Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne
Reviewers tend to agree that Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne is ambitious and handsomely produced, but that its pacing undercuts much of what it promises. The game is the Western Europe half of a two-part civilization design by Adam Kopinski and Andre Novak, published by Board and Dice. Its companion box, Holy Roman Empire, plays almost identically on a different map, and the two can be combined for larger groups. Chairman of the Board, which had listed the game among its most anticipated releases of 2021, said it achieved most of what they wanted from an epic, sprawling conquest game with Euro foundations. They still found the experience a slog, and ultimately decided they could not recommend it for their own shelf. In a September 2021 monthly ranking, the same channel placed the game near the middle of its list and described it as a Euro game with a dude on a map aesthetic.
The Dice Tower takes a harsher view. Tom Vasel revisited the original Kickstarter edition in the Look Back series, which returns to older reviews, and kept the original verdict of 5 out of 10. Vasel grouped the two boxes together as 4X designs that were never going to be combined, and judged them to be dull.
Reviewers converge on the idea that the game's depth comes at the cost of a slow start and a long session. Chairman of the Board's two reviews dwell on pacing and combat, treating the combat system as a disconnect from the rest of the design, while the Dice Tower's verdict is the most dismissive of the three.
Core Mechanics That Define Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne
Action Selection With Noble Discs and Fallout
The central engine is a disc-placement system that Chairman of the Board singled out for praise. Players choose from five actions, including maneuver, development of culture, building, research, and recruit, and each action is marked by placing a noble disc on the board. Players may take the same action as others, but the third disc to land on a stack triggers a fallout action for the disc at the bottom, drawn from the two spaces beside it. Chairman of the Board described it as "so easy to explain" and called it "a really smooth system." The fallout rule means every placement can deliver two rewards, which the reviewer valued because it keeps players engaged even when they are not the one who triggers a stack. Passing returns all discs to hand and grants a gold, a wild resource that can upgrade technologies, though it also forces players to spend or lose goods held in the warehouse.
Roll-and-Resolve Combat
Military resolution is a deliberate contrast with the rest of the design. Infantry, archery, and cavalry units fight in a fixed order, with archers firing first, cavalry charging next, and infantry resolving simultaneously. Units upgrade through levels, and each level hits on better numbers, while keeps in a city boost combat strength for adjacent regions. Chairman of the Board acknowledged that the Euro foundations are built on top of combat that is "as Ameritrash as it gets," and noted that the design is a hybrid. Dice rolls decide the outcome, so a large army can be lost in a single roll, which made the reviewer reluctant to commit forces to attacks against other players.
The Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne Experience
A Slow Squeeze on Scarce Resources
Much of the feeling of the early game comes from resource scarcity. Chairman of the Board described starting in a "straitjacket," where getting the motors running is difficult and players are "pulling teeth to get maybe one basic resource when you need it." Many actions yield little, which left the reviewer feeling that they were "walking in mud." The tension does ease as cities compound through duplicate buildings and technologies accumulate, and the reviewer said the game became "a lot more fun and a lot more dynamic" by its end. The experience is one of frustration that slowly converts into momentum, and that payoff arrives only after a long wait.
An Epic Sprawling Conquest
The other prominent feeling is scale. Chairman of the Board repeatedly described the game as an epic, sprawling conquest experience, with an almost 4X scope layered over Euro systems. Chairman of the Board praised the sense of ownership that comes from building a little empire, and noted that the components fill the table so completely that a four-player game would require a very large space. The Dice Tower offers no such praise for the scale, and its brief verdict calls the game boring.
What Makes Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne Stand Out
An Elegant Action Selection System
Reviewers consistently point to the disc system as the design's most successful element. Chairman of the Board praised how simple it is to explain and how cleanly it plays, and expressed surprise that more games have not adopted it. The system works because each placement feeds into others, so the decision to take an action is never purely isolated. Chairman of the Board also noted that the decisions interlock, with each choice affecting the next.
Multiple Routes to Victory Points
The scoring structure gives players several paths to victory. Churches award five points plus one point for each adjacent region without a church, which encourages early evangelization. Farms score points at the end of the game and increase how many troops can move at once. Title cards reward control of regions such as Aquitaine, and keeps award points based on the territory around them. Chairman of the Board described the result as a "point salad" feel, and appreciated that players are not forced into combat to score. The technology cards add further variety, with each one pushing players toward a different strategy. The production also earned praise, with the commander miniatures and city constructs described as "fantastically done" and the artwork singled out as strong.
Potential Drawbacks
A Slow Start and a Long Runtime
Length is the most repeated concern. The game takes roughly three hours, and Chairman of the Board compared it unfavorably with two shorter Euro games that could be played in the same time. The reviewer felt the design would have benefited from a quicker pace and suggested that starting players with more resources, or giving them access to resources at any time, might have helped the opening. Scalability is another issue. Chairman of the Board said the game works well at two players and could even accommodate three, but with a fourth player the game begins to feel too long and players grow disinterested during other people's turns. The reviewer considered five or more players to be ludicrous for a game of this design.
Combat That Punishes Investment
The second concern is that the investment required to build an army is out of proportion to the outcome of a single battle. Chairman of the Board said that players can spend many turns building an army and are then unwilling to risk it on one dice roll. Because losses are costly and difficult to replace, military units end up serving more as a deterrent than as an offensive tool. The reviewer also found the combat disconnected from the rest of the game, which they considered otherwise tightly coordinated.
If You Enjoy Dark Ages: Heritage of Charlemagne
Players who enjoy the sprawling 4X conquest scope that Chairman of the Board praised will find a similar sense of building a large empire in Twilight Imperium, although the reviewers covered here did not draw that comparison themselves. Players who want the same point-salad flexibility without the long runtime may prefer Holy Roman Empire, the companion box that plays almost identically on a different map and can be combined with Dark Ages for a larger, longer campaign. Players who are put off by the roll-and-resolve combat may find the game more satisfying if they focus on its scoring routes, which Chairman of the Board described as the strongest part of the design.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I will keep hearing back to the pacing of this game. It does feel like you're jumping through a lot of hoops to get very little done, and I think that's going to be the lasting impression of this game."
— Chairman of the Board
"They're 4X. Really boring. They just weren't good."
— Tom Vasel, The Dice Tower
"In my gut I thought I wasn't going to like it, and in reality it turned out I didn't like it as well. A lot of the time the investment you put into building armies just wasn't worth it when it came down to a roll of the dice."
— Chairman of the Board