Charterstone (Solo) Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
happy new year everyone welcome to 2018 and on this episode about amiibo we have got a belter of hype this is Charlie stone from Stone mire games one of the most hyped games of last year as soon as this was announced you know a euro game that you built from scratch in a legacy style from Stone mire you know site creator yeah the internet went wild it went crazy for this and even though I was pretty excited as well because I mean all those things combined yeah I was like yeah this could work you could really make this work and I was so hoping that this one would meet the mark does it well you'd have to say the way of format I'm gonna do this though is that I now the format for this video is going to come in two parts first up I'm going to the spoiler free I'm not gonna give out spoilers I'm just going to give my faults on the game roughly how it plays and then leave it at that the second part of the video which I will give plenty of you know fair warning will be spoiler if ik I will spoil the living daylights out of this game and you will have to accept that if you accidentally strolled on to that part of the video that's kind of your own fault so you know we're gonna do spoiler free then spoilers okay so what is charter stone it is straight-up a euro game but the idea is is that you've started off with a board that is almost blank it has a load of spaces that you know you're going to build buildings on a few basic starting setups and a ton of boxes full
of cards and pieces which you don't know what they are just yet this is one of those games that you don't actually need to read the rules in advance you can literally open the rulebook put out the board and just read the book the book basically has some rules built into it and then your stick stuff into the rulebook as the game goes on as well as the campaign goes on to be more accurate and new rules will come into play new pieces will be available new cards will come out you know all sorts of these things will just build up and build up and build up until eventually you are left with a finished board that you can still play the game on this is how it differs from a lot of other legacy games particularly the pandemic legacies because in pandemic legacy you never touch the board once it's finished at least I don't know of anyone who has so you know mine's actually my first season luckily mounted on the ball over there actually and as soon as we're done with season two of which I'll do a a midseason review pretty soon actually then that one will get mounted on the ball as well now that both thankfully out of shot of a camera so I can't accidentally spoil anything but you only doing this is once you've got the finished board after twelve games you can just put on it you have all the rules in the book you've stuck them all in you've got all the pieces and cards that you'll need and you'll even have more that you don't use but you can potentially get as you play more games so even though you've evolved most of the game by the end of game twelve you actually have a chance to evolve it further with more plays the question is
does it warrant those twelve plays or would you prefer to just start from scratch well that's where things get a little bit more hitting this with me oh I will stress the caveat I played this solo okay there are the autumnal rules as they believe it's pronounced in here and even if you're playing with multiple people you can have inactive players but you can also have automated players now I played this solo the whole way through with two automated players so I had free people like free charters active on the table and the other three were inactive I played that way the whole way through so naturally some differences might occur from an experience point of view with multiplayer and solo so just bear that in mind but first of all let's get on to like the bits that are easily good components and art the art in this is beautiful lovely gorgeous colorful artwork the components are pretty solid you've got wooden pieces for the majority things now not every component is great but I can't really go into that without spoiling so you know most of what you get is pretty solid though and you'll have wooden resource tokens and you'll have metal coins that for a kickoff is already pretty good you've got lots of cards all wood color for the artwork you know the graphic design it's easy to tell what anything is there should be no confusion whatsoever as to what an icon or symbol means once you're comfortable with the rules in terms of
the ease of play pretty straightforward I mean the first couple of games are so dirt simple you actually might get put off the game as a result I will stress that the first two games you play of this are going to be the least enjoyable because the board is just that basic there's like nothing there and the game itself is pretty generic so the first two games are probably going to be a bit for you but it will develop and it will improve as time goes on in terms of either play as I mentioned it is pretty straight forward I mean you've got very few rules to learn to begin with and yes the game gets more complicated as you go through but none of the rules felt like I know how does that work again don't quite get it so for the most part you should be fine where things do get a little bit fiddly is with those altmer rules because you have a separate book actually here you've got the main rule book for Shara stone and I'm not going to spoil it right now but this is basically where you'll have the empty bits to put the stickers on and a reference guide pretty straightforward you've then got a separate guide for the or Tumnus and it's pretty small mean that literally is it you know I'm sure I'm not spoiling much with that and you will stick some extra rules in here as the game goes on so obviously the Altima has to work with other things but ultimate is literally a deck of cards where you flip the top card it has a picture where they will go and how many victory points they'll get and any other
random effects that occur you flip the card every time there is a meeple available because this has a similar meeple mechanic to the Manhattan Project if you've ever played that game which is where you put your meeples out worker placement style but then once you've used them all you have to spend the turn getting them back and you've only got two meeples to begin the game with so you're kind of like hmm donk donk drawback donk don't draw back and as a result turns out very quick whether it's with automated players or with normal players in fact I would probably say that the automated pay take longer to process than your actual human turn will it's that quick so when it says 60 minutes on the box that's pretty accurate I was going every single game in less than 60 minutes and that's me with two automated players and I was probably doing a lot less than 60 minutes at times you know first you're 45 maybe once you've got the hang of it I believe that if you had more human players that time would stretch you know four five or six players maybe be pushing it to get it done in an hour certainly with five or six I think you're pushing it but for free too I reckon you get easily doing an hour no problem at all the game develops at a fairly slowish pace I mean you don't end up with tons added as each game goes on it's fairly steady in how it progresses there is a story narrative although the story narratives a bit weak you can kind of predict half of it before you've even Zoar got to that stage and it literally
is pretty much like a chapter of text well the chapter a paragraph of text after each story had so after each game happens so this is probably like you know a kids book in terms of how much writing there actually is with the narrative but you have to accept that this is different from the other legacy games where more story happened think of pandemic legacy and I suppose see fall or see fail as I call it but think of those as narrative cinematic story driven games in pandemic legacy yeah the game changes each time but it's following a complex narrative and a decent storyline with no story changes as you go through this one has a pretty linear story you don't really change a great deal of it basically I think you end up with about two possible outcomes for the end of the campaign depending on what you've done that's about it you know how you start off an end each game will kind of pigeonhole you and it would take a route but the idea is this one is that you're building the legacy board you know you're building the Euro so you're not tearing up pieces you'll just have to peel the stickers off and put them where they need to be you never actually have to be told right destroy this card or anything like that it's just the fact that all the cards all the stickers are in crate boxes so when you open it you literally have the rulebook and a board and your charter chests as they call them your individual boxes and I could have given props for the way they've utilized every part of what you need for some use your charter chests
have got all the bits you need in order to record progress throughout the whole campaign on the box so no extra pads no paper no extra m-- you know side components needed everything you need to record your progress is either in or on the outside of those little Tucker boxes and they've made use of all the space that there is available on these boxes and in the index which is basically the giant box for the cards so props to stow my games they've really thought about how to best utilize the space now as you progress through the game you unlock different cards based on what you've built and what they call unlocking crates it's hid a bit like the elder like unlocking the treasure chest and going oh I got this now in this one basically every time you open a crate it will tell you via an index what cards and pieces you need to get and you know the cards will explain the rules you'll stick them in the book if necessary and you'll put them on the board or you'll keep them to one side depending on what the game wants you to do I don't want to spoil any more than that for now so after all this is said and done you end up with a fat to fit a final product a final euro board which will be I have to say very different from other players pretty much every single group will have a full board for the buildings what buildings they've got though and where they are will be fundamentally different fundamentally different from anybody else's board and if you have done with one side the board is double sided so
you can actually buy a recharge pack which gives you all the components you need in order to reset the game and you simply continue on that plane board so with the additional purchase you've effectively got two uses out of this game and you can play on the board when you're finished as a straight up your a game but here's where things get a little bit more sad for me only star it off not being a huge fan mainly because as I said the first two games also are very bland and generic very little happens in not doing very much of dido things started to then take an uphill stretch foo games say 3 to 10 3 to 9 I was thinking oh yeah this is getting better and better but I never felt wow yeah like wow I've opened this creighton that's amazing no it felt like okay I've opened this crate and now I've got a chunk of the gyro game I wish I had before yeah and some of the extra bit safer and there neither of whom are good some of them are great I'll get into more details and spoiler but some of them were a bit like that's really annoying and fiddly by the time I got to the game 10 to 12 though I was kind of like yeah we done with this now I kind of want to wrap this up I was starting to get a little bit bored with the campaign because the story is pretty generic and the games even though I was unlocking more stuff they never felt that different apart from just having an extra component or piece or certain type of card to you know use and that's only
if they actually came up in the game now maybe it's because I played this solo instead of multiplayer maybe that had an effect but certainly you kind of get pigeonholed into a certain way of playing against the automated players because the way the deck works is they go to a specific space and they score and a certain amount of victory points now sometimes it's specified sometimes it's based on their strength and the strength depends on how many games you've won over time little know on that is a FAQ fact that you need to begin this game solo with strength of 1 ok it says 2 in the book begin with 1 if you do not you will get creamed ok note that but their strength will go up and down depending on how many times you won basically and it kind of forces you to play in a particular style because I want to play this game where I'm going oh I want to open up more stuff yeah let's do this but the effort it takes to do that outweighs the amount of victory points you gain for doing it now against multiplayer opponents that's fine because every he's probably trying to do that and if one's going at a slower pace but the autumn alternating players aren't they are consistently going card points card points card points so they're constantly trickling up this track and when the strength gets to about four or five they become outright dirt sick overpowered you know I can beat them on for strength but that was not until about late in the game yeah
when they're five straight I think they're actually impossible to beat because they just literally go I'll go to this random space over here normally with only get your wood oh well I victory points what and imagine that they're doing this constantly whereas you're having to spend several turns just to get the requirements to meet something that gains the same amount of points yeah when the strength went to five they were unbeatable it had to divert it back to four and even then it still remained a challenge now a challenge is good but I think that this was based on me having to gun for the victory points more than actually trying to unlock stuff in the game which is not the way I wanted to play it I wanted to every time I took a game where it's like I'm gonna focus on opening crates I lost I'm camp member if there was an exception but I think the majority of the time that I went for opening crates and building buildings I lost but when I focused solely on victory points like objectives and things like that I won you know with either close or pretty easily and that was a bit of a shave I didn't want it to force me into that position but I'm sure a multiplayer experience is a lot different but as I said I I don't know something about this just didn't Wow me I was expect maybe I expected too much from it I knew this wasn't gonna be a cinematic story driven game I knew this was gonna be a euro game that you built up but the Euro game itself didn't really stand out against
wall right how many worker placement games on euros I got behind me and once you've got the finished product I was kind of like hey we're done with this campaign finally right you unlock most of the stuff anyway and here's my board I don't feel the need that I want to get this out just to play on that board now even with multiplayer so I'm kind of left with a game that I can't don't really feel like playing but then you can't sell on either because you've built this board you know you've ruined half the fun for people so I've got to make a decision whether I keep it and try it but the multiplayer and see if I can grow to like it more or I can a belies the game and take all the resource pieces and various components out which would actually come in handy in other games I'm not saying that charger stone was bad far from it I thought it was ok but that I just never felt wow amazing this is exactly 101 you know I'm opening crates and I'm getting similar stuff each time and it never felt like you know I was really adding chunks to the game it just I know there were some high notes but for the most part it just felt kind of men you know this is okay it's an okay euro with a build-it-yourself dressing over it you know group components good artwork and a decent ish euro game but now that I've done it I'm not sure I want to play it anymore beyond that and that's a bit of
a shame but fair enough I got twelve plays out of it but by the time I got to play sort of nine ten I was kind of done I was gonna yeah can I just get the stuff I need now because I'm not loving this system maybe it's because the automated players aren't decent enough in this one I mean they worked well in size they weren't well in some other games but maybe in this one they're a little bit too dull or a little bit too lights you know stuck on their pan for big dew point fifty point fifty point fifty point rather then with human players where they're probably going I want to open that crate before you did give me that give me that card I'm opening this crate so all in all I'm I was a little disappointed with how this turned out overall I'm glad I tried it and I'm glad I got my twelve games out of it and certainly I'm you know got got the values work out of it but and now kind of stuck as to what I want to do with it so I'm gonna have to think on that so I can't really say much more this was purely from a solo perspective I hear people join it more with like their spouse as a two-player or with a couple of friends don't know what I wouldn't want to play this with five or six players I think the game would just go on too long even with the quick turns but some people have enjoyed that as well so overall I'm probably just gonna cap this one at six I think I think I think it's fine you know I think a lot of people are gonna love this game I can certainly see that some people are loving this game and you are gonna get your money's worth because you're gonna play through this
you're gonna want to see it through to the end and you'll get 12 games out of it most of these games behind me I haven't played 12 times yeah do you think I've played 12 games of lisboa yet or even vimeos you know that some of these big games are hard to get played where is this one you're gonna get your 12 games and if you really like it you're not stuck with a product that you've just gotta check out you have a game that you can still play and it still works so if you are enjoying it you've got great value for money twelve games plus future proofing and then buy the recharge pack do the entire thing again with other people now granted yeah you're going to know exactly what the plot is that might influence how you play the game but you've got another use out of the game I think it was a good design point to have a double-sided book because I could have easily just ignored that but nope they actually thought about this and all you need is the recharge pack probably not something I'm gonna be grabbing though unless but you'd have to convince me to get that recharge pack but who knows maybe in the future if I know in the friends who want to play this game then maybe as a group we'll get the recharge pack and I'll sit through it again but yeah I'm not exactly desperate certainly not from a solo point of view as well I think this one is much better with multiplayer you know then it will be solo at least I hope it will be so six for me that's it from me reviewing charger stone spoiler free so now if you want to wrap up the
video at this point then by all means do so okay but now we are going into max spoilers I am gonna spoil this I'm going to say what I didn't like what I did like I mean talk about things I unlocked you know how am I born so all books you know I'm gonna talk about spoiler ethic so warning I can't give enough warning alright okay just do you guys who want the spoilers right okay so hmm component-wise I liked what you unlocked for the most part I mean the minions are the best part I loved all the little mini meatballs you've got and I think they work best in the game because each one gave you a little bonus that was really useful but they were all really different although kind of a bit of a myth to unlock them because you go oh unlock the new me pool this is great oh I've unlocked a meatball - and the meatball and it's like it's very repetitive alright but once they were all in play I like the variety and I thought they were really cool except you couldn't always get them this is a bit I found annoying with the buildings because depending how the buildings come out some components and some aspects of the game are less useful you know the payroll tokens hated them there you are horrible tichy little tiny queues that you got and they just scattering all over the board they mean different things but who cares they're just little color cubes and then their sole purpose
for most of the game is just to trade into the quota market for a few extra points that's it I found two buildings the entire campaign that converted those cubes to something else and that only worked with the purples and the yellow ones and I didn't even get the other one until I gained ten eleven so I was almost done so most of these color tokens which is completely pointless it's kind of weird that you have a pair of token that game unit is a good thing as well as I technically solving the peril but then you just end up with this little cube doesn't do anything you know unless you get a multiple copies of it and you go to the chroma market so yeah that was a little bit lacking in that respect some of the other cards that you got I was fine with them I like the treasure cards the treasure cards again get them into the lab game nine or ten so it was a bit late in the campaign when those cool things opened although a lot of them are kind of repeated like the scroll of wood fire water and all that all do exactly the same thing so what's the point why not just call the same name I don't know the guests are for they were pretty cool you know you got them and they generated an income for you although income doesn't happen often enough in this game I mean with a free player game I think it goes off three times and one of them was at the very end yeah with more players it would go off a few more times but yeah that's not a lot of income to get from your guests when you imagine that it probably costs you a coin and
the resource to get the card in the first place and then it just gives you some like one or two things you know for the rest of the game so I never really felt they were worth anything well with one exception the sorceress will get onto her a bit later the who has about friend cards friend cards I thought were better than the guests because they gave you bonuses for using specific buildings on other people's charters that I thought was quite a cool little addition except that it depended on which buildings you built in the Charter yeah you could have one that said if you go to the blue charter you get an extra victory point another minute I didn't build any buildings that give victory points in the blue charter so this friend is completely useless I don't like it when you get like Deadwood cards like that that was just like really odd and really annoying Oh what host yeah yeah treasure card you would guess you had friends oh yeah the assistant they were okay but they they diluted in value as the game went on and by the end of it I was kind of like yeah I don't really want them any more I want more of the other cards items were a bit of a waste as well actually I mean it's quite amusing that a loaf of bread is apparently an item you can create for victory points but considering you have to spend a resource at least I mean but the basic building there are other ways to get the cards but it depends what you built I didn't build much that allowed me to get more cards so unless you were lucky enough to have the the robot people I think robot minions
you know get mo more advancement cards which unfortunately the smithy only got built on an island and the island never saw play all the time you know you're not getting those cards very often so you might have spent a resource if not more to get that card then you need another free resources to cash it in for points that's a fair few turns in order to get the resources you need just for those points it almost seems like it's not terribly worth the effort and certainly not as fun as say grabbing an unconstructed building sorry a constructed building card off the deck and trying to open it as to get a crate certainly that's more enjoyable to do for the time and money than it is to just simply go here's an item card victory points so they were kind of hitting this I wasn't desperate for them with regards to the rulebook coming and the storyline pretty generic I wasn't that great with it I mean what do they end up with like free happy King faces and one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen unhappy faces yeah the forever King and I did not get on well let's put it that way I enjoyed the little gimmicks that they threw in like you knew you had to compare your score to an average that was on the internet that was pretty cool although you tried beating the average score by yourself with automated players yeah good luck with that and from that point on it just spiraled out of control with you know because the automated players never really went for the same stuff you were going for with those guide post cards you always ended up ticking off the King so basically the
King hated me by the end but loved me enough to take over my soul and when I won the campaign yeah not the best way to win the campaign you know I won you are now Eve you are now a douche bag King yeah not the best way but like I say stories pretty generic and it's kind of a side thing really you didn't really care that much about it just changed up the rules every now and again one warning about the rule cards so when you stick them in here if you can see the bottom of that you might notice that the middle one is a little bit wonky a little bit off kilt that's because I made the mistake of coming into contact with this rule book too soon after peeling the sticker off the cards if you are not certain you know where sticking it or if you accidentally brush this page with a sticker it's gonna stick and you will not be able to peel it off not without tearing the card in half it's not possible as soon as any part of that sticker touches this book it's going there even if it's wonky you need to make certain you get it right first time without fail so a couple of my broad cards in here are tad wonky but yeah well that's a minor thing guest item treasure starving oh yeah what was that candle power that was weird yeah it did wonder the snare is it gives you a candle which you liked before the game starts and it's meant to be a beacon for the King as he's coming to visit and basically you have to keep it alight but if it burns out for any reason whether you take a particular
token or somebody just happens go and blow it out then you tick off the king and it's a story element that you have to do I thought it was amusing that they actually bothered to pack an actual little miniature candle in here but what was that point you could have literally just done a die roll that's seem like so much of an afterthought yeah look at the dice tower reaction on their video review it's quite amusing but yeah that was really it was a nice little gimmick I suppose I can't fault it too much um trying to do you think of anybody else I mean the yeah the buildings I was fine with you know I I think most of my Chargers you know do not forget that the inactive Chargers build at the end of every game oh sorry started every game do not forget that rule because I forgot that for a couple of games as I okay build stuff now but you got more to do and the the way buy territories ended up you know it was fun to name everything although only ended up with so many assistants and guess so there's a lot of blank names in this in this game and yeah the buildings work okay but the problem is is that you don't have enough variety with them I mean there's one or two there's a few of them that give you income but the effort to go and get that income is so much by the time you've actually got the income the game's almost ended the payroll tokens you know you can get some buildings that convert certain colors to victory points they're all the same change X color 4x color but I've only found two of them so most of the payroll
tokens are worthless there's only one building I've got that allows me to get a friend card there's only one building I've got that allows me to get a guest card yeah I mean granted you can just get him by the normal method but there's only so many ways of doing things and some of the resources have clearly become better than others I mean if you've got coal you can make a fair bit of money on my board same with metal with bricks not so much and certainly not with grain grain and pumpkins are a bit better on my board you know you get a little bit for them but not a lot so suddenly half the resources aren't as good as the others otherwise they're all pretty generic you know a pumpkin doesn't really function any different than it would it just different buildings require different resources it's not like you need the wood to build and the pumpkins to feed or anything like from a tip like that it's just literally this resource triggers X building so not the best way to go with that so I don't mean there's much more against a mean I found the automated player is a little bit dreary didn't work as well but it allowed me to play the game solo so I'm glad they put it in and certainly if you're only playing with the two of you I might recommend having one or two automated players just so that you can fill up the chargers in a different way but pure so though probably not as good and everything there's really much else on the spoiler front that I can mention I mean I like the persona cards you know the the fact that now now that the game is finished
you know if you don't unlock everything by game 11 it pretty much tells you to unlock everything you know or at least I'm not the major stuff so that's pretty good at least you're not leaving stuff out but now that the game's over you've got a bigger objective deck you've got a big advancement deck full of some buildings you've yet to build or yet to open crates for that's quite cool because now the game can still evolve in the future plays and then you've also got a persona deck that's really good because now you shuffle it up you give personas out to different people and they get to choose one for the game and you can potentially unlock more so that's all pretty sweet as well so like I say I don't think charter stone was bad I just wasn't wowed as much as I could have been and maybe because I was playing solo only maybe that was half the problem but you know some people are really enjoying this and hopefully you will too I just leave it to you to make up your mind as to you know which way you stand with it so effort starting to go a bit I think I better wrap this one up so thanks for watching if you like what you see then please subscribe to the podcast feel free to give feedback and I'll see you on the next broken meatball review have fun guys open the 2018