Skip to main content
Loading video...

AYCB Podcast: Episode #18 - Key to the City: London & The Voyages of Marco Polo

Transcript 54:35

Hello everyone and welcome back to the All You Can Board podcast. This is episode 18. My name is Dylan and I'm Carlo. Uh, and today's episode we're just talking about games. It's going to be a little bit different. There's not going to be an appetizer. You can consider maybe the first game that we talk about uh as the appetizer if you if you wish or you can have two main courses today. Um, but we're going to be talking about Key to the City London and The Voyages of Marco Polo. So, this is something that we kind of talked about internally doing for a while where we kind of alternate maybe or just spend some time with certain episodes uh honing in on some games since uh we haven't been doing videos on the channel as of late. Um, and we there's lots of games to talk about still and uh even though there's lots of discussion that we enjoy and um that's sort of like grander or encompasses a lot of games. Uh we know a lot of you guys like hearing us talk about specific games and we love talking about them too. So we're going to start uh today with Key to the City London. Um we'll take a little break and then we'll come back with Voyagers of Marco Polo.

So um I'm going to kick things off just by giving a little bit of an overview of what Key to the City London is in case you haven't heard of it. Um, this is part of the key series of games. Um, some of the other games you might have heard of from that series. Obviously, Keyflower, which is my number one game of all time. It's in Carlos's top five last we did it. Um, we've talked about that game a lot. Um, but there's also Key Flow, Key Harvest, Key Market, uh, Kedum's Dragons. Uh, the newest one being Keyside that we still haven't played came out, I think, in 2025, 2026. Um, and so, uh, it's a it's a like there's there's through lines throughout the entire series, but I would say that, uh, what I was most intrigued about with Key to the City London is the fact that this is very much, uh, like I don't want to call it a sequel to Keyflower, but it's it's it's more closely tied to Keyflower specifically than just being through lines through like Keys. Um,

sure. think of I think this one and key flow I think are two of the ones that are considered actual they're branded as reimplementations of keyflower whereas the other ones are just games in the key series or universe where they're not they're completely different mechanisms but you can see the common DNA from keyflower here for sure. Oh yeah. And like even I mean they they go so far as to like give you a section in the rule book called quick rules for keyflower players in where it's like this little box where in essence you could theoretically like just read that and and you know gain 90% of the knowledge you'd need to be able to just start playing Q of the City of London if you were a Keyflower expert. And like I didn't do that but I I feel like I probably could have and I probably could have taught it to everyone at the table and only had to refer to the rule book for a couple small clarifications. So,

well, and even just when we wanted to refer back to what the differences were is super helpful. That's something I'm glad you brought that up. Uh, having that section of the rules cuz I wish more games that are borrowing from another game did that. It makes it way easier to jump in for people who are familiar with it. And we criticize bad rule books all the time. So, we Yeah, that needs to be applauded for sure.

Yeah, 100%. And I feel like, like you said, either if a game is doing what this one is doing and sort of really reimplementing a lot of things or if it's just like in the same line, if you can give me a way where I can like skip half the rule book. And this isn't the first time I've seen this done. A lot of times in other rule books, it'll be like it's not in one box, but throughout there'll be like bolded text or a different colored text and it'll say this is just for I think Frost Haven might have done that where it's like if you're coming from Gloom Haven, just read the new colored stuff and you can probably play. So it's it's a cool little thing that they've added. So, um, I'm going to give a quick little overview of what this game is, but I'm going to spend most of the time talking about the differences with Keyflower, cuz if you've heard us talk about that, you probably already know what this game is. So, um, this is an auction bidding game, but it's also a worker placement game. Um, there are going to be these hexagon, uh, tiles that come out in different in this game, they're called eras. In a Keyflower, they're called seasons. Um, and those tiles are going to be able to be bid on by the players at the table. And the way you bid is that you have colored meeples in three different colors. Um, in Keyflower, there is an additional fourth color that can come up, which is the green maples.

There are no green meeples in this game. We'll get into that later. Um, but basically, when someone makes a bid or uh or uses a tile, cuz you can also use all the tiles that you're bidding on by placing meeples on them. Um, when you signify, say, I'm using a blue mele, you have now designated that tile as being only available to be used or bid on with blue meeples. And so, everyone's meeples are behind their own screen. You don't know what colors everyone has. You don't know if someone has a lot of red or has no red. And so what you're you're not just bidding. You're not just choosing what you want to do. You're also trying to discern at the table what everyone else has access to because maybe you can win a tile by only using one mele if you have strategically waited until late enough where you think I don't think there's a lot of yellow meeples left. And that's really I I think for me I can uh safely say that's my favorite part and what makes Keyflower one of my favorite games is is that sort of blank on the word not negotiation but that like discerning or you have to do and trying to figure out what everyone has or strategically knowing I want this tile but how long can I wait before I make a bid on it so that I can see other people's colors come out and see their colors deplete so that maybe I can know which color I want to bid with or how much I have to spend to win that tile because yeah, if I want something I can bid right away, but if I bid right away, everyone has access to all their colors still. I'm basically guessing I hope people don't have a lot of this color that I've used. And so, um, that's like the the crux of the game, but then those tiles after you bid on them, they come

back to your in Keyflower, it's like your your village. I think in in London key, you say London, it's London, it's like the city. Um, and you're basically now you own those tiles. And so now for you to use them in the future, you put your meeples on them and you'll get those meeples back because they are in your village in your city. Um whereas if other people want to use your tiles, they still can just like they could use those worker placement tiles when they were in the center. But now if they use them, you keep their meeples because they've placed them on your tile. So it's like this extra thing you have to weigh. How badly do I want to use this tile? Because I'm essentially giving away that meeple. Do you bid on tiles that you know will be attractive to other people so that you can get a bunch of extra meeples? So that becomes its own thing. thing. And then in Keyflower, you would also have this sort of managing of resources where once you had those tiles in your village, you had you're generating resources with them and you're trying to move those resources to other tiles where they're going to gain you victory points or where they're going to allow you to do upgrades and different conversions. And that was an entire other aspect of Keyflower was the moving of resources because you had to get tiles that would give you movement. You couldn't just move by saying I'm moving. You have to use that as an action. Um, key to the city London changes that up a little bit. There's a couple changes from what I've said. Upgrading, uh, you in Keyflower, um, Keeples are placed on the upgrade T. Yeah, just to be clear, they're called Keeples in this game, not meeples. Um,

I will not be referring to them as Keeples. I hope that's clear.

Um, Keeples, Meeples were placed on the upgrade tile. Um, in Keyflower there would be like you would get tiles that have upgrade actions and you would say I'm placing my mele on that tile and I'm using it upgrade action. Whereas in key the city in London, whatever tile you want to upgrade, there's no upgrade action. You're just putting your mele on that tile and saying I'm upgrading. So that's a big change which again we'll get into what we think about that after. Um, another big change is in Keyflower there was a maximum of six meuples uh that could be on a single tile. And so when you beat someone's bid you have to beat it by at least one. So if I put one and the next person puts two, that means that there's only a spot for three meles left and then it's capped out. That cap is removed in Q the city of London. So as much as you want to bid, you can bid. And that happened in our game at least once I remember where bids got pretty high. And so again, we'll talk about that later. Um there are boats in Keyflower. Those boats um have special abilities. is they can only be attached to well not only be attached to water but you're trying to usually attach them to the water spots on your village or then you're having to like position the tiles to be on the grass side. Um in this game there are no boats. Um, and and another big thing in Keyflower, the boats determine which meuples you were going to get access to in the next round cuz you'll get a a fresh set of colored meeples and you'd kind of see these boats, see what colored meeples were on them, and you'd bid for the opportunity to have first selection or second selection to be able to say, I really want to get that boat with those meuples. That's also completely changed in Key to the City of London. Instead, um, a birth is selected. Um, and

basically you just choose when you want to set sail uh in a round, which is kind of like passing for the entire round. And whoever does that first, whoever sets sail first is going to get first choice of where they're kind of moving their little this little boat token you have and where where you're moving that and that's going to designate what you're getting access to in the next round. So, that's changed a little bit. They've kind of removed the the bidding aspect of of seeing what you get in the next round. Um, and then the last big change that I'll I'll mention here, the rest will kind of come up organically, um, is the connectors. So, uh there are these connectors that if you're you've seen these, uh components in many games um that I believe they're even in Katan, if I'm not mistaken, and um Gricola maybe as well. I can't remember. I've seen them in so many games. They're just like these little like wooden uh sticks essentially, and they all kind of function differently in in every game that they're in. But in this one, you're connecting tiles. And and the reason you want to connect tiles in the first place is really just because there's different requirements on upgrading. And so a tile might say to upgrade this tile, you have to have uh all like six uh connectors on it. So based on every single side, but of any color. Or it might say you need to have one white connector, one blue connector. And so you're having to position these connectors to be able to upgrade tiles. Uh otherwise you you don't meet the requirement. You can't upgrade them. So that was not present in Keyflower. I feel like in some way connectors sort of replaced like the the like upgrading was more complex in Keyflower and so that complexity has been shifted to like now you need these connectors as another resource you have

to manage and that's just how key to the city of London handles it.

Yeah. And the connectors they let you just dump them wherever you want. You don't have to have them connected to a previous like you don't have to add it to a chain of connectors you previously have. You can put down new tiles on one end of the village and just say I'm going to put down my connectors here separate from all my other connectors. So definitely a lot less restrictive.

Yeah, exactly. Uh so that's that's what I'll do for the overview right now. I I think I think some other things come up. Carly might want to fill in some gaps if there's anything I didn't mention, but I'm going to throw it to you first, Carlo. Just like like overview, we've just to clarify, we've played this one time, but we've played Keflower several times. Um and again, Keflower being one of our favorite games. um after that one play like what was your initial like leaving that session heading home like what were your initial thoughts on it? So, you might remember that I said to you guys before we even took the first turn of the game. I said, I suspect I'm going to like some things about this more, and I'm going to like some things about Keyflower more. And I have a [clears throat] feeling I'm going to be frustrated that these both exist separately and that they they you can't take the best of both and [clears throat] kind of make like the ideal version.

Yeah.

And that's exactly how I ended up feeling at the end. Um, I will say after just the one play, keep in mind I've played Keyflower what maybe 10 to 15 times total between Inerson and and board game arena plays um more in person I would say. And so like Keyflower is definitely the better game in my opinion.

Um I think like [snorts] they've definitely streamlined it. Okay, Key to the City London they've made like it's just easier to learn. It would probably be I don't remember how long our game was. cuz I know we were chatting a lot throughout the game and especially a first play usually does take us a decent amount of time but I think realistically once if we had you know known the rules going in it probably is closer to like the hour to hour and a half range whereas keyflower usually is closer to the hour and a half to two plus sometimes sometimes two and a half with setup and with new people and whatnot. So it's definitely streamlined easier to get into. Um, the connectors makes it, like I said, a lot less punishing because you just have more options with putting down these connectors. You can use them for to upgrade multiple like if you have a yellow connector between two tiles, that one connector, um, you kind of leave it there as an option. Do I want to use it for upgrading this one tile?

Do I want to use it for upgrading the other one? And it's e I think you also just put the mele on the tile itself to upgrade it rather than having to like use someone's upgrade action which again sometimes you're having to pay big cost for your in keyflower like do that in someone else's city or whatnot.

And so just to stop you stop you there for one sec cuz both what you just said do you like it better um in Keyflower where you have to get upgrade actions and use those upgrade actions or other people's or do you like it better in London where you just put a mele on the tile to upgrade it? I think I like it in Keyflower more. I think in Keyflower, the other thing is like there's these there's multiple parts that kind of all are tied together here. And it has to it's the upgrades, it's the connectors, and it's the tile distribution that goes not only up for auction, but in people's villages. And this is where I feel the streamlining hurts the game in some ways because I've talked before about how my least favorite part of Keyflower is the uh the logistics aspect of like moving the resources around because it's not just to upgrade the tile. You need to get these resources from your home tile or whatever or wherever they were generated and then take the transportation actions to move them around. You have to get them onto the right tile. And if you're like one movement point short, that could be a huge difference. So, if you don't upgrade that tile, not only could it be like eight points or whatever, but the next time you take that action, if it's not the stronger upgraded version, like these things really compound in key flower, so you feel it when you have a plan that doesn't come together. But I like games where that happens because then you see where you could do better the next time. And I feel like game to game, I would suspect that this is going to feel a bit more sy. It also felt like everyone was kind of doing the same things a little bit more. Right. Right.

In Keyflower, we start with those winter tiles that you keep secret. You have three of those tiles at the beginning, and you're not going to show those to anyone until the very last round when we decide, are you putting one, two, or three of these up for auction. So, suddenly, everyone sees, whoa, there's this last offering of tiles in the final round. Maybe three quarters of these I didn't know were even in the game because people were holding on to them. So, there's all this kind of like surprise scoring. Everyone's been like going for different things throughout the game, but secretly, you know, like I might be going for a lot of tools. you might be collecting a bunch of oil because you're going for this tile that gives you, you know, certain points for every oil that you have at the end of the game, whatever. So, we have all these different lanes to pick and I have these more distinct memories of each game of Keyflower and like what someone's strategy was and how the games played out. And this one, it kind of just felt like we were all getting connectors. We're all trying to kind of get more meuples kind of. But even the extra meuples in Keyflower, it felt like that was a big like one person's going they're like that's the mele per like that player has like they're just hoarding meeples. They're getting all the tile with mele or all the tiles with meeples on them. This other player is going for tools. Okay, we got to stop them from getting tools. And in here it was kind of more it felt a bit more tactical in the sense that like every time it came around it was just is there something out there that's good for me now that will help me and if not is there somewhere where I can block someone or get in someone's way. So, it did feel a bit more tactical, which I generally like, but Keyflower, part of what made it so good is that the way it blends the strategy and tactics.

And I don't know, it just feels like Key to the City London shaves off too many of those. Like, it I wish there was a way to keep all of those interesting things about using the upgrade tiles in people, like transportation tiles in people's village, too. Like, there's games of Keflower where someone has the two biggest transportation tiles in their village, and everyone's deciding the whole game, do I go there? I really need the transportation, but if I do,

and you could intentionally have done that, like you could you could intentionally have been like, you know, I'm not saying it's necessarily going to be like a viable I win every time I do this, but like you could say, "Wow, this game it looks like there's not a lot of transportation tiles like and I think I can win this or no one's bid on this yet." And if you get them all now, you're you have this sort of like engine, so to speak, that if people want to get meaningful movement and upgrades, they might have no choice but to come see you. And that means you can count on getting a whole bunch of meuples. And that creates an interesting dynamic and strategy that sort of comes about without it being feeling like overt and like oh I'm going I'm just yeah just it's just a cool way to sort of approach a a game or strategy that you're doing. Um I agree with pretty much everything that you're saying. I the way I kind of looked at it and I have a hard time describing this, but this is kind of what I landed on is that like I I think over the years I've started to view board games as like if you take if you strip away the theme, if you strip away some of the complexities, like at their core, board games are sort of all the same thing. They're all efficiency simulators. And I shouldn't say all the same thing. I mean like generally a game is is coming comes down to how efficient can I be to score more points than my opponent using the rules and the confines that I have to be able to like maximize what I'm doing. And like and and that's not how I'm saying I approach board games when I play them. I'm just saying that like if you were if you were only focused on winning, if you were only focused on like just doing the best possible or just like that's what you that's what you have fun doing in board games, you're trying to be like how efficiently can I do the things the game

wants me to do to like score points. But like yeah, it that I just in some way boiled it down to that. And what I feel like with Keyflower is that Keyflower adds in enough interesting systems with green meeples with uh the having if you want to upgrade, you have to use the specific upgrade tile that you might not have access to. Keyflower adds in enough different things that it sort of in some ways masks the the the resources efficiency point efficiency thing underneath. It's still there. That's still what you're like working towards if you're trying to win a game and and you're trying to do better than your opponent on. But with Key to the City London, it it lacking some of those um intricacies. I'll say it just means that it felt more obvious to me at times that I was just trying to be efficient with being like well yeah I need to get this resource like I'm just using resource as a blanket general term right now but like I need to get this resource to do this I have three turns to do it and if I felt I found myself sort of falling back into that more whereas with keyflower I would do that sometimes but I was there were so many things that I I would have to think so deeply about like okay well I also have to win this tile I don't know what colors I have I need to be be able to upgrade. I don't have access to the upgrade. I have to hope someone doesn't use that. But I also need to move this resource here. And so I couldn't

Does this person have a green mele left?

Exactly. The green meeples alone. Like the fact that as soon as someone gets a green mele, you know, it's possible they can just win a tile because if they're the only one with a green mele on the table and they bid green, no one can match their green unless they have that boat ability that allows them to or something. So like you really like there there's so many things to consider or so many extra things to consider with keyflower that I think that that's where uh a key to the city of London the more I' I've sat with it is where I just like I didn't want keyflower sort of made streamlined. I think what it revealed for me is streamlining keyflower um makes it a worse game for me. For me personally, like it's just I like the things that are not even I wouldn't say complexities because I like they are they are complexities but I it's I'm not viewing it through the lens of like oh I like Keyfire because it's more complex.

I just like Keyfire because it it layers enough things on top of what's going on on underneath the hood that I don't have to see underneath the hood and be like a little disillusioned by what I'm seeing. Whereas Key City London I see it all and I'm like yeah [snorts] like it's still super fun to do the bidding. still super fun those dynamics on the table. But it did get to the point like I would say like past the halfway point of the game where it just felt like everyone was sort of just like, "Yeah, I have this many many amount of turns left." Not that everyone's doing the calculation, but everyone sees that like, well, yeah, I need this connector. I I'm going to have to upgrade this tile. All I have to do to upgrade is just use a mele. So, I'm going to hold a meo back to do this upgrade. where it's more interesting in Keyflower to be like, I could hold this mele back to do an upgrade, but what if someone goes to that upgrade tile first cuz it's on someone else's uh village and then I don't have enough of that colored mele now. So, do I do that now?

Do I take the risk? Like, there's just way more interesting decisions that were organically coming out in Keyflower.

Yeah, I agree. Even though the connectors and stuff, it feels like a clever way. Like I applaud them for being able to make another version that feels familiar and yet distinct enough because there are going to be people who prefer this who feel like Keyflower is a bit much and just they like the bidding and the way that system works and can get that done quickly. Um but yeah, the the connectors even though they tried to make them kind of thematic, it's like one of them represents like water and electricity and gas. It's like it just that never really it never really felt like it came together thematically. So it just felt like this like I don't know. I don't know how to explain almost like very abstract like

it's just I'm moving these kind of little wooden sticks that are colored but what does it really mean? Like it just felt kind of out of place. So

yeah,

the last thing I want to mention real oh sorry I just that I want to show for a difference was the passing versus setting sail.

Man, I wish they had that in Keyflower. I don't even remember exactly how it worked, but in in base keyflower you could pass and then when it came back around to you could still come back into the round and there was no like detriment to passing. In this game you can choose whether to pass or set sail. And when you set sail, you take your ship and you place it on one of these little spots and you get a reward and whoever sets sail first actually ends up being first player the next round, I believe. And you also get some other benefits. So that was a really interesting thing where I went, "Oh man, like we just house rule that somehow like we'd have to get the components." But that was one where I was like, "I wish this was in Keyflower." So there's maybe one or two things like that where I go, "This was such a good idea." Yeah, I'm torn on that one only because I I so especially for turn order and just having the ability to say I am either passing temporarily or passing permanently I think is a cool dynamic to add. The one thing that you lose with it that I missed was I liked that there was another thing to consider bidding on that in on top of like bidding on all the village tiles and everything. It's like there was this other thing that like people wouldn't put a lot of emphasis on and then suddenly people would realize like oh no but like being able to pick first for some of these ships or even like not having to pick last for some of the seasons where like one of the ships only has like four meuples on it and so you're going to have like a low stock like that's something I really enjoyed having a bid tied to it because it made it so that during the course of the round at any point you could make a bid on that and suddenly you could sometimes feel it shift to the table where someone's like okay hang on I didn't care being first, but I certainly care about not being third or fourth or something. And

suddenly that amps things up. And so you lose that, but you gain this other stuff with this like Yeah. It's like how do you meld those two systems is what I'd be curious to get the best of both worlds.

And now because now that you mentioned, I do miss the bidding of the tiles too and I forgot that those are now eliminated. But the having the option to set sale gives you the interesting choice of ending your round when you might still have a bunch of meuples left. Whereas before it was like, oh, I have meuples. I may as well do stuff with them.

So, it's just like Yeah, that's that that frustrating thing I mentioned at the beginning where it's like why can't we somehow get the best of both? Why do we have to compromise?

So, what's your I know we haven't this is an official review. We didn't brand this dig in or move on. Do you have some sort of verdict whether it's a rating or how do you feel about playing it again?

I'll give my verdict. I just want to call it the two things that I would bring over from key this to Keyflower if if I could. one. Um, there's another added aspect where there are certain tiles that can be upgraded a second time. Um, it's not so much the upgrading the second time that I'm saying I liked. Like I I I did, but it that's it's more that when you upgrade them a second time, you get to put this 3D building on top. That's basically you've erected this building, you get extra victory points for it. I like the aspect that you could go for certain tiles and say, I'm just going to go for a strategy that like like imagine this in Keyflower. I'm going to go for a strategy where I'm going to upgrade these um and just get go for like a more heavy point strategy. But even more than that, it's just the fact that like if you could be erecting different buildings on your village thematically uh and immersively, it just it would look really cool to be able to look around at everyone's and see like oh they built the farm, they built the the windmill or whatever like and see those erected. So you like I just really liked that aspect. I wish they could bring that over. What do you think about that one by the way? Yeah, I think it was great and especially it goes kind of handin-hand with the fact that the art it was a different team of artists from Keyflower. And so the art does look like a different style in here. And for anyone familiar with these other two games I'll mention, uh all of the buildings uh in this look like the same art style as the power plants in Power Grid. Uh or they kind of remind me as well of the houses in Forale, that kind of old cartoonish kind of style. So really nice art. It just it looks a bit different, but uh it fits for the kind of London setting.

Yeah. Um, and then the last one is is something we could bring over and I just I just am interested in it, but I think I don't know if I fully like it or not because I have to play it like a dozen times. And that's the Jennifer variant that's in the rule books or in the rule book for Key of the Say London. I don't even remember now if that like it would be very easy to just do that in Keyflower. I don't know if there's a reason if they just didn't think of it and then when they were doing the rule book for this, they're like, "Hey, there's this cool other variant that we've heard people doing with Keyflower or what." But the Jennifer variant is essentially um when you it's I can't remember now if it's when you get meles back at the end of the round or if it's your losing bids um basically any non new meuples the meeples that you already owned that you're keeping from a previous round go in front of your screen and so now you have this you have some information you can see oh they have access to these colors but they don't have access to I don't know what they have behind their screen. I don't know if I'll ultimately like playing that way more if I like both in different settings. I just thought that was a cool like it was just a cool thing that when I read it I'm like oh that's actually like super intriguing like enough that I would be like can I play that key in Qflower for the next like six plays and then make a decision after that if I like it or not kind of thing.

Yeah, it's it's basically a way to get rid of the hidden trackable information. It'd be like if in El Grande instead of putting them in the Castillo, you just put them beside the Castillo so that people don't have to remember or calculate

but not all of them. Right. Like some some would go in some.

Yeah. Right. Right. So, so you're having to like manage like what you do know with what you don't know. So, I I ultimately I might not end up liking it more. I just thought it was an interesting thing that I hadn't considered until I read it in the rule book. Yeah. Uh so, anyways, my verdict is I would play like I would play this another time just to kind of see if it reinforces the way I feel um or if I start to feel something different after that time and and I want to dig in more. But as of right now, I would feel like I would be ready to like I wouldn't be upset. I would move on and I would be not upset that I'm moving on because I have this amazing game called Keyflower that I know I like more. But again, because I love Keyflower so much and because this is a, you know, a re-implementation of it, I would be willing to give this another shot. But I guess there's just a part of me that feels like I'm not going to necessarily suggest it. I think I I would just suggest Keyflower because we already don't play Keyflower enough. So, it's a hard sell to be like, "Oh, we have the group. We have people who are in that mood for that style of game. let's play the the potentially lesser version when I can play a guaranteed better version and that's

or even a different or even a different game in the key series. I still haven't played key key harvest which you have and there's you also have what Kdum's drag like you have a bunch of these. So

yeah, for me like if we were doing dig in or move on, I would say this is probably a move on for me as well. But I will say this, if I had never played Keyflower and I just played this, it would absolutely be a dig in. And even before playing it, I thought we should play this a few times to compare them. But I just feel like we've saw enough of it in the first play to know like I'm 99.9% confident. I will never like this more than Keyflower. So additional plays beyond this would just be for like the sake of getting into the minutiae for comparing them. So if I don't play Key to the City London ever again, I'd be fine with it. I'd probably rate it a seven out of 10. Uh and Keyflower is still a very strong nine for me.

Very strong 10, I think, is what you meant. But that's okay. We'll I'll I'll edit in post-prouction.

Yeah, you have you have full control in editing.

Uh, and so before we jump into uh, Voyages Marco Polo, we're going to take a quick break for our sponsor. All you can board is proudly sponsored by Victory Pints, our local game store of choice here in Winnipeg, Canada. We strongly believe that Victory Pints is the gold standard of board game stores, not just here in Winnipeg. Their main priority is having a wide selection of games, many of which you won't find elsewhere. They ship Canadawide, $15 flat rate or free shipping for orders over $200 and even take requests to try and order in specific games. They also have a used game section where you can trade in games for store credit and maybe even find some hidden gems that others have traded in. Note that the used game section is only available for in-person purchases and trades. again located in Winnipeg at the corner of Henderson and Hespler. Check them out at victoryypines.ca.

A massive thank you to Victory Pints for all their support over the years. All right, welcome back. And we are about to talk about The Voyages of Marco Polo, a game we've talked about a couple times on the channel previously. Um, and I'm going to throw it to Carlo to give you a little bit of an overview of it and the last time we played it, which was the first time we played it in person.

Yeah. So, this was a 2015 release designed by Simony Luchiani and Danielle Tasini who have done a bunch of the games in the sort of T series together like Zulkin and Teayot Wakan. I mean, there's tons of them now. Won't get into that. Um, so yeah, we reviewed this in detail in October 2022 on our YouTube channel. It was our episode one or two, I can't remember, of our uh retro reviews series that we had done at the time. And just for some context here, last time we did our top 50 games back in 2023, I had it at number 38. Uh, and Dylan, you had it at number 45. So, it was in our top 50, but maybe kind of on the fringes. Uh, I guess that was three and a half years ago that we did that those lists or almost four years ago now. Um, so yeah, in terms of what kind of game is it? So, we're basically it's dice drafting, sorry, dice uh worker placement. So, there are a bunch of spaces on the board. Uh we each have a sort of special character that we start off as that has uh really powerful uh sort of variable player power. We start off in uh Venice or Venezia as it's marked on the board. And the kind of like goal of the game, not always, but there's uh you know there's big points if you make it all the way to Beijing.

So you're moving around on this map uh fulfilling contracts, collecting resources, all kinds of stuff. There's two kind of main forms of uh resources. There's well there's like money and camels are your main things that you need. You know, money is how you pay for a lot of the stuff. Camels often has to do with transportation and there can kind of be some camels can sometimes help you get money. Money can sometimes help you get camels and vice versa. I won't get too into that. And then there's a variety of other resources like gold and uh I think pepper and silk. And so there's these contract tiles on the board that you can collect throughout the game that will say, you know, trade in three silk and two camels for five points and a new contract or whatever. There's all kinds of different combinations of all the things. And uh every round you everyone starts off by rolling their five dice. And then those are your five values for the round. And then you kind of go around clockwise taking turns placing your dice on these action spaces. And the action spaces require either one, two, or three dice to be placed there. And they don't always have to be the same value. If you go to a spot that needs three dice, let's say the strength of the action or the value is determined by the lowest one. So if I place a 1, five, and six altogether where I need three dice, it's a value one action. So it would be worth the same whether I place three ones or a one and a five and a six. I'm kind of wasting that five and the six potentially cuz it's going to count as a value one action. Um the other main thing is that there's some actions where or spaces where only one set of dice can go and then that's it. They're locked for the rest of the round. And then there's other spaces, I think they're colored in blue, where you can place on

top of other colored dices uh dice. So, another player's dice, they can place on yours, etc. Um, but when you do, you have to pay money equal to the lowest value die you're placing. So, let's say Dylan had a value five dice. Doesn't matter what his value is. I can place mine on top, whether it's lower or higher. But, if I place a three on there, I have to pay $3 to match my value three die in order to take that action. So, everything in this game is very, very, very tight. You never feel like you have enough money. You never feel like you have enough camels. you never have enough actions to get what you need to get done. Um there's a literally an option on the board where you have to place two dice just to move around just for transportation. And there's so it costs a lot of money and camels just to move two three spots. And sometimes you might not even get a reward from moving right away. There's places you can get to on the board to set up trading posts to either get immediate abilities or long-term abilities stuff that you can that triggers at the beginning of every round, etc., etc. So, there's just a variety of ways to get points, you know, the sooner you get to Beijing. Um, and you only score for leftover resources at the end of the game if you actually made it to Beijing and set up a trading post.

So, you can play this game in a variety of ways. I've seen people, depending on their character, not move at all and just spend the whole game standing still going resources, fulfilling contracts. There's other people who are flying all around the board setting up trading posts. Uh, every game feels like it has played out differently. So, like Dylan said, we'd played this exclusively on Board Game Arena for the past few years. Probably logged for me probably between 10 and 15 plays. I really, really liked it. Finally got a physical copy. We played it in person. And Dylan, why don't you tell us uh what our four characters were for this game.

For sure. Yeah. So, uh we our friend Dave had Kubla Kublaon, um which is they start in Beijing, which is wild because part of one of the things you can you strive for in the game is trying to make it across the map to Beijing. The first person there gets 10 victory points. Uh, this character, you start in Beijing and you get the 10 victory points as if you travel there. Now, you started on the right side of the map, which has its own potential benefits. You have easier access to Sumatra where there's three different um uh abilities you can or things you can then use your dice on. I think every other spot on the map only has one action that it opens up. So, Sumatra, depending what has been randomized to be there at the start of the game, um could uh be really beneficial to be able to go there. So, you get quicker access to that. Uh Braden had Matteo Polo. I don't know. Is that like Marco Polo's like lesserk known younger brother or is that

Matt put me on the spot? I think it's okay.

Son, but yeah, maybe Matteo Polo. uh he got access to a white dye uh every round, which is another die that he gets to roll and be able to use, as well as one new contract every round off the special pile of contracts that aren't sort of assigned at the start of the game. So, he's getting a free contract every round. Again, very powerful.

And to take a new contract, you have to place two dice on the space to get one or two new contracts. So, that's saving you a lot of extra actions. And the other thing I want to mention about the white dye real quick is we said like if I go to an action space and I'm yellow, I place a yellow dye, I can't place another yellow dye on top of my own, but if I have that white dye, I can place a white die on top of the yellow. So it gives you more flexibility to double up on actions, too. Not only giving you a sixth die when only everyone everyone else has five. So

yeah, totally. Um Carlo, you had Burkcon. Burka, uh, where you didn't all that stuff you mentioned about having to pay, uh, when you're putting dice on top of other dice depending on the values didn't matter to you cuz you don't pay anything when using occupied spaces, blue spaces. So, uh, hugely strong ability and and throughout the game, like I felt like we constantly kept forgetting that you had that because again, it's breaking the rules, but that's that's your individual.

The amount of times someone went, "Uh, did you pay for that?" And I go, "Uh, Burka doesn't pay." Oh, yeah, right. I forgot. at least 10 times that game. It's like I don't pay.

Great feeling. Great feeling.

Yeah. Oh, yeah.

Um and then I had Merc Merkar X to Breeze. Uh which was when another player takes goods from the Grand Bazaar um I take one free good of whatever they choose. So if they go there to get uh silk, whatever. It doesn't matter what how many silk they're getting, whatever. I just wait to see what they've grabbed and then I grab one of that resource as well. Also feels very great to just whenever it's not my turn. Every time someone wants to go there, I feel like I'm benefiting from or not. I even feel like I am benefiting.

It's interesting though that yours is a That one was a very It's a passive ability. You're not

Yeah, it is.

You have to play around it, but you're not actually like doing anything differently other than observing what resources people are allowing you to take, right? Like,

but I So, yeah, it's 100 like I would I totally agree. It is absolutely a passive ability, but what I think I was surpris I we've played with this ability in play before. I cannot remember if I actually had this ability previously and if I did it would have been online and it felt different but in this inerson play it's funny how a passive ability felt active in the sense that I would have to try to factor in okay I don't have this but this resource but what are the chances I think that Carlo is going to go to the bizaar and potentially use spot I'm having to like look at what other people are doing and say even not specifically do I think someone's going to get gold it's like I might I might have multiple outs and I'm just like, I just need a resource. And it could be silk, it can be uh pepper, it can be gold. And so I just look and I say, okay, I think there's a high chance someone's going to go to the bizaar this this round. So I'm not going to go because I know I can get my resource through them. But if they don't, I I'm hooped. And so having to factor that into my decisions really, really fun.

And I I really like that aspect.

Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's a great show because I I didn't mean to downplay at all cuz you you won and you played an extremely good game. And I don't say this, I I didn't say the passive thing to downplay at all. I just meant it's interesting that the like a lot of the other abilities like the being in Beijing with a trading post is like you are on the other side of the map playing a different game at the start. Matteo Polo, it's like you're getting an extra white dye and a free contract every round. you were playing a different game and Burkcon not having to worry about money is like these are it's just yours is constantly permeating throughout and you have to be I think yours if anything you had to be more observant and aware of everyone else's game plan and if you see that I have five or sorry three number five dice and you see that I have a contract that requires gold and I don't currently have gold you're probably looking being like he's going to place those three on that gold spot I can just wait to get the gold that I need but how long do I wait

you feel yeah it makes feel much more in tune with the game that's happening around you. And I think I don't I don't often

I shouldn't say I don't often play games that way, but but like it's not the way I default to playing. And so being forced to with my ability sort of be more in tune with what everyone else is doing and and how that might impact me. I'm not saying I did that the best I I could have done, but it was just an interesting thing for my brain to have to focus on that.

Yeah. And it's Yeah. It's tough for other people to play around that character. So

yeah. Um, so the this being our first in-person play, but also the fact that like I feel like every time at least every time I played this game, there's like a long gap between plays that we of it. Um, I've I've I've every single time I played this game, my initial impression has always been, "Oh, I forgot how much I liked this game." Like it feels like that's always the impression I leave with. And because this time was in person, because we've played it a numerous times, even though they have been spaced apart, this felt like the play that sort of solidified it for me as like a game that not only do I want to keep coming back to, but I would like I I wouldn't be opposed at all to this sort of becoming a bit of like an evergreen lifestyle game for our group at some point where it's not like the only game we're playing, but like we we come back to it like we do games like Keyflower and stuff more often because the variability of the setup uh um with like where all the the stuff gets laid out on the map and and like I really enjoyed that in this session completely at the start of the game. Um, I won't get like super far into it cuz you'd have to have the board to understand what I'm saying in front of me in front of you. But like every there was a path that I could take to go sort of detour at the start down to Alexandria and [snorts] I did that and no one else really did it because there was an ability there that I saw that I'm like if I get access to this early and I utilize it a lot, I think it'll really benefit. I think it was my money engine or something that was going to be less.

It was it was either a money or camel engine. And I remember thinking like that's a lot of resources to spend really early to go there.

Yeah.

And I was wondering if it was going to pay off for you.

Yeah. But like even just the having that decision at the very start of a of a game to be like I'm going to try this detour cuz and I don't know if it's going to pay off, but if no one else does and I'm the only one, it could be a huge payoff kind of thing. Um like you can make decisions like that or you can look at Sumatra and say, "Wow, Sumatra is stacked." And especially if someone didn't like have the ability to just start in Beijing like we did did in this game, you might be like, maybe I'm going to rush to Sumatra and be the first one to get access to all those. But again, that might cost you a whole bunch of money going across the water. Is there an engine? Like there's so many decisions that you make just looking at the board at the start of the game that it kind of feels like a sandbox game despite despite it being more combined than what I would consider sandbox games, if that makes sense. It's like when I when I think of like talking about Feast for Odin as a sandbox game, it's because there's so many actions.

It's like what am I going to do this round? But with this, it's like you look at the board setup and if you're familiar with the game, you say, "Okay, like what do I think is going to be beneficial?" Like what do I think is going to work? I've never seen this this ability end up here or this action, I should say, end up here. And so it just like that to me is super intriguing and exciting and it's felt that way every time I've played. Um, but another thing I feel like I've gotten over is that in my initial plays, I would get frustrated by the restrict restrictedness of Marco Pluto. I liked it, [snorts] but I was I was always a little bit frustrated by how hard it was to travel sometimes, how hard it was to like get enough money or enough camels. And I think what I've come to appreciate after this play is that not every game is going to have the same thing be hard to get or hard to acquire, but every game is going to have something that is hard. And so it's about navigating that and saying, "Okay, well, I certainly can't go all in on the thing that's going to be hard to acquire because I'm going to be fighting all game just to do stuff while other people are utilizing the things that are easier." It's it's like you can't be stubborn that stubborn in this game. You can be a little stubborn, but you have to sort of let the game speak to you by looking at the board and then it's like how well you've interpreted that conversation is how well you do that game. And I I just I really liked that in this game. And so, um, I'm glad it seemed like everyone else liked it, too, because I would definitely be one pushing to say like, let's put this in the rotation more often, even just to find out like, does it have the legs to be played 10 times in a year, and do we still want to play it at that point?

Yeah, man. Honestly, I'm super happy to hear you say that. I I suspected that you had a really good play of it. I think we all left there being like, man, we should play this more often. And I think where I landed on it was and just actually before that I used to just going back to something you said I used to feel like I had to do a bit of everything in this game and that I was like forcing myself to be like but if I don't travel around I'm not going to get those abilities and I had I there was like a point where I don't know it was the eighth game I played or something where I kind of realized like I don't have to get everything done. It's okay if I don't move around the board that much this game. And like you said, it's all about reading the variability of not [snorts] only which tiles are in play and where they are, but which characters are available that game, too. And what are other people going to be doing? And everything is constantly a reassessment of people's priorities, too, at the beginning of the round. Like, yeah, I need this resource or I need to grab contracts, but can I wait for my second or third action? Is that going to be available? Or do I have to take my first action there and then maybe lose out on something else? or you can go somewhere where it kind of blocks other people or makes things difficult. So, it just feels like an unsolvable game. Like, it feels like it's just a new I think of those like uh procedurally generated video games where it's like it's the same rules, but you're in a different level every time you boot it up and it's a different thing to figure out where to go and stuff. Like, it kind of feels like that.

It's like it's a new problem to solve, a new set of parameters every time. Um, but it's just there's something comforting about it, too. And I think as far as I want to ask you like as far as dice placement games uh go, where does this rank for you or games that primarily use like whether we're lumping in games like Castles of Burgundy and Evolution, like the Feld kind of games, but also other dice placement games we've played like I guess Bku and trying to think of

like it definitely ranks high up. I I think I need to now that I've experienced it again in person, I need to have a couple more inerson plays that are closer together to just really or or just sit down to like craft something like a top 50 to like really ask myself some of those questions. But I I think it really does rank high up. I I It's funny like I I I would be interested I I think I've had the ability in the past, but I would be interested to play with the character that you had in person um a couple times because I I I love and hate, which is probably the best feeling, but I love and hate the restriction of when you place dice on top of someone else, someone else is having to pay. But I too,

but I wonder I wonder if like playing that character will end up making it one of my favorite characters because I get the joy of being the only one at the table not having to do that. But also, it's just like it's taking that that aspect out of the game for that session for me. I don't have to consider that. I can consider other things. I I don't like I don't I'm not saying I dislike that mechanic enough that it's like something that's pulling the game down for me, but it is something that like there was times where I I was mapping something out and I was like I can do all this and that would be the one thing on my head holding me up or or being the roadblock preventing me from being able to do it. And maybe that is a good thing. Maybe that's what makes the game feel tight and restrictive in a positive way. But it did make me like be envious multiple times of your character specifically in that game because I'm like, "Oh, I would love to just not be charged for all this."

Yeah, of course. Of course. And that's that's the beauty of this game is you feel like everyone else's, but no matter what power you have and the other players have, you always feel like everyone like it's unfair. Like everyone else's power is better than yours, right? And everyone else feels like your power is better than theirs. Um, but I want to shout one thing we didn't touch on, especially because we've touched on how punishing and unforgiving the game can be and all that kind of stuff and how specific you have to have and not being having enough resources. I want to talk about the mitigation real quickly that you can have in this game and the risk takingaking that you can do to have bigger turns in bigger rounds. So, as I said at the beginning of the round, by default, you roll five dice, but there's depending on player count when you play with the max four players, I think it's five black dice that get added onto the board that are just like there there's no value yet. And at any point you have these three free actions that you can take on your turn. So one is you can spend one camel to I think it's just roll a dieice. And then it's or no, what is it? It's two camels I think to increase or decrease the value of a die by one. So you can move a four down to a three or a five for two camels. Or I think you pay Oh yeah, it's one camel to roll a die, two to do that, or then three camels. You gain a black dice from the board and you just roll it and add it to your pool of dice. But you can only gain one of those black dice per turn so that everyone has at least one chance to get one. So sometimes you have these rounds where you might get three extra black dice or something like that.

And even just talking about this power with the extra money. I you know often times when you don't have this character, you immediately go for that if someone has a six, they go for that spot to get six camels cuz you don't want to pay a bunch of coins after to then take fewer camels. But that was one where I just never had to worry about that cuz at any point in the round I can just go there. I don't have to pay anything and I just got a whole bunch of camels. Then I can use those camels to get a black dye to get another dice to take more stuff. Like it felt like it fed into this engine. And so sometimes if you feel like, oh, I'm a little bit short on this resource or I need this die to be a value five, but it's a four. You always have some room to be like, well, you got some camels. Do you want to roll? But that's a risk. Do you want to instead pay more camels for the reassurance to manipulate the dice the way you want? And that little bit of mitigation along with the fact that if you don't get a certain value of your five dice at the beginning of the round, you also get compensation in the form of extra I think if your five dice total less than 20, if you get like 13 total from your values, you get the the seven difference in money and camels. So there's a lot of I like that. Yes,

it's really really smart because if someone did get five ones and someone got five sixes, it happens consistently, it can make a big difference. So I don't know. I just think the game is really really smart. really welldesigned and it's it's been 11 years and I feel like it holds up extremely well. Um, uh, how I'd like to sort of like wrap this up because verdict-wise, it's a little different because we've obviously played this, we talked about it in retro reviews and stuff, but so I'm going to ask you sort of on the spot here and you don't this you you won't have neither of us will have an exact answer, but what what in your mind, do you think that if you were to right now do a top 50 that it would be higher than the spot 38 that you had it at before? And do I think it would be higher than the spot 45 I had before? Like, do you think it's grown on you? Do you think it stayed the same? Do you think it might have dropped?

Here's the thing. I think my opinion of the game has not lessened. It's either the same or possibly even slightly improved just because the playing it in person really solidified. And to answer one of your questions from earlier that I didn't, I think I would love to play this ideally like three or four times per year. I think that'd be perfect like once per quarter kind of thing. At least with the amount of gaming time we have now. Maybe in the future play it monthly or whatever, but like just just being realistic. or a couple times a year in person and have some BGA games going. Um, but yeah, how about you?

I so I think um I my opinion has definitely grown. Um, and I think I can confidently say it's going to be higher than 45 because really before this play it would have slipped off the list cuz we just hadn't played it enough. I it wasn't on the top of my my brain. There's a lot of other games we've played since we last did that list that would have to go on to the top 50 and stuff, but that play really I think helped it. I'm not saying it's going to climb from like 45 to like 19 or something like that. Like some huge jump, but I wouldn't be surprised that this is in like the 30 to 40 range for me. um and that it could comfortably sit there or like grow a bit if we were like you're saying playing three or four times a year because I just after that play I just feel like there's so much more to uncover that I it took I think playing it in person uh to really sort of solidify for me that it has that that like that amount of legs and it's interesting like I knew that from the online plays but I guess it just goes to show like there's something about tactile nature having in front of you and like being able to really like look at other people's uh what they're doing across the table, looking at the board, analyzing it rather than doing it on a screen that I just connected with the game more strongly than I did on the online plays, even though it was still a strong impression from the online plays.

For sure. I think it really does help playing it in real time as well. Not only for something like a passive ability like we were talking about, but if you come back and you just look, oh, the recap says I collected a gold and a spice when it wasn't my turn. Cool. But like, are you going to go really look into what the other players did? Are you remembering from turn to turn what your plans were in terms of like you assessed the board, you looked at everything laid out, you I don't know. You It's just a different experience. So

yeah,

but yeah, I think it would I think it's probably going to be in a similar range for me. Like I wouldn't be surprised if it cracks my top 50, but just based on how many other games I've come to love in that time that I I know I like a bit more, it could slip out of the top 50. But either way, I don't see it going any lower than like the 50s or 60s. It's it's a really really solid game. it if it slips out, it'll be at the window of the top 50 house peeking in, waiting to sort of break in next year, right? That's the that's the metaphor I'm using.

Absolutely. But yeah, I do want to try to get the uh Agents of Venice expansion as well as the new character. I think just having those new a bunch of extra characters would just add a bit more longevity to the game. And I know technically there's a crowdfunding one that went up not too long ago. I didn't like the art choices they went with. I don't know. I don't agree with whatever. It doesn't make sense to me to package number one and two. I would never want like if I ever liked two enough, I would just keep that and sell number one, but I like number one way more than number two. So, I mean, for people who are interested in both and have never played them, like it's not that it's a bad starting point to go. And I think the crowdfunding campaign is closed anyway. I didn't not too up to speed with crowdfunding these days. I apologize.

Um,

when I saw that and then I got a physical copy, I was of number one, I was like, I don't really need to look into this too much. But yeah, anything to to add a bit more longevity and variability would be good. But I I I could still play this easily another 20 times just with what's in the base game.

Totally agree. Um and so those are our two games. This is uh been a bit more of a condensed episode. Um but also focused on on games and we're going to try to do these a little bit more often um in between the discussions so that you guys can have the best of both worlds and we can have the best of both worlds where we get to discuss and dive into more hard-hitting or meaty topics, veggie topics um as well as talking about specific games in almost like a review style as well. So, um, thank you so much for, uh, being here for this episode. As always, if you want to find all of our videos and past content, you can do that at youtube.com/allucin board. Um, if you'd like to chat with us and our amazing community, we have a Discord. You can join us on that Discord. The link is in our show notes, and you can find it on YouTube as well. Um, if you want to support us beyond just uh, subscribing, liking, leaving comments. If you want to do anything beyond that uh monetarily, we do have a Patreon that you can uh join for some extra perks and to help us uh keep doing what we're doing. Um and uh other than that, we will be back in 2 weeks time for episode 19. Thank you so much for listening and we will see you then. Happy gaming.

Progress saved