Tainted Grail: Kings of Ruin | Solo Review (My first Awaken Realms game!)
Transcript
Hello everyone, welcome. I'm Robert and today I want to discuss Tainted Grail Kings of Ruin. So, this is my first Awakened Realms game, who are a titan in this board gaming industry, and I'm 5 years into this hobby, and it took me this long to finally try one of their games. And disclaimer, I backed a Sundrop version of this game with my own uh fonts from their game found campaign. And I played controlling one character primarily, but I did try playing two characters. More on that later. And I played the entirety of the first chapter. Uh so now let's give you a quick overview and then we'll get into what I think about the game. This is an openw world exploration game that is very narratively uh driven. Uh you have a a book that has passages that as you explore the world, it'll instruct you to go to certain passages which unlocks other areas and uh unlocks uh advancements in the story. So everything is driven by uh this narrative book uh that you use. You're going to also uh as you traverse the world encounter fights or combat encounters and also diplomatic encounters which uh you use to gain materials and experience over the course of your exploration. And during these encounters, you use a deck, a diplomacy or a combat deck. Uh so the game comes with this ver this uh very particular card play uh system that I have not really seen in any other games. It's it's pretty unique to this game. So, it
has its own system that is card uh system that is used for diplomacy and combat uh encounters. And as you progress through the campaign, you're going to level up and improve your diplomacy or combat deck and also gain powerful abilities. And as you explore the world, uh you're going to unlock new areas and also gain trades. There's this sheet that you use to keep track of traits that you've gained. uh that affect the story in the long term. So decisions that you make early on uh will have an impact later. And now let's move on to what I liked. All right. So I think the first positive that I have to mention is the quality of the writing. Um now from my perspective, which I'll get into this later, uh the story didn't capture me per se. like I I didn't really um I wasn't really invested in what happens in the world uh per se, but I can't deny the amazingly written paragraphs and the uh you know the vocabulary. Uh so all of that is just very very expertly written. I don't personally play board games usually uh for the story. Uh but you know this game really does its best to try to everything that is written is just pleasant to read and it's just uh well written. So it's not like amateurish writing or anything. It's really really well written. Uh so if you are into uh that um you know uh this is a joy to read and I can't imagine the amount of work that was put into orchestrating
this entire project because uh the world uh you know even though it's in cardboard and this was my f by the way this was my first openw world uh board game. I know that there's games like the Seventh Continent for example and the recent Vantage. Uh so I know that it's a small category of games. Uh but uh yeah, this is my first open world board game. Uh I think that this game boasts that it's it's meant to be a open world board game. And uh yeah, I mean it really does feel like an open world game in board game form. It's crazy uh the way that the uh you know the decisions that you make u through dialogue and through tests also um how they have an outcome that will affect things later that uh outcomes and decisions that will unlock areas. How when you explore things you find items that you record uh that will have an influence or an impact later. It really beggars belief and I can't imagine the amount of work that went in in into this. But yeah, it is monumental. But yeah, that book that you open to to you know um resolve parts of the story as you explore the the game uh when you when you resolve the numbered sections. That is incredible. It really blew my mind. Another huge positive for me with this game is the fact that it works pretty well with one character.
Now, uh this also will be dependent on what character you pick. The game comes with four characters, and some of them work solo better than others, and some of them will have a uh better ability to focus on diplomatic uh encounters versus combat encounters. Uh so, depending on what character you pick, you might struggle with either one of those types of encounters. Uh but even with that uh there are a couple of mechanical adjustments that are made if you only want to control one character and it works really well with with one uh which is a a attribute that I always seek and appreciate in games in RPG games like this. If they let you control one character, that's a huge plus for me and and I'm happy to report that, you know, just controlling one character here works beautifully. And there is a wealth of content and replay-ability here because uh even if you do a play through uh with one character, uh you know, each character has its own uh traits and backstory that uh give you different outcomes when you do a playthrough. So, there are certain parts of the world that depending on what character you control, you're not going to be able to see if you don't if you're not playing as that character. And then that character has its own backstory and and like uh quests that you can do. Even putting that aside, the the charact the the character specific things uh related to the story, uh you know, there are other decisions that you can make. Uh so if if you made one decision in one playthrough, you can then do a different decision in a future playthrough uh and see what kind of outcome you get. Uh but yeah, it is um it is extremely
replayable and there's tons of content if you want to play through the campaign uh multiple times. Uh the game does give you reasons to and I also found the components and presentation to be uh pretty wellmade. Uh I like the art and the component quality and the insert works pretty well. uh assuming that you don't add a million expansions. I only have the core set with the stretch goals and that with the miniatures and that's it. Uh and uh you know for that u it worked pretty well. All right. So now I want to get into uh one mixed area and that is um the fact that the combat and diplomacy card gameplay. Uh it really didn't do anything for me and this this unfortunately this a huge issue because um uh you know we going to be doing that uh extensively throughout the uh playthrough, right? So, uh, this card this card game play of you matching icons with your either diplom diplomacy or combat deck. Uh, unfortunately, like I I just didn't care for it. Um, and also, and this was playing solo, but it's even worse when you play two-handed in my opinion, the way that you uh have to coordinate your two characters uh hands and try to line up the icons. I don't know why, but when you do that two-handed, uh, I just could not wrap my head around it. Like, uh, and I've played many complex games. It's not a complexity issue. It's like, um, spatial issue, if you will, or something. The
way that you have to coordinate between two characters so that you line up the icons properly and then leave room for more icons in the future. Doing that with two characters, uh, it made it impossible for me to enjoy playing it with two characters. And, uh, it just gave me a headache. It just gave me a headache trying to figure out how most efficiently uh you know play cards from both characters for maximum efficiency. And so it's not a complexity issue. Again, it's just more the way that that game play is structured. And even when playing one-handed, which again, the game works pretty well uh with one character in general. But uh you know, I just did not enjoy uh even putting that aside, the two hand the two-player complexity issue that I've I found myself in. Uh even putting that aside, when I play with just one character, I I really didn't care for the the game play. Uh so uh it's not necessarily a negative or a positive. like, you know, combat's there and it it can be fun at times, but uh yeah, I just did not care for it. All right, so now let's get into some possible cons. All right, so as I mentioned earlier, uh while the story is competently written, um I still uh you know, I didn't care about what happened in the game. Uh you know, the story was not a selling point for me. Like, it's well written. It uses uh cool vocabulary and all of that. and uh it it feels like a world like a rich world but as far as like um you know motivation for me to read the story like it wasn't there and to give you some uh perspective you know I've experienced um you know gloom
heaven I know that the story is not the greatest thing in the world there didn't care for it uh I've played other campaign games and no campaign game has really captured me except the one exception is Midara that's you know if if you want some reference as far as what stories appeal to Midara is the only board game uh story that I've read so far that where I'm genuinely interested in what happens there and I and I do want to read more uh after I'm done with the missions here. Uh I did not care. Uh you know, it's pleasant to read. It's cool cuz it's it's well written. I just, you know, as far as the plot, I didn't care for it. And is an issue because you're going to be reading a lot. And I think this game hinges um a bit on its world and story being compelling. But in my case, it wasn't a motivation to to keep playing. But of course, your mileage might vary with that. A lot of people adore the story here, but in my case, unfortunately, it wasn't a selling point. So, next I want to uh mention my learning experience. And in my case, um it wasn't very pleasant. I did not enjoy reading this rule book. it. And this is a trend that I uh experienced cuz I played other two Awaken Realms titles this year. Uh and this is a common issue that I've had with all of their rule books. Uh they they almost like they feel double their length. Uh and they're just clunky and weird to read. Um and yeah, this uh this felt on par with all of their other rule books. So in and from my perspective, it seems to be a um
uh a consistent issue with their rule books. Uh and yeah, this just felt like double its length to to learn. Uh so I yeah, I did not enjoy learning this game. It took a lot of work to to wrap my head around it. All right, folks. So ultimately, while I do recommend this game, and I can see why people like it, uh there's a lot to love about it. Um I think ultimately for me, uh I I I'm not sure. I think I don't see myself playing it again because uh I the story was not a motivating factor for me to keep playing it. And uh you do spend a lot of time reading these passages and while they're well written, I don't care about what happens. Uh and the card gameplay uh with combat and diplomacy did not capture me. uh I would rather uh you know play other uh campaign games that have to me much more interesting um uh combat mechanics. Uh so uh yeah, there's a lot to like here. Uh and you know, I still haven't decided 100% if I want to like let it go, but I'm pretty much uh on the verge that I think I'm I might end up trading this personally. But um I'm still glad I tried it. Uh it's really cool and uh you know it's it it did blow my mind in a few areas especially with the the passage book, the secret book, you know, like reading uh you know, seeing how many passages this game has, how rich the world is. Uh it definitely is mind-blowing, but um yeah, I think I would rather play other
campaign games personally, but um yeah, but there's a lot to love here. Again, it works really well with just one character, which I think is one of the biggest selling points for me with this uh is the the the open world aspect is really cool and the fact that it controls well with one character. And if the combat and diplomacy card um you know entice you and you enjoy it more than I do, I think it could be a hit for you. But uh yeah, for me it it wasn't unfortunately. But uh yeah, so that was my first Awaken Realms game. And uh I want to know what you think. Uh, if you have any comments, uh, questions, feedback, uh, go ahead and put them in the comment section, folks. And if you enjoy this content, make sure to like and subscribe. And I'll see you in the next one.