Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Idles Review: Man vs. Machine

Transcript 17:05

Hello everyone. I'm Tally. This is Farrell. And we're Born of It. And welcome to our review of The Idols, a head-to-head asymmetric card game for two players. Now, longtime viewers of our channel may remember our years long continuous praise of Caper Europe, and it was at a time our favorite two-player game. Now, The Idols is the designer of Cape Europe's first game since, and it's also head-to-head two-player. So we were very excited to hear of its development.

Yes. So as you said it's two player and it's asymmetric. So one player is going to take on the role of Maxwell, a supercomputer who's been made manager of a company and is of course obsessed with productivity. I should say this is all taking place in a kind of dystopian 1950s America setting. while the other player is a lowly employee just trying to get through the day, work hard, be noticed because they don't want to be branded an idler, which from context sounds very bad in the universe of the game. So, there are two things to know before we go into the review and how to play. So, the first thing is that this is a review copy from the publisher. And the second, and this is where there's probably going to be a bit of a train crash for a lot of people, is that the art in this game is all, I believe, uh, generative AI art. And now the designer, publisher have reasons for doing this.

I'm probably going to explain them badly, but from my understanding, it's something to do with kind of being a subversive piece of art. the fact that is kind of envisioning this soulless dystopian corporate hellscape and to use soulless art as a way of showing that um and also as a as a kind of statement to draw in a forum of having discussions about this. In any case, there are a lot of I think discussion articles they've posted on their website about why they've done this and their reasons behind it and discussing. They have posted a thread on BGG where I think basically anyone can go and talk to them and they're responsive and you can debate it with them. From our part, I will just say that we don't agree with the decision they've made, but that's what it is. Is there a game? So, we're just going to stick to what we do and review board games. And with that, let's get to how to play.

The Idols pits Maxwell, a supercomputer, against some average employee with the factions playing asymmetrically. This is actually a deck building game with both sides coming with large decks of action cards and a couple of character cards to choose from. The game comes with instructions on how to create starting decks alongside tips on how to create your own. There's also a companion app where the designer or other players can post decks for other people to recreate. On a player's turn, they will draw a card, reset their energy to max, and gain three actions. The core actions are to play a card, draw a card, or generate caps, which are the main currency of the game. Players may also choose to spend their energy in order to boost their action, and they'll get to do that action an extra time for each energy spent. Cards that have been played, may also give you other actions that you can take. Maxwell has three types of cards: programs, supervisors, and events. Aside from events, which are a play and discard type of thing, all of Maxwell's cards will be played face down. Programs will be played next to the character card, while supervisors go above the programs character and deck in order to protect them. Programs can be activated at the start of Maxwell's turn by paying caps, but the supervisors can only be activated once the employee interacts with them.

The employee has skill cards, asset cards, and events. Skill cards will provide ongoing powers, while assets are cards that can be used for effects such as generating energy or caps. All their cards are played face up and paid for as they go into play. The employee, importantly, has a unique action, the grind action. They will pick a column of Maxwell's board and work towards Maxwell's programs, character deck, or discard pile. When they do this, Maxwell can activate supervisors. with activated supervisors usually requiring some sort of sacrifice from the employee or else their grind action will end. If the employee reaches the final card of that column, they will get to look at it and get some sort of bonus. That card may give the employee caps or it may allow them to pay caps to discard that card to Maxwell's discard pile, thinning their deck. Now, what players really want are to get productivity awards because whoever gains three productivity awards will win the game. So, the game goes like this. The employee is kind of probing Maxwell's defenses trying to make it through to their deck or their hand or their programs to uncover these productivity award cards because then they get them and they're one closer to winning. Whereas Maxwell plays them as programs and wants to defend them with supervisors and on their next turn flip them over, which means they've scored them and then they're their one closer to to winning the game. Now, the game

can also end if a player has no cards left when they begin their turn. The Idols is a strange, strange game, and it certainly takes a play or two to get to grips with the asymmetry. However, once you do, the game really blossoms into something rather interesting. You begin to see different strategies. Tensions start to build, and it truly does become head-to-head as you actively work to hamper the other player.

Yeah. So, this could have been just another two-player head-to-head game, and it could have felt very similar to the other games out there, just that, you know, it has an asymmetric twist. But I think what changes this is the fact that there is hidden information. So the Maxwell player plays all their cards face down and this creates this element of uncertainty and it becomes almost like a social deception game or a bit like poker because if you are the employee Maxwell you're kind of having to read each other like you would in poker which is quite interesting. The faceown cards provide opportunity for misdirection and fake outs as Maxwell can build a big wall of supervisors in front of a program and the employee grinds, spends all their resources and finds nothing. While the actual productivity award was left undefended and ignored by the employee who assumed it was worthless because why would Maxwell leave it undefended? Because the employee never quite knows where the productivity awards are. It creates a lot of tension for both players. For Maxwell, it's sitting in fear that the employee is going to guess right and discover where your productivity rewards are. Taking a precious one away from you uh from literally your hands. Uh you know, it it's sitting there going, "Oh, are they going to guess right? Are they going to figure out that this program I've just played is a productivity? Are they going to breach my defenses?" Or sometimes you get into situations where you're sat there and you've you've got like three in your hand and you're like, "Oh, please please don't grind towards

my hand." Or just living in fear when they grind towards your deck and neither of you know what's going to come up. Then if you're the employee, there's the tension that you're always against the clock that any program Maxwell plays could well be a productivity award. And do you risk going for this one or that one with your limited resources? Should you go with the deck? Maybe Maxwell hasn't played any. And this is uncertainty that builds the tension. We've talked a lot about, I guess, what it feels like to play, but not so much the mechanisms. And something I think we both really enjoyed is how the decks feel different in terms that they give different strategies that you can go with

and each play can be a bit different even within the same deck and then you can expand that out to the fact that it's a deck building game which we haven't talked so much about. Would you agree?

Yeah, exactly. I think in one game as an example when I was the employee I was putting a lot of cards out that gave me extra actions for example and then another game maybe I was building up to get more cats to allow me to do more.

So even within the same faction obviously it depends on what you draw out but you can really lean into different things and ways of going about things because maybe it's more beneficial to get extra action. So obviously you can kind of do more in a turn, but if you were to get more caps, it gives you more chance of beating the supervisors, for example. So yeah, I definitely leave this game feeling like I want to have another crack at it and maybe just going about it in a different way.

Yeah, I think similarly playing uh as the employee, I've seen different strategies. You know, I had one where I was working on getting you to discard your cards. Yeah. which means that your deck thins out quicker, especially if I can see that you've set up a lot of draw and extra card cards

because then that can become a negative effect if your deck goes too thin because you can lose if your deck runs out of cards.

Yes.

So, I was kind of raiding and discarding a lot. And then in another game,

I made it my strategy just to set up a bunch of combos to raid your deck where I was kind of getting to look at four cards at a time instead of one or three cards. And then, you know, if any of those are productivity awards, I get them.

Yeah.

And I ended up winning that way by kind of right at the end of your deck drawing three or four cards and two of them were productivity awards and that's all I needed to go out of the line.

Exactly. And then Maxwell, for example, you could choose to get a bunch of program cards out because they give you extra benefits and bonuses. Um, or you could choose to kind of build up your supervisors because you want to protect them up front because maybe you have a scoring card in your hand in the beginning. It really depends on when they're coming out. But then you're also given a signal to the other person if you're protecting a lot that maybe you do have a scoring card and then they might change the strategy to

go after it on the suspicion that you have scoring cards. So it's just Yeah. Is like

very interesting blend of

these kind of strategic and tactical things with a little bit of mind games as well.

Yeah, exactly. It's like and it's interesting balance because at the start of the game as Maxwell, you're weaker in terms of your defense.

Yeah. So the employee might be more likely to raid you as you play programs, but if you haven't really played any scoring programs and it gets towards the end of the game or the second half, then they're probably going to pivot and start going to your hand or to your deck because they know that they're not they haven't been played or scored.

So it's kind of interesting as well how things can pivot.

Yeah. And it hasn't happened in our game, but you might be able to make Maxwell like forcefully discard a program

or a productivity award and then you can f it in their discard pile for it and they can't really do a lot besides

set up supervisors.

Yeah.

I think something that's really interesting is you can always replace cards

cuz you're limited to how many you can play based on your character of each type,

but you can replace them. And I've also had interesting strategies like that, like late game when I kind of only needed one more productivity award, but I had like two or three in my hand.

Um, I basically blitzed my program area and played four cards at once, replacing all of my previous ones. So, they're all face down. They're all protected in some way. And Tally,

I know that I can't go after all of them.

Yeah. So, you have to like kind of, oh, which one is which, you know, and and hope like you can get it. Mhm.

Um, so I think all that's really interesting and turning to the deck building element. So it is a deck building game. You get a large kind of number of cards and your standard deck is made up of 30 cards plus uh your character and there are some very basic rules like no more than three copies of a card which to be honest I don't think there are more than three copies anyway. Um, and you know, some tips on how to build that. You have instructions for a starter deck. And then additionally, there's this app, uh, Babble, which you can download for free. And essentially, this acts as kind of a repository for the game. So, they're going to put Arata in there. They're going to suggest other decks you can build or players can build decks and suggest them to other people, I think, is a concept. The rules are in there. Um, and it's supposed to be a little kind of forum, I guess. So, we played with the starter deck and then we played with at the moment there's only kind of one recommended deck for each side in the app and then we played with that deck and I think that was really interesting as well. And in the future we'll try deck building.

Yeah, exactly. Because a lot of the powers will interconnect with each other, right? So, you want to build in a way that lets you get chains of action for example. Yeah, for sure. Um, one thing I is stressful when you're playing it, but I think is very interesting is the economy with the caps. Um, because you, especially as the employee, you know that you need to have enough in order to try and make a dent in the supervisors, but you also need to spend them to build up your is it the assets for the um employee, which gets you could get you more actions, could get you more caps. I struggled a lot with getting enough caps and or just knowing should I just grind to try to eliminate one of your program cards or get one of your programs because it was unprotected or should I just spend the caps on setting myself up for better terms in the future. It's quite it's quite a tough decision which is uh always interesting when the decisions like a little bit hard, right?

Yeah. I think also for Maxwell, I think I found it generally a little bit easier to get coins, but one thing I find quite interesting that I've used against you offensively is that Maxwell always pays when the cards are activated, not when they get played. So, one thing you can do if you can see that Maxwell was a bit, I don't know, low on coins. Let's say they activated a few cards at the beginning of the round and they spent some coins is that you can kind of save some of your actions and you can go, "Okay, I'm going to grind here." And then they're like, "Okay, well, I'm activating the supervisor." And they pay for it, but then they now don't have enough caps to pay for other supervisors and maybe they haven't considered it or

Yeah.

or you know, just because, right? And then it go down supervisor and they can't afford to activate them and you kind of get a free pass and you can play.

So I think that's quite interesting as well because there's a balance of when you spend cuz sometimes

maybe you will let them raid your deck just because you're like I I don't want to waste the caps or

Exactly. Yeah. And maybe you deplete them through being able to activate the supervisors, but then they might not have enough next time to activate the program cards, which then are the scoring.

Yeah, exactly.

Yeah, it is. Yeah.

So,

challenge.

Yeah, it's really good. Uh I look forward to exploring it more uh and deck building. So, I think the end summary is that uh we really really enjoy it. We really like what it's doing. We really like a lot of the gameplay. We like the uh potential it has. Obviously, it's disappointing with the whole generative AI thing, which I think for a lot of people is always going to put a black mark on the game and turn them away from it, no matter the purpose of that.

But that's what it is. And you know, it's almost a shame that this game is very good because if it was terrible, then everyone could just kind of forget about it, right? where now I would say it's something worth playing, but people are not going to want to uh for reasons basically.

Yeah.

Uh for for understandable and and good reasons. So that is our review of The Idols. Uh please ask us any questions you might have about the game. We appreciate you watching. We hope to see you again and thanks a lot. Bye.

Progress saved