6 Scenarios We Changed Our Opinion On (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to the list video here at playing board games. I'm joined by Daniel from Quick Learner. How's it going Daniel?
Pretty good. Happy to talk about some scenarios. We haven't done that in a little while on your channel.
Yeah, it's always also weird asking a person how they're doing when we've been talking for like an hour at this point. But you know the video it's just like we just started talking for the first time. But you're 100% right. These are six scenarios that we changed our opinion on. Maybe for the better, maybe for the worse. We're going to find out here as things go. Um, but it should be pretty fun. Uh, so Daniel, I'm going to throw this one to you to talk about your first one here, which is Where the Gods Dwell from Dream Eaters. Okay, Dream Eaters is not my favorite campaign. It's probably down there towards the bottom, which makes me a bit of a unicorn on this channel, I think. But I do like this scenario, but I didn't always. And I think the reason why was because I had a few bad experiences with the hidden card mechanic in the scenario. If you don't know, basically the whole point of the scenario is this kind of crazy boss fight where you're what you're doing is trying to collect some hidden cards and they're coming from the encounter deck
and it's pretty swingy. Sometimes you find them, sometimes you don't. And the first times first few times I played this scenario, I want to say I might have been playing Patrice and it wasn't a good time. I don't think the hidden mechanic hidden card mechanic worked very well for her. Um, and then I think another time I was just bogged down with all the hidden cards and I literally couldn't draw anything else because my hand size was also reduced and it was just kind of bad. Um, I didn't have a fun time and I thought this is a really strange scenario. I don't like it. you are still doing skill tests and you happen to autofail one of them, you're sometimes out of luck. It feels pretty bad if you fail those tests.
Yeah.
But I've played this scenario more recently and I've enjoyed the stress a little bit more and I think I've understood how to mitigate some of those other issues better. Like the play patterns I think in in a lot of scenarios are do you brute force what the scenario's objective is or do you play back a little and hedge your bets and in this one I think you can't just ram through the encounter deck because it punishes you.
Sometimes you're drawing things that are going to keep you from actually advancing. Uh, but getting clues from the different locations, using them strategically, handing cards off to other people. Um, I found it to be stressful, but in a more fun way more recently. So, it's climbed up my personal scenario ranking list uh from the first time that I played it where I just thought it was not great.
I still don't love it, but I have enjoyed and looked forward to playing it more more recently. Mhm. Uh, I'm Yeah, I enjoy Where the Gods Dwell. I think I think the thematic nature of the two finales of Dream Eaters are pretty enticing. I'm kind of uh It didn't make this list um for the scenarios we changed our opinion on, but I think like Dream Eaters as a whole has gotten worse with more replays because it's incredibly [snorts] linear. Um, like I think that even though it's I wasn't a fan of the return to, I think that dream eaters could have really benefited from some variety in their uh scenarios because like I it almost made the list which is like point of no return or even Dark Side of the Moon. I like those scenarios the first time I played them, but uh when you play them 10, 12, like 20 times, you just realize that it's kind of just this like it never really changes. Like, yeah, maybe the the encounter cards you draw can change and the impact of how things are affecting you in the moment, but that's not really like that's every scenario has that.
That's true. Every scenario. Yeah.
Yeah. Um, but like the structure and the locations, they're always the same for those ones. Even like Search for Gadath, which I still think is one of flavorably one of my favorites in the campa like in the entirety of Arkham. But like now that I've played it so many times, I'm like, "Okay, I go to Manar. I know what to do here. It happens the same every time." So, I feel like as a whole, Dream Eaters is this. I think like the only scenario that is actually replayable in that campaign is Waking Nightmare and then everything else is like just very linear. So, you've played this one in particular twice recently from the time we're recording this.
Yeah.
Once with me and then once as part of uh the thing with head librarian Chad.
Yeah. How do you feel about it? Has it gone up or down in your estimation? No,
it's kind of like it's kind of settled to where it is. Like it's like it's unlikely to change at this point for me. It's it's kind of just like I I like I said, I enjoy it. I think it's good. Uh maybe like I would like depending on the day it might go up to like great, but it will never go below good for me. Um
right.
But it's I think that it's a fun experience, but again, I just wish there was a little bit of like variety to it. But I can see like not liking it. It's a Especially if you play like two-handed solo or solo for the first time. It's like a nightmare to I don't think it's like
this might be like the first case of seeing the balance really affect the lower player counts with the mechanics
where like um this is what Nick said in the AMA where I wish there was more control over what was in the deck. And I feel like yeah, in two players this should have less cards in the encounter deck, right? Like it shouldn't just be like a flat here are all the cards. That's like a byproduct of old Arkham design. They should be able to experiment with that and I think they will going forward and I think Where the Gods Dwell would really benefit from that.
I think so too. But the time that we played it together recently was the most fun I've had playing it and it was
not easy.
No. No.
We got our teeth kicked in a little bit, but I I felt like I was doing something. And the times I played before, it really felt like I had no control. And I think that's just to me. I mean, again, it's not like my favorite scenario or anything. It's just gotten better because I think I figured out how to have a bit more control over what was happening in that scenario despite the fact that it's still very random. So,
yeah,
that's my first one here.
All right, let's go to my first one here, which is ice and death part three. I did not like this scenario the first time I played it and I was just like why would I ever want to do this one? It's just a really boring on enemy onslaught scenario. But then uh I think I actually you even were like no I think it's fun. And I was like okay whatever. Yeah you think it's fun but you what do you know? Right. And then we played it during the um our sealed run right. Yeah.
And uh I was like okay okay I see it. I see I see what you were cooking a little bit here. And then every subsequent time I've played Ice and Death part three, I've had more and more fun with it. And like I was like I did one where I was Finn and Jacqueline when I did the gauntlet and I killed one of the guys before anything even spawned with Finn and I was like
that's cool.
Okay. Okay. I see like the highs and the lows of this scenario. there's some actually like it's a dynamic scenario and dynamics are what makes the game fun and that uh and then every other time since that I've played it I've been like okay so like now it's about like positioning where am I going how am I going to get there what clues do I need to to solve this and then I was like oh okay there's actually a lot of really good stuff in this scenario and it's actually welldesigned and it's actually very fun. Um, I've played a lot of custom scenarios that have similar sort of like enemy assaults, and I am, this is no knock on all the awesome custom custom content creators, but I have never played an enemy assault scenario that's good in a custom world because they um, this one does something really good where it takes all the enemies out of the encounter deck and it puts them into only play. And I think that like that's kind of like the dividing line where the threats need to be the threat.
You can't have threat on top of threat because that kind of like skews the balance. And I think Ice and Death Part Three is actually really well balanced in being an enemy assault mission and changed my opinion of it because of that.
Let me ask you an interesting question cuz I didn't know what was on your list. Um, Longest Night is another enemy assault mission
and it's sort of similar in that there's no encounter deck uh enemies, right? Everything's just in the separate enemy deck.
Uh, granted that is scenario four sort of um with some different XP scaling.
Uh, this is an earlier one.
Mhm.
I find this scenario to be fun um but not super super stressful. I think there's just kind of a it's a good time to go around and try to see how well you can do as early as you can while still potentially doing your supply recovery stuff if you want to.
Uh that scenario, longest night, is incredibly stressful.
Yes,
it's a great scenario. I think it's very interesting, but it's to compare the two. This one is relatively simple
in the enemy assault mechanic. It's just they spawn every two turns maybe. um and everything else plays identical. Whereas Longest Night has many other constraints for to keep you from getting ahead essentially.
Um that one doesn't end if you kill everything. This one does, right?
Um I'm not saying that they're uh I like one versus the other, but it's interesting to me that they're actually kind of the same idea, but the other one is just trying to be much more difficult in how you're interacting with enemies.
Yeah. And I I think a big thing for that is that uh ice and death part three is you are the aggressor, right? Even though the enemies are coming to you and in the longest night, you are trying to survive. So like the the mood of them change where like everything in uh Longest Night is tuned to kill you, right? Like they're like it's designed to actually be like unfair, right? Uh, and the the Idolons in um Ice and Death Part 3, they're designed to be fair because they're just basic enemies, right? You just have to deal with them at a constant like ticking clock style of play.
Um, so that's what makes it I agree
with you.
Yeah. And I don't think they're scary, but it's it can still be a fun, tense scenario, but for like I wouldn't call it like outright scary like I other than longest night can be.
Yeah. Yeah. No, I've always enjoyed this one just because I think there's a little bit of a video game feeling to it, too, where it's just kind of let's sit on the the ridge and blast as many enemies as we can in the time period.
Yep.
Um and that's enjoyable.
Yeah. And it's fun to try to kill the guys early.
Yeah. It's a good scenario three.
And if you can if you can make it work, Yeah. you can get ahead and and do even more. And I like that there's still other stuff to do in the scenario if you're trying to get that stuff.
Yeah. And it's it's one of those things where um it's uh it's unfortunate that Edge of the Earth always leaves a bad taste in my mouth because of the ending and like the things between the scenarios, but the scenarios actually like for the first like for like 90% of the campaign like everything except the final scenario are actually all I think really good scenarios. All right, I think time is will be kind on Edge of the Earth for me. So it's already showing some stuff here. All right, let's go to your next one here, which is
Okay, so I talked about the first one where I didn't like the scenario and then I like it more. This is the opposite. I'm I'm not surprised uh based on having talked to other people of course and heard all of your content about this, but the first time I played Hard of the Elders, I was like, "This is fine." Um, I think we got three pillars or three ways or whatever in in Boundary Beyond. Played the scenario, got through it in maybe one or two plays, and then moved on. We're like, "Yeah, it was a fun little mini scenario where you're just doing Arkham things where you get clues and then kill some enemies and do whatever else they want you to do." It felt very simple. It was just a mini scenario before the more full heart of the elders part B.
And then it is been a slog. We played a challenge version of this last year, I think it was, or maybe two years ago. Gosh, I don't even know where we did the Yithians and it was miserable.
Yeah.
And that wasn't the first time I started to understand the discourse around this scenario being just like
overstaying its welcome. But
I don't think the design of this makes sense unless it is a set number of paths.
Yeah.
Because that's just it it just shouldn't be scaling in this weird way. If it's too few, if it's one or even two, it's trivial.
You just do it.
And if it's five or four or five or even six potentially, then it's miserable because you're just doing this forever and it can grind you down. I mean, we took trauma after trauma trying to play this one. It wasn't fun. And I don't think there's enough meat on the bones there to warrant replaying it. So, I started to realize, okay, this is just like not welldesigned. I don't think it's not fun in the sense that the first time I played it was I was deluding myself in terms of the fun I was having, but rather it has not a good design. It needs to be something that's set. you play it maybe a little bit more there to enjoy and then you move on to the next one. But
uh yeah, it I don't need to play the scenario ever again. If if I can manage to to not play it, it would be fine.
Yeah.
Not anything.
It's unfortunate that Heart of the Elders part one is actually so good when you get three pillars to start, right? That's like when it's at its best and like that's obviously what it was designed for. That was like the goal they wanted you to hit. But I I I'm confident that something happened in Boundary Beyond that changed it like later in testing to get there. Um because most people on their blind run, they might get three if they're lucky, but most people are walking with one or two cuz Boundary Beyond is it's a gut punch. But
um the other thing about Heart of the Elders is after you play it, you might as well just like choose five cards from your deck to be your opening hand because once you realize that there's like no penalty, you can just like reset if your mulligan's bad, which we've done. I've done it because it's also totally fair within the rules of the scenario, right?
And
I like the swing that they took with it. Um I think like it's an interesting like design experiment. I think ultimately it did fail and I think that Forgotten Age is lucky that everything else is so good because I do think that Heart of the Elders part one is like the worst scenario in the game
just because of like everything around it.
Yeah.
Yeah. So, this mostly feels like a replay issue, right? Where most scenarios in this game are fun to play again.
Yeah. Um, and this one actually is the one where it says you might replay this one more than once in the same run and you're like, "No, not like that."
Yes. Yeah.
So, yeah. I just It's It's just unfortunate. I was I looked forward to playing with the rainforest stuff again. Um, the big snake is kind of interesting. Yeah. But then when it's happening over and over again and you're not making progress, especially because Forgotten Age can beat you down a bit, uh, it just gets worse and it's not interesting to draw Lost in the Wilds and not be able to move and get poisoned. And it I think it suffers from some of the negative stuff of Forgotten Age wearing you out because there's nothing here. There's nothing interesting here
and you don't want to play this over and over again.
The first time was fine. It was good. And then after that,
Yikes.
Yeah. I think if they like just made some like if they didn't just handwave full reset but they were like the locations stay but are like returned to be unrevealed, right? Even though the treachery is on the back, right?
Or just like the replenish clues. I feel like there was a lot of things they could have done. Even if they just like changed the the rebuilt the explore deck but didn't put treacheries in or like maybe put like a random treachery per player like a random sorry random encounter card per player into the explore deck. I feel like there was a lot of growing pains that came with the explore deck in general that also impacted this. Yeah. Gosh, when when you look back at that video of us playing it as again as Ythians, which is not the design intent, um I don't think the decks were necessarily awful or that the Yethan ability was getting in our way. I think that you can have a string of very bad luck and just a a snowball really of it being
awful. So, while maybe it's fun for viewers to watch that video and and watch us being miserable, but there was a good reason why we called it after that scenario. Yep. because it was just it wasn't fun anymore. So,
yep. Yeah, 100%. All right, let's go to my number two here, which is horror in high gear.
I thought I'd never like this scenario. And um when I first played this on my blind run, I was like, "Wow, this is this is this is it." Like, this is what it is. It's It's just like go forward in a straight line and get clues and like it's complicated. There's some weird stuff. There was like the guessing game where you have to choose which path to go. I was like, "Oh, this just feels so nightmarish." And while I wouldn't say I think this is a a great scenario, this is probably the scenario that's climbed the most ranks of my c of my campaign rating where it was like abysmal, never want to play, absolutely hate the hell out of this scenario to fine. But I think that that's a pretty good like uh thing because there's been no other scenario that's um escaped the bottom two tiers in any of my my like my scenario ranking is pretty consistent as a whole. Um but this one is the one that's kind of the outlier where now I'm like yeah I like horror and high gear. I enjoy playing this scenario when there were times where I'm like this is one of the worst scenarios in the game. There's nothing fun about it. It's literally on the rails. But I actually think that it becomes more fun when you don't have to think about how the road mechanic works or how the car drives. It has a huge steep ass learning curve to make sure you're playing it right. And odds are you've played it wrong if you've played the horror in high gear in some way. But
as you play it more and more and you realize what to do, it becomes a lot more enjoyable when all that baggage is gone. Eric uh for their blind run of Inmouth was like, "I love that scenario." And I was like, "Eric, I'll be real. You're very lucky that I was doing all the rule stuff because that scenario is like a mess when it comes to design." And I still think the design is um as nicely as I can put it, inelegant. I think that it's a very clunky sort of sort of vibe for the scenario. I think it works when you have it, but as a whole, uh, I think I wish it was tighter, right? Um, but I think they did okay with what they had and it led to, I think, a fun scenario with a few fun stressful decision points. Like, for example, uh, what if we auto failed a test and we don't have enough clues and now we need to take some damage or we need to, uh, find the path because we didn't find the correct path. Or what if um we didn't get enough clues and now we have to make a test to see if we just die, right? Like that can be really fun.
Um like there was a recent one where not recent, it was when I lived in my in the at my grandma's place for that year, but where Travis Burn and I uh did our I think it was our Survivor run where we were all survivors and I was Will Yoro driving my own car, desperately trying to make sense of the whole thing while Travis and Brin were totally fine in their car. And I think again it makes fun stories because of that. Um so horror and high gear I've definitely changed my opinion on uh for the better.
Yeah, it's really interesting to talk about the mechanical differences between scenarios in the sense cuz the last one I talked about very simple, maybe too simple and with replays it's gotten worse. And for scenarios like this one, and I put Obsidian Canyons maybe in the similar boat where there's just a lot of things going on. And a lot of people the first time they play these are just like not by the merits of the game play, but the merits of the making the board do the thing it's supposed to do is they don't like the scenario. It's it's it's hard to get into it. And you're right, this is a fairly simple scenario once you understand the core mechanic of how the roads work.
Mhm. I agree with you that I wish it was a little bit better in that sense, but once you can just do that part or have someone else do it for you, it's enjoyable. The loop is is fine. I think it's it's a a good scenario that doesn't outlast its its welcome. Um, so I agree. Um, it's unfortunate that of course in a game where the components you have are all cards, you have to do new creative things using cards and sometimes that's going to make things more complicated than is normal. So those probably do become more fun for people once they understand or don't mess up that mechanic the the first time. But the first playth through of course yeah I made mistakes with this entirely. It was like wait which
how many do you put out here? Where do they go? How are they connected? Yeah,
that part was never never explained well in the guide.
Yeah, like and even like the small things where it's like because you read like all this text and there's one line on the act that just says or the agenda that just says enemies gain hunter, right? And we did our first play and we had like our cursed follower six locations back and then we were like, "Oh, wait a minute. This guy should have been following us." Cuz we were like, "Something doesn't seem right."
And it turns out it was wrong. You know, it's like one of those weird things, but like that one line of trinket text that
can just just change everything because there's just so much other around it.
Yeah. They had to give him a motorcycle. He wasn't just sitting down the road.
Yep. Yep. Yep. All right. Uh what is your last one on this list? It's the Doom of Arkham part two, otherwise known as the finale of Drown City.
It is. Okay. Okay, if you haven't played this one yet, you know, don't listen to me. But this was a a scenario that I've played now. I guess I've played it four times, maybe five, and the first time I played it was a three-player group and our decks had way too much XP
and it was just a pushover. Um, I don't think that the scenario is particularly welldesigned for a number of reasons, but I don't think I got the intended experience with a large player group with a full card pool and us doing some really busted stuff. Um, it felt very anticlimactic for the campaign, which I otherwise enjoyed mostly, but I was just like, okay, this wasn't a stressful or maybe even interesting scenario at the end. Mhm.
So, I didn't feel like I got it. Now, the second time I played it and the third and the fourth, it was much different in terms of what I was bringing to that scenario.
I wasn't going with a 50 plus XP George Barnaby deck with a Michael Mclenn and a Lucius Galloway alongside. I was a homunculus the second time I played it [gasps]
in it. I I okay again not saying that I still think the scenario is welldesigned but I think I got more of the intended experience when I was running with all twos uh as a Kate Winthrop who turned into aulus. Um and it became more interesting just two players with that one. Um we still won but I felt like there was much more going on that we had to pay attention to. The third time I played with you. Um I was playing Patrice Sealed Deck. You were playing Kimmani, right?
Yeah.
Um, and it was, you know, not super easy because we were running with not the optimized decks at all.
Mhm.
But we still made things happen and I enjoyed it quite a bit. I thought that was it was fun. And then the last time I played it was with a Lily Chen deck solo and I had no weapon for most of the time and still made it work but it was it was challenging to really make the things I wanted to do actually happen.
So I felt like every time but that first time I was getting maybe closer to the intended experience.
Yeah.
Where I didn't even experience anything the first time at all. I felt like it was just it was just there. So, while my opinion about is this a well-designed scenario hasn't changed, I feel like I have now understood more of what I think the designers wanted to happen to the investigators
uh better since I've played it just because I was not running,
can't even call them overpowered decks, just decks with a lot of XP.
Yeah.
So, whereas the first time I thought I don't understand this, now my opinion is I understand it now. I just don't think they did a good job of getting players to that point without playing some meme decks.
Yeah, I think that um that's actually kind of the issue with Drown City as a whole. And I've said this to people where Drown City is at its best when you're not playing good decks.
Uh when you're like doing some sort of weird challenge run or trying something out
because um it gives you a lot of XP for doing well and it gives you a lot of XP for doing well. So, it's like one of those things that uh the most fun I had in Drown City was that Kmani and Patrice sealed run where it was like nothing's working. Oh my god, how are we doing this? I don't think we even defeated the unescapable. I don't remember. Uh maybe we did. I usually make that a priority. Um but it it's one of those things where
we did it.
It becomes more fun.
We did
when you are not just like getting eight experience a scenario. And I think that it's I think yeah a design like miss that it is so easy to actually do that right um
but I think Drown City is more fun when you have less experience. I also now after playing the the hidden scenario in that campaign I realize that oh this is actually just like the the bad ending. This is like the not the actual um intended finale. Uh, and the real intended finale is easily the hardest Arkham scenario in the game. Like without question for that one, the the um the supplicure one. Like that one is incredibly difficult by design. It's meant to be unfair. Um,
right.
Uh, and the other thing is that I think the other thing that Doom of Arkham would be a lot more interesting is if the buildings collapsed coll were broken down quicker. I think that the game the scenario is more interesting when you're actually in the waters fighting Cthulhu as opposed to standing on a building. He's like, "Stop, [snorts] please. You're hurting me." Right.
Right. And in the first time I played that never happened. Partly because we were just going too fast.
Like the buildings never got uh demolished.
Um and that again too much XP usually means you have many other actions to take. You know, you throw guns out there with Michael Mlenn and Robert, right? It's just crazy. Uh But the times I've played since then where I've been forced into the city
has been much more interesting.
Yep.
So, um, again, I still have some huge design problems with why that is the case and some other stuff with the final act about him not moving, but never mind that part. It's just it was interesting to me to replay with very different circumstances and then get what I felt was more the intended experience. So,
yep. Hell yeah. All right, let's go to my number one here, which is the twisted hollow. Now, uh, Feast of Flock Veil is, I mean, in the running for my favorite campaign. It's like top two between it and Carcosa, right? And a lot of people, they might not understand why it is, but the answer is just that the scenarios are very good. And I think Twisted Hollow is to me kind of now like the apex of that example. When I first played the Feast of Hemlock Veil and I did my first campaign rankings, I was like, "Yeah, this one's fine." I gave it like it's an okay fine scenario. There was nothing wrong with it. It wasn't bad by any means. But let me tell you, after playing Hemlock a few more times, I actually think this is the best scenario in the campaign. It's better than even The Longest Knight. Um, it's one of the most successfully designed scenarios in my opinion in terms of hitting every mark that it has. It's a perfect lost in the woods scenario. Uh, where like the map even like cascades and like it shrinks, like grows and shrinks depending on how your light's going. It leads to an incredible boss fight against the bear where you have to try to run from it the first time because killing it bad. And then you get like the final showcase of like the whole thing where it's like it all comes together. You have the entire map made up and you just got to get out, but you still got to kill the bear on the way.
It's like a perfect pacing. And it also is just like it has such a good cadence for the threats that show up, right? Where you first start getting them in the pursuit area and they slowly start dripping out, but then also now suddenly they're no longer at the pursuit area. And the enemies in that scenario are also very unkind, right? There's the one that drops doom. There's the giant ass deer that's going to like ruin your day. There are the plants that you can just ignore, but they're going to lash out if you get clues. There's the mushroom that keeps getting like that's like taking up space. There's the thing that No, there's the thing that grows. The mushroom lashes out, but like there's the uh the weird plant that gets bigger, right? Um, there's the guys that scale with the darkness level, like the weird frog looking mfers, right? Every enemy is scary.
Yeah.
And then there's also just like the the bear, of course, but um every note hits on the twisted hollow and it's it's kind of crazy to me that starts with just like a oh yeah, this was fine. Like I thought it was a good scenario, but nothing really memorable to go into I think the best is a crazy sort of growth with it. Um, it's an it's an amazing scenario and is I like I said, I think just one of the strongest, if not um the strongest in Hemlock Veil.
Yeah, I've always loved this one. So, I think you're crazy for missing it the first time. Uh, I I think it's always been my favorite one. I I I also really enjoy Lost Sister and maybe the Silent Heath one I think is also pretty fun. Mhm.
Um the one that I've bounced around about in Penllock fail is about the finale, which
there's all kinds of things to think about with that one.
Yeah.
Um
but this one has always been really good. The only thing about it that I'm I wish was slightly different was if you I mean you're you're trying to find the exit location, right? And there's it could be the location next to you.
Yes.
Or it could be the last one you pick after, you know, looking for like seven or eight of them. And that can be a very different experience if it's just yeah
a randomly you're lucky or randomly you're very unlucky. That's okay. Like the game has to be that way. The game cannot just be like you go to the garden to resign and that's it. Um but I found very different experiences where it's extremely stressful trying to look around for the darn exit location
while dealing with the enemy pile up. Uh or you just get out. But I would say that nearly every time um it's been down to the wire, like the amount of health that I have, the the doom, um all of that, it's it's very close. So, it's a a banger of a scenario. I I really enjoy this one for Arkham at its best. And
this is a tough campaign, honestly.
Yes, it is.
It sets the tone right here, I think, for a night scenario.
I um uh I actually just did a run uh last week. Well, it's gonna be months ago at the channel by the time this video comes out, but um I uh I I I did a Twisted Hollow where I was like, "This is going so smooth." I think I like revealed the layer in Darkness 2 and like got to the Twisted Hollow in like Darkness 3 and I was like, "This is going to be cake." And then I got out with two Doom left. Like it it suddenly became stressful, right? Because it is. It's that random chance of trying to find your way out. And the game gives you a lot of tools to make it easier, right? Like it understands that um this is going to be difficult um because there's the random chance. It could be easy, it could be hard, but we have to skew towards it being like one of the la last ones you look at
cuz that's just what the odds say.
But uh it it is crazy how this scenario always comes down to the wire. And I think that's because the threats are so welldesigned for this one. Have you played this one with the the lantern that is the like not good lantern?
No, I never I've always been like, "Mother Rachel, you're the best. I love you. Thank you."
But it I like actually Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah, I've started playing it more with the the the bad lantern and not just to up the difficulty level on it, but mostly because your consequences of some of the things early on
are just so god- aful later in the campaign that those cultist tokens, I don't want them.
I really don't.
And that is one of the ways that you can avoid them. So, I'm okay with
the slightly bad lantern.
And I actually So, like I actually even looked at it and like the bad lantern isn't all bad. It's actually just different, right? Because it's easier to pick up. It's easier to pick up. Um, which is an interesting sort of thing to go with it where like the Mother Rachel lantern has a better effect, but it's an action to pick up.
It's like it's like the opposite, right? Like it's a it's a it's a lantern to cancel and like the other one's I think an action to move or something like that on the bad one, right?
And then it's the opposite where it's a lightning bolt to pick up and an action on the Mother Rachel. And let me tell you, I think I'd rather pick the card up fast than otherwise. Yeah.
Yeah.
So, yeah. Yeah. Give it a shot. Just it does make you play a little different in terms of exploration because you can't have people uh out in the darkness for too long.
But maybe you do. Maybe you want some extra enemies at that point because then they don't all come out at once later. it is that it's a lot of things that you can even just change your strategy which I think is again a good reason for what makes an Arkham scenario uh good as well, right?
100%. Yes.
Wow. All right.
Well, those were six scenarios that we changed our opinion on. Let us know in the comments what are scenarios some scenarios that you've changed your opinion on for the better or for the worse. Well, my video mine was pretty like going up. I never had really any I I I can't think of a scenario that I've started to dislike. I think the dreamer ones are the closest to ones that I've started to dislike, but even then I still think
hypothesis about ones that that people might uh put in the comments. So I have some guesses.
What are your guesses? What do you got?
Well, okay. So again, there are some that have like a really bad first play potentially, right? Like City of Archives people might get
that's what I was
more into. They understand it a bit more. Um, and potentially some of the other finales uh are going to be ones that you learn a little bit more how to play or the black throne might be another one that's like that.
Yes. Yeah.
And for the other direction, it could be things that are just like overstayed. They're welcome where they find it more boring now and it was exciting at one point.
Uh I'm not sure I can pick up any right now that are like that. But maybe if someone had a great time with the the Inmith finale and now they're like,
"Yeah, it's too easy.
This is kind of lame." Yeah, I think Boundary Beyond could be it. Like people be like, "Oh, as their card pool got bigger."
I think like Forgotten Age as a whole is one that's a grower that as your as your card card pool gets bigger and your understanding gets better. So I could see Boundary Beyond being there.
Also could see Wages of Sin for a similar reason.
Wages of Sin. Exactly. Wages of Sin potentially people gotten Otter on that one.
Maybe in the Clutches of Chaos. Uh maybe with the return to I think that it tends to become more like regular Arkham and not as much
I could see Secret Name going down.
A lot of people like Secret Name on the first one and then they realize, "Oh, I'm just killing rats over and over and again." Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. And and again, we didn't really talk about the return too for for this in general. I think were any of our scenarios from that era? Well, just Heart of Elders, I suppose.
Yep. Anyway, but some of those maybe people enjoy more because they got a bit of a a faceelift, but
probably not that much.
All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody.
Most of us have good Oh, yeah. Okay. See you.
Oh, no. No. Sorry. No. Were you going to say I don't want to Oh,
no. I just say I think that most of us have like pretty good evaluation of the scenarios after the first couple tries that it's rare that this changes and it's interesting to talk about like why like what must have happened differently. So,
yeah. Yeah, and that's that's why most of mine skewed upwards, too, because I feel like the first time you play uh it's it's very rarely a discovery of like, oh, uh this was actually bad, right? Like it's like very rarely that happens. Mo, I think most of the time it's the other way where it's like your mulligan didn't work out or you drew the wrong encounter cards and or you didn't really like appreciate some of the design choices that happened in your blind play and it becomes easier to come across those as you've played it more and more.
Yep. Exactly. All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this video. Um, again, leave a comment because now Daniel and I have some we have a pool going. So, let us know in the comments of uh which ones uh are yours uh uh that change your that you change your opinion on. Otherwise, thanks for watching. Have a good one. And as always, a GG's.