Skip to main content
Loading video...

Undergrove - Board Game Review - Badger Badger Mushroom Mushroom . . .

Transcript 19:05

hi everyone I'm Lor and this is the Bo me a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games but usually more the ranting part this is lwn overw I was made to give it a speed review last year but it just kind of got put on the backside in terms of priority and then the cruise and all that so this one's just a little bit late to the party I almost wanted to put it on that whole rest of 24 reviews list I did recently but I thought no this one deserves its own dedicated speed review this is undergrow and this one had a decent amount of hype when it came out for two main reasons the artist and the designer yes it's designed by Elizabeth Hargrave and Mark wuten I hope I pronounce that right and art by Beth soel now the name Elizabeth Hargrave you don't have to be that dedicated a board gamer to know Elizabeth Hargrave Elizabeth har gra is the same designer who did the phenomenally popular Wings man it is basically the equivalent of an evergreen game it's also one of my like probably my top 25 favorite games of all time I suppose that's a spoiler for the top 50 ah whatever but this you know and the same Artist as well so this was going to be visually pleasing even though it's about mushrooms and not birds I mean birds great and mushrooms I would say but it's just like o okay what else can this designer do if Wings ban was this popular this could be really good as well so a lot of people jumped on board for it but then I didn't really hear much about it like it sort of is is it come and gone already cuz it it released and I saw some review coverage of it but not a lot it's like okay is this a distribution thing or is it just come out and people played it and

they've gone huh that was okay then it's like interesting I'm uh kind of curious about this so I wanted to jump in myself and see whether this one is a solid game and it's all right or is it actually a forgettable one in underground the aim of the game is to have the most victory points go figure by the time somebody reaches the top of this carbon track at which point play the rest of the round and then one more and then game ends but your C of the game is that you are taking control of a tree and you are spreading your seedlings around this sort of shared table space represented by the starting tile and then introducing more mushrooms as time goes on all these different types of mushrooms of different categories but eventually you'll essentially have this board that will be expanded as the game goes on and your seedlings will populate these little slots in between the various mushrooms with from these seedlings you have roots that will extend and each route allows you to access the special ability and the scoring victory points of that particular mushroom now your seedlings can have a number of roots attached to them to score for different tiles but as soon as they get three or more they effectively upgrade to a little tree that you plug on and it says that you score pretty much everything that there is to know around it and it's like the strongest thing that you can have have so how do you facilitate all this well it's a resource management game of which you have potassium phosphorus and nitrogen which you will proceed to spend the rest of the game referring to as PK and N yeah trust me on this these resources allow you to do various actions like put another seedling on the board add more Roots you know move

carbon around the board which is represented by little black discs as you do various actions carbon will appear on the tiles that you can move around and absorb into your trees and all the you you absorb them into your seedlings in order to turn them eventually into trees but the actions are pretty straightforward you've just got five of them on your board and essentially you pay resources and carbon to do most of them one of them lets you generate more carbon One lets you activate these different mushroom towels on the board and these abilities are nothing particularly like crazy most of them are essentially some way of getting different quantities of you know different resources or they allow you to flip these uh tokens that are on your Ward which basically allow you to do various actions so it's all about action efficiency it's a puzzle you go through and you just constantly rinse and repeat these five actions and run all players until somebody hits the top of that track every time one of their seedlings absorbs carbon into itself in order to try and eventually make itself into a tree that's when you level up this track and so player the more players spend absorbing carbon the quicker the game timer will run you've got a few go cards as well to you know gain some extra victory points but most of your victory points are going to come from your from your roots sticking out of your trees and seedlings which will score VP represented by you know little pine cone symbols on the bottom of these tiles that's kind of the Crux of the game you carry on doing those actions keep making trees keep activating mushroom Powers

until eventually the game ends and try to have the most VP so in terms to the Aesthetics it's definitely a step down from something like wingspan but then that one's like a really good produced game this one though is no slouch and it's kind of a good mix of trying to be economically friendly while still also looking good compared to something like Daybreak for example which gave you that economic style packaging and everything and then looked really garish and kind of horrible really you know this one actually does a good job of being very NE in the Box I mean this has still got the original Shipping cardboard insert in there all the tuck boxes and tiles slot into there very neatly and tightly so you can jiggle this around your hearts contend and it won't like you know go you know mess up everywhere but in terms of the tiles these are cool I mean they've got the cutout slots for you know putting seedlings in between they're a decent you know card stock and they've got be soell lovely artwork on there to showcase the different mushrooms and there's enough artwork on these tiles you know it's not entirely covered by iconography you know in order to like oh hide the artwork now they do look pretty cool on the board sadly you do have to manage the resources though with Cubes but they're trying to keep the cost of this game down they're trying to make it more economically friendly so they've had to cut Corners in a few spots and it's like well it just turns out the resources was one of those things even that your personal tokens I mean you've got some wooden tokens uh and some basic little cardboard roots and a little tree that you put together with two bits of carboard I mean it's not the best like the most well produced game in the world

but for a game that's trying to cut corners on the like packaging to make it more eco-friendly I've seen far worse when it comes to how it looks I think a lot of that comes down to be sell's artwork though cuz I think if you had you know basic artwork on these tiles rather than somebody as good as Beth is then I think it would have like looked a bit on the table but you know when you've got all these tiles laid out and a bunch of trees are popping everywhere it does actually look relatively picturesque don't waste time doing too much with the whole Deluxe thing though I don't think you really need I can't remember there was like a deluxe version of this from the kickstarter not that desperate I think the retail box one is fine and those stupid stands that I've seen I mean my friend has this game and they and she kickstarted this game and they've got these like stands that are about this tall on the table and their literal purpose is just to hold your hand or three tiles if you are unable to have a hand of three tiles and sort of deal with these at any point then resign from board gaming immediately because the stands are ridiculous do you think maybe he's compensating for something rules wise pretty easy to learn this game actually I mean this rule book is quite thick in terms of its size but there's a good iconography guide on the back as well as like a you know decent written version of all the actions probably would have rather this was a reference card for each player but you know never never you mind although the graphic design on your board is pretty straightforward to understand what these

actions do without necessarily referring to the book but the book has a lot of pictorial examples a lot of you know you know pictures and not too much text for actually explaining the game that's got a decent amount going on so yes this is a little bit thicker than you would expect but it's not like it would take you long to read this and this is including solo rules as well we'll get on to those but what I particularly love in this game and I think more games should do this particularly heavy games this is probably quite light for a game that warrants this but heavy games you should take note these quick Sprout guides as they call them basically each player has one and it takes you through a unique four turn progression for your early game and then tells you what you should aim to do for your next turns but each one is asymmetric so you're pursuing a different strategy and they go through all the different type of actions and scenarios that you can possibly have these are brilliant if you are learning this for the first time including yourself I cannot recommend more highly that you use these to begin with because you'll all be different you you'll learn the rules it will guide you through them and it's an effective teaching tool but it's not a substitute for the rule book you are still going to need to teach some aspects of the rule book but if you're a little bit uneasy on teaching and you have just jumped into this for the first time these are great can you imagine if heavy games had these when you go do a demo at a game at Essen or something and the person has a

script that they follow don't you find that you just learn the game so much better by getting stuck in but following the script that explains how things work well this is effectively a script and it's great you will never need this after your first time doing it and if you've got a decent teacher and people that are kind of used to this sort of game you might not need these at all but having them in there as an option I I can't like praise this enough I think more games need to do this particularly those with a lot of options I mean setti Civ olution um possibly even black Forester is a good example you know even Arc Nova from like earlier years can you imagine those games that give you a wealth of options it would they be a lot better if they had some quick start guides for new players I think it'd be pretty cool so mechanically is the game fun that's a little bit more hit and miss the it's very much a puzzle there's not a lot of luck in this game at all really I mean you can see what tiles are out you know yes the other tiles that you draw will be from a face down stack but you know these tiles are mostly the same kind of thing they're mostly about flipping tiles sorry flipping tokens getting resour ources of certain types or you know doing some ability like absorbing carbon faster that kind of thing but you know you can't Bank your whole strategy on fighting a specific tile that's just not going to work so that doesn't really play into it from a luck perspective but everything else you do in the game from your you know your resource management or what these actions do and everything there's no luck it's literally a puzzle but players can still get in your way because there

is an element of interaction here it's a shared table space so people are fighting for spots in terms of seedlings people are sticking out their roots to access mushrooms that also you can access and because these black carbon discs are basically being littered all over the board but they're absorbed by every particular seedling that's there you may have a bunch of carbon in one area that gets absorbed by another player before you get a chance to do it yourself other than that though you can't really do much with your boards and you know the boards are all the same I mean there's no asymmetrical uh boards in this you know they're all the same so there's not a huge amount of variation in the game and I suppose that is kind of one of its main issues that the you know the variety isn't really there cuz yes you have got all these different tiles but they don't do drastically different things from each other they're just more variations of the same kind of thing and you know there isn't really anything else to sort of go oh yeah this dramatically changed how this game played out it's like no they're going to play out in kind of roughly the same manner now as I said this is a big puzzle and if you are just into a straight up puzzle game then you're going to get some decent enjoyment out of this and so did I you know to up to a certain point you do have to really micromanage this well because you can easily get put into a situation where you just don't have the resources to do anything and the tempo hit you take to get the stuff back is you know kind of a kind of a downer a little bit on the dull side but you got to do it in order to get back in the game but if somebody else is doing quite well then well that's a few turns that you've wasted

that they didn't have to you know this is definitely one of those games that you can kind of get good if you like that phrase because with the limited amount of luck involved you can be you know a decent player at this game like being able to manipulate this puzzle without writing yourself into a corner but this also creates a little bit of a problem I have with the game that it feels like you've got to jump through a lot of Hoops without too much of a fulfilling reward you play you know no no turn in this game feels like oh yeah that was an awesome turn like oh proud of that turn that felt good I got a lot of stuff done on that turn no all the turns kind of play out at the same rate but you still have to jump through a lot of Hoops to get the resources and the tokens flipped and everything and even the carbon at times to actually do those bare minimum actions compare it to a few other games with these sort of themes okay well let's take Earth for example you could play a turn in Earth you do the blue action and then all these cards in front of you trigger and you get to do loads of different things that feels fulfilling in Arc NOA you can play a card which then allows you to flip a card which then allow you to gain this which allows you to activate this bonus you know there's a lot of stuff that can chain off and those turns feel fulfilling even wingspan you play these birds out and individually on their own they might not necessarily be amazing apart from some play abilities but then you activate the row for eggs and then you generate a bunch of eggs and then you can generate this bird's power this bird's power this bird's power and all this cool stuff happens all of those examples feel like satisfying turns that

never arises in undergrow though your best turn in this game game May literally be just to do what your basic action on the board is which is to put a Seedling out with a root you know there's no right I've done this which then Changs into this bonus which then Changs into this bonus you know nothing chains in this game it's all just little actions but none of the actions on your board feel like those big turns because these are the basic things that you're doing and they're all just basic stuff like activate a mushroom power or put a seed thing out or put some extra Roots out or get carbon that's kind of how they roll but you could still be in a situation where like all I want to do is put out two Roots well I need two potassium and a carbon well I ain't got any potassium I barely got any carbon right where do I get potassium from well I've got to activate a mushroom over there well I haven't got enough carbon to do that particular action I know where do I get carbon in well I guess I'll photo synthesize right let me do that first then I can do that mushroom thing then I can do this just so I can put two Roots out it's a lot of Hoops now the better you get at this game the less you Hoops you have to jump through but again it still has that feeling of you know I'm doing a lot of work for not as big a reward as I would like to have for the amount of work I'm doing for it you do get a solo mode in the game though which is actually not a bad solo mode you effectively play against two different AI opponents and they ignore half the rules and they use a deck of cards in here which basically just has different rows for different actions that they can do takes a little bit to get used to the iconography on these things but once you've got that done

it's actually a very easy AI to Pilot and it does allow to have a good satisfying puzzle for a solo experience what it does however do is UPS the chaos factor of the game because players you can kind of see what they're doing you know what they're limited on you know what they can and can't do the AI however doesn't care about a lot of that stuff I mean you'll flip a card and it will just say absorb carbon from the most right what the leftmost mushroom of yellow type or something and it's like ah I just sucked up all the carbon on that mushroom that I was just about to use well you can't stop the a doing that the card just flipped that said that so you do have to accept the solo mode as a bit more chaotic but if you're willing to deal with that solo Mode's actually pretty decent you know you can get a decent puzzle experience from this without losing anything really from the multiplayer game because you play in pretty much exactly the same manner and in some respects you can even kind of game the AI to an extent because you get more rewards if the AI can't do the actions on their cards you have no way of predicting when they're going to do these actions but the more that you limit stuff for them to do on the board particularly in the case of you know leaving too much carbon out on the board the more you might be able to benefit without even realizing it so that can be quite fulfilling as well so undergrow is overall a decent game but the two main issues I have with it is that it doesn't feel you don't feel like you've got very satisfying turns you know you don't you got to jump through a lot of Hoops in order to do every little thing in this game and that you know that does dull

your experience a bit unless you're into really tight puzzles the variation is also a bit lacking here because you don't have any asymmetric board the gold cards don't really change up that much and the abilities on these tiles yes they're all unique but aside from a few that have ongoing abilities which there's not a huge amount of them in there they just variations are the same this one's a decent puzzle but just not quite up there with the rest of them this one you know is still decent though I'd give it a six out of 10 overall above average half decent pretty decent you know it's got its merits but I think the problems I have with it do take it down a bit you know you we'll play this a bunch of times and maybe it'll get a little bit syy after a while but the fact that the turns don't feel as fulfilling as I would like just doesn't give me a sense of excitement with the game you know you you'll have an enjoyable fulfilling puzzle but you'll never feel yes or excited or get that buzz you'll never get that buzz with this game it just can't really happen there's no bees in the game so that's probably one reason reason but still it just I don't know it lacks that little bit of a push you know to boost it into endorsement rating but it's still fine and I think they're still going to be some fans of this but it's kind of come and gone I really haven't heard much much anybody else talk about it so maybe that's a sign who knows so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the page and consider subscribing because your views and engagement are what keep this channel going I've got a patreon going as well if you want to donate a little bit of cash just to help this channel

afford it fees and subscriptions and again keep going cuz it is not my day job but also let me know your thoughts about this game do are you a big lover of this game or you a big hater or somewhere in the middle be interested to read your thoughts and debate as necessary so until next time remember regardless of what is your favorite mushroom whether it's a uh black Elfin sadle or surprise Web Camp or peppery bullet I don't know a lot about mushrooms I just like eating them it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved