Five Tribes Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm talking about five tribes now five tribes is a game by Britain and Cathar let game designer and I tend to like a lot of his designs and this one is kind of very kind of widely regarded as one of his best games so I was very intrigued to try it out a friend of mine taught it to me and I must say when I was being read the rules I was pretty confused as a lot that seemed to be going on loads of kind of individual rules and mechanisms that was going on and it was very very overwhelming the game takes about I say about an hour to play take place 2 to 4 players and it's almost very very abstract in its kind of design and basically the game is if this board of tiles and maybe I have two five by five grid or something and all have four meters on them all different colors and all the different colors have different kind of abilities assigned to them and the the mechanism of the game is you can pick up one of these pile asad of meeples and move them equal space dropping one off on the way almost like a Mancala and where you end up is you're going to pick up all the meeples of that same color that you've just dropped off and these are going to give you kind of different abilities you can use such as maybe having the majority of that currently in the game or letting you buy these genes which give you kind of in-game abilities and bonuses and stuff like that or like assassins which let you claim tiles if they're empty and so on but the the thing is you want to kind
of line them up so that you're picking one up and collecting at the last of those resources because you get a place one of your camels down which kind of gets your points the kind of area control at the end of the game or just let you claim that tile basically more than a more than an area control but not only you're trying to think about which meeples you're picking up which territories are going to be claiming but all those tiles have a unique ability on as well and well not necessarily unique but they all have an ability on and they'll let you kind of draft from a row of cards which is going to kind of count for set collection into the game you're going to clap these different kind I think they've got a-- fakirs which give you kind of little bonuses as you go along and then even like give you kind of extra bonuses or points for claiming those tiles in the first based by posting palaces or palm trees but yeah at first I said it was very very overwhelmed by the rules explanation probably because I'm used to kind of teaching games myself but the more and more I played it it was actually pretty intuitive not too much going on this game gets a lot of kind of rap for being very analyst or you can overanalyze it very prone to analysis paralysis and as soon as I play that I could completely see why it seems like no matter what you do in this game you're kind of lining someone else up for someone else it's almost impossible to analyze because the game is constantly evolving and it's going to completely change by the time it gets background to you and they matter what you do you're going to be kind of helping someone without realizing it so I said I'm not a I'm not an AP poem prone player but even at type points in
this game I was like oh give me a minute I need to kind of work this out in my head but I think if you kind of restrict yourself give yourself a little time and don't overthink it you can get a really good time out of it yeah you don't you don't want to play this with AP parent players because you'll be there all day it's just so so vulnerable to that kind of way of playing but I really like the way that the game works it kind of moves along really quickly you start to kind of see opportunities that maybe other players don't trying to snap up those certain meatballs trying to get the majority in certain meeples trying to get those good gods that you want because they're going to give you points as well as abilities trying to clean those different tiles it just has all the kind of stuff that you you know really good fun mechanisms in that and not only like fun ones but like thinkI ones as well it's it's not like although like the game kind of feels like the choices are almost obviously what to make you've got to kind of be careful how you do them because as I said you kind of rewarding other players by doing certain different things but yeah I just enjoyed the way it ticked along it seems to kind of sort itself out at times and it and before long and you can't really make moves and that means the game's over so it kind of lasted a very very nice amount of time didn't our states welcome at all and you kind of get quite into it as well yeah so that the decisions are really nice in this one there's said it's not it's it's because you want to make it really I wouldn't because of that the the complexity of the game I wouldn't really overthink it as much as you possibly
could but yeah the balance is good even though some players might kind of just just have a no brain and move kind of little a denial plate for them the mechanisms are a bit different kind of food's very abstract time time investment is very good at only takes about an hour or so to play not even that which just feels just about right for this one as I said definitely doesn't out States welcome up time if you have players who aren't gonna just sit there and just you know look at the board over and over again trying to you know completely optimize their move then it's going to tick along just fine and you're not going to be sitting too long out the game but beware you probably will be you know having to wait a few minutes before your time but the player interaction is really good one bit I didn't like about it is these assassins I'm base if you lined up these red nepa which you can pick them up and then you can either kind of kill me pose on the board or you can kill people's in other players kind of like little collection of them like for majorities and so I don't like that kind of take that in the game I didn't kind of partake in that at all but I had it done whether I saw it done to other people and it just seems to rub them the wrong way I just didn't seem to fit in for me but other Matt absolutely fine I like the kind of race for the cards because some are rarer than others and you want to get them in your tableau as quick as possible because there's a big big endgame scoring for those set collection aspect all the different and all the different materials or merchandise I think it's called yes so uh visually I said it looks pretty
abstract but it does look completely Pleasant the box art as dust really nice the art of the genies or jinns are really really nice as well our component quality is absolutely up to scratch no complaints there at all and the theme is air pretty much tacked on and pretty much a theme this game but I like the kind of desert the kind of I don't know what it is as an Indian kind of theme to it but yeah I also actually pretty impressed with this game I didn't think I would be by the original kind of explanation I thought it was kind of seem a bit convoluted a bit fiddly too much going on but very quickly to wrap your head around it or something I really I really loved a lot again one of my favorite mechanisms and I'd love to see this mechanism in other games is the way you bid for turn order that is absolutely fantastic I love that you've got this little track of coins and you place your kind of marker on where you want to pick up that track on will see the higher or the more expensive spots like 12 13 coins whatever if you pace your place your your marker on that one you can have to pay that amount of coins but it means you're going to probably go first and get these kind of more opportunistic spots straight away whereas if you don't have pay anything you're going to kind of go last but you're saving your money which is ultimately your endgame points because there's kind of one currency in this game and it's all about the money the most money at the end of the game wins but yeah I like the way the different peoples work as I said I didn't like to take that on the assassin ones but every other one seemed absolutely fine and a very viable kind of approach to pay the game using you
know using your kind of visual skills to snap up those opportunities to try and get those get those unclaimed territories is very interesting I love the different god cards it was it was a game that I almost the more I played that the more I was enjoying it the more kind of you know the opportunities I saw and I kind of went home thinking about it and I rarely do that and that kind of makes me think that I really want to play it again so definitely a good game one I'm not gonna be picking it myself but I'm certainly looking forward to playing it again one owed I think a lot of people are gonna like I think you can kind of teach it as a gateway but it's going to be a bit of a struggle at first because of all the different rules on the meeples oh yeah okay keeping your the GM information in your head it's not that but it's not that high of a learning curve it does seem like it at first but once you're over it absolutely fine so yeah a solid solid game and I can certainly see why it is so kind of revered yeah probably one of the best Cathar the games I've played so yeah definitely a recommendation for me it's a good game so I hope you've enjoyed this review of five tribes if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for Evan else I will see you next time on chairman of the board bye