Arena The Contest Review with Board Game Coffee
Transcript
today we're reviewing arena the contest from drag gory games on mark Maya welcome to board Ginga Arina the contest is a to date hey there mark from the future here now before we get started with our review I thought I'd make this little edit to let you know that a lot of the grievances I had about arena the contest have been addressed in their newest Kickstarter now I haven't changed the review to reflect those changes because since those changes were made I have not had a chance to play the game in its new form so keep that in mind and enjoy the review arena the contest is a 2 to 8 player versus player combat arena game no it's actually a wonderful player cooperative dungeon crawling game with quite an extensive campaign if anything it's an arena game with schizophrenic tendencies that tend to lead towards Dungeons & Dragons I don't think so if anything it's an epic adventure that's lump set from time to time as a brainless beat him up brainless fine fine Arena the contest is a
versatile miniatures game that can either be played as a cooperative dungeon-crawling campaign or a one-off PvP combat arena battle to the death you've been also played as a one-time scenario-based mission no siree required you done there's also this capture the flight your doesn't so as you might have gathered I really contest is a game that offers a lot of variety but who is this game for is it for everybody is it for dungeon crawling campaign junkies looking to throw down from time to time or is it for fans of arena combat with a curiosity for epic fantasy adventure answer yes if you're the kind of person that wants to do all those things and arena the contest might just be the game for you although depending on your group maybe no that's it let me break it down for you first the art the art in arena is great just look at it the detail on the characters is fantastic the environment design top-notch and the game board is just yeah what happened here like for real all the 2d artwork in this game looks great until you get to this I mean sure it still functions as a play board but why would you hire extremely talented
artists to whip up all your other 2d work and then bring in the part-time intern to work on your main play board and what looks like a hurried afternoon project these broken away pieces of floor that exposed the very blurry lava artwork looks like nothing more than a rushed Photoshop mask with a simple inner glow applied to it and these 3d rendered pillars and walls look like they were pulled right out of a sea students art portfolio but as ice as a play board it functions just fine and the artwork on it as was it maybe doesn't get in the way of gameplay and that's important and if you're customizing your Maps you're just gonna use the clean side anyways and that side looks fine although the flat wall tiles leave very little to be desired so if there's still time on the Kickstarter campaign to get the 3d walls and doors I would definitely do that because this this is my favorite part of arena the three dimensionality that the walls and doors bring to the environment has a profound effect on my enjoyment of the game I really feel like I'm moving through the dungeon on a quest to my ultimate objective while at the same time fending off monsters to survive it's just not the same with the flat walls it's really
not the same no it's not want to meet up for coffee later yeah sure sounds like fun say hi to your mom for me alright well I can't very well I'll talk about art and components without and bringing up the minis just look at these things all posed and ready for adventure and looking well kind of man actually I mean they're okay but there's there really nothing to get excited about I mean that the dragons are alright but you don't play with them all that often I mean back in the day of Hero Quest these would have been amazing but this is a 1989 people we live in a world of come on miniatures and these just don't cut it anymore I'm pretty sure that grigory games wasn't too happy about how these minis turned out either since their new Kickstarter offers brand new minis produced by the same people who create the come on minis those are gonna be awesome I can appreciate a company that owns up to their mistakes and instead of making excuses they make it right and for that I took my hat off to you all right now like a lot of you before I even took the lid off arena I watched my fair share of how to play playthroughs and review videos and a common message I noticed in all those videos is how well the rule book is
written how easy it is to learn and how all I need to get started was this six page fold out well I call bull okay maybe that's a little harsh I mean there is some truth in what they're saying but there's also a lot of misleading information first off the main rule book is 39 pages long and I'm being told that all I need to get started is this awkward to hold six page brochure which I read in the wrong order my first time through and I got me wondering why not just print this out as a light six page rule book instead of this instructional centerfold
but you know what if this is gonna save time and get me in the game faster when I give it a yeah that's why not and this and that before I even selected a character I had questions how am I supposed to play on the board if I don't even know how it works nothing in here told me that lava deals four damage or that stepping into this teleports me to the other side of the board or that standing on these things means my character's blessed now I don't know about you but I'm the kind of person on likes to know as much as possible when going into a new game but in all fairness aside from those specific tiles they didn't manage to cram a lot of gameplay information into this simple to read floppy piece of laminated paper and it can't help but think that if they just added one more page or extension to this thing that all my questions would be answered well as far as the PvP portion of the game goes because if you want to play the campaign you're gonna need a lot more than this firstly and most obvious you'll need the rulebook to learn how to play the level layouts can be found in your quest guide and the story will be read from the campaign tome oh and there's these cards this quest deck which adds some multiple choice decisions fun little puzzles and some extra little story bits it does sound like a lot but for the most part
you only need to read it when you need it which is good because there's a lot to read although you will have to make room for all this reading material because you'll be jumping back and forth from book to book quite often and don't kind of feels like a bit of a chore now in regards to arena being easy to learn it is but there's just way too much to track and remember which wouldn't be nearly as bad if there was a good way to track and remember everything that's going on during your play session you're more than likely to forget to gain a benefit from one thing and apply a negative effect of something else and if you're playing a two-player PvP with a 4 versus 4 scenario prepare to question everything you know or everything you think you know and if you decide to add scrolls and artifacts into the mix oh man everything that happens in your of Nady becomes a case of does that trigger my passive Dwemer school for that what could all my characters do again did I apply the benefit of that effect but I use my artifact last turn oh I think I forgot to add our mob bonus which heroic actions did I choose shouldn't my team token be set to special ready or no special I forget damn it forgot I could use focus and there's probably more than I'm just forgetting but it's all very annoying and tends to
make the game drag on a lot longer than it has to sure eventually I might get more comfortable with it but how long does that gonna be and don't get me started on the tracking of conditions the best way that we've come up with to track if a character has a helpful or harmful condition on them is to give them the card from the character who applied the condition makes perfect sense right and for the most part it works but what if I don't have the card because I gave it to someone else who copied my ability and the best way to track that they had said ability was to give them that card which makes perfectly logical sense because I can still reference my abilities from my character board so since my single card can't be in two places at once keeping track of what's going on is getting a little bit messy not to mention abilities that can apply one of many effects to a character in those cases even if I give them the card how am I supposed to track which of those effects are applied there's no way I'm gonna remember that with the other 20 things I have to remember you know it could solve this condition tokens other games use them in this game really needs them now the majority of those concerns are specific gripes when playing a PvP match with two players each controlling multiple characters which is the way I prefer to play a team-based arena game but if we're talking a camp with four players each controlling their own character then a lot of my issues
although still present are much easier to deal with except for tracking conditions that still remains a problem now in regards to the campaign if you're looking for a big old dungeon crawl fantasy story experience and you've come to the right place but unless you've got yourself the right group for it prepare yourself for the possibility that you might be experiencing that fantasy all by yourself you see arenas campaign is a lot to take in there's a lot of story to read and set up to do before you even get started and personally I think the writing is just okay I mean the story's not bad but it could have definitely benefited from some better writing and less of it you see if you got the kind of group that likes long stories and sitting quietly while one player reads aloud and then they're still pumped to jump into a long play session that follow this very slow startup then you're all good go get arena right now but if you're the only one and you're trying to get a new group to share this experience and you might notice that the excitement that was in the room before you started is slowly seeping its way out through the cracks of inactivity
so I do believe that this is too much for a new group but with the right group it could be amazing and I know I've been going on with grievance after grievance about arena and you must be thinking to yourself Wow board game coffee must really hate this game but that's not true although there are some of us in the team that are not a huge fan of the games pace I get that personally I would have preferred a shorter story ahead of each mission something more akin to what you find in zombicide not that I'm claiming that those are amazing stories but they're short sweet and paint you a picture of what's going on without drowning human detail I prefer my gameplay experiences to tell the story rather than the story to tell me my experiences but that's enough about the story because in truth if you don't want to read it you don't have to you can just pick a mission out of the quest guide and play that no story required problem solved well if you're the kind of person has a problem with story which I for the record do not well this one maybe just a little so let's skip the story and just jump right into our fast-paced dungeon adventure well not quite but they don't call it a dungeon crawl for another arena missions are slow and earlier missions don't really have much in the
way of enemies on the board which is okay because they deal enough damage as is but I would have preferred softer enemies and more of them I am the hero after all best of the best cream-of-the-crop champion of the arena so why am i struggling with every orc that can swing an axe mission sound intriguing at first but tend to lose steam fast but then pick up again at the end when you meet the levels big Betty and those fights are always intense battles oh my god we're not gonna make it we're not gonna make we made it high-five all around that's a great feeling but it would have been a lot greater if we got there two hours earlier the quests leading up to the warlord the leader of all the minions you've been beating on for last few hours seems a little disingenuous not necessarily the things you have to do just how long it takes to get it done it feels like the time leading up to the warlord fight is just a way to soften up the heroes for the final battle like tenderizing your meat before you throw it on the grill and this idea is really driven home when in the early levels your characters are taking a sign damage from one magical source or another with little to no opportunity to respond which seems more like lazy game balancing than a genuine attempt at environmental immersion but quests themselves although long are not bad but once again if you're not playing with a group that shares in your enthusiasm
then you're gonna feel their lack of interests draining on yours like a band of fun sucking vampires okay so you've survived the quests you've beat up the big baddie now what well more reading of course but that's not all between quests when allowed players get to spend all the XP they've earned as a team to buy improvements for its members improvements come in the form of statistical level ups scrolls new abilities artifacts all kinds of cool stuff and that I love I definitely feel rewarded for my efforts which is not something I can say for all my dungeon growing experiences I loved customizing my characters to match my playstyle and testing that you build on the next mission it's a great feeling one of my favorite things about arena come to think of it I haven't talked much about the characters yet if you got in on the full Kickstarter package who you are in for a treat there are so many characters to choose from and each of them bring their own unique blend of abilities and that's very cool as well I remember reading through all their abilities and getting excited like I was actually getting connected to these characters through their powers because each character skills actually fits like they genuinely belonged to that character when I played thunderous charge I felt like a total badass barreling into action ready lay down
there hurt with my enormous beat stick said beat stick beat although not all characters are equally good for PvP in cooperative play as some characters abilities seem to be attuned well to work against other players but are far less useful in a co-op situation where all your targets are mindless monsters with pre-programmed rules for a movement before we wrap up the campaign portion of our review there's one last thing I want to mention this deck of cards is your campaign deck and it contains some of the most fun that you're gonna have between missions yes they add more story but they also contain a bunch of moral decisions that need to be made decisions that come in the form of multiple choice questions and we'll have you second-guessing what kind of person you really are maybe you're not as good as a person as you think or maybe you're more gullible than you know and depending on your decision you'll unlock achievements or alter the path of your story very cool stuff but it gets even cooler some of the cards have come across will have puzzles you'll have to solve or suffer the consequences I love this idea these puzzles made up some of my favorite moments of the campaign there's so much fun although they are a little hard to discuss with the table due to their size but worry not when you do
pull a puzzle from the campaign deck I would recommend that everyone at the table grab the phones that they've been checking while you're reading the story and take a picture of the puzzle this way everyone can contribute to the solving of the puzzle together it makes for great group into and it gets better once you think you have the solution you can scan the QR code on the back enter your answer on the page it takes you to and it'll let you know if you were right or wrong very very cool so what's my final verdict arena the contest offers a lot of gameplay and a lot of gameplay options for your money and contains some of the best 2d art you'll see in a 4d PvP is fun although it's a little annoying to track everything that's going on the campaign is great if you're looking for that big story experience but the big stories tend to slow things down and the missions tend to drag on until you reach their final act the campaign deck with its moral decisions and fun little puzzles is absolutely awesome and spending your XP to upgrade your characters your way is very rewarding and definitely one of the game's highlights and overall I do like arena despite all my grapes although I
don't know if I'll be pulling it out anytime soon do - oh the fiddly management thanks for joining us if you like this video and you want to see more subscribe to our Channel it's the best way to keep up to date with everything we do here at board game coffee but if you want to see more right now we got plenty of videos to choose from and if that's not enough follow us on Instagram Facebook and Twitter I'm mark Maia and this is board game coffee and remember have fun keep gaming be social see you next week