Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kanagawa Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 13:55

Hey everybody, today I'm taking a look at Kanagawa, which is a two to four player card game designed by Bruno Cathala. This one takes around 45 minutes to play. So the the idea of this game is that we have these watercolorists trying to make these panoramic paintings and to get as many points as we can in the process. So the board is going to look like this or the table state is going to look like this where you have all these different diploma tiles out there and these are objectives we're trying to work towards to get these victory points that are depicted on them. You're going to have a big deck of cards here and the back of these cards is going to look like such where you have a kind of an indication of what's on the other side. So we have an idea that on the other side of this card there's going to be a character. You're going to have this this board here where you're going to be drafting from and this is this kind of wooden bamboo effect style board and you're going to have your own little tableau of cards which is going to be your painting. So I've advanced the game some rounds here just to give you an idea of what we're trying to build towards here. So you can see from the cards that they are double-sided. So you've got the side here that's going to contribute towards your painting and you've got the other side which kind of goes towards your workshop which is the bottom part here which is going to be the kind of criteria that you need to reach in order to make the painting paintings in the first place. So you can see here this building part of the painting needs a one of these sea one of these sea logos and you can see on my workshop I've got one there. So in order to have painted that I would need to put one of my little paint markers on that marker to show that I've met that criteria and then I can place that painting down there. And from then on you're going to be kind of maneuvering these paint pots around by using these

arrows or of course if you get any more to your supply which you can do so and you can actually place them wherever you want. So that's going to be how that's going to work. So let's talk about the game flow and see how you're actually going to get these cards and build towards getting those victory points. So first off depending on the amount of players, so let's just say for example we play a three player game here, you're going to draw an amount of cards from from the top of the deck and place them on these corresponding spots in a row. Any of these spots with these red logos on or these red backgrounds you're going to put face down. So again you've got an idea of what's on the other side so you know it's going to be an animal but you don't know exactly what animal that is. And then starting from the first player they are either going to choose to pass or they're going to choose to take a column of cards. So if I particularly wanted maybe this symbol or maybe a tree, I could have taken this card as the first player.

Then it goes to the next player then it goes to the next player. However, whoever's remaining in play as long as there is more than one player in play and they've all passed, you're going to put another row of cards out. So currently it has this incentive building and the longer the wait you wait, the more cards you can collect. However, sometimes you know people will kind of cash out early and take a particular column because there's a very specific card they might want. So for example this player might say you know I really want this house building so I'll take this column of cards. And it's going to continue until each player has taken a column of cards. And once you've taken those cards you're going to either choose to as I said add them to your painting or add them to your workshop. So let's just say this player wanted to add this card to their workshop and this one to their painting so you would tuck them beneath like so.

And of course you would need to have that matching symbol. So I've got you can see I've got the symbol here and however if it wasn't there I could always choose to move it onto that one because again it matches the symbol and the other ones are always going to be able to be played because there's no kind of prerequisite to put them there and it's just going to build towards your your capability to paint new new paintings. And as you can see as well on a lot of these workshop cards you've got bonuses or sometimes hindrances on them. So well this one here is a wild symbol so I can use it as anything. It's actually going to cost me two points at the end of the game. This one here will give me this first player marker meaning that next next time I will be the first player. And you've got one such as giving you more paint brushes. You've got ones that can make you keep cards back from round to round. So these are all quite useful and the more you build up the more flexibility you have and the more again the more capability you have to make more paintings. So let's talk about what we're actually aiming for and how we're going to get points in the first place.

So the game is going to end as soon as a player makes 11 of these painting cards or until the deck runs out. And then you're going to of course calculate final scoring. However, something I wanted to talk about is how you actually get these diploma tiles. So these are a big factor in how you're going to get points. And as you can see you have all different kind of categories here. So this one here relates to characters you've collected on your painting. So if you have two different characters or three different characters or three of the same characters you're going to get the corresponding amount of points. And we've got here relating to trees. If you have three, four or five trees you're going to get these points here. And you're going to get these ones here depending on how many of these arrow symbols you have on your in your workshop. Buildings again different buildings and the different types of lands or different types of symbols here that you have in your workshop. You've got the how many different paint pots you have and how many different animals you have or if you have these sets of animals. And however when you acquire these um the way you acquire these diplomas is not as you'd expect at the end of the game.

These actually happen during the game. So as soon as you hit one of these criteria you can choose to take the corresponding diploma tile. So let's just say I had two characters which I do here. So I've got one character here and one character here. I can choose to take this tile and put it in front of me for end game scoring. However, as soon as I as soon as I hit that criteria I have to make that decision because as soon as I take one of these diploma tiles I can never take another one. So it really has this kind of push your luck aspect to it where do you want to cash out now while I've got the two or do I want to push further and hope I get a three. So it has that real cool again that risk factor and weighing up whether you're going to risk going for more or whether you're going to play it safe and cash out now even though maybe down the road you might get another character and have blown your opportunity to get more points. So and that's quite an interesting way to score. So let's talk about how actually end game scoring and what you're going to tie up to get your final result.

So first off to calculate your final score you're going to count every single piece of your paintings including the starting tiles. So that'll be 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 points. Then you're going to look at your longest sequence of identical seasons. So as you can see here on the cards you've got the symbol in the top right hand corner. In this case that'll be kind of autumn logo. And also these storm logos are wild. So this will be 1 2 3 4 additional points because that's my longest sequence of identical logos. You're also going to have a look at the the symbols here. So these bonus points. So some are negative points but you've got some positive points here. So I've got 1 2 3 4 5 6 take away 2 for 4. You're going to have a look at your diploma tiles here that I've collected throughout. So that's another 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 13 points. And if you have the the master token at the end of the game you're going to get an additional two points. And of course then you're going to calculate who's got the most points and whoever's got the most points is going to be the winner.

So let's talk about how I feel about Kanagawa. So let's start off with some of the cool decisions here. I suppose it all stems back to the way you're drafting your cards. And I do like this system where you have this push your luck element. Are you going to hold out even though there's a particular card you want in with the idea that you can potentially get more cards and more bang for your buck but at the same time risking other people taking it from under your nose and leaving you with stuff that you didn't want because you were a little bit greedy. So this kind of reminds me of a game like Coloretto where you know are you going to wait and hope for the hope you get the card you want. But I suppose this one doesn't have that double-edged sword. It doesn't have a negative because you always have the potential to play these cards on this this red side to add to your workshop. So there's no there's no hindrance to taking a particular card. And of course you're always trying to build towards your painting making sure you have the criteria to build these paintings with the aim of getting these diploma cards.

And I think these diploma tiles are one of my favorite ways or one of my favorite kind of mechanisms in the game. That push your luck aspect. Are you going to go go go for broke and go for the massive points here? You know are you going to get a three of the same throw some points away if you did later achieve the criteria because you can only take one particular type of tile. And I think that's quite a cool decision. I do like that part of the game and it adds a little bit more weight to your decisions and a bit more impetus on actually you you're putting you on the spot and making a decision now. So I think that's pretty cool. I also enjoy the management of the paint pots because you you do not you do not have a lot of scope to move these around unless you heavily invest in these these movement symbols. So you're putting things in the right place at the right time and keeping them there can be important and you know really influence the cards you're going to take into your paintings because you know if you have things sitting in the right spot you know you can happily take more of these paintings in but again more paint pots you acquire and the more of these movement symbols means you have the flexibility to really divert your strategy and aim towards particular diploma tiles again giving you that more that more flexibility. So I do like the way this works. It adds again a little bit more weight to your decisions and means that you have to consider what you're placing when and where. So it I do like the way that you are you know you are restricted to to these symbols and you can't just move things around whenever you want. I mentioned at the start of the video that the box does say this game takes 45

minutes to play. I would argue that that's a bit long. I could happily play play this in half an hour. I you know played this three players the other day and it took I think happily within half an hour. And particularly if if you have more more fast gamers. Turns aren't long in this game. You know just grab a grab a column and I'll do your own thing without really considering what the other people do. Grab a diploma tile if if you've reached that criteria and pretty much carry on. So they really do take quite quick turns. It isn't really a long slow slow paced game. It does feel pretty snappy and I think again I think that 45 minute mark is a little bit overstated and you can get it done faster than that. On replayability, um while you are simply just, you know, building up sets and aiming towards these things, I I do feel like there's not a tremendous amount of replayability here, even though there is, you know, a lot of different tiles to go for, um and you are, of course, reacting to what's available to you.

I do like that the um there are quite a few different ways to score. You're considering a lot of things at the same time. You're building all your um seasons together. Um you know, getting points from the um from the tiles themselves, of course the diploma tiles. So, there are quite a few things to dis- to, you know, to consider here, but I think generally um this is aimed towards more intro level game intro level gamers. And I think if you do just play with more experienced gamers who want a richer experience, then this is going to have a bit of a ceiling and it isn't going to hit the table too regularly, because I think you're going to experience everything it has to offer uh pretty quickly. The interaction in the game is pretty solid. Of course, there's competition to draft the um draft the cards before the other people do. You know, are you going to cash out early to make sure that you get the cards you want? Um or the other people might do the same for you and leave you high and dry. Um and of course, there is attention to get these diploma tiles. You know, are you going to um you know, grab a tile early um and make sure that you really force your opponent to go down a certain pathway um and maybe, you know, back themselves into a corner by not being able to achieve that criteria. So, I do like that fact that you can, again, just grab things before other people do and um really kind of put them uh off track.

So, I do like the way that works. Um and the the progression as well, it does feel like there's a mounting tension because you do want to build towards those diplomas. And as pe- if people are just keep on smashing down these paintings, it's going to trigger the end of the game, which can be less than ideal if you haven't actually achieved what you wanted to achieve. So, it does, you know, the pacing is okay. It's got a decent amount of progression. Um so, yeah, overall, um I I think Kanagawa is a a good game. I think it's pleasant. I think it flows well. Of course, it's massively um or hugely beautiful. This is actually a a a wonderful looking game which you have these watercolors, uh all these different characters and buildings. And as you put them together, they line up really well and um they make this nice nice panoramic picture. Um and uh and again, the components themselves in general are are really really quite beautiful.

But the gameplay, you know, despite being nothing wrong with it, it's not it's not anything I dislike about it. I just can't help but feel that I can't help but feel a little bit underwhelmed. It just didn't It didn't get anything singing for me. It didn't have any compelling decisions. I never felt like I was um on the edge of my seat. I wasn't really too fussed if people snapped up a certain column, you know, even I even if I wanted a particular card. Um there was never any punishment of taking a column, which I think it would have been nicer if it did have that. You know, that more, as I mentioned before, that more Coloretto feel where if you start taking cards that you didn't want, maybe you'd suffer negative points in some way. But I suppose that's not really the the energy that this game's going for. It is supposed to be a kind of a breezy, relaxing game. And I think it does achieve that quite well. So, I think if you if you want a a really beautiful looking game that almost anybody can play um and has some nice set collection methods with some little twists on some of the mechanisms and tensions on um how you're going to acquire these points, then I would recommend checking out Kanagawa. Um however, if if you know, if you're more experienced, more seasoned, then um I don't think this is going to hold up too well um after repeat play.

So, I can't really recommend it as a as a general rule. But I'm happy I played it. I thought it was enjoyable. And again, just just a fine game, but a little bit underwhelming. So, that is Kanagawa. Thank you so much for checking out this video. If you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining, then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already. Additionally, if you wish to support the show because I am a one-man operation and I don't I don't get any support from publishers, then please consider backing on Patreon at patreon.com/chairmanoftheboard, where you can back for as little as £2 per month. Thank you so much. I'll see you next time.

Progress saved