Stamp Swap: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games online to today I'm doing a discussion over stamp swamp now disclaimer this was sent to me as a review copy because I'm just that important no uh I'm obviously kidding but um yeah so this is game that had it not been sent to me as a review copy I would have completely avoided this not for any like specific reason except that it's about philanthropy philanthropy no not philanthropy filtering fatalist geez I'm an idiot God if I had nether I'd be like cut this out um but no it's about stamp collecting and that is not even close to a theme that I would ever ever jump into um but here I am and what I got to say is as I was learning this game I knew I was going to like it I'm like damn it this is going to be I know I'm going to like this game because the there's this is like the perfect um filler s game not necessarily a filler but it hits that Niche for me it's not overly complex but it's not so short that you're like I could have just been doing something else um it's in that wheelhouse of Calico and Shake That City and Tiny
towns and those spatial awareness games and the closest one that this fits honestly is fit to print I mean almost in idea alone it kind of reminds me of that here you're placing stamps in a book and then fit to print you're placing articles and stuff in a newspaper page it has very similar Concepts so if you've played any of those games you're GNA be in that same wheelhouse with this one but this one does a few things that is actually kind of unique that I enjoy uh one I mean one it's is very simple to learn but it has enough going on with endgame scoring and the spatial awareness those kinds of games just work so well for me that's why I love polyomino games because you're worried about spatial awareness and positioning and it's like if if I put this here it has to stay there is that going to come back to bite me at the end I just love that kind of that kind of gameplay but on top of that this uses a mechanism that I don't even know if the term is coined like this but it's the only term I know called I pick you choose and that's not a a mechanic that's done done in many games honestly I can think of probably like two that actually utilize it but here it does it's an integral part of the game so the game is structured in a way where you
reveal three cards and these three cards are going to dictate what types of stamps come out whether they're face up or face down that's also something unique where you don't know what the face down stamps are but you might get abilities that let you look at them and then there's a round event I like that I like one it's not a big deck but it's enough to kind of throw a wrench into things on what might happen hey you get two points every time uh someone picks up a face down card or everyone draws one less collects one less um stamp or item this round uh and there's only three events that they're going to affect you the entire game but those are really unique so then after you collect generally your six items taking turns between all players then you go to the swap phase and whenever I first heard about the swapping I was like oh no is this going to be a game that just requires multiple people no it doesn't it I mean it works well at any player count probably three is a little bit less so because it runs into that issue of well two people might swap back and forth and then the third player is okay I guess I'll just keep all my stuff which they may or may not want they I mean they pick the ones that they that they chose so they they're like yay I get to keep all these but if no one's picking their stuff they also don't don't get to pick stuff from other people so they're just kind of playing solo so I feel like even players are um
are a good player count here but whenever you take your items you get to reserve one so you get to ensure that you get to keep something that you wanted which is great and then you split up the other two or the other items into two piles and as long as a pile has something in it you can split it up in any way you want and then players take turns choosing one of those two piles they take that pile and then the person that they took from gets to keep whatever's remaining and then it goes like that till everyone has picked and kept and then you go into the placement keeping in mind for five different endgame scoring stuff that you only get to score three out of those four uh I know I said five but the fifth one is an end of round final scoring thing so there's four round objectives and you pick one of those to score and the I pick you choose system is so nice in this it's an extra layer of decision making where not only do you have to keep in mind of how you're going to take the stamps you want but also how are you going to split them to where you are both H you are happy with either one of them but realistically you want one more than the other and you just hope that other players don't take that one like the last game I just played I had like two foiled uh stamps that were like 18 points both revealed and I was playing a two-player game and the other person took the other one and I didn't even once I I I incentivized them to take the 18 points that's why I had them in that grouping
because I wanted the other two or the other three and nope they didn't want those apparently and I was like dang it uh but just that extra layer of thought process on top of after you keep everything you now have to place it and depending on the sizes of the stamps that you get which is only two um technically three if you count the small forever stamps but placing them into your area where from previous rounds the stamps have to stay there but you can move and swap out any of the other ones for that round uh it just keeps kind of adding to the extra thought process without becoming overly complicated cuz whenever I was setting up this game or even uh punching it they came with a very nice I mean it's not the most expensive or lavish looking thing but it actually came with a nice storage solution which it's like d was this Kickstarter jeez like we can only be so lucky to get a store like a a decent Siz storage solution and a retail game um but yeah so that was nice that it was all organized and then again you just do that for three rounds and then the game's over so I mean in terms of like negatives like I really don't have one for for a game like this except I mean my only negative for it would be
it's very similar to a bunch of other games hell the even objective scoring kind of feels and the ice spit you choose slightly reminds me of Isle of Sky not quite the same but it has that same feel with Isle of Sky it's you're still splitting things up you're putting them up at a price that people you may buy or may take from you and you kind of get to keep the rest um and then the endgame scoring or the scoring also kind of reminds me of that where you could see kind of in the future and plan ahead and but then here you have some Agency on which one you score you could in the first round go big on one score it but then also try and plan a little bit for later to where you will score a lot more points each round CU you can only pick one each round you can't double up you can't just get all the same color and then do that one three times so which I like but there's enough of each of those different scoring cards because there's five different colors red orange yellow and green and there's the those are the decks and you just Shuffle those and pick one and those are the ones that are going to be there for that game so for a very small footprint of a game like this you have enough variety and I wouldn't really want this to be any more complex than it already is because not only does each board come with their own exhibitor which is like a theme of a stamp that you're trying to
go for but you can get more of those because there's more in the more in the decks and there's also more for um Specialists which the Specialists are worth points on their own but they also give you special powers during each of the phases and they're really good like normally when you reserve a card or a card reserve a an item you can't reserve the foiled rare ones but one of the Specialists does allow you to do that so that's just something nice to have this one again fits in all those types of spatial awareness filler categories uh now does it do anything revolutionary I really again I wouldn't say it does but it layers a bunch of different mechanisms that I enjoy but the question becomes well I have all those other games fit to print and Calico and Cascadia and God I mean I'd have to go into my collection and look and be like oh yep I something like that something like that something like that uh so does it warrant me keeping this one as well I don't know it's it kind of would probably come down to theme like the the closest one for this that it just reminds me of the most is fit to print and it's like do I like newspaper making or do I like stamp collecting better uh
I don't know but if you don't have this problem of other games of this type I would recommend getting this like I know State like it's a stamp collecting game I mean honestly this box is a little bit too big for for what you get but it's uh it's a clean looking game it's honestly the design element is slightly elegant everything looks nice the the art that's on it is very nice for the stamps the foil tokens look really nice uh the quality of the components is really good it's I mean it's your standard stonem production and they didn't really cheap out so it's it's a solid one um so yeah like that's that's pretty much it for my thoughts on stamp swamp on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to give it an eight I think this game is great I I really I mean I can't imagine what it what it could do more but I don't really think it needs to be anything more I don't really think it needs more it doesn't need more stamps maybe the only thing that I would feel might get a little stale after playing this one a ton are the events there's not a whole lot of them and the visitors and maybe the objective so like a card pack up like just to give you more of the cards just so you have a little bit more freshness
and way more variety that would be the only thing honestly like and that would be that would be enough but that's my thoughts on stamp swamp let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time up day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you