Crossing Oceans Review - What did 5 years do to Transatlantic?
Transcript
hello everyone this is Cinema and this is Johannes and you are watching board gaming ramblings and today we are taking a look at Crossing oceans this is a new game from PD warlock designed by Matt guards it plays from two to four players in 19 minutes so let me tell you a story it was the year of 2017. Johannes just started his board game channel board gaming ramblings it was long before Cinderella's even on the channel and we were back from our first Spiel at Spiel we got this game called transatlantic and it was not very fun you didn't want to watch my review of the game it was not a horrible game but I did not love it and there was quite a few time things about the game I did not like it was a pain for me to go back and watch my review of the game five years ago so if you want to see me five years ago trying to get through a review and also doing 10 minutes of rules explanation go and watch that review and I hope that's gonna be like a boost of yours on that reunion so five years later smack gurks is coming wind he's kind of it was called transatlantic 2 and then it changed the name to Crossing oceans So today we're going to take a look at seeing what five years of development did and if it's any good Crossing oceans is if you haven't played transatlantic a game about getting ships you're gonna get ships and you're gonna place them out on a map trying to kind of like have a there's kind of like it's not gonna be a majority Army area control but it's good to have more of
your ships out on the table than the other players then you are basically using Aaron Dell you're gonna be getting income different ways and then you're gonna try to buy more ships place them on the board maybe build some training houses but you can place tokens on your board and the tokens on your board shows you how much you're gonna score for a different boats colors at the end of the game game and I'm going to continue doing that until you're through the stack of boats or ships it's not boats it's called ships I think that's because it's so large I don't know anything about it I think that's our bigger than boats and what is smaller than boats banana yeah and that is basically what you're doing in Crossing oceans yeah uh artwork wise it looks like a Euro game I've seen this rondelle in first game before it's like it is colorful will with these specific colors matching the different actions so it's easy to specific colors but the the map in itself is very simple laid out it's like symbols on the continents to have resources on them we don't do that I don't like that no I don't like it either and overall it's uh it's fine I like the artwork I like how the ship looks but other than that it looks like a Euro game I enjoy that you have a double-sided board so you can play with the uh historical map on the back so like an old Globus basically I think that's enjoyable I feel like though like when when most of your map is made for places to place things it kind of gets messy I don't like to do that other than that there's basically
regions with the different both ships actions on them and I think that is fine yeah I do like this like there's gonna be there's gonna be some kind of comparisons to transatlantic here because it's impossible not to and I like this better than just a plain born of locations in a room in transatlantic it makes it a little thematic the rules are like in most macular schemes you get a piece of paper for for a setup and then when you're done with setup you can take the other piece of paper this is actually a long macular rule book it's actually six pages which is very long for a MacBooks book usually it's like play the card and do what's on it you're done that's the game rules and and the rules are very simple like you're gonna either place a ship or get a contract and you're gonna do an action or you're gonna use the contracts for different kind of small bonuses and then you are going to do an action on the rundown moving your little piece and you're gonna do like this very very smooth very very quick and yeah so nothing bad to say like most it's good like most my virtual books it's very nice condensed nothing more than it needs to be and I'm not less than it needs to be either which is important when you it's harder I feel like to make a show older rule book time to make a longer rule book because you have less words to explain what you need to explain yes and it's a little neat to play right as well that it gives you some additional information and we have played this with two and three players and it's taken us uh one hour and 20 to 1 hour and 45 minutes yeah and what does the box say uh it
says 90 minutes what does the box say it's impossible not dude I was so close and what is how did you say nine two minutes okay so that's kind of that's right I think that's fine yeah I like maybe and and you're playing the same amount of ships even though like so gameplay game is actually the same amount of length depending on the number of players if I'm not 100 correctly or incorrectly there's so many games in my brain some don't like to to distrust all my own thoughts about the rules of a game uh but yeah so I feel like the gameplay uh the time is not bad like it the turns are very quick yeah it's actually with two players you feel like it's your turn all the time yes markers has these micro turns that is just like very focused on that downtime isn't an issue and you're you're it's very fast before it's your turn again usually yeah so this game has a rundown and as I said we are gonna probably if you don't know anything about transatlantic you will after this review and the game has the wrong Dell in transatlantic use chords like in discordia so you Concordia sorry I'm missing those we'll just review that uh you play a Call of Duty what's on it and then you have a card that makes you take it back and you can get more cards here it's kind of more basic it's simpler because there's no way to get more cards there's no way to like build up a strategy based on that it's a set round run down with a set number of turns between the others you can move one to three spaces and then you can pay a contract to move how far you like and look but you cannot take the same space twice so I feel like this
rondelle is kind of a boring rondelle I'm reminded it's it's um depending on what kind of strategy you go for oh yeah you kind of want to be very efficient around the rondelle or you have specific spaces that you need to go to you can't really rush around it and I feel like it's a little looser than the cards because they're like you have to play I think it's four cards before you can take him back when you get more cards you can maybe have like these two ship cards or for example and do these actions more multiple times in a row but on this in this rondelle if you want to you can be very loose with your actions but I feel like in the same in both games and and the thing that I really like in my coach games is like I plan a long time forward so I can know maybe like six or seven up to 10 actions that I want to do after each other it's going to change a bit here because there's some interaction on the board but I can have a plan like okay like when you play the transatlantic and also Concordia I usually like have my hand of course I'm going to do is my turn I just do it and I like that a lot in my good designs I feel like there is um the map here is kind of nice like you have the every time it's your turn you can place a ship or you can take a contract if you play the ship you can place it in one of the different locations or in the areas and it's going to get very it's going to get full very very soon like there's one location has four spaces one has two and the others has three ended up using fewer
locations if you're playing or regions or um continents if you're playing with fewer players and when it's full you have to always take out the all the ship there and the ship you're replacing it with has to be um younger than the ship that you're replacing it with so if you have like so game ships are basically gonna be obsolete pretty soon like you have a ship in the beginning you when it gets pushed out you get it back you're probably not going to be able to place it out again or maybe in another location oh yeah where another ship is older I like that that when a shape goes out which can sometimes place it out in another location but sometimes we have better ships those are usually better to pet out I don't know um but I agree I think that the map and the tightness of it is kind of fun you you'd be like oh no and now Johannes has a lot of um votes on the map now I should try to get like this a little more even out so that you won't earn so much money when it's your turn for example let's talk a bit about the actions on the Rundell there's eight spaces on the rundown two of them is the ship action we're going to talk a bit more about later but basically you buy ships and then you have a call Action which lets you put coal on your ships that you use in the few of the other actions that give you money you also have the house action where you can build like a market a stall or a market house a house basically yeah a trading house that's the name of this house that
doesn't make sense a training house I own location where you have a ship and you don't have a trading house if there's another player's trading house or other players you have to pay them money to be able to place your trading house there as well and then the rest of the actions are different ways to get money what do you feel about the actions and like the the let's say like the actions is kind of what choices you have in the game do you feel like the choices are interesting fun and different uh I think it's they're very simple I think most of the time it doesn't engage me a lot it doesn't seem very exciting like oh I'm finally going here and I'm taking these calls off my my ships I can produce and I get 70 money yay well it's a lot of that during the game but with very much less excitement because yeah that's what you do in the game yeah I feel like the actions are like the different actions there's there's three different ways to get money there's a region action where you choose a region and you get all the tips there even other players produce which has a colon and produces and you get a bonus for the trading houses you have there then you have the cargo action where you choose a ship you take out the coal and then depending on how much cargo it can hold you get some money based on that later in the game that's going to be something and earlier it's not then you're gonna have the fleet action where you take all your ships and take off a call of all the ones at Haskell and produce with them and then you have the Blue Ribbon
action which is only in one location and if you have the forces tipped there you're gonna get double of that boats production yeah and none of those actions feel like oh no I'm gonna do this action now they are different it's it's not that they're the same action but none of them are makes me feel like I'm doing something different it's all about getting the money yeah so you can go to the ship action which is the game and get the ships yeah and when you get ships you can buy one to three of them and no matter how many you you buy you're gonna discuss god of the tree so that's a change from transatlantic which makes the game float smoother and and you are gonna some of them goes like into a Side Market where you can have one of each type and every time there's a new type that gets pushed out of the market you're gonna discard that and put that there instead when you buy these shapes you put them in front of you and you get a flag token on the on them like the Dawson and transatlantic it's just to make it easier to see what you have is I don't have to look all of the airships which is simpler I like that and and that's how you score the points basically in the game you get some points for uh having um trips like having their ships on the table at the end and having the trading houses but the majority of the points are going to come from these flags and you have the flags and the the different tokens and if I have like let's say I have five red ships I want to also have a lot of red tokens because then I'm gonna get from I think one two or three to ten points I think red trading houses
you mean yes yeah Reddit tokens yeah the red for the houses um I think that also the buying of the ships isn't that exciting because usually actually I see that oh I want this white flags because I have a lot of white trading houses that I will buy them if they're not available to buy all of them in white I can buy up the tree um then I will see okay what trading house do I have in the next most oh okay that's red then I will get the red shapes so I seldom look at all of the other stuff sometimes if I'm going for the Blue Ribbon I might go for the first chips and that's it yeah I don't feel I agree with you 100 I don't feel it's exciting because one of the things I had a problem with the transatlantic was that I felt like the strategy was to go for one or two other one or two of the colors and then just Spam that as much as you could and that's what you want to do here as well if you see somebody else go for the same color as you maybe switch colors and but maybe not to give them a fight I don't know yeah but that is basically I feel like the game boils down to you are doing that they're they're trying here to do it differently you have these multi-colored Flags which kind of like tries to force you to do the different colors but you get one of them at the beginning and again you might get one or maybe two at the end of the game and they're gonna score you a maximum of Five Points because there's one point for each different color you have so it's much better to focus on two different colors and go for that
um I I feel like like the changes from transatlantic most of them has made the game shorter and smoother the biggest change is the way you score points because when I played The Crossing oceans the first time I thought this was the way he scored points in transatlantic yeah then we went back and saw the review that I did five years ago and I was like oh it's very different yeah it is and I actually maybe think that I like the transatlantic way to school way better I am I think this is is more like plain and boring yeah because the way it works is that you score when your ship is pushed out of the board yeah and then you score it instead of at the end of the game so you will still trying to get the ships with the same way that you have because when you want to score them but you kind of can try to push somebody's shape out before they get to to work up to get nine points maybe they only get five points and also the trading houses was way more strict in the other game there's a set amount of spaces and every time you you score a zip there I think you got another point or every time you did something in that region I don't remember exactly you've got a point as well so there's those things especially the ship scoring I think I enjoyed better in transatlantic I agree it has made a version of this game like you know yeah he published a variant yes that is what I meant that is I think meant to balance out not spamming one or two colors but balancing more which he has then uh tweaked some of the um costs
for the trading houses for example but it's kind of weird for me to to be working on a game for five years then publish it and one month later put out a variant that addresses the thing that people have a problem with the transatlantic yes um I don't know what's going on behind the scenes I don't know what's going on in in his brain and but I felt like um yeah this is final thoughts let's continue yeah and but I'm really ready for final thoughts first waste and who is it for uh I think this is a medium game yeah um I don't know it's kind of it's It's a light medium game maybe for me who is it for I don't know um if you like Mike Gertz rondells I think there are better my current Ronaldo games out there um to be honest yeah hamburger for example yeah if you like a transatlantic you might look into this one um yeah um I I don't know I I'm like basically who is it for is where we kind of recommend the game and I'm not recommending the game because I don't I don't think it's a good game no you don't have to see for yourself but uh final thoughts time maybe um yeah we were talking a little bit about if we should try the variant that he has published to see if that changes our thoughts on the game because we were like okay it's like a one-trick pony where you just found these two colors or one and you you kind of or basically like we also tried before people say that in the comments yeah like the last time we played you try to do more balance yes and then all scholarships were almost the same points and that also worked but it's not more
interesting no it isn't that is my point basically I didn't really need that I um feel like I needed to play a variant because my thoughts on the game is still that I don't find it interesting yeah um I think that it's it's all right it's it's I'm not bored while I'm playing it but I'm not having a great time I'm not being excited I think it's nice um that the turns go by so quickly and I'm taking this okay I want to put this about out haha you're out of there now and I'm the fastest now I'm going to go to this Blue Ribbon uh pull the space on the rondelle and do get income and then I can buy these three ships because I got a lot of money but it's very repetitive for me and I don't see um I I just don't think that this is an enjoyable enough puzzle for me to be satisfied by it basically I I think this is like a little bit of average game for me I'm going to rate it a 5.5 yeah I I think Hmm I agree with you I don't find it boring I was just sad that I felt exact the same thing that I did for transatlantic five years ago that it was just not interesting enough and I have enjoyed many my goods game especially Concordia being one I I really really like um so I was I'm really excited to see what he was doing for five years making this game better and for me sadly it was not better it's not a game I ever need to play again
and yeah maybe in five years transatlantic three trans Atlantic Crossing yes something like that it's going to come out and maybe that will be a better game however me it's a five it's an average game it's not a horrible game but for me it was not something I am ever excited to play again yeah so that is the end of this video if you are still here and you have not subscribed you can do so now bye clicking the subscribe button is fun and it's free it makes us happy like this if you want to do something that's not free you can go to patreon.com boardgamingramblings and support us there and that is the end of the video thank you so much for watching I'm Johannes and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and bye bye