The Hungry Gamer's Gest of Robin Hood Mini Review
Transcript
Oo, that looks tasty. Welcome folks. Day the Hungry Gamer is back with another mini review. And today we're talking about a guest of Robin Hood or perhaps suggest Robin Hood. I'm not sure what it is, but this is from GMT Games. And for this one, I'm not going to go into a full rules overview because as a coin game, a counterinsurgency game, there's a lot of little things going on. And so rather than that, I'm going to actually highly recommend that you check out the watch it played Rodney Smith tutorial of the game because that is thorough and you will get everything that you need there. So, with that said, this is a two-player only game in which one player is taking on the role of Robin Hood and the Merry Men and the other player is taking on the role of the Sheriff of Nottingham. And you are both trying to tip the scales of balance to either to justice or order.
And the way it's going to work is each round each player will get to pick one of three things. They can either play the event. Every round there'll be an event card that flips up and it does something different depending on if Robin Hood or the sheriff activates it. You can do a single plot which is just take one action or you can do plots and deeds where you can kind of do as many things as you want and you get access to your deeds actions. Plots and deeds are going to be doing is they're going to be removing the other players pawns from the board be the merry men or the deputies. They're going to be moving troops around the board. They will be potentially attacking carriages or moving carriages though that's not true. The carriages don't tend to move by doing that, but you get the idea. Moving things around, getting more troops in different regions and either suppressing the revolts that are going on in the different shires around England or making them revolt.
And every so often through the game, you're going to come to a judgment phase where kind of the board resets a little bit and points are given. And by points, I mean again this kind of balance towards justice or order. And these points are given and we kind of move our way towards the endgame. Then at the end of the game, King Richard will return. That's the bottom of the event deck. And you'll do the same thing. And whoever has more reputation, i.e. closer to justice or closer to order, will determine who's going to win the game. Now, that is a very high level overview of what's going on. Let me just say that this is a complicated game. Nothing about it is actually hard, but there are just a lot of rules for each different action that you're able to take, which makes it quite complicated. So, with that said, what do I like about this game? I like the asymmetricness of the game, obviously, and my understanding is that is a feature of coin games in general, but I like the way it works. I like that it feels thematic. I love that Robin Hood's running around in the forest. I love that the sheriff can capture the Marion Man, capture Robin Hood, and you're slowly trying to get them out as you can. You're attacking carriages. Meanwhile, the carriages are being moved from the outskirts into Nottingham. And if it gets there, the sheriff's going to get a bonus for doing so. I like that the sheriff can set traps for Robin Hood. I like that you're finding camps. I like that Robin Hood can turn the populace against the sheriff, or maybe the sheriff has the populace suppressed, but then they go and they take all these taxes and now they're revoling again. And it's just so very thematic of this kind of highlevel overview of Robin Hood and the Sheriff
of Nottingham. And I say high level because you're never really playing as Robin Hood or the sheriff. You do have a Robin Hood pawn that you're going to move around and he's more powerful, but you're never really just playing as Robin Hood. And you're looking at all of England as you're trying to again get towards justice or keep order in England. And it's just very very clear the way that works. But what I really like is every turn is a hard choice. Every single turn. because you're choosing, do I want to maybe take the worst action where I can just do one thing, but that's going to give me first choice of action next turn, or do I want to do all these other actions I can do, but that's going to give me last choice of action going to into the following round. And as you're going through, it's a very tight resource game. There's a lot of resource management in here, even though the only real resource is shillings, but most things you're doing are going to cost you shillings. And so you really have to keep an eye on what am I doing? How am I making shillings?
Do I have enough shillings? And then as your Robin Hoods are moving around, you really have to take time to figure out, okay, I'm going to need some money, but I'm going have to rob somebody. So I have to make sure that I have enough people so I can successfully rob this next traveler that I'm going to try to attack. At the same time, you have things you can do that change this traveler deck. And I love all the travelers. It just it's very cool the different travelers. But the sheriff can slide Gia Gizbborne in there which is really hard to take while the well the merry men can get a bishop in there which is easier to take and gets more money. And it's just very clever the way that that deck is always changing. I also love the events because one of the things you can do is you can just activate the event. Every single event has something that Robin Hood does and something that the sheriff does and they are different and they are always good.
It is always tempting to take that action and I just love love love the way that works. I also like the clean look of the game. It's just very clean looking, but when you get into the cards, I love the art on them. I just think it looks fantastic. Everything else is just little pawns and they have, you know, symbols on the sides and they're clean, simple, easy. So, what are my quibbles with the game? And I actually don't have many. The first thing I'll say is either you're into this counterinsurgency style game or you are not because it's all about figuring out what the other player is going to do and countering it. Figuring out where you think they are and exploiting it. That is the game. Period. The next thing I want to say about it is every choice, as I mentioned, is hard. There's never a time where you're like, well, I'm just going to do this. No, it's I'm just going to do this because I need this thing and I need this thing to do this thing. So there's never a time where you don't have to be thinking multiple moves ahead or thinking about what the implications are every single thing that you do. And brainwise that can become a brain burn because as I said before there's a lot of things you can do in this game but none of it is particularly complicated. So that just might be a bit too much for some people. The next thing I'll say and the second to last thing I'm going to say is it's a two-player game only and that makes for a very limited audience. It is very hard for me to get this game played because Mrs.
Hungry Gamer not gonna play this. Not for her. And so I actually have a very hard time getting this to the table, which is why I've actually had this game and I've been working on reviewing this game for a year. I've had it for a very long time. And it's just been that hard for me to get to the table. It helps that you can play this on BGA and it's a very good implementation on BGA, but for me it's been hard to get to the table and I can imagine for some other players it might be hard as well. And the last thing I want to say is something that I have heard said many a time and I've heard said many a time that it's an easier game for the sheriff. And I haven't found that personally, but I've heard it said quite a bit though. I've also heard it said quite a bit that it's easier game for the merry men, which makes me think it's easier for nobody. But something to consider, the factions aren't perfectly balanced.
They're better at some things, worse at others. And for some people, it clearly feels like one faction is easier than the other. But there you have it, folks. That is Guest of Robin Hood or Jest of Robin Hood. I'm not sure how it's supposed to be pronounced. And I think it's great. I really think it's great. It is so hard for me to get this tabled, but I think it's wonderful. This is one of my top games that I almost never play. This I play this usually a game that is this hard for me to table. I don't keep it even though I like it. I don't keep it because I just know I'm not going to play it. But I'm not willing to let this one go because I think it is that clever. It is that much fun and I really really really think it's a top top tier of two-player head-to-head games. If I was making a list of my top five head-to-head two-player games, it would absolutely be in there. But there you have it, folks.
That is Guest of Robin Hood. As always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, and maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.