Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pagan: Fate of Roanoke - Discussion

Transcript 33:16

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock and Brad and I are doing a discussion over Pagan the fate of Rano which was uh surprisingly uh one of gen con's hotness this year of Our Lord 2024 and um and it was weird because I was going by their Booth because it was um Capstone Capstone yeah Capstone games who had taken taken in uh brought it over from I think Europe to the states um and I was kind of looking at it because I remember seeing it and the art style reminds me of darkest dungeon if you ever played that that video game and I was like oh you know this that Witch theme is very popular nowadays it seems like so I was like okay I'm kind of intrigued went by they kind of did a quick demo it's like it's a two-player you know hidden roll game like deduction game and I'm like well I love mantis Falls so that sounds intriguing so I picked up a copy and you and I had played it uh pretty shortly after that and then again to do it for the review this game is fantastic it's so it's so good um and I don't it's one of those where I do not know which side I like more like cuz we have both both now played uh both sides to just kind of see yeah cuz typically typically I like in hidden rooll games you know Star Wars rebellion

or whatever I like being the person that has the information the one that knows like what they're trying to do um but being the hunter is also just as satisfying like this game is Just sings on all levels for me um so we'll get into the details more but Brad what are your thoughts I really like it too it's one of those that um it definitely makes you cuz we've played both sides now mhm um it's not difficult no the rule book format makes it right it's like at times they're they're clear in things but then other times they're not clear you know like for example with like doing a familiar action is like wait does that replace the action or does it like enhance it you know it says it says augments the action and it's like well that could mean two things you know right the thing is that is awesome with this though is I think the replay replayability is really high even though it is a two-player with the same factions mainly because there's tons of deck building you can do with it construction not deck building but if you're getting the Capstone version you only have the base game but I know they have announced that they are planning to bring over the expansions but if you can get a copy of the worm gold um I think the only difference is mine's actually worm gold theought from Miniature Market okay I had the Capstone because that's what they were selling at Gen Con and then someone was selling their full

Kickstarter of everything I'm like well I kind of want everything as far as I can tell the only difference is card quality I think the cards are all the same so you're not like if you have a cstone version you can if you can find the expansions for the other production company I think it's the same so well what I was getting at though is like like this one you you would once you learn how to like it took me a little bit to figure out how to handle what you were doing yeah like you wouldn't have been getting those piles of six um with Secrets once I I know but I was like worried about my stuff I was just letting those build up yeah but I didn't realize for for one reason or another I didn't realize you could convert all to two like just swoop cuz you canver three secrets to a favor Max of two times right so then I was like well [ __ ] now so I kind of got behind the eightball there a little bit but now knowing that and we go through and play it then it's going to be TI you know and kind of keep guessing well because every every side has aspects to Big swings like with the the witch she can just have all these Bru just waiting to be used the way I was able to get those six Secrets stacked up was not because I was doing one one one and you were just like it was like more so of like oh well this round I'm going to consume this Brew potion that lets me double the

number of Secrets I pass out go to that place to dump four on one location and that's I already had two there and now it's still my turn so I get to go there again convert all of them and now I have two favors and that all happens before I use its power to get it twice so it's like there's a lot of big swings and normally in games like this it feels like there's a lot of like jockeying for position and being like one side's really reactive to everything but both sides can be very proactive on a lot of stuff the witch with her enchantments and you with I mean allies that are so cheap on upkeep that but they're so strong like and then locations that only you can go to that it's like oh man like I had a couple but I just never could really find a good time to get it out out I found yeah I found locations to be like man these are so good but that means I'm not going out on the board to villagers and blocking you know mhm um but at the same time it's like cuz I had a card like a charm card that was remove a location but it's like well he's not putting any out so I don't really have anything to use but luckily I have my familiar so I can these cards that don't do anything for me are still useful in some way um I will say yeah learning the game is easy but because it's a two-player deduction hidden hidden roll game uh it's it's very difficult to figure

out the Nuance like cuz where I had difficulty as the witch is like how do I cuz the only way the witch wins is performing the ritual you win in two ways the hunter wins in two ways of exonerating all those characters which it's like okay if you just keep going cuz your Clues don't go away unless I remove them at one point in the game before you started cuz what changed it was when you converted six of those to two yeah deals because I was just like okay I have my my uh people going to the places with three Clues I was just like I'm just going to every time I'm just going to spam it just drop three out there keep loading that up just keep search I was just going to start spamming that deck but then when you when you threw those six down and turn two that changed everything crap yeah so there was one moment where it's like I was like man I don't think he knows who I am you exonerated once this game and then you like looked over at the red and I'm like [ __ ] he's he got the mayor like he so because I had a lot of people stacked up on him um as well as her I looked over there on purpose I I assume I was like I was like did he do that to throw me off or did he actually did he actually draw who draw into that person um so I was like okay and I I I did a consume six on a few people on like two blues and then you were getting rid of those and you got rid of the mayor and I'm like oh okay so he doesn't have the mayor he's not really focusing on green and neither am I so we both know it's

not green so I was like maybe he thinks it's a blue and then I did one power play that I miscalculated because I forgot that I was going to pull my people off and then I put all three and I was like Yeah well yeah was whenever you're like well I pretty much know who you are and I was like oh [ __ ] cuz I think I was like I had two two um well secr you had you had two secrets you had two secrets and two favors or three favors you just couldn't go there because you had already been there um or it was something cuz you had you had three and oh no yeah yeah it was I had two favors and three Secrets but then you went and removed a favor right and I was like [ __ ] cuz it was like it was like that was like three or four turns ago but I was like I was so sure I was going to get to win that next turn um which it ended up being that case because then I had to remove I mean you kept taking that spot so you were able to put on there faster than I could get them taken off yes exactly so it's like okay I think there was a point because because what's very interesting is you don't take turns back and forth which I very much appreciate in this game otherwise you would just be undoing yeah would take forever it would get that it would take forever and you would just be basically just doing a tug of- War so it's cool cool that it's like oh where my people are blocks you and that can be huge cuz I was like man he's going to pull some [ __ ] out of his ass cuz like to be able to to to kill like I had a I had a brew that put secrets on all

of them so it's like okay that kind of covers my bases as the witch it was hard for me to kind of throw you off cuz I saw found that too when I was controlling the witch yeah um so I don't know I know what the play is for that that's not maybe that's just a strength of some players I think a lot of of course the abilities and stuff is eventually like not necessarily having to lie the entire game but being like Oh I'm going to play this m like the misdirect where I pulled all your Clues off and just threw them onto someone else it's like okay I just kind of stalled you to give myself an advantage more so of me being like did I do that on the Widow because that's me so I don't know I it seems like there's a lot like the the enchantments some of them are like hey uh you know I get to control your your first action every round cost me four influence to get uh to place that out but um like you have to now spend an action to get rid of that which is super cheap do you find I don't know I because I I I don't think so but do you find anything of any of these factions more powerful than what the other one has the the I mean the potions can be super big time yes they can I mean but they also yeah they can yeah the potions there's no counter I can do to those

there are there you there are yes there are cards in there that do remove remove brus which the game is set around now you can do a starter deck of 30 and it tells you at the back of the book which one but your deck is typically consist the 50 cards um and yes because I remember drawing you you whenever we play this when you were the witch um I drew a card that was remove a brew uh potion but you never had any or you didn't have any that I thought was like that's not that big of a deal for me right now um cuz I would agree yeah the consumed potions are like damn that is huge but at the same time to even make that work unless I have a card that says otherwise I have to instead of place secrets on villagers place them into my cauldron so it takes time to set up now there are cards in here that are like allore add four secrets to a cauldron that combined with most of the C combo that you just like put that down drop the Allure and thenew yeah the one that was like yeah play play two cards but they increased cost it's like okay Surplus that I think that cost me six it was like add one secret to all villagers and then aore was put four secrets on a on a brew and that one costs four to pop off and consume is the only like free action in the game so it's like haha combo this feels rewarding now what is secrets on all the villagers do for me not much that just

keeps me guessing it's not like you're not focusing on anyone you do that spreads it out keeps you guessing and also like well because if I can get two favors on a villager I double I guess to do their ability twice so all the abilities are good so it's like okay well at the very least if I can get two favors on a couple people I get to like the one where I had two favors on her and it's like oh I'm going to draw four cards and then I'm going to go over there and I'm going to you know gain play two cards and now I have a whole hand of cards CU card draw is rough um you have any negatives at this point I don't have a ton like I said it's one of those the more you play a faction aside you're going to get better at the game yes um I do think this is one of those games though that is unfortunately like probably only going to play this with you because if i' if I've played the aside more then it's like well it's unfair to the other person well and that's my worry cuz I bought everything that I could retail uh for this yeah mainly because because it's competitive and I'm and I'm hoping that my wife likes it cuz my wife doesn't like it there's no point in even having is you know what I'm saying like like so and she's never played a hidden a hidden role game like that so it's in the air right now with that I I would

think I think for a beginner I almost think being the hunter is what like you should have your the first person be because it's more straightforward in my mind there's because I mean you're playing these down you're playing these down all you're doing is just puking tokens and you're trying to over there you have like all the you know your cauldrons you're trying to maneuver you're having to try to throw people off your scent there's a race element on the witch's side because over time I do not have at least with the the the Decks that we've played with I don't have any way to really remove a lot of clue tokens from you most of the time they're getting removed because you're doing actions to remove things from me so it's like over time anywhere you go you're going to start getting boots which then just as an action you remove three to draw a card not only is that a way for you to win if you remove all of those but two it's process of elimination so yeah I I would agree that's like naturally the game is if the game goes on too long the hunter will eventually figure out who the witch is especially for somebody that's never played a hidden movement has to try to hide their emotions of when yeah like whenever you're doing anything I have to sit here and just be like right exactly you don't have to hide anything as this you're just put stuff out going for it it makes it easier though whenever you're doing things to them who to is not the Witch and it's like okay what an idiot I managed to

kill somebody in this Dam eliminated a false person but you know it was funny cuz every time you went uh you went to who I was I was like damn it like he's blocking me like quit going there yeah I mean that's the other thing one thing that I think our very first game that we messed up on was we thought you had to have a clue on each person in that family but it's actually you have to have a clue on every every living villager MH um as well as three on that person you're killing which one cuz my worry was the same thing with and I even asked the people demoing I'm like wait couldn't the hunter just randomly guess to kill someone and win they're like yeah and I'm like how is that balanc and they're like it takes a lot of work for them to do that and the witch would basically have to sit here and let them right be like yeah no I'm just not going to draw cards I'm not going to sit here I'm not going to stop you in any way cuz I feel like do you think that there's any way that the witch can bum rush who they are well I mean a lot of it just depends if you can lock down the locations yeah I mean because that's I mean that's virtually what you did I don't there was I don't have enough actions to stop that so like no no no so yeah like at the end of the game yeah I bum rush because I needed to because it was like well I think you I think he knows who I am I'd be very happy with myself and I'm not this good of a player if I if that wasn't me and that's why I went

and f that because there were I figured oh well if you had some stupid potion that threw a bunch on there and you just went right there and it was done that's why I killed that one I was just like you know what it would be your mind [ __ ] to to do that and then the win be clear out in left field yeah God I you have no idea how mad I would be if you just I guess I'll kill I guess I'll kill this person and it is me why didn't you kill the Widow earlier it cracked me up because I think I don't know if you saw me but cuz you Shuffle the the nine cards and I draw one at 2 a.m. I looked at it and I kind of cracked up because I'm like of course who I get is the person who looks the most like a witch I'm like yep that's definitely as far as you mean just like just coming right out of the gate and just start start of the game I just I only focus fire on the on who I am I mean if you're that focused on it I would kill it but that's the thing is you'd have to again get three Clues on it and then put a clue on every single person I mean I would think it would be a a rush but you that means you're putting you'd have to get what nine and then get the um yeah I mean it be at least three because again it could be like like at the very least it with these villagers because there's also a ton of villagers that have different abilities and things um like it could be since the witch starts it could be boom boom in this case boom boom boom go there to convert it to a memory and then I've locked those three places pull back do the same thing right but if when you pull back oh yeah cuz you pull back to the start it's that pull back yeah so I

would have to inter you the person would have to interrupt and then try to get that take over those slots again but it's like man do you do that because the only way you can ready someone is if you have a clue on them right oh which which is easy for you because then you just go to someone like okay I'm going to go to her put the blue put the things over there and then bump off yeah it's just a matter of trying to get the hold I'd be very curious if someone that was able to kind of just like didn't even focus on anyone else like only tried to put one on who they were like basically playing like this yeah and be like hey I'm the Widow yeah let's see if you can stop me if even if you could I think that like it'd be one very difficult and I feel like everything would have to go right for you and I don't know I don't think that would be very fun a fun way to play um because the game is also not necessarily that long no like maybe what do you think an hour when we're whipping through it I mean we we've been playing it for like an hour and a half or so but but I mean yeah like it's I mean then not only that if this game alone was just cards to build Decks that would be that' be one thing but one there's an expansion I haven't played the expansion but it adds Gloom cards so yeah there's like the Gloom skull the skulls yellow ribbon and a cleanse effect so it adds

new unique cards and there's scenarios like scenarios to determine the family which are the type of like villagers that are out and like different rule sets and this game is cheap yeah it's not bad at all that's why I went and nabbed it when we played it and then I got I looked up on bench Market when we were done playing I was like oh and I just bought it all it was 75 bucks to get the the game The Wooden token upgrades and the big playmat yes it was 75 bucks total Oh I thought I got I'm a witch so that was just crazy you know to have yeah and I think like whenever I got I bought that person's Kickstarter it was like I think he like did a 100 or something it was like cuz I mean really it's just cards the playmat is sexy um yeah I can't remember I like this playmat better yeah I think so too I think it's more it's more laid out so you you know what the actions are the other one has a lot of the same stuff it's just it's kind of Blended it does yeah it's almost like a map of everything blended it does yeah like whenever we first learned we had that other map and then we had the actual player boards next to us cuz it's like what the [ __ ] are these actions um yeah like so which side do you like playing better after playing both gosh I don't know I mean I I probably would say hunter the hunter okay I mean it just I mean there it's it's well balanced and it's good either way but I yeah I think I

like and which is opposite what I would normally say cuz normally I'm like you I want to be the one that knows mhm like in Rebellion I want to be the one that knows where my base is you know and stuff so I can go but in this game I kind of like this better yeah um well because they kind of have yeah they have that Star Wars rebellion thing where it's like okay I know exactly who I am from the begin that's the only thing I'm going to have to have hidden but it flips it to where the hunter will eventually start exonerating people but then I don't know who so it's like I could be trying to mislead you mhm with this person this whole game and you're like that's not even that's not you and it's like I but I don't know that right so there's hdden information on both sides right and I love the fact that it's like okay yeah it it it's interesting because it feels like oh well they're just the same they're playing the same game but it's re themed but you're really not like my Brew yes my my Brews are the equivalent of your locations it's like okay you have location but that means you have now new worker places to go to and I have new secrets to place on right your locations are something you send workers to to do new actions I can save up my cauldrons to pop them whenever I want to consume them you have um you have allies that give you a variety of abilities that are very conditional but they're passive unless you don't you have to pay their upkeep I have a unique worker that works just like anything but I can modify it with

these by just having an ability or empowering it so this would have been like that little lightning bolt on these is so if you place a worker there you just get that ability it becomes a new location for you that's um yeah you have these uh investigation cards I think is what they're called uh yeah invest that gets placed like you're investigating a particular villager so if you're like hm they seem well cuz the cool thing is also I'm just not trying to hide you from empty villagers it's like all of them have powers that are really good that it's like hm okay you seem to like to draw cards with this character so I'm going to make sure every time you go there I get three influence there's another way you beat that oh that's disgusting E I can place it quarantine skip the distribute secret step yeah I mean there's there's there's ways that's [ __ ] nasty um but yeah you have your investigate that yeah locks down particular things and didn't you have oh your scholar let you have more than one yeah I could I could have spammed them out if I wanted to on certain deals yeah yeah and I mainly just put her out because she would had no up upkeep and if in case I drew into stuff but then I have enchantments that are like bored State that's like benefit for me or bad for you like the ones we played this game was that you finally left alone which was probably my godsend yeah was now I have a consistent to to uh influence it wasn't because it cost it

was because I didn't have enough at that point I was trying to catch up yeah and and spending a worker out here to get rid of it was going to put me even further I I needed to keep putting stuff out there and funny enough that one cost two and it C but it was the most expensive for you to get rid of but then other ones that I had which I mean that's passive those other those other ones affected me big time so I probably need to make it cheaper so it's not it'd be yeah if like hypnotism which costs three for me is the witch decides the action for the Hunter's first worker it must be visiting a villager that only costs one for you to get rid of and it's like okay well that's like I wish this would have cost you more to put out um yeah was only two and then you're going to gain two I gain two yeah the other one's cost but I mean again it's not like it costs six or anything for you to get rid of so it takes you one worker to go there to get two influenced to then go to lift and jam to get rid of it but like hypnotism being able to control what you do one that I played way early on was um tardiness all your allies text boxes were blank so you were paying the upkeep for nothing um and the cool thing is even about those and that cost me four and it costs one for you to get rid of but even then at least I get to use it once yeah yep and it burns it I get to use it it still Burns you a worker to go get rid of it it's like okay yeah like those abilities aren't happening right now you still pay the upkeep for nothing and and lost an

action okay like I'm never upset when you go to get rid of it because I know for a fact if you didn't you just like letting letting witch win oh I did get you you [ __ ]

die sorry you all had to see that hopefully P yeah hopefully Peta doesn't come after me um yeah it's it's phenomenal like I I really really like this game and super thematic somehow yep kind of it like all the cards and stuff are thematic it's not like I feel like I'm a witch or a hunter while playing the game right um trying to think I can't really I can't really think of anything else I think I honestly yeah I think I like being the the witch Moore it felt it felt good to be able to to build up like the potions and get really powerful swings mhm of turns um but now once that I ever feel like I was like in control I'm like no idea who I am this is going to be a cinch I'm just like every time I'm like I think I got it I don't think he knows who I am and then you started going towards like the who I was and I was like okay maybe not like may maybe I maybe I need to try try and end this before before he really figures it out and just kills me so I don't know I don't know it's great I and if also kind of like what you're saying play the hunter to like learn the game mhm um there's another way where it's like you can play a starter deck for just the scenario one and it it caps you at the 30 card deck and it tells you how to build them so you can it's like you can play a full game but it's more

simple and fastpaced then um a 50 card deck and additional rules so there's another way you can you can learn yeah this one's amazing so you have anything else y I don't think so on a scale of 1 to 10 what would you give Pagan fate of Raman milk I think I for the record there's also these are the two decks for the Hunter and then the two decks to deck build uh to deck build and I I don't know how many are in here I think I think these are from all the expansions so it's like these might be 50 cards each and these are 50 cards here so 150 cards give or take for each side and then on top of how many scenarios uh 1 two three four five 6 seven eight there are 13 13 scenarios with the different the different houses the different households so how many more villagers are there um actually I can count from from this so there are you play with nine so there's always three so 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 30 30 30 more uh yeah 30 more it's not bad so uh yeah and I was like wait a minute why don't these have abilities it's because it's the the suspect cards oh yeah

um yeah but like for the welcome to Rowan Oak it's like villager says the caretakers which are which are like these they say caretakers but like for the for your first game it tells you um oh the witch you may perform the ritual when you have two uh two favor on the true witch and Hunter the exonerated villager action only requires you to spend one boot you don't need Clues on other villagers to perform an eliminate a villager action gotta so and it's like oh we recommend you use star their decks and then you just get more complex with with with just different rules for the witch and the hunter for each each scenario so anyway so I think I'm in at a really good solid eight a solid six no eight I think an eight eight yeah with the potential of being high I mean a lot of it's just going to be you know if you actually can ever get it played right yeah so I mean but no it's it's a superb two-player game for sure y um man do I do it do I do it [ __ ] it I'm G give it a 10 I really I really like it if I if I liked one side more than the other probably would be a nine but I really don't have negatives on this like maybe like because it is kind of a more

in-depth game of a head-to-head it's like maybe I'll only ever get to play this with like you or one other person but at the same time it's like well you know what like maybe the first game of with a new person is just bad or the first couple games where it's like okay maybe the witch isn't your play style try the Hunter and then you just kind of get into the new ones cuz what's great about this is it's not so much letting the game play you there's also different play Styles how Tendencies of a player how well they're good at bluffing um on both sides mhm um that that it's like I remember whenever we were we were playing this again cuz it had been a little bit like I think it was like round two I was like yep yep I'm back into it yeah so I got I got no complaints especially with just how much content there is I guess my only actual major complaint is with all the expansions this is the shittiest [ __ ] box actually it's like it's like come on if you're going to do a Kickstarter why don't do you have a way to store your game come on well maybe if they uh do anything else maybe do something a little bigger yeah I don't know I don't I don't know the I don't know who worm gold is since it was kind of more I think it's a European company gotcha and I have no idea who these designers are so but love the art style as well that goes a along way to so it is fantastic because I gave mantis Falls a 10 play that one did you have it I don't have it you know have M this Falls no I

was going to buy at one point but I don't oh well you're a [ __ ] idiot uh that's I was going to say cuz Amy has never played a hidden roll if she likes this then you should grab mantis Falls mantis Falls is fantastic uh as well as this so anyway that's it everyone that's our thoughts on Pagan fate of roke let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever Tom day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that P patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved