Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:51

Most games are not Ticket to Ride, Carcasson, or Katon. Games that have been in print continuously since their debuts, respectively, 21, 25, and 30 years ago as of this recording. Most games have a brief time on the market, and then they're gone. Maybe never to be seen again except at a flea market or in a box in someone's garage. But [snorts] publishers always looking for something new. And by new, sometimes they mean old. They look at a design and think it's ideal for today's market. And so they will license it, often give it a new look, a new title, and present it as a new game because for most people it is a new game. They have not seen every game that's come out over the past 10, 20, or 30 years. So they'll look at something like Waddle, a game released by All Play in mid 2025, and say, "Huh, I wonder what this penguin game is all about." And then other people looking at the game play say, "Wait, I remember that design. That was Gypsy King, a game that came out in 2007 from Dutch designer Cornet von Morcel, who released it through his own brand, Quali. That game came out, I played it number of times in 2007, few times in the years after that, and then kind of forgot about it. Even though I really like the design, just more games keep coming and you forget to go back to things that you like. Just how it works sometimes. But Waddle now

gives me an excuse to talk about this fine design because it's on the market again as a [clears throat] new game. Whereas before you were trying to place gypsy caravans around lakes in a forest, you are now placing penguins around fishing holes on the ice. So, it's the same, but not quite the same. They made some changes to the gameplay here. Let me show you how this works. To set up Waddle, place the ice tiles on the table and push them together into a continuous sheet. The tiles are numbered from 1 to 20. You adjust the number of tiles you use depending on the player count. Then, you just push them all together and place this identifier ring around the number one fishing pool. You randomly determine player order and place the marbles in the track. And now your players are going to take turns placing penguins around the active fishing pool or jumping ahead to the next one, the number two fishing pool in this case. So orange is going to take a penguin and place it on one of the empty spaces around the number one fishing pool. And then green will do the same. Purple goes here. they can place here, but maybe they don't like the looks of that and they say, "I want to be first at the next pool. I'm happy to jump aside."

Maybe red does the same. And yellow says, "Whatever. I will go ahead and take that." They go to the back of the line. All the spots around one are filled. You move this over to number two. Move this to show the active track. And all of these players stay in the same order and go to the back of the line. Now, each player has two double penguins, and you can place one of those twice, and then that's it. So, purple goes to the back of the line, red over here, maybe orange [snorts] goes here, and green doesn't want this spot. Maybe they want first shot at number three. And so, they jump over here. And maybe everyone jumps over here. Whoever is last must fill the remaining spaces with their penguins. So, they get a free placement.

Orange was at the back of the line just went. They get another placement, but it's not a super valuable space, at least as everyone else is judging it. Number two is filled. And now we go to number three. And this shows one of the things that we are trying to score because some of the fishing pools have fish in them that are worth a certain number of points. And you score those points by having the majority of penguins around that fishing pool or the combined fishing pool in this case. So the number one has no fish next to it, but you can place next to the one and now you're placing next to the nine which has a fish of value five. Similarly, this one has four. This is nothing. So maybe that's not attractive to go there. The purple player jumps ahead to two and takes the only space that is next to this fishing pool which has a seven value fish and they place their double penguin because they want a head start to getting the majority of penguins around this space. That is one way that you score and ties are friendly. So if people tie for a majority of penguins around this fishing pool, they will each score those seven points. If there's two fish in a pool, whoever has the most or is tied for the most will get the larger number, eight.

And second or tied for second gets the other number, six. And third gets nothing. Okay, so green may jump ahead because this has a five and a one. Fish has a two right here. And they're happy to drop their penguin. And now they're next to both of these pools. In addition to placing penguins to try to score for the pools, you are also trying to create valuable waddles. And waddles, well, it's the name of a group of penguins that's on land, right? If the group of penguins is in the water, it's a raft. If it's just both all around, it's a colony. But here, it's a waddle because we're on icy land.

And a waddle is any group of penguins together. This is a group of penguins. It's only one penguin. It's worth one point. One point. One point. One point. One point. This is two penguins, which is worth three points. So the game uses triangular scoring. Every additional penguin that goes down is worth as many points as the number of penguins now in the group. So that was one point, this is two points, that's three points. So six total, 10 total, 15 total, and so on. So, in addition to scoring the fishing pools, you are trying to create waddles. And both of those ways to score are reasons for you to jump ahead and not just take your turn like normal. So, three is filled. We go to four. Red is up. Looking here what they want to do. There's two fishing pools, right?

So, maybe they go there. Orange goes here because they get those two fishing pools as well. Green goes here and hopes to maybe connect. Yellow does connect. Okay, go to the back. Purple comes up isolated here. Maybe they want to go here. Maybe they want to jump ahead to five. But five, well, you get first shot at these right here. And then red goes. And now you start having choices. Well, I probably want to cut off the orange. I can't connect with the red around the four. You go here. Orange is like I want to go first on five. If red if green jumps ahead, that lets yellow make a bigger waddle. But what value is it of green? Well, if green goes here, then they tie for a majority around this fishing pool and they'll be sitting at the back for a little while. Four is done. We go to five and purple goes out here. Often when you're placing, you're trying to leave yourself options for where to play in the future.

Purple could go here, but now it has only one other spot around the five. But now it's got two. It's got another opening out here. Orange can go connect. Yellow cut people off. Right. Do you want to be jerks? Do you want to score for yourself? Well, often it depends on the player count. Two-player game extremely jerky because every point you can take away from your opponent is essentially a point for you. Five is done. Go to six, which is right here. And again, green might want to try to connect. Okay, so we continue as follows. You see how this works? All it is is placing a penguin or jumping ahead. It's extremely straightforward. It's a minimalist Euro style game. You've got two choices and you just do that for the whole game. And then at the end of the game, you are going to score points based on majority around the fishing pools based on the size of your waddle up to 28 uh sorry, 36 points for a group of eight. In a two-player game, you will score up to a group of 10.

Use this little whiteboard to track your score. And that's it. You are done. Now, very simple, straightforward. The difference between Waddle and Gypsy King is that you in Gypsy King would play from one up to whatever the highest number is, which will vary depending on player count. You score, you remove everything, and then you play again starting from the highest number and going down, which reverses some of the incentives. You're going to play differently starting from 20 than you would from one because as you're playing certain numbers, you're setting up potential places for the future. Green is looking ahead and wants to connect at 10. So, as we start going to eight and nine, green may decide I just want to jump out of here so that I can connect here. And now I've got a group of four, which is worth 10 points. And this would have been filled by someone.

And this would have been filled. Actually, these all would have been filled with the six. So, they have to say I score for 10. I go to the back of the line. Maybe I get to do 12 as well. If I jump ahead and do 12, this spot will be filled by someone, but 20 is still open. And maybe I can jump ahead and score again. So, you're judging whether to jump ahead or not. But then when you play in reverse order, you're going to start [snorts] from 20. So these spots will all be filled first and then you're going to 19. And now you already have someone seated at the five hole. You've got this one out here for five or two trying to connect. So now you have reverse incentives for where you're jumping at which times.

And interestingly, as you play, often spaces will get filled completely. So, this 18 here is going to have all five of these spaces around it filled. By the time you actually get to 18, there's only one spot left. Orange wants it, red wants it, purple wants it, and maybe the other colors are looking ahead to 19. Try to get the majority here. So, the board fills up in different ways every single time you play due to the random layout of the tiles. Many games always advertise modularity and we set up the board in different ways and this has a very organic feel to how the modularity works because the tiles are relatively small and you just put them together without thinking about it and then you start looking and seeing where are the possibilities to play where one two three four five how am I going to play and try to fit together waddles while also trying to get the valuable fishing pools.

Very straightforward play, but highly engaging no matter the player count. I played Waddle five times on a review copy from AllPlay, three times with four players, and twice with three. I've also played Gypsy King at all player accounts. So, I'm merging that experience into talking about Waddle because the gameplay is the same aside from the twoact structure of Gypsy King. And the gameplay is incredibly engaging at all player counts, but you definitely change tactics in how you're doing things because with four and five players on the board, you're placing many fewer penguins. And so you have a tendency to be willing to jump ahead more to ensure you get the spot you want. You might be at whole 12 and you're like, "Nope, I'm going to hold off to 13." And then you get to 13, you're like, "Nope, I'm going to 14."

Because that was your actual target, not 13. you just really wanted that one to connect two smaller waddles into a large one or to grab some fishing pool and you wanted to ensure yourself that you would be able to do that. So you can hold your spot in line as you keep jumping. But of course with every jump, you're not placing out a penguin. So you have to judge if I place on 12, how many people are cycling through? And will I get the shot at 14 that I want? And of course, someone else could jump ahead to 14 and take the thing that you desperately need. So, all depends upon desire of the players because there's no randomness in the game at all. You see everything out there. And if you want to guarantee yourself a spot, you can do that, but it may cost you a lot by jumping ahead many times. something you can't do as much in a game with three players and especially with two players because when you jump ahead, every spot around the current fishing pool is filled in by whoever is the last player in the track. In a two-player game, you jumping ahead means the other player gets to fill every space around that pool, which immediately is often giving them a waddle with two or three penguins together or gypsy caravans if you're playing the original game. So, you have to change a lot. Where's the point where you're willing to jump ahead and give up something? How valuable is it to you?

And you could calculate everything. Here's the current score for each player and here's how I'm going to, you know, get advantage because they're going to get three points, I'll get four points, this, that, and the other. And I imagine some people play that way. And I play much more intuitively where I am not keeping track of anyone's score, but just individually, what's that waddle scoring for me? What's that one? Who's getting that pool? What are the chances that I can get into that pool as well? You have only the two double penguins to manage. So, everyone is thinking about that constantly. Who has what available? Where is the majority? How can I snag it from someone else by going in after them? Or will that space be filled and I won't even get the chance? It's a very quick playing game. Just incredible how simple this design is, how intuitive it is, at least intuitive for what you're doing, but not how to play well because what are the right times to jump ahead?

You sometimes get an issue with lots of players where clearly there's a good move for this particular player and it's terrible for everyone else. who's going to bite the bullet and occupy that space so they don't connect those waddles or someone doesn't get that pool. Maybe someone will do it, maybe not because people say, "Not my job. I'm just going to jump ahead to the next pool and leave it for someone else and they and someone else goes and someone else goes and then one player gets a giant group." So there is that dynamic that some people might not like where you feel obligated to stop someone or you just look out for yourself or you play with two players which is awesome because then it's just you and one other person and you don't have that dynamic.

Three players you still have it but not much because you know it's only you or the other guy. So, you hope someone else is going to jump ahead and maybe you're coming here and you're going to end up getting everything that's left over because the other player doesn't want to go in this terrible spot or a terrible two spots around the perimeter of the area. There's lots to think about every game that I play. And it's it's weird because it's not a memorable game in terms of remembering particular moves because every move is just place a penguin, plays two penguins. You don't have this story of the game in terms of different types of actions or experiences or something you're something you're building towards, but it's more this continuous flow of placement, little battles all over. Can I connect that? Can I connect that? Can I get the majority? What am I doing here? There's little bits here and there. And then you add it all up. And one advantage that one player was talking about, of course, this is a very tiny box. Waddle originally appeared in a box uh size of the that's life, not quite as thick, but it was originally this size with much larger tiles. You had these chunky wooden caravans and um just larger everything. And now you've got this little tiny thing. So that's kind of the style, right?

did a video before for Big Shot. Came out 2001 and then the Korean [snorts] version comes out and it's one quarter the size of this older game. It's amazing how we do that. All these older games now getting reborn as tiny little things. Now, one issue I have with Waddle, the only complaint I have about Waddle is not about the game design, but about the graphic design. Let me show you. You might have already noticed this when I was explaining how to play, but the numbers on the fishing pools are not easy to make out. And the numbers on the fish themselves are even harder to read on the table. This is a one and this is a seven. And this has the bar across it and the European style for writing a seven. Yet on the table, I find these two almost indistinguishable.

So that's a problem because you definitely want to fight for the seven. You don't care as much for the one and you want to know where are valuable spaces to be competing over when you are deciding where to go and when to jump ahead. That's been a problem in a couple of the games that I have played and that's not good. So, I'm need to label these better or possibly just go back to Gypsy King and pull that out of the closet and play that instead in order to be sure that everyone knows where the next links are, where the the valuable spaces are to compete over. The Laurel Laurel is a big miss as well with the type of type face because I also looked at this at one point and confused it with the four because this part of the laurel loops around just like this part of the four. So thought it was four. Oh, look again. Oh. Oh, that's actually one. Okay. Type face is not ideal choice here because you have tiles that are going to go in every orientation on the table and so that you want the numbers to be legible no matter how they're arranged. Game would really benefit from the dyslexic style font that's heavier on the bottom so that even if you're looking at something that's turned around you can visually see where the bottom is by having the wider base on the numbers.

have this be a lot larger or I don't know just fill in with a larger type face maybe a bold type face so it's a thicker number and you could read that color more easily in the space. That's the only miss for me in this design is the actual graphic design here which makes the game more difficult to play. Maybe the solution is to take a marker and just write the fish values more clearly on each of the tiles. Not sure exactly what the solution is, but I need to do something so that the game is more immediately accessible to everyone learning it for the first time and for people who are playing again like me who can't read the tiles no matter how many times I've played. That's the only downfall with Waddle.

Progress saved