Beast: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion over Beast. Uh one of the newest hidden movement games that came out uh last year, I think. 2023, I think is when this game came out. Um so here's the thing about this game is I had Yeah, it was 2023. I had originally backed this game um cuz hidden movement is a genre that I really like cuz I find it kind of difficult to execute because of the staples of that are like, "Hey, these are the really good ones. How are you going to differentiate yourself that makes me want to play your your hidden movement game over you know, those other ones?"
Right. Uh so I got this game in. I got like all the Kickstarter stuff. This was before they went out for their expansions. And I was like, "You know what? I don't really want to play this." So I ended up selling it. And then it they went on Kickstarter again and I was kind of like looking at it cuz I get advertised a bunch for late pledges. And I'm like, "All right, let me just take a look at it again cuz I really like the theme. Like I think the theme is really cool of one big monstrous uh European folklore beast." Mhm. Um it gives me a sense of and I was trying to I was hoping you had at least heard of the video game um but it gives me the sense of that shitty video game that I cannot remember where it's four hunters chasing after a beast that has to level up as they go.
It's kind of similar to to that. Uh so the theme was something I was really interested in. Then I watched the play through and I'm like, "Okay." Plus someone selling it and I bought it. Um and for me, I got to say they do a lot of really different things here. Yeah. Like I actually think this is a hidden movement game that I'll end up keeping cuz I do like a lot that it has to offer. Um so before we get into that, uh what do you think? What do you think of of Beast? I'm torn on it because I like aspects of it and I dislike other aspects of this game. Okay. Um So let's start with the negatives. Let's start with the the overall negatives of the game cuz yeah, this game is not perfect by any means, but I don't really think any hidden movement game is.
Right. Um So some of it is probably wording is poor in a lot of aspects where they use words that have a traditional meaning, but then when you look at the rule scape, so they use nearby to me, orthogonal plus your location plus yourself. Yeah. So it's like nearby hunters get this. Well, when we read it, we understood what nearby meant, we assumed you're helping an ally. Mhm. Well, you are, but you also it's always affecting you, but it's also helping your ally. Yeah. And that might have changed a few things for us cuz we would have had some bonuses that realistically one of us took to versus the other player.
Other. Yeah, well cuz yeah, nearby is like yeah, adjacent locations, but then it it explains like, "Oh hey, nearby means adjacent locations." But then you look at it again, it's like, "No, it also means yourself." It's like, "Well, yeah, that kind of comes down to when you're playing cooperative games and it says helping allies, are you an ally to yourself?" Right. No. Right. I mean in that context, but almost always it does Right. you as well. Um so I do agree because nearby locations like I make sense it thematically in the context of the game. Right. But mechanically it is a little odd. Right. And you can change the wording to something like within one space of you cuz they use space on a lot of other things, too.
So just let's keep it consistent say uh all hunters within one space get X. Yeah. It's not adding that many words, you know, in addition. It clarifies a lot problems with it. Mhm. Um Cuz I will say one thing that they do is they they try to minimalize the text. The text for the most part is very clear cut. Right. Rage, all this card does is attack. I know what attack means. It does one damage if I'm the hunter or if I'm the um uh well, this is the beastly talent. So if I'm the beast using it, then I reveal myself and I deal one damage to whatever is there. Right. Unless I have a thing that does more. Yeah. Um for a lot of kind of especially recent hidden movement games, that is kind of like muddy it up with just like a bunch of rules that's like okay, you're doing away with the simplicity and now I don't really want to learn and play your game over and over. This one was very streamlined but maybe to sometimes it's detriment.
Yeah. And again, if it was created by cuz we've seen this with other games that come out like Eastern Europe where they translate into English, there is a translational issue that comes from it. Um we've seen that before other games. So to me, again, you you can get around it. But you have to be aware of that. Yeah, it's one of those that after you play like a couple times, you're going to know exactly that okay, here when a card says nearby, that means yourself as well as adjacent areas. Right. Um or if it says nearby hunter, that means yourself and adjacent areas to you. Right. Um other annoyances in this I mean people might think this is minor, but the fact that we are taking damage there's lots of things that can take damage.
Mhm. You basically have no damage counters in this game. No, yeah. You have six ones and then they immediately go to threes which I get, but this can play up to four players. Mhm. So the very fact that you can't even have eight ones because that's where theoretically you could all be at two Yeah. before the first person hits three. You don't have enough for that. Yeah. Let alone that everything on the board can also take damage. Yeah, except for the sheep. The sheep are the only things that die in one hit or in the battle and like the summons. And the summons. Um but yeah, like boars take two, uh bears take two Right. and the settlers take two or three on top of the hunters on top of the beast itself. It goes up to five. So to me there's those that's an issue.
Um it's a hidden movement game that has multiple win cons in it which I do like. Um and maybe in this game we just have focus of trying to kill the beast versus trying to do other things with it. Yeah. Um Yeah, because in every other hidden movement game it's one objective per. Right. Uh Letters from Whitechapel Jack has to get home all four nights. Right. Four nights, yeah. Yeah. Fury of Dracula he just has to stall out for 13 weeks or get his get his whatever Yeah, so basically get the influence high enough to Uh cause enough fear. Yep. Um and then Specter Ops I think it has like you have to get in and get out. Right. But this is like one of the few that are like oh the hunters can win by I mean depends on the contract. I think they're all the same.
Yeah, all the all the Well, sorry. Um one Yeah, three out of four of the contracts, which are just depend on players, um are hunters win if they last three nights. Right. The only other one for two to three players is shipwreck, which is in the final night the beast actually wins. Duh. Um but yeah, it's either kill the beast for the hunters or survive the night for the most part. And the beast has to do different things. Yeah, depending on what the contract is. Like the northern settlements in the four-player game is the beast wins when three settlers are dead. Right. Um northern gods is the beast wins with four settlers are dead. Um and I think the contract thing is cool. I think that's a really neat aspect. It just kind of feel like, "Oh, okay. Each night if you complete an objective, you complete the contract and you get a benefit for that."
Right. Um both the beast both players have it. Um I think that's very neat. And obviously, this being basically the base game, you are very very limited on player count. If you have a player count of four, then you have two contracts to choose from. Um and in a two or three player game, you have two contracts to choose from. Right. Um so more expansions adding more contracts would just add more variety cuz they also determine what map you're playing on. Mhm. Um which like this the the Drenchlands is is broken up into two zones and then the other zone is broken up into can't remember off the top of my head.
Four. Yeah. Yeah, there's four zones, but there's a bunch more settlers more more villagers to go after and and so on and so forth. Um you want to go into my biggest negative? Yeah. It's the movement. So I I wasn't going to say that because it's really from your side of it, but yeah, the movement's bad. The movement's I wouldn't go so far and say it's bad, it's janky. Um, but I for a hidden movement game, I guess it needs to be more clear-cut. It's bad in the sense that the ability to track what you've done is very difficult. Yeah. And there's too much opportunity for it to get mixed up, to not be able to follow a trail. Because here's the thing, here's the problem with all hidden movement games. You have to trust the person who's doing the hidden movement is doing it correctly.
Yeah. And I've played games of Fury of Dracula where I forgot to put the water card down and cuz you have to take a damage as well when you go over water and it throws the game. Or you caught yourself when I went to a spot and you didn't put a second marker and then you looked at the card quickly and realized well, yeah, I mean, you put another marker. or actually, no, I didn't go there. Oops, because all movement is done in or you know, the the compass spaces, north, south, east, and west and you just keep an active movement trail. So, if I move two spaces and I want to move south and south, I put two south cards down. And there's enough cards in here that you're not really ever going to be like, "Oh, I'm out of south cards." Um, so at least I enjoy that. Right. But, you should have just done numbers.
You could have kept the terrain, just make it to where every section has a small number next to it. Yes, and you just write it down and you trace it. Cuz what Hunt for the Ring does, have you played Hunt for the Ring? I haven't, yeah. Okay, so we really need to try that cuz that's another great hidden movement game. Uh, so Letters from Whitechapel, I think, and a bunch of other ones give you a sheet to write on. Um, Hunt for the Ring has like a hollowed-out section and you just fold a piece of paper and slide it in. It's like, "Here's your Get your own paper." Uh, Friday does the same thing. Okay, yeah, it's like, look, you have paper. Just slide it into the slot and write on it. Right. Um, and it's not like, I've never been like, "How cheap?" It's like, okay. Because, yeah, you're right. Like, if I was able to be like, okay, I went to 22, then 19, then 76, then 34, and then you move down, and then it's like, "Okay, uh, yes, I have been to 76."
Right. I've been to 76 twice, cuz I can see I wrote down 76 twice. Right. Uh, and here, it's like, you kind of as the beast have to always be looking at your last known location, and then you're running deck of cards. Uh, and half the time, what I would do is I, cuz there's the mini map that the beast can use. Uh, half the time, like, I think one time whenever you went back into the village, and you were like, "Have you been there?" And I was like, "No." And then I was like, "Well." And then I think you moved back, and I was like, "Well, no, I'm not there, either." And I looked over, then I had to look at my card. I was like, "Oh, no, it says east. Yes, I did actually go there." Right. Or the antithesis of that is that, uh, I think it was like at the beginning where I went all the way, I basically went north, and then went around this way, which you caught on pretty quickly, but you went like here, or here, and then I put a token down. I was like, "Oh, [ __ ] no, I didn't go that way. I went straight north and banked around that one specific spot, but I put a token there, and then I have to be like, 'Sorry, no, I didn't go there,' which gave you all the information, where it's like, okay.
Right. But it'd be dishonest to just leave it there, where it's like, "Well, no, I didn't go that way." The other, I call biggest negative for me is, again, not enough components. The action card deck isn't large enough. Um, we saw the same cards every single round, practically. Yeah. Um, which to a certain extent isn't bad, but at the same time, it's like, but these are the same cards. It's, there's lots of double movement cards. There's lots of Well, if you find this, do this. And while it is interesting drafting, a lot of times you still are drafting just the same cards over and over again to your hand-ish.
Like there's a most of the times I had to at least two, if not three, of the same cards I've had in the entire game. Yeah, that's not necessarily a negative for me because I think this game kind of comes down to like what you loved about Whitechapel. Is it comes down to more about the how the the beast is leveling up and how they're going to be maneuvering and going after their contract versus what the hunters are out. So, if you have a fat stack of action cards where every time you draw it's like there's no way to be like, "Well, [ __ ] What did he draft?" Well, I guess you're drafting, so it doesn't really matter. Right, that's what I mean. Because you're drafting, it's fine. Yeah, just have a big deck of action cards cuz then they would be like There's more you Cuz again, like Yeah. you hated the fact that I got the prowl and I bought it back for health.
Right. Because then I could basically just constantly move around trying to get away from you. that because that meant you were at two health and I just had to hit you once. Well. But yes, it's um But again, having more different variety in cards cuz at some point just kind of like, "Well, these are all the same-ish like we're only seeing the same cards." Mhm. There's no variety in it. Yeah, it it's not really a positive or a negative for me because yeah, it does kind kind of come down to what you know, there are still some cards being left out. It would be really bad if it was always like you ran out of action cards. Um Right. Cuz so cuz there's kind of some Have you ever played Inish? Yeah. Okay, so Inish has that where it's like you draft through the act but you pull one out. Right. And you But you don't know what it is.
Right. Um Love Letter does have this well. Yep. So, they do something similar to that where it's like some action cards are removed. So you don't know entirely okay which card did you keep which card did that person keep? Right. In the four player game it's something different where you set aside one card for the beast player then everyone gets three. Yeah. So he gets one secret card. But cuz to counter kind of your point if it was a fat stack of action cards yes you are drafting. Let's say there were 50 I don't know 50 action cards. We still do the same four they're unique and it's like okay cool but then you get one that lets you look through the entire deck and pull one. It's like okay well what the [ __ ] you know there's 30 cards there you get to pick like we can't like at least in like playing this game a ton when you go through the unused it's like well I don't have this and they haven't played it so maybe this is what he grabbed.
Right. I think I I do cuz I love variety as well. I would like more action cards. But not like a whole bunch more maybe like 10 10 more action cards. Um Because also at the end of the day this game is not that long. Uh Which is a good thing. Which I actually enjoy because one thing a Fury of Dracula even though while I love the cat and mouse chase it's always three four hours. Yeah most of mine I think take two and a half hours. Yeah. Um It's like I mean and that's if like I like I don't think I've ever had to be under three hours. Um and that game has a lot of well we got him no we don't well we got him no we don't which I mean can be really dynamic if you get into it.
What's great about this game is it's I mean it's a lot of like yeah I'm I'm moving but now I'm revealed cuz I need to attack. Right. Um you guys are able to go in and find me or find my trail pretty quickly. Um And then that kind of leads to a good chase. Right. Like, for me, whenever it came down to the final night uh or the second night, I was like, "They know exactly where I'm at. How the hell am I going to get out of this?" And then, I realized, "Oh, I get to start the next night. Hopefully, I get a bunch of attack cards, and that goes well." And man, whenever I moved to attack you, and then you flipped that trap, I was like, "Oh, it's going to completely like the complete destroy my whole plan." And it could have It could have been a better trap um that allowed you to like move out of the way. And it's like, "Oh, no."
And that's why I really like this one. It's not overly long. It has that prey-predator kind of feeling that Fury of Dracula has, cuz Fury of Dracula is like, "Okay, daytime, it's all the investigators' turn. The nighttime, it's like, 'Haha, now it's my turn.'" And I like that. Yeah. Here, it's like, "Okay, as the beast, you know what? I killed some of these sheep. I killed a bear. Um that's like eight uh grudge tokens coming my way. I'm going to be a good attacker that deals two damage now whenever I kill with like it Right. Whenever Now, I can petrify. Um so, this part of the game, I think, is really cool Yeah. of leveling up the beast and even leveling up the hunters. Yeah, we didn't get to level up very often because like they say, and this is one of those things where it is interesting, if you want to go level up, you have a lot of opportunity to go level up cuz basically, a lot of things give you grudge.
Yeah. Um for us, I want to say there was one, maybe two cards. Um us one, and then we had to complete the contract for one more. Right. But, when a lot of your abilities are significantly more expensive, it's pretty hard to get much grudge for us. Well, also, you got to think about it. If I want to go out and get grudge, I'm revealed the entire time. Right. But, so like, cuz Brett and I were you know, halfway almost empty to go all the way over here when you went this way. You could have killed as many sheep as you liked at that point. That is true. And realistically, if I hadn't chased you over onto that side, I would have assumed that's what you would do. Uh, yeah, though my initial thing was to beeline it for the was was actually kill the boar that I did end up killing. Um, because I was like, "Oh, it's two sheep or a boar. I'm going to get the same amount of grudge anyway." Uh, but at the same time, that basically means I I wouldn't be able to do that because that would mean I'd have to have a [ __ ] ton of attack and a [ __ ] ton of move cards and I'm just not going to have that much. It's either a little bit of movement and a little bit of attacking or a lot of attacking, no movement. So, like the beast, at least Raga specifically, the way I played and built, wasn't allowing me to um, do that. Now, the thing about Raga that's really cool is they were huge on transforming. They wanted this entire map to be that those flower locations
and then I would have been popping off. Um, but I just never did that. And that's cool. That gives some replayability of the of the different beasts cuz there's five, six in the in the I I guess in the first Kickstarter. There's Raga, which is a snake hog bad. He's a giant boar. Um, Mara, I think it's a vampire. Okay. Fangrir, there is no way that is not a play either on Fenrir Yeah. or looks like the wolf from Dark Souls 1. Asmira, No idea what that is. And then Bolgan. Mhm. Um, that all have different um, summons, different abilities, and different you know, the beastly talents are unanimous, but different starting cards.
Right. Um So, it seems like they all have one Um God, that scared me. They have one major Like every single uh beast has one has the same ability, which is making their attacks deal two damage. Got it. Uh all of them have that. But, Raga has five health, Bol'gahn has five health, Asmira has four, Fang Krewe has four, Mara has four, and Hogban has five. Got it. Um So, tons of variety there, and then you have two, four, six Yeah. six characters to choose from that again, each of them have their own unique ability cards. Well, so what is is there's actually you only get one unique. Everyone has the same two.
Oh, the hunt and track. They're all the same. Okay. Oh, yeah, I'm seeing it cuz it's up at the top. Scout, Cleaver, Trap Master. Which I find a little interesting that you can see you have these ability cards that are all you, you know, set to yourself, that they're not all three unique when like you have four unique cards to yourself. Uh yeah. So, Yeah, that is true. I wonder if that's something they're addressing in the expansion. I don't know what the expansion is bringing specifically. Um But yeah, like this one just kind of feels a little bit more aggressive on both ends just the sheer nature of like very limited on time. Um the fact that to even attack, I have to reveal myself. Uh which is huge. Um And you're you I mean, you guys find the trail pretty easily.
Which is neat cuz Yeah. cuz I know in many many games of Whitechapel and Fury of Dracula, if you just cannot get a clue, it's like, why are we even playing? Like if you're like if you cuz like letters from Whitechapel you have to figure out clues and hopefully get enough of them that lead you okay, here's the direction he took. His so his hideout's probably somewhere up here. Um man, if you just don't get those, then it's like okay, no idea where he's at. Uh I mean here I felt like you guys were like, okay, so here's what he did. He's right here. He's over here. Like, okay, I'm going to go in real and attack and it's like, yep, I'm there. Right. Cuz in this particular game, I uh like I I had three damage. I mean just one like one of your turns, it's like okay, I guess I'm probably dying. Like if I didn't knock you and Brett out uh when you got in, you probably would've damaged me at least once.
Yeah. And then Brett would've came in and I just have to sit here and take the damage. Right. And there's no way to heal that I can Yeah, there's no healing that I know of. Yeah, which would be shitty. That would be really annoying if like it's like, oh hey, a beastly talent. Heal one damage. It's like that took forever to deal one damage. Right. Um and maybe that's why they kept the action cards smaller because there are the talents you can get that are unique. There are items that you guys can get that are unique. Yeah. Um that allow you to be a little bit different whereas the action cards are going to be a little bit more of your staples. Um So yeah, I mean overall like I I think the theme is done really well.
Mhm. I would like to see I mean there are a ton of beasts. So I mean just out straight out the gate, six I think is a good number. Um I'd like to see more contracts, more maps. I the God, yeah, the the stupid movement deck. Like, I get where they were coming from, and for the most part, I'm revealed, so it does get wiped, but like because nothing in the rules or on the board state from night to night you remove those. Like, I don't start each day fresh of in a new location. Right. If you don't if I have like four movement out and then it's like, "Oh, my turn to start. Oh, I'm going to play slither." That lets me move two spots.
I'm going to move and I'm going to play Especially if you like are the last to pass, cuz then not only do you pass last, but you also then move cuz you have more cards than we do. Yeah. Um yeah, I think I have my cards are a lot more restrictive, though, with terrain and stuff. Um Right, but what I'm saying is um Cuz passing more cards, you have the opportunity not to basically pass last every single time, which means you also start, which means then since you get two turns between the hunters. Yeah, that's true. Um That's what I'm saying with extra cards. That's the advantage of extra cards. Yeah. Yeah, okay. No, yeah, I see what you're saying. I was thinking it was like more I was like, yeah, inherently you might get more turns, but I don't think so cuz I only get to play two cards and you guys get to play four.
Like when you Well, yeah, not but you don't you don't I mean, just turn order is like, yeah, I could end with the with the beast and then it's like, "Okay." And then you start with the beast again. Yeah. Yeah, so then you just have a running track of action cards and then it's like and mini maps are always kind of annoying because it's like I hate doing the Right. "Am I moving?" It's like I mean, it seems like no matter and maybe it's not to you guys, but like if I if I like move my hand like this, do you know where I moved it? Like did you could you I assume you move it that way or north. Okay, so I moved it south. So it's like but it always feels like it's so obvious like I like I'm going Which is why a paper with numbers is easier because you write every single time and it doesn't matter cuz you wrote something.
So nobody can tell what you wrote. That's true. Um And it's just easier for clarity cuz I think what they were trying to do is they took a few ideas from other hidden movement games. They have the they have the movement track which in Fury of Dracula you have the location track. And that works because eventually like that's how you like you seed events and vampires. You never can cross never backtrack. Yep. So again because you can never backtrack, it's very easy to see the path when the cards are out there. Yeah. They make us even if they got shuffled together to a certain extent they kind of make an order like even when you put them all out. That is true. Yeah, you you couldn't do that card to that card to that card. There's just no way. Yeah. Um Um cuz I think there's only six spots.
I'd have to look at it again. it's seven. Okay. Seven before it falls off. Um but yeah, you want it to fall off and that's the you have to keep moving cuz then it's like oh this fell off now it's a mature vampire. Aha. That's four influence. Um and here there's no falling off which you think I think there should be. Because it's like thematically if you're trying to track something Right. the one that's the seventh one is or the the first one that's going to be the oldest trail. It's like oh this trail's too old we can't follow this. But it doesn't have that. It says seven plus so theoretically if they just never catch on and I never attack and I I mean but I don't win if I don't attack so as soon as you reveal except for the one that you said Except for the one where you're supposed to survive. Right.
Yeah, the one where um Yeah, the beast wins when two settlers are dead or when the final night is reached. So, yeah, you can just keep hiding and hiding and hiding. Uh and realistically, honestly, if you really wanted to hide, I don't know that we could find you. Um well, I mean, that's why the one of the best things about this game I do think is the card drafting. Yeah. Even though it's you don't like how it's a thin action deck, um just the sheer amount of the fact that you get to see exactly what you're handing over to the beast player I think is really or what I'm handing out over to you guys. It's like if that's the case, it's like, "Oh, what's the contract?" Oh, he has to survive. Uh okay, well, let's never intentionally give him movement cards. You can't fully keep it from the player, but Right.
at least it's like, "Okay, all I have are attack cards, so I guess the limited movement I have will be the try to kill settlers." Kind of because I can only keep one card every single time from you. Um keep all of them. That's true, but I mean, if if because not every card has movement. So, if you have one movement card that lets me move, you keep that one. Um and then it goes to Brad or the whoever's playing, then it's like, "Okay, hey, I got a couple movement [ __ ] which one should we keep?" And Right. And what's really cool about this one that they actually mentioned in the rule book is they're like, "Have the hunters sit by each other so they can show cards." Yeah. They truly are fully cooperative. Instead of being like, "Nope, you guys have to fully talk and everything is open knowledge to me." Yeah. Um I don't know. I feel I feel like this game is it it is a little wonky. It's a little rough around the edges. I don't the the movement cards are absolutely my least favorite part just for clarity.
Um but it worked still. Like, at least it wasn't like, "How have you been here?" I have no idea. Like, I was like, "Yep, that's exactly what I did." You were able to still follow the path, so it's serviceable. It could have been done better. Um So, other than that, no real glaring negatives. Think the art is fantastic. Uh at least for the beasts. Like I really like the design Yeah. for them. The characters kind of look They're all the same kind of base and they're like faces. Yeah, they're very similar. Except for this guy. Yeah, it's like they did really good detail, I think, for the clothes, but then their faces kind You know what they look like? It looks like a Ryan Lockett. I was trying to figure out who the artist that looks like Ryan Lockett faces where it's like, I don't know how to It's like you've seen them in person, right? Totally.
Right. [ __ ] [ __ ] what do they look like? Right. Um So, yeah, like I think this kind of is a a pretty unique hidden movement game. Yep. Um So, yeah. Uh did you have any other negatives? Nope. No? Any other positives? Nope. Like, oh, absolutely not. Uh so, on a scale of 1 to 10, what would you give Beast? Seven. That's where I'm at, too. Yeah, I'm at I'm at seven as well. Funny enough, I don't know why, either. Like seven just feels like this is a good game. Um Yeah. Cuz it's like I'd have to go back and replay Fury and some of those other hidden movement games, cuz right now they're just fond memories at this point, cuz it's been so long. So, it's like what is Keep, cuz right now those are like eights and nines.
So, some of what for me in hidden movement games that I'm really looking for is this feeling of tension. And I don't feel tense in this game. Yeah. feel like so, I know you do Whitechapel, I do Whitehall. And Whitehall is very like I've never played a game where both sides, after I asked them both sides, ever really felt like they were always right there at catching the person. Jack always feels the cops are right on his tail, and the cops always feel like he's just that one step ahead. And that's And like so for my problem with like Fury is it is a long game. My problem really isn't the length of the game. The first half, no one feels tension.
Yeah. The hunters are all building up their stuff. Dracula's just seeding the locations to basically try to mature up then some things. Yeah. It's the second half then that everybody is a little more tense. Oh, you almost killed a hunter. Um but Dracula took two damage. Is Dracula going to be able to get away? You cornered him. Yeah. The first half of the game is It's yeah. Honestly, I could figure out how to just place out seven cards and give them the supplies that they should have and put Dracula in the middle of the map and them in their original spots and play the game. Right. Um that's where I like to me Fury of Dracula could somebody could come and revamp it and make it into an hour-long game because the first half is just a supply side.
And then it becomes the actual hunting down. That's true. Um this one even when I was tracking you, I had an idea of where you were, but you like you complain not having enough movement. I didn't feel like I had enough movement to track you down well. And so like you would move two spaces and the best I could do is move two spaces. Well, I was already three spaces behind you, so I didn't gain anything. So it wasn't like Like again, you always had a lot of movement and I had enough movement, but they were almost even movement. And because I can only search places that I've literally been on, where like Whitehall and Whitechapel say you can scan the spaces that you're close to you, so you can figure out the path going forward. Oh, yeah, cuz you can Yeah, you go until you find a clue.
Right. Yeah. So, here it's more like, well, if I have a card that says I get extra movement if you've been there, well, I got one movement. You played two movement cards. Now, I'm even farther behind you. Yeah. And so, that's where like, yes, I my character had lots of attack, but if I couldn't find where you were or you didn't pop up, it really didn't matter. The times I hit you is basically when you popped up. Uh right. Yeah, which I mean, I think it's part of the design because I have to pop up to do that, but Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm fine with that, but again, for me, for him movement game, the hunters should either have more movement than the enemy because they need to catch up from cuz again, you have perfect knowledge of where we're at, so you can try to avoid us, but if we don't have enough movement to actually go all the way around, then it doesn't matter. We're just trampling.
Yeah, it's it's definitely a a difficult balance because if you had a bunch of movement as well as all your attacks, then what advantage do I have besides being hidden, but I have to reveal So, if I if I was like, "Oh, I need to attack this guy to win." I reveal Oh. I guess I'm dead. That's my thing with hidden movement games of why we add more complexity like even Fear of Dracula, when we add more complexity to it, it takes away from the cat and mouse side of it. Where like the Jack ones, you just have to find Jack. Once you find him, there's no fighting, there's no Wow. combat. You have to find him. And so, the whole thing is it is a cat and mouse game. prevent him from if you can nail down his location, you just, you know, surround it, then he can't get there and he Right, if you can make him run out of time.
Yeah. Okay. So, to me, it's still one of the things where it's all cat and mouse. Mhm. And that's what I probably really want from a hidden movement game is cat and mouse. Yeah. Yeah, I think Cuz here it was more I just positioned like so I thought you went this way in the first one. So I went through the middle side of it. I didn't even try to go from your where you started. I just went east and figured eventually I'm going to hit into somewhere. Yeah, because I well that's where the contracts come in. It's like, okay, what's his goal to get a benefit? Right. It's like, oh, in the shipwreck one he needs to kill, you know, two sheep or a boar to get an ancient power and do a summon thing. Right. Okay, well, that's probably what he's going to go do. There were a lot of stuff where it was like, okay, like the commander moving the villagers away, moving hunters into. So that's where I kind of like this. And cuz in regular love for my chapel no one has special abilities or anything like that. It's playing the same game. Here you have your specialty.
You know, the commander has their specialty and so on and so forth. So they get they get some differences. And again, like I think even count mouse games you could have special abilities between players that either like, oh, this guy allows you to get more movement. This guy does better searches. Okay, that's unique. You can have that. Right. Um Again, I wasn't I didn't almost realistically, it's why I hunted the um basilisk in the first round I had a hatchet for. Yes, cuz I waited to try and find you. It's like, sure, but there's a threat here. The chances of me finding getting my cards in the right spot are limited. Might as well just do it while I have the chance. it was a good decision, too, cuz summons can be disgusting if they just run rampant. Um So yeah, I'm very curious what their expansions are bringing because it's like maybe, I mean this game's been out for Uh well, I guess not even not even not even a year.
I But enough to hopefully get some feedback to streamline it or I mean, it is pretty streamlined, but I so I don't know what they're adding. I'd have to take a look to see if it's like, "Oh, okay, that's something that Zach was mentioning that he didn't like. Now it's being implemented." Sure. Um I will say I never feel tension when I'm not the one hiding. Really? Like no. Not even a little. Even if I'm like like if I know exactly where they're at, I find then I'm actually disappointed. Then I'm like, "Oh, I found you." That's you suck. I cuz it I mean Like why would it It's like, "Okay, well, this is where you're at. This is where you're going." You can't really do much because it's it's all four of our turns. Um So, and if it and then if it's the opposite, if I have no idea where you're at, then it's just I'm just defeated.
And I'm like, "Well, okay, I can't find you. I don't care." Hm. So, um and I've played so many I mean, in I played Sniper Elite. That was one of the new hidden movement games. Didn't like it. Um then Mind Management that everyone loves, I didn't like it. Uh and then now this one. So, three hidden movement games within the year, and this is the first one that I was like, I actually enjoyed. Maybe the theme plays a huge part into it. Yeah. Uh but it wasn't until I realized that it was the end of the night of the second night that I was like, "Oh, I get to start. Hopefully I get some attack cards." But whenever you guys dealt three damage, I'm like, "Shit. I might die." Uh or whenever I moved north and went around and you guys and you were like, "Oh, okay, he moved four spaces. That's probably what he did." It's like, "Shit." So, while I wasn't sitting here going "Fuck.
Like how do I get out of this?" I was still like, "I might lose. Damn it." So, I guess it just depends on what you want. Um it sounds like hidden movement games you want basically imperfect information that Whitehall gives. There's not much to the game except you know, how well I guess kind of and this is just a hidden movement aspect that is how lucky the one searching can get on the first go. Cuz they have to basically get you on the first go to have that cat and mouse at the very beginning. Whitechapel is the exact same way. If they have no idea by the end of the first night, second night's going to be real rough. Right. Um and Fury of Dracula, if they don't nail you down with Mina's ability like in the first couple regions, it's going to be real rough because then it's like, "Oh, you thought I was in Europe? Haha." Like this whole thing is Europe. You thought I was in that section? Uh well, I wasn't. Now I am. And that's just kind of a problem that I don't know how you fix.
I'm not saying this game fixes it. Um I'm just saying different strokes, different folks. Uh but I mean, at the end of the day, we still gave it the same rating. Yeah. Um I I even if they modified the action movement uh with the I think it's Shattered Isles is the new expansion. I couldn't see this going above an eight. I can see this getting up to an eight. Uh Yeah, I don't see it going to an eight for me. Well, I'll just I guess we'll just never play it with you. Um but that would be the highest I can I can probably give it. They'd have to really just all of a sudden wow me with it. I also this is kind of a design decision. The the order like the the phases, the dawn, day, and night phase I don't like that it's on the board, but I also do like that it's on the board cuz it's a nice quick reference.
But it's just kind of distracting. It's a lot of text. That's just kind of that's just kind of there. With that like it's like I get what they're doing like Pandemic has that where it's but it's like here. And it's like three things. Yeah. literally four lines. that's This is like the rule book on the side. Uh But yeah, I think there is some unique stuff that they could do to kind of give you give like cuz in I know we keep referencing these other hidden movement games, so you almost got to lump them all in together and compare. In the expansion to Whitechapel, the Dear Boss expansion, it's a modular expansion that gives like oh, is Jack winning too much? Give the players this. Sure. Or the player's winning too much? Give Jack this. And there's a bunch of those that do add player abilities and like very specific like prostitute like oh, hey, if I kill this one, I get this ability.
Um I think they can do a little bit more with that. Yeah. Like yeah, they have the items and they have the talents. I love the trap concept. I think that's really cool. However, I think it's very restrictive. By making it thematically, yeah, put it in the location. Hey, we set this trap in the woods. Yeah, okay. But if I just never reveal myself in there, then it's never going off. It's like okay, I guess that's there. Sure. But I guess you can have multiple in each zone. Yeah. So, I don't know what they're going to add. Uh But out of all the most recent hidden movement games I've played that have come out recently, this is the one I've liked the most. Um So, I get that's a win in and of itself. Yeah. Uh yeah, I think that's it. Sevens from both of us on Beast. Um let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.