Skip to main content
Loading video...

Vantage - Board Game Review

Transcript 19:07

Welcome to Allies or Enemies. I'm Jess

and I am Sean. And today we are talking about Vantage. And a couple of things before we start. First of all, this game was provided for review. And also, we're going to try and keep it as spoilerfree as possible. There are a lot of secrets here. We don't want to give them away, but we do want to show you enough that we can tell you how the game works and we can show you a bit of what's inside the box. There are, however, like thousands of cards and so many. There are four times that many. I don't even know how many things in the book and little story things. So, we're going to show you like a dozen or so. So, this is not going to give away enough that it ruins anything for you at all. Advantage is a one to six player cooperative game designed by Jamie Stagmire and it is a narrative openw world exploration game where you have come from space and landed on a strange planet and you can explore it however you want. Let's look at how it plays.

You start the game with a character card, a few skill tokens, a bunch of dice, various health tokens, a random starting location, and a random mission. And then it's time to explore. On your turn, you choose one action, either on your location card or on one of the cards in your tableau or on the mission board. All of these actions have a color which connects to one of six types of action. Move, look, engage, help, take, or overpower. After you choose your action, you or another player finds the number of the card in the matching book and reads out the bold text and the action cost. Then roll the number of black dice equal to the cost of the action. The lines are safe. Arrows go back in the pool. All the rest need to be placed somewhere, either on an available card in your tableau or on impact slots of one of your teammates.

For every dice you can't place, you decrease the corresponding health token. And if these ever reach zero, you have to read an entry in the book of secrets, and you might lose. If you survive, the rest of the text for that action is red, which will often gain cards to your tableau or tokens or boosts, which allow you to take special card actions. The point of all of this is to move around the planet exploring different cards and taking actions in an effort to try to complete your mission. If you complete your mission, you win. If you find and complete a destiny, you win. Or if you complete both, you get an epic win. Then you leave the planet ready to be explored again another day. This game surprised me cuz we've heard about it for like 8 years and I knew it was going to be an open world exploration game. So what I had pictured in my head I think was like this giant map that you're going around and you're exploring. And when I started seeing pictures of it coming out and seeing that it was really like this limited card tableau, I wasn't too sure what to expect.

Yeah, I had exactly the same thing. And now that I see it, I think of course this is the only way you could have done this. Otherwise, it would have been boxes and boxes of tons of different boards that you had to put out and it would have been it just would have been so unruly. And so this was definitely the way to do this. But yeah, I did not expect it. When I saw it, I thought this is not going to be the game I expect. It is the game I expected but just delivered in a very different way than I expected.

Yeah. And as its name suggests with Vantage that is a key part is you can only see what's in front of you at that time. So an important part is that your view is only for you and you can describe that to the other players but they can't see where you are and you can only see right in front of you. So anytime you move forward, you're replacing your card with a whole new card and you just have to kind of keep track of where you are on this strange planet.

And it's definitely difficult to keep track of things. And that makes sense. A lot of the stuff that I like are almost complaints for me. I realize, oh wait, this makes sense because I don't understand what's on this world. So of course I don't have a map to figure out what's on this world because I've never been here before. I'm seeing it for the first time. But one of the things that I've seen people complain about, I I do actually think was a really good decision choice in the game, and that is that you can only activate one action on each location that you're on. So, if you do something, sometimes it will say continue, then you can do more things on that card. But sometimes it won't, but you might learn something about that card, either from that or from something later, and you're never allowed to go back and use that again, at least not for that game. And some people say, "Well, that's not very thematic because I learned about this treasure chest. Now I can't open that treasure chest." But if you could just do things, you would just sit there, do all six things for every single card. The game would not be interesting. So sometimes it breaks the thematicness, but 99% of the time is really good for the game.

Yeah. Cuz a key part really is exploring the world. And so that pushes you to always go to new locations. And you're gonna want to do that because you're gonna have a mission that you want to accomplish. You might have a destiny you want to accomplish. And that's going to involve moving about. But I could see if it didn't have that rule that people would be tempted to do everything and then complain that it took too long to do the missions. So by making you move forward, I think that is really important. And what I really like though is how you interact in the world is totally up to you because you have those different actions on each location and the different things for the card. You can choose whether you're like laying back and like watching things seeing how danger it is or if you're just like jumping in right away.

And those are a lot different. And you can really have a different personality as you play as well because I've played games where I'm just murdering things. I'm just running. I'm just a jerk. I've landed in this planet. I'm just a maniac or like I'm stealing lots of things or I'm like praising things and I'm like giving people compliments and I'm like trying to make friends or I'm bartering with people like and you can really push those things and the game sometimes will push you in that direction because as you add to that tableau you're going to get more spaces to add your dice and a lot of those spaces are going to be specific basically all of them are going to be specific for something And often therefore kind of color. So if I end up with like five red spaces, I'm going to be super aggressive. If I end up with five yellow spaces, I'm going to have some real steely hands. So it it definitely changes your focus from game to game.

Yeah. And I like the card tableau because you can only have eight cards as well as your character card in your tableau. And I feel like that's a good amount to remember. So I like that it is capped. And those might be equipment, it might be skills, it might be abilities, but I like that amount cuz it has felt manageable. Any more than that and I probably just get overwhelmed and forget about cards, but I really like that you can just choose your own path.

Yeah, this is very much a choose your own adventure game. And I like the amount of story in this as well, cuz often times with a board game, someone thinks they're a writer, they're not a writer, and you end up with this giant chunk of text that doesn't matter cuz it's not really a linear story, and you're just like gh. This doesn't do that at all. It gives you just enough that it immerses you in the world, but not not any more than that. It's two, maybe three sentences. It's really helping push you with just like some adjectives that give you a sense of how you feel about that or what this place is and that's it. And I think that does a really good job of making it feel like it's you. It's not some other character or it's not about the writer. It's really about the player and just quickly get that text to them and then you're playing the game. You're not just listening to, you know, reading time.

Yeah. Cuz you don't need a lot of background because you wouldn't know that background. you have landed on this strange planet and it's a really interesting world that's been built. We've played like half a dozen times and I still have so many questions about this world and how it works and I like that it's this world that I want to keep exploring. So, let's talk about replayability. And really, all these sections are going to smush together in this game, I think. But the replayability, I think you probably are going to guess is there's a lot of it. There's so there's 1,700 I'm looking at it right now. 17 1,78 cards in this game that includes 82 different locations. Plus, there's other like secret cards and a little special satchet of cards. We've only got to look at one. Only I've got to look at one.

You've never got to look at one. There's also two other books that just have secret things and maps. There's tons of seven other books. So, there's a lot lot lot here to explore. And every time we've explored it, it has felt wildly different.

Yeah, it really has. I think one of the key differences is the mission. The missions really get you to do different things. Sometimes it encourages you to go out and explore and find different things. Other times you it's more commercial and you have to like get a lot of items. Sometimes you really have to work together. Other times it's more individual.

Yeah. Yeah. There they are really different. And there's another layer to that as well where there's what's the second the destinies. So you can have kind of like a super victory if you do a mission and a destiny. And so obviously combining those two together there's I don't even know how many of each. We haven't seen the same one twice. We've played like five times I think. And every time they've been very different.

Yeah. And so it's important to note this is not a campaign game, but every time you visit the world, you're learning a little bit more about it. So how you choose to engage with it might be different. And you might encounter locations. So there have been games when I found something really, really interesting and I didn't get a chance to explore it. And then a following game I was like, I want to go back and I want to find that thing. even if it maybe didn't go with my mission, that's what I wanted to do.

Let's talk a bit now about the components. And there aren't a lot of components here, so it's going to be very quick. So, first of all, card quality is great. All the cards are really, really nice. The books are all really nice.

I do like the card holders cuz I think that does a good job of showing the card that you're on. The tokens are nice and clear. And the key part really is the cards with the locations because that's your vantage. That's what you see. And I think it's really neat because it's um it's not like crystal clear, but it sets the scene. So you can tell if you're in like a meadow with one giant flower or if you're next to water or if there's like a crumbling building, but you're not seeing much more. And I think that's kind of how it would be if you were there. But

I actually really like the graphic design on the tableau cards as well. I think those look really nice.

Yeah, and it is nice and clear cuz there is a lot on your tableau cards cuz you've got the slots for the dice and usually those are restricted to certain actions. You'll also have actions that you can perform that are on those cards. And it is it can be a lot of information, but I think it was presented in a really clear way that I could tell like what's an action, what's a dice slot, what is, you know, something that might require tokens. So, I think the graphic design is nice and clear. And kind of tied into that, I do like that whenever you're doing an action, it has the color of the type of action, but the specific action has a different word. And I think that really helps with the storytelling of you're doing a green action, but it might be like you're brewing something, so you know what you're doing.

So, moving on to player count. And I think this is really going to be dependent on the kind of player that you are. It is a openw world exploration narrative game. So I could see this working really well solo because you could just land on this planet. You get to explore the whole world and engage with it however you want. Anytime you're adding more players, it is somebody else's experience as well and you get to hear about their experience. But I think it depends on how invested you are in their experience.

Yeah. I think the nice thing with two players is you have someone else reading the bits to you. So you have them going through the book, reading the thing to you. You're making the decisions. And I think that dynamic works. That's kind of the ideal dynamic by yourself. Still going to work fine. You're not going to really see other things on the page that are going to affect anything. I think it would be pretty unlikely that you see something and you remember, oh yeah, if I go to blah blah blah, that it's just it's just not going to happen. So no, I wouldn't worry about that. I think Solo is going to work great. I really didn't think that this would work in more than two. So, we had a friend ask, "Oh, yeah. Can we play this at three?" And I was like, "It's not a three-player game. I'm sorry." But then we had another friend a few days later be like, "I really want to play this at three." And I was like, "All right, fine. Let's try it." And I liked it way more than I expected to.

Yeah. And we took turns like reading the different passages. And I was interested in what both of you were seeing and what you were doing. And I think like it reminds me a lot of Dn D. So, if you play D and D and you're used to a lot of people doing side quests and you're interested in what they're doing, I think it could work for some groups at a higher player count.

But the thing that I think makes a difference for how well it works at more players as well is what that mission is. Because in that game, we had a mission that really felt like we were working as a team. In other games, we had missions that I felt like I think this might be better solo. So, the mission is going to impact how it feels as a group.

That that is true. And the other thing that makes it feel a little bit more interesting with more players as well is being able to use their dice slots. So on everyone's card tableau, if a dice slot has a lightning bolt, that means anybody can use it. And so that can be incredibly handy if someone's doing a really difficult roll and they're able to use like two or three other players dice slots for some of those dice. So, on to final thoughts. And this is first of all, this is really a storytelling kind of narrative driven game. Even though that narrative isn't a linear narrative at all, this is very much about that choose your own adventure and where am I going? And you're going to have to be invested in that story. So, you got to be the sort of person who's going to, you know, kind of put something into that because you're going to get as much out as you put in.

Yeah, definitely. So if you like the thought of being able to try and interact with a world in a different way and try and figure it out and it is a very interesting world as well. It's this alien planet and you don't know what's happening. You don't know like who's bad, who's good and you yourself could be a bad or good person. You can be a pickpocket or you could help people and so you really can interact with it in any way you see fit. And I think the mechanics are really streamlined that it still I feel like feels like a game.

Yeah, it does. This this does feel like a game. And I like that it's got the missions and I like that it's got the destiny because there have been other games like this that I felt like this is just kind of going nowhere. Like I'm just kind of flailing around in this box and sometimes it's interesting but it doesn't matter. This doesn't feel like that to me. And I'm usually not the audience for this sort of thing, but this has won me over. Also, the short story passages I think are nice. I love to read, but not when I'm playing a board game. I just want it to be nice and short, but give me enough. I think this does a really good job with that part of it as well.

Yeah. And I think it really is up to you. As you say, it's what you put into it. and even how it ends as well cuz it does say if you accomplish a mission the game could end or you can keep playing to try and do your mission or your destin and your destiny but you can be play as long as you're invested

but I will bring up a few things that I think some folks could see as negative. So one of those is that play time. We have definitely had games that I've felt like have gone on I'm just like I don't know how I'm going to do this cuz it can feel a little random how you get to things and if the mission is a little specific you need to get to of this thing and you just you don't know where that thing is in the world that can feel like oh this keeps going and I'm not the sort of person who can just be like enough I'm going to stop I really need there to be a set like mechanical reason why I've stopped this game so that could be a tricky for Some folks also there's maps in here that kind of show you where you're going. I cannot make heads of tails with those maps. That could be me, but I really have trouble being pinpointing where I am in the world.

Yeah. Whereas I have been able to use those maps pretty successfully. But what I have found tricky is keeping track of where I am. And so you are able to keep a notebook. So if you want you can like record the directions you're going. That's not really how we play. But there have been instances that I have ended up back on a card that I've already seen and I didn't mean to be there and then I'm like, "Oh, shoot. What direction do I go so that I'm not retracing my steps for like multiple cards?" And so that can be a bit tricky. I guess it's thematic cuz if you're exploring an alien planet, you could get lost and end up back where you started.

Yeah, it does kind of count on you just remembering where you've already been as well so that you don't do other things on that card. And if you don't have a great short-term memory, just know that maybe you're going to want to jot things down that might be helpful.

But even with us ending up kind of back on certain cards and not being too sure, it's been a really engaging experience and a really interesting world and it has felt like I'm an explorer and I'm I'm exploring this brand new alien environment.

And that is it. Have you played Vantage? What did you think? What are other narrative driven games that you have enjoyed?

Thank you so much for watching. As usual, please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.

Progress saved