Cascadero Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I am taking a look at cascadero which is a two to four player board game designed by Rina kitzia artwork by Ian o tool this one takes around 45 minutes to play on average now before I get started on my review of cascadero I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off off your first order okay so let's talk through how the game works and I should say that this game does come with a double-sided board uh the side I'm showing you here comes with these farmer tokens um which are added from the other side so basically the other side is simpler than this version so this side I'm going to show you has um everything you need to know essentially um but basically the objective of this game is to get as many points as you can however you will only be eligible for scoring if you reach the top of your track of your matching color so as the yellow player here I won't be able to win unless I reach right to the top of this yellow track now there is an exception to that if nobody reaches the top but generally speaking somebody will so you want to be making sure you hit that Pinnacle now gameplay wise is very simple where all you're going to be doing is you're going to deploy one of your little envoys anywhere you want um onto the big hex map here so I could go here for example like so then it would be my opponent turn and then it would be my turn again so just showing you some
examples here so if I ever placed a Envoy and it reaches a city or one of these towns for the first time and that has to be at least a group of two uh then you are going to go up on that matching track you can see here that I've reached this orange track for the first time therefore I'll go up on the orange track like so now if I'm the first player to do that then I would get one movement up the track but if I'm the second or subsequent player then i' would go up two spaces on that particular colored track now these white pieces on the map here as well they will increase it by one again so again if you're the first player on one of these white cities then you go up twice and if you're the second or or third or fourth or whatever you'd go up three times so those are particularly powerful towns to visit now when you go up these tracks you can see that you are going to get a number of bonuses so these four tracks here matching the players colors uh come with these bonuses here which will give you victory points if you are the first or following players to reach that particular spot um they might give you these um these little seals here if you land exactly on that spot and these seals are cool because when you deploy them you can deploy them with your envoys and I'll instantly count as a group so you know as I said earlier you need to have at least a group of two before you reach a town this time you can go straight in to a town like so and move instantly up on that track so it saves you a turn essentially other bonuses on the track come with these little Cube movers so if I reach
this spot that would instantly let me move up another spot and as you can imagine that can um combo and Domino with other bonuses um if you reach one of the seal spots and the Seal's already gone then you'll get to shift one of your envoys to an adjacent spot you won't get a bonus but it does let you can cover more ground get more victory points take extra placement actions and more victory points and so on now in addition to trying to climb these tracks and get points that way you can see in the center of the board here you have a number of objectives that you can go for so these top six here are first come first serve so you want to be racing to get to these objectives and I'll explain what these are so this is to get all five of your cubes to the level one spot with the little fer relase here so if you're the first person to get all of your pieces there then you'll get three points uh if you get three of your pieces pie to the level two spot you'll get three points or one of your pieces to the top spot you'll get three points now these objectives here are common objectives that everybody can get with no kind of competition really uh this is where you will get points based on connecting uh two different places or so two different locations of the same color together so if I built a whole chain like this with these blue pieces so with these yellow pieces but I attach these two blue towns together then I could place my little flag showing that you know I've attached these two blue towns together and i' would get two points for doing that um and if you get all five of those done
then you'll get a bonus 10 points but that's quite difficult to do uh the other race objectives are to have three seals in your supply um to connect five cities of different colors together or to collect three cities of the same color together and you can see here also on the track that there are some of these um crossed out spaces and that means in order to cross out little threshold there you need to move up by at least two spaces in a single turn so if I was here and I moved two spaces I'll be bumped back to this spot like so so you need to be making sure that you're timing that just right now with this farmer side of the board you do have these tokens as well which are pretty self-explanatory but much like the uh the towns you need to have someone next to it before you can Venture onto it like so you can't just go straight on to that spot so in this example you can you can place more workers get victory points get move more cubes up your tracks um and so on and as I said you're going to keep on doing that until somebody has reached to 50 points or somebody has deployed all of their envoys um and then you're going to calculate victory points based on I know if somebody's reached the top of the track then only the players who've reached to the top will be eligible for scoring and amongst those um you'll be the person with the most victory points if nobody reached the top of the track then it's just going to come down to victory points alone okay so let's start by saying that I am a huge Rin kitzia fan and I'm a particular fan of his root building style games of this nature so
naturally I was very excited for this one to come out and to be honest this was at the Forefront of my most anticipated games of 2024 and especially when you mix that genre of game with the art style of this you know I love medieval style games and this might just be my favorite box cover of all time it's absolutely stunning to look at the graphic design is really good but let's get into the actual nuts and bolts of the game play here so you know I do like the minimalist nature of the game playay in terms of what you're doing on your turn simply Place one of your little envoys down and get the relevant bonus should you trigger you know a scoring of one of the towns or get one of the the bonuses or of course reach one of these objectives but I have to say that I think the flow of this game isn't quite as smooth as some of his others of this nature you games like through the desert Babalon Blue Lagoon I think they're a bit more free flowing and a big part of that for me and this might sound silly is that the kind of polarizing parts of the game as in the the map movement and the Track Climbing I don't think they blend as harmoniously as I would have expected um because it seems like you're just doing something here then you're over looking over here and you're always going back and forth moving up on spot on the track whatever and it's very difficult to plan out what you actually want to do because you are juggling so much information in your head especially when you start hitting at these points like this when you're starting to move other tracks as well now don't get me wrong I really do like this idea of getting bonuses as you
go this kind of reminds me of another kinia game called celtis where you're getting these huge combos by climbing up this track that you come this track let you put another one down which lets you do this action which get you some points and so on so the combinations here are really cool um but I do find that boiled down nature of this grid movement is slightly or the attention is slightly taken away from this because of that CL Track Climbing now I also tend to like Kia's twists on scoring in games now the twist in this one is that you need to reach the top of your particular track before you are eligible for winning the game um and for me that put you in a little bit too much of a box in this one because obviously you're going to really focus on your particular color and it seems like you don't have that much wiggle room to do other things now don't get me wrong you can you know get to the Rift of most other um of the uh tracks if you focus on doing that um but of course you're always going to prioritize your own color and I must admit it can feel a little bit deflating and a bit anticlimactic if you're doing really well on points your opponent maybe isn't doing so well but they reach the top of their track um and they win so you know it can draw to a bit of a halt especially when you burn through envoys at different Paces because of the bonuses that you're getting I do quite like the public objectives here you know racing to get to these particular ones is a difficult thing to do and you have to focus on doing that which may detract from your Track Climbing um and i' also like the fact that you can go for these
as well without the worry of people taking those spots from you but of course only one person could go on each spot on the hex grid therefore people will be blocking off your roots either you deliberately or inadvertedly and this is kind of the next talking point I want to mention um I do feel the game is a little bit loose unless you playing with the full compliment of four players now even at three players I didn't feel like I was massively blocked in or boxed off for doing stuff which meant that the sense of urgency to get to particular spots wasn't as interesting as the other kitzia roote building style games you know I me I think of games like Babylonia if somebody goes somewhere that's a huge opportunity cost for something else whereas this one it didn't quite feel and as strong now that being said I do feel like this side of the board with these Pharma Tok is a bit more interesting because you know getting a a three-pointer is quite nice and the other side is just has a little bit less going on and it doesn't kind of pull you in different directions as much now despite the potential for some cool combos in this game I do think that the game lacks those big turns like for example like when you climb these tracks or when you get this particular action to shift one of your envoys to the next you don't actually score that particular town if you were to do that so you know if I had this shift action and went here I wouldn't score this town I'm not sure why that is the case maybe because it can be abused a bit too much but I felt like that would have been a cooler thing
to do and it makes your turns feel more meaningful it just feels a little bit too subtle for me the game does flow at a nice pace and it does not outstay its welcome at all so I definitely do have to mention that you know 45 minutes for a game like this feels right on the money for me and production wise I think this game looks fantastic it does mix that cool medieval style artwork with the bright colors and still very functional components um very well all the wooden mles look fantastic and all these bright again vibrant colors all matching those tracks so yeah no issues at all nothing's too big nothing's too small everything's very clear symbology wise so yeah when it comes to production this is um top marks for me okay so let's get into some final thoughts for cascadero and I think I do have to um Asterix this review by the fact that I am such a huge kitzia Fanboy and a particular fan of these styles of games and because of that I hold this sty of game in the highest possible regard and I hold them to the highest standards um because of that and for those reasons I feel like I cannot avoid saying that this game was a little bit of a disappointment for me I think it's a little bit too clunky I'm always kind of just doing something and hoping it works out um I think that the tension isn't quite there when it comes to the grid placement particularly when you are playing at two or three players which I think is a big no no in a game like this now what other con game you know that don't section off a portion of the map
when you play with lower play counts this game does not do that there is some you know relatively decent interaction when it comes um to reaching for the objectives and know sometimes routs will be blocked off but you can always find a way around that I do like the celtis style track movement I think this is cool um but again all in all I think the game is a little bit too subtle and maybe tries to be a little bit too clever for its own good and you know maybe even lacks that fun Factor by taking those big turns everything just feels uh too small here and you know this game did come hand in hand with a roll and right version of the game called cascadeo which I haven't played yet and I have a feeling that this game would actually lend itself better to a roll and right Style game rather than a full-sized board game cuz I think you can get the whole feel of the game in a pen and paper quite easily um and I don't really see the point in having the both of them now I've not played cascadeo yet but that's just going on my gut reaction now this review might have sound like it's very negative and I don't want it to sound like that because this is still a good game you know it's still probably a five and a half or six out of 10 for me but as I said when I wanted this game um I was almost expecting it to be my favorite game of the year um because it has everything I want you know I love that grid movement I love love Track Climbing but they just do not harmonize very well here in my opinion again it can feel a little bit too anticlimactic doesn't scale too well the replayability isn't great because the tension doesn't come through very
strongly on the grid so yeah it's just a bit of a disappointment for me which I'm very very sad to say especially when it looks so so gorgeous and definitely my favorite box cover of all time so surprised but disappointed to say that this one did not work for me so that is cascadero