Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Lord of the Rings: Fate of the Fellowship - Discussion

Transcript 34:41

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm doing a discussion over the fate of the fellowship. This is the newest game by Matt Lehawk, the designer of the Pandemic games. And I am a huge fan of the Pandemic system. Almost every single iteration of Pandemic I have enjoyed, ranging from base Pandemic all the way to Legacy to all their spin-offs besides Star Wars uh World of Warcraft and that really really bad uh water one, Rising Tide, I think. But um like I have Iberia, I have Cthulhu. I even liked Rapid Response, uh Fall of Rome, and Legacy, you know, season 1, 2, and three. All of those are my uh are are absolutely phenomenal in my opinion. So, whenever I heard that they were doing a Lord of the Rings Pandemic game, I was like, "Okay, I'm all I'm on board." You know, they could just take Pandemic and rethe it. And that's what I was expecting whenever they were uh you know whenever I was getting this played. And it could almost not even have this pandemic system on the box because it's pretty far from pandemic. Uh my initial read of the rules I was like, "Okay, no, I see it." Um but then as I kept playing it, I'm like, "No, not really." It does feel a lot closer to Fall of Rome, which was pretty far from pandemic already, but it was called Pandemic Fall of Rome.

I'm glad this box doesn't say Pandemic, you know, Fate of the Fellowship or Pandemic Lord of the Rings or something stupid. It is pretty much its own game. Um, right off rip, literally the only thing. If you're a fan of Pandemic, then you know, you'll most likely like this. Um, if you're not a fan of Pandemic, then I would recommend you give this a shot as well because the only thing that it pretty much has in relation is its deck system. Um, in the sense that or and also its kind of turn structure. You have four actions on your turn and then at after your turn you draw two cards from a deck that is layered with, you know, the skies darken cards. Um, and then you draw cards from the uh the shadow deck, which is how troops move and uh and how they're placed on the board and things like that. But other than that, there's there's no, you know, uh like there's no outbreaks. It's not like these uh little enemy shadow army uh meuples. It's not like once there's three then they outbreak and all that. Nope. There can be um 30 in one spot if you're unlucky enough.

you can carry a bunch of troops with you to help fight them or to go and fight them. There's no Yeah, there's no spreading things. The way the the orcs and the Urukai and all of them move is uh very clean uh in the way that the system works. So, I have had a fantastic time with this game. Now, I will say, let's go ahead and talk about the negatives um because there's not really that many, but there is a massive one that does alter my enjoyment um with this game. And I had I had heard a podcast talking about this issue um and I was like, well, that was before I had played it. And whenever I was setting it up, I'm like, no, I don't think it's going to be a problem. It is. And that is the fact that this board is in way too small for everything that you are doing. it gets so crowded with [ __ ] um that it becomes extremely fiddly uh because of the fact that there you're not limited to a certain amount of uh troops or enemies in one spot means they can all congregate in one area and then the Naz Ghoul are constantly moving across the board. Um well depends on how often you're moving Froto because they kind of hunt Froto down the entire time.

Um, and if you aren't moving Frodo, then they just kind of will latch on to where he is at, and there's not enough space. It becomes very uh cluttered uh pretty quickly to where you're knocking over pieces. They're they're literally in one spot. All they needed to do, and other games do this, is have like a sideboard. Well, all they actually need to do is make a bigger board, but that costs money. And as can't spend money. Um, then if they weren't going to do that, then make a sideboard to where it's kind of like, oh, here's a token that you place in the spot and here's where all the enemies are off to the side. So, it's it's freeing up the main board. So, you can see the o you can see the icon, you can see the sideboard, know that all those troops there are in that spot. Um, I'm really hoping someone becomes a fan enough to make a playmat for this where it's a an enlarged board so that you don't have that issue. And I like the way the nascal look. I like the little meeples of, you know, I mean, they're all the same for the the free peoples, but they're different colored colors.

Um, but at least they're a different model. I much prefer that over cubes. Um, but the fact that they're tiny doesn't make a difference. There's so many times where things are just meshing into one that it becomes a mess of trying to actually play the game or look for where things are at because you had to cover up words, you had to cover up regions. It is a major problem. Uh, in terms of production, normally, unless it's coming down to actual quality, uh, normally I don't bring up production, but it's it it affects gameplay enough that it needs to be brought up. The other thing about production, and I have moved into a new house where I've actually had zero issues with humidity on literally any game, something about these cards, these tarotized cards, has caused them to warp pretty egregiously.

like I every time I'm playing I'm like boowing them back. It's every single every single card um where they're just warped in such a way. So it's like it feels like they kind of skimped out on production whenever you're buying an $80 game. Um so that's extremely frustrating. Um so then you go into the actual gameplay. So, the unique thing about this game is every single um card has an icon on it. There are four types of tokens you can get where it's the ring, it's it's a like resistance, sneak, friendship, and attack. I I don't remember what they're all called, but it's it's a a cloak, um a heart, a ring, and two swords. And those are tokens that you can get that you can just have as a pool of tokens to spend. But you also can spend your cards that have the icons on them. So, whenever you're doing actions throughout the board, whether it's needed to move Froto without having to make a search roll, whenever it's, you know, trying to muster and get more uh f uh free peoples on the map to help you attack the armies, you can spend cards and or tokens.

Well, that just almost feels like an unnecessary action. It almost seems like they couldn't think of a fourth action for you to do because you can I mean you can move, you can trade cards, you can uh you know spend um a a friendship token to add more troops to the board. But there's an action called prepare, whereas if you're in a haven, which is like these, you know, popular name spot, Rivendell, Helm's Deep, uh the Shire, things like that. If you're in those spots, you can discard a card and get the token that's on the card. And the only reason why you would ever do that, besides some characters having a prepare action. Hey, when you prepare, you can do this. It just lets you free up your hand to have a token. So, they're the exact same thing. It's not like you can only spend tokens to do actions. you can spend your cards the same way, but it's like, well, I have nothing to do with my cards, so I guess I will uh I'll just get rid of this card to get a token, and I'm not really missing out on much except now I can draw two cards in my hand because you have a hard hand limit of seven. It's not at the end of your turn. It's when you hit seven, discard down to seven. And I find that action to be almost useless unless you have a way to get cards back, which characters do.

There are ways for you to be like, and I mean, I guess that could be part of the strategy, like let's say someone has Gollum in their hand, Gollum has an ability where uh you can as an action, you can just take any stealth card um from the discard pile. So, if I have Gollum and I and I'm trying to move with Frodo to get into Mordor, then it's like, well, we need a sneak card. I don't have one. someone before me could discard one, still get a token, then on my turn as Gollum, I can, you know, pull that and that's perfectly fine. I I mean, I much prefer there are ways to interact with the discard pile cuz in other Pandemic games, you had to almost card count. If you discarded like too many reds, then you might not have enough to actually cure it if you didn't have ways to get them back. So, there are reasons to do the prepare, but there's a lot of times where it's like, well, I have too many cards in my hand, so I guess I'll just prepare and get tokens. Um, and then I mean, that's not even really a negative. It's more of just kind of like a eh I wish there was a a different kind of action. It works. It's fine. My my only two big negatives are the the board size and the card quality. Now, let's get into the positives. This could not be a more thematic Lord of the Rings game. And because Lord of the Rings uh the trilogy as a whole is the best uh trilogy ever made and they're my absolute favorite movies. For the

record, Fellowship of the Ring is my favorite between the three. Um there's so much theme that you can pull from this because one, the objectives that you get uh that you're aiming to do are all thematic. um the actions that your characters have and the characters in the game uh which there are this many in the game uh is all thematic. It just when you can play this put on Spotify and play the Lord of the Rings soundtrack uh it's it's amazing. Is it the best Lord of the Rings game? Um it's it's up there. like if you are wanting kind of that full Lord of the Rings experience where you can really kind of get into the immer uh immersion of what you are doing um it's it's up there now it's enhanced because it is a cooperative game. I would still probably argue that War of the Ring is the better Lord of the Rings game, but it's also a 1v one. And the reason why that one is kind of above it is because it has kind of like a what if scenario um where there's like things that you can do in that game that are like oh what if this happened in the lore here you're getting a lot of stuff that ends up being exactly what happens in the book or whatever happens in the movies and that could be also incredibly fun too but there are the the the actions and the strategy that you're taking is uh very thoughtful

like there are a lot of forward planning because I mean when it comes down to pandemic there's a lot of times where it's like you're biting your time you know reacting to a lot of stuff while you're waiting for the scientist or one character to get the cards cuz it's like oh my opening hand blues in it or whatever it's like okay well I'm curing blue here uh they've pretty much nixed that where everyone is playing an integral role uh because every single character plays completely different which is amazing. I mean so you have Gollum, Gandalf, Phamir, Aragorn, Legalis, Arowan, Boramir, Marian Pippen, Aomir, Gimly, Galadriel, and Aowen. Why Eland isn't here, I don't know. That'd be cool. Um, but I mean I'm trying to you without dipping into the Hobbit, you really have almost every single character here, but like for example, Aayowin can muster for free in Rohan. Um, so that means she can get Rohan troops out pretty quickly and she has no living man am I. And if she's present in battle and one of the results of the Naz Ghoul icon is rolled, she can actually remove Naz Ghoul from the game.

uh which is huge. Uh then you have like Gollum. He reduces the amount of search dice that are rolled by three. So, but he can't do anything else. Like he can't muster, he can't attack, he can't capture, he can't travel with troops. He is literally there to help Frodo get into Mordor. Um but he also has a negative where if there's friendly troops, him and Frodo, you lose hope. Um, Aragorn has he can reroll one search die if he's present when a search is rolled. He can kill two troops if um a certain result is uh is rolled in battle and just for free if at least one quest has been uh completed, he can just kill a uh a shadow troop. So it it they've solved the problem of having like meta characters in this game where you're I mean there are characters that are like man this character would be really good with this quest. But that's part of the fun I think is not having to sit here and be like okay we need the scientist and the medic to do well. You know like in Pandemic you almost always want a medic and you almost always want a scientist. Here it's like okay let's shuffle up the characters. I mean, you always have to have Froo and Sam um to win the game, but depending on the objectives that you have, you might have to play with certain characters. Uh if you don't have that, then it's just a random assortment of who is involved in this uh telling of

Lord of the Rings, and that could be incredibly fun. like each game I've played has gone completely different uh depending on the characters that I've had and uh even if I've had the same objectives because it's the the result and the the ease of access of completing them is going to be different based off characters strengths and weaknesses. So I I love the fact that there are so many diverse characters uh in this game. And then my favorite part of this is are the objectives. This I mean this alone should have been implemented into the pandemic games. This is easily the best the best part of this game cuz there's one there's so many. You always have to play you always have to have destroy the one ring because you got to destroy the one ring. But you can't do this until you've completed three objectives because when you're setting up, you have this one and you have three more objectives out that need to be done before you can actually destroy the the one ring. And in your starting game, for example, you have Sauron on your staff is broken. Uh challenge Sauron and then attain the blessing of the elves. Those are the three you start with. And each of them are done. you know, they have a different goal that you have to do before you can actually complete them.

So, attending the blessing of the elves actually limits your elf pool. So, you can only have so many out if they're removed. You you can't really pull you might have three missing, but then you have to get two characters to Riendell and get rid of three hearts, whether that's cards or tokens to be able to complete it. Um, then you have Sarum on your staff is broken. You have to make Eisenuard a haven, which means you have to have three swords and no enemies in Eisenard to turn it into a haven. In my very first game of playing this, I remember we got an event card because there are events that you shuffle into the shadow deck that had the I think it was called Antmoot and it had let you place three uh green free peoples into Fangorn forest and then you can move them out. So, we had them go and move into Eisenard, which is what happened in the movies. And it's not like we planned that. It's not like this game is like on rails where that stuff happens. But the fact that it randomly happened in our first game where it's like that's how Eisenard got taken. That's amazing. And then you have to have no enemies in Rohan to be able to complete Sarum on your staff is broken. And then you have to have challenge Sauron where you need three Gondor uh meuples, three Rohan meuples, and three elf meuples and go to north uh if I ethyon.

That could not be more of a big middle finger to anyone who has a lisp. Elthian. Anyway, uh that means that the shadow eye goes to uh wherever it's called, Ethylion, and it moves all the troops to Udun, which is thematically appropriate, too, because you were the lords of the black uh Yeah. What was it? Yeah. Where the lords of the black land come forth and it's like all those troops are there, which is like, oh, hey, great. Now I don't have to roll for searching as Froto is sneaking in. And then you can try to destroy the one ring. Um, and those are just three objectives out of I don't even know how many. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20.

Out of 23. Um, and you just do these randomly. Uh, infiltrate Menace Morgle. Lay bare the pits. Uh, that makes six. And that's one that says use legalis. Um, lift shadow from dwarven lands. Unseat Denithor. Deal with Frea's heirs. Shield maiden no longer. Rangers secure uh Ariador. Um, these objectives are uh such a breath of fresh air because if these didn't exist, um, the game would be fine, but because you have the challenge of like which in what order do we complete them because we have to complete them before eventually you're just going to not have enough troops because you yes, you're not limited. One thing that's nice is unlike War of the Ring when your troops like the free peoples are, you know, killed, it's not like they're removed from the game. Uh you just put them back in the supply and you can you can muster more, but you're on a time limit. You're still limited by the the player deck. Once that runs out, you lose a hope for each card you cannot draw. And that once you hit zero, that's how you lose. Um, so trying to figure out in what order uh to do the objectives is awesome because you are rewarded for doing for doing them.

Like the sarm on your staff is broken. The current player gains a ring token from the supply. Um, and you might think, "Oh, that's it." Well, you turned Eisenard into a haven, which means that uh no enemies are going to be spawning there because there are shadow strongholds out throughout the board. And there are specific ones that if it's removed, you there are no more uh shadow army meeples that get placed there. The attain the blessing of the he uh attain the blessing of the elves gives each player with a character in Riendell a heart token which you need to muster and you gain a hope. And then the challenge Sauron moves a bunch of troops to one area which means that Froo isn't going to have to search. Um, so it's it's pretty pretty amazing with how many you have. This alone gives this game a ton of replayability.

Um, but there is kind of a negative that I have with this and that's you are still at the whim of the cards. you still have to I mean what can be frustrating and I've had this many times when I'm playing is the only use of like ring tokens for example is for rerolls which I mean I'm glad there's some mitigation. Um your characters by themselves unless they have an ability can't fight on their own. So it's not like you can take Aragorn and move him to this spot and then roll the battle dice. you have to have free peoples with you. So if you need free peoples and they're off somewhere else or you need them in a specific spot for an objective, then there are kind of what seems to be a lot of dead turns. A lot of well, I really just moved. I I'm not in a haven to prepare, so I can't get rid of my cards. Um, I don't really I have a bunch of, you know, rings, but I'm not since I can't battle, I can't roll. I wish there was more of kind of a natural way of kind of getting r getting getting tokens so you can be more useful. The attacking with free peoples is kind of weird because I mean the characters do have a benefit to being involved in battle. I mean, Gandalf has an ability that is uh you could spend swords to turn the die into whatever you want. Uh Aragorn can he

kills two people whenever a a shadow mele is killed. But I mean other than that, whenever they're involved in battleload, you can discard a sword card to just remove an extra shadow army. But I mean, other than that, there are a lot of times where if you're not attacking, you're just kind of moving. You're really wasting a lot of time. It's like, I need to be in Riendell and we really need to get three of the of the friendship cards or friendship tokens. I don't have any, so I guess we'll just wait. And you you're like, well, what am I going to do in the meantime until that comes around? I can't go around and just freely kill people. So, it it just feels like there's a lot of kind of biting your time until, you know, luck goes in in your favor or not. Cuz like I said, these objectives are amazing, but so many of them require specific icons and specific cards. So, that's the alternate use for your cards.

But, I mean, until then, you're not really doing much. Well, you I mean you are like you are still playing the game and and diverting because once like a shadow uh army enters a haven and if there are no free people there to defend it, it just becomes a stronghold and you lose three hope. And that's I mean that's huge. Like you only start with six. So if you have no way to gain it and they just rush to those those haven areas and you just lose. But but yeah, like I I just don't like the feeling of wasting turns and it happens more often than not. I feel like it could just be again my experience is is that's how it happened. That might not happen for some people, but yeah, I I just wish that you could attack with characters. Um, but I see why I see why you can't because the attack dice only show um, you know, free peoples and shadow uh, armies. So, if you were just a character that could run in there, then there's I mean, no downside to doing that besides action efficiency.

Um, in terms of actual fighting, I don't I I don't think these dice are that bad. I mean, one, this is a dice tower. This is the best T dice tower I've ever seen. Um, and you just, you know, you just throw them in there and see what you get. Now, one thing that is weird about attacking is that like, let's say, for example, these four people, these four shadow armies move into Laurian and there are two free peoples there. The rules say that you roll three dice or you roll dice equal to however many shadow um armies, you know, meuples are there up to three. Okay. Well, I roll these three dice. Now, one of the results is like a trade-off. You lose a free people and you lose a shadow army.

Well, the weird thing is is like let's say all of them happen to be that. It's like, well, if I rolled three trade results, you know, I kill the shadow army, they kill the free peoples, but there's only two there. It's like, okay, well, I guess I kill three shadow meles and they kill my two. Now, in that case, that wouldn't matter. They'd still have one shadow mele in Laurian, which would become a shadow stronghold, and I would lose three hope and all that. But the fact is is like you, let's say there wasn't four and it was just 3v2 and that was the result. It's like, well, that's a better result for me. I don't know. It just it feels like there's there's no hierarchy of how dice are are rolled. But again, I'm I'm nitpicking on how the combat works. The combat's uh quick. It's efficient. Um there are always going to be more shadow meles on the board than you will have free people. So, and they're constantly spawning more and moving around. So, it it it ends up probably being a wash. Uh, so that and then the way that the shadow army works I actually really enjoy as well. So like I said, it still has that pandemic system. You have a discar pile that when the skies darken um, you know, you increase threat that indicates how many cards you draw from the shadow deck. Uh, but what's nice is each card has like a top and a bottom effect. So whenever you draw a card, you

look over on the top of the deck and whatever if it's a banner, then that means that you spawn a shadow troop and then do the effect. And this is where the game gets cluttered. You are that's where Nazoulool are moving. Sometimes they they will follow, you know, where the eye is at. And if the eye never moves, then they're going to cluster in one spot. Um, sometimes the eye will move, but if it's already on your spot, then you do a search roll, which uh again is ways you can really lose a bunch of hope. Like for example, if all of the Naz Ghoul are there, which one, two, three, four, five, six, there are nine. I don't know why I counted. Uh, you'll only have a roll a max of seven, luckily. Um, but uh the icon for this, you know, that's actually not a bad roll is the despair, which basically means you lose a hope. There's one that is you lose a hope unless you're in a haven.

There's a blank and there's one where the Naz ghoul return to Mordor. Um, so and I like that there are blanks. It's got like slip by. There's two blanks on the dice, so it's not like a always a big FU just because you're always kind of going to be rolling searches. Um, so it'd be really annoying if there wasn't if there was like one blank. Um, but that is that's the banner. And then if it's a flag, then that's when the the uh armies move. And I think this is also a really clean system because there are these colored arrows that point to certain locations and those uh troops will move along those arrows depending on where they're trying to get. So they don't bumrush to the shadow havens, but if you leave them alone then they can really, you know, get there quickly. But you can also break up their their pattern. If you know, for example, that you know that rune is activating a lot, then you can send people over there to kill all the shadow armies that are over there and then not have to worry about it. There are times where you can draw and be like, "Oh, okay. They're trying to move from Rune to the Woodland Realm. There aren't any people up there. Okay, cool.

We got lucky." Um, so I like that you're not quite sure which effect of the card is going to actually happen because it's determined by the next card, the top of the next card. Um, and then you can actually have a response to those instead of being like, well, I mean, nothing we can do about whatever is being drawn, you know? So, that that is a nice a nice touch. And there's also a few cards in there that will always add enemies. Like it's called Oh, what is it called? It's not in here. I think it's like the drums beat. The the drums of war beat or something. Uh it is Oh, the drums of war. Yep. Add one shadow troop to every shadow strong uh stronghold in Mordor.

Um, oh, I just realized I have been literally playing that wrong this entire time. It says in Mordor. I've been doing every single Shadow Stronghold. Uh, cuz that's what made sense to me. I was like, "Yeah, okay. Add them to Mordor and Dollor and uh Umbar." Nope. They're just in in Mordor. Uh, so that's nice. And those will always be cycled through because those those special cards are they start in the discard pile and you're going to be cycling the discard pile over and over. But it's it's a very neat and clean system. I think uh only deterred by the really tiny board that everything gets that gets clustered around. Overall, I think that this is a phenomenal Lord of the Rings cooperative game that really captures the uh the theme of, you know, of the the IP that it's that it's following while also not making it beyond rails. It's not like ah going through the motions of the movie like yes, you have Frodo starting the Shire. he has to get to Mordor to destroy the ring, but everything around that is up to you and the objectives that you're trying to complete.

Um, yeah, it's it's extremely solid. I've uh enjoyed my time with it quite a bit and and yeah, I can't really think of of anything else. Um trying to yeah talked about attacking, talked about muster, talked about the actions, the different characters, the objectives. Um this amazing dice tower that I like uh quite a bit. Yeah, I think that's it. So on a scale of 1 to 10, uh I'm going to give The Fate of the Fellowship an eight. I think it is a very good uh cooperative game and that's only enhanced like it's a nine in my heart.

It's a 10 in my heart because it's Lord of the Rings and I absolutely love it. But as an actual game that has a smidgen of the pandemic system without it being just pandemic rethemed, I I really really like it. I think it could have been a nine if it wasn't if this board was like 25% bigger. If the regions uh I mean because whenever you're looking at it, you can see the regions. It's not like you're looking at cards and you're like I have no idea like the Rising Tide one where it had all those nonsense locations. It's like I don't even know where any of this is. Um, but because it is such a uh an an issue when you're playing that does get in the way. It breaks the immersion almost immediately whenever you're trying to figure out how pieces fit and then you're trying to move characters and move all these little little meeples with your characters into spots that are that are cluttered. That does have an effect. Now again, that could be fixed if someone makes a player, you know, a player mat uh that enlarges the the board, which you could easily do. Like you could literally I know that there are play like custom playmats that people make for board games that include like all the expansion boards in one rolled out mat.

I'm really hoping that someone does that cuz I don't hate the way the board looks. It's I mean in terms of how you're moving around, it's not like it's weird following the way the shadow armies move. It's very clean cuz it's colorcoded. That all works. It's just a hindrance when you're actually trying to play. So much so that it it loses the point for me. But if that is somehow fixed by a fan, then that would honestly bump this game up to a nine. it would probably be my go-to pandemic just because it's Lord of the Rings and there are so many of these objectives I haven't seen. Uh, and the different combination of objectives with characters gives us a [ __ ] ton of replay-ability and I could listen to the Lord of the Rings soundtrack forever. Um, and I that's that's just amazing. So, eight out of 10 for Fate of the Fellowship. Uh, let me know what you think of the game in the comments below.

Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved