Emberleaf: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm doing a discussion over Ember Leaf, which was a game that was highly anticipating because it proclaims itself as like a card dancing style game. Um, let me see if I can find. Yeah. Uh, card dancing. Place hero cards within your movement to grid to activate skills and enhance your fellowship. Slide cards to trigger powerful combinations and charge them at the perfect moment for even greater effects. Uh, clearly this is a coin term that I had not heard in any other game. Uh, which was the sole reason why I backed it because I was like, card dancing, let's see what that's about. Um, and at the end of the day, this game just could not be any more mediocre. I really found this game just overly long and boring almost immediately. Um, and as I've been playing it, I'm like, what is missing from this game? because like systemwise, mechanics-wise, it's sound. The I mean, how you play the game is is overall just clean and learning the game is also very straightforward.
Like I've played much worse games and just in 2025 I've reviewed much worse games, but I've I've always adhered to the the the fact that like an inherently bad game is going to be more fun because you can make fun of it the entire time. And what's worse than that is a painfully boring game because you get nothing out of it. You get no humor, no no cynicism from it. It's just when does this end? And if this game was 30 to 60 minutes, I would forgive a lot of it. However, it is. And it even states on the box, so it's not like, oh, it's a, you know, it's it's a whatever. It's a group issue. It states 90 to 120 minutes and there is just not enough game here to even come close to justifying that as a runtime. Um, so everything that you do in the game and how you progress it is just so tedious. You just run through the same thing over and over and over trying to get the game to end because they do a thing where the game there's no rounds. And this game would definitely benefit from having a certain number of rounds. Uh it's based off the the number of trophies. So there's six trophies in the game and you get them by basically filling out clearings, which is where you're just building the same type of building over and over uh to get
minuscule points or defeating banners by attacking basic ass banners that are I'm pretty sure from his other game uh City of Kings. Uh which is a nice little nod. um just different colored banners that do nothing. They the banners serve nothing and they go down the shared track uh the shared war track and once it reaches the bottom uh you get a trophy. That's to my knowledge the only way I have found to actually end the game. So, if people aren't building um and everyone's just fighting, like, yeah, the game's eventually going to end, but both of those uh uh ways of getting a trophy takes forever. Um, so, and it even says in the rule book, oh, getting the first trophy is about halfway through the game, and getting the second trophy is 70% through the game. So, an hour and a half in is when the second of four trophies come out.
And then yes, by that time each clearing is one building away. People are able to kill banners left and right. So then yeah, the trophies go in rapid succession and then the game ends. Um, and throughout the entire game is how you're gaining points. And basically at the end of the game are these are these uh scorecards that I also feel are kind of from Isisle of Cats. Uh, and then you just see whoever has the most points and that ends the game. So it's it's insanely long. the banners the only like they're called dangerous areas. Um I guess I have the deluxe version so I say they're banners. They're literally only there for the the uh favor cards um to get you victory points. Um so like so that's just boring by itself.
You look at them and you're like ah victory points. Okay. Like and I guess they're kind of in the way. It costs two movement to go past them, which I can just inherently get. I like I I was just trying my hardest to get every game I've played of this to end. I just I have been searching for ways to be like, what am I missing about this game? Uh because simplicity and and you know, production and quality or art quality, it just isn't enough. like, hey, I mean, this is the art is gorgeous. The fact that every card it has a different name and a different uh animal on it that it just looks amazing, but the cards aren't unique enough to justify having a lot of them. Um, the unique like, oh, hey, it's a different art and a different name.
Yeah, you put it you just put up a name generator and then, you know, get art on it and you just kind of cycle through the same abilities. It's like, "Yay, every card's unique." Well, yeah, technically, but they're they're still cards with the same abilities on them, and even if they share the same two abilities, yeah, the little icons up at the top, the skills they have might be different. So, cuz it's not a deck builder, you're kind of crafting your hand. So, you have a hand of creatures that you eventually because you run out of ways to recruit more. So you just kind of rinse repeat the exact same thing every single time. And if we're talking about the card dancing, it's not done enough. Like it's not interesting because again, you're not running through different strategies and different play styles. It's like, oh, okay, I have my six out. I'll slide them over. That one lets me move. That gets me a wood. That gets me a food. All right, that one fell off. Now I can build. All right, I built your turn. And then next turn, it's like I'm gonna play this card that lets me move. Okay, I'm gonna just take go over here to to here.
That's my turn. Your turn. Oh, back to me. I'm going to slide. Okay, that gets me a food. That gets me a wood. I'm going to build. That's this game for an hour and a half to two hours. It is insanity of how little this game actually provides in any thought-provoking sense. So, the card dancing, which was the sole reason that I got the game, is an extreme letdown. Uh, whenever people are talking about I don't know what people are on when they're talking about this game because it's like it's like, "Oh, man. The the the high strategy synergy of the cards you play with the card dancing is so innovative and and never done before." Yeah, maybe. Maybe there's a reason it's never done before because it's boring as hell. Um, like half the time you're not doing anything because you don't It's like I don't want to move, so I'm not going to.
I need to finish out this clearing, so I'm just going to stay here and just gather resources so I can build one of the same five buildings. And even that gets restrictive if you happen to go for and I know this is player choice but if you happen to go for like a favor card that gives you a lot of points they are some of them are just exact. It's like have exactly one townhouse and five houses. Okay. So once you meet that then you're like okay well out of the five buildings I could you know build I'm down two of them because I want the 14 points. So, I'm done building town houses and I'm done building um houses. And then some of them are like have exact home exactly three rabbits. So, once you do that, it's like, okay, well, never touching my rabbits again. So, and I understand that like that's what you as a player chose to do.
But so many of them are like that that you can pigeon hole yourself into a way that's like, well, okay, I'm getting a lot of points at the end of the game, so I'll just omit half of my people. And yeah, they have a nice element of four different types of not really workers, but creatures you can home that kind of have similar abilities, but they're all relatively the same. Hey, this one gets you wood, gives you points for every wood you have. Uh, this one gets you sword, so you can attack. This one uh gets you, I guess, kind of a sampler. And this one gets you food, and they're all the same. So, where they're housed doesn't really matter. I mean, it does again for the favor cards. Oh, have a rat in every and in in at least four clearings. Like, that's it there. It's just nothing. It's a nothing burger of a game. And again, if the hero cards that you could recruit to of course make your um your card dancing thing more interesting. Yeah. I mean, some of them are good. Some of them are neat. Like one of them that I had this last game I played was, "Oh, when you play him, you get to activate another ability of another hero in your clearing." Oh, that's neat. Like that that gives me some some semblance of of strategy. Um, but other than that, they're all pretty much like the same. Oh, yeah. Okay.
Whenever it falls off, you get to attack. Or whenever this falls off, everyone gets to attack. Yay. Like that's okay. Well, we can already kind of just do that naturally. It doesn't really invoke any type of excitement uh just from playing these these unique cards. And that's the thing is like there's there's so many heroes and so many favor cards that you would think, oh, that's going to add variety every single time you play. and and it will in terms of that you're going to see something different, but the problem is is you're going to use just the same type of hero cards to do the exact same thing. Fight banners or dangerous areas and build the same five buildings.
You're just going to do that in a slightly different order. So, it's there's just not enough game here. And like I said earlier, if this was at most an hour, I would forgive a lot of it. Now, there are um like expansion packs that this game kind of has. It has uh different trophies, which is kind of nice like that because there's only the same the base game has the same six trophies. There's some extra hero cards that add complexity to the game. Uh but yeah, like I guess if you're someone who just I don't know, wants to play a long game with uh you know, with just monotony to it, then yeah, like this might be the game for you. It looks really good. The art is is very nice, but again, the art doesn't really serve a whole lot of purpose here. It's just Oh, this is uh look at look at Squeak. He's a little little um little drummer boy. That's cute. For some reason, he lets me walk one per one per foot. And when I gather at least five uh five food, I get to build one. Neat.
Oh, look. It's Zara. Zara is a um a flying rat, flying squirrel. I think a blind warrior, blind samurai. Attack one per sword. You may spend a honey to gain three attack. And when he slides, you get to walk one per foot. So, because on your turn, it's not like you can slide and get into position to do something like I'm going to do that and I'm going to get to attack. Yeah, if you might have some cards that let you attack when you slide. And yes, based on how you place them, you have to put the one that lets you move to uh, you know, first, so it slides first, so then you can move and be in a position to attack. But you're attacking the same stuff. it's just a slightly different number and collecting different different colored banners. Uh, and the other thing that's very annoying about the attacking banners part is that track, this track here is shared between all players. So, if you're the one running around and attacking five times, all all another person has to do is attack once and they get the trophy. Like, yeah, you might have gotten all the resources, but a trophy gets you points and resources.
So, and it it's one way for the game to end. And in all honesty, the trophies that the base game comes with, there's one that's superior to the rest. Well, there's two. One's just eight points. Another one lets you home any one of your uh villagers, one one of your people. So, just anywhere on the map. And that goes a long way towards Oh my god, they're attacking me. um uh that goes a long way towards some of the the favors where it's like home a certain number of of creatures or have a certain number of houses like so that's clearly one of the best ones. The other thing that's kind of annoying about this is along the way on the village track uh there are these bonuses that only apply to the first person who gets there. So, if one person's just running away with the game, then they're they get all the bonuses and everyone else is just kind of like, "All right, neat." Again, to be fair, a lot of them are, you know, everyone gets to do it. So, like the very first one is refresh the favorite track and everyone gets to pick one. Um, but not all of them, which is kind of again, it just adds insult to injury.
And I mean, you you do score a lot of points in the game, but by the time you're done playing, you just kind of want to rush through the ending, and it's like, "All right, that was that." Yeah, I'm And I'm That's the thing is I'm not even mad with this game. I'm tired. I'm tired after having played it. I'm just like, "Okay, let me just let me let me just be done with it." Uh, that was a big box. That was heavier than I thought it would be. of stuff and then there's just no insert for it either. It's an empty white box. So now I have to store it in some way. It's it now now I'm just nitpicking, but it's like come like come on. Like you couldn't with the deluxified edition.
You couldn't come up with a a way to store it all. A nice insert it. It's just bags of All right, cool. So yeah, like I I don't know. I don't know. This one it almost feels like that the reviews that I see on BGD are bots. Like like how you can sell something online and then you just like have bots spam it so it it is constantly in your feed. That's almost what this game feels like. It's like, hey, I'm going to have a bunch of bots spam this uh the rankings on this game so it's high. It's like I don't get it. Out of a lot of games that come out every year that I see the score for, this is the one that I'm like, not even close. This is it. Just I don't I don't see it. So, unless I am, you know, aggressively playing this wrong. What are you doing? That's a little moth. Hey, little moth. See, I'm more interested by this moth landing in front of me than I am the two hours of playing this game. Um, so and I even lost my train of thought. Um, thank you Moth for uh for for having me, you know, thank you for letting me forget about this experience. Uh, yeah.
So, unless I'm aggressively playing this game wrong, which I would be extremely shocked if I was, I I would almost rather play literally anything else. And now there's worse games I've played this year for sure, but at least I was able to get some type of feeling out of that. Either rage or just, you know, hilarity. But yeah, in terms of positives, um, the art is amazing on the cards. The art on the board is so generic. The buildings are are incredibly painfully generic. Uh, production quality, all the wooden pieces are very nice. The card stock is nice. The player mats are nice.
I think there I think the the card dancing could have been done way better, but because you're so limited on the cards that you get, uh it's it's rinse repeat. You do the same thing over and over, so none of it's very interesting. All right. Well, that's my rant. Um, on the scale of 1 to 10. Um, I'm going to give this the most basic of scores, it's a five. It's It's average. Like, I mean, I don't think it's bad enough to warrant anything lower. Definitely. It's not above average by any means. Um, yeah. like because I I mean like I said, there's worse games I've given worse scores to, but I just I'll never touch this one again.
Anyway, that's it. That's my thoughts on Emberleaf. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.