Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dark Ages Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 29:43

hey everybody today i'm talking about dark ages heritage of charlemagne which is a 2021 release board game published by board and dice who you may recognize as the company built on the back of daniel tashini designs however this is not a tashini design this is made by adam kopinski and andre novak this one accommodates four to one to four players and takes probably around three hours to play now dark ages is actually um split into two games you've got this one the heritage of charlemagne and you've also got holy roman empire the games are relatively similar or pretty much 90 similar however you are able to plug the two games together to make a a one to eight player game so if you really do want to get that higher play account this one does actually facilitate that but let's talk about what this game is all about so as you can probably imagine there's a lot going on in this game i'm going to try my best not to go into all the little rules my new shirt and just give you a general overhaul and an overview about what's going on in this game so as you can see here you've got the massive board here which is a map of europe and of course if you plug this one in with the holy roman empire board then it's going to be even bigger um and you're going to each start with a home kind of city or your your home domain and you're going to have a leader which in my example is this one here william the first the pious and each of these characters has a couple of cards that come with that leader which give you a little kind of boost in a certain field uh you could also gonna have your troops you gotta have your own little starting city here which

you can upgrade you've got these different farms here which are gonna increase your ability to move troops around the board uh you can potentially get these commanders as well which is like an optional module you can put into the game and this game is very modular i should say there's a lot of different things you can tweak and put in and take out of the game you've got all your different resources here so you've got your your steel your stone your wood and your leather and they all kind of relate to your player board which shows all the different things you can build in the game and different troops and stuff you can make so you're going to start the game with very basic troops like so and you're going to have the ability to upgrade them to make them better better in combat and just generally more durable um you can see here on this board as well you've got different tracks and things so this one here is my farm track which basically determines um not only how many points i'm going to get at the end of the game so the more farms i get down the better because i get more points but again the higher the art up in this track means that you can move more troops around the board at any time to make you uh kind of more maneuverable you've also got a warehouse here which is important because when it comes to a certain point in the game where you need to pass then you can keep hold of certain resources and the higher you go on the track you can keep more on your supply and potentially sell more goods which ties into this part of the board up here which is the kind of communal board where you can choose to get new cars new technologies into your fold uh you i've got this track here which basically determines how many cards you can draft from so at the moment you see the the orange player here is at this point

meaning that they can only draft at this point or lower down the board here because this is a sliding scale whereas the blue player can draft all four of these cards um should they take that action you've got this little church track here which is a countdown to the to the end of the game you've got this big deck of cards which is going to be used to refresh the technology row and i suppose the main action and user interface of the game is this part here which is going to be how you choose your actions and the fallout of those actions so let's talk about what all the actions are okay so yeah throughout the game you're gonna have five actions which you can select from um and these are interchangeable so sometimes you know they're gonna be different spots which can affect the different reactions you can take um should that situation arise but they're all pretty simple in their own regard here so you've got maneuver which means that you can choose a um a cluster of uh of your soldiers and move them from a kind of region to region or province to province depending on the borders a development of culture here which means that you can take a card from the culture um offer so this is the culture offer so you can you can take cards um straight into your hand to be able to play them a bit later you've got the building action which is going to be of course how you're going to build buildings you're going to build these cities which are great because they allow you the opportunity to build more of these kind of manufacturing buildings and also let you climb the track up here and they also are really good defensively as well because if people attack your regions with cities then you get a bit of a proxy unit to help you defend uh defend that attack uh you've

got these different again production buildings which produce you the leather they'll produce you the steel they'll produce you the wood and the stone so of course you want to have a good balance of different resources in order to build other things because all the different things are quite costly to build in the first place and you can also build these churches and churches are one of the main ways to score points in the game so you can you can see here i built a church so when you build a church you're going to get five points plus one point for every every region next to it that does not have a church so you're really kind of incentivized to evangelize the religion and get those churches down first and you can also build these keeps no keeps are really good and they start off quite cheap but they can get more expensive at the higher you build those towers so you can see it here see here in my main city that i've built two keeps which are these two little kind of cylinder things you can plug into these cities and they will increase your ability in combat in any adjacent any adjacent region by giving you more minute manipulation of your dice and they also boost your combat score at the end so again if you have keeps and people attack keeps then you are much more likely to win the battle if you are the owner of that keep and again you can increase your warehouse here to uh by paying these resources in order to be able to carry more resources through round around and of course being able to sell them when you sell the resources you are going to look at the worth and then move up this track the current the correlating amount of spaces so that's the building action you've also got the research action which is going to let you play um

technology cards and upgrade your military units and i suppose the main thing that ties to are these cards here so i think this is such a really cool mechanism where you actually have you start with these kind of basic things and here when you acquire these technology cards and they'll let you do different things if so this one here these um this private deniers one says immediately i'll get one gold but whenever i take the action i can actually pay a gold in order to move up and upgrade the action to the next one so this one says i can spend one gold as any two resources instead of the usual one or if i upgrade it again i can whenever i pass i get two gold instead of the usual one and you can see here as well these are all requiring me more points at the end of the game so there's a lot of variation in what these can do and some of them are going to be more attack focused some are going to be to get units onto the board and they can do lots of different things i really do like that and of course as i mentioned earlier if you ever acquire these upgraded troop actions then you can again pay a gold in order to upgrade the strength of your military units and the uh the final one here is to take a recruit action which is when you pay the amount of resources corresponding to your troop value so here again my infantry costs one leather and then i can take one of my infantry units like so and put it on any region where i have a city now as you can see here the way we've taken these actions we're going to be placing these noble disks on the different spots correlating to that action but once you place the third cue third disc let's say i just place this one on here

as soon as there's three on a stack the one at the bottom is going to take a fallout action which is going to be the two um adjacent below it so for example because that one's just been placed i can maybe put this one here and take a wood or a stone or i could have gone this way and i could sell goods um or trade iron for gold you can regroup which gives you more kind of maneuverability to kind of retreat back into your own regions you can recruit which we discussed earlier uh you can take wood or leather or you can do a cultural exchange where you can sell cards for gold or buy any card for gold so i do like this um this mechanism here where people are taking actions and just naturally you might have a fallout of that and get a reaction to get more mileage out of each of these discs so of course this is what the game is going to look like towards the end of the game but if you could imagine a lot of these regions in fact most of these regions being completely abandoned and completely empty apart from our home regions and all the other regions are going to be allocated one of these barbarian tokens so these are going to be flipped randomly face up or face down so you've got the one side that shows the um the different units that are going to be there as barbarians and the other side which is going to show the almost the boon in which you're going to get by defeating those barbarians so you can see this one here says take a military technology from the cultural offer so that's the reward you're going to get by defeating those barbarians so in order to expand out you're going to have to defeat them and they're going to be basically these proxy units or these default units which are pretty basic but i suppose initially they can be quite challenging and the more of these tokens you acquire by beating them you're going to add them

to your player board here so you can see i've already defeated two and got a couple of rewards and you're gonna also add an additional unit for each one you get and get victory points for doing so so yeah that's really something to consider and they do get tougher and tougher but of course you're gonna need to expand out in order to start conquering these different regions which which can produce different resources because i will say that resources in this game are really tight and it can feel like you're in a bit of a straitjacket at times and it's quite hard to get the ball rolling and get things going but i'll talk about that a little bit later and talk about a few more things what we're actually trying to do in order to get the points so let's talk about all the different methods you can actually get points so first off and you can try and claim these these title cards here by conquering certain regions so you can see here i've i've really got at least the majority in um in aquitaine so i've got two out of the three things here that means i can potentially get these titles which will get me victory points and i'm not only initially also at the end of the game if i'm still controlling it and these actually let you basically do a bonus action by um piggyback of a of another one you've just taken and exhausting that card and you can also get points by end game scoring so a lot of these cards will offer you end game points but i won't go into detail there um of course i mentioned the farms earlier the more farms you get out the more points you can get again the more barbarian tokens the more you can get if you upgrade your warehouses enough you can get victory points if you get churches down of course you're gonna get victory points because i said as you place them down you get points for all the adjacent regions that don't have churches the keeps are going to get you victory

points depending on the different um areas around them that you control and all different things like that so there's quite a lot of ways you can get points and of course you can actually end up getting points if you end up conquering or trying to attack your opponent's capitals um so i suppose that leads us into um combat so let's talk about how combat actually works so despite some being very euro the actual combat in the game is purely roll and resolve so you've got your three different units as i mentioned you've got your infantry yeah your your kind of archery and your cavalry and um it's going to be resolved in a specific order so your archery of course are going to go first and then it's going to be your kind of charging cavalry units they're going to go in and then your inventory units are all going to fight at the same time and you're going to start with some basic modifiers so you can see my cavalry here just hits on a five plus and then on six plus in in melee and and but as the more you increase these units to get better and better and better and you can end up hitting on much better numbers so you can see my my crossbowman here actually hit on three pluses in um in ranged attacks and only and five plus in close quarters and that's going to be how how it works just going to be killing units and rolling off against each other and then you're going to calculate calculates the battle score at the end of the game or at the end of the fight and seeing how much strength in military units you have left being boosted by these keeps if need be so very simple roll to resolve combat which i think is a bit of a juxtaposition to the rest of the game which again i'll talk about a little bit later

so as long as you have one of these discs placed on the main action board here you can choose to pla pass which will mean you can take all your discs back into your hand ready to deploy again in the next kind of phase of play um also there's no rounds or anything in this game it is a constant free-flowing game where you keep taking actions up however if you choose to pass you are going to get a gold which is useful of course which is going to um be a wild resource and they're going to let you upgrade your technology etc but it's also going to mean you're going to have to refer to your warehouse and potentially lose goods sell goods um depending on that threshold here um so it really is a game where you're incentivized to use your resources at least early in the game because they will go to waste if you don't use them um after that you can actually choose to take little bonus actions such as settle so as you can see here i've invaded normandy i'm in control of it but i haven't got a farm down there yet so in order to get a farm down there i'm gonna have to give up a number of military units depending on my settlement value so you'll look at your own little leader card here which will show three different values which shows the settlement costs depending on different criteria so the first one means if it's in your home region and next to your capital and this one i believe it's next to your capital but not in your home region and the final one is anywhere else so you can see here um accutane was my capital this is nowhere near it and so i'd have to give up five a five value of troops in order to do that so at the moment my infantry are worth a value of one so i could i saw a value of two so i couldn't do that so i've only got two up the five i need but however maybe um down the line i'd maybe do this i have a complete

value of five because my cavalry are worth one these are worth two each i can give up these troops in order to build a new farm there which of course is gonna get me more points and it's going to increase my ability to maneuver around the board so hopefully that gives you a basic idea about how the game plays out we're going to keep taking actions until either the amount of churches are built depending on the player count until either the deck runs out until a player has built all of that technologies and upgraded them to the highest capacity or until a certain amount of these um these cities are built um and yeah that's pretty much how the game's going to play of course this is a more of a generic overview i'm not going to gone into tremendous detail russ some things i've missed out but again hopefully it's giving you a general impression now i do think a lot of the flavor comes from the cards in this game because there's a lot of variation in the cards and what they can do um so let's just take a look at a few of them here so i mean some of them will come in hand-in-hand with your leads etcetera so this one here this clooney abbey um it means instead of placing a noble disc i can actually use this card and gain two culture immediately for each city in a neighboring province so it's good to kind of boost things up before playing certain cards to get bigger and bit bigger multipliers um you've got like of course the military units that come in different levels and you can see they're double-sided as well and you can only have a level one up at a time so if i have like a level two cavalry i can upgrade into these really powerful level three nights and which of course are really durable because they have like uh more health they hit on better numbers and but of course they'll

be more expensive to build this one costing a massive three steal which is not the easiest thing to acquire you've got these commanders as well which i mentioned and my one here my edward the first um he means he lets me um hit or get kind of a pre-rolling phase where i roll two dice i hit on a four plus if i have a set of arches cavalry and infantry um i've got you can be build these massive buildings which i've done here in my capital and this one these are really cool they're expensive but they're really useful um which means that i can build three levels of a keep but then from then on whenever i resolve a recruit action i can place an infant unit for free in this province there's a nice little spawning military unit there and you've got these different weird um vassal cards here which let you do cool things um once per round so this one here lets me remove a barbarian token from a province neighboring my capital and i may move any number of units from a neighboring province into that crop into that province so it means i can kind of go around fighting barbarians and choose to settle quite quickly and i've got this um this card here as well let's me take any card from the offer um regardless of where i am on that culture track here and there's a lot of different things like that you can do as well there's also these quite interesting cards which hopefully i'll get one out um quickly where you can actually get little points bonuses depending on certain situations so um undoubtedly i'm not gonna find one now but they are really quite interesting and let's just see if i can get one out here we go one like this that says you know i can discard any number of resources and i

receive one victory point for each resource you discard or these ones here where you know you receive two victory points for each city you control and with three buildings uh and you can receive two vector points for each level three keep you control so these are all very situational and they're good little points grabs because they have to be scored out or cashed out at the end of the round when you pass and you can see here as well which i didn't mention that each city can only actually have three different buildings attached to it or three of the same buildings if you want to but they too kind of compound on each other so if you have two of the same buildings in the same city then you get bigger multipliers so the first building is going to going to produce one resource then the second one is going to produce two resource and the third one is also going to produce two so you can get maximum five resources per city if you build all the same thing in that city and that is going to happen whenever you pass you're going to get all your new resources in which i should have mentioned earlier um but let's talk about what i like and what i don't like about this game because there's quite a lot to cover and it's quite a difficult thing to articulate um because again there's a lot going on here so let's start off with some of the basics so first off the main actual action selection system i think is great so simple really pure and i just thought you know just put your disc on her on a location if somebody else goes there fine but the third person who goes there boom you're going to take fallout action which is going to be one of these two here and that's a really smooth system so easy to explain and you know what considering how simple it is i'm surprised that many other games haven't used this system it's so so elegantly done and really well implemented so yeah two thumbs up for that part of the game

i might also really enjoy these um these cards here i think these are really well done um and they do scale really well and do again let you do lots of different things so i love the way you can invest in certain strategies and can tailor your own little little engine i suppose differently to the other people so there's loads of variation of these cars that do lots of different things and i think it's really quite impressive and again another streamlined simple system which works really well um i also do like the actual scoring systems in this game as well because you're actually not massively incentivized to go fight and smash the other players and you know you can get a lot of points by just building churches or building your farms and building keeps so it really does have that point salad style feel to it and of course you can even get a lot of points by cashing in those um special cards so there's a lot of different routes you can go to victory lots of different paths you can take and lots of ways to generate points um i will say there was also a lot of things i did have quite a problem with this game with um i suppose one of them which i was bound to assume um the combat system is a bit underwhelming i i'm not a massive fan in fact i generally hate role to resolve combat um and this one is that which as i mentioned earlier it feels a bit it feels a bit of a disconnect from the rest of the game which is obviously very euro in its approach and this part here is you know as ameritrashi as it gets um i i can understand why they did it it's a kind of a hybrid style game but it just feels somewhat unsatisfying when you end up killing a lot of units um

especially when they're so expensive and hard to build in the first place and that kind of ties into my next thoughts which is i suppose the pacing of this game and the general vibe and flow of it so it really does feel like you start this game in a bit of a straight jacket it's very hard to get your motors running to get things flowing and get things kind of resources going through your system in order to build and build and build it does eventually hit a kind of threshold where you do start to generate a more comfortable amount of resources to keep you going um especially because these cities do compound when you build more of the same buildings but it really does feel like you are pulling teeth to get maybe one you know basic resource when you need it and you know the buildings that they're not massively expensive but and of course you can improve them as well with technologies but it does feel like you were going through a lot of actions to take very basic actions or basic buildings as a payoff to all that buildup and that's kind of a running theme throughout the whole game for me i mean it feels like you're doing a lot for very little i think maybe they could have tweaked the pacing by giving you more more resources just at any time maybe starting with more resources and again it just feels like you're constantly um you know walking in mud not getting anywhere and it can feel like you're just taking a basic actions just to pass and pass and pass in order to acquire gold to use it as a random resource so yeah that's something i did have a problem with that it did kind of alleviate as the game went on and certainly by the end of the game it

became a lot more fun and a lot more dynamic than it does at the start of the game i just would have liked to have seen it had a bit of a kick up the ass to get rolling and to kind of chuck people in at the deep end as soon as the ball gets rolling in terms of the decisions you have to make you are completely bombarded with decisions on what you can do now of course are you going to go and grab the cards that are only available um at the lowest spots before the other people do um are you going to try and make a military maneuver before the other people do are you going to try and upgrade your cars do you want to upgrade your military units to boost you up in the first place are you going to settle because you can't even attack until you have a certain threshold here anyway because you're going to end up wasting units so all of this does tie in together quite well and it does actually synergize with each other and all the different parts of the game do merge quite well and one thing does affect the other thing but it all kind of ties back to um feeling a bit plodding because you do have so many prerequisites and so many things to consider in order to do basic maneuvers so you know even if you want to acquire cards here you know climbing up this track isn't the easiest it does it again is a bit of a slog to get rolling and in order to go higher and higher up this track you're gonna have to discard resources which are like gold dust in the first place and that almost ties in with the military fighting as well you know you will build up a bit of military um but i think mostly you'd use that as a deterrent rather than going to attack the other players because it's just too costly um you do get a bit of compensation if you end up kind of ransacking an opponent's region and they have farms um that you kind of can send

infantry units back to your hometown which is you know a minor consideration something that's good for the game i think but i didn't ever find myself having that bloodlust and wanting to have a massive incentive to go and invade another region that that has another player already in it um for the for those reasons because it's just too costly you can spend 10 turns building up an army and you're just not willing to sacrifice it in a single roll of a dice additionally there is some competition over these um over these titles which i think is good um because you know there's quite a big chunk of points here and that can be quite significant so they are trying to throw you a bone there and try to make you attack the other players but i do think it all stems back to just being too costly and resources just being too scarce dark ages does take as i said about three hours to play uh which to be honest i was expecting um however i'm starting to feel like am i going to really reach this one off the shelf when it takes you know three hours um with a lot of that being quite a slow methodical plod uh where as i could play maybe two pretty involved euro games for an hour and a half a piece um in the same time it takes me to play this one now i do understand and appreciate this game does have more of an epic feel to a lot of the other euro games there's a lot going on here a lot of things to consider and you do have somewhat of an ownership over what you end up building throughout the game and you do get attached to a little empire but i i do feel like it would have benefited from being a bit quicker and it does vary in in pace as well because the game isn't a set amount of rounds it is until someone to be able to

certainly churches or cities or upgrades their cards and i wouldn't say it massively outstanding welcome but i think it's more of the pacing that goes with that it just made it feel a bit too long and um it felt made it feel like a bit of a slog um the uptime itself is pretty good because again you're just placing one of these discs down potentially getting a fallout action there's not a massive amount of ap in this game um it really is just about managing your resources and what you're going to do about them and just kind of that managing that tightness on what you're going to do next and i think aesthetically um i'm really happy with the way the game looks i think it's got a quite nice table presence um certainly there's something to look at wherever you look um it's very sprawling uh there's certainly boards everywhere um and you're gonna need a massive table to get this one to the table i've got a very large table and i can barely fit everything on and this is only a two player example so imagine being four players where each player's got their board and you're going to need an absolutely massive area in order to play this with and i can't even imagine playing this in the eight player version just you're gonna need a a banquet table uh absolutely ridiculous the actual physical production of the game is to be honest right up there with the best i mean the the actual board itself is you know it's nice and durable all the miniatures are pretty good i mean these these aren't overly um exquisite or anything like that but they do they do feel quite good um all the buildings are nice and durable as well particularly cities and the actual um these kind of big constructs and the actual commanders as

well these are these are fantastically done they're really good sculpts um again really robust and they do look quite cool when they're on the table um the only thing i can complain about is the resources so these basic little cardboard chips they feel a bit cheap they don't quite match with the rest of the game would it be nice to see um better versions of these i understand they made deluxe ones for the game but i think if you don't choose the deluxe version you can still get you should still get a decent product and i think these are a bit of a corner cutting and they're being a bit cheeky trying to make people take the um take the deluxe version but the actual artwork on the cards and stuff is right up there i'm actually quite aware with this artist who did this art and he is absolutely brilliant i mean this is such glorious artwork um this is right up my alley and i think these look really kind of um they really signify the time and the age of where this game is set and i really do like in in general i like the production i think works quite well um and you can really do kind of decipher what each thing um is supposed to do so yeah in terms of production as you'd expect with a game like this it's really good scalability is a strange one with the game like this because normally you'd expect games like this to really peak at the higher player counts um however i don't think that's the case with dark ages i would happily play this at two i would even happily place three just to add that bit of spiciness in and more competition for the areas um i will say as well that the game does scale um depending on the player count not only by the number of churches the number of buildings and but also the regions that are active so in a two-player game like

all of england here is shot off you can't go there um all of these parts here are shut off so the board does kind of compensate for the you know the tightness for the play account however i do think when you start injecting that fourth player in it's going to start making the game feel a bit too long and you're going to be a bit disinterested when it's other people's turns um as for considering playing this at five six seven eight players i think that's absolutely ludicrous this game is not equipped to deal with that amount of players so let's go into some final thoughts here for dark ages so first off if you are a regular kind of viewer of my content you might be aware that this was actually probably my most anticipated game this year i was so so looking forward to this one because on paper this has everything i'd want you know i love this time period it's like my favorite time period and setting out there um i love the idea of having this epic sprawling kind of conquest style game this almost 4x style game with real euro foundations and i will say it did achieve most of that i will keep hearing back to the pacing of this game it does feel like you're jumping through a lot of hoops to get very little done and i think that's going to be the lasting impression of this game unfortunately um i will say i want to make it very clear that i do not dislike this game i think it's a lot of fun um i did really enjoy my experience with this one and i'm glad i've played it however you know in order to secure a place on my shelf i'm going to have to have that incentive and that urge to keep coming back to it and am i going to have that uh to keep coming back to dark ages when you know this is

going to take three three and a half hours and i can play two other fast flowing dynamic uh really great games in that time frame um where of course time is a premium as it is so am i going to keep reaching for this game to pull it off the shelf am i going to get it back to the table i'm pretty confident that i won't so yeah unfortunately i cannot recommend this one but again i still did enjoy it that is dark ages thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time

Progress saved