Monthly Live Q&A - Ask Me Anything - December 2025
Transcript
And I think we are live. Let me know if you can hear me and you can see me. Okay. And welcome to the final Q&A ever for 2025. I will be back next year, don't worry, for 2026 with a live Q&A which is bigger, better, faster. No, it'll be exactly the same. Exactly the same next year. Uh we'll be continuing the live Q&As's hopefully every month. And this is the last one for 2025. So, thank you very much to everybody for joining us live. Uh hello to everybody who is watching back afterwards. But yeah, if you are watching live, thank you very much. Keeping me company and Vicki as well while we're while we're doing this Q&A. The format of this show is going to be the same as it always is. We're going to first of all, we're going to answer all of the questions that I've been asked in advance from the BGG Guild. So, if you are watching this video back afterwards and you think, I can never watch these shows live, how do I ask Paul questions?
Well, every month a few days before these Q&As's, I put up a thread on my board game guild, which is guild number 2258. Head on over there if you're not already a member. Join the guild. Make sure you click on the subscribe button because otherwise you won't see anything. and I ask for questions in advance and that's what we're going to be going through first. After that though, we are going to be going to the live questions. So, if you are watching live and you do have any questions for me, please put them in the chat. Start with the word question, ideally in capitals, and then Vicki will see those and transfer them over to a document which I'll be reading as we go through this Q&A. A few things just before we start. These videos are not sponsored in any way. Nobody sponsors these videos. Not this year anyway. Maybe next year. Who knows? I've never actually had any publisher reach out to me offering to sponsor uh any of my Q&As or video logs.
Other people get that. Um I don't. Maybe I should be asking. I don't know. Um but yeah, all of the advertising revenue goes to charity. Uh not just from this video, but from all of my videos and I'm able to do that thanks to the support of the Patreon campaign. So if you are one of my Patreon supporters, a huge thank you to you for making not only this video possible, but everything else that I do. And if you want to support me, patreon.com/gaming rules is the best way to support me. Right, so uh is that everything? I think that's everything covered. Just a word of warning before we start. Uh I'm in a pretty angry mood at the moment. I'm quite frustrated with a number of things that have been going on this week. Um work related and nonwork related. And I've had a lack of sleep for the last couple of days. So, just in case I start getting really really frustrated and angry, uh, which might happen depending on the questions, Vicki will probably throw something at me. Have you got like one of those? No, not a mug. Like, like a soft potato or something. Yeah, potty plant. Um, anyway, I apologize in advance if if I get particularly ranty in in today's video. Right. Okay. Let's head on over to the questions that we've been asked in advance. The first one is a very important one. This is from Gavin. Gavin is generally one of the first people to ask me questions. Every time I put a post up on the BGG Guild, uh, he's generally the first. And he says, "What is your favorite piece in a game?" Now, I have been asked this question many, many times before, but Gavin has asked this one with a little bit of a twist than normal. We're not
talking about a specific piece where there is just one of them, like a start player token or anything like that. We're talking about general components where there's multiple of them. And Gavin's favorite one, well, he says, for example, the bird mele in Routt. Now, I've seen the bird mele in Route. I've not actually played Root. So, I've had a bit of a think about this one and Vickiy's helped me out with it. So, some things that I particularly like, the Globeries from Perseverance, the squishy globeries, they're really nice. I like them. And also the cat meeples from Evenfall. Even expansion. So, Evenfall came out a couple of years ago. and your witches. And these witches have pointy hats. And then even Fall had an expansion. And this expansion had little cat meeples, but they were a weird shape. And it was like, why are they that shape? And it's cuz they go over the actual hat of the witch. And they're they're quite cool. But if you've got any examples of game components that you like, please put them in the live chat if you're watching. And if you're not watching live, if you're watching it back afterwards, leave me a comment and let me know because there's probably lots that I've missed, but they were just a couple of the ones that came to mind.
Now, Mario wants to follow this up with another question to say, "Do you have a top three game pieces? Not generally from games, but specific not general from games, but specific from different games, i.e. starting player token, card for its power, installation." Yeah. So, I've got loads. Um, we're talking specific game components here and I ran out of time this afternoon. I was planning on going through, you know, lots of games in my collection and trying to work out what the best ones were. I haven't been able to, so apologies for that. Um, I will try and get back to you. Uh, I I would say ask me again next month and I will try my best uh at going through and having a look, but I I'm definitely sure that I've been asked that question in the in the five years or so that we've been doing these live Q&A, maybe even longer.
Uh, I'm I'm pretty sure I've been asked that question a number of times before about favorite components in games, but I just can't think of anything right now. Okay, so Asaf from Easy Board Games has a question. He says, "I'm not sure if I've asked you this in the past, but did you ever try to get into tabletop miniature gaming? Maybe this is something that you did in the past and decided that it's not for you." So, as many of you know, I am not a spring chicken and I have not been in the hobby for a short time. I've been in the hobby for a very long time for 43 years or so and over that time I have dabbled with various what you would call tabletop miniature gaming. In fact, right I I have in the attic the very very first edition of Warhammer Fantasy Battle. It's a in a little box and it's just got three rule books, no miniatures, no nothing. Um, but yes, miniature wargaming is something that I tried many, many, many times. Multiple different systems over many, many years, mainly fantasy, but also I dabbled with a couple of other uh systems as well.
But that was a long time ago. I I basically packed up my attempt at any kind of tabletop wargaming probably about 25 years ago when I decided it it isn't for me. Now, I still do a number of board games which you would class as war games. And most recently, I've covered Quartermaster General South Front and Quartermaster General East Front. Those are war games. They are absolutely war games, but they're not tabletop miniature war games where you've got scenery and you're measuring distances and things like that. So yeah, I have done a number of them in the past and I as I say I tried many many different systems and I never found one that I felt comfortable with to enjoy it. Now as I was saying which game would you recommend for beginners? I have no knowledge of the details of any tabletop war game systems. I am aware that there are two for Star Wars. There's Star Wars Legion and Star Wars Shatterpoint and then there's Marvel Crisis Protocol. I have no idea whether they are good for beginners. I've also heard good things about Frostgrave from Osprey Games, but I believe that's not really a war game.
I believe that's more of a a skirmish um a skirmish game where you've got like four or five miniatures per side rather than 40 or 50 per side. So yeah, I I I don't know. Apart from the obvious ones of Warhammer, whatever it's called now, uh, and Warhammer 40k, which I don't know whether they're good for beginners or not, I I don't have much knowledge or detailed knowledge of of current tabletop miniature board games. Right. Next question for Regina. I've heard you mention in several videos that you don't enjoy games where you chain actions, but I have been playing games and enjoy games such as White Castle and Tatum. Could you elaborate on that? How are those games different from perhaps other games you have in mind? So yes, for those people who don't know, my personal preference in board games is for player turns to be short. Civilion is one of the most recent examples. I'm going to take my turn. I'm going to do this. This does this. Done. You go. And my turn is 30 seconds long. And that's it. That is my ideal personal preference. I don't mind it when player turns take a little bit longer than that. But one thing that I am particularly not keen on is chaining actions. And what that what I mean by that, some people call them combos, I call them chaining, is where I'm going to do something. This is the thing that I'm going to do this turn.
Here it is. But by doing that, that has given me something else which then allows me to do something else. And I'm not talking about I move up a track, I land on an icon, and I gain $3. I'm talking about I move up a track, I land on an icon, and by landing on that icon, that enables me to do a whole other action. Like literally, that could be even be longer than the thing, the main thing. And then by doing that action, that leads to something else. And the reason why I don't like those is player turns take long, a lot longer. I lose track of where I am, what I'm doing, especially when you've got one action nested within another one. Was I was I doing that? Was I doing that? Um, and I have a limit. So, you've mentioned White Castle and Tatum. White Castle, I don't that there is chaining of actions in White Castle, but it's not that big. Basically, you do an action, you'll move a mele up to a space, and if there's an action on a card, I'll do that action, which is what? Place a gardener. Okay, I'll now place a gardener. spend fun food. Do that.
That's it. It's I I don't mind some chaining. Tatum is a little bit on the border for me. I There is chaining in tot. I enjoy the game. It's not too much, but I agree it's there. Most recently though, I have covered covenant and covenant for me was way too much. I think on one turn I did six or seven different things. So yeah, I have limits of how much chaining I can tolerate and my personal preference is for none of it. My personal preference is I'm going to do an action and that's it. And and there's no chaining, but that's that's hopefully an explanation. Uh, next question from Davis. If you could speak to your future self, in what areas of life would you seek advice? Gosh, I mean, yeah, Vickiy's laughing. Um, I mean, literally I could talk to you for an hour about all of the things where um, if if I'm trying to think of specific things, what areas of life would you seek advice? Almost everything. Um, but with regards to the channel, what would I do differently back then?
I mean it's it's difficult because there is a lot of stuff that I did on the channel you know five six 10 years ago which I don't do now and part of me thinks I wish I hadn't have done those and I do more of what I do now but life changes life evolves everything moves on everything changes and some of that stuff that I used to do I'm I'm still quite happy with even though I don't do it anymore I'm happy that I did do it uh there's a lot of stuff that I didn't do one of the things that I has has been a big surprise for me is the Patreon campaign and I kind of wish that I started that earlier because lots of other people were doing Patreon campaigns and going back before the Patreon started which was seven or eight years ago now. I was doing these video logs every month. I was doing review videos and none of it was paid for and I wasn't making any money through YouTube for it. So it was basically taking a lot of time out from my paid work in order to create those content that content.
Now, that's fine because, you know, 90% of board game content creators are doing it as a hobby alongside a paid job. I wasn't at the time. I was doing it as as my job and therefore it was eating into the paid work. So, I'd probably start the Patreon a year or two earlier, but that's, you know, I'd never expected the Patreon to be as successful as it is. Um, but yes, there's there's lots of areas of life where I would I would seek advice. Um, yeah, without going into too many personal details, I would probably look at taking up more healthy outdoor activities at an earlier age. Um, it's difficult because growing up as an only child with parents that may not have guided me, uh, in my opinion, possibly down some right way. I'm not saying they led me astray with, you know, robbing banks and things like that. I'm I'm just saying that there's things about my upbringing in my childhood that I wish were different when compared to I how I see other people and how their families have been have been brought up. Um but that's that's kind of not in my control, but at the point it became in my control, I should have possibly done something about it. Anyway, moving on to lighter things. Uh Andy Pelton says that I have a story to tell about through the ages.
Yes. So a conversation happened and I can't remember how this conversation happened but I said somebody asked me this in next month's live Q&A. So what it is is, and this is going back many, many years now, but there was an Asian gentleman, I think Chinese, maybe not Chinese, but definitely Asian, who was posting on Board Game Geek that they were the world's best player at through the ages, and that they would if if people sent them like $10 over PayPal, they would give them a one-hour tutorial session where they would teach them to become better players. Now, Board Game Geek shut the thread down uh and closed it and deleted it because effectively you've got somebody trying to sell their services. But a lot of people, including uh Check Games Edition, who are the creators of Through the Ages, took note of this. Now, in a lot of people's eyes, this was an extremely arrogant post for somebody to basically post and say, "I am the best in the world. Give me money and I will show you how to play the game." But the people at Czech Games Edition when they were working on the digital version of the game, they looked into this and they got I think I think they got in contact with him. This is years ago, so I might be misremembering some parts of the story, but they got in contact with him and they got his, you know, user account details for through the ages,
the digital implementation, and they analyzed his stats and basically he was correct. This guy was the best player in the world and Vladger really went into the details about how this guy was playing the game and he was winning the majority of his games and he was doing things that were not anything that anybody thought would be a good thing to do. He was buying cards for like three or four civil actions. Cards that are generally regarded as h they're okay but they're not great. He was buying them when they were at the end of the row like spending all of his actions on them and people were looking at it and going well why is he doing that? That's a terrible move except it was right. So yeah, the guy was an absolute genius and he was the best player in the world and I think CG might have looked at the moves that he was making in the game and I think they might have actually altered the the AI for the game based based on that. It was fascinating and I and I only vaguely remember bits of the conversation but it was along that lines. So that that's the story that I wanted to tell.
Andy's got another question and and this is interesting. This this is this is something that I've I've seen a couple of times in the last in the last few months, but Andy has said, "Should content creators show themselves on videos or use AI tools to create a human-looking avatar and a fake generated voice to read through their script? Are the days of content creators on video streams coming to an end? And what do people want to be informed by?" Um, and also, do people want to be informed by content creators that have actually played the game? So the reason Andy Andy is asking this question is there have been and I've noticed this myself in the last few months there have been two YouTube channels which contain AI generated videos and they are one of them was actually creating how to play videos and it was all AI generated and another one and I think this is the one that Andy is specifically referring do is that this is a channel which does reviews of a game and like don't buy this until you've seen this video. And I've watched a couple of them out of curiosity. Now, it is AI generated. It's probably an AI voice. I'm pretty sure it's an AI voice, but what they're doing is they are actually not playing the game themselves. They don't have the game. They're not playing the game. What they're doing is they are trolling through all of the other content creators
who have played the game and have done videos on the game and they are using an AI program to basically troll through all of their videos and put together their own video saying why you should buy the game or not. And as much as I absolutely detest that, I watched that video and it was impressive. If if an AI system has literally done that, the output, I was kind of blown away by it. Now, I'm I'm say blown away from a I was impressed by it. I don't like it. I don't want it. And I'm never going to watch another one. And I don't think anybody should ever watch anything like that at all. But it was hard to tell that it was AI generated. It actually came across as because I I watched it. I watched it and I listened to it and the stuff they were saying was correct. Absolutely correct.
It wasn't just AI nonsense. It was actually factually correct in what they were saying. And it was it was very very strange to see it. But do I think we should have more of that? No. Unfortunately, there are a couple of these channels around. They're knocking out one video a day and they're getting loads and loads of views and comments and and it's just Yeah. Um, but the one thing that does bother me, I will be honest with you with this. The thumbnail that they are using for those videos contain a very attractive AI generated woman. And that is, as much as I I dislike clickbait, that is not one of these people. I don't know who these people are, but they are basically using um you know the the physical attractiveness of a woman on their thumbnail in order to generate more and and I I don't like it when when people do that. Um but anyway, Andy says, "To me, this is absolutely ludicrous. How can anyone say this game is brilliant or rubbish by just watching a preview or a how to play? Um, yeah, as I say, I I was I was very impressed by the video when I watched it from a I can't believe AI is this good to be able to create this much factually correct information based on other people's videos. Uh, but anyway, that's yeah, let me know what you think.
If you've not seen any of those channels, I'm not going to say what they're called for two reasons. one, I don't want to promote them, but two, I can't remember what they're called. Um, if you're really really curious, go out and try and find some, but I kind of don't want them to get any views whatsoever. I do remember one of the channels, and I think this was the channel that was posting the how to play videos, they were appearing on BG, and they got taken down. So the first channel that I I remember seeing which was these as I say tutorial videos I think they got removed from BGG. These other videos I don't think they have been removed from BG. They may have been. I don't know what BGG's stance is on the use of AI. What I will say in defense of the people running this YouTube channel is they are very open about what it is, right? They they don't claim that this is themselves.
They say that this has been AI generated, so they are they are honest about it. Anyway, moving on to lighter things, but I am really curious to know what other people think about this. Uh Andy says, "Do Thor and Loki spend much time climbing the Christmas tree or debbling it?" Thankfully, no. I think the first year we got one, they may have battered at the decorations that are hanging off the bottom, but yeah, generally they're they're pretty good with it. Next question from Benjamin. Have you ever gotten a rule wrong in a board game and then upon realizing your mistake preferred the incorrect rule to the correct one? So Benjamin's example is in Galaxy Trucker the rules are that when one player has finished building their ship, they can turn over the hourglass which basically starts the timer for the end of the round. Well, the way that Benjamin played it is that anybody at any time can turn the timer over. And he said it led to complete chaos. But he prefers that rule to the current one. So it is true that I have played games with incorrect rules. Some of them quite major. Not recently I hope.
But most of the time I I can't remember a situation where I then went on and preferred my rule to the original one. And I'm somebody who does play games with house rules. But generally, if I find out what the rule of a game should be, I will unless I decide, oh, I don't like that rule. But no, I I can't think of any any recent situation where I haven't switched to the actual rule of the game. But again, let me know what you think. If you've got your own ideas on that, I always love reading the comments on these videos. Please let me know. Next question from John Curtis. Of the 16 games designated as ring games at the World Series of Board Gaming, which three would you feel you could possibly win a ring in? So the 16 games are Ark Nova, Castles of Burgundy, The White Castle, Seven Wonders, SETI, June Uprising, Wingspan, Splendor, Earth, Brass Burningham, Ticket to Ride, Azul, Terraforming Miles, Loserings of Arnite, Cascadia, and Aquire. Which of those 16?
Well, which three of those games do I feel I could possibly win a ring in? Well, I theoretically all of them. But honestly, as assuming that I'm going up against reasonably good players, I would never win Brass Birmingham because I'd never played it. I would never win Azul because I don't remember the game really at all. Ark Nova, I think I would have a relatively good chance if the cards came out right. I am I am a person who believes that Arknova is a very good game, but I am also a person who believes that it is quite look dependent. So I I could win a game of Arknova. I could come last in a game of Ark Nova. It really depends on how the cards go.
Castles of Burgundy, I think I would be in a fairly good chance of doing well at that game as I've played it a huge amount and I think I'm pretty good at Castles of Burgundy. White Castle, I don't think I'd be very good at that. Seven Wonders, no. SETI, I've only played a few times. June Uprising, probably not. Wingspan, definitely not. Splendor, probably not. Earth, probably not. Brass Birmingham, no. Ticket to Ride, no. Azul, definitely no. Terraforming Mars, maybe. I And I'm going to cause some controversy here, but I personally believe Terraforming Mars is less look dependent on the card draw than Ark Nova. Uh, Lost Runes of Arnach, I think I'd have a reasonable chance, but not as much as Castle of Burgundy. Cascadia, I've never played. And Aquire, I I'm absolutely rubbish at Acquire. So, out of those, Castles of Burgundy is probably the one that I think I'd do the best at. And then, Ark Nova and Terraforming Mars. If I if I get good card draws, then I definitely have a chance of winning them. Right. Next, we have questions from Keith. If you could meet one games designer for a long lunch and they're paying, who would it be and what is the name and location of the pub, restaurant, stroke, establishment?
I've had a think about this one a few times this afternoon and then I ran out of time uh to to actually pick one because there are I've been fortunate enough to actually meet a number of designers and have long lunches with them and sit down and have good discussions with them. So there's you know people like Vital Lasserta, Isaac Childd, Vlad Shioat, people like that I have been fortunate to you know spend the time with them and sit down. There are a few there's a lot of designers who I respect a lot of designers who I would love the opportunity to sit down and uh and you know spend time with and just chatting with them for about all sorts of different things sometimes game related sometimes not game related. So Stephen Feld I've met a few times but I've never actually really properly sat down and you know had a good chat with him. Uh people like Ranic Canitzia uh less so but that's only because Stefan Feld knows who I am and we've met each other. Ranic Canitzia wouldn't have the faintest idea who I was. So I'd like it to be something that was something appreciated from both sides.
Uh there is one designer who I'm a huge fan of, Alexander Fister, who I've never actually met. So, that would be high on my list just because I've I've I've not met them. Uh, and yeah, where where would it be? Honestly, I'd probably take them to uh somewhere in Colton because then it's it's near and I don't have to travel very far. Um, yeah. So, yeah, probably the place that we went to, Keith, for for that meal. That's probably I think the best restaurant we've got in Colton. Um, what's it called? Alente. That's it. Right. Next question from Henrik. Because of your experience with learning new board games, you can properly easily pick up the rules of a new game. Yes. Generally speaking, I I can. Do I think that there are downsides to this either while playing or reviewing a board game? I don't think so. I I I think I I can't see any downsides to me being able to easily learn a game. And that all depends on how good the rule book is. If the rule book is not good, I get really annoyed and frustrated. And that that hinders my ability to learn the game more so than anybody else because I I get really angry and frustrated about bad rule books. Whereas other people would be like, "Ah, I know what it means. Let's just move on." I'm like, "No, it's not clear." So, yeah, bad rule books will frustrate me and cause my learning process to be harder. But I think my experience at learning games is generally an advantage. I think the only
time it would ever be a disadvantage is if a game does something different than what is the norm, at which point my brain would assume if I'm placing a worker on a space, I'm going to get the benefit of that space. If, for example, the rules of the game are you only get the benefit when you take the worker off the space. Oh, there's an idea. Has anybody done that? Oh, I don't think anybody's done that. There you go. I've just I've just designed a new mechanism. Uh worker placement, but you don't get the bonus for placing the worker. You only get the bonus for taking the worker off. It's probably been done before. Um but yeah, something like that. If the rules of the game are different from what is considered the norm, it might hinder me a little bit. So, yeah. Um Henrik also said that I've mentioned that there is a trend for board games to be fully developed before going to crowdfunding.
So, apologies if I wasn't clear with what I said, and I think it was last month or the month before, but I I don't think that there is a trend to be fully developed. What I'm saying is some publishers fully develop games before going to crowdfunding. For example, all of Vital Lord's games with Eagle Griffin games, by the time they go to crowdfunding, they are done. The design is done. Everything's done. The rule book's done. it it's finished. It's a finished game. And there are other publishers who go to crowdfunding with an idea and then it will be a year of development work. Uh and Henrik is mentioning Open L Studios which is that approach. So Threshold which is Open Studios latest crowdfunded game which I covered on the channel the day before I went to Essen has raised $770,000 and it's I mean it isn't the bare bones of a game. There is a game there because we played it and there is enough of a game there to give people the idea of what this game is about. But that game is going to have at least a year's worth of development to add more content, develop the game, you know, change things that aren't quite working well in order to try and make the best game they can. And that is two different ways of doing crowdfunding. One of them, the fully developed game before you go to crowdfunding. And the other one is you go to crowdfunding with enough of a game to show people roughly what it's going to be like, but then you're going to develop it and it's going to be
delivered, you know, two or three years later on. Do I think that fully developed games are a positive trend or is the hobby missing out by not having more games use crowdfunding to seek funds for further development? I I'm ambivalent. Um I have a personal uh a personal point of view that crowdfunding should be used for publishers to raise money in order to make games happen. And the idea of fully developing the game before it goes to crowdfunding is like, well, why do you need crowdfunding if you've already fully developed the game, but you need the crowdfunding in order to, you know, produce the game and everything else. So, and and I'm thinking back to what Kickstarter was originally set out to do. It was for people who've got an idea. I've got an idea. Here's some scraps of paper. This is what I think it's going to be like.
Give me a million dollars and I'll make it happen. and people go, "Yeah, I want to support you to make it happen." And it won't happen unless you're gonna, you know, make the money to do so. I I like the idea that that's what crowdfunding is for. However, the industry has moved on, the hobby has moved on, and it's now perfectly acceptable for people to use it for fully developed products as, you know, effectively a a sort of marketing tool and and sales mechanism. So, I'm fine with that. I just I just like the original idea. Next question from Bart. Have you ever had problems explaining a game concept rather than the rules properly? For example, Bart says in Bunny Kingdom, he has to point out the difference between a territory and a thief. Thief or F. It's a five, isn't it? Uh at least once per game, probably.
Bart. Um yeah, there there are certain games and if I if I had more time this afternoon, I would have sat down and I would have thought about it. There are certain games where the terminology is really important and it's very common for people to get two things uh mixed up. And there are definitely certain games where with some of the players who I regularly play with who have gone, "Oh, I'm I'm going to do this. I you can't do that. Why not?" Because it's it's Easter and you can't go onto that space in Easter. Oh, yeah. and then, you know, next round, oh, I'll I'll do this. Oh, you can't do that. Why not? Because it's Easter and you can't use that space in Easter. There's there's definitely been situations like that. But, uh, I'm I'm not sure about game concepts rather than rules. I'm I'm struggling to understand the difference between a concept um and and a rules because to me, they're sort of the same things. You know, what defines what a territory is and what defines what a F is. I would say that's more rules, but uh yeah, not sure. Uh right, next question from On your Slack channel, there is a specific sub channel called I Blame Paul, which is for games that I have been personally responsible for others buying into. Is there another content creator or designer who I blame for some of my favorite games? some of my favorite games possibly not, but there are
definitely a couple of uh a couple of games which I have had and have covered on the channel or am going to be covering on the channel where other content creators or other Discord servers have influenced me. And one of the best examples of this is Primal the Awakening. So, Primal the Awakening is a fantastic boss battler style game which I have covered on the channel 15 16 times. I have done a lot of videos for Primal Awakening on the channel and I found out about Primal Awakening through my work on Aon Trespass Odyssey. So, when I was working on the how to play videos for Aon Trespass Odyssey, and I spent six months playing Aon Trespass Odyssey, I was part of their Discord server. And on their Discord server, there was a lot of discussion about a game called Primal Awakening.
And a lot of people were saying, "Paul, you should check this game out." So, this isn't another content creator. This isn't another channel or anything like that. This is just a group of gamers who were on the same Discord server as me for one game who kept talking about Primal the Awakening. In the end, I had a look at Primal the Awakening and I watched a couple of videos and I did watch a couple of videos from other channels who I like and who watch the same kind of games I do. And it is a combination of things that led me to then contacting the publishers of Primal Awakening, Reggie Games, and getting in contact with them. And yeah, and it's it's a great game. So that that's definitely been one of them. And the other game is a game which I'm going to be covering in the new year, which is called Uprising: Curse of the Last Emperor. I am very excited about this game. I've not played it yet at all. I am due to do a playthrough of it, a Patreon only playth through next week, next Friday I think. But I'm going to be doing a public playthrough of it in January. And this is a game that many many other content creators have covered and they all say it's absolutely fantastic. So I am I've got very high expectations of this game. And it's not just content creators. Other people that I know have played this game and have said it's amazing. So I'm very much looking forward to it myself. Um yes, I just wanted to give a shout out to George Os. George, thank you very much for the super chat. Um, for those people who missed earlier on, I mentioned that all of my advertising revenue goes to charity. And anybody who leaves any
super chats in either this video or any of my other videos, that super chat doesn't go to me directly. What happens is YouTube and Google bundle that super chat money into my advertising revenue. So, all of that goes to charity. So, thank you very much, George. We haven't decided which the charity is going to be for this month yet, but at you know at the end of this month or the start of January, we will make a donation to a charity and that super chat will be included in that. So thank you very much for your support. Right, next question from Blaine. What if anything makes Decas stand out as a solo game? So, Deckers, for th those people who don't know, is a new game that came out at Essen Spiel this year, designed by Richard Wilkins, aka Ricky Royal, aka Box of Delights, published by Deeprint Games. Deckers is the re-implementation of Ricky's older game called Renegade. It's the same theme.
It's the same game, but it's been updated. It isn't just a reprint or a reskin with a different name. There has been a lot of development work done on the game, but it fundamentally is the same game. What makes it stand out as a solo game? I'm not going to answer that question. I am going to answer what makes it stand out as a game because Deckas is very likely in my top three of this year along with Galactic Cruise and Elder Scrolls Betrayal of the Second Betrayal of the Second Era. But Decas is something special. It it's it's it's it's hard for me to pinpoint exactly what it is, apart from every single time that I've played it, it sets off all of my pleasure senses because of the way that the game plays.
It's a puzzle style game. And I don't mean an escape room style puzzle game. I mean a puzzle game as in okay so the objective at the end of this round cycle whatever it's called is that we need to have green programs on every even numbered space on the purple and the red server right how am I going to do that this is how I'm going to do it but we've got sparks appearing right okay the the puzzle is ever changing because of the way that the board is evolving and you have to use the cards in your hand the abilities that you have available to you in order to try and meet the requirements of the particular mission. And if you like the way that combat works in Mage Knight, it's like that. It it triggers the same sort of experience for me because it's hard, it's puzzly, it's challenging, you really have to think about it, but when it works when it works out, it's it's a it's a it's a rush. So, yeah, very very um yeah, very big fan of that game. And yeah, that's why it stands out for me as a game is just the intense experience of playing it and having to work so hard to achieve the success. Same with Spirit Island.
Exactly the same sort of thing. You know, you're presented with this situation and you've got to work out and if you're playing multiplayer, you work out with the other people how you're going to achieve it. And when you do achieve it, the experience is fantastic. Next question from James. Can you name a few games then that are not in the BGG top 1000 that I still like playing? So, this is one where I did do a little bit of looking. I looked at the BGG top 1000 and I have picked some games that are outside of the top 1000 which I still like playing. There's loads more. I mean, literally, if I was to scroll down through the pages, I would find lots and lots of games, but here's a few. Star Wars the card game. I really enjoy that. Palaces of Carrera, Evenfall, Atiwa, uh, Atica. So, Atiwa and Atica, Fam, Fam, Homesteaders, Black Forest. Black Forest is outside the top 10,000. Um, there's loads of other games outside the top 10,000 that I still enjoy playing.
There is one of them that I'm going to give a notable shout out to, which is Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Baker Street Irregulars. The green box for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is fantastic, but I'm not going to play it again because I've played them all. But it is fantastic. So, there's a few great games that are outside of the BGG top 10,000. Again, let me know what yours are. Head on over to BGG, find the top 10,000 games, go just below 1,000, and tell me what the first game you get to is that you will that you will enjoy playing. and leave me a comment in this video and let me know what it is. Let me know what your favorite game is that's outside the BGG top 1000. Right, next question from Alex. Uh, Alex bought Senora still in shrink and then realized it had been sitting somewhere in shrink for 10 years now. That's scary, Alex, because I did the how to play video for Senora and if it's 10 years old then wow. Um, it needed airing for a bit. What's the oldest game that I've had that's still in shrink or unplayed?
Was it a gem like Senor EA is for you? So, I'm glad you've played it. Uh, it is a good game. I do enjoy it, but I personally feel it should be six rounds long and not seven. I think the seventh round insignia makes it too long of a game. And I've pretty much done everything I needed to do by round six. So, I I personally play with the variant that that game is only six rounds long instead of seven. Now, just before we went live today, I was in the attic. And I was in the attic looking for a specific game that I was pretty sure I knew exactly where it was because I'd seen it a couple of weeks before. And that game was going to be the answer to this question. This is a very old game that I have had for a very long time. I didn't I didn't buy it from new. I don't know how I got this game.
My guess is somebody that I knew 25 30 years ago was having a clear out and gave me this game and this is a game which is one of the game I mean I have a number of unplayed games in my collection or I have oaths worn right this it's not really been played since getting it I have a number of unplayed games but Freedom in the Galaxy I think is the oldest game that I have which hasn't been played by me. And I'm just going to look up I think it was 1977. Um, and I and I've spoken about this before on the channel. Freedom in the Galaxy. The full name is Freedom in the Galaxy, the Star Rebellions, 5,764 AD, 1979.
So, this is a 1979 game that I have in the attic and I've not played it. And at some point I want to play it. Now I want to play it for a few reasons. One of them out of curiosity. Two, I think it would be a fun stream to do something very different on the channel. Something that no other content creator would would. I don't know any other content creator that would go and get a game from 1979 and cover it on their channel. if there is one, please let me know. So, I kind of like doing things a little bit quirky. The other reason I want to cover it is it's space. It's kind of a space opera style game. And another reason that I want to cover it is one of the designers is John Butterfield. Now, John Butterfield, who designed this game in 1979, John Butterfield is still a games designer. He is still doing games right now. And the game that you may have heard of, which he designed, is Space Corp 2025 to 2300, which is a great game. So, to be honest, if his name wasn't on there, I would be less inclined to cover it. But at some point, maybe I'll cover that game. Now, according to this, it's a two-player game. Um, and Stephen who who is part of my Earthborn Rangers campaign. So, for those of you who are watching my Earthborn Rangers campaign that we are playing every couple of weeks on a Tuesday, I'm
playing that with Steven. Steven has played this game. Well, I I don't know whether he's played it. I think he has a copy of this game as well because Steven's been around as long as I have. Um, and he's been playing games as long as I have, maybe a little bit longer. So, he's got a copy of this game as well. And it might be a terrible game. It might be a really really ter terrible game. It's a very old school game. It's Avalon Hill. It's probably got a terrible rule book, but one of these days, one of these days, maybe we were talking the other day about new Patreon goals, maybe we will make this the next Patreon goal that if I make it to, I don't know what, 1400 Patreon supporters or something like that. I mean, that's not going to happen for a few years, unless I suddenly see a massive increase in Patreon supporters, but if I make 1,400 Patreon supporters, I will do a live stream of Freedom in the Galaxy. There you go. At some point, I want to do this anyway. So, um yeah, that is going back to the original question. That is probably the oldest game uh that I've had that I haven't played yet. The next question from Alex is he says, "I don't think I've played a game since Gridcon.
Can I come over and make you play RCOO? Yes, I'll see you tomorrow. 9:00 tomorrow morning, me and Alex will be doing a live stream of RCOO, assuming that Alex can make it. Now, Alex is a train driver, so maybe he can just get in the train and just That's how trains work, isn't it? Yeah, you do that and he can come around. There you go. We'll see you tomorrow morning, Alex. Uh, next question from Mario. Is there a specific reasons for the Q&As's to happen on a Wednesday? This is one of the best questions I've ever had. So, my thinking about this is Vicky has a regular day job, which is four days a week, Monday and Tuesday, Thursday and Friday. Wednesday is Vicky's day off from her main job to do gaming rule stuff and various other things as well. Is that why we do the Q&A on the way? It is.
See, I thought we'd been doing the Q&As's before you went four days a week. No. Wow. Because we've been doing the Q&As's for a long time. Anyway, that's what my thinking was. And Vickiy's nodding, so that's why we do them on a Wednesday. Next question from Mario. It says, "I don't look like a religious person. I I don't I don't know what religious people look like. Um, but I'm curious. Am I a religious person? Do I believe in gods or gods? Uh, or do I just light a candle during Christmas time for the almighty vitila?" So, personal information here. I have no problem sharing this information. I am personally I am not a religious person. My personal beliefs are and I know this might upset people is that there are there is no God or gods.
I am generally speaking a person of science and I need to see things and physically touch things and I know there are things that we can't explain and I know a lot of people will put that down to um you know religion and things like that but yeah I I as sad as it might be I believe that we we are born and then we die and then that's it. I I don't believe in uh heaven or afterlife or that there's any gods or anything like that. Um, so that's my my my personal beliefs. I am a tolerant person for anybody of any religious beliefs and I am friends with people who are extremely religious and I accept their own beliefs and whatever you know whatever it is that they do.
The things that I don't like about religion is mainly historical. Now, religion these days is generally seen as a as a good thing and helping people and things like that. But in the past, a lot of damage has been done through religious beliefs. And when I look back at at history about how much damage religion has done, that that's not something that I'm comfortable with. And I know that was in the past and I know things have moved on now. But the fact that scientists who said that the earth was not at the center of the universe got burned at the sake or killed for, you know, because they were spouting stuff that was against the will of God. And it that that's not right because the earth is not the center of the universe. You know, we know that now. science has now proved that Colton is the center of the universe. Uh and anybody who says otherwise will be um yeah will have their Jaffa cake allowance cut. So anyway, that's that's that's very very brief summary about my my religious beliefs. One thing that I do want to say though is that just because I'm not a religious person and that I don't follow any religious, you know, doctrines or beliefs or gods or anything like doesn't mean I'm a bad person. I have my own moral code of conduct which I hold in high standards
and we try and do good things and we try and be good people and we try and be nice people. We donate a huge amount of money every year to charity. We buy food for the food bank on a regular basis. You know, we try and help people out wherever we can. And I do that because that's what I want to do. And I think that that is the right thing to do. I don't do that so that when I pass away, I get to go to heaven because I've been a good person. I So yeah, I I just I I just try and be a good person because I think that's the right thing to do and that's what I want to do. Right. Anyway, next question from Mario on a slightly different tone. I have games in storage in the attic. Do we have problems with humidity and do I want to share some tricks that we have to fight it? Luckily, we have no problem with anything in the attic. I've got boxes and boxes of games in the attic that have been there for years and years and years, and there is no problem with any damp or humidity or mold or anything else. So, I can't share any tricks other than putting you in contact with the builder who built this house 25 years ago. Um because yeah, um yeah, we're fine. We don't we don't have any we don't have any issues apart from the hole in the roof where the water's coming in, but that's well the three holes in the roof where apart from that, we don't have any issues with with humidity or anything like that. Next question from Kyle. Uh he says, "You have mentioned several times over the last year that your tolerance for heavy games has diminished." Kyle says, 'I respect that, but my question is simply,
why do you feel that way? And that is also a really good question. I think my tolerance for heavy games has diminished. I think the primary reason for that is me getting older and me me realizing that my time is more precious now than it was when I was in my early 20s. And uh a classic example of this is and it's what made me think about this is the board game Europa Universalists that came out a couple of years ago, 25 years ago, a younger Paul Groen would have gone, "Oh my god, look at this. there's a new board game that's come out with uh you know a thousandpage rule book that's going to take a week to play and is going to be the most complicated board game ever. Right, that's it. I'm going to do this. And I would literally spend every waking moment that I had trying to learn this game, decipher this game, print my own player aids, do all of this stuff in order to really get into it. I would put in all of that effort for this game in order to master it and be able to play it. I would do that. I would do these things right now. Me, I'm like, "No, I don't want to go anywhere near that game literally because I don't have
the time. I don't have the patience. I don't have the energy. I just Yeah. don't have it." And I think as well as it being partly related to me getting older, it's also the fact that I've got so many games that I want to cover on the channel. And if I have a game where I can get it out in the morning, learn the rules within an hour, hour and a, you know, hour and a bit, have a bit of a practice game for maybe an hour, invite my friends over in the afternoon, teach them how to play, and then we play it. and then we play it again in the evening and we're like, "Ah, we've played this game. We enjoyed this game. Great." If it's a super super heavy game, that whole process to get to the point of being able to enjoy it takes a lot longer and I just simply don't have the time. And it's because I want to cover more and more games on the channel. So, if you think about it, let's say next week, Friday night, I am going to play Europa Universalis. Let's say I'm not, but let's just say I am. I would have to spend all of next week learning it and practicing it. And even then, I still wouldn't be ready. Or alternatively, I could play five different mediumwe games where I learned them in the morning, practiced them in the afternoon, and then played them.
And it's also about enjoyment. It's about enjoyment versus the time spent. And there are so many great games which are medium weight, medium to heavy, which you can learn in about an hour, play in a couple of hours, and are great. And this is why I will no longer play Advanced Civilization, which used to be my number one favorite game of all time because playing it is 12 to 15 hours, and I just I don't have that amount of time to get that much enjoyment. So yeah, it's yeah, it's a combination of me getting older, uh, time being more important now to me than it has been before, my patience and my tolerance going down, mainly because I'm getting older. I think I can blame a lot of it due to age, but it's also not just age. It's me developing and evolving as a person and realizing that there are so many great games with great rulebooks that I have less patience for games that are over complicated, overfiddy, don't need to be that fiddly. I don't get I don't get the same amount I'd get the same amount out of them for more work. I hope that makes sense.
Right, moving on. Uh oh, this is another question from Kyle. Kyle says, "I can name a few games that I am terrible at, but I still enjoy because the game is simply fun to play. On the other hand, there are games that he plays quite well, but he prefers not to play them because he doesn't enjoy them." Does my ability to play a game affect my enjoyment? Yes, absolutely. And one of the best examples of this is Tracharion. Tracherion is a great game and I have got rid of it from my collection and I never ever want to play it again. And it's a great game. So why don't I ever want to play it again? Because I'm rubbish at it. Not just I'm rubbish at it. I'm rubb Yeah. I I just can't do well at that game. Every time I play it, I just don't do well. and I've played it five or six times and that's enough for me to just feel I'm not enjoying this experience because I know that I'm not playing well and I don't seem to be able to play well. And again, it's all about time spent. And you know, if we had an infinite number of hours in the day, then I would go, I tell you what, I'm going to play Tracherion again because I want to learn it and I want to become better at it. But if we just look at the games from Mind Clash Games, we've got Tracherion, we've got Anacrony, we've got Perseverance 1, two, three, four, we got Voidfall, we got Ember Heart that
I've not played yet. Um, we got Ren, uh, not Revenant on the way. What else have we got? We got loads more games from Mine Clash games that I've probably forgotten about. So, and some of those are really great and some of those are my favorite games. So, Tririon, no, I would never play Tracherion instead of Anacrony. Anacrony I do okay at H and I enjoy the game. So, yeah, that's that's why. Right, few more questions left and then we come to the end of the Oh, no, there is a few more. Right, I'll try and be quick. Adam says, "In your opinion, what three board games do you believe could be enhanced with minis, even if those minis are mainly cosmetic, like in an acrony? What would those minis be?" So, controversial time, but games with acrylic standes, I think, are great. And the two specifically that come to mind that I've covered on the channel recently are Kinfire Chronicles, Kinfire Council, and Uprising: Curse of the Last Emperor.
These games do not have miniatures in them. They have acrylic standes, which means it's cheaper, takes up less space, and it means you don't have to paint them. And the acrylic standes are really nice. I would prefer them with minis because even as much as I like acrylic standes and understand why these games have acrylic standes, I like miniatures and I like painted miniatures in games. So, personally, I think those games would look nicer with miniatures. The other thing is Gloom Haven. Gloom Haven has miniatures for the characters, but it has standes for the enemies. We played Gloom Haven about 40 or 50 times. If we'd have played Gloom Haven with miniatures, painted miniatures for the monsters instead of standes, I would have enjoyed it more because I just enjoy playing games with painted miniatures in. Other than that, the only one that comes to mind is something like Quartermaster General. Now, Quartermaster General that I've covered on the channel recently has got little wooden pieces for the infantry and the tanks and the planes, and they look great. They're perfectly functional.
Would it be nicer with miniatures? Yeah, as long as they were painted. Now, the next thing, and this is from Andy, and this is where I might just need to take a deep breath before I get too annoyed. So, you've got something to throw at me. Right now, Andy is asking the reverse of the question. Which three games do I believe could be enhanced by not having miniatures? So, without picking three games specifically, I wanted to use this opportunity to go on my usual monthly rant about the state of the board game hobby and the overp production of games, but and I I I'm I'ming on the side of caution with how much detail to go in here into here, but there is there is one game specifically which I'm not going to say what the game is, but there There is one game specifically which to me highlighted this issue more than more than anything else. And this is something which I I see on crowdfunding maybe not all the time but now and again is I see games on crowdfunding which have really really nice artwork and really really nice miniatures and they've got a soundtrack and a story book and five expansions and this oh and
you can get a you know playmat and deluxe components and metal coins and all of these things. And the game's terrible. The game is awful, right? It's not been play tested. It's completely imbalanced. And yet there's a crowdfunding campaign with all of these completely over deluxified things and the game is rubbish. And it it just bothers me. It it really bothers me. Now, I'm not a marketing person. I'm not a crowdfunding specialist, but I know people that are, and I know why these campaigns are like this is because that's what sells. If I produce a game and I put it up on Kickstarter and it was a brilliant game, right? Literally, I've designed this game. I put my name on it, but it's actually Vlad Vatel, Stefan Feld, David Turzy, you know, Vitil Lassera, Rhina Canitzia, I all these top designers, right? And we all collaborated. I paid for them all to come to Colton for a week and we sat down and we designed a game together and we designed literally the best game that's ever been designed. and then I put it on on Kickstarter and it's got it's got a board and it's got cards and it's got cubes and it's got this and whatever, right? And it might do okay.
But if I put it up on Kickstarter with a fancy video, amazing artwork, gorgeous looking miniatures, even if they serve no point in the game whatsoever, right? and say, "Oh, but if you're back now, then we're going to get this and you can get a free plushy and Paul will come around to your house and he'll mow your lawn and all of this stuff." All of these things to add on to the campaign all to make it more attractive and and the game itself is Yeah, it it should be about the game and it's not. And crowdfunding, I think, is our worst enemy as far as getting good quality games out there. Now, that's not to say that there aren't some really good quality games on crowdfunding. There are. There are some fantastic games that use crowdfunding.
So, I'm not saying all games that use crowdfunding are bad. I'm just saying the bad games wouldn't have existed if we didn't have crowdfunding because the designers would have gone to a publisher and the publisher hopefully would have played the game and gone, "Your game's rubbish. You need to go off and redesign your game." But unfortunately, as a as a consumer, crowdfunding has given terrible games a platform to be made. And yeah, and I I yeah, I wanted to say a shout out to Asaf from Easy Board Games who Asaf is one of those people that have reached out to me and said, "Paul, if you ever need to vent, please just give me a shout."
And earlier this week, I did. So, thank you, Asaf, for listening to me as I had a massive, massive, massive rant about the state of the board game industry and one game in spec specifically. Um, and thank you for listening and that allowed me to uh yeah, to calm down a little bit. Um, anyway, there there you go. So, going back to your question, Andy, which three games do I believe could have been enhanced by not having miniatures? Yeah, I I wasn't able to think about a response just because my brain went off into the uh the over production of games. Um there we go. I'm not looking at the chat, so I don't know if anybody's agreeing with me. If you feel the same or if you feel the opposite, let me know in the comments. If you're watching this video back, let me know in the comments. Right, I will try and be quick with the rest of these questions.
From Cat, good evening. I recently watched an older Q&A from November 2021 and in one of those questions I said, "Do you have a game that you prefer to play solo instead of multiplayer?" To which I answered, "No. Is this still the case?" Yes, this is still the case. I will always, always, always prefer to play a game with other players rather than solo. And that's not to say that I don't enjoy solo gaming, but I always always prefer with other people. Next question from Kristoff. Which campaign game have you already tried at least once that you would love to play more if you had the time? Which campaign game have you not tried yet that you would be interested in playing if you had the time? So, Oath Sworn, I mentioned that earlier on. I have played Earth Oath Sworn when it was in development. I have not played it since getting the final version of the game. Would I like to play it? Yes. Fate Forge Chronicles of Karm for Mighty Boards. I have covered that on the channel. I have started the campaign of that. Was it very good? Yes.
Do I want to play more? Yes, I want to play a full campaign of it. Kinfire Chronicles. Loved it. Really want to play the full campaign of that. Um, ISS Vanguard, the other campaigns because we finished the main campaign, the other Tainted Grail campaigns. So, there's so many of them. So many of I've recently taken Delivery of Rove. Uh, and yeah, I'm not sure when I'm going to play that, but I' i'd like to play that as well. So there are a lot of campaign games that I would like to play if I had the time. Next question from Ronald. How much interaction is too much in your opinion? So this is the thing as a Eurogamer. Eurogamers quite often get categorized into we don't like interaction between players and that's wrong. Right? I am a Eurogamer and I love interaction between players but only to a certain level. So, for example, Kais or Kais 1303. Perfect. Perfect example of player interaction. The way that the provost moves up and down the road. It can be brutal, but it's controlled by the players and it's just it it works brilliantly.
That for me is one of the best examples of good player interaction in a Euro game. I'm not just talking worker placement. You went on the spot I went to. I'm talking about actual proper player interaction. So, I don't shy away from player interaction, but when is interaction too much? It's when it's direct take that interaction in a game with more than two players. I have no problems at all with take that mechanisms in games and direct player conflict as long as it's a two-player game or a team game. I have issues with it when you're playing a three or four player game and somebody plays a card that says lose 10 points and destroy half of your buildings, right? I I that's too much interaction. So, direct player conflict in a game with more than two players. I I generally would avoid those games at all costs.
Final question from the guild is from Marie, and this is about the fighting fantasy books. Do I ever go back and read all of the options that you didn't choose to find out how to win? No. Uh and I and I want to and it's due to lack of time. So, for those people who don't know, when I took my week off work at the start of December, on one of the days, I think it was Thursday, I did a playthrough of one of the old fighting fantasy books, book number 20, Sword of the Samurai. If you're interested, it's on the channel now. We're talking those choose your own adventure books from the 80s. And I spent all day Thursday, Thursday afternoon and Thursday evening and I played through Sword of the Samurai. I did multiple playthroughs because you die and you go back to the start. But we got to the end twice and we didn't succeed. On both occasions we didn't succeed. And Marie is saying, "Do I ever go back and reread the other options to see what would have happened?" And I generally don't. And it's mainly due to lack of time. Um, and in the back of my mind, I'm thinking maybe at some point, I mean, I was thinking about this over Christmas, but I'm so far behind on other stuff, I'm not going to have time. Maybe over Christmas we do a special Patreon only bonus stream where we go through and play Sword of the Samurai again, but this time we actually make it all the way through to the end. I I I don't know. Um, but that's it. That's the end of all of the questions that I've been asked in advance on the BG Guild. So, a big thank you to everybody who's asked those questions in advance. And like I
said at the start, if you are watching this video uh back afterwards and you want to know how to ask me questions, then you need to head on over to the guild on board gamegeeek guild number 2258. Join the guild, subscribe to the guild, and then a few days before the next Q&A, there will be a thread that appears where you can ask me questions for the next Q&A that will be the middle of January. Right, contest time. So, every month as part of these live Q&As's, I give away either £50 or £75 of Games Law game vouchers. It's £50 if you are not a patron supporter and you win, and it's £75 if you are a Patreon supporter and you win. £25 of that comes from Games Law and the rest of the money comes from myself. And I'm only able to do this again thanks to the support of the Patreon campaign. So, a big thank you to all of my Patreon supporters. And the winner for last month is Brian Robson. Now Brian has been told about this. So congratulations Brian. Brian is one of my patron supporters. So Brian gets 75 pounds worth of games vouchers from Games Law and Brian will let us know what he's going to buy with that money hopefully.
Talking about the Q&A from last month. Last month's live Q&A was one of my most popular live Q&As that I've ever done on YouTube. bits had 2,700 views, which is quite a lot more than most of my other Q&As's. 2,700 reviews. Only 181 people entered the giveaway. Now, it doesn't cost you anything to enter the giveaway, and you can win £50 or £75 at no cost. You could literally get free money, and less than 5% of people who watch the video enter the contest. That just feels a bit weird. Now, obviously, the fewer people that enter, the more chance there is for everybody else. But when we look at how many Patreon supporters I have, I have over a thousand Patreon supporters. I have 1,250 patre supporters and only 181 people entered the giveaway. I mean, it's up to you. It's free money. Um, I'm just I'm surprised by the low number of people that enter that anyway enter the giveaway. And while we're talking about giveaways and the low number of entries, there are two other giveaways that I'm currently running at the moment. The first one is for digital copies of a game called My City. So, My City is a board game designed by Ranicia, published by Cosmos. There is a digital version of it that is published by Spiral Burst Studios.
and I'm doing a giveaway. And to enter that giveaway, you need to go and watch my video for My City Digital Playrough, which was on the channel from a few weeks ago. Um, and the details of how to enter are in there. There's been about 60 people that's entered so far. So again, free digital keys for a copy of My City, which you might not like My City, and that's absolutely fine, but tell your friends, spread the word, go and check out my video for My City, and I'm doing giveaways for some digital keys. The other giveaway that I am doing at the moment, this is only for patron supporters. But if you are a patron supporter, I'm doing a giveaway for for a copy of Magnate the First City published by Naylor Games, designed by James Naylor, friend of the channel, friend of mine. Uh, and Naylor Games have donated a spare copy of Magnate the First City. And I'm going to be doing a give I am currently running a giveaway for that. Now, the details on how to enter that one are in my bonus video log, which is only available to Patre supporters. So, not my regular video log, but my bonus video log where I rank all of the games that I played last month. Go and check out that video, which you won't see on the YouTube channel, but it's Patreon only, so you'll need to access it through the Patreon page, and the details of how to enter the magnate giveaway are in that video. So, yes, there you go. Right. So, let's move on to the questions that we've been asked while we are live.
And the first one is from where are we? Where are we? Where are we? Here we go. Right. So, the first qu and I've not seen these before. So, these could be absolutely anything. Uh oh, did I do um Oh, for the contest this time. Yes, sorry. We've got a contest this time. I'm telling you all about last month's contest. We have a contest for this month. The link to enter this month's giveaway is in the chat right now. It's also in the description of this video. And if you're listening to this as a podcast, it's in the link to that as well. Let's hope we get more than 181 people. Uh I mean, it doesn't matter to me if only one person enters. It doesn't actually matter to me. Um but all you need to do is click on the link, enter your name, enter your email address, and the secret word. And the secret word this month is going to be tell you what, let let's make it dungeon pets. This is a dungeon pets mug from Czech Games Edition. So the secret word this month is dungeon pets. There you go. And that's all you need to do and you might win £50 or £75 of games law games vouchers with which you can buy games with.
Right. So Trevor has got a question. I know you answered this in a prior one, but I don't remember the answer. What are your favorite sleeves? My sleeves of choice are Paladin sleeves because they are really good quality. They don't seem to vary in size. I've bought hundreds and hundreds of Paladin sleeves and they are all exactly the same size across multiple packs bought over multiple years. They are very thick but not too thick. They don't split and they're cheap. They're really really good price. So yeah. So my my sleeves of preference are Paladin sleeves. Uh next question from Miade. Uh would you ever consider consider hosting a convention in Ireland? Absolutely not.
Preferably Dublin, but Belfast would work as well. We don't have a similar convention to GridCon on our little island. So the reason why I say absolutely not is because we run one convention a year and that's enough. Um so hosting another convention in another country uh is even even hosting another convention somewhere else in the UK is not something that we want to do. So personally no I would never consider hosting another convention anywhere other than where we currently host it unless we have to move. But we we don't want to go far. So, um it's a it's a shame that Dublin doesn't have a convention. Now, I I do know people um who live in Ireland and I'm more than happy to help them organize a convention if they need any help. So, yeah, if you are one of my supporters from Ireland and you are thinking of hosting a board game convention and you need help, please let me know. We're more than happy to help.
Next question from 9,000 Brett. Sorry if I missed this answer, but I really missed your rules explanation for speak easy. Is there any plans to have one done? So Brett, you need to follow me more because I have been talking about speak easy. Um, and I'm literally in the middle of filming it right now over there. It is set up on the table. The script is written. I am 65% of the way through filming and then I will finish that hopefully um yeah if not tomorrow I'll finish it early next week but then I will be editing it editing it I'm not going to get that done this year so my aim is to have a first rough draft of the video available by the second week in January which will go to my patre supporters it will go to Viddle it will go to Viddle's testing team and then once we've got approval I will then begin the final editing and my aim is to have it done by the end of January. But yes, if you're one of my patron supporters, you will get early access to it, but only in the in the draft form. The finished version will be pretty much made available to everybody at the same time. So, yep, speak easy how to play video is a work in progress. Uh, next question from Scott, which is a very important question. Apparently, we all know what the best gift to receive at Christmas is, do we? But if you were to receive board game themed socks this Christmas, what board game theme should they have?
I mean, Mage Knight, obviously, cuz that's the best board game that's out there. So, Mage Knight themed board game socks. Yeah, there you go. I mean, that that's a really easy question. I'm not sure if there's some kind of subtle hidden message in there. If you were to receive board game themed socks this Christmas, what board game theme should they have? Yeah, Mage Knight. There you go. That's a really, really easy answer. Uh, hopefully that's the answer you were looking for. Next question from Stephen. What are you looking forward to playing in 2026? So, that's really interesting that you've asked that, Stephen, because yesterday I was thinking while I was in the shower, what videos would I do if I had more time? So, these these are these videos are not going to happen because I don't have the time, but I was thinking of doing a video of what I'm looking forward to in 2026 because there's already quite a lot that I'm looking forward to in 2026. Now, Steven says he's excited for To Boldly Go and Second Contact, which is wave two of Star Trek Captain's Chair. So, for me, there's a lot coming out in 2026 that I'm really excited about. First of all, to Boldly Go and Second Contact, more content for Star Trek Captain's Chair is great.
Lands of Evershade is very likely my most anticipated release of 2026. This is the next big campaign game from Awakened Realms from the same designer as Tainted Grail and ISS Vanguard who does all of the narrative and the story and the world be building. I'm a huge fan. So super super excited about that. What else is coming out in 2026 that I'm excited about? I look I I had these ideas the other day and I'm trying to remember what we've got coming out next year. I'm going to look at my work diary, see what I'm covering next year because some of this is stuff that I'm excited about. Uh, where is it? Where is it? Where is it? Uh, oh, Cloudspire. Cloudspire content.
More Cloud Spire content. So, I'm going to be covering Cloudspire again next year. Um, what else have we got? Horror on the Orient Express. I'm quite excited about that. Lots of other people have played that already, but but not me. Um the Oh, I don't know if that's secret. That might be secret. That might not be not secret. The Voidfall expansion. I don't think that's secret. Uh so I'm excited about that. Um there's a game called For the Gods from Mighty Boards that's designed by um David Thompson and pro probably Trevor Benjamin and I think Brett Gilbert as well. So I'm excited about that. Anyway, there's loads there's loads of stuff next year that I'm excited about. I'm really excited, as I mentioned, about playing Uprising. Um not for the first time. I will be playing it for the first time next week, but I'm playing it on the channel in January. So, yeah, just looking ahead to January, February, March, and beyond.
I'm really excited about that. Also, and I don't know where this is. I might have accidentally deleted it from my diary, but um Enormity from Into the Unknown. I'm excited about that. Uh Kingdoms for Lawn, also from Into the Unknown. I'm excited about that. And Hubworld Avalon from Earthborne Games. I'm looking forward to that as well. I'm gonna just put that in because it seems to have disappeared. World Avalon. I'm doing the how to play video for that next year. So, yeah, loads of things for 2026 uh that I'm excited about. Right. Okay. Next. Who is your favorite darts player? I don't think I have a favorite darts player. Um it's a good question, but no, I I don't think I have a favorite darts player. Uh what's yours and Vickiy's favorite game?
Well, my favorite game is Mage Knight. Vicki doesn't have a favorite game. I think we got asked this last month and I don't think you I don't think you had one. No. No. Vicky doesn't doesn't have a favorite game. Um uh Jeff is saying, "Oh, following on from my discussion about religion, do I ever get challenged? How can you be a good person if you uh don't believe in God?" Nope. But Jeff says that he has been challenged thusly. Oh, I love the I love the way you've written thusly. It's such a good word. You get challenged. No, I don't. Um to be honest the the the religion discussion is not something that crops up. Um also me being a good person doesn't crop up like that day where I was walking to Tesco uh and there was a a woman with a young kid. This is years ago. Do you remember this? Uh years ago now. There was a woman with a young kid and the young kid was wearing Wellington boots and one of the boots was literally in the stream. I don't know how the boot had got into the stream, but it had uh so I basically spent like 20 minutes helping them trying to fish this Wellington boot out. Most people would have done that. You know, I'm not saying I'm some kind of hero or anything. I think most people would have helped them. But I did go out of my way and went in and everything else. and then came back and I said, "Oh, I'm Wellington boot rece or fix or something or other." Uh made made a joke out of it. But no, I I don't get challenged on that. And and I'm pretty sure I'm not
the only person. I think there are a lot of good people in the world who do good things who also are not religious people. So yeah, I'm not saying I'm special in any way. Next question from Retroare. I would like to know if storing in a callax, can game boxes still fade in normal room lighting? Does anybody know or should I check the UV index in the room somehow? So this is not anything to do with the callalax. Callax is how you store your games in your room is irrelevant to the discussion about whether your games would fade. It doesn't matter if they're stored in a bookshelf, in a callax or or anything else. Can games fade in a normal room lighting? It depends on the room. It really It really does. It depends which which direction your room is facing.
What I will tell you is that if you are in the UK and you have a south facing room and in your south facing room on one of the walls you have your game stored, then within a couple of years you're going to get color fading. Uh I unfortunately have color fading on a couple of my boxes because I had them I'm pointing over there. You can't see, but in front of my south facing window, I have a games cabinet. And I had some games on top of that cabinet. I say a cabinet is like three foot high. And I had some games on top of that. And they were on there for a matter of months. And some of them have faded. And that's because in the summer, the sun can be really strong coming through a south facing window. So yes, any games that you have near a window of natural light are going to fade. That's that's just the reality of the situation.
Next question from board game therapy. Can you please tell me what is your camera and microphone and also lens? Uh I can I can tell you this now quickly. My current camera that is on me is a Logitech Brio. Uh my microphone is a I can't remember. It's a a Bayer Dynamics M340. I think it's like a a gooseeneck microphone. It's one of those ones that you It's a lect turn mic, but I've got it hanging down from the ceiling. Uh and I don't have a lens on on that one. There is a thread on my BG if you want to know more about the overhead camera, the other camera, and all of that lot. I do have a thread on my BGG guild where I list all of the equipment that I use. So, it's all on there with all of the technical details. I think it's up to date, but there is a thread on my guild on board gamegeeek. Just go to my guild, scroll through, and you will find a thread on there. Uh, next question from uh DMB. Hi, Paul. How would you spot a poor game without trying it? Yeah, it's a good question, and reading the rule book normally normally would give me a good indication. So, if the game So, I'm not always right on this.
Sometimes I will read a rule book for a game and I'll go, "This game sounds awful." And I will just dismiss it and I will choose not to cover it on the channel. Sometimes I will read a rule book for a game and I'll be like, "Okay, this this sounds okay." But then when you're actually playing it, you realize it's a bad game. For example, right? I'm going to give you an example here, a completely madeup example. The rule book for the game says if you go to the tavern, draw two quest cards from the deck, choose one, put the other to the bottom of the deck, and that is the quest that you're on. Okay, fine. Yeah, I like that as a rule. You're not just telling me to draw one card. You're telling me to draw two, choose one, and put the other one to the bottom. So, I can already see from that that this isn't just a, you know, a silly game. Draw a random card off the top of the deck, right?
So, I say, "Right, I'm going to cover the game. Send me a prototype, whatever." And they send me the prototype, and I draw this quest, and I draw these two quests. And one of them says, "Go to the nearby village, kill a rat, and get a,000 XP." And the other one says, "Travel halfway across the world, kill 5 million rats, and get the same XP as this one." Right? I mean, a really, really extreme example, but that is a terrible game because you have a balance issue because the cards are not balanced. And sometimes you won't know that until you're actually playing it. Also, the rule book might say this is this is a one and a half hour game. There was one game recently that I remember seeing on Kickstarter that said playtime 1 hour.
Everybody I know who played this game, it was between three and four hours. And yet their marketing and their Kickstarter and the rule book says one hour. It is not one hour. That is just a lie. So sometimes, and that's down to misinformation in a rulebook, but sometimes a rulebook can give you, you know, the wrong opinion of a game. Um, and yeah, that playing it is the only real way to know how it's how it's going to play. Next question from Looting Rek. Uh, what nonboard Oh, yeah. No, no board game question. No more questions. I haven't said no more questions, but no more questions, please, for today because it is 6:30. Um, and I'm getting very hungry and I've got another show at 8:00. We'll talk about that in a minute.
Um, what non board game themed socks would you get if you could? Oh, non board game themed socks. Well, I tell you what, the other day, you remember those socks that I saw on the internet? What were they? They were like animal socks, but they weren't just socks with animals on. They were like an animal was actually on the front of the like the animal was hugging you and there were loads of them and they were really funny. Now they're in completely impractical because I can't wear Oh, no. You probably could wear things. No, you could. Yeah. No, they'd be fine. So, yeah, they they'd be cute. I I Yeah, if somebody got me those and I'm not saying you should, I would probably wear them. So, non board game theme socks. And I can't remember what some of the animals were, but some of the animals were really cute animals. One of them was like a vampire bat. Very cute vampire bat that basically attaches to your sock. Um, what is your go-to animal to visit at the zoo? It's got to be the mircats. Always the mircats. I mean, other animals are available and very cute and very nice, but uh, always look forward to seeing the mircats whenever we go to any kind of zoo or animal park.
Next question. Do I have a favorite word? I don't have a favorite word, but I have a number of words that I really like. Like shenanigans is a great word. If I was forced to pick one word, it would probably be shenanigans. What other words are my favorite words? Vicki is going to try and have a think about some of my favorite words. But shenanigans is definitely definitely a word I like to use. Uh words that make you happy because of how they sound or connotations from the word or your own. Yeah, shenanigans. Definitely definitely shenanigans. Next question from Zia. How do you pick a game to play when you have too many to choose from? So, this is this is a good question and I refer back to my patron supporters. So, my patron supporters quite often vote on which game they want to see. I will put a vote up on my patre page sometimes of here's here's 20 games that I want to play.
Choose one of them and and they will choose which one I play. But other than that, it is quite tricky. Um I mean there's two things here. How do I pick a game I want to play when, let's say, people come over for the afternoon and we don't have anything planned and we have to pick a game? I will be picking a game based on the people that I'm playing it with, whether I'm happy teaching it, whether they're happy playing it, whether the theme is going to be good for them, how complex the game is, and how long it takes. So, I will be factoring all of those things in, but I will always then pick something that I want to play. The other side of it is if I've got a slot. So, I'll tell you this. I'm just looking forward to January, right? If I go back to my diary for January, because this is a this is a real example of a real situation.
January the 2nd is a Friday and in the evening I'm going to be doing a live play. What game am I going to play on January the 2nd? Well, what I going to Right now, we are in the the few months after Essen. So, every year I go to Essen, I bring a whole bunch of games back and I haven't yet gone through all of the games that I have brought back from Essen, which means I will be going to my patron supporters and they have already been voting. They've been voting for the last two months on which game they want to see next. And I can tell you now the current votes are for the next game that they want me to play. If I just find out here, Essen Games 2025, the one with the next most number of votes. Oh, I can put that in green. Is Voinich Puzzle. So, Voinich Puzzle is the one that has received the next most number of votes.
However, I have other things planned for January 2nd. I have I am planning to do the vlog. So, I'm not going to get December's vlog done in December. I'm going to do it on the 2nd of January. That means I'm going to spend all day uh filming and editing the vlog, which means in the evening I won't be able to play Voyage Puzzle because I won't have had time to learn it or practice it. So, in that case, I'm going down the list because I don't do things in the exact order that my patron supporters. I use that as a guide. But going down the list, we have, for example, White Castle Jewel. Now, White Castle Jewel, I have no idea where it is, but I brought it back for Messen. I think I will probably be able to learn that and play it in an evening. So, it might be that or it might be Kingdom Crossing.
Now, let's say, for example, I've already covered all of the games for Messen and I have a free day on January 2nd. I will have a good think if to see if there's something that I really want to play. But to be honest, I really like letting my patron supporters choose. And I know a lot of my patron supporters, every time I put a poll up and I say, "You vote. You tell me which game you want me to play." A lot of them say, "No, Paul, you pick. You play the game you want to play." And I'm like, "No, you're not understanding how this works. I have given you 10 games. I would love to play all of those 10 games and I'm more than happy whichever one you pick." So, you pick it means somebody else is making the decision instead of me. Um, yes. So, there you go. That's my That's my process of picking a game to choose from. Is that it? Is that the last question? Gosh, we didn't have many live questions today, but that's fine. That's fine. That means we can wrap things up. So, a few things before we wrap things up and uh we say goodbye. First of all, don't forget to enter the contest for this month. The link is in the chat. You could win50 or £75 of games vouchers from Games Law.
All you need to do is click on the link which is in the description of this video. It's going into the chat now. Now it is going into the chat and that's all you need to do. Just click on the link, fill in the form, and the secret word is dungeon pets and you could win 50 or 75. Also, if you're interested in winning a copy of My City, the digital a digital key for My City, the digital adaptation of the board game, please go and check out my My City playthrough from a couple of weeks ago. And there are there is information in there on how you could win a copy for that. And final giveaway is a copy of Magnate: The First City. You need to be one of my Patreon supporters to win a copy of that. And the details are in my bonus ranking extra video log for November. So go back through the Patreon posts and you will find it. It is on there. It is the is not on my YouTube channel. It's not on the public YouTube channel. You will find a link to it on on the Patreon page. So yes, um that's the contest.
Also, thank you very much again to all of my patron supporters for funding the channel, making this video possible. Without your support, I can't do what I do. So, thank you very much. And if you want to support me directly, patreon.com/gamingrulesules. Remember, if we get to 1,400 Patreon supporters, I will do a live stream of Freedom in the Galaxy. I know everybody wants to see it, so I'm expecting 150 people to join the Patreon page overnight. That would be awesome. It's not going to happen. I might get one, but it's nice to have these goals. And to be honest, at the current rate of growth of about an average of 5 to 10 people per month, it's going to take uh a year and a half. At the current rate of growth of the Patreon campaign, in about a year and a half, we might make 1,400 Patreon supporters. To be honest, that's probably the next bit of free time that I've got in a year and a half. So, yeah, that's fine. Um, but yeah, let let's do it. Silly goal, but but we'll do it. Uh, that is everything except at 8:00 tonight, I am going to be the quiz master on the Whose Turn It Anyway podcast live stream. We're going to be doing a Christmas quiz tonight at 8:00. Now, this is not on my channel. It is on the Whose Turn is It Anyway channel, and there is a link to it in the description of this video. So, in the description of this video, there is a link to their video that's happening at 8 o'clock tonight. It's a live stream 8:00
tonight. I'm the quiz master and you can play along at home. So yeah, if you're interested, that will be happening 8:00 tonight. And again, you can watch that video back afterwards as well if you want to. But other than that, we are all done. Thank you very much for watching. Thank you very much again to everybody for your support. And I will see you all, some of you later on, but for the next Q&A 2026. Happy Christmas. Bye-bye.