John Company & Molly House Reprint - Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time and hopefully actually start the live the correct live stream. Yesterday I failed to do that. So uh my apologies if you're trying to find yesterday's live stream or it was miserably labeled. I've been off the horse for a while. I'm back though. some really cool stuff going on behind the scenes that I can't talk about at all, but know it's all very exciting. It could potentially really uh help our camcorder in the long term, in the short term. But today, I'm excited to be checking out what I believe was the 17th most popular project on all of games, right? Actually, sorry, 19th. That is John Company and Molly House reprint. Hey Sean, glad to be back. Two of the most evocative historical board games are back for a new print run. So immediately I'm like me cuz it's just if I don't know [clears throat] what John company or Molly House are if I have no clue which you got to think is going to be the majority of people who might just happen to stumble upon this because I know they're much beloved games. They're much beloved historical games.
But it's still just like there's tons of people who don't know what Ticket to Ride is or well maybe not Tick to Ride but you know you get what I'm saying. Uh so I was just the player link the time counts the age the prices. I get you're showing the components. Maybe a little bit more of the history, right? Because I know Molly House has like a fascinating like I was really interested in Molly House just when I saw the box and like the theme about it and then the player count as well only going up to three players and John Company. Same deal. So I feel like this main image definitely doesn't do this a service focusing on components that are fine. Like they're they're fine. Like that one's nice and that's those are dice. Who cares? But it's just I definitely feel like we could have done more not only in the main image but also on the description as well. I really feel like they didn't do themselves many favors with either of those. However, they're lucky because they have two games that people really, really want. Hopefully, they're going to spotlight that incredibly well in this video, which hopefully will answer the three big questions. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? The three things you need to convince Kickstarter backers of it. They've done it for $300,000. Let's see how they did it.
Let's go. Fast. Wow. pieces. Oh my dice. Okay, cool. You have components. They're nice. They look historical. Yippy freaking Skippy. But do you have a great game? Because here's the thing. You could show me and talk to me about your great game and I could then naturally infer the spectacular graphics and components. So you just doing nothing but that with fast music. Come on. Give me some meat here. This is all sizzle.
Ah, not going to say it's not there's not some steak here, but it's like the steak is just it could be so much wasted steak. Oh, playmat. It's a nice playmat. Cool. Great job showcasing playmat. I will say that.
Yeah, cool. What? How do you What What are they about? Is it worker placement? Action selection? Is it bidding? Is it is it like I Thanks for Thanks for telling me nothing. Thanks for telling me nothing. All right. and hopefully we'll get here. Cole is an exac. And here's the thing. I hate that as a gamer, but I get why they did it honestly because I imagine that there's going to be a large subsection of the people that back this are just into historically themed things and like games like [sighs] I'm just trying to figure because okay John Company second edition. We got Paxir reprint and then launching soon.
We're doing a reprint of that. Okay, let's make sure people got their stuff. I pretty sure I've seen this game in the wild, so I do believe this is not going to be something I'm concerned about, but we'll double check. See, uh, I think I misreceived my copy of this somewhere. Hey, Seth, 10 months ago, 10 months ago, three years ago. Yeah. Boom. Three. So, we're done. So, cool. Back some air. Did people get their stuff once again? I believe I've seen this box in existence. Uh, asked for a player replacement board. You sent me the wrong color. One twice. still have my problem fixed. Unfortunately, never get replacement tokens from this project. So, being sent out, I just resize after a long time to get my replacement tokens. So, some customer service stuff that comes with being a smaller company that probably has, you know, one, two, maybe three people probably I would guess and most of the time it's like a one one plus person show a lot of the time. So that's something that you always need to realize because if you're not that deep in the hobby and you just like know of board games and the companies and the big you might assume that these companies are larger than they are and they are not large. A lot of most of I would say most of the board game companies that currently launch Kickstarters now have less than two employees. Like 1.78 would be the guess that I would go. Um all right 90. So 90 bucks. That's a great price. Oh, that's for just the one. Okay. Then 60. So 150. Okay. So there's a quote here. There wasn't a quote. Cirly the world warming thing stuff. Uh John Company second edition is a great work of art.
Thank you for pulling out something that I can see with my eyes instead of the fact that shut up and sit down probably said some absolutely just lequaciously delicious quotes. I could go through this, which luckily is clickable, and I could probably very easily find something, and you probably could, three to five quotes be like, that'd probably be better because heck, yeah, I can see the art. This is a deep and moving game that rises above its peers. It's deep and moving. So, it's 200 bucks. I thought it was 150 for both. Thought it was one. So, it's 90. So, that's 150. So, what am I What's the difference? Is this like deluxified? Uh oh. metal pawns and metal coins. Okay, so that's like the super deluxified with metal. So, this is just like the regular deluxified of 150 seems like a good price. Um, not a fan of the fact there's not that third pledge where it's just like, hey, if you don't want metal coins, so hopefully there's just an easy add-on to it, but whatever. 1 to 6 90 to 240, ages 14 plus a game of nepatism and bureaucracy in the British East India Company. Okay, let's go back to that.
The how they use THE DESCRIPTION. JUST THAT BRIEF DESCRIPTION right there makes me that sounds like a really fascinating game that doesn't have another theme like that. And that player count like we're at medium to holy crap range. Okay, we're at medium to we got to kind of plan a day around playing this game range which I'm all for. Give me the Z. Give me the Twilight period. Like I'm I'm down. Unflinchingly examines the early gangsters of capitalism. I don't understand what that means, but it gets me excited as a historical gaming fan. Once again, I feel like an extra sentence or two here would really unlock this quote. And unfortunately, we're we're left wanting more. The game tickles my brain like no other, and it is a joy. Okay, designer Gloom Haven.
That's a nice one. Big one. Uh, best of the year board game geek for. Yeah, I would put this up higher, but that's still great. Uh, we have the quote that the only thing that apparently is important from that is them knowing that they like the artwork. Uh, how to play
beautiful money 49 minutes. But hey, when you're playing a 90 to 240minute video, do you care? The answer is no. An intense exercise in empathy. One of the best board games of the past year. An intense exercise in empathy. Now, that's one where it's like, yeah, I I w a little bit more, but that's a fascinating quote. Molly House asked us to become reluctant traders of the self and hopefully come out the other side a little more human. Um, okay. Like I feel like we're going too deep here. It's like when you're at a party and you're like, "Okay, settle down there, buddy. We know you're going for your doctorates. You you're laying it on a bit thick, right?" And that's what it feels like. You're laying it on a little thick here. Okay. You're you get like the game's Okay. It's a great game. We get it. It's historically themed. Cool.
But at least talk to me like I'm five when you're in the quotes at least about why I should want to buy the game because honestly like there was a quote I straight up just didn't understand there were two or three quotes that were kind of cryptic to me and that's not generally the best idea with quotes I don't imagine but hey they're going from a slight I feel like they're going what is this uh John event India companion this is a lot of text that's what that is uh 150 metal coins this the sleeves the packs from here. Okay. All the stuff here. Nice clean add-on section. Great. So, you can you can just get that for 150. That's good. Good stuff. We continue. I will say uh can you do it on the price? I don't have a problem with that. When you're talking about a game that's that long, I don't think people beny at 90 bucks. Like when we're talking about a potentially fourhour game, someone says 90 bucks, you say, "Okay, that's Twilight and you know, no problem there at all." Uh so nice prices. Board Game Arena. Whoa. Let's talk park tutorial.
Oh my gosh. Yeah, this looks so up my alley. I eventually want to play this game. Uh let's have a society. We played Molly House. Okay. Uh we played it. So there's gameplay videos. Looks like there's previews. There's how to plays for both the videos. Good stuff. Shipping rates. Click here. Love the fact you didn't make this just a document. Here's here's a little thing. You take the Windows key. You take the shift and you take the S and bada boom. Check this out. You copy. Look at that. Look at that. And you just boom. You're done. How long does that take? You're not going to do that? Is that Is that too hard? It's not. I'm a fool. I just did it. It's just laziness. I don't understand it. Like, oh, we got this pretty Kickstarter page. We wouldn't want to silly it with this graphic. And it's like, I bet you that's probably why like would take the time and like come on.
And it's like, oh, because it's a work in progress. Okay, it's a work in progress. They didn't make it clickable. Hey, this is subject to change and here's the most recent or something like anything like that. But put it there. Don't make it extra clickable. It's just I won't make it extra click all the time to you. 25 bucks. Not when I'm in the country. 175. Okay, that's not bad. Or so 15. That's nice. Oh, plus one to two small. This is a really nice shipping section, by the way. Like nitpick aside that you got to click to get to it. That was a that was a very pleasant pleasant se shipping section. Plus one to two small add-ons. Okay. Okay. So, they're like not the game probably, but the other stuff. Good stuff. All right. Uh campaign. This is nice. Hopefully this gets moved up higher once this thing's complete. You know, just plop this thing at the top. Like um Oh. Oh, what is it?
Oh, something Giraffe Games does is the first people I saw do it. They did it really well where after the campaign was over, they just had like this big chart. I was like, "Hey, here's where this game is in its process and whatnot." I just feel like that's so funny, right? I don't need to see your pretty game. And what actually I guess I would say you probably want to do that after you get uh to the point where people are going to keep giving you money, right? I don't know because I think there's definitely a delicate balancing act there of like you still want people like, "Hey, because you get money after the fact." The pledge manager, that's it. Uh that's it. That wasn't too bad at all. That was 11 minutes. Short, sweet, in and out. Uh didn't waste your time. I'm not I'm not hating on it. Uh and at the end of the day, do I want it? Yeah, I do. I do. I feel like it could have spotlighted stuff a little bit better, but I got the gist. And here, how much is it? Your price wasn't that bad. Especially for these two games, which, you know, I'm not I'm not assuming that I'm going to be able to pick these up at Target.
Like, these are the kind of games where if you see them on a math trade, you're like, "Oh, they perk up your ears." Like, those are going to be games that are a little bit harder to come by. Uh, at least at least that's the impression that they're trying to go up. Which kudos, they nailed it. Updates and add-ons. 2451. That makes a lot of sense because you're going to get a lot of people who already have one game and a lot of people who already have the other game. Uh oh no, cuz they got 386 here. 987. So more people excited for the John company than the Molly House. Uh the allin John company Molly House Deluxe 457. Yeah, metal coins. And you know what? I shouldn't say the metal coins aren't moving the needle because once again, there's going to be a huge chunk of people who already own one of them. But at the end of the day, I also don't feel like that video did a great job. Like I don't feel like the main image or the video were either very good at all. Like they just like not saying they weren't wellmade, professionally done, did a great job spotlighting the components, but there's more in your game than the components.
And you hinted at like, oh, there's also game play here. Look, there's dice being rolled and look at that. And you showcase the components. Great. It's just I would love if you narratively weave together what all these components did instead of just trying to have fast historical music. It just I don't know it was just too much sizzle not enough stake for me but at the end of the day the sizzle was good. It was good sisle an infamous traffic 2e. We did working on a new edition of an infamous traffic. We'll be doing a play test during this campaign. I know what that means. Cool. Neat. Uh I'm not saying that in a sarcastic way at all but that's where the FAQ that's where it should be. Like that's a weird specific question that someone will have and they answer it already. So that's terrible engagement. I gotta say like this is just this is not hard. This is so hard. That is just I'm going to say it's pathetic, right?
It's really bad. You have 14 comments on this project which you know is nothing but historically themed enthusiast and you can't generate more than 12 comments which most LIKELY LIKE HEY WE'RE SUPER EXCITED DAY ONE FUNED OR SOME STUPID crap like that right? Yeah. Just ask the there's so many lowhanging fruits like what expansion would you like from this time period? pluck. You could do that for both expansions. Or or better yet, what historical event do you think would be fascinating and what mechanism would you utilize it? Like there's so many lowhanging fruits that you could ask because this is the smarty farty crowd and they would love to get an opportunity to show how smarty farty they are about interweaving mechanisms with historical events. And I'm all for that. I'm not even dogging on that. Like when I play a game like Twilight Struggle, it sets my brain on fire. Like how someone play tested to balance this.
Even though they totally didn't balance the space race. Space race, it's fool's goal. Uh okay. Could it be possible without a separate thing for the stuff? Uh so good customer service. Four days. Uh so took the weekend off. Uh no, no, it's it's it's uh it's Wednesday, so yeah, it's not great customer service there, but hey, I mean, it's just a $300,000 campaign you're running in the final week. I'm sure I'm sure there's you know uh do they have collaborators? There's I guess that's the question. Yeah, they they did actually took my maybe he's a designer or maybe as I said collaborators can a lot of time just be people that you know that you trust to like just micromanage like easy comments like yeah we're super excited that you're excited about it too like just turn engagement kind of things. Um so end of the day final grade four John company and the Molly House reprint. Do I want it? Yes, I do, but not as much.
So, you know, I try and come into these and as a blank slate, and I can't because I've seen this game in person. The components look great, and I actually want to play it, and I know it's very highly rated, but if I didn't, I think they did a good job convincing you either way because as much as I nitpick about how much I'd love if they focus on the components and this that, and the other thing, like uh the gameplay is it's frozen. Everything's frozen. Oh my god, Elsa did me. It's it's they still like they they did spotlight their pedigree, right? It's like we've won these awards. Uh we were nominated for this. Yeah. 452. And they did that. So that was good stuff. And then they have stuff people want, right? Like everybody wants this game if you've heard of this game or if you played this game. And I just feel like there was definitely some meat that was left on the bone here. And I'm curious to see how how their other campaigns did. And I can't help but wonder if it's just that lackluster main image followed by what I feel like is a very lackluster video. Like even as someone who came into this wanting to be excited about this game, I was like, "Okay, there's there's a hundred other Kickstarters that have funded in the last two years with gorgeous artwork, gorgeous components, and trash gameplay." And I know that's not you.
Like you could you prove that's not you, but it's just Yeah. Yeah. So, the John company did $787,000. That's that's a that's a big chunk. And then so you're essentially doing a reprint of that game and then a a reprint of Molly House, which Yeah. I don't know. I definitely feel like there's meat left on the bone here, but do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yes. How much is it? Yes. So, good grade. I I But I think it could have been great. And I feel like and I feel like that's one of those ones where it's just there's too many things to juggle running a Kickstarter, right? It's it's you have to get people excited pre-launch. You have to get people excited during the campaign. Like and it's just like during the like those updates like there's let's see if they were getting people excited these ones. Zero comments, but these are early ones like fulfillment update and spill. But that's a fulfillment update. It's it's hard to it's not fair to judge these comments because comments because updates after a campaign is over compared to updates during the campaign are drastically different things, right? The information is much more valuable after your money's locked in. It's like, OH, MY MONEY'S GONE NOW. HOPEFULLY, this is good news.
Uh, so the end of the day, Final Credit, I think it's going to go with a B+. Yeah. Yeah, I think B+ is fair. I think it's rock solid. That video though, I definitely I just I just wish they would have added an extra 15 to 20 seconds and just really been like so Molly House create joy in the queer community in the 17 like I could just read this. In Molly House, players take the role of the gender-defying mollies of the early 18th century London throw grand masquerades and cruise back alleys while evading moralistic constables who seek to DESTROY COMMUNITY. BUT INSTEAD, YOU'RE SHOWING ME ALL THIS THEMATICALLY on the board with the delicious delightful components and oh look at this and this is like like oh this is the back alleys or whatever like I could then see like OH YEAH LOOK LIKE LOOK OH THIS IS WHERE I'M WALKING AS AS THIS MOLLY like this you could have done that you could have interweaved it so much and I think you could have then brought in more people who aren't here just for historically themed game and I feel like that was just the missing component there but end of the a B+. I still feel like it was well done. Um, let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for John Company and Molly House reprint. Also, if you have a request for a Kickstarter, uh, I'm hold it until next week, I guess, because I'm trying to catch up through all the stuff from last week. Uh, also couple Kickstarter autopsies coming up for campaigns that are over. We'll see how they did. We'll see how they shook out. Uh, just because I I for I I've been super busy this past week, but I'll tell you about that soon. We don't know. Bye. Love you.