Kelp | Fierce Battle Between the Octopus and the Shark | (Board Game Overview and Review #96)
Transcript
hello everybody my name is Ilia and my name is Tyler together we make up c a couple that loves to play board games and sharks and octopie octopie we also really like two-player games we do we did a whole month two-player month content we did a month of two-player content yes today we've got another two-player game that we're really excited to chat with you really excited and it is called kelp so what is kelp well it's obviously that green seaweed stuff that's floating at the bottom of the ocean is it seaweed I don't know actually does it classify it's like a plant under water it is a plant it's not an animal but we're not here to talk about ocean plants we're here to talk about kelp the board game kelp is designed by KL Robinson and it's published by wonderbow games Who provided us with this prototype copy now in kelp what you'll do is you'll take the role of either the octopus or the shark as an octopus you'll want to slide around and maneuver through the various scalp to make sure you're not caught mhm but as a shark you'll want to catch and eat the octopus oh no yummy yummy well with that quick overview out of the way let's take a look how at how the game works as always you'll begin by setting up you'll prepare the main board in each of the rolles separately the shark will gain a bag of dice the shark deck and Grill tiles the AU octopus will
gain a deck of cards to start with cards to learn in the game and of course blocks which will start on and off the board the octopus will place a shark in one of the dens and at this point the game begins in kelp you'll either play as the octopus or the shark your goal as the octopus is to either Outlast a shark or to eat all four food blocks your goal as a shark is well to eat the octopus as the octopus on your turn you'll have two actions to take you can either play a card draw up to your your hand size or discard one card from your hand and then hide one block if possible majority of the game for the octop was displayed through the deck of cards each card played usually involves the octopus revealing blocks on the game board providing information to the shark then taking various actions moving swapping and shuffling blocks hiding blocks learning new cards which essentially strengthen the octopus deck and of course eating blocks when the octopus is near a food block and the core responding card is in your hand you can reveal both and eat blocks will not only get you one step closer to Victory but also give you various abilities you can use now as a shark your turn looks vastly different you'll have Mandatory Actions and optional ones now each turn you must draw and roll dice and move everything else is optional your dice will guide your gam playay you'll have current dice which help you navigate the map quickly moving from high currents to low you'll have search dice which help
you search the blocks if the values at least equal or higher and of course you'll have strike dice these allow you to strike a block where the octopus may be be careful though you'll want to avoid traps Now by moving through currents and searching you'll be able to contribute dice to your growth track which will help you grow and unlock abilities as you play on you'll also be able to use any of the dice you haven't used as energy which you can use to buy Shark cards which will help you add dice to the bag and give you special effects you can use now you want to be careful as every time you buy cards or strike you'll have to place a die into the hunger track if this track ever gets filled up you'll lose the game now what happens if a strike is successful on the octopus well there's a confrontation each player will choose one of the three cards to play if they match the shark has counter the defense and wins however if they do not the octopus escapes and can perform the survival strategy on on the card these cards are then discarded lowering the survival chances in a further confrontation you'll keep playing until either the shark or the octopus wins and that's the game of kelp will you survive or get eaten will you catch your food or go hungry who knows and it all depends on which character you play so what did you think of kelp I really enjoyed kelp I think even even today like when we're prepping for this video I found really hard to find negative things to say about this game everything from the
production to the design to the my experience playing it I want to play this again and again yeah I really enjoy this game an asymmetrical two-player game come on what more do you want right the thing that really keeps me going when we do these reviews is like asking what other people would not enjoy about this and we'll get into that but of course like from my personal perspective I think this game is a lot of fun it's great to play with just me and Ilia of course because it is that two-player game and we've enjoyed playing both the octopus and the shark so yeah yeah I think the last thing I'll say to even to top off the sprinkles on the High Praise is if we did this in two-player month I think it'd for sure be a contender for my top 10 list oo look at that I'd have to think about that I'm not 100% you have to ponder a bit more yeah that's fair the tiles actually do give me like um um aqualin vies and we do love aqualine oh I guess I didn't even think about that connection of like our favorite is that Under the Sea theme too exactly but let's not get too distracted too distracted and let's talk about why people might want to check kelp out well the first thing I'll say is the production quality in this game is outstanding it feels like not only is everything really well thought out of design Wise It's also really reflected in the graphic design and the user experience as well the one example I use is the octopus the way that you have the two action cards well you have spaces to play them so you always know how many actions you have if you draw cards you can take the draw token you can put it
on top of the card space and it just flows so smoothly with the reference cards with the way the kelp towels are laid out it just Mah mhm I agree the graphic design makes it pretty simple to know what you need to do uh even just like the cards the way that they're laid out the text and uh it's pretty obvious like what needs to happen the other thing that I of course love about this game is not only is a two-player game so me and can play it like just ourselves but it's asymmetrical and the cool thing about that is it's not just like asymmetrical where there's a lot of different things um there's very very similar things with each character and you're both trying to get like specific points but it's a head-to-head combat game essentially where one's trying to protect themselves and the other is trying to hunt so the way that they've design those mechanics to really like flow into the game I think is really clever and then on top of that the game progressively gets more and more evolved as you go because you're unlocking new abilities as the shark and then you're adding more cards to your pool as the octopus so there's a lot going on and on top of that too the mechanics are significantly different for each of them exact so one of them is more of a dice placement and more of explore go see what happens where the other one is more driven through cards and it's more planning and strategic almost bluffing your opponent a little bit so each of the the shark and the octopus have various traits that if you really like you can be gravitate towards one or the other mhm I did actually find myself
when we were playing like the octopus and the shark like if I was playing the octopus regardless of the outcome I wanted to then play the shark because I was interested then to see my perspective on the other side of it and I think that's a really good thing to note about the game and also a reason that you might want to check this one out I think that's a good tell of a good balanc game because you always think the other character or player is better and that's how I felt too it was just like I want to be the octopus what the heck I the shark is so hard but then it plays the octopus I'm like no I want to be the shark the octopus is so hard so I think that balance was just really well integrated into the game mhm and then on top of that too like speaking of balance like every time we play we've played the game it's been very very close and I think that speaks a lot to well the balance of the game and then also just like the way that we've been able to work off of each other while we're playing the game I really really like um how close they've been but on top of that the basic like end game is really really nice because there's ways to like um there's the octopus just like gets those four tokens but then on top of that you've got like those cards that exactly like IL confrontation yeah and you you end up coming basic well you do come to a 50/50 about whether or not I'm going to play Down the same card that Ilia plays down and then that like will determine who wins the game so it's a nice little little like way to end the game in an intense way cuz it's like this buildup cuz the odds could win cuz in the beginning you have like one in
third odds then you have one in half but in the third time you know you're like if the octopus gets caught it's game over cuz that's the only thing you can do so it's very very clever well how about things or reasons why you may not want to check this game out the one thing I will say about this game that playing either of the shark or the octopus that I think would somebody from playing this is actually there's times where I felt like I was running around in this in circles or where there was things where I couldn't really manage my board the way that I wanted to and I put myself in a very like at least from my perspective a very like big disadvantage and that felt like that gave me anxiety I guess so in that sense I was always worried about what ILO would be doing next because I felt like was going to lose that turn or felt like I would going to have to go through this confrontation during that turn so it was a little stressful on that front sounds pretty thematic it does it does it does the one thing I'll say is memory oh if you don't have the best memory like me uh this game does require aspects of it because the octopus player for example will put tiles back up potentially Shuffle things around so in your head as a shark you can be like okay the octopus could be here or here and then like there could be delineations from that and trying to find different ways of where the octopus can go so you are trying to remember stuff and pay attention as stuff goes and that goes for the octopus player as well because you're trying to remember what does the shark know does the shark
know has this been flipped before do they remember that so there's a lot of layers in terms of that yeah I agree and that actually brings me to the next point that I wanted to bring up is it is really like a chest type feeling because you're doing that head-to-head um player interaction you still do have the asymmetry but you're also playing the player mhm it's like it's like this in a lot of two-player games I would say where always playing against the person you're playing rather than um playing the game sometimes and you do end up of course playing the game but you're really adapting your strategy based on how the other person is playing the game and you're really like trying to play Mind Games essentially so if that's something that you don't look forward to in a game I might not recommend checking k out well I think it's your poker face too because I think you definitely could be as the octopus somewhere over here and if you're just like maybe then it like if you if you can't really hold a straight face of where to go cuz you're going to know where your octopus is and you could potentially Give It Away with your facial expression so if you're that type of person this game could not be that much fun for you yeah I actually even remember like grabbing going to grab some of the tokens on the board and I had a decision of like I could exchange some or like show certain ones but often I was never going to show the octopus and the unfortunate thing about that is if I was moving my hands around the board it would it was kind of a good tell that the ones that I was like putting my hands over were maybe not the octopus or maybe that's what he wants me
to think or maybe that's how I wanted to play the game who knows who knows I mean I know that was not the case but still maybe he's fibbing now to try to outsmart me and strategy in theut next time we play exactly but overall what do we think I think this game is fantastic I like two player asymmet games it's got a great theme to it it's a lot of fun to play and it I don't know it pro it hits the right spots because I can play the shark or I can play the aquus yeah this one checked all the boxes for me I can see this becoming part of a regular rotation for our two-player games I think the one thing I'll say too is I am a person who typically does not like H Symetra games because especially multiplayer because I want to know what everyone's doing why they're doing it but in this one it felt so easy and obviously there's only two characters but it felt really easy to understand what each of the characters is doing how they're played what the strategy could be so this is also potentially a really good introduction to asymmetric games cuz you can definitely scale up and see hey we can all do different things but we can still connect in one way or another over this game mhm yeah that is very good point well that's kelp Shark versus Octopus we've really enjoyed this if you think you might enjoy this or you have other thoughts on this game let us know down in the comments below I believe we have a question of the day now today's question of the day is a little bit educational o uh I realized from our earlier question is that Tyler and I don't know too much about kelp so we encourage you to lay a fun fact about
kelp or any other ocean fact cuz that would be fun I wanted to learn about kelp well hopefully somebody talks about kelp in the comments well if you know kelp or ocean facts you can comment down below let us know because that's our question of the day and if you enjoyed this video hit that Thumbs Up Button hit that subscribe button if you are new here because we make weekly board game content where we talk about games like this oh we completely forgot this game is coming to crowdfunding it sure so make sure to check out that page there's also a mini expansion you can get if you pre-order the game so we'll do that link down below you can click the link learn more learn about the mini expansion and sign up to potentially play this game in the future and then we can compare thoughts on who indeed is the best the octopus or the kelp or the kelp the real winner the real winner anyways thanks so much for watching and we will see you in the next one
bye