Skip to main content
Loading video...

Living Forest Review - Kennerspiel Worthy Or Not?

Transcript 20:47

hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken people if you like what you see please thumb up the video consider subscribing to the patreon to help me out or mainly just the channel itself but of course leave a comment on the video tell me about your thoughts on this game or anything by ludonor or about the video whatever let's engage in some conversation we'll get on with the review in just a minute but first a quick word from the sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.cod.uk kinder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5 of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kiander and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get done with it and thank you in this case to keender for sending me a review copy of living forest to review so my background to this was mainly from last year essen and the recent spiel diaris awards so i played this at essen last year and i thought this is quite cool okay but i need more time with it it was not the best circumstances to play it with i mean i you know i literally no word of a lie i had a couple playing it with me they hadn't played that many games it was quite a slow game and honestly one of them was more concerned with their newborn baby than they were the game for obvious uh you know normal perfectly reasonable reasons damn you vile woman yeah it just made the game not your

atypical like format so i figured when this got announced in the spiel yaris awards i was like hmm okay maybe this is worth giving another look but there was a little bit concerned that it was in the kenner spiel category and i must admit my thoughts on the spirit of the artist awards are kind of declining as time goes on but spiel diaris is essentially the family game like gateway game award kenner spiel now just seems to be whatever the hell else that isn't for families or kids anymore because kids have got the kinderspiel one because we've had games from dune imperium to terraforming mars to this in the kenner spiel and for reasons we'll get onto later i'm not certain this is really a kenner spiel game but may i say that's just personal musings they can do their awards how they like i never get involved in politics so the living forest combines a few mechanics from some other games nothing particularly unique but it does use them in different ways firstly everybody is essentially playing a spirit defending the forest from some evil fire spirit will uh we'll say it zed in this because evil zed evil zed burning down the forest and the idea is that everybody is playing animal cards in order to gain the resources or the icons in order to perform actions which can put out fires grow protective trees or do some weird ring the ring and roses around this board we'll get on to that in a minute but the idea is is that it uses a card system very similar to a game called mystic veil which you may not have played the idea is is that it's sort of a deck building game and in this one you do add cards to your deck but what you essentially do each round is

simultaneously everybody flips the cards off their deck and each card has got icons on the left hand side that dictate you know how powerful certain actions can be but what you do is that you keep flipping these cards and totaling up all the icons and you can sort of flip as many as you like and go flip another one maybe another one but in this case i've got nothing but you know nice light creatures this is all well and good but for the purposes of uh you know actually getting the point across you know eventually you're gonna draw these what i like to call nighttime animals but effectively they're solitary animals they're powerful cards but they have a symbol at the top which means if you draw three of these in your display you effectively bust so i've just drawn one there i then draw a second one and i'm like uh do i want to draw a third one or not maybe i'll just hold back and leave it at that but then you might go now i want more free oh i'm good let's try another one ah there's my third one now i bust now the only thing that busting does in this game is means that instead of two actions around you get one it's annoying but it's not quite as crippling to say what happens in mystic veil whenever you bust but then what happens is that everybody in turn order gets to choose one of four actions in a round which can involve buying new cards so buy more animals more powerful cards to add to your display it can be putting out fires which is you know one of the victory conditions more on that in a second but it enables you to basically stop everybody collecting these dead cards which are effectively nothing but the bad symbol on them and nothing else you can plant trees which again is a victory condition but

they go on your board and grant you permanent bonuses so when you complete rows and columns or get certain trees excuse me they add icons to the various actions on top of all your cards so they can be quite useful as well and then finally there's a little ringer in a roses mechanic here where you essentially have this board and for every wind icon you have you move your character across leapfrogging other players and you get the effect of where you land but on top of that by leapfrogging another player you get to take one of their victory point markers from them which can help you to win and hinders them in some way not crippling but you kind of know it's there that's essentially the gist of a typical round and you just carry on until one of three victory conditions is met you either collect 12 fire tokens you call you plant 12 different trees or you have in your display on your board 12 of what is known as essentially the lotus flower it's another icon on the bottom of the card and if you can get 12 of them showing up in some way that's a win also so it's effectively a race there is no one more turn in the game ends or wait until everyone's got equal turns no it's at the end of the round did anyone meet one of those three conditions game end that's it it is a pure race affair now the first easy thing to get out of the way is the components and the artwork are pretty good actually these cards are decent quality cards i recommend sleeving them because you are going to be constantly flipping them off a deck and shuffling new ones in that but there's not many cards to sleeve and it is actually just really nice pleasant

artwork you know i think the artwork on these animals in particular is really really cool you've got a nice big selection of them including one spider one take that two wickets one of satan you've got you know cardboard fire tokens you've got little standees with nice artwork for your um interesting looking spirit shall we say i mean spirit either eat your heart out i think with some of these looks and you've got a couple of stands that you do to put all the different trees in there and don't worry it's not too hard to put these together and you don't need to disassemble them in the back so they are fine just maybe don't man handle them like crazy but oh no it's a decent level of production for the cost which is pretty cheap i mean kianda sell this or something like in the early 20s i think like 22 23 pound i think most retailers are kind of in that bracket as well you're talking around 25 pound max for this game that's not the thing about shipping but yeah that's pretty cheap for a full box size game and this isn't even all the components i mean there's more cards in here there's more player stuff there's more tokens i just haven't got them out but you know you've got all these different animal creatures from three different tiers so they're kind of laid out a bit like in splendor and so there's a lot of different cards to buy there's a lot of different things to do it's not bad really for something that's in the early 20 pound bracket really good value for money here from ludendorff now you telling me that's not worth 20 shekels the turns are pretty straightforward and it's not even a particularly large rulebook i mean this is a fairly thin rulebook lots of pictorial representation for what

actions do very clear i didn't find it very difficult at all to learn the game from this rule book there are one or two little minor fiddly things you need to bear in mind stuff with like the scoring the tiebreaker and one you know little marginal things but for the most part you know that the victory point tokens for example aren't as well explained as i would have liked but they're very minor niggles i mean there's a rules in video that you can scan the qr code for and honestly i think you'll pick this up pretty well by the end of your first game it's not complicated at all always a good thing the turns themselves are pretty smooth as well nothing really feels clunky you flip your cards simultaneously so that's all done it cuts a bit of the downtime round and then it's just turn order and you basically go well which two actions do i feel you've got trees fire movement or cards trees fire movement yeah so four of them and so you know pretty straightforward you just pick two of them not the same one twice just two of them and if you bust you only get one of them so terms can be pretty quick when you've got the gist of the game and you know what you're doing anybody who aps in this game probably needs to play similar games because there's not a huge amount of ap on honestly you've only got so many actions and you're not gonna do everything this is definitely one of those games where you're kind of focused on one maybe two of the victory conditions from the beginning and you completely ignore the third one but even then you probably are just gonna focus on one like i'm really gunning for fire i'm really gunning for trees and you might not have even made that decision until your first couple of

turns because you need to see what kind of head start you get it's no good saying i'm gonna gun for fire and in the first couple of rounds you barely get any water and somebody else has already put out a lot of the fires it's like uh maybe i should change my attack and go for something else the whole card flipping mechanic i enjoy mystic veil although it can be frustrating and there is a bit of luck of the drawer as well in the sense that you might have gone well i've flipped over a bunch of cards one two three and then like in three cards you've already got two of the bad symbol granted your next term will be better but it can be a little bit annoying if you just get caught out by luck of the draw you're gonna have to accept that going in this is a game where you're flipping cards off a deck and hoping for a decent turn it's push it like yes but yeah it's luck you know it's not like there's no skill involved but if that kind of thing puts you off you're not gonna get a lot of enjoyment out of this game but i do love the fact that you can buy these new cards because in mystic vail when that you card cracked it that's a whole different story here this is more like a mini deck builder you rarely get to trim cards out of the deck i mean you can kill off the dead ones with these fragment tiles that are just another thing you can collect but you can also use these to discard a card from the display that you didn't want for the round but other than that you are basically not trimming cards out your deck you're adding new ones in and at the end of the day you want to play as many cards at your deck as possible so that doesn't really make a big deal you know there are symbols in here that can counteract some of the dark symbols on here so there's one that cancels out the dark one so you can basically play out more cards they don't have as many bonuses on them but canceling out one of

those symbols can make up for it and then some so you know it's a light little affair with trimming and manipulation of your deck the turns themselves feel pretty satisfying when you pull off these little combos so you've got all your cards together and you think oh hang on a minute if i let's see i've got two actions if i buy that tree that gives me an extra icon which means when i do my second action it then bolsters that but then maybe instead of doing that i should use my movement action to move around this board here because then i'll leapfrog you i'll take your tree token thank you cause i'm gunning for trees and then i trigger the action that lets me buy cards anyway so i get to do all three of those things rather than two these aren't like rocket science things that you come up with but they're still satisfying power turns you will have occasional turns that feel a bit lackluster but the game's pretty quick i mean this game should not take longer than 60 minutes to play i've had it take longer because of four players and ap players it can happen i mean i don't think this is a gateway game by any means but it is a light game it shouldn't be that hard to figure it out but yeah if the game's taking you longer than 60 minutes something's gone wrong i think but it's not filler length either i think 60 minutes is kind of as long as the game takes really because you're yes you've got the turn order sequence and it's just how long it takes people to do their turns but you're doing the first part simultaneously and you're still racing the 12 no matter what so you are talking around 45 max 75 minutes for this game which is a pretty good length actually i mean you played this with two players and it's super lightning fast

you played this before it's a little bit longer but still doesn't really outstay its welcome it's got that length down quite nicely 40 seconds but i wanted now the interactivity in this game is so-so i mean you are kind of doing your own thing but then you have to pay attention to other players the turnover marker goes round after every round you can see what people are like putting out in their displays you've got to think well hang on a minute if i'm going after you you're also going to fire us which means you're likely to put out a bunch of these fires before my turn so maybe i should think about planting a tree instead but then there's other aspects of the moving around the circle because it's one thing to say oh wow i can do this bonus action but then you gotta think about that whole leap frogging aspect you leapfrog other players you nick their victory point markers of course that then puts them ahead of you ahead of them which means they can leapfrog you and potentially get other marcos or take those back so you're not just trying to leapfrog over people you're also trying to stay ahead of other players so that they don't do it to you and these victory point markers are just basically a fire a tree and a lotus flower so on top of what you have on your board for fire tokens and the like for victory conditions collect enough of these and you can offset some of the burden that you have to deal with do not underestimate this board now it feels a bit tacked on as a mechanism i mean you're doing most of your stuff with cards and you're putting little tiles down on here this kind of feels like a really arbitrary thing i mean i'm going to tell you something what the thematic reason is for your spirits to just be like playing merry-go-round you know around this tree it's a small thing i don't think you can make this super thematic anyway it just

it's kind of like a weird mechanism but at least gives you four actions rather than three it'll probably be a bit lacking otherwise but then there's some extra interactive dimension with the fire tokens because when you buy cards there's a side effect when you buy cards depending on how high the tier is of the card more fire tokens get put in by the evil zed here into the middle on this tree so if somebody's gunning for fire you might be less inclined to buy cards because it puts more fire in there but then i really want a powerful card so just buy one powerful card the fire token is level four it's harder to put out rather than buying a bunch of cheapies which puts a bunch of little two fire tokens in there which could mean someone could really accelerate their victory condition for fire tokens because you've just put in a bunch of little twos and they're easy to put out it's a cool little thing that you have to consider these things again not rocket science ow fire hot now the biggest con with this game is a subjective one i don't often talk about game balance with these because you need to play these games like 100 million times before you can really comment about balance but there's a common thing going around with this game that balance is potentially off the free victory conditions that you have are not necessarily equally balanced in terms of how easy they are to accomplish they got the fire tokens you got the trees and you got the lotus flowers in the games i have played to date i can safely say that the fire seems to be the easiest way to win closely followed by the forest you can win with the forest trees pretty well if you gun for it and do well with it but fire is definitely

simpler now a lot of that is because fire tokens are always going to be available because people are buying cards but also new players don't necessarily realize that by buying a lot of cheap cards they're fueling the forest with fire you can potentially shut down the momentum of a fire player why not buying a lot of cards but then new players don't tend to realize that and so the fire tends to be an easier way to do things get the water put out the fire nice and simple the trees you need to get quite a lot of tree icons in order to collect these trees but they are giving you the permanent bonuses so it's nice to have some trees anyway nobody has won with the lotus flower rule yet wrong the lotus flag has come close a couple of times if people have really gone for it but they've usually just lost out i feel that they could have won the game in those ones so i don't think it's impossible to win with the lotus flower thing but it's definitely the harder the three i cannot accept any argument that says the lotus flower is balanced with the other two or easier than the other two i do think it's just that a little bit harder because if you're gaining lotus flowers as a bonus you're not gaining the stuff that allows you to put out fires or collect trees or even buy more cars it's a dead thing it's like the provinces in dominion you know those victory point cards yes you need them to win don't do jack for you when they're in your deck though it's the same for these lotus flowers yeah you need 12 of them to win they don't do jack for you during the game though they don't give you any extra bonuses and so i've always found that it's fire greater than forest greater than lotus

now some people may have different views on this and certainly if you go into the board game geek forums there's a lot of debate on this oh yes lots of people are debating the balance of this game and as i say it's hard to say if it really spoils the game or not i personally feel that fire and forest is relatively well balanced lotus just requires a bit more effort to do it's not impossible but i don't think a new player will ever win by lotus flowers yeah you just buy the cards to give you lotus flowers but then you need the acceleration to be able to do that so a decent player i think will be able to do the lotus flower victory and i've come very close i have tried it i was on 11 at one point and then somebody got the win because of turn order otherwise i would have won it you know in that round and i think there was one actually where somebody got 12 but tied with someone else and because they spent a long time getting the lotus flowers they didn't really get a lot of other stuff done and so they lost on the tiebreaker it's doable but nowhere near as simple as the fire in the forest and that is a bit of a con i must admit because i know this going in and people will soon discover this when they come out it's just not quite as balanced as it should be we are reasonably satisfied with the events we have seen so there's a lot of good stuff for living forest actually i mean i don't think that this is quite kenner spiel award worthy it's a good solid game but can it be an award yeah that's going a little bit far and even kenyspiel in general i mean this is one step away from being family weight i

would probably have expected this to be in the spiel diaris category but even then probably a little bit too much for that so yeah kendra spiel is literally just picking up everything else that isn't a spilled iris one maybe they need a few more categories in this award but that being said it is still a pretty good solid game i mean the components for the the vast most part are really good the artwork is sublime it really does look colorful it's really nice cutesy nice pleasant little feeling the rules aren't particularly complex the game goes at a nice pace there's only a little bit of down time you know four players you get a little bit of down time and ap players could hold everything up but generally two or three players it goes at a pretty quick snappy pace i can't click my fingers to save my life but you know four people who are familiar with the game should be able to get the game going at a decent pace as well it's like i say it's a decent over decent game overall but there's just some questionable balance issues and it's probably one that i'll play the game once be done with it be fine for a little bit but then i'll want to bring it out every now and again and use it as a kind of next step game not quite gateway level but certainly a next step like game overall i'm giving live in forest a close but close cigar 8 out of 10. i was contemplating giving this only a seven but i don't think this is anywhere near a distinction level but i think there's just a lot of good stuff going for it you know it's a decent overall package especially when you consider how cheap this is so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meatball if you like what you see please consider thumbing up the video subscribe to the

channel particularly the patreon if you want to help me out get with review copies and produce more content for you mainly though leave a comment in the comment section what are your thoughts on living forest do you agree with it being a kennespie nominee would you vote for this as the kindest bill winner have you played it what are you forced do you think it looks cool do you understand how it's so cheap do you agree that zed is like an evil fire breathing spirit of destruction you know or is he actually misunderstood yeah let me know your thoughts in the comments until next time you can check out more content on the broken meatball including the recent review i did for sniper elite the new hidden movement game from rebellion unplugged but also the recent expansion review i did for star wars outer rim unfinished the business which is definitely taking the expansion world by storm until next time remember as always regardless of whether you're burning down a forest or planting trees to save it it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved