Merlin & Arthur Expansion Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm taking a look at Merlin which is a game by very prolific euro game designer Stefan Feld and published by Queen games now this game was released in 2017 and it piqued my interest straight away now Stefan Feld generally receives extremely high praise and within the euro game community he's a firm favorite of a lot of people including myself now his Jains as I said his games are generally very very well received now this one received a bit of a more mixed reception because it appeared to have a bit more of a luck factor compared to some of his other titles the game is a rondelle stock of rondell style game where you spend your dice to move around this will in a clockwise motion and you also get another dice which uses this moves this our Merlin pawn in a clockwise or anti-clockwise direction and when it wherever you land is the action that you'll get that turn now as I said the game always didn't treat me I really like rondell games I'll really like Stefan fel games I like games that use dice so yeah it ticked all the boxes but I had that nagging feeling that this just might be a little bit too light for me it might be a little bit too luck dependence now that was until I heard the Arthur expansion came out now the Arthur expansion was supposed to completely fix all those original mistakes give you more dice mitigation to kind of manipulate your dice and get the results you want a bit more give you a bit more control and it also gave a
new rondell to the game to basically make things more interesting and add another layer of strategic depth because you've got another another pawn in the game the arthur pawn which has a completely separate rondell now this is what really piqued my attention and made me take the plunge because it was placed on Kickstarter with the original to Queenie expansions which I kind of very small expansions that Queen games tend to put out and I heard that the first one which is called something to do with the environs which is basically an area control mechanism within the game is supposed to make that aspect of the game much more interesting and much more dynamic and so I've only ever played the game with the Arthur it's and with that Queenie expansion so my review of the game is going to be solely on that experience and not the base game alone so take that into consideration when watching this so yeah the the game is very very simple mechanically you're going to get your five dice so you can get a three dice if your color which move your knight you're gonna hit one Merlin dice which moves clockwise or anticlockwise and that other players have control of two and you're also going to get an arthur pawn as well or a dice to go with it that moves him on a separate run down again clockwise or anti-clockwise and again other players can move Arthur to so you've got to be careful when you want to use him or when you don't want to use them because other players can really mess up your plans the game is very much of a Stefan felt nature in respects of being a point sylars you get points but almost everything in this
game and it's a pretty it's a weird way the game scores as well because it's not our very swing game it's a very kind of it's a slow burner so it's almost like trickles as it goes along because everything kind of gets you one two three you know if you're lucky four or five points so it's a very you know it's a neck-and-neck game where you're edging it against each other throughout the whole game but if someone does play more efficiently than the others they will eventually pull away and win the game I have to say I really like the way the game works just the way that everything synergizes together is really interesting you've got these kind of five different main principalities on this huge round board that's really beautiful to look at and if you land on one of these principalities you can do one of four things I believe and they are either take a shield bearer of that principalities color which helps you fight off these Knights that attack you're on board those Knights or any of those Knights aren't offended by the end of the two rounds scores you minus three points now Stefan Feld kind of tends to use this kind of mechanism in a lot of this game where you've got this nagging tension to try and fight off something you know throughout the game such as trading with the UM you know with the needs of the people or you've got not you're done with like the rats and stuff disasters so yeah he's really kind of known for this and this game does use that really well you've also got these kind of construction material which is these little wooden blocks and let you kind of build your strongholds on this separate board which is uses
this very simple area control mechanism so you've got these three different types of terrain you've got trees you've got mountains you've got rivers and whoever's controlling the majority of strongholds at each of those zones get points equal to the amount of hexes in that zone so again you're going to be getting four you know three four or five points depending on the control on those regions now what the environs Queeny does is that whenever you build in one of those regions first you get a bonus and those bonuses can be lots of different things such as a shield of any color to fight off those different in a fight of those different kind of invaders you've got different you can apples which let you choose any face of the dice you want when when using a dice so lots of mitigation there you've got Merlin staffs which let you they let you use a double active so if you lied on a certain space with Merlin you could do that action twice again you get a shield of any color you get a construction of any color you get points so there's lots of things to consider when placing your um replacing your stronghold down on this area control board so I really like that and you've also got influence so influence is important because it it kind of puts a what are your little tokens on one of these principalities and that kind of makes things a bit more efficient for you because certain spots let you use abilities depending on where you had influence but it also matters for a very simple area control mechanism again where you score a few points depending on who's got the most influence in each Principality and finally you can take you can place your
flag bearer which gives you a flag of that certain type of principality and they again have very different ways to mitigate your dice rolls such as going anti-clockwise around the board with your dice you can activate any dice with a certain color you can activate the spot where someone else is using or stuff like that so there's lots of different things you can play with and the Arthur expansion really did improve this part of the game because the original base game came with some flags that were pretty uninteresting such as completing two mission cards at a time which I'll explain in a second or but the new ones yeah the new ones are much more impactful giving much more control and just do improve the game dramatically so yeah I really like that so yeah you gotta be scoring points through a lot of different ways as I said controlling those different regions the area control of the of the different influence regions you've got the fighting off the invaders you know you don't be scoring your negative points that way you get points such as like if you land on a certain spot you'll get a point for each flag you're currently controlling or a point for each influence you have on the board and stuff like that so there's lots of different ways to score points there's also mission cards or objective cards that I can't remember that cool story and those cards give you either one two or three points depending on if you've met the criteria of those cards so for example one might say I have a green shield have a black flag and have an influence on gray and if you have that you can cash in your card that's one card per turn and get the
amount of points in return and then you replenish back up to to your full hand or four cards so these are give you a little something to go for you know you want to try and reach to get those different and things onto your player board another thing as well is that sometimes you can just get pure lucky and draw cards and that you happen to have already fulfilled already because you do not need to cash in those resources when to complete your cards so I said if I needed that shield on that flag and that influence I just need to have it I don't need to spend it which is a really cool incentive to keep hold of stuff so you've got that other decision whether am I going to try and keep this stuff on my board just to complete my mission cards or am I actually going to utilize them to as I said to mitigate my dice rolls etc so yeah the game flows really nicely and and the rules overhead is pretty simple because you are very much limited limited to the to the dice rolls you have so say ah roll a 3 or 2 and a 1 I can either go one space I click that then 2 spaces and I take that or three spaces they're not to make that or I can do any variation that so there are different kind of vary abilities you can have but obviously with the more mitigation you have the variability just expand and expand and expand and the more mitigation you have already do open up your choices so so much and you can actually eventually have a lot of control over your decisions and I think a lot of that is attributed to the to the Arthur expansion the mitigation really is ramped up you get a lot more choice and a lot more kind of free rein to do what you need to do to get as many points as possible so I
really do like this is a to me it's an absolutely in this unnecessary expansion it's completely mandatory to have that to enjoy the full potential of this game I love the way that different rondelle's interact with each other because once might say muth Arthur three times and you land on the white spot which lets you move Merlin three times then you move Merlin and that one might let you move your pawn to the next principality so there's Bru a good synergy and tinkering with each door you're different pollens to try and get the most out of your time and the most out of each dice you roll up so I really do like that I love planning things with dice that's one of my favorite mechanisms in games . i love dice games a lot of my favorite titles involve dice in one way or another i think all the different routes do getting points you can get in this game a very well balanced as I said the game really does film neck and neck throughout the whole game and yeah that like there's really not much potential for runaway leaders and stuff like that so I do like that aspect of the game the decisions are really good you know especially with am on mitigation you get as I said you can really be racking your brains about how to plan your time most efficiently to get all those shields you need to try to fulfill the objective cards you need and yeah so lots to think about there the something that the expansion does involve is as I said it does involve a new dice or completely which does quite considerably extend the length of the game now the game is I'd say you know basically I will predict about an hours of play and maybe with the expansion it
takes up to about an hour and a half because I said it does add another dimension to the game as another turn to each players round so yeah naturally it's going to increase that that that time of play but something I would or would also mention and this person he doesn't bother me at all I like the way the game feels but there's not a lot of engine building in this game there's not a lot of feeling of progression it almost like you're always chugging along at the same space and you're not doing much different on the last turn as compared to what you're doing on the first turn of the game now that being said there are different modules you can plug into the game to add a bit of engine building into the game I think it's called the Kings favor so instead of cashing in a objective card for the points you can cash them in to activate a certain spot on this unique board that you can choose to include or not to include which gives you a permanent ability throughout the rest of the game or that or if you're cashing in those more powerful cards it gives you abilities that you can use for a limited time throughout the game so yeah another kind of dimension or another layer you can add into the game there the uptime of the game is really good as well and because then you can really plan your turns quite well at least on your own dice and things you can't sometimes plan for is the arthur dice and the merlin dice and i said you've got to be really worried about when you can't use them because people can really sculpt your plans by moving him before you needed to use him and completely throw your plans completely off rails so that's something you need
to be prepared to this game your plans could be absolutely you know thrown under the bridge because you because someone else has got in there before you so take that into consideration we play with playability the game is really good at this as I said because there's so much to choose to include who's not to include there's another queenie that lets you kind of do other things I have not look too much into it but it's not as good as the environs one you've got this I said that module what lets you engine build you've got another new expansion coming out called the knights of the round table which I'll review separately because again it's not completely necessary to the core mechanics of the game so yeah lots to play around with here and it does have that kind of addictive feel to it and it doesn't Oh at the same time for a euro game for a Stefan failed game it has it's always leisurely filled to it it's very enjoyable to play because I said you asked some what at the mercy of those dice and you know just getting the most out of each turn it's almost like an enjoyable little puzzle and yeah that's that's addictive to me at least interaction of the game is really good actually I do like the way that interaction and there is some kind of meaningful interactions well because there is that area control which in itself is naturally very interactive there's a jostle just thing for position to control those regions and again some of those are quite lucrative in points you've got the interaction of moving the Arthur and Merlin dice to not only help
be a bit because that could potentially hurt other players as well yeah and stuff like that there's also some with the environs Queeny expansion there is some interactions whether it's almost take that ish where if you land on the same spot they have to get rid of a shield or something like that so yes some very very minor take that involved with that Queeny expansion the way the game looks is absolutely stunning it in my opinion I love the way the board looks like huge rondelle with the round table you've got the different castles around the outside the symbology is really nice and clear to understand nice bright vibrant colors the components will have a really high standard and that the player boards themselves are absolutely fantastic they're like this castle where you can store everything you need on them the invaders slot into the board absolutely beautifully and they look like they're invading your castle walls the way the shield's fit on the board to fight off those invaders it's just such a an ergonomic and such tactile way that the everything fits together in your player board I really cannot fault the way the game looks and the way or just a visual appeal of it I think is absolutely beautiful and the theme as well a theme is again it is kind of pasted on but for a Stephane failed game it just works you know the roundtable being the rondelle it's just everything just feels like the skin just wraps around the mechanics really well and just the the visual aesthetic of it just I just I just really like it Arthurian legends and
medieval stuff is like my favorite genre of games or my favorite a theme of games and this one is right up there I just love the way it looks and feels setup time is a bit niggly you have to put a lot of different things onto the board in preparation a lot of flags lot of shields although all the cues for the construction material you've got to set up the area control board which is all modular so yeah you've got a lot of quite a bit of setup but it's not too problematic if you get a couple of people doing it it's pretty quick so yeah that's it's significant but not you know not overwhelming and not too much for the game itself the overall this game is excellent I love this game it is everything I wanted it to be without that Arthur expansion I'm not sure how keen I would be on it I'm sure I'd still have a positive review but not as significantly strong as I review it now it just is the perfect expansion it's everything you need just to take it just in to that next kind of layer of depth that extra decision to make each turn the rondelle was just better more decisions to make more mitigation and can more control and it just makes everything come together nicely the puzzle of planning things out is so enjoyable the or just trying to be as efficient as possible trying to get as much in your turn done as possible it's just so much fun for a failed game it's very different it's a bit lighter
in terms of its decisions than some of the other titles but at the same time there's still a lot to think about and a lot to consider so yeah I think this game is amazing I really do enjoy it and I could see this going right at the top of my um my personal rankings I actually like this more than the castles of Burgundy which is one of Stefan fells most prolific titles and probably his most popular title but yeah I like Merlin more than like castles burned Oh candy which I'm sure is that sacrilege to some people but that's the way I feel about it that being said as I said you need that Arthur expansion you need the be environs Queenie that is so necessary for me it adds so much more interest to that part of the game something I will say that part of the game does feel a little bit tacked on but it's still an enjoyable part of the game too but yeah that's my review of Merlin a solid or more than solid it's an amazing game so much fun yeah absolutely recommend this one completely I said with that expansion with the Queenie's that concludes my review of melon I hope you liked the review if you have please subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and also keep your eyes peeled for my review of the notes of the round table expansion which adds unique player powers to the Merlin board game so yeah that concludes the review I'll see everybody next time on chairman of the board bye