Skip to main content
Loading video...

Obsession - Board Game Review - Oh Mr Fairchild, You're Spoiling Us!

Transcript 26:07

perhaps I didn't make myself

clear hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meol this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews to 10 and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kendra. Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today wow by popular demand am I doing Obsession because everybody's been asking me about this fans of the game people who haven't played the game people who are on my patreon list it's like you name it people want me to review this game and and this was before I even got hold of the game they were asking oh Luke are you going to look at this one I like well I haven't got the game I never really get a chance to play it except I have a couple of friends who own the game and I've played it with them and I had some thoughts but then it finally came back with a second addition it came back on retail and I thought you know what let's get the entire lot Upstairs Downstairs wesex Obsession get the whole lot and jump into it properly play some group games play it solo and give it a full review and blim me um I might want to put my defenses up at this

point the people who want me to review this are waiting on tender hooks with pitchforks at the ready just waiting for me to give this game anything less than a 10 out of 10 and then we'll hunt me down it's there's a lot of Obsessed fans for Obsession go figure and hopefully that joke's not going to be a repeat this video but yeah it's got its fan base and this is what is class is a one of the biggest sleeper hits ever it came out at first and barely anybody talked about it but there was a few little voices saying oh this game's really really good but it's like barely even heard of it it was a Indie Kickstarter it's a you know just one game caner games it's just like this is it this is it it's pretty much a self-made Kickstarter kind of like a uh you know almost like a dream project for them and nobody really cared and then all of a sudden in recent years people w't stop talking about this game and suddenly it's in the top 100 on Board Game Geek and you know topping a lot of people's charts it's just like what happened when did this suddenly become like the new hit considering it came out two to three years ago so I had to to try it played a couple of games before I owned it and had some thoughts but then I thought right get into it give it the beans and see what it is question is has it met expectations or is this one of these overrated titles that people should really stop Obsession about you are the head of a respected but troubled Family Estate in mid 19th century Victorian England after several lean decades family fortunes are looking up your goal is to approve your estate

so as to be in better standing with the truly influential families in darbishire obsession is a game of 16 to 20 turns in which players build a deck of Victorian Gentry British social upper class people effectively renovate their estate by acquiring a building Tils from a centralized Builders market and manipulate an extensive service staff of butlers housekeepers under Butlers Maids valet and footmen you name it that's there utilizing a novel worker placement mechanic players will host various events during the game which they must carefully plan to have the proper staff AA able to surface the event and support guests as needed the reward for success is new investment opportunities permitting further renovation of the estate and increasing reputation and an expanding circle of influential acquaintances and new guests throughout the game a competitive courtship for the hand of the most eligible young gentleman and lady in the county presents specific renovation and reputation objectives the player who best meets these objectives while accumulating victory points will win the hand of the wealthy love interest and of course the game of course When comparing this to other games the best way I can go about it is more to do with its theme rather than its mechanics because it borrows a little bit of deck building well we've seen that before we borrow a little bit of worker placement with some different types of workers okay cool we've seen that but it's more the theme and feel of this like the setting and what kind of mood it puts you in so games I would compare this two of things like last will last will has you in a similar kind of setting except rather than trying to gain money or trying to squander it you're trying to

throw yourself all these various you know G gather all this type of wealth and go on balls and activities and squander all your money but it's set around this kind of Time games like the legacy of Duke Dei has a similar deal where you're trying to build a prestigious family tree and you're trying to marry off to the right families and such and here you have the courtship with the best lady and gentleman in the region and so everybody is trying to make themselves more desirable in order to gain favor with those two during each round and so there's a similar feel with that and if you want to advance a little bit on last will the prodal club again in that similar kind of vein that similar time period where it's this 19th century Posh English type setting and that's kind of more where I would go for comparing this because we could name a 100 deck builders we could name a 100 worker placement games you know even everdale could technically fit I mean you're building a tableau of stuff in front of you and it gets more powerful over time but then ell doesn't have uh you know the workers to put on the things themselves so you could compare this mechanically to a lot of stuff it's not that there's uh it's not that it's not original it's just it's borrowing a few little mechanics and creating its own them which is quite cool but theme wise yeah those games I've mentioned I think are going to put you in that kind of mindset so let's get the most obvious thing that's done well here and that is the theme the theme is wonderfully represented here however don't get me wrong I hate hate this setting oh my

dear dear Lydia she will be married be quiet shut up victoriia in England is one of the worst settings I have to learn about or have any dealings with because I have spent enough history lessons in the past learning about readyy victorians I had to watch The Pride and Prejudice 6-hour serial and read the book in English literature lesson back at school and the m of the phrase downt Abby is enough to send me into a fury okay I have PTSD from my English lessons with this rotten Pride and Prejudice book and the stupid honestly the theme I couldn't care less about but here's the thing I actually like it here what so what the hell am I on here what I'm saying is that a the theme is very strong everything from the way the game looks the Artistry the glossery all this detail and like effort that's gone in here you can see it on every page that this isn't just simply taking a setting and bolting it on no thought was put into this the idea you're trying to caught a lady and the gentleman who are the most desirable completely fits all the events you're doing Billiards and a little picnic in the Gazebo and having the Butlers and valet and all that and foot men everything in this game screams out this settings theme so why am I praising it this much when I hate this setting well because you can play this in two ways you can either get into this theme because you're an absolute downt naby fan and you've read Pride and Prejudice 100 times without vomiting but

the idea with my way of doing this is that you can play this and kind of have fun with it ham it up take the mick treat it as a bit of a parody it's the difference between the player who you know loves Pride and Prejudice and has the book and would dress up in this sort of costume if they had to at a murder mystery tea party or something and would have a whale of a Time versus me whose favorite undertaking of anything related to Pride and Prejudice is the sequence in R dwarf where kryon goes around assassinating all the characters because they skipped out on his lobster dinner that sequence in Red Dwarf will go down as one of my favorites because it just speaks to me on so many levels I love it no robots got PMT but that's the thing I don't know that many people who are massive Pride and Prejudice fans and watch down to Abby all the time but we can just have a laugh you know the fact that I'm holding Billiards or playing balls or doing some you know having another ball ball and that but you can take the mick you can ham it up you can just sort of treat it as a parody and it works great in that setting as well so even someone like me who some of you out there are probably wanting to stab me with pitchforks at this point because I'm ragging on The Pride and Prejudice set you know history side of things can still have fun with this game and I thought it was going to chase me away like crazy but you know what if I just go in with that happy gol lucky take the know little have fun with it Hammer up mindset it actually works really well well and I can't deny that the theme is just screaming off this game component quality follows on from that front I

mean wow this was a Kickstarter yes I've seen Kickstarter projects all over the shop from various different Publishers and most of them from people who do this on a regular basis can't get stuff that looks as good as this this stuff is really really good and you can buy this game I think for like around the 50 Mark I think it was like 50 something pound you buy this for on retail that's insane that's insanely good value for what you get I mean it may not look like much but you have got big funky cardboard Tils you have got a glossery book you've got a pretty sizable rule book score pads you've got you know a fold away you know board with one of the most beautiful picturesque paintings I've seen of the derisha countryside that is gorgeous you know you've got the the round tracker which is probably the best looking round tracker I've seen in any game you've got these boxes your player pieces are held in these little authentic tuck boxes with all the details that you normally see on like you know the on these buildings you know in this time and here you can have all your room tiles you've got different size and color meeples there isn't really a bad component in this game other than the fact that the first edition came with really chintzy little cards and they were a bit of annoyances but this is the second edition of the game so in this copy they gave you larger versions to use thankfully that is a good thing and honestly I can't really fult a component you know even a giant bag for all the tiles oh yeah what tiles oh these tiles

I mean I've got you know big bags of stuff here but then you've got all these chunky tiles with not a lot of artwork on the tiles but it's clear and easy to read what's necessary and there's pictures on some of them but for the most part these are kind of generic but in terms of their look but it's functional and it fits the setting and the theme honestly wow when I play some games and I see component choices where I mean remember the Skyrim review I did before that retails for £125 this game completely creams Skyrim in terms of its component quality and it's available for less than half of that price it can be done Publishers just put some effort into it everybody got that the game play overall is good fun I like the the different tiles that you can activate you've got a selection of them at the start of the game and you only pick one and you've got to go Through the Motions but you acquire better tiles you can buy what it is you fancy you could focus on different colors or focus on all the one and just be really good at it and then I really enjoy for the most part the deck building element with these cards so with the expansion thrown in I've got a bunch of these Gentry cards in here they all look cool they've got real photos effectively used from this Sera which is really cool and it's kind of like a mini deck building element where you gain more guests and create a hand of cards I hate to say it in some similar veins to Concordia but yes where you build up a hand of cards and you play them and then you have to basically spend the rest

turn to get them back once they're done but the card system in this is really cool I like building up a little mini deck of all these guests and I like sort of taking a mick out of the types of guests I've got especially when they've got lots of different little rewards like some will give you a little reward and not cost very much but then for example I pick up a guest who you know can get me a ton of money but also loses me reputation cuz I'm not particularly popular with everybody and that's a cool system as well however we'll get to a negative with the deck building a little bit later the rules of the game are actually not that complex either with a caveat in terms of how you play the game a lot of it is actually written on your board a very nice little reference guide for the order of play so I'll look in my hand and go right well let's see I got that gentleman she's a woman okay I got that gentleman and that gentleman and so forth and you're trying to like combine the rewards for different things again it creates good powerful combo turn turns but then I also need a footman okay there it goes there and then you just resolve all the effects so your turn sequence is actually not particularly complicated that being said the rules are quite extensive and it's not the best rule book I have seen this is kind of a mix of a good and bad point I mean there's certainly a decent amount of detail here and certainly a lot of pictorial representation but the order in which some stuff is written and some of the way it's worded does make getting through this rule book a little bit of a chart first I mean it's not it's not an easy game to return to if you've forgotten the rules after a period of pain but if everybody's okay with the rules then the game play is

actually pretty smooth it doesn't feel clunky and you can get through it reasonably well but there is quite a lot of stuff to absorb I mean there certainly a lot of text and a lot of long- winded explanations for stuff you can do in this game and I almost feel like this rule book could have actually been smaller with what it is you're doing in the game as it is the solo game is relatively straightforward you effectively have a card with a score and a layout on it which effectively dictates the type of solo AI you're going up against and then for the most part you just play the game as normal and do what it is you want to do but the AI basically will take the odd tile and score for certain things and then by the end of the game you have to beat that score for that AI which during the game has values for their tile so that they can CAU the lady and the gentleman at the same time honestly the solo Mode's such a nice easy implementation compared to a lot of other solo AIS that you probably will end up playing this game more solo than you will in groups more and that a bit later so so far there's a lot of good stuff to say but there are some bad elements as well oh God you're killing me firstly the player count and the scaling with the length this game is says on the back one to four players and 30 to 90 minutes how on Earth it is physically possible to play this in 30 minutes even solo is beyond me but 90 minutes with four players you serious good fraking luck with that oh my word this is a game that

frequently can take anywhere between 2 to three hours to play it four players this game goes on a long time and part of the reason is because you have two ways of playing it that 30 to 90 minutes on the box is assuming that you are going to play this game in what is called standard mode which only has you know you know 15 16 odd rounds in the whole game now that standard mode is fine maybe for the old solo game but you're going to really want to play this in extended mode because in standard you don't get to do quite as much with the high level building tiles as you would because the games ended too soon at that point so you play this an extended mode in this format thing is that's now bulking up to 20 odd rounds and believe me that makes the difference those extra few rounds but it's also the most enjoyable way to play it so you kind of have to make the the the the choice between longer shorter but then less enjoyable more enjoyable and that's a little annoying but also turn down time can be quite High the analysis paralysis capability of this game is fairly extensive you know you've got all these different tiles to pick and then you got to figure out which men you need and what characters use from your hand if you're not planning your turns in advance you're going to have problems and the fluctuation of the Builder Market doesn't help in that respect but while it's not your turn you can't really do a lot other than plan that turn once you're done with that you've got to wait for multiple people to do what can be fairly lengthy turns and so these games as I say can go on for a long time we're talking two to three hours easily but also well two hours of

your lucky with four players you you're more looking onto the free Mark particularly conventions but even then I'm sort of sat there going right I'm ready you know you're done with your turn you're done with your turn there's not a lot of interaction in this game at all particularly between players I mean other than the fact that they might buy your building tile they've got their own meols they've got their own cards they've got their own house and reputation marker I don't really get to do anything with the other players apart from just laugh at the setting that they're doing which is fun but that's not the game doing that that's me doing that I said supper is ready now there is a common complaint that is made about this game when you look online at other reviews and I got to admit I do share it myself it's not a deal breaker but it definitely is a complaint the luck factor of this game does stem from quite a lot of different parts and when it all adds together especially if you're playing this three or four player and it's taking 2 to 3 hours it can feel like that maybe there's a bit too much of it what do I mean specifically well there's several things firstly building tiles they come out in different orders some of your objectives require the exact two or three tiles to appear in the game if they don't appear in the game your objectives null and void you know it's a wasted card in your hand the objectives may come out really high reputation and you might not have very high reputation at the time in which case you can't really build anything for the turn and you don't get that many opportunities to do it so you're kind of stumped if that happens but two big aspects of this game where the luck does get a little bit annoying and I do find

it slightly questionable design- wise here is twofold firstly you've got these Genry cards the different guest they come in two different decks but basically some are more powerful than others but most of them are like oh yeah they might give you a VP or two or maybe some more and they'll give you various bonuses any different people but then you get ones where they give you a big bonus but usually a big negative that's cool you know this one here uh cor Porter gives me 600 Quid or and knocks my reputation down by three so okay there's a big bonus but a big negative I'm cool with that but on top of that they're negative VP that I don't like because it's annoying to draw several guests from apart and have oh there's a zero oh there's a minus two and there's a minus two well I'm stuck with vus 4 victory points and it doesn't balance out because other players may get more luckier with the draws now there are actions in the game that do let you scrap these guests but you have to spend time out of a 20 turn game to do that and use a particular guest to to screen them and I'm not even certain if that's guessed is in the initial game or in the expansion but even then I've never seen anybody use that well not guess sorry one of these meols um I've never seen anyone use the MEO in order to screen gu never have I seen anybody do that in any game whatsoever and so drawing those negative VP guess just feels like you're you're getting hampered by dumb luck and I don't know why they're in the game to begin with why do they need to be negative VP you already have a negative

part of the card it's on the card why make it worse if I have to spend actions getting rid of bad guests that is something that another player is not doing therefore the other player is doing better as a result the other part is with the courtship of the Fairchild the Fairchild requires you to gather certain tiles and get as much VP as you can in different colors in order to court them you can play it by open or closed courtship don't play by closed courtship but I think the solo mode actually requires you to play by closed courtship which is not something I'm a fan of but open courtship is the only way that I'm willing to let it fly because that one at least you reveal which you reveal off the top of a deck like oh it's green blue red whatever this isn't the deck but you get what I mean and it was revealed at the start of a season so at least you know what it's going to be as the game goes on the problem is that might Jael with what you've got in your objective cards it might not you know it's all well and good saying well you know Reds are going to caught Fairchild oh I've got an objective that wants me to gather red cards that's brilliant but if my tactics don't go that way then I'm kind of losing out to what is a particularly powerful card it sounds dreamy so Obsession had a high Benchmark to achieve with everybody that's been raving about this game the fact that is a sleeper here now it's in the bgd top 100 not that I care about the board game geek ratings I mean come on look at recent events um but also just the fact that fans of the show are wanting to

stab me with pitchforks if I don't give this a 10 out of 10 there was certainly a lot of like okay right you setting the bar High have you met my expectations for the most part I had to actually say yes the theme obviously is not one that I go mad for you know Pride and Prejudice and all that pgsd I've already mentioned it but I can have fun with it I can just ham it up and just have a bit of a laugh with it and it it works for me in that regard you know don't take it too seriously but the fact that that is screaming off everything in this game like the look of it the component quality which is already stellar and just everything about it shows that this is a passion project where there was heart and soul poured into this game this wasn't just a tacked on theme or trying to be the next like oh this IP is popular right now let's go with this I mean nobody was nobody when they made this game was going oh downtown Abbey's popular let's make a Downtown Abbey game it's like no this had thought and Care put into it and you can see that happened and that makes for a more enjoyable experience when you put it in the table in front of me the rules themselves weren't too complicated this is a midweight game sure the rule book is not the best in the world but I have seen much worse if this had more fiddly rules to contend with it would probably hurt it more but here it's a good midweight level the solo mode is decent there's not a lot of upkeep for the solo mode so you can play this by yourself and not have to go through a ton of fiddlin or organization just to Pilot a solo player you essentially just play

the game by yourself now it does hamper the it is hampered by the fact that there is a decent amount of luck in this game which I'm not as comfortable with at times but also the fact that playing this with more than two players kind doesn't feel that necessary it feels mostly pointless because of the lack of player interaction but overall the game is still good fun there's a lot to speak for it when considering everything that's gone into this game I've got to be fair give it a nine out of 10 I think it's welld deserving of a seal of Distinction now that does go down to an eight if I'm playing with more players particularly if they haven't played the game before I'm actually hesitant to play this with three or four players unless it's with a specific group of friends friend I know who have this game and know the rules then I'm okay with it but teaching this to free brand new players I don't know if I'd want to and that would take it away from an Excellence rating but if you're going to play this primarily solo and two players and two of you know the game you're in with a good shout cuz even though I hate the theme at centers around it I can still have fun with it the component quality is Stellar the the variety of tactics and the tiles and the different uh places you can be and just you know those different guess is cool it's interesting and it's fun and you can just tell that this was a passion project done right and that it you know maybe that's factoring into the rating but you know what I've seen so many games lately where you know that they've just stencl an IP onto something in order to try and make it sell and it's failed Skyrim and you know and a fair

few other games where it's just like oh there's a theme but it's not that strong it's mostly abstract here it doesn't feel like that it feels proper feels genuine and you know what I got to give props for that so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele please don't kill me with pitchforks and if you like what you see then please thumb up this video on YouTube and on Board Game Geek When You See It by all means leave your comments down below what are your thoughts and Obsession and the various expansions solo multiplayer do use some of the variants in the book I mean I didn't mention all the variants you could do I mean you can technically with the expansion play it with five or six players but yeah no not not going to happen in a million years but you know I want to know your thoughts and I I swear a lot of them are going to be positive because a lot of you really wanted me to review this game and we're waiting you were waiting hopefully this has pleased you and this is honest opinion I'm not doing it just to please you I honestly think the rating I've given it is fair so until next time you can check out more content on the show including the recent Quick Draw review I did for Hamlet The Village building game and my recent top 10 where I talk about two-player games starting with top 10 casual two-player games take care and remember as always regardless if you prefer pride in PR this or pride and briers and zombies For Your Entertainment it's still only a game bye for now everyone

Progress saved