Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cascadia: Alpine Lakes - Board Game Review - The Same, But Deeper

Transcript 18:22

That's Cascadia.

And I'm his friend, Jesus.

Hi everyone on the Broken Meeple. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you, and this is the last review video I'll be putting out before I make my way to Essen tomorrow by the time this goes out. So, it's Tuesday now. Wednesday I head out to Essen. I won't be back until after Sunday, and even then it's going to take me a little bit to recover and get on with some other video content. So, you know, bear with me for that little gap. But I thought I'd get this one out nice and quick for you, which is Cascadia Alpine Lakes. It's no secret to anybody who watches this channel that Cascadia is yeah, one of my favorite games because it's been sat there for ages. So, I've had this original for God knows how long. I don't like the expansion to it cuz this is not a game I want to play above four players anyway, but it just works so well on so many levels. It's good for gateway gamers.

It's good for gamers. It's good for just about anybody, frankly. Even my parents can play this. Granted, I tend to win more often than they do, but still they can play it, and they can kind of get it, you know. So, any game that can get past them is usually a winner in my books. But this one is just always good fun to play out. It does that perfect blend of giving you enough depth for the length and complexity that it has. And it's a very simple game, very easy rules with a lot of variety based on the scoring conditions of said cards. So, now we got Alpine Lakes. This is a standalone version which basically inherits much of the same rule set from Cascadia. So, I'm going to go through the rules overview anyway, but suffice to say if you already know to play Cascadia, you kind of already know to play this. But this one has got some differences, particularly with regards to the scoring, [snorts] what tends to score, the spatial awareness factor in terms of the tiles you're playing out, it's multi-level aspect, which is something that Cascadia didn't have, and various other bits besides. So, is this one a decent stand-alone to this? Is it better? Is it worse? Well, that's what I'm here for. Wingus, dingus, listen up.

So, let's do this as if you've never played Cascadia before. Essentially, you start off with a tile of four hexes, and there will be four hexes on view, 1 2 3 4, laid out for players to take along with some animal tokens. These animal tokens are drawn at random from a bag, and they consist of various different types of animals. We've got cougars, we've got eagles, we've got uh pikas, and yeah, it's impossible to not say Pikachu when you're drawing these things out. And the idea is is that you will select one pair of tile and token to place out on your own little personal map. The tile will go alongside the tile that you already have in place, and the animal token will go on a hex where there is a picture of said animal token. Certain to- certain spaces will give you a pine cone for placing them on. These pine cones are basically used for you to change what ones you want to take. Like, if I don't like this particular pair here, I might want to take this tile and this pika, and I can basically do that with the help of a pine token.

As you go through the game, you will effectively be putting all these different tiles together, putting them into this nice little kind of map layout, and you can build it however you like, sort of spanning out. But, what you're most interested in is what you do with the habitats, the different colors of hex terrain that you have. The animals don't score specifically themselves. This is a difference in the original Cascadia. What happens is that you now have various terrain scoring cards. So, you can have a forest one, you've got a glacier one, you've got a lake one, a meadow one, and these ones score for animals, yes, but it's how you arrange the animals in the habitats themselves. Like, for example, this forest here wants you to have unique wildlife types in it. So, it doesn't care like the fact that you have, you know, maybe more cougars and more eagles. It's the fact that it wants all the unique animals. And then you've got for something say like the meadow where it wants you to have a big giant group of the same animal ideally. It doesn't care which animal it is, it just wants the largest group of them. And you'll score accordingly for that. And glaciers and lakes have got similar scoring mechanisms as well. But while you're placing hexes out, you can now elevate your map a little bit higher. So, for the most part, you'll be building level building at level one. And what you can do is if you have got a matching terrain space, then you can essentially place a hex down so that it covers some of your map and raises up. And it can go up to multiple levels, but ideally you're kind of looking at level three and four basically. And obviously you can't overhang tiles, you can't have something weird like that. But what you'll

probably do is that you'll then build another one, say there for example. And then later on down the line, you'll have Oh yeah, I could put this one down. And now I've got a level three section.

Whoa, whoa, slow down, egghead.

Why do you want to build up? Well, you have ways to score for that as well. You always have a wildlife elevation scoring card which basically gives you points based on having the highest of each wildlife type. But then the lake cards that you can use also score for the lake tiles which are essentially ones that look a bit like this. You probably can't see as well on the camera, but essentially it looks like a lake. And you score more points for having lakes on higher levels and surrounded by other tiles. Each turn is basically that. You take a tile and a token. There are rules in place for if you get too many of the same token out, you can reset and you can spend coins to do the same. But predominantly it is take a token with a tile, put it on your board, and keep going until eventually all the tiles run out. Now, in terms of the scoring which is kind of like the bulk of the game in terms of its variety, I mentioned that you have the scoring cards for each terrain and you also have the wildlife elevation scoring. But you can also put in advanced mode which is to have these habitat these other scoring cards, shall we say. And basically, you choose up to one from each of three different categories. So, you can have a you know, one that is based on habitat scoring.

You can have one that is based on spatial scoring. You can have one that is based on wildlife scoring. And essentially, you choose one from each of them, and there's quite a few. I mean, there is a decent amount of variety here, and that's not even all of them. I mean, the rest are in this bag here. And the idea is is that you will pick three of these cards. In fact, I put all the wildlife ones in that bag. That was bright. Here we go. One of each. And now you have three different ways to score on top of everything you already had. So, in this case, what do I want? I want scores for any every two total habitat corridors or areas, as they're called. I also need scoring for each hexagon at level three that has at least one edge with no tiles adjacent to it. Open cliffs, it's called. And then I've got scores for the wildlife type that I have the most animals of. So, you've got those on top of everything else if you want to interject even more scoring in.

And basically, you get to the end, total up all the points, and the one with the most

Of course.

So, even if you've never played Cascadia before, this is a very simple game to get into. And if you've played Cascadia before, well, then 90% of the rules are the same. So, you basically just need to learn how the scoring works. Although, it is a little bit different in feel because when I found that when I was playing this, I felt like I had to kind of unlearn how I played Cascadia because you're so used to taking animal tokens based on, all right, I need to get the eagle so that they're in line of sight with each other. Okay, I need to get the What are they called? The bears so that they're in little family packs together, but not too many family packs. And then this time you're looking at an animal token and going, "What do the birds score for again?" Oh, wait, they don't. They score based on the forest. What does the forest want specifically? And so, it's a little bit of a weird switch, but you get used to it relatively quickly. The rules are still straightforward, though. I mean, they're well explained in the book, and the only new stuff you need to bear in mind for Cascadia veterans is mainly how the elevated tiles work. But it tells you specifically what tiles can go on top of what, and you've got a fair amount of flexibility. The main thing you've got to link up is the animal type on the hex itself, but you have the opportunity, for example, let's say there's a uh good example here, a an eagle on this one. If I put a tile down and it can house an it has to have to be able to house an eagle above it, but it can basically move up to the top level. So, you don't lose the animal entirely. It's relatively flexible. You just can't do silly things with it. But, this added level of depth, or I guess elevation, is a welcome addition to the game because it does add some extra thinkingness to it. It's not just simply, "Oh, I'll just

build out and build this massive like giant habitat of green," which is what you had to do before. You constantly had to think, "Right, have I got more desert than him? Have I got more uh, you know, marsh than them?" It doesn't work like that here. You're not scoring by having the biggest habitat. I mean, you may have a scoring card that goes for it, but for the most part, these aren't concerned with things like that. And you don't get bonus points for having like the largest glacier habitat or the largest uh meadow habitat. So, that bit's not in the game anymore. You can have tiny little pockets of various terrain all over the place and it'll still be fine. In fact, some of the uh terrain cards and that actually want you to do that, you know, with glacier in particular. Um one or two of those are very much like having lots of separate little glaciers rather than one big giant one. So, it is like just a little bit of a change-up from before. But, having the extra elevation gives you more tactical choices as to where to place your hex and more ways to focus on the game. Like, you know, you may may ignore elevation for the most part and just build a sprawling map, but you can also focus heavily on the elevation, get some lakes up to the highest point you can and surround them. It's good points, but the more you start building on elevations, the harder it is to place hexes generally because you still have to build up in a logical sense, you know, you can't have a uh you know, a tile that is four levels high and everything around it is only one level high. No, you've got to have at least like just one level difference between the next bit. So, you're creating like a sloping hill rather than a sheer cliff. And the more you start elevating up, the less choice you've got

as to where to put future hexes in terms of elevation. So, there's definitely a good thinkiness to it. But, when it comes to Cascadia, a lot of it is down to A, how simple it is, and B, how replayable it is. All the scoring. Well, if you thought there was a lot of scoring in the previous one, having five animal types and having A B C D E of those, this one takes it to an uh the nth degree and then some. I mean, wow. This has the Kickstarter kind of like add-on to it, all right? But, you still got an A B C D in all the different terrains. You've got A B C D forest, A B C D glacier, same for meadow, and a lake one. The lake is kind of the same each time. And you always have this elevated scoring card in the game. So, you've always got at least, you know, four different, you know, one No, sorry. One, two, three, four, five different ways to score in the game. And if you have the Kickstarter extras in it, then you're getting an E and an F in those ones as well as another lake, so you've got even more. And it's like ridiculous enough just with that alone. But, then when you play advanced mode and throw in these, it just gets insane. I mean, there is a good I forget what how many there is.

Five, three, five, 10. Yeah, you're talking 11, 12 of each. Yeah, about 12 of each of the types of scoring objectives here. And you pick one from each. That's it. And they are pretty varied. I mean, I'll just go from the the wildlife scoring ones, for example, okay? So, each animal surrounded on all sides by tiles scores for each one you have three or fewer animals of. Score for each one wildlife type you have exactly four animals of. Score you got exactly five of. Scores for each wildlife type present at three plus different levels. Scores for each line of five animals with all five unique wildlife types. Three wildlife sets, you know, one, two, three high animals of the same type. Score for the most animals you have, most of the fewest animals you have. Score for a type you have seven or more of. And you know, score for most animals of each amongst all players. So, there's even like some of them are interactive in that respect.

That's just for the wildlife ones. And then you've got 12 of those and 12 of those, it's insane. Now, it is going to up the complexity to a gamer level here. I mean, it's not crazy complicated, but if you imagine that previously you only had to keep track of five different scoring objectives and for the most part they weren't that chaotic until you started getting into season for the most part, the days really. But here, you've got the four different types of terrain, you've got the elevated scoring one, and then you've got those three on top. When you're looking at all of these on the board and trying to think, okay, what the hell am I aiming for here? It requires a little bit of extra thinkingness. And those who struggle with options and you know, thinking that well, how do I do well at this game, might struggle a little bit with this one in advanced mode just because of the sheer amount of ways that you can score. Like you might even forget one or two of them are even there on the table cuz you focused really hard on certain others.

But that's fine. If you did really well at those, then it's not that big that big of a problem. But suffice to say that if somebody was brand new to games and certainly brand new to Cascadia, I'd probably be hesitant about throwing them into this one first. And if I did throw them into this one first, I certainly would not play the advanced mode with them. But a gamer, yeah, you could throw in advanced mode in this and have a great time. And in terms of the answer that I'm sure everybody's asking, which is do you need both? Need? No. But it depends on your audience. What's your target audience for this game? I mean, you can play both solo. They both have that, you know, great scenario section where you play through the different scenarios with different little difficulty tweaks. And you can play this solo to your heart's content. So, that's exactly the same as before and it's still fantastic. This is still a really good quick game to pull out solo. But, in terms of who they're for, the original Castledonia, new gamers, families, parents who are, you know, in their in their 70s plus, you know, like mine, you know, that's a perfect one for them, okay? This one is def is not like crazy complex or medium weight, shall we say? It's still a lightweight game, but there is more to think about. There is a decent degree of more depth here. And so, this is the one that you get if you're predominantly playing Castledonia with gamers and you want a little bit of extra meat. You know, you can pick your poison as to which one you want. I'm happy with both because I feel that there is a decent different market of them, you know, for them, sorry. You know, I definitely need this one for the

easier times, and then I need this one for when I want something a little bit extra. You know, I might play this one solo more often than multiplayer, but if I can play it multiplayer, then fantastic. Whereas, this one I would play multiplayer more often because I'm probably introducing more new people to it. So, each one does have a purpose. You've still got the same, you know, great you know, what is it? Component quality? You've still got the bags, you've still got the cards, you've still got best of all, I love the artwork all over it. The you know, the only sort of negative I have with this is really much of a nitpick is the tiles themselves. I mean, the tiles are thick and chunky, I don't mean them, but the the art for the terrain. I mean, the glacier looks like mountains, that's normal. The forest looks like forest from before, but now you have the meadows which kind of does look a little bit like baby puke.

I'm not entirely sure. It's It's like this green with flakes in it. It's like, "Eh." You know, it's a little bit on the ugly side for a meadow. And because the lakes are their own thing, you don't get quite as much of a varied look to your map as originally. Cuz originally, you had something like five different terrain types all over the place. Here, you've only technically got three because you've got the forest, you've got the glaciers and the meadows, and that's kind of it. Because the lakes can appear on all three of those terrain types. The lakes are not technically their own thing. They just look nice in the middle of the terrain. So, perhaps there's not as much color variation as there was in the original one. So, that is a little bit of a negative, but it's a minor thing to deal with when you're, you know, playing the game and trying to concentrate on all the different scoring aspects.

So, he's not perfect.

Honestly, what else do you need? This is just a really solid stand-alone version of Cascadia. It doesn't replace the original, in my opinion. You know, they they both have different markets that they're good for, and they're both fantastic games. I still think that Cascadia is one of the most essential games that you should have in your collection, because it just caters to so many people and does everything that needs to and ticks every box, regardless of whether you're a solo player, multiplayer, you know, new player, gamer, whatever. It just does the lot. And this one continues to do so, just albeit more skewed towards the gamer side than the family and non-gamer side. But, as I say, both have got distinct markets. If you want to pick your poison, well, then you know what the deal is with the two, then pick your poison. You're going to get a fantastic game, no matter what. You know, this is still, you know, really solid, as great as Cascadia was, and it's getting a 9 out of 10 for me. I mean, it is, you know, as close as I can get. You know, like, it's not a game I typically want to play over and over and over again, but sometimes I do end up doing that.

And certainly this one is going to burn your brain a little bit more than the other one will. So, it's like shy of a 10, but good blind me, it's damn well close. You know, this is still a 9 out of 10, fantastic distinction level game. I'm keeping both of these. I will pick my times when I want to play them solo, when I want to play them with others. But, yeah, I'm glad that this one is not just a direct replacement of it. It's It, you know, you couldn't really have done this as an expansion. You had to do it as a stand-alone game, and it's still just a really solid title. What more can I say?

It sounds dreamable.

So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meeple. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and BoardGameGeek. It will go live on both of those pages. Most of the games I get, including this one, are not review copies. I usually have to pay them out of the channel's pocket. So, the Patreon is always open, and it's because of the Patreon that I'm able to get all these games, do the review content, and keep this channel going. So, thank you very much for your support. And if you are able to join, then you are very most welcome. Check out the rest of my content. Recently, I've been doing a lot of games, including some like 60 Below that will also be shown at Essen, as well as Ashes and Amber, another one for you to check out. And if you're going to Essen, then by all means, say hi. Say hi, shake my hand, ask for a selfie. You got any food and drink on you that's like weird and wonderful, then by all means, I'm willing to try it. But, I look forward to seeing you there, and I hope that if you are going, you have a great time. And if you're not, well, then look forward to some more content when I get back. Take care, and remember, it's only a game, and I'll see you on the next Broken Meeple video. Bye for now.

Progress saved