Skip to main content
Loading video...

Terracotta Army - Overworked Clay - Board Game Review

Transcript 25:14

hey folks i'm luke hector from the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember you can thumb up the video you can subscribe to the channel or the patreon but most of all get your comments down below about this game or any of the others from this publisher's range we'll get on in just a second but first a quick word from the sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiandro.co.uk kinder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5 of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kiander and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get done with it so today we're taking a look at one of board and dice's two new releases that are kind of the hit list for sn and gengon this one being terracotta army and thanks to board and dice for supplying me with a review copy as well so this is not a game in their usual t series of games i mean yes it is called terracotta army but it's not like you know taken you or teotihuacan or anything like that you know they are very separate from how this feels this is like different designers it's different feel different look it's definitely not i think to be confused with those games it's one in its own right it just happens to begin with tea i suppose so in terracotta army you have an action wheel here and workers that

you will place around the outside of the board i'm gonna have to make certain i get a few of the uh bits and bobs from underneath the board here but essentially you have these tiny little workers you'll pop them around the outside and resolve free actions on the wheel but you can spend money to twist the wheels slightly to change what they do they could give you money which is used to get master abilities they could give you clay which is used to build the warriors and it could give you some other little bonuses as well but what you are doing primarily is that you are trying to build statues on this grid here so you've got specialist statues in grey that score or do various different effects but then you also have these generic four warriors here each with their own associated weapon token that you can build in order to place on the grid wherever you want you'll have bases on the various warriors to dictate they are yours and what you're essentially doing is you're building them for victory points generally but then there's end of round objective scoring and there's end game scoring based on who's got the most of them and within particular groups a group of the same type of warrior next to each other orthogonally but each round you've also got two inspector pawns that go around the outside of this little grid that score the row and column based on who's got the most essentially it all revolves around two words domination and presence domination you've got the most of some inc presence you have at least one of something and so each round you will basically get your workers back you'll you'll pump them on this wheel more and more you'll keep getting money and clay and spending and these warriors will dwindle in value but this board will get

much more congregated with a lot of warriors on it and specialists more on that later and so you keep going until five rounds are done at which point you then scored groups based on a selected criteria and then of course the one with the most points of course so that's a very basic overview of the game because there's a bit too much to go into too much detail there so first off let's talk about the components and the production quality hit and miss and board and dice do have a thing about this you almost feel that the b in board and dice almost stands for budget at times now you do get miniatures here you get a decent organizer box with these statues in it but there's not a ton of detail on them and they are basically bendy plastic so expect a few floppy spears every now and again i feel like i'm gonna break this damn thing they're fine they do the job even though the color coding could be better i mean you have you know cream then you have grain and you have light brown and dark brown and then all the specialists are gray which is fine when it's a horse and you can easily tell it apart but then it's a bit harder when it's a musician or a footman which yes they have the bases of different shape but when you are littering this thing with a ton of warriors good luck trying to spot that when you have a cacophony of warriors all over the place it gets very crowded very quickly the other components are pretty basic as well i mean the coins i hate these coins i get the idea you want to be authentic but for a game that literally has no theme whatsoever i mean when you are playing this game the whole

thing about it being the terracotta army is pretty much non-existent so don't worry about that the fact that you then go right well we've got to have at least chinese currency in here with these annoying little bits in the middle that you got to pop out with a chopstick or something because your fingers are too fat and you've got to do this to about 100 coins no i'm not punching these out this is stupid i'm using iron clay chips i hate these coins i get that they are they're authentic chinese currency but is there not a better way of doing this the clay tokens are also literally just a cardboard tile where you've got cracked clay and then just solid brown with barely a texture on it it's very basic looking clay i mean you couldn't even just give us wooden bricks or something like in catan or any other game that does this really the only bit you're spending that much money on is the action wheel and even then it's just basically two dials that you just pop into the board and they twist around just fine although the annoying thing with this is that as you spin one it always spins the one above or below it so i want to turn this one oop turns the whole thing so okay i've got to hold this in place spin that and then because that goes the opposite way around i've then got to hold this one in place while moving that one fiddly and kind of annoying now for ease of play this is mainly a mid-weight game but i feel that this tries to go out of its way to make life more fiddly for you than it should be you know the rule book is not a small woo work i mean there's quite a lot of pages near 24 20 yeah 24

pages in here there's quite a bit going on but i will give credit to some of this rule book the actual rules themselves if you have played these types of games before are not very complicated there's a lot of pictorial examples there's a lot of like you know sidebar like side boxes with key parts in them there's you know a chart with all the different iconography on it and such so there certainly is a lot of good stuff to say about this rule book it's not always worded great i mean the kneeling archer rules the specialist for the archer and the endgame scoring takes a couple of read-throughs to really understand but for the most part a lot of these rules are not too hard to understand and you know even the in-game scoring has a decent amount of pictorial representation examples to get the point across where this rulebook falters quite badly however is the lack of any decent reference aids you have got at the back of the book you know a couple of reference pages which is nice for the warriors and the various master abilities great except they're in the back of the rulebook where's my reference card for each player i don't want to have to pass a book round every time somebody wants to look up a particular thing and even then that tells you the abilities okay cool because the iconography in this game is far from intuitive it's actually pretty distracting at times but you know this will explain it fine but then all you have for a reference aid is this on the

back of the rule book and frankly it sucks it sucks as a reference aid it tells you five of the abilities in a nice little chart here but then it foregoes the chart to tell you about other bits which doesn't make sense why don't you just make one big chart and put them all in there but then also when it gets to the point about building a specialist or masters or warriors it tells you see page 15 for details the detailed information can be found on pages 15 and 16. i don't want a reference guide to tell me where in the book i can find the detailed rules give me a summary sheet for each player with the rules for everything on it and especially for scoring because the scoring in this game is barely noticeable on anything you've got a symbol for victory points which doesn't even tell you that's the symbol for victory points anywhere in the book but you know what you're scoring for these warriors but then the specialists if you were to literally just look at the iconography down here you might struggle to understand exactly what it's going on about just from here and that's just like when you place them down it doesn't specify what's end game scoring you have to figure it out from the iconography but then the various things that you do in the interim scoring it you have to go into the book to find it and end game scoring is a wall of text which you have to read like very carefully to make certain you don't make a mistake but none of that is on the board so there's no like you know turn structure part on this board you've

got little bits like little reminders but they're kind of dotted around randomly so you can easily miss them when you're trying to do stuff and that is a problem because you know i like to give praise to a decent rule book and a lot of this rule book is decent but why no reference guide is it really i mean you've got miniatures everywhere you know you always put a ton of dice in your games can you not give each player a reference aid in 2022 we should not be skimping like this on games each player deserves a rose reference guide in every game there is full stop everybody got that there should be no exceptions unless the game is literally no thanks or can't stop but in a game like this which has a lot of rules and multiple ways to score points i want a reference guide now the whole game essentially revolves around the manipulation of which warriors you build at what time and where they go on the grid while juggling around this action wheel the actions on this wheel though kind of rinse repeat themselves a lot so as much as it is cool to kind of manipulate the wheel to how you see fit that kind of gets a little bit samey relatively quickly the master abilities are quite a cool thing you essentially have a token that you place on a master to say you have like you know affiliation with them and it gets more expensive as the game goes on to like you know the more masters you have the more pricey it gets but these masters are not balanced no way i mean there is a master here that allows you to place a warrior using as much money as the number of rounds you're on okay

one two three four five that quickly gets very expensive because money is not something you have an abundance in this game you can pay money to move this wheel around which you're gonna need to a lot you need money for specialists you need money to get the master ability in the first place money is not something you have a ton of so to be able to use this ability in later rounds just doesn't happen you know i i every time i've seen people use it they use it maybe once twice if they're lucky and then never again for the rest of the game whoopi honestly being able to flip all your weapon tokens over is pretty good to be considering that the weapon abilities on these warriors is something you cannot ignore they get you points that you get more money they let you manipulate these inspector pawns the weapons are critical to what you're doing and not to mention you need a ready weapon to get the specialist on the board in the first place that master is one to go for but then you've got the warehouses around the wheel to get clay from a pretty decent source of clay as long as you take the action to wetten them later and yeah more on that in a second the one that just gives you a bunch of clay each time you use them that's pretty powerful in itself so yeah these masters are great but i find myself going for the same two or three every single game and not really going for any of the others because the others are much more situational whereas these ones like flipping your weapon tokens and getting more clay are just universally good now notice the way i said wetting clay um i mentioned that the theme of this game is non-existent and i stand by that the

theme in this is just gone i mean as soon as i mention what the game's about i can just tell people to forget the theme but what this game does is basically it's an excuse for children to generate as many wet jokes as possible because you have to wet your clay in order to use it to make warriors the amount of jokes that come through every game i play about making things wet or moist is limitless yeah we spent most of the time laughing in this game because of the jokes we were making about the clay because we couldn't say the words together without sniggering i had to be careful that i wasn't riding the high of this game purely because of us being children and joking around as opposed to like the game actually being fun to play the whole puzzle with the warriors is good i like the idea that you can move some of these around with one of the warrior abilities i like the way that you have to juggle which weapons you've got available at what time i like the way that you know with the musicians and the horse for example you've got various like cool little tactics you can play in order to get dominance and presence in an area but you don't do a lot of interaction with the opponents and this area becomes such a crowded affair that like i said it just makes scoring a chore trying to figure out who's got what and where you're constantly looking into it with your eyes getting sore just trying to pick out which ones are yours because the basses yes they're color-coded but when you've got all of these on this board here it's chaos it's a ton of

stuff to look at and try and decipher and it gets a little bit hard to visualize really effectively the other thing is that the scoring just seemed a little bit lackluster in a lot of areas i mean getting points for these is great the whole dominance and presence thing though i mean some of these objectives each round is literally have the most clay well to get presents you need to have one clay it's not difficult to have a single clay in your area for a bunch of points but you could make so much effort trying to get domination and yet that only scores you a few extra points more it's far more effective just to have presents in a bunch of different pots than it is to win domination on a couple of pots and nothing in the others so it didn't feel like the point scoring really changed that much based on who had domination and presence anywhere and of course when you are scoring points for stuff like you might get free points for this and whatever considering in most games you tend to lack the board i don't think it's really that tricky in fact i think i've i think i remember lapping the board twice in some of the games like getting 200 and something points when you've got 200 plus points the whole idea of getting six seven here and there doesn't equate to a ton when you all think about it it's very difficult to necessarily see who's going to take the victory at the very end because of the end game scoring and so it just feels a little bit anti-climatic the duration of the game on the box is 90 to 120 minutes i'd say that's closer to be 90 to 180 because it depends entirely on the players because this game has a very bad player scaling

issue with two three or four players you can play this with the solo mode will touch on briefly later but for two players the game goes at a reasonable pace and you should be able to get it done in 90 minutes the problem with two players though is that the whole tug of war thing with this board here where you're vying for control and you know positioning your warriors for the inspector pawns and stuff like that uh that kind of doesn't feel quite as fulfilling in the two-player game because it's just basically you and your opponent there's not a huge amount of player interaction in this game and so you're just kind of like doing a tug of war with one other person three players i find tends to be the sweet spot because with four players who we um this board here gets littered with so many warriors in that that you end up in a situation where you can barely see what's going on in terms of who owns what and what should score what the musicians in particular they're on their knees so they're low down and they don't have a color base they're not different colors of the specialists and you will not be able to tell it has a cross bass because it's surrounded by a bunch of other miniatures unless you are looking top down on this thing you're going to look at it from a distance and you're going to not see where the musicians are very easily and so what happens is that the game screeches constantly on its breaks when it's scoring time you know each and every round you've then got to go right hang on so we're scoring this objective who's got presence and domination right we got that one sorted okay musicians oh god there's like three of them on there all right so hang on where's the musician

right that's got one two three oh four for me there right and there's one two oh but you're facing two magicians so there's another two for yellow okay and it's just constantly er you get into the flow of a round and then the round ends and then you're having to stop the game dead to do scoring it's a bit like the problem with bunny kingdom add a similar deal you play a really cool round and then the game screeches to a halt to do the interim scoring and this is no exception and the you know police said about the endgame scoring the better of it you'll spend pretty much a round's worth of time just trying to do the end game scoring for as you're trying to understand what makes a group and how to do what scores for what and counting how many different players are in a group for each point were for each warriors gets very very fiddly at times but the other problem with four players analysis paralysis this wheel i like i think it's a cool idea the idea that you've got this wheel that you can manipulate to a little bit of the extent and you choose your particular segment and you put your worker there and you get all the actions here's the problem this is basically an analysis paralysis generating machine it's insanity especially in four players because you already have a ton of spaces to do you've got one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve twelve different spaces here so that's twelve but you can pay two coins to move this wheel space or that wheeler space so your twelve spaces

just became umpteen amount of different combinations with this wheel which is cool from a gameplay perspective but this causes players to freeze up like crazy because there are too many options to consider and each one that involves building warriors and that has four different types of warriors to build each with a weapon token that you could flip and then depending where you place it might incur some other effect or some other consideration but then that's just when you know that everything's available to you if you're going third or fourth in the turn order in a four-player game good luck trying to get what you want to do because every sooner somebody nix your space or worse twists the wheel slightly suddenly your plan a is dead so so could plan b and c you need to have about three or four different plans for your turd because it's very easy for a player to literally just do something that benefits them not realizing that it screws you over in the process and now you've got to rethink pretty much your entire turd it's a nightmare in four players in fact without reference guides and without you know these things to make the game a bit smoother i don't know if i really want to play this with four players ever again i think i'm gonna cut this at free for life i don't want to play this with four with that much analysis paralysis and that much chaos on this board two just feels a little bit too loosey-goosey three just seems to be a bit of a sweet spot i find that's my perfect player count for this game but then do i want a game where i only have really one player count here's the rulebook for the main game cool

where's the robot with the solo mode oh yes it's online you gotta go download it as a pdf from the website i hate it when rules are stuck online i know we're in a digital age people but for crying out loud give me a book to read they're easier to pull out for reference purposes and they're easier to learn from i hate staring at a phone screen for ages reading a rule book to try and understand what's going on okay hate it don't like it but that being said the solo mode itself it's a david turksey design so it is pretty good and pretty solid it's a 10-page rule book though and the main issue with it is not its gameplay the gameplay of it is actually pretty decent in fact i dare say it's probably better playing the solo than it is to player in fact honestly i'd probably say it's better playing the solo than it is multiplayer the solo mode picks you up against an ai opponent and you know does a good job of giving you a nice puzzle to figure out the problem with the solo mode though is that much like a lot of these other designs it's a little complicated in places to start with the main sort of turn sequence is not tricky but then you have a different priority rule for what the ai will do based on numbers on a grid i mean there's literally a diagram with numbers for this grid that you're supposed to follow differently in each round that gets fiddly you've then got you know what warrior will it build each turn what's what it does with the specialists etc that gets fiddly they have spare actions as opposed to like you know master actions it is basically

a whole new game that you are learning on top of the game already to learn the solo play so it's a bit of a slock but it is a decent like a wordy result once you get to the end of that slog problem is put this game away and don't play it for a few weeks you're going to forget all those rules and you're going to have to learn them over again that is not something i can see myself doing very easily but i've been said it's still a decent solo mode i just wish that the rulebook was actually in the box and it was just a little bit more streamlined but it is a pretty solid game to play in that mode so terracotta army is fine it's okay but sadly it's not one that's gonna blow my mind it's not one that's suddenly gonna rejuvenate the board in dice line because i started off pretty highly with the t series and then they started dropping off as time went on this one is okay i mean people i've played it with have enjoyed it but none of them have come away saying that this is like oh i must buy or oh i'm gonna like really really love this one they've come away saying i like it it's good but they won't necessarily seek it out they're not gonna ask me to bring it back to the table again they'll just be like yeah cool i'll play if you bring it to the table again but with four players i don't know if i ever want to teach this to three new players ever again because of it so chances are i'm only gonna restrict it to three because i won't get two player games at the table very often that becomes a problem for me and so you've got the solo mode but then if i put this away on the shelf i'm going to forget those solar rules because of all the priorities and all the different rules for each warrior and specialist

i've got to learn which becomes a bit of a chore so for me this game doesn't really have a place to you know doesn't replace any other midweight euro i've got and it's not bringing anything that new to the table other than just the idea of you know area control with these statues to make it stand out from the crowd it feels like another euro game with a mechanic that's fine with some puzzly aspects but just some annoying things that make the game a bit more fiddly and a bit more long than it should be if we could shave 30 minutes off the length of this game and make it a little bit smoother with maybe less scoring all the time i reckon this would be a solid solid hit but as it stands for me this one scores a respectable and comfortable six out of ten not quite high enough for me to go giving my seal of endorsement to it but i can see this one is going to have its fans there are some people who really love this i think they're being very forgiving of some of the ease of play aspects but to each their own you know so it's for me it's a fine game i would play it but it's not one i'm gonna seek out it's not one that i'm gonna say everybody must go out and grab i think board and dice have done better euro games today i think i'd still rather play te kenyu i'd much rather play territory and certainly the newest one title tom which i've got to review in the other room looks a little bit more interesting as well but like i say to each their own i'd be interested to hear your thoughts so by all means get your comments down below and let me know your thoughts on this on anything in the game have you

played it is it hit for you was it a dud for you let's hear what you have to say so that's it for me remember you can always thumb up the video subscribe to the channel or the patreon but most of all get your comments down below and let me know your thoughts on terracotta army is it a hit for you is it a dud for you what do you think of the other t series of board and dice you know you're looking forward to taltum get your thoughts down below i want to hear and i'm sure other people do as well until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the top 100 which is entering the second half of the list finally but also some cool reviews i've been doing in preparation for essen with some new releases expected there take care and remember as always regardless of how you're going to arrange these statues in this giant grid here it's still only a game take care bye for now

Progress saved