Skip to main content
Loading video...

Don't Buy Dice Throne Vanguard Until You Watch This! (board game review)

Transcript 10:29

If your favorite board game suddenly grew fangs, learned kung fu and started mining diamonds midfight, would you still love it? Because Dice Throne Vanguard might be that glow up. Hey everyone, I'm Eve.

And I'm Adam. Brace yourselves. We borrowed Dice Throne Vanguard from a friend to test it out, and we're going to say things that might hurt your feelings. Not sorry, we don't sugarcoat. We are the Board Game Critique and today we're tackling Dice Throne Vanguard, the expansion that adds four new heroes and basically yells, "Surprise! Dice Throne can do more." And yes, we're going to tell you if you should actually buy it.

Quick vibe check. We're not doing a tutorial. If you want a tutorial, hit the link in the description. We're talking should you buy this or skip it, and we're pulling from our actual playthroughs, laughs, mistakes, rage quits included.

Okay. High level Vanguard gives you four heroes. The Forgemaster, you craft armor midfight. The Duelist, he literally dances across a footwork board. The Druid, cat scratches, bear hugs, shapeshifts. And the Sun elf, manages a solar dial like a caffeinated astronomer.

The core dice thrown heartbeat stays the same. Roll custom dice up to three times, play cards, bring your opponent's health to zero. But each of these four heroes messes with that formula in a way that's spicy, sometimes delicious, sometimes nuclear.

Let's start with Forgemaster. I played him and I swear I turned into a fantasy welder. He has zero upgrade cards. Zero. And a deck full of ore cards. You mine, you scrap, you craft helmets and shields that literally sit on your character art. It's tactile and absurdly satisfying. Absurdly oppressive. You mean she crafted an ultimanium helmet and an ultimanium shield? I hit her for what? Nine damage?

Nine. And you took six back in retaliation because of the helmet while my shield just shrugged the rest off. I was cackling.

Cackling is one word. I was emotionally bankrupt. It's cool that you can scrap gold to heal or draw or hoard for big crafts, but man, the table got busy. cards, ore piles, armor tokens. My brain needed a filing cabinet.

True, the component management climbed hard. I had scrap, gold, diamond, and ultimatium stacks. And look, I loved it. But if you want breezy plugandplay, Forgemaster is not your guy. He's a slow barn tank that punishes reckless aggression.

And speaking of aggression, the dualist, my main dude. He's got this five space footwork board. Each upkeep, you move one to two spaces forward or bat. Forward means more damage, plus one to plus three. Backward gives you defense or card draw. It feels like fencing in a bar fight.

Adam literally glided forward to that plus three position and smacked me with 12 undefendable damage. Undefendable. Do you know what that does to my carefully crafted armor? Nothing. It laughs at me and leaves.

Timing is everything. I danced forward for big hits and popped back when I smelled Eve's ult coming. One turn, I retreated, drew a card, then bounced forward and finished with an undefendable combo. It's super tactical. Tiny decisions that snowball,

but it might be too snowbally in mixed seasons. When I played my friend's season 1 hero against Duelist, it felt like bringing a spoon to a sword fight. The undefendable damage ceiling is scary when someone pilots him. Well,

totally fair. Now, druid. This one surprised me. Cat form, you apply wounds that tick on the opponent's turn. Bear form, thick hide, regeneration, big cuddly wall that slaps back. You can swap forms when you've got the right tokens.

I had a turn where I went full cat, applied two wounds, then immediately shifted to bear, soaked your counterattack with thickhide, regenerated, and watched your wounds ping you on your turn. It felt like chess with claws.

And it's flexible. You can bait someone while in cat, then turtle. If you love planning two turns ahead, Druid rewards that. But if you forget to manage your tokens, it's like transforming into the wrong animal at the wrong party.

Finally, Sun Elf. She's got a sundial that charges from dusk to dawn. You build energy 1 to 5, then flip to dawn and unlock new powers. You can spend energy for bonuses, extra damage, strong heals. She's a resource puzzle in a knife fight. I messed up with her so hard. I hoarded energy like a dragon, flipped to dawn, and then spent it recklessly. Next turn, I needed healing, and I had the resource instincts of a raccoon. She rewards discipline spending. When you manage her correctly, oh wow, I timed a dawn flip into a burst turn, spent energy for bonus damage, then healed, and it felt like playing a tempo control mage in a dice brawler. Very cool. But the mental load is real.

Let's talk likes. For us, mechanical innovation. These four heroes don't just reskin old stuff. Forgem crafting is an entire miniame. Dualist's footwork is spatial tempo. Druid shape-shifting is reactive strategy. Sunf is a resource dance. It's genuinely new.

And the theme integration slaps. The armor pieces slotting onto the art. The duelist literally advancing and retreating on a board. It makes the fiction feel tangible. It's like the components are cheering for the design.

Backwards compatibility works, but with a big asterisk. We threw dualist against a season 1 hero, and unless that player is sharp, it can feel lopsided. Vanguard is a leap in complexity and ceiling.

Generally, production quality gorgeous. We only had our friends copy, but the art, the boards, the tactile feel, all top tier dice thrown. It's going to look amazing on the table, provided your table can handle it.

Because here come the dislikes. Complexity creep is real. Forgemaster has ore types, crafting choices, and timing windows. Sun elf asks you to budget energy with foresight. Dualist makes you track position plus dice combos. Druid juggles forms and status tokens.

Component management was our biggest pain in the butt. I had ore piles, armor tokens on my board, and a hand full of mining cards. Adam had the footwork board, plotting his moonwalk. We actually moved our drinks to the floor to protect the tokens.

Classy

balance worries, early impressions, Forge Master can become a brick wall that punishes basic attackers. Dualists undefendable spikes can create feel bad turns. You can play around them, but if your group includes newbies, expect some I guess I just die faces. learning curve. Each hero is basically a miniame. It's awesome depth if you're a fan. But when we introduced this to two casual friends, they were like, "Can we just play season 2?" That says something.

Also, Kickstarter exclusivity. Some deluxe bits are locked behind the campaign. If you're a completionist, hello FOMO, my old friend. If you hate that model, you might side eye this release. Real quick, some stories from our sessions.

Druid versus dualist. I play dualist. I stalked forward to plus two, threatened a big undefendable. Eve went cat for wounds, then bared to tank my retaliation. On my turn, wounds pinged me, and I had to retreat to draw, giving up pressure. It felt like a tugof-war of tempo.

Forgemaster mirror match took ever. Hilarious, but we were two tanks slapping each other with pillows full of nails. If your group likes speed, maybe don't mirror the anvils. Sun elf versus a simple season 1 hero. I watched our friends struggle to track the dial and plan spending, then eat a massive undefendable from dualist in the next game. It highlighted how Vanguard raises the execution bar.

Where does Vanguard sit among other sets compared to season 1, this is a huge jump in sophistication. Season 2 took things up a notch. Vanguard breaks the ceiling. Marvel sets honor their characters. Vanguard experiments hard. Adventures: Added Co-op. This mutates competitive play.

So, should you buy it? If you're an established Dice Throne fan who wants fresh mechanical toys and doesn't mind more rules overhead, this is a resounding yes. It will make your collection feel new again.

If you're new to Dice Throne or your group hates bookkeeping and prefers clean, quick duels, skip Vanguard for now. Start with season 2. You'll thank us or you'll tweet us politely angry messages. Either way, we read them. And because we promise not to sugarcoat, mixing Vanguard with very simple heroes can lead to skewed matchups. And Forgem Stall plus dualist spikes might tilt your table. We saw it. We felt it. We ate snacks to cope.

But when it sings, it sings. The moment you place that ultimatium helmet or hit perfect footwork into a surgical strike or time a cat to bear pivot or flipped on and turn a losing board into your spotlight, it's electric.

Final verdict, 8.5 out of 10. Bold, beautiful, and mechanically ambitious. It expands what Dice Throne can be at the cost of complexity and potential imbalance in mixed play. We borrowed this from a friend and yes, we're giving it back before we accidentally keep it. Would I buy it? As a fan who loves crunchy asymmetry, yes. For my casual cousin who plays once a month, nope.

My buy or skip? Buy if you've got a dedicated group and you enjoy mastering weird awesome kits. Skip if your table is allergic to tokens, sideboards, and reading cards with your thinking face.

Either way, hats off to the designers for swinging big. Vanguard doesn't feel like more of the same. It feels like a manifesto that Dice Throne isn't done evolving.

All right, we're out. If this review helped, like, sub, and tell us which Vanguard hero you want us to pit against Barbarian first. My money's on dualist making the Barbarian cry.

Barbarian doesn't cry. He rages, then loses to a helmet. Kidding, kind of. Bye and see you in the next

Progress saved