Under Falling Skies | Game Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing under Falling Skies but I'm going to be doing it with a friend with David Thompson how you doing David awesome thanks for having me yeah so um I've never done a co-review like this on the channel before but we were just talking about how we were both playing the game we decided to do it together so uh let's have an overview of under Falling Skies and we'll come back for some final thoughts all right so here's under Falling Skies all laid out as you can see it's super awkward to film because it's just like vertical board so it's taking up all of my table uh but only like this little sliver of it but we're gonna do a quick overview so under Falling Skies it's kind of like Space Invaders the board game and basically what's happening is that we've got these alien ships who are on a mother ship that's gonna descend throughout the game and this side has the rules on it which is super convenient but the alien ships are going to come down the mothership is going to descend and our goal is to research these aliens and figure out what we need to do about them by hitting the top of our research track before one of two things happens so either the ships will keep damaging us and our base will hit complete destruction basically we'll take so much damage to the game is over or the mothership will get so low that it basically destroys our city anyway and so that's the other lose condition for the game so we want to max out our research track before the mothership gets low enough or before we take too much damage and this setup has the basic
Roswell setup but there are a couple of other cities so you've got Washington DC we've got New York and there's also an additional tile so you can basically have slightly different setups so basically what happens in this game is there are three phases the first phase is called the dice phase and that is where you take and roll these five dice and you're going to allocate them to different columns and different rooms within our little Subterranean base so basically you would allocate one of these dice to each column and each room that you allocate a die to does different things so for example these rooms up here at the top they basically are just anti-aircraft they don't they don't do anything except they decrease the amount of movement for alien ships for dice you put there which I'm going to show you in a moment this room is basically firing on enemy ships so we can put a die here to attack potential bad guys that are coming down this is a room that is going to let us do some research and so we would be moving up and so we'd be moving up the research track according to the value of the die we put there and then this room which you have to put two dice in to get anything from it um is the power Rim so you basically need to spend power to do your various actions so in order to get that power you have to put dice in the power room Additionally you have this little excavator here and you can put one die each turn ahead of where the excavator actually is and what that's going to do is allow you to move the excavator down to reveal more rooms which are really going to need in order to get the die totals that you actually need to finish
your research as you can see this total up here is 11. you're going to need these multi-dice research rooms to make that work so basically we've rolled all of our Dice and we can just place them and I'll show you how it works so these gray dice are a little bit different from the white Dice and I'm going to show you exactly how so let's say that we want to put this gray die this gray 4 right here in the attack room what that's going to do is we put four Pips here and that means that this alien ship is going to move down four spaces which in this case I actually wanted it to do because it's landed in a space that I can shoot so as the aliens come down they are potentially going to damage us but also they're going to do different things depending on where they land and part of the puzzle of the game is allocating your dice in a way that helps you it also moves the ships in the way you want so this guy will move down four because I put a four die here let's say that I want to do a little bit of research so I'll put this gray die here for three and this guy will come down one two three let's say that I would like to place this four and I'm going to put it here so then this alien will come down one two three four and then now that I've placed a white die I have to re-roll the dice that I have placed yet so the white guys kind of give you a re-roll or you have to save them until the end so now I have a six and a two so sixes are good and bad at the same time all right so let's say that what I want to do is put the six right here because I want to you know get a bunch of power
maybe too much power actually we're going to bring the spaceship down one two three four five six so he's getting closer and then I'll just put the two here and the excavator can move over to it one two and then by leaning here on that Arrow my alien ship will go over one in that direction so depending where they land alien chips can make the mothership descend faster they can move to the left or right or they can put themselves on a space where they're vulnerable to be shot by me when I use an attack space these dice are robots that you can play with and basically you can set them in a room where they're automatically gonna do some work so once I've placed my Dice and I've brought my ships down then I can actually resolve what I've done with the dice that I allocated so this space has a minus one so this is worth a four for enemy movement but it's only worth a three for shooting however it's still going to be enough because this space has a two right here and it's got a little explosion so I can kill this alien with that die nobody else is on a place where I can hit them so that's all I'm gonna be able to do with that room for that turn and that's going to cost me a power so you can see the cost right here on the bottom and then here we have this power room so I've actually got 10 in here minus three so it's going to take me to seven so basically I'm just going to max out my energy which is something that is a good thing to do then I can spin two of that power to do science so this three will take me up here one on the science track so basically the sum of your dice has to be able to take you up to the number
value of the next space if I had four I could do three and then four but I just put a three there and then I can move my little excavator forward here which is also going to cost me another power but it also opened up another research room and has just got my excavator moving in one way or another so I did my room space then I'm gonna do the mothership phase so basically with the mothership I'm gonna bring it down by one I have to take the consequence that's here which means I'm going to spawn one of these clear ships in addition to this purple ship that I knocked off the board earlier
and then once I've taken my little consequence so this one is spawn a clear ship this one is move my excavator backwards so this thing can undo my progress um and this one is undo my research progress so once I've taken that consequence I get to respawn so basically I'll spawn this one first and this IP column and then this clear ship will appear here in this other empty column and that's a full turn I'm gonna take my Dice off foreign get ready to roll again and play some more so basically the game is very simple but the difficulty is in all the choices because you need to do the right things with your dice down here while also paying attention to the consequences they have in the sky so that's the base game uh there is also a campaign for under Falling Skies so you can either play Standalone games or there's a bit of a campaign you can play that has a comic book and some characters with special powers and other stuff that you can add in to spice the game up even further and then you can mix and match those components after you've completed the campaign so now that I've given you the quickest overview possible let's go ahead and have some final thoughts so now for some final thoughts uh David so tell us about your experience of playing this game because I know that you got really into it because you're playing with your kids yeah so so what happened with me is I'm on this Quest right now to play all of the most popular no kidding Solo solo games like solitaire games so games that are specifically designed only for one place person right and so um I played quite a few of them but somehow
some way I had never played under Falling Skies um for people that are familiar with Capstone games the publisher they just open up their first retail store in the Cincinnati area amazing store highly recommend it and I was there for their grand opening and I saw it on the shelf and I was like okay this is the no kidding the most popular solitaire game period you know according to board kinky so I need to play this right um but the secret about me is I don't actually play many solitaire games right solo actually how dare you I know I know I know yet yet we're still friends and you'll occasionally have me on
I love testing them I love designing them but playing them by myself I don't love it so that's not true okay so what what my experience is typically I'll get the game out a solo game I'll get it out I'll set it up I'll start playing it and as I'm playing it I'm I'm more interested in like exploring the game than I am necessarily playing the game right and um and so like under Falling Skies is fantastic and we'll get into this you know this this whole concept of input Randomness and dice manipulations just as soon as you start playing like oh this is amazing this is really cool um but if I really want to play a solo game to fruition like if I want to sit down and play the game the trick I do is I bring my kids in because I love playing solo games co-op with my kids so um usually it's my son who's eight my daughter who's 11 and the three of us or some combination of us will sit down and we'll play the game so we've played warp's Edge like that we've played um you know we played just a lot a lot of solo games so I knew that they would want to play this with me and sure enough we all sat down we learned it together we started playing it and they were both hooked so um yeah so we've had a fantastic time playing what I call you know Solitaire Co-op basically that is so cute I love it um yeah my my closest equivalent of that was like sitting next to my mom when she played Wolfenstein as a child so that's awesome yeah yeah yeah uh but no I'm a big believer in Alone Together Like Mike Kelly and I have also
had a lot to say about that um maybe we should have more to say about that but so I I do want to ask though is this actually the most popular solo game like I don't actually check numbers this game has been sitting in my closet since it was recommended um when I was talking to a bunch of other solo Gamers about best of the year it came out and I just finally got it out and learned it and played it a bunch of times so where is that number coming from really so so this if you go to board game geek and you do an advanced search you search for one player games and you have to make it exclusively one player there's an option to say exclusively one under Falling Skies is the highest rated game followed by Friday and then warp's Edge coffee roaster Maki Etc right so no kidding when when you list those when you hear under Falling Skies Friday warp's Edge these are all fantastic games right um for any solo player like this is like the Hall of Fame for solo games right but what's really interesting about that is so the People's Choice top 200 voting is underway right now and I'm actually gonna be filming commentary about that next weekend with Paul Grogan Mike Kelly and Jeremy Howard and I already know the list is not going to look like that like these games will be on the list somewhere maybe maybe Fridays will be the top like I'm not even sure where Friday is in the list anymore but when I think of top solo games I'm thinking the People's Choice list and it's quite different yeah so yeah I mean you could you can run the same search by going through it and just saying uh one player but don't limit it to exclusive and then you'll it's the list is completely different but you know it's an interesting and this we're we're tangenting big time here but I had asked
you recently um you and Mike Michael Kelly what are your y'all's thoughts on the difference between a game that is design Solo versus a game that can be played solo right and I mean I don't mean tacked on solo I mean games that actually put some time and effort to making a solar system and you know do you do you view those differently and I think to what's your your point when you ask the solo Community to vote on your favorites and the game let's say the top 10 solo games none of those might be actual solo unique games clearly you know there's there's a there's a difference but not meaningful in terms of like people's perception of what the best solo experience is right yeah although I do like a catered solo game so let's let's come back to that actually as a kid that's a good segue into talking with the game right so underfox guys is a solo specific experience yeah you can play it like by making decisions to come up together with other people but it's really a game that's designed for solo player and I actually really do appreciate that like I like a good just pure one player game that's not trying to be everything to everybody um and I thought that this one was nice it's nice and like we'll kind of get back time with that like I enjoyed the puzzle of it I enjoyed the dice allocation um the board is very long but like you know that's not really a problem you know I have a whole table for gaming it was a pain to film but um but you know it's it's basically like a tabletop version of I guess Space
Invaders or something yeah um and so how did that feel for you as somebody who loves like word historical games and then how'd your kids respond well so so for sure what's funny is funny you should say it looks like Space Invaders because clearly that's I guess that's exactly what they were going for because both of my kids who did not grow up with Space Invaders obviously but have known it through its cultural you know cultural whatever phenomena um immediately they said the same thing they're like oh like that video game where the things are coming down and what's funny about that is like you would okay if you were going to make a Space Invaders game you would think it was like super light and not like just kind of like whatever right and that is not this game right so yeah you might think it looks like Space Invaders some light little experience but no this is stinky and so um I I guess the good thing about my kids is they've played so many different games that they don't have a lot of like gameplay expectations so when we dot the taught the teach they were they immediately both groked it and um the other thing about playing this sort of solo Co-op way we play I guess you could have some like quarterbacking issues right like if if I was a dominant personality or whatever um but the cool thing about doing it that way where I make a conscious effort to not do that to not guide them or we really collaborate is when you have a game like under Falling Skies where the decision tree is huge right you can make all sorts of different decisions that all have massive ramifications on on the
other things that happen um deferring to the Judgment of a different person can make you explore the game in a way you wouldn't otherwise because you get into play patterns by yourself right yes I definitely have favorite things to do yeah yeah right right and so I mean we'll you know you've you've you've already given an overview so let's say that you as a as a player you to a fault love to try to destroy the ships as they're coming in right like that's yeah that's what you always prioritize over everything else you know if you have my kids my kids are like no we have to research and we just I just defer to them on that decision the game you actually experience the game in a different way and it'll help you appreciate the game more probably right yeah like I definitely so research is important kids but I'm definitely focused on Excavating and destroying in the early part of the game and it sounds like your kids like to make sure there's like a good research Bank going before you to those lower rooms oh yeah yeah yeah yeah for sure like it's funny you should mention Excavating because I'm like let's excavate let's excavate and they're like no we want to do these other things I'm like come on but if we don't estimate we can't win and I like the way that you're talking about the game is having kind of a complex decision tree because okay so it's not a hard game it's not a heavy game it's not a difficult to learn game but you're right like there are a lot of decisions to make and under Falling Skies and I think that that's really where the charm is for this particular game it just really gives you a lot to
do with very little like five dice and like a robot yeah yep and there's a lot to be said for a game unless you do so much with so little yeah yeah I mean it is definitely a puzzle and you know is it solvable you can debate you know etc etc um but at least even if you were on the side of oh it's a puzzle and you can solve quote unquote solve the game well holy cow there's a lot of different ways to approach that right yeah yeah so this kind of takes me weird so I I mean like this is a very good game definitely reckon bend it for solo players but I guess it's kind of leads to the discussion of like is it a keeper so for me like I'm part way into my first campaign I think what I'm probably gonna do is finish the campaign maybe play it one more time let it sit on my shelf for a little bit kind of see how I feel but I don't I've really enjoyed my time with this game and I'm still enjoying it I'm not convinced it's still going to be on my shelf in a year and even less odds of two so like where are you with that is is under phones guys keeper like is it one for the ages or is it one that you kind of play out and then you move on you know where are you with that yeah so I think I I think um I think you and I are pretty much locked up so for solo Gamers highly recommended I think you're gonna have a fantastic time with this game right I think it's it's a really good experience um I think that you're gonna get your value for your money for sure you're going to play through the campaign once
at least maybe twice and then you're going to pass it on to somebody else but for the cost of the game and the value the play that you're getting out of it like I definitely highly recommend it it's not I think once you've played it a couple of times once or twice through the campaign there's you're probably not going to come back to it but I mean you've gotten so many plays at that point right that I yeah I so maybe it doesn't stay in your collection but not for the for but for a good reason right yeah yeah because you played it out like I'm definitely still in the kind of heat of having a bunch of initial plays but I can feel my like you know how you you start playing something and you're just super hot and you just can't quit and you're like Play and play and play and play and then that starts to slow down yeah like I'm kind of entering the Slowdown period which is why I like to play things so much times before and so yeah I feel like this is a game that I'm gonna get my money's worth out of it like you know I bought I bought my copy of this this is not already copy you can usually assume something's pretty crap it doesn't actually but um I think I'm gonna get my money's worth out of it I've certainly spent a lot more on something that I spend a lot less time with right yeah but yeah absolutely um but yeah like is it my number one solo game of all time I mean no but it nobody's beating majority in all these years so whatever you don't even know that but um yeah I really feel like this is just a I also think that there's something to be said right for a game that you just have a really good time with and then you give it to somebody else knowing that they are also going to have a really good time with it yep yep
absolutely yeah so you are a game designer a prolific one we are designing game together right now um how has that affected the way that you're looking at all these solo games and yeah what did you learn from under Falling Skies that was interesting since we're here we can talk about it there's there's one for me there's one big takeaway about under Falling Skies from a from a game design perspective now I will say that you know people often ask me like when I'm when you're playing a game do you want to redesign it or whatever and the answer to that is no right so I never I'm never like oh I'm gonna house rule this or I'm gonna redesign this now I'll I'll absolutely be inspired by games but not in a way that like I want to change that game it just for for myself for later on um the interesting thing about under Falling Skies is because of the way you so at the beginning of that you've already people have already watched you know you've already talked about how it plays so you roll the dice and then you figure out what you're going to do with the puzzle um Jeff ingelstein in bluedology podcast has talked multiple times about this concept of input Randomness and output Randomness and the simplest explanation is input Randomness a thing happens so in this case you roll some dice and then you make your decisions right dice manipulation versus output Randomness where you make a decision about what I want to do and then we are successor failure hinges on you rolling a die or drawing a card or whatever so those are the two oversimplification but that's that's the difference under Falling Skies the tension of this game like just climbs climbs climbs climbs right you're you're you know are
you gonna lose etc etc but in the very last turn of the game because of the puzzly nature of the game you roll the dice you figure out the puzzle and then you know if you're going to win or lose in that last turn as you're resolving that last turn so what you have in this game is this massive tension that comes crashing down at the very last second as you mechanically step through winning a game or potentially losing the game and this is not me trying to fix under Falling Skies that's not the point of the discussion it's more of an interesting design like philosophical game design discussion about if you're designing an input Randomness game like this that has this puzzly nature what are do you just accept that there's that last little bit of experience because as humans psychologically the last thing we feel when we're experiencing something is the thing that sticks with us right yes so you know that that's the one takeaway from under Falling Skies as I was playing it but you know other than just enjoying the experience with my kids and stuff from my design perspective that's the one thing that stuck with me as that as I was playing it yeah and I see what you're saying like in real life in this situation it'd be a great relief to be like yeah we're gonna finish this research in time I can see it I know that we're there you know but in a game you know it doesn't I I don't think I've ever had an epic final turn really in this game right because it's always been I did enough research that I'm pretty sure I'm
gonna be able to make it or I screwed up and I don't know if I'm gonna be able to pull it out right right I mean the the closest thing that could happen would be you're allocating your dice and you you place like a white die at the very end to re-roll a gray die where you need to do something but you've just now shifted it to be an output Randomness game right so you've just kind of you've you've shifted that entire stand-up dice roll possibility to the to the last second and then it's just it I would say that doesn't reflect the puzzly nature of the rest of the game but yeah again this is not really a criticism and the game is is clearly fantastic it's not a desire to shift the design of the game it's more just an interesting thing that the game has to deal with by the nature of the game yeah it's kind of an observation about how the play experience feels which is largely very good but then it's almost like the last couple turns are less thrilling than the setup in kind of the mid game almost right right yeah which is that's that's an interesting I I normally think about yeah games that have a dramatic ending but this one really kind of front loads yeah yeah or or at least in that last turn it yeah as you said you can kind of know if you're gonna win or lose right yeah you would want that
but uh yeah so David I've never actually like co-reviewed like this on this channel this is super fun and I really um I really enjoyed it yeah this was awesome thanks for having me definitely and just enjoy chat with you all the time so the opportunity to actually chat about something that just happened to both be playing at the same time was really cool yeah so those of you out there please uh comment let us know if we should maybe do this again and uh and uh by all means uh like subscribe comments support me on patreon uh and most of all happy gaming thanks so much for coming on David thanks foreign