Nucleum Review: I HAVE THE POWER!
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tal this is farl and we are bard of it and Welcome to our review of nucleum which is for one to four players and is set in an alternate history where nuclear power was discovered in 19th century Saxony the players take on the role of industrialists looking to create rail networks and energy infrastructure in order to generate and Supply power to the population so nucleum is the hot new Euro diing of the moment at time of writing and this is because there's been a lot of comparisons between it and Brass Birmingham and barrage now these are both games that get people excited including us since you'll find both those games in both of our top 10 games of all time now it's got elements of them so it's got the network building and tile flipping from brass it's got the energy infrastructure and production from barrage but it's also got a few tricks of its own with a devilishly delightful action selection system
system nucleum is played Without rounds so players will take it in turns until the end of the game is triggered on your turn you can do one of three actions the first is to play an action tile to your player board with each action tile having two action on it which can be taken in any order you can also fill a contract the second available action is to lay new Railway here you'll take one of your action tiles and place it onto the main board in an empty rail space and if the ends of that action tile match the adjacent cities or other railway tiles already on the board you also get to take those actions the third available action is to take a recharge and here you'll gain income put yourself in for endgame scoring and then take all of the action tiles back that you had played to your player board importantly there is a concept of your network which consists of your built buildings and your rail tiles now you can build buildings with the action urbanize and that means you have to place those buildings within your existing network but Rail Link tiles can be built anywhere meaning you can use them to create new networks the industrialized action also has Network restrictions as this allows you to place turbines and mines on the board but again they have to be built within your existing Network other important actions include develop which allows you to take new action tiles contracts which allows you to take contracts and finally energize arguably the most important action energize can
be considered the accumulation of all of the other actions as it's what allows you to produce energy which allows you to flip building tiles to get VP and also get achievement tokens to put yourself up for endgame scoring the power plant result sources and building you choose for your energize action all have to be connected by rail you'll then attempt to produce as much energy as the building requires and to produce energy you're going to be using up coal and uranium although uranium can only be used if you choose a nuclear power plant represented by this nucleum token you may also get some free energy from your player board and your action tile flipped buildings will get you endgame VP and also get you achievement tokens which are traded in during the recharge phase so that you can put tokens on a milestone board so in essence you're trying to build up infrastructure and a network so that you can transport resources and produce energy ending the game with flipped energized buildings and tokens high up on the Milestone board first thing we should probably tackle is the question since this game keeps being brought up in the same breath as brass and barage is it better than either of them now in our opinion we would say no and for two main reasons the first reason is that both brass and barrage are games with you could say a singular Focus that they hone to Perfection whereas here things are a little bit more shallow a little bit less focused just because it takes a bit of this and a bit of that so each of
those systems is a little bit thinner and the second reason and I can't believe it's us saying this cuz generally we're not that interested in art and how it affects the game is the art it's so dated and unappealing nucleum and I can tell you that brass and barrage would not have been as popular if they didn't have the Stellar art that they do have and if they instead had nucleum art you know art can elevate a theme which then in turn will Elevate the experience of gameplay and in nucleum it's it's somewhat detracting from it now let's leave all mention of brass and barrage behind and turn solely to nucleum the good reason too as this is a brilliant board game one of the very best we've played this year it hits all of the right notes there's terrific action selection system Network building bigger and bigger turns as the game goes on there's a really wonderful flow to nucleum the actions are pretty straightforward with perhaps the exception of energize taking a little bit more time so the turns bounce back and forth at a rapid Pace because there are no rounds the flow also never stops so it feels like you're moving towards the finish at Brak neck speed there's also a really nice sense of improvement as the longer the game go go on the more you'll be able to do each time you take a recharge action you're going to get more and more income so you can afford more expensive buildings turbines and mines your network will get more extensive you'll be able to afford more coal you'll have more uranium and also
more bonuses all of which make nucleum a really fulfilling game dual use of the action tiles as actions and railings is a particularly cool idea firstly it gives players agency and how they want to play as they can curate the pool of actions available to them and very often improve the actions they have in a small Way by buying new tiles secondly the fact that there are also rail links is Devious because to build links you have to lose the action tiles it's a real fine balance of placing links ahead of other players to create important networks and not reducing your pool of actions to a point where you struggle to do what you need and this makes for a particularly engaging challenge thirdly allowing players to do an action if they correctly color match their tiles to the adjacent City or other tiles is outstanding design and brings a whole new twist to gameplay in other similar games generally placing a link or rout is the most boring action in the game but here if you plan well you'll not only get to grow your network but also get a full turn on top it also means that it's rare players have a nothing turn where not much really happens and it's also a really great feeling to combo off your rail placement and build in the city that you just added to your network we also really like how players can build a Rail Link anywhere giving everyone equal opportunity to get where they need to go in general what we love about nucleum is the fact that it gives players a bunch
of toys and says have at it in this big sandbox because there's no restrictions in which order you build your buildings or infrastructure leading to a sense of freedom and living in the moment it also leads to really interesting game States because a player could arguably build their most expensive mine and their most expensive turbine unlocking a level three technology early in the game and there's a risk reward here but it also gives them a massive Boon to gameplay for the rest of the game on top of that you could build a level four building as your first building and then build out from that and attempt to maximize the scoring of that building just touching on the Technologies which we haven't really mentioned each player has a semi-unique technology board there are eight Technologies across three levels and you mostly get access to them through completing contracts there's a nice mix of instant and ongoing which gives players a tough decision each time they choose it also provides a bit of inter-player variability particularly as their more powerful level three Technologies are completely unique necessitating a unique approach the one minor problem we have with nucleon is the achievement system so when you take recharge you spend your achievement tokens to get a star up on the Milestone board now you can't put a star in a tier where you've already put a star and it's one of those rules that board games sometimes have where it just seems like it's there just because I can't see a good reason or thematic reason and it
actually becomes a bit annoying because say you do well and you get into a good tier and then next time you do even better but you're still kind of stuck within the barrier of that same tier then you can't go there again you have to drop down and go to a lower one which means you're getting less points and it's just very weird this is the case considering that first of all you can't block spaces from other players so it's not that you could just take over a whole tier you can score twice for the same Milestone scoring because some of the tiers back onto the same uh Milestone scoring so you can kind of double up your points that way and the fact that you know they're available from the start everyone has the same opportunity to get onto the Milestone track and it's very weird that it just is kind of hurting players for doing really well multiple times by making them get lower and lower points it's just it's just I would have preferred that anyone could really go anywhere it seems an arbitrary restriction to us one more comment to make which isn't necessarily equival just a consideration is I'm not convinced about the longevity of nucleum at two players because because nucleum is a game where when you first play your first two three games you're going to struggle you're going to be caught short you're never going to have enough resources and you're going to get caught in bad situations but eventually you're going to crack it you're going to know how to manipulate the systems and you probably then won't be too caught out essentially and you kind of you get
cooking things are comboing and you get a lot of points now the two-player map is actually very spacious and generous the two players which ends up meaning you don't really have to consider the other player and it's kind of more of a solo game against yourself and once you've cracked nucleum you're just comboing comboing comboing and bouncing off each other and it can feel like you've solved the game whereas at four players you consistently have to think about what the other players are doing because from your turn to your next turn an entire city could be blocked off and you can't do anything about that so it's not to say that it's not still brilliant at two it's extremely enjoyable it's just that this is a game that if you said let's play it at four players I would always get it out whereas after a certain amount of plays at two I'd probably get it out occasionally As a treat but I wouldn't want to play it too much because it it it would get a little bit boring and style once you've kind of done nucleum if that makes sense so final thoughts nucleum is a downright brilliant game on one of our highlights of this year thus far if you love Euros then you're going to love this and there's so much that it does right and so much that it does cleverly there are a few minor gripes but we cannot recommend nucleum enough so that was our review of nucleum thank you for watching if it was helpful Please Subscribe it really helps grow
the channel and of course if you have any questions please ask us but thanks for watching and see you next time bye