card you gotta Chuck away another one but then you also have this map in the middle to travel around so there is a I don't think I've got him out at the moment a Mozart piece that you move around the board to different areas and these cities will have different tiles on them which give you a bonus as long as you're willing to spend the journey points to do so if you don't take them in the round they'll flip over and become better versions of themselves but essentially it's a case of pay the gold move the piece get a cool bonus possibly even a end of game objective Point scoring Tower although more on those a bit later alternatively you're also doing area control on this Requiem track down here so with your various little music note pieces that you have there are two composers that are buying for like the the right to complete the works of Mozart here and you have these tiles from each composer and you decide right well I'm going to put a music note on this violin one here here I'll take it off my board from the respective section get the bonus put it down there buy the tile for the money and story points it requires get the bonus but then depending on which composer the person wanted at the end of the game each section of this like this track will

score victory points for area control based on which composer was chosen to pick it in the first place so I mentioned about the theme not going too far with it yeah the theme in this is not really there which is a shame because this was on setting I thought that's a bit different you know I mean it's definitely a beige Euro setting more on that in a minute but I thought like you know what with this cover and everything it's like oh yeah this could be a good theme to really Embrace but it's essentially a point salad game the best game I can compare this to is Newton if you've ever played that from cranial Creations I mean that one talks about oh you're in you know you're doing all these inventions and going around and being like Isaac Newton and building up your library now and it's the driest Point salad that I think I've come across since Pulsar 2849 you know it's Super Bowl own dry this one pretty much bone dry as well I mean yes you're completing a Requiem track it's literally put a marker on a space and area control yay and then with these cards up here you can buy these Opus cards which you know are the various different works and yes if you have a music history knowledge you can recognize what uh Bastion and Bastion is or soulsburgers and Funyun is or whatever half of these things are but other than that the fact that one's a chamber music piece and one's a religious music piece literally means nothing until you score it via a tile you know so you're not really going to be getting a music theme out of this it's just a setting to apply euromechanics to much like batoku was literally a gorgeous Anime Studio Ghibli style setting with mechanics thrown in

and no fever same sort of story here a bit of a shame I was kind of hoping for a bit of a stronger thematic connection so this one's gonna have to ride pretty highly on its Aesthetics and its mechanics to win me over while Aesthetics wise is beige very beige there's a lot of beige this board is as you can see very beige you know the Box actually is kind of misleading for what you get here because the box cover is really good you know you've got the full picture of Mozart you've got the red embossed letter you've got this red kind of shiny like picture of the wagon and that being drawn like he's on his journey down there and in the background you've got all the music notes it's a really good quality cover and then you get beige and it's not that they I'll give it credit it's the prettiest beige game I've ever seen but it's still beige you know a little bit more color here and there would be nice I hope you like cream and beige because that's the biggest color you're gonna see with some hints of black and red thrown around the place you know if anything your player pieces are probably the most colorful thing on this board but like I say it's not a bad looking game I've seen beige games that look dreary and horrible and I don't want to see them on the map this one is actually pretty decent looking you know for a beige game it's pretty nice it's just not going to win any prizes and certainly no other cards because the cards are just generic action cards with a Sim some symbology and that's about it really there's nothing no other background on the cards or the cards of

the same back face so you know and even the map is not particularly that interesting I mean you got a few little trees dotted around a couple of people but other than that it's a pretty basic looking map you know much like the map interlatum was know if anything this probably has a little bit more detail than what that map did but yeah not much more so you know artwork wise meh the cover is the best thing that's looking in it component wise pretty good though you know these are decent sized counters for the story points and your music notes the cards are pretty decent quality cards and you're gonna need them for this bit which is easily the best component in the game the Dual layer boards which fold over which is really cool with the nice little logo on that and it's got a removable like uh kind of a reference age for the phases in all the different languages I mean this thing came with about six different languages in the Box you know it was kind of insane but it's dual layered so that you can put these cards in and take them out which is easy to do if you don't sleeve the cards um depending on what sleeves you use you might find it quite a hassle to get the cards in and out somewhere better than others if you go online you'll find loads of different references from people where they've said this sleeve works okay this is too big too thin sadly they didn't think to make this a little bit uh shall we say more easy to do for sleeves and personally I just think you shouldn't sleep this game I mean you've got a hand of cards but it's like four cards at a time they'll come out on a display and yes you may scuff

them a tiny bit if you play this game religiously when you're slotting them in but I don't think they're gonna play this game quite that religiously and so I think these cards will hold up for a decent while but you'll just find it a lot easier to get them in and out of this thing if you don't sleeve the cards that's my personal opinion anyway the rule book is a little bit hit and miss in terms of the rules of explaining the game the rules aren't particularly difficult to understand if anything they're written very well but whoever wrote this rule book clearly needs to learn the meaning of order what happened to them we passed that when just now we're at now now because much like the nethervelier rulebook the native linear rulebook is not the worst rulebook in the world in terms explaining the rules but the order is so jumbled up in it it makes it an absolute chore here it's not as bad but it's still like questionable as to why the order is like this yeah you start off with the content section and the setup okay good that's what I kind of expect but then you quickly get into player turns and then it explains all the actions in detail before explaining what happens at the end of a turn and the maintenance phase it's like no tell me how the round order works then go into the main actions why do it then but then on top of that it goes into the components in detail after you've learned the rule to the game so you don't know the anatomy of any of the cards in terms of what the symbol means or what this action means or what the what these various bits on the tile mean until you go past the main rules of the

game and then it's like several pages of explaining every last little detail about them then you get the solo rules and then you get the reference guide which could have been shortened down to something less than three pages I think because it does I mean it it goes it takes up a quarter of a page to tell you an opus can fall into four different types as if anyone cares because there's no theme in this game so the back of the book is telling you a few Edge case reference ideas for like some of the tiles but I would have more preferred a reference guide to be per player and on one sheet you know like I've been banging all of that in every single other game I've played the rules are not too complex it's a relatively straightforward game to understand the rules to it not necessarily how to do well that's a different story entirely but yeah it could have been like you know some a rulebook editor needed to look at that and just put things in the right sequence you know it just makes it a little bit fiddly to read but not as bad as other games and certainly once you've read the rules to this you shouldn't need to reference it too often when will then be now so in terms of the various mechanics it's kind of like most other bay Euros really I mean you know the the card system is the best part of the game for me it's not just the whole like deciding whether I'm going to put it at the top or the bottom I mean that's really cool as it is but also the fact that you can upgrade the cards much like in Newton when you had those different action cards you got and you could upgrade those into better actions same deal with this and it's cool to sort of go oh that card looks juicy yeah that

would give me two actions and those how can I afford it shut up and take my money you know what bye-bye card I want this juicy one this one's nice and it it feels good particularly when you've only got the nine cards in the game you don't have like 20 of them sprawled all over the place with too many choices to make you're only ever looking at four cards and you can get some better ones now the luck factor of this game does get in the way a bit though because you are only looking at four cards with every round and more often than not you will end up in a situation where it's like right I really need to do this action next otherwise somebody's gonna screw me over or I'm going to miss out on a really key thing to get points oh all my cards are about traveling buying cards oh there's nothing for Requiem or opus's um huh that sucks yeah you can disregard the action to get money but I'd rather have something in the game that lets you disregard the action in order to actually do an action you wanted to do in the first place so you know in a game that's a good two to two and a half hours long at least most of the time I kind of find that that's a little bit too luck swingy in my opinion I had so many times where it's like I need to do this and I can't because the car doesn't come out in the right order you Shuffle it before the start of the rounding you have no other way in this game to mitigate the cards draw which is a bit of a problem hello hello anybody home but all blemishes aside the game is a good fun tight experience because a lot of times you're going to be short for cash and you're gonna have to think I gotta spend those story points it's annoying but by the time you get to the

fourth and fifth round if the game is going well for you then you should be in a position where you are generating a decent amount of story points you are getting a decent amount of cash and you can do more powerful effects buying the cards is still a fun experience number one boarding it's just that there's only the the main action five main actions that you've got I believe and the cards don't vary that dramatically when you get ahead it's just mainly the fact that they might give you a coin or they combine two actions together but that's kind of it really even the Opus cards are basically the same thing it's just variations on cost and reward so it's not like there's a huge amount of variety in there and you do see every card in the game pretty much so it's not like there's going to be a massive surprise when you play it for the second time I go oh I didn't see that card you know that one's come up the court tiles I like though the sorry not the court the city tiles because I like the idea that you have got this bonus that you can grab every now and again there's a cool like oh a tactical opportunity here and I like the fact that if you let it slip for a bit it's like now it's a little bit more lucrative you know it gets you a little bit of extra with it and it's like no I'm really looking at that tile that's pretty good but oh you're ironing up as well stop it and there's definitely a lot of contention here with four players you're gonna be fighting for a lot of this stuff not so much with less players though because the scaling in this game doesn't really do a lot all that happens is that some of these spaces are taken up in a two three and four player game based on it so more of them are taken up in a two-player game less than a four player game but really they don't make any difference you might as well just leave

it all blank it makes no difference because what tends to happen is somebody will start off with a particular composer on a segment and then most other people will follow suit because the likelihood of that composer winning the majority for points is now high so why go against them why create the competition when you could just join them well we're supposed to haggle grabbing the bonuses on the map is also good fun but rather inconsequential for the most part a lot of this game kind of feels Much Ado About Nothing like there's a lot of faff and a lot of this you can do but it doesn't necessarily equate to much with these most of these are just like bonuses so I might get a couple of points with this Whoopi you're in two points to spend your entire turn to visit a place that's not particularly worth it but then there's other ones like oh I get one on my finance track or I get seven money which is really used for I get a few story points or I get to do this action when I could have just played the card and done the action anyway but I mean I suppose that's one way to mitigate the card luck but it's very situational that you end up doing that so these don't really get you many points to win the game they just get you some cool bonus every now and again so a lot of the times most people don't really focus on this much they'll occasionally do it because they see a bonus tile they like but they're mainly doing the cards and this this kind of takes a back seat despite the fact that it's one of the three main story Point focuses that you get and the Royal Court tiles I just never found these that worth it you know you've got two main types of it you've got ones that are based off Opus cards and ones that are

based off the Requiem but they only get you somewhere between four to seven points a piece bear in mind you're getting somewhere close to like you know 80 to 100 each game it sounds like lot but then everybody will get at least one of these during the game so you're not really overtaking them by many points and if you get too many of these you just can't physically do them because you can't use the same card or space to satisfy multiple Court tiles so if I get a tile here that gives me seven points but requires me to get an opus card from four different rounds out of the five then I've got four cards there you know if I get something else that requires me to get three different symbols of cards I need to get seven Opus cards in order to fill those two tiles it's a lot of effort to do it and for the points you get not really that worth it the only time I've really gained much from these is when I've grabbed one for this and one for this then it's not so bad because you can go right I need to contribute to three bits on this track that's pretty straightforward there's six points and then I need to grab two specific things from this track or like oh here we go uh yeah well no let's grab a card from four different rounds okay seven so I get 13 points for two tiles that becomes more significant but never get two from the same area it just doesn't seem worth it with the exception perhaps of the Requiem track because it's quite easy to spam that one whereas getting a lot of Opus cards not quite as straightforward but yeah I just never found these to have too much of an impact on the other hand though you want what has the biggest impact Opus and

Requiem tracks oh my word particularly the Opus cards the Requiem track gets you a decent amount of points at the end but if everybody's contributing to it then chances are it will be relatively even Steven maybe somebody will get slightly ahead but the Opus cards man focusing on them is kind of like the golden thing I'll try to do every single game because these Opus cards that you get with the different like perform effects on them firstly they get your victory points for buying them great because they get you a size of them at victory points for buying them and sometimes they're not even that expensive I mean this is one story point and one goal and they get you three points that's a cheap deal if I ever saw one but then they get ridiculous later on like getting you seven 9 11 points for buying a card yes they're expensive but by that point you should have the ability to buy them but then you can perform them to get more money and money's tight in this game so getting more money is great but then you can also sell the music off to get more income on your Finance track so your board has a finance track which every round will get you story points and victory points and a lot of money if it's high up it's not that difficult to get it high up and at which point you've got a pretty steady source of points cubes and you know money to last you for the whole game but what makes this a little broken is the fact that when you get to the top of the finance track you get two victory points every time you get more Finance income it is possible to practically break the scoring in this game by simply focusing on Opus cards getting a bunch of upgraded action cards that let you sell and perform uh cards as well as buy them and then you just

Spam the finance selling as much as possible to basically spam a ton of points I mean if you sell a piece of our um piece of musically of a free finance points increases and you're already at the top that's probably about seven to ten points for buying a card and another six points for performing it um that's pretty significant and I've seen evidence in the games I've played where somebody who focuses on that and makes it work will dominate the scoring it happens every single time someone does that Requiem focus is the only thing that comes remotely close to topping it the rest of the points in this game again much to do about nothing a few every now and again for a journey for a journey made whoopee do the bonus tiles each round there who cares about these yeah you get oh I can get a story point counter for every travel I do this round you might get one or two that's kind of it you know but then it's like you can get a victory point if you travel this round great I got a point you got a point you got two points what does it matter it's like a it's like why is this here it's just another bit of faff I don't need to deal with and it's very swingy because if somebody has Focus say on the sell and perform action and then the title comes out that focuses on that action well great for that player because it's gonna be in 10 mainly lucrative for them sucks for everybody else and that's entirely luck of the draw but then much to do about nothing also with the composers because you have two composers to pick for each game and there's four in the game so you

pick two out of the four you think oh that's good replay value it begs no difference it's like you have to go for this fact at the setup and the setup is long I mean you've got a bunch of cards to sort out you've got to put them in five different sections and stack them up you've got to swallow the tiles and then you've got to get two of these composers you got to get their tiles and then you've got to put them in order of the five different sections and in order of cost man the setup in this takes ages it's really infuriating you know the folded space have an insert for this and even that's only going to do so much for you and the setup it will help but it won't mitigate at all but it doesn't make any difference with these because they basically are split into five different types of bonuses you know you get an instant number of story cubes you get uh one cube of some type in the maintenance phase you get a point if you buy a certain type of opus card you get flat out victory points and you get to do an action twice if you do it in the fifth like segment over here that's the sequence that all the composers have the only difference is what type of Opus card it matters for so one likes religious ones and the other one likes chamber music what does it matter there's no female difference within them and these ones are pretty much exactly the same the victory points ones are exactly the same the fifth one is just which action is duplicated so in this game you'll have to Requiem and the art one in this game you'll have to travel in the Opus One for the amount of fat that you have to deal with and setting these things up who cares it's it's just lots of these little things in the game where I feel like as much as this game is relatively smooth it could have been streamlined

further if you just didn't bother with these unnecessary bonus tiles if you just kind of like I mean I'm not saying you shouldn't have two different composers I think that's fine but at least make them a bit more differentiated I mean it says in the rule book I recommend you use these two composers each time who cares it doesn't make any difference just pick any two it's not gonna affect the game that much oh well that was pointless the replay value is also questionable here because everybody kind of does the same thing in every game you're pretty much doing the Opus cards and the Requiem for points anything else you get is little bits here and there just thrown in a little bit of spring clean of points now and again nothing particularly lucrative it's this or Opus cards that's your point scoring that's what everybody is doing somebody might focus on one a lot more than the other but other than that you're all kind of doing the same thing in the game and honestly stick to spammy Opus cards it really does work out best really but the the rest of the game is just what everybody does every now and again so one game doesn't feel that different to the next oh this composer tile gives me a slightly different action I can spam would be do the cards will come out pretty much the same you know you you use the level one then the level two then the level threes but just because one particular action card comes out in a different order it doesn't really change anything in a meaningful way so so and there's only so many of these City tiles and you'll go through them all every game you'll be rinsing them repeating a bunch of them the only

thing that doesn't rinse and repeat are the court tiles and frankly they're all basically just similar variations of each other who cares so when you play this game a few times you go oh yeah this is cool and the mechanics are decent and it is a smooth elegant game you know there's positive points there but then after a few plays you think well I've played this and I've played this and I've played this and yeah where's the variety you know can I do something different in this game nope all right I'm gonna Focus entirely on the journey map well good luck you just lost okay I'm gonna Focus entirely on buying more cards while buying more cars doesn't get you any extra victory points so tough luck you lost great um uh I guess I'll just buy a bunch of Art and perform it until the day go by yeah you'll get a lot of money yeah but you also lost the game because you don't score enough points your pitch pulled into doing those two things otherwise you will flat out lose this game it's just gonna happen now now there'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return so lacrimosa is generally a good game generally there are some really good things to mention I do like the card upgrading system I think that's cool I love it in Newton I love it here you know I think the component quality is pretty spot on for the most part I mean the cards are good the towels are good these cameras are good the coins are probably the little lackluster thing and I can forgive the fact that sleeve cards don't fit in this that easily because frankly the cards are good enough quality and these boards are just lovely love these folded dual layer boards the rule book could be better though just saying it's in a weird order but it's not too difficult to understand the game

but the blemishes I have with this game do add up and some of them are pretty big issues you know you say what you like about whether you think those two methods of scoring and winning the game are the true methods I'd love to hear a bird if you know one but they're the only two I've seen do well Opus card spam or Requiem spam and generally you're going to be doing everything in this game anyway it's just a case of which one you do slightly more than the other and that's the other thing it gets a bit repetitive you know you play a few games of this and you go this is really good really good I like this I like it I like it uh same world same old and that's what's happening to me because the first few games I played of this were solid I'm thinking oh eight out of ten you know eight out of ten this is a great game enjoying it then drop in then oh it's the same it's the same and it doesn't really change up from game to game so as much as this will entertain people for the first bunch of plays it doesn't have the legs I think to stand out playing it further down the line at least not regularly you'll pull this out once every now and again know that you're gonna focus on one of two things and then you'll be glad you played it because you'll enjoy the card upgrading and all this stuff and particularly at four players the uh the tightness of the game but it doesn't work that well when you have less players and there because you you faff around doing so much setup with these tiles and with these uh like the blocking tokens and with these cards and the city tiles and for the most part it's again much to do about nothing so therefore it's a game that started

off being really great but has had diminishing returns from repeated plays and I think that's going to be the case because I've played it a bunch of times now I'm now kind of good I've had my fill of it and now later on down the line say a few months later if somebody wants to play I'll be like yeah cool we'll play it and I'll enjoy it I know I'm gonna Focus entirely on one of two strategies but at least I'll be like you know what it's a while since I played this game I'm happy enough to play it but something like Newton gave me more variety more different parts to Victory a bit more of a meaty experience this one is lighter than Newton I think because there's certainly not that many roots you can go down and it's not the most complex game in the world to understand it's just fairly tight with the resources but I don't feel like I'd want to bring this out all the time I'd rather bring out some more thematic Euros or some Euros which have more variety with setups that actually matter and make a big difference so I give it respect and I think it is generally a good game but that longevity issue the player scaling the rule book the fact that there's no theme there they do add up big so I gotta give this one a little bit of tough love because it's not good enough to just simply be good for a few plays it's Gotta Stay it stay strong I'm giving this one a very strong but they're strong not quite there yet six out of ten it's a six for me it's above average it almost gets a seal of

endorsement for me but it doesn't quite because eventually if I was to play this game more I'd just be like yeah you know what I'm done it would sit on the Shelf gather dust and get come out once every now and again but a truly good Euro should be one that I want to bring out over and over again at no point when I play this game do I feel like I want to play it straight away after that's more for like nine out of tens and 10 out of tens but even then when I had to play it say the fourth and fifth time and beyond that I was kind of like yeah you know same as before really just that tile's over there now and that card's over there you know big what so as I say it's generally good and I give it respect and I will play this if it hits the table every now and again but best of the Year 10 out of 10s I'm sorry but there's some Rose tinted glasses I think with that so that's it for me if you like what you see then please remember thumb up the video get it shared on social media and Film It On Board Game Geek as well it helps to drive the algorithm not to mention get your comments down below is this a game you're excited about do you like the idea of what I've been talking about do some things put you off is this for you a 10 out of 10 game that you're gonna play all the time if so why I'd be interested to know why there's no diminishing returns for you on that respect have you found a mystical third way to score really highly in this game because again I'd really like to know that one as well but as I say I'm interested to hear your thoughts and I hope to respond to as many comments as I can until next time you can check out more content on the show including the recent review I did for atawa the URI Rosenberg title but also I'd like to to

check out my other review for tribes of the wind I don't think this will get enough buzz and it really deserves so check out my positive thoughts on that one until next time take care and remember regardless of whose music you're playing what you're into it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved