Operation Overlord - First Impressions: Three Things That Stand Out
Transcript
Hi everybody, I'm Stella Blitz and welcome. There are a lot of tabletop war games that cover D-Day and Operation Overlord, but what happens when Vuca Simulations takes their creativity and design to the topic? In this video, we're going to take a look at their latest game, Operation Overlord. Now, this video is going to be a quick look at the game. So, we're going to give it overview of gameplay, set up the first scenario, look at the components, and then talk about some of the rules and some of the mechanics that are involved with the game. Let's jump right in and get started. So, before we dig in, let's do a quick overview, big picture look at Operation Overlord. First up, this is a big game. It's got a big box, a lot of stuff in it, and at its heart, it's a two-player game, block-based system with a lot of different cards coming into into the action as well. It's designed by Clem, published by Vuca Simulations. Gameplay length is 2 to 8 hours depending upon the scenario and the historical length as well. So, scenarios are either going to be 1-month long or the campaign game is 3-months long. There are four scenarios in the box, by the way. Three 1-month scenarios and then the full campaign game, which takes 3 months. A turn in a game is 1 week, and units are core and division level. Let's take a quick look at the components in the game. First up, our map. Now, this is roughly 22 in by 34 in wide, point-to-point base map with a quite a bit going on. And we can see, just to get a sense of the scale, here are the invasion beaches. So, Sword, Juno, Gold, Omaha, Utah are here.
And then the From this edge of the map here to about here is about 130 miles. So again, a rather big scale. We've got units are divisions and core. So, this is kind of more of an operational level look at Operation Overlord. Victory points are tracked over here, and gameplay is based on victory points, largely by reaching your objectives or holding positions if you're the Germans, and then also casualties inflicted. We have a number of reinforcement tracks here and then around the edges for the Germans. Supply is tracked way up over here, and then our timeline is over here. So, a lot of the information that you'll be using and managing is all based on the map as well. Really beautiful map. Again, the points have quite a bit going on with segments delineating things that are in between. Colors different differentiate different aspects of gameplay, but I really like this map. Let's jump in now and take a look at our units. There's over 100 blocks in the game, and they come in two different sizes. So, the core here are these larger blocks, and then the divisions are much narrower here. They don't stand up as high. And again, this is going to be block-based combat, so you're going to be hiding your information from your opponent, which of course makes me think, and we'll talk about this a little bit more, this is not a game I would recommend for solo.
This really feels like at its heart, it's aiming for that two-player experience. Now, we can see the German divisions here in this darker gray, Allied divisions, the US divisions in the green, and then the Canadian and British in a little bit more of the olive drab colors here. The game comes with a couple of options for stickers. You can either use NATO symbols for everything, or you also have uh drawings that you can use for the units instead. I decided to go with a mix for myself, so I've got NATO symbols for the infantry units, and then for the armored units, I like the tanks, and then for the headquarters here in the core, I I some markers, I used the trucks and the the icons again as well. But, you can do again, whatever you'd like. You could have them all be NATO symbols, or you could all be the icons and have icons for infantry as well. Here is a quick look at some of the German units as well. I really like how they've added all of the divisional symbols for these.
It adds a little bit of a historical flair to it, makes the cut the the units that colorful, but not annoyingly colorful. So, nice touches here. Again, Vuca Sims does a great job with their design, and this Operation Overlord is no exception. Let me mention a quick word from our sponsor, too, that I'm using Cube4Me storage trays for this game. It works great for the blocks and the cards and these larger blocks, and there's a lot of stuff to keep track of. I'll put a link to Cube4Me down below in the video description. If you use that link, you get a 5% discount, and it also helps out the channel a little bit as well. There will be eventually an official kit up on the channel for Operation Overlord. Someone else is doing that one, but I'll put a link to that, too, as soon as it's there. So, Operation Overlord comes with three decks of cards. The one we're looking at right now are the event cards. Some of these are played, a fair number of them are played during combat. We can see some of these German events down here played during a combat phase, and the combat phase itself is fairly involved, and we'll take a little bit closer look at that as we talk about gameplay. And these cards are one part of that. So, a lot of the cards you'll be playing during combat. Now, there are other elements of it. Here, we're playing some during activation phase, where you can mess with your opponent's event card hand. And then the other one I want to point out here is this Erwin Rommel card for the Allies, which depicts Rommel getting seriously wounded by Allied strafing. And this touches on an aspect of gameplay that I'll I'll talk a little bit more about in a moment, which is the alternative history aspect of this. As
the Allied player, you're going to be selecting your objectives, and as the German player, the Axis player, you're going to be selecting your fortresses to defend. So, every game is going to play out differently depending upon where you're trying to move to as the Allies and what you're trying to hold as the Germans, which is good, I think, because this is going to give it just enough historical variation that it's going to create a lot of replayability. So, I One of the senses I get from looking at this game is there's a good bit of freedom on both sides to dictate slightly alternative history to make Operation Overlord play out differently every time you play the game. A second set of cards in Operation Overlord are these combat cards. These are used in lieu of dice.
So, the game doesn't come with any dice, but when you're having combat, these cards are drawn to add in a random element into the combat resolution. The third and final deck of cards has a big impact on gameplay. We hinted at this when we met talked about it before, but these are the objective cards. So, the Allies are going to be selecting from a subset of all the cards depending upon the scenario and the month you're in, you're going to be selecting some objectives. Some of these could be historical like the Overlord one here, the objective is Carentan. Others are fictional and just not necessarily elements that actually happened in real life. Now, as you pick a certain number of these objectives, the Germans then are going to use their intel points to try to reveal these objectives, to learn what they are, and that interplay between the Allied objectives and the German intelligence dictating where if they know where the Allies are going and some of the benefits they may get to successful intelligence operations. And as the Germans, you can spend more victory points to have a higher level of intelligence. So, this gameplay that revolves around hidden objectives and German intelligence creates another [snorts] element of gameplay that makes me think this is very much a two-player focused game. This isn't going to work very well as a solitaire but it also highlights this ahistorical and historical alternative pathways that could happen. I don't think any two games of Operation Overlord are going to play out exactly the same way. I should also mention that all of these cards are a very high-quality vinyl, too.
Operation Overlord also comes with three counter sheets. These are all printed pre-rounded, nice quality again as usual, and printed on both sides. The large Basically, what we're looking at, you know, we noticed the the units are all blocks. These counters are basically markers and often times dictate elements that are going to be brought to play brought to bear on the combat equation. So, support, artillery, air support coming in that's going to influence the combat in in equation here. And again, talking about the combat execution is somewhat of an involved process that's going to have a lot of different factors that are being bought brought to bear on it. So, as you're attacking, you're going to be thinking about what kind of support you can bring in. Likewise, as the defender, you're going to be thinking about what units and what types of forces you can bring to bear to help influence the combat outcome. We can also see here, these are the German Festungs. So, German player is going to be picking uh points that they have to defend. So, these are elements of the map that they are going to defend at all costs. This is the alternative, the flip side to the Allied objectives are the Germans and trying and determining which ones of these spots they are going to dictate as very high defense and high priority defensive areas. Now, as we can see, there's more markers in here. Uh these are for marking Allied control, some more objectives here, bridgehead markers, uh used rail support this week, and then lastly down here, some more Allied supports that are brought into combat, some more control markers, and then more German objectives. Let's take
a quick look at the rulebook, which weighs in at 32 pages, but it's loaded with a lot of graphics and support. Great layout, of course, as always with Vuca Sims, and the rules end on page 27 and a half here. So, the back part of it basically outlines the scenarios and the victory conditions and some of the different scenario rules that are varied for each one of the three scenarios. The On the whole, I'm going to give this about a five and a half five on complexity. The combat in particular, the combat sequence feels fairly novel and involved. I think it's going to take a while to to wrap your head around that. Some of the other elements feel pretty straightforward, but there's a good bit going on here. So, all in all, yeah, I'm going to give it a five for complexity. For solitaire, the backs of a back of the box gives it a three. I feel like that's fair out of 10. I feel like that's fair. I I don't think this is a game I would recommend if you're just going to be playing it solitaire.
This really feels like it's designed for the the two-player experience with all the hidden movement and hidden objectives and such that are involved in gameplay. Operation Overlord also comes with two identical player aids. You can see map sectors here. They open up and have different combat supports, combat sequence here. And again, look at this. This is 16 steps on the combat sequence. So, we can see that combat is fairly involved, and this is where I think a good bit of the complexity in the game is going to come from. And then lastly, on the back here, some of the information on the unit blocks and some of the support markers, and then the map key helping you interpret what you're looking at on the map. Operation Overlord also comes with four scenario cards, two for the Allies and two for We mentioned there are four scenarios, so these are vinyl and double-sided. Each of the three shorter scenarios represent 1 month, so Neptune represents June, and then this is Cobra, which is July. Then we have the full 3-month campaign scenario as well as the August scenario if you'd like to play another one of the three monthly options. And this is basically the situation where your starting points and then all of the information you need to get started with each individual scenario. And there's an identical set for the Germans. The last thing we have to look at are the army boards. Now, each of the three German armies that are in the Operation Overlord have their own board, and these are single-sided, so you're going to be using these. This is going to increase the playable footprint of the game, of course. It shows the different core that are in an individual army, so we're looking at the 7th Army here, and then
which units are inside that core, which blocks are there. So, this is used for organizational purposes, and again, there's one for each of the three German armies in the map. For the Allies, we have a similar set. We have the US 1st Army, US 3rd Army, 1st Canadian Army, and then the 2nd British Army. Working again the same way. The core are here, and then the divisions that are inside the core are listed off here for organizational purposes to keep control of your forces. So, what I'd like to do now is to give three general impressions of gameplay based on what I've seen so far. With the caveat that this is very early days. So, I I I've just read the rules, I'm starting out to play. I've been in here probably about 2-3 hours now I've spent with the game trying some different things and trying some different activities. So, with that in mind, let's talk a little bit about some impressions. Now, first up, what are we looking at? Well, this is the D-Day invasion. We've got British Canadian forces, US forces now moving ashore are in D-Day. We've got some airborne activity behind the beachheads. We'll come back to this momentarily. Both sides have picked their objectives for the month, and then we're digging in now into combat and action in this first week of June 1944.
So, observation number one has to do with the objectives and the festung for the objectives for the Allies and then the festung for the Germans. So, the first cool thing I want to talk about is the objectives. We can see on the This is a map of the Allied objectives for the first month. And at the beginning of every month, so three times in a campaign game of 3 months, but you only do it once if you're playing one of the 1-month campaigns, the Allied forces are going to map out their objectives in the order the weekly order they want to get them. So, on the left-hand side here, we can see these are the week one objectives, week two, week three, week four. And there are two types of objectives objectives. Special operation objectives are ones that can be deceiving your opponents or give you a little bit of bonuses or do different things. The The geographical ones that are the heart of this really are these strategic objectives.
And so, you're picking these locations from a wide range of cards. And this These are the locations that you think you can get. So, we've got Bayeux in week one, Cotentin in two, Cherbourg in three, La Hougue Dute I'm sure I butchered that one in four, and then Caen in number in week four as well. So, if that really dictates how we're trying to progress beyond the D-Day beaches and get inland, and you could map this out in an entirely different way depending on what you'd like to try to do as the Allies. So, I can see this having a lot of replayability. This was a lot of fun. Now, we also did the German intelligence phase, but they were unable to note or identify any of our objectives. Now, if we're playing this two-player, this would all be hidden from the German player. So, the German player doesn't know what we're doing unless they've revealed and negated some of them as a part of their intelligence, but that didn't happen this time. And what that means for the Allies as their objectives, this is the week one objective. This is week's two objective.
Week three is down here, a tough one in Cherbourg down here. Week four is over here on the coast as well as moving inland a little bit in Caen here. So, it really maps out the progression that we're hoping to get, but we could have done this in a completely different order. We could have thrust inland here and ignored the peninsula over here to a large degree or cut up this way and come back down maybe in the second month and try to clear out the peninsula. So, lots of different options as the Allies as to how you want to map out your operation, which is just a lot of fun. Now, what we're looking at as well from the German perspective, they have four tiles that are active in June that they can pick from. And as the Germans, I selected Saint-Lô up here and then Cherbourg down here. So, the Cherbourg is both an Allied objective and a German festung, a stronghold that they have to hold. So, this is going to be worth a lot of victory points that the Germans are really going to try to hold, and the Allies are really going to try to take in this first month. And you can see again, had we as the Germans picked different of these strongholds, it would have created an entirely different perspective, a different way that this battle could have flowed as well. Now, normally these aren't on the map, I just put them up so we could see them, but they are face up, so both sides know what the German objectives or holding ground is. The second thing I want to talk about is the rule set and how the learning of the game has been going.
It's been a little bit of an adventure if I have to be totally honest here. The It's a This is a game that has a lot of novel gameplay, and so I'm finding it's taking me a while to learn and get up to speed with the game. Now, the rules do have a lot of examples, but what I really wish the rules had was an extended full turn example of play starting with the the first phases and working all the way through cuz connecting all these things together I'm finding is taking me quite a bit of time. I have noticed a couple places in the rules where I think there's a little there's some contradictions, some things I'm wondering about. Most of the time I've been able to figure things out, but yeah, it's taking me a while to learn this one. This game has some some complexity to it, and I sure wish because of the novelty of gameplay that there was a longer example of play. Now, let's go to observation number three, which involves the combat. And to do that, I want to talk a little bit about what's happened so far. So, we dropped the 101st and the 82nd Airborne outside of Cotentin. I thought maybe we could get lucky as the Allied paratroopers and attack it right away the night before D-Day and take Cotentin, but unfortunately the Germans held it. They are exhausted, our paratroopers are shaken. It was a big battle. It was cool, but we just couldn't take the town. The Germans opted to hold the ground. Then as the Germans, this was one of the other objective I had them push in here to Caen because this is a supply depot, so I want to keep these British paratroopers outside of out of away from that. And so now it comes back to the Allies activation, and what we're going to do what I thought would be cool to do is Utah Beach. So, I want to show
how this works with the caveat again that I'm learning the game, so I might get a couple things wrong here, but I just want to show the level of depth to the combat system. So, let's do Utah Beach with the US attacking up the beach here trying to take Sainte-Mère-Église here, and the Germans are going to defend it. So, we're going to start and walk through the entire combat procedure here to show you that yeah, this has got quite a bit of in steps to it. I'm going to follow the sequence of play right now. We are declaring as our activation we're going to activate this core. It's one of the larger blocks here. So, this is 7th Core, and we are going to have it attack up the beach on Utah Beach to try to take this objective. And so, the first thing we do is we turn this up. However, there's more to it than that. So, this is the 1st US Army's activation board, and basically what we're looking at these are the different core that are attached to the 1st US Army. And this is 7th Core, so it's not just the core unit, which has a weak value. It also has these divisions, and they are assumed to be with it. So, we are going to commit both of these divisions to the attack as well. The second thing we could do is to have any reinforcing divisions, but we don't have any available here, so we're not doing anything like that. The next thing we do is we pick the supports. So, these are the additional elements we're bringing to bear on Utah Beach. And since we can activate this 7th Core once in a turn, we're going to bring everything. We're just dropping everything here. So, we have armored support, we have the US Air Force, and then we have some field artillery that we're going to be dropping in to add to our attack here.
So, it's going to be expected we're throwing everything at Utah Beach. We have got to succeed. The next part comes the random element to this. We're going to add our combat card to this, and it goes face down, so we don't reveal this. This has a number on it anywhere from zero to five. So, the US has added their combat card here as well. So, this is basically the the initial attack element here of the US motion on Utah Beach. At this point in time, the Germans could opt to withdraw, which honestly with one defense with one division here and the way they're not going to be able to bring support, would probably make a lot of sense. But for the sake of showing combat, we are not going to withdraw. And so, we are going to stay and fight. So, we're going to flip this unit up, and it has a defensive value of two, but we'll see. It gets quite a bit stronger.
The next option is if we could bring in some any other units, but this unit is exhausted, and these two other divisions here they've already already activated and fought, too. Our two far away. They can only move two squares in. So, this division here is on its own. If we hadn't dropped these paratroopers up here, this division could have come in and supported the defense, which might have been a good idea. But, the German 709th Infantry Division is on their own at Utah Beach. Another option, the Germans do have supports available for this army corps, but the army corps isn't close enough, and this is not the army corps, so they can't use supports in here, but they we get to draw a combat card. So, we're going to add the German combat card to this as well. The next choice for the Germans, each army has a doctrine that they can use once per round as well. But, once again, the German core and the German the army core is too far away. So, it has to be within two spaces, and so they can't use that.
However, we could select the US first army's uh doctrine here, which would give us two strength to our attack, which would be helpful. However, we also need to attack Omaha Beach later in this round with these units. So, we're going to save this because we have something else that we can bring to bear on this. So, we're not committing this. We're going to save this for Omaha Beach. Now, initially, these supports here would have been hidden. So, we should have hidden them from the Germans, and we would flip them up now. I did that I put them up visible by mistake. But, now we get to flip things over, and we get to see what results we get. So, let's see what we get for a combat card. For the Allies, we get three, and for the Germans, we get a three as well. So, that's a wash. But, our combat basically is, for the most part, fairly well committed here. The last thing, however, that we can do is it says, "In any order, both players can commit as many event cards as they wish." So, the Allies have four event cards left. The Germans have five, but none of the event cards that the Germans drew are helpful for this. However, the Allies do have an excellent event card that they can play right now in this spot. And check it out. It is Heroes of Normandy. And this card gets a two up arrows, which are an attack bonus of two. But, notice this, if the battle involves the US fourth infantry division, which is right here, it gets three up arrows. So, we're going to use this one right away on Utah Beach because it's going to give us an
increased attack strength of three. So, a perfect event card for us. This is the only event card that we're going to play, and the Germans don't have any that really can be brought to bear here. So, now comes time to calculate the values and execute the combat. All of our pieces are in place here. The first thing we do is we total up all of the attack factors for the the attackers here. We've got one and two and four is seven. Our card here is three, that's 10. Our supports here, add these up arrows, each add one. So, we are at 10 11 12 13 14, and then our event card adds three. We go all the way up to 17. Now, we have some subtractions here, too. This city here that we're defending has It's a major objective, so it's a minus two. So, that takes us from 17 down to 15. And also, whenever there's for each enemy infantry division in the defense, you lose another one. So, now we're down to 14. But, our field artillery has this S, which is a special effect, which means it negates one defensive bonus for infantry. So, we go back up to 15. Now, on this little combat results chart, we're going to put our attack value of 15 right next to this thing, and that gives us the results that we're going to get for our attack. But, we need to look at the defense. The defense gets the value of their card, three. They get the value of the unit here, which is five. And this Atlantic Wall marker here adds four more. So, they get five plus four is nine. So, on the nine spot, we take the the defense here, and that's the amount of damage they've inflicted on us in the
results they've inflicted on us. Now, it's time for us to apply the results. The defender goes first. Now, the defender under 15, there is a little red three. That means it's taken three hits. There's also a blue X, which means it would have to destroy one support, but it doesn't have any support in this battle. So, that doesn't impact it in this case. But, it has to take three hits. We've cleared our cards out of the way. Now, the German unit has three options for taking these hits. You can either take a deterioration state in the unit, or you can retreat, but you can only retreat once one or two squares, or you can destroy two supports. The Germans have no supports here, so that's not an option. So, they have to take the three hits either by deteriorating the unit and or retreating. So, what we can do once we'll apply one to make the unit shaken here. We'll do another one here that's going to have it be exhausted.
That's its second hit. And then, our third hit on the German unit, we can have it retreat, and let's have it retreat two. We'll give ground. We'll push all the way back here. So, this unit is now exhausted, and it's been pushed out. So, the Allies have two hits to take, as well. Under the number nine, there's a little red two. So, they have to take two hits, as well. We are going to have the 90th Infantry Division and the fourth infantry division and make them both shaken, and we'll put them back now on the army card. So, we've put our shaken divisions back into the seventh core's little army status here. We've also burned up our supports, so they'll be gone for the rest of this turn. And one last thing to do, actually, two last things to do. Because the Germans have vacated this spot, we can move in, and we have captured Saint-Malo Sainte-Mère-Église. And the last thing, when you do this and you destroy a chunk of the Atlantic Wall for Utah Beach, because it has this one supply thing, we have established a bridgehead, and this negates the Atlantic Wall for the rest of the battle. And with that, US forces are ashore at Utah Beach. We're pressing up to Carentan. We've driven this unit back and exhausted it. It's a pretty good start for the US here on D-Day, at least on Utah Beach. But, there are a lot of factors left to be decided, and the Germans have a lot of reinforcements moving towards the peninsula here. And the reason I wanted to show that is I really like this combat system, and you can see also that there's a lot of pieces to it. There's a lot of math.
There's a lot of steps. Each combat is its own little mini event. So, it's going to take a while to parse some of the rules and the event cards and how they all come together, but it really is a fascinating system. I've not seen a block combat system that takes combat to this level, and so I really wanted to show it and how it works in the game. Um I'm very excited to dig in and play this. I I'm playing it right now, actually. I'm playing it solitaire here. I must say it is fun to play it solitaire, but I think it's going to be even better when you're playing against a human being because you have all the card play, the objectives, the intelligence, the spy. You don't quite know what's going. This is a game that's designed for two people, but it is definitely fun to play solitaire, at least from you can try a lot of different ideas as both sides here. And with that, this is a little bit of an overview, a first look at Operation Overlord. Thanks for watching, everybody. I hope you enjoyed the video.
If you have any questions, let me know. And again, it's very possible I've made some mistakes in here. I'm still very early in the learning process. And you know, there is that element I talked about with the rulebook. There are a few things I'm not quite sure of yet.