Ahoy: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we are doing a no run through review for ahoy uh the main reason we're doing a no and through review is because i forgot to turn on uh the [ __ ] overhead camera uh which is just incredibly frustrating but it's probably for the best um
i hate this game this game made me so so mad like from turn one i was just annoyed at everything that everyone was doing and i think leader games this is riding high on root and they've just flopped in every other aspect wait for it's not for it oh yeah that's right ford uh which i think is the same designer is is as this one certainly is an artwork uh yeah i i think it is uh the same designer but uh i was intrigued because whenever i met him and he's he's a very nice guy uh he was telling me about ahoy and he was like okay if you like root then check this one out uh but it's a little bit lighter and obviously less less complex uh which it is yes it's definitely if you're trying to see if you like asymmetry uh i would actually i i'd pick this one over vast like yeah i don't like vast but there's just so many fundamental problems that at the end of the day it's like because then i i don't mind conflict games um and most of the time if there's conflict and someone you know attacks me or slights me i'm like yeah that makes sense right uh sure um or it's like if it doesn't make sense the person will be like here's why i'm doing this because you know yada yada and this one is just like cutthroat for the sake of being cutthroat which i guess it fits the pirate theme right but it's like
this is just [ __ ] obnoxious like it feels like every time someone does something the next person well actually sorry you're really not in this conversation right every time you did something it felt like i was just doing my actions to then undermine that right and then by doing that then you just did something to undermine that and it's like so we're just doing this weird backup you know back and forth tug of war which makes zak in this weird position of trying to play devil's advocate because if he picks favorites and it definitely swings one direction and it's like well then the smuggler has no chance of winning right right because he can't car he can't deliver enough like i just did a nine point swing at the end of the game that we just played and in my head i was thinking oh there's no way that that can happen and the thing is like if you just look at the board so as the dice basically tick up as i deliver i delivered across the board like there isn't for the most part two spots that had more but there's a lot of twos out there yeah and that's that's a lot of points especially i mean brett got i mean two four uh five six seven seven seven points and i got nine right so i definitely i don't think that this game is unbalanced nope uh i think all the factions do even though but my problem with it's like okay they're balanced fine but are they fun so i guess my question is i i despise this faction i do not like them i think
i think they're weirdly powerful right but they don't feel powerful uh i never felt like i was like man i'm doing a lot i felt they were and maybe that's just the kind of the the balance aspect where it's like man that's like way better than mine and you could have been like man those [ __ ] sharks are way better than mine so i wonder because i felt the same way honestly i actually thought it was like wow man you guys are powerful because you're getting four points by controlling that and unless i go and attack which then seems like an act of aggression when i'm trying to be to a certain extent neutral in it yeah uh you're just trying to make a delivery and you are forced to attack somebody right so i was like but i feel almost the same way not again only in the sense like i always feel weaker than my opponent is is the same as like war of the rings oh right right you always feel like you're doing terribly until the person wins right and i wonder if this is the same kind of principle like man they are so powerful you just don't always realize how powerful you are from that person's point of view yeah right because yeah so i will say i probably felt pretty much the same way okay um i felt like i had you know spikes of success and then you would slowly grind it down right and then i'd have another big spike right so it was interesting that that yo-yo effect yeah it's definitely an interesting dynamic of that and then we kind of but most of what i did was defensive you know i took a card not intending to use it just to make sure you couldn't have sure oh no it totally made sense for you to take that and then once you started using yours i went okay well we'll fight over that
i was actually holding off to see what you would do no wait for you to make the first move that made absolutely i was like there was no point to come up with a ceasefire in a game like this right um because then at that point we do nothing to hinder each other and then zach wins and it is a competitive game so it's like if there was a lot more in this game like if this was if there was something like that in ti or something then it's like yeah sure we can do a bunch of other stuff right but this is like at this point these cards were so crucial to okay well you hinder my patrols i hinder your mollusks but actually besides the one card that you and you had the whole time uh waited too long god that would have just i don't know if i probably would have thrown up just if you played that and uh like just okay and for the record i if i had added it up then i would have if i had taken the time to be like oh he's gonna end the game now yeah i would have and i honestly don't know if i would have won doing that but i probably would have because you would have got to place them on any other islands just right any number of them so anyway he would have gone at least one two um taking i mean he could he he couldn't you could pile them all up on here you didn't even need to you just needed to put two on there two on there and then take everything else over and yeah that would have been because you only needed five points to 30. right uh so yeah you could have easily and then you actually probably wouldn't have been at 29 because you put more cards on to me yeah you
but you worked out i mean i actually scored i think equal because i started putting cards onto brett's oh yeah because he started taking more islands on the surrounding so like i scored two points like just from reds because the minute i started delivering reds like okay i don't think you're going to get back down there so i have to do that yeah yeah and the only way i could have stopped any of this was by using the convincing comrades but right i didn't by brett keeping them all at once it felt like a wasted die right it's like well i don't want to just move one over it definitely behooves me to move two right um so it's very interesting so i don't i mean it seems like it's who can use their overpower better right because every everybody's overpowered in some way yeah and i think you're overpowered i think by your cards actually more yeah more than you're like those are real and the ability to the ability to most of the time spread anywhere i'm not limited by geography yeah the smuggler is very powerful because he just gets he just [ __ ] takes cards cards yeah i mean basically i can make these almost free mm-hmm because which is a 50 50 chance using four dice oh you have this oh yeah yeah so you have a stacked crew the smuggler i would say is the most versatile one right out of the three yeah uh because you could go on the aggressive and but you as it's so weird it's very bizarre the smuggler is kind of the one who dictates how well certain factions are doing yes they can yeah which
i don't think is fun someone's just going to get butt hurt they're going to definitely encourage what areas you need to start controlling right because either you need to be the molest can just spread everywhere and just try to get one point just tons of one-pointers yeah um and maybe that's why i don't know yeah i mean because you put the i mean a four and three and then the the one in the middle it's like you actually helped me by destroying my stronghold because then you were able to bump it up right like oh okay well i'll just go back there deploy drop move them in and then just immediately place a stronghold back right uh i just and then and then the strong the the strength of the the bluefin squadron is they just have insane attack power yeah uh constant constant attack power and i actually think their strongest thing is that one extra die 100 i have so much connection and the ability to go last every single turn around right because you're uh yeah yeah always
which to me because this is still because it's combat but it's also a little bit king of the hill especially for youtube always being last is always good that's insane yeah because i get to see if he does anything because if if he came in here uh and or came in here and took it over it's like oh okay well i luckily have you know a three left so i can do my order and you know it is very situational but it's like i can still counteract to whatever anyone does and then we go right to scoring right and i i don't know it's like again i'm not saying these are unbalanced i just think they're annoying yeah yeah that's kind of my balance like i don't think this game is bad it's just it's annoying at least for me and this is from someone who is it too limited no the option no i think it does a great job for what it's wanting to do it actually for a base game like it's it's relatively solid like there's there's enough strategy that i'm not sitting here like there i mean there was one time of being like well i have one [ __ ] die i don't know what to do with it um but then zach's like oh just move over there and then you can control it's like oh yeah you're right i can't do that right and so like i actually am a little interested in this game to play it more but just watching the other two factions like like why would i never not want to play just the smuggler yeah because i think that's the most enjoyable portion of it i can see myself enjoying the blue fins because honestly
i'm just saying you can't be butt hurt i'm going to take you all out with it that's the thing is like the blue fins are only as strong as the smuggler allows them to be if you if i was playing the smuggler and you kept and you kept like i mean you would only be attacking him but if you kept attacking me it's like okay fine i'm just gonna start racking up points that he controls and that's the thing so like because you could have put more cannons down like you could have started hitting me harder to limit my ability to place because realistically you actually kind of want the game to last a long time no actually no i don't think so i think they they want the game to last a long time because they they rely on on having one mollusk get you know because i i'm i'm very congealed with my i mean yes i could order and eventually start spreading them out but they're so easily killed by that point and because i do want to play strongholds and i only have three i want to be very central focus i want to let the smuggler you want to increase regions and then i just want to hoard those down that's right i'm king of the hill like he's air i feel like he's more area control just because yeah and yeah because i have no way i have one strategic area control yeah i'm diverse area i have literally exactly i have one spot that lets me put out an extra patrol one die and i could theoretically use a five and then go to a harbor and move it over and then do it again yeah i get that but every time you sail you put out a patrol if you have a cannon all your patrols
now can fight so they're all now basically limiting because the thing is if you cause a fight they're done moving uh that but that only stops you it stops his ships too i mean he only has one ship unless he gets the other two out but then he just stays away from me the fact that he has an ability to just take four mallets and just right but he can only do that once per turn theoretically no because then he could go and stop in the harbor move it over too you start putting your sharks out to start damaging stuff my shark's my sharks cannot attack where his molochs are i know so what i'm saying is you start putting your sharks in the harbor areas with the cannon always set because you can always have you have two cans right you're forcing him sure yes i could do that and then just hold up but then then you're not moving around and i'm not moving around and placing strongholds i'm just i'm just kind of like again you're focused in one area hoping and strategizing how to make that worth the most right in my mind me preventing him from being able to drop him out is because then he just okay well yeah you have a six i have a six in my cannons i'll drop it down to a one so will you then it comes too this is [ __ ] trash like what he must have just gave up at the end when deciding combat that [ __ ] is so frustrating but yeah but then it comes down to oh okay we're evens on cannons i rolled a four oh you rolled a five okay like that's that
and or even worse nope i roll two dice nope boom boom boom boom boom here's my ten cards that i guarantee i'm winning oh yeah i started out this game well one of the ones i was dealt with was the one where you add this many to your die roll to your cannon oh yeah so that's why i had a stack of pants right off the bat because if anybody hit me i was like okay yeah i i win because then the attacker and you don't lose them right it's just however many you happen to have in store the only time i actually did use it i knocked that down to two yeah and and the die roll the attacker has to spend their cannons first so you just sit there and you're like right okay i'm not even going to spend this card because i i'm or i'm going to spend it now because yeah um and as we're as we're conversing it's like obviously the annoyance of playing the game is is subsiding um it is showing that surprisingly this game because you asked if it's too much i think there's more depth here yeah then than one would initially be especially because you're obviously going to be comparing it to root same company yeah and uh and asymmetric factions right um i weirdly think this is more aggressive than root but i could just be because i play i always i'm playing the aggressive faction and you're never gonna play a three-person game no not really no there there's too much aggression too much defensiveness going on to keep track of who you're supposed to be gunning for yeah i never i've
never no i have played through that three-player game it's not the worst the worst but it's not great it's not ideal yeah four is where you really you want to be better yeah four or five or six yeah um i would take four or five or six so yeah this is definitely more focused and therefore it's like okay we're yeah it's also very weird that what what he chose to do instead of doing four unique factions he chose two or three unique factions in an extra smuggler right be
and and then and then you have two vagabonds god that would be a trash can that would be gonna be horrible uh so yeah and i'm very curious if adding another man i don't know i do not i actually didn't mind this at three i don't know that it would be good because so another smuggler would change the values that these guys would write drastically all we do is realistically give you guys more points and each smuggler would lose points totality because there's only so much cargo just there's only so much cargo uh we're technically in a three-player game you miss uh unless the smartphones decide from the game because it's one of each uh suit in a three-player game or they're okay so there's more there's there's six more cars one one more of each suit that's only more island more regions theoretically six more points if you got half and half yeah i was about to say well you got to 29 but that's because you were the sole focus of all those yeah right and the other thing is because if we hire crew then that limits the cargo that you can get right um which actually is kind of but then you also have then you would then you become i feel like with a smuggler in a three-player game you do become more smuggler like more cargo focused if there's another smuggler you probably lean more combat yeah because then you want to win battles and then trick around that because you get what five points with a four or five so so the corners are really good so
spend up to five gold get point for whatever gold you spend get four fame but raise the die again repair all damage get a star for every damage you repair and then gain just three fame by itself but everything around it is kind of eh which i like i honestly do like that yeah i mean i mean they're not nothing though they're not added tile to map so you could have actually done that and pulled this one out okay because there's no dye for it so you can't oh you're right yeah so once that pile because again everything's limited yeah you can rush repair all damage is solid if you're not going for the the repair option a free tailwind is really good free table one was actually halfway decent yeah so and then just having gold just i mean hell like i didn't even think because i knew i had gold at the beginning so that's why i did this path so i went down here got the two gold and then came back up with the idea like i'm going to make sure i have five gold when i hit this spot to get the five points nice so i hang out three points and five points i mean eight points of mine literally came from going around yeah so but it took you seven deliveries to do that right seven or eight uh one two three four five six seven eight deliveries and a total deliveries to be able to pull that off and in fact uh to get a third of my points it took eight deliveries slash combats yeah um which again i will agree if you had two smugglers someone's becoming a buccaneer on that one yeah
yeah 100 and uh and just because it's not in the uh we don't have the run through because i didn't turn it on uh the final score ended up being me at 30 zack at 29 and brother 25 right which throughout the entire game like i mean you would you would go you would go it's kind of like nightfall a little bit where it's like you would jump in points but only during the game and then at the end of the round then it's like okay i'd leap frog and then zac and then brett leapfrogged so then we were we were kind of going back and forth and then throughout the game then you pass us right so it's a very interesting dynamic of point scoring and i mean i'm actually just amazed that i even pulled it off just because at one point brett was at nine and i think i was at 15 or even like i think and then he passed me and i'm like i'm [ __ ] like like he just jumped so high how am i even gonna combat this and then it's all it all came down to me having one extra turn yeah and just the way that the and me not taking the time not to use yeah not using that very like situational card because god yeah in fact what i was worried about because i knew the buccaneer was in here um i think you have it uh i thought you were gonna aim to try and get it and fight me because then you could have just wiped this right out because the buccaneer is like oh remove two crew and i i was gonna go for it but it was like i think the two red hats ended up being way down here it's like yeah that's not happening these were not a main focus of mine the only one that i
focused on was the one i didn't want you to have and as it turns out there's another one that came out anyway there was another one i think he took his cargo and but that's just and that's the other thing is like so many of these we kind of talked about on the initial run through was they seemed so much better for like these should be like faction cards right but they're not it's like because this doesn't behoove you to ever take as a smuggler right it's like it makes it's great for you to have because then you have more control over your uh comrades it's great for me to have because then i have control over my enemies comrades insane and vice versa yeah i don't know why i can't the only reason i ever care about having the uh shark one is just to get through shark blockades of islands yeah if you have cannons because i might not want to fight them yeah but the more i think about like the fighting i get the fact of not liking the die roll and that's i think comes down to some personal preference on but the the victory conditions aren't devastating ever right um but so i feel like like i kind of avoided fighting but then i'm like at the same time i was like why yeah realistically for me i probably should have fought more because the consequences of even losing were like who cares especially like i got the ship right so i could repair all damage i take four damage yeah boom that's not even that it's like okay you take two damage like that's the max i could do the you uh
and it was only it's just so weird that yeah there were so many times in the game where you have battle victory that it's like but i don't get anything for it yeah like and the loser doesn't really lose much either not really like because it's so easy but it's easy to repair damage it's um i mean harbors heal you too or move stuff to cannons to basically fight yeah um there was two ship rights so you can always heal up um repair heals two of your damage which realistically i took more damage by going through trash than i did anything else i never felt the need to repair i have four damage on my on my ship and i'm like okay like i think the only time i did is because i think you fought me at one point and you went into i wanted you to i had canada and you went into a patrol yeah i didn't realize you yeah and i lost my full sale which that's probably the most critical one to me negotiating full sales the only good things for this thing yeah um and so i was like okay i have to repair that right but it's more of just kind of like a hope you accidentally went into a spot i guess we have to fight uh and it's like yeah i guess i'll do two damage um there and there like i never really cared about damaging really the only reason i wanted to fight you was because i specifically had something as a battle victory yeah right like okay i deal with damage and i get to remove a comrade out which i need to so i can take over that spot i do think that this i would would agree it's root light so if you like root
this is probably going to work for you and i could see it or if root is a bit much for you then you'll probably like this you have to like aggression games though that's the thing okay so i think the thing that i don't enjoy about root is just the overall complexity right i've got to figure out all the stuff that i can do and what should i do best and there's no way i can figure out what you guys are probably going to try to do to counter it so that can't be a fact that's how most people teach the root is it's like you learn your faction ignore everybody else yeah yeah this one it's it's simpler enough that you can think well if i do that what's he probably gonna do they're like i don't really want to get rid of your patrols but i don't want you having strongholds so i'm gonna get rid of your patrols yeah yeah um it's interesting because i love rude the root's a 10 out of 10 game for me um and i don't really care for this game but you also know that's always one rather because complexity but even in the aggression of i mean i've played every faction um and but do you enjoy a reflection i do aggressively yeah yeah we even the ranking like all of them right yeah i mean even the rip i mean the river folk aren't you know you know what i bet it is just knowing your personality i bet it's because in root there's a puzzle in figuring out how to accomplish your goals more than there is here here it's produced that could be it it is basically there there's all the factions i mean like i said there is some depth
to them at least how they integrate with everything else but at the end of the day i need to fight right like there's no other way for me to get points and even then it's like it's so weird that it's like yeah i'm aggression and i should fight but why like i don't gain anything for fighting you except hoping to fight for these your goal in fighting is to knock me down so i don't get the points pretty much yeah and and that's and we talked about that stuff like petrichor yeah which is actually kind of weirdly like in that sense of i'm hurting you or you not for me to gain anything but to hurt but to hinder you and i don't like that type of conflict right because it's like if i if i if i attacked you in any way in in a game it would be like okay yes now i'm stopping you from getting four points and now i'm getting four points okay great but so many of these cards and stuff was me just like i'm just stopping you from getting points i'm not getting points and yeah which is interesting i wonder if that's because the design because they're so aggressive like so i actually am kind of you know goal oriented to fight a little bit because i get fairly decent rewards but that then kind of says in this type of game you just aren't going to fight that often yeah um because the two factions who are definitely more geared for fighting have kind of not are just okay reward systems steal gold uh destroy a mollusk from the board or do two damage to a ship and it would be a little bit different if gold was a
victory point at the end right uh but it's a tiebreaker or worth more and i mean to be fair like and i will say this on the game placed around dice as your actions um they actually weren't a problem yeah like i totally expected it to be one of those well i can't [ __ ] do anything never had an issue never have no and because and so they at least have gold as your mitigation i use gold one time to make a game i think i did too yeah and so so if we really think about how many rounds do we think we did probably four four around the table yeah um well you were first who was first player at the end to you so so we did we did four i think we because i started one two three well i'm saying oh yeah we went seven yeah yeah yeah one foot seven full rounds because i forgot i yeah if we were each first place i was the first player twice yes okay yep so seven total rounds and so in seven total rounds the re you only have a mirror gate your dice one time says okay the dice system is balanced at least yeah yeah which i like i'm how i was having because i was like man you gotta get six and the five or five but i was like we have five dice and twenty or a thirty three percent chance of hitting getting those you're pretty much guaranteed one like because of the way my two best things are both sixes are both sixes but even then it's like oh okay i rolled a five dang it oh i'll just go uh over here and i'll i'll collect that gold right and then next turn i'll spend it
and bump it up to a six right so i like the fact that you have a lot of control over how you dust this is the way i like dice this is why i hate the combat in this because this like your turn is oh okay now what can i do with this it's the war of the rings yes and this doesn't frustrate me it's actually more of a puzzle where it's like if i youtube versus man i sure would like to sail i can't i know that kind of [ __ ] is so frustrating uh that's why a lot of skirmish games don't work for me because it is just kind of like okay let me tactilely move over here and here and here and i miss okay so the dye system worked fairly well but but yes the the the aggressive factions that i play in root um there's there's always a reason to i mean mainly there's a total fighting game so it's like me attacking you to do that is because i'm gonna get victory points off of doing that and i also now control this region which then allows me to place to build whatever if i'm playing the cats to build in there and also oh hey i control it so i can build this which now i can work with the vagabond so there's a lot more integrated into the aggression of root versus this right and one thing i will say kind of the counter of the root is realistically you have two factions who are pretty focused on fighting and one faction is not and roots the birds aren't even focused on fighting they're focused on making a
continuous system yeah they're good at fighting yeah like you can oh the woodland alliances even really focus on fighting they're just the best it's right and so and so in a game that is about aggression but there's so much control over your aggression where this one like i thought you more often because i had no choice you're like well that's the only orange spot there and you even forgot for goad forgone the the cargo because you wanted me to control it at the end right which ended up being a hinder like and which is kind of a weird thing because it's like well i wanted to control it because i have his card in my thing right but that's four points he's just getting unless brett can take it um which is not at all hard especially with that card he's just like okay right it's mine now right it's like oh well then that but then it's like okay well now i heal and i go over there and then i just bombard them and during the or i still or i get the second convincing comrade take both of those then take four and pop them back over here right and during the run through like you know there was a complaint like because i wasn't exploring and i was like i don't need to all pretty much everything but red was discovered and i was like the cards didn't call for me to go look for red at that point right i was like why would i ever go it's a waste of for me it's almost a waste of an action to go do it it is uh and it only opens up more points for us right and i didn't say that at the time i was like why would i go do that when it's not helping me any
scorable point because i want this game to have negotiation and it doesn't right it doesn't like it's like yes i want to work because you you are kind of like the middle you obviously are the middleman between us two so it's like okay i need your help to sway it in my favor because i'm losing so to do that how about you quit bumping up the [ __ ] that brett has control of and then explore out so i can follow you but it's always in this game right now it's a one-way negotiation there's no benefit from me you can't give me anything right so there's no encouragement like if you could give me gold like if gold was tradable yeah i'd be like okay yeah i can do that the only thing is like yeah you could be like okay if you go explore that then i can control it and you can put those in my pile but right it's that's such a weak counter offer because i'm just gonna gain more points right if you did it in like round three right for the next four rounds i get two points so you trade off two victory points for eight that i would get right i do like the fact that i'm limited to two cargo because i could see because if you could if you could grab more i know you could honestly would never go to a port until i had like four of them and then just dump it out yeah it's definitely the the factions are absolutely balanced so here's the question did you do you guys did you guys have fun with your factions i did i enjoyed it me personally yeah yeah uh is right on that edge of thinking too much to have fun versus but again we know i'm gonna lower i'm at a lower point
i would say that i i i certainly can imagine people having fun with it and really taking to strategizing yeah and and the luck factor and knowing what's coming yeah and the fact that you can just sandbag on those the fact that you draw two every round it's like it is at the end of every round but it's like man i wish there was a way to like because you're only limited to two cargo it's like you have a hand limit or something of three and it's like okay well now you kind of have to play them to then draw more well most of them are not not great they're all good but there's only a couple of them that are really good and i just happened to stack them part of it by avoiding comments so that was like um i'm trying to the uh nightfall it was kind of the thing with nightfall right that because you can stack so you can hold it waiting for that perfect moment it's always better versus with a hand limit yeah this isn't the option moment for me to use it but these other cards are better that i know it's going to be more so i play it it's not opportune but who cares he must he must have been trying to think of a way to counteract okay i want to give the blue fins an extra die and so he always gets to react to stuff that happens therefore the mollusk as his enemy needs to have a way to have it have a you know because you don't know what i'm going to do with my final huge enough advantage that the to be yesterday so i can't i can't prepare for that and then the fact that i think you just have pure crew and right um you you control
how much we score you are the you're basically the dm of this game um it's very interesting i i'm i will apply that based off the way it was briefly explained to me at gen con i was like okay it's pirate root right and it does not feel like root it does like at all and and i will commend him for that because it does feel like oh man yeah looking from the outside it looks like fruit playing it does not feel like it's nothing like it so so yeah it's uh it's it's in that weird position that it puts me in where it's like as we've talked more and more on it my annoyance as playing the game has subsided but i know it's still there and i know for a fact just the way that the game is set up it's it it no longer boils down to let's say we're playing a three player game of root where we're all equal enemies yeah someone might be in the lead so then the other two kind of seize fire and go after them to knock them back down but at the end of the day okay we're all trying to negotiate with one another this does not have that nope you whoever is playing the blue fins and whoever's playing the malice are attacking each other the entire time and then they're annoyed that's a smuggler because it's like well he does what the [ __ ] is he doing right and it reminded me of the analogy i made in the run-through of a three-player game of merchants and marauders it's like okay we're just fine the entire time oh man cat one like oh she just did rumors the entire time because like i couldn't break away from you to do like i can't break away from you to
deal with him so that it felt very similar to that same idea of uh tiny epic pirates okay where you can fight people but then that one person who just goes around selling resources to different islands then just wins yeah so or like even hell even western legends has it where someone's going um you know evil the whole time then it's like okay so no one's gonna be the sheriff to stop him okay i guess i'll [ __ ] do it i don't want to be the sheriff to do this but i guess i will right um which i don't like western legends for that one main reason um but yeah and i think that's really where the crux it's like everything is relatively a positive besides the the combat die i don't have a whole lot of negatives in all reality like the factions are balanced and even whenever we i made the recollection that oh because i think you guys are better than me and you guys are thinking the opposite therefore it's balanced you know right like if you guys have ever played voyages of marco polo yeah where it's like everyone's ability is better than yours right but they're all thinking the same thing right interesting though so you've got a game that no matter what faction you play you're not going to like it yeah but you know that everybody else isn't liking it either right so you've got a universal they might they might
the difference is like i feel like your powers are better doesn't mean i dislike my power yeah because to me it's war of the ring i love playing both evil and good because evil i feel like oh i have so many minions but they're so far away to do anything valuable and good it's like i keep losing people but frodo just gets one step closer and i can't find him i can't corrupt him right and so both people are like man i think i'm going to lose this game until you hit that end condition because it's it's actually balanced pretty well of both sides actually have lots of good strength it's just the other side points face to face in those situations just look overwhelming yeah i mean put it this way like like the the final score like i just edged out 30 points it was won by like the point spread from first to last is five points right and that that is literally one area control away and we had at one point one card one card play away actually if i if i had mapped that yeah then i would have stopped it yeah right and i mean hell because i only had one or if i had if i had masked it out and thought oh i can get to 30 if i do this right now yeah i i i thought i needed one more sure and on on a lot of playthroughs that it that kind of is what the game becomes because then you were mentioning um oh well i think we talked about it before we when we did like our first play of like oh are we ever going to look at what other people's dice are and we're like i said probably not but it
actually as you play this game more and more you could have looked and be like he's gonna go last yeah he has a three oh he's probably going to order like he's probably gonna because then he can or he's like he's gonna get four three oh [ __ ] he can get nine then you'd be like i'm gonna play this card and then spread it out it's like oh well brett won right because then you could have swung five points in that instance with and then i'm like because i can only do stuff with the one die at the end of it i can't i can't stop that i might have been able to stop you getting to 30 but but that would have been it that would have been it unless you're lucky enough that it's your last three days oh where i'm in second that's also true but again it's still those same situations of trying to negate like and that's why i think this game will take off if people give it a chance is you'll become really familiar with what every card is in that 12 card deck yeah um yeah you actually card count where it's like okay what is it used i mean and that's the thing is like yeah because root players do it ti players do it yeah but they also don't have any friends i mean i don't mind card counting whenever it's very limited but like yes someone could how many do you have 12 12 cards it's like probably probably half two of them are duplicates right so really ten cards oh i see so it's like yes if he played six cards and i'd be like okay let me look through those you
probably have six cards in your hand okay i know now what you can do right um so it kind of does become that but i mean the more strategic it gets the more thinking about that stuff the slower it gets too yeah so i felt like i was slow on my turns most of the time because i was just waiting to see what happened i was reacting the entire game i think that is kind of what this game is a little bit though again because of that because of the very nature of i do too you do too you do too and the turn order it's like which would be normal because if you always think you're weaker that means you always are thinking i have to react to a thing yeah it's players who are in strength who don't think i have to react to a problem and some of it was just unfamiliarity after applying several more times you you you understand your strengths and and should be fair like whenever i place my strongholds down i was like oh man i have that on lockdown nah i mean mainly because i never bolstered them with cannons right but i also never thought at the time of placing those in there that anyone was going to attack me so each time i lost the stronghold i was like oh that sucks right like because now i because that was the only reason i had control over what brett had and then if you as a third party just swoop in and you you remove it then it's like why the [ __ ] did you just do that you just gave brett four points like that because he thought he wasn't a threat he can't be a threat like in in the sense of the area control
yeah he's actually not even really a threat in any way because we can't do anything to stop him yes if i get the buccaneer then i could i could attack your crew but i can't stop your cargo right um i can't hinder your yeah i mean i guess if you were battling going that route i could try and always win and so you never move your thing but it's uh yeah they're just so third party and i think that's ultimately what annoys me the most about this game is that no matter what in a three or four player game we're we're just at odds the whole time right and you have a neutral party which is how it's set up which is how it's designed and that's why i don't see myself keeping this game right because of that it's like i don't want because i know for affect my feelings for how we played the run-through aren't going to subside right unless i play the smuggler like i would want to play the smuggler because it's like oh ease like there's just no one to like i just can dictate i can actually kind of negotiate for nothing but yeah i i would not want to play either of these factions whereas in root i will literally play any faction and have a good time um you guys get anything else production quality it's fine so it's good yeah uh except for the fact that the command tokens have to have stickers put on them oh yeah which was i mean yeah it was whatever but it was just like really stickers come on i'm
very curious to see how this game does though because i i know where the score is on i was going to say imdb on uh board game geek um which is surprisingly what i'm gonna gonna give it but i think this has a relatively small print run i don't think it went on kickstarter if i didn't go on kickstarter it's it's all pretty good it's all um it was released first at gen con but still not type it's in pre-order right it's a pre-order okay so they did a small print run for gen con and then it's pre-order right now yeah because they were i i had to rush to the booth and they had the whole pile whenever i got there but then later on that day i walked by and yeah it was all gone right i was like yes again leader games kai i mean definitely did at least push out that was coming out in general for the short run yeah so i think they even got lucky that it showed up because nick whenever i asked him he was like hey hey come back tomorrow because we weren't we were surprised we're actually getting them in tomorrow so uh but yeah production quality is solid like it's a it doesn't replace any pirate game for me like dead reckoning is way up there merchants marauders is up there i haven't played tiny epic pirates but i don't like the tiny epic games or that designer all that much as a designer as a person like scott almost [ __ ] sucks as a human being he owes me money yeah it was fine i'm trying to think of other pirate games no tiny epic pirates yeah that's what treasure island rum and bones which is not really i was
like i guess this is not combat oriented that's true uh i've only played the first edition so i don't i've heard second edition that's more your moba kind of style roman bones if i remember right i did have a fun time with but i ended up getting rid of it yeah there's not a whole there's
that feels like you are a pirate right so there's lots of ones that are pirate themed um so like you know um um what's the one that's cards that we played the you have the ship you're getting cargo uh other zach loves it yeah jamie just came out with a new version of it with the cap oh libertalia yeah oh yeah it's it's pirate thing i was like oh yeah yeah it's pirate theme but it's not a pirate game yeah i don't feel like a pirate doing it and that's my thing like when i started looking like to find my pirate themed game to fit that slot in my shelf it's like man there just aren't pirate games yes you i have two yeah dead reckoning and merchants in morocco which again dead reckoning fulfills the spot now it's going to be hard to kick it off that's because it's so specific that like that theme is that i want to feel a very specific way versus just sci-fi or fantasy it's like yeah i don't wanna i wanna feel like my character in those games but i don't need to feel like i'm in a fantasy world or whatever so yeah um this this this feels like it's gonna be a niche niche game because it's like if someone wants the combat but they don't want the very like aggressive directed at [ __ ] you as another player dead reckoning right because you can just fight and there's actually reason to go fight and if you want to just go around pillaging villages dead reckonings yeah merchants and marauders would be my other one if you can find it and and the expansion right um it's fantasy flight it's old fantasy
flight so it's very ameritrash but it hits it's probably more thematic than dead reckoning probably uh probably so so yeah i don't know um skill one to ten what would you guys give ahoy start with start with brett yeah i will speak first so there um i will say seven seven that's exactly where i'm at that's exactly where i am yeah and that's what it is on board game is a 7.3 i was going to say 6.9 was what game geek was going to do oh it is yes 7.3 okay um which i feel like that's that's accurate i would like which is surprising for their rating system uh yeah that's true which means there's a bunch of people rating it lower than that probably uh but it i mean because it's only on like 70 ratings like because no one has it everybody's still thrilled about i got one yeah it's all the gen con people who are playing and giving exactly what we just gave it so so yeah that's our thoughts on ahoy everyone i hope you enjoyed let us know we think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful every time today is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other
than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you