Skip to main content
Loading video...

Allegory Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 14:03

hey everybody today i'm taking a look at allegory which is a two to six player card game designed by zack weissman and published by kalipa games this one takes 30 to 50 minutes to play so allegory is a card driven bidding game where you're trying to get as many points as you can by collecting these cards so the setup at the beginning is going to look like this we've got a number of cards in the center of the table ready to be bid on um and the number of cards is going to depend on the player count you've got a deck of cards here which again is going to scale based on a player count and each player is going to be given a bunch of these tokens or these like poker chips and you're going to get a pass token and you're going to get a secret card here which is going to incentivize you to collect a particular type so these would normally be face down but just for example sake i put them face up so we know that this play here is looking for these particular cards and this player here is looking for these particular cards so as i said the idea is to get as many points as you can in this game and the game is going to end once a player has collected 10 of these cards however the scoring in this game is a little bit different than your average game because out of the three different suits of cards in the games you've got these sun ones these wing ones and these are these greeny ones here out of your the cards you collect only the lowest value of the of your lowest set is going to be your final score so if i had say seven points in this this one here five points in this one here and two points in this one here i'm only going to score two points because it's my lowest um however there are additional ways you can collect points one is based on your secret card here so for every one of these cards i collect i'm going

to get a bonus point so i might be looking for this one here and also for each identical set of three of these symbols you're going to get a bonus two points so there's quite a few things you're looking for so let's talk about how the game actually plays so first off the starting player is going to put out a starting bid and should they want to using these tokens so let's just say for example say go this play puts out four of these tokens uh in the center of the table showing that's their bid they're not going to show which particular card they're after but they will be showing how many tokens they've bid and then it'll go to the next player which can either choose to raise that bid or pass so let's just say this player um bids five tokens like so and then it'll go to the next player and they can either again choose to raise the bid or they can choose to pass so let's just say this player passed they're going to move their token into the center of the table like so then to go back to this player as well again are they going to raise the five or are they not let's just say they pass and then they're going to take all their tokens back that they bid back into their supply and then this player being the last man standing is going to get first dibs on the card that they want so let's just say um he really wanted this um this card here to start off this this set so they're gonna put that card in front of them in their scoring tableau and then the other one empty slot is going to be replaced with a new card from the top of the deck so that's all pretty standard fare but the thing that makes this game different is what happens next so out of the um out of all the tokens they've just used to have that successful bid they're going to choose to divide those tokens amongst the existing cards so they can go like this for example and any way they see

fit so they might put they can split they can put like no two on one or they can put them all on one single card like so however they wish so let's just um do this just for an example and then again we're going to start with a new round starting with the player from the left of the winning player you're going to take your passing tokens back and then you're going to start again so is this player going to start a new bid or the new option they have is when they pass again if they put the token in the center they can take the card with the most tokens on it or the joint most so for a free bed or free action they can choose to pass and then take this card and put it in front of them for their scoring and take any tokens as well on the back of that and of course replenish the cards in the middle now as you can see here now some cards have minus or negative points on them which of course you don't really want to get but sometimes you can afford to take them if you are really running away with a certain color and of course the negative cards generally tend to build up these tokens so as i said the game is going to keep keep continuing going round and round and round either passing and taking cards with tokens on them all winning the bids in the first place and dividing out the tokens so play is going to continue until one player has 10 cards they've taken and then scoring of course is going to be calculated so let's just use this some example um to explain scoring so as you can see here these winged cards i've got a total of four five six take away two for four uh this one here i've got four five six seven eight nine this one here i've got four five six down to a three um so

and as you can see as a total my lowest of the three different types is this one here with three so therefore my points for my cards are going to be three points and then i'm gonna look at the matching symbols so i've got i got three identical hammers here to take my score up to five and i've also got three umbrellas here to take my score up to seven and then i'm going to have a look at my um and my hidden role card here for service it with seven eight nine ten uh ten points in total for my final score and that's how the score's gonna be calculated and of course the play with the most points is going to be the winner so let's um talk about how i feel about allegory so if you're a regular viewer of my content you're probably aware that auction and bidding games are really my jam i tend to really enjoy this genre and i think it's a timeless mechanism a lot of things that happens in allegory is pretty standard fare there's not a tremendous amount of uniqueness about it but the one thing that does really make it unique and um is a mechanism that i haven't seen before at all is the way that when you win an auction the um the tip the tokens that you've used are divided amongst the cards um available and i think that's a really cool mechanism and you can use it to incentivize people to take cards that you that you would want them to take and not take the cards that you're looking for yourself and i also kind of like this um this classic canadian scoring where you know you're collecting different suits and only your lowest suits is your score and that's been done in a lot of games and i think it's just a great idea of you know spinning the plates and trying to make sure that you focus on a diverse strategy and fight divers on different things rather than just being tunnel visioned and focusing on a single color

so you really do have to keep your you know keep all your cards as balanced as possible because yeah you can have as many greens as you want and have a total of 50 if you wanted to but of course um if you're only got one yellow card then your score is going to be one so it's a really cool um a cool clean scoring mechanism that makes um i think it just makes some really interesting decisions and it really does wrap up the tension of being desperate to claim a certain type if you're just not competing with that particular color and the additional ways of scoring are okay you know you do of course get bonus points for having um you know these little symbols as well and you've got your bonus roll too um just to add a little bit more option and give you a bit more flexibility to go for different things so yeah i really do like the um i like that canadian scoring it does work well here and i suppose the yeah the biggest thing is the way those tokens are divided and that can create some pretty interesting decisions i think the flow of allegory is quite strange because it does almost feel like when you want a particular card you know you're really um kind of incentivized to take the one that you need you're going to end up bidding quite a lot of tokens to take it and um you know 15 tokens does sound like you've got a lot to start with but you do quickly run out of them and particularly if you win a couple of auctions on a in a row um and it does kind of have that stop start momentum you know you feel flush with coins and then all of a sudden you feel like you're bankrupt and then you flush again because you pass and take the uh the biggest card so it does have a bit of a start and stop momentum thing about it but i suppose that's that's no issue with the game at all but it is just um something that you do have to consider because you do want to have that flexibility to keep bidding on cards and keep the

income of your scoring going um but i'll take at the same time not be taking too many cards even though they might be good because again as soon as you get that 10th card down then that's going to trigger the end of the game and that can leave you in quite a desperate situation if you've taken too many cards and neglected one of your particular columns so um yeah the flow of the game is quite strange and it's although it flows well in terms of just you know just bidding or passing and then replenishing cards um you do have to consider about how you're going to pace yourself and knowing when to go for that kill an observation about allegory which i would not say is a negative is the fact that this is a low scoring game it does feel like you're working pretty hard to get very few points out of it and because of course there are you're only scoring for your lowest one but there are a lot of negative cards amongst the deck you know there's minus ones and minus twos and it does feel like you're constantly just building up and then taking them back down and building up and taking them but back down it's it's a strange one you do feel like you're working very hard for the few points you get and you know if you're getting you know five to ten points in this game you're probably doing quite well which does feel a bit different to a lot of the games that come out nowadays which normally do shower you in points and make you feel like you're having more satisfying bigger turns but i suppose that's again it's not a bad thing it's just something you need to kind of um understand that you know you're not gonna have a bunch of points you're not gonna be flush and counting up you know dozens and dozens of points when you end the game it really is a game of small games and i mean getting any single points card to boost up your lowest one is um is very valuable

and i suppose that ties hand in hand with the fact that this game does feel like it ends quite abruptly you know as soon as someone gets that 10th card it's going to be the end of the game and you feel like you've just really started to get going so it's quite a strange one where you feel like it's almost too short and you don't get enough cards to build up in front of you but again i don't think that's a negative thing it's just something that felt a little bit weird and a bit wonky for me when i started playing this one but of course now i'm more experienced with it it does feel like it fits the game quite well but yeah when i when i initially played this one for the first few times it did feel like it ended too quickly and i didn't get enough chance to acquire the cards because even though you're not you know even if you're not winning bids and you want to pace yourself the other players might be grabbing cards a lot quicker than you and it doesn't matter how many cards i have if they take their 10th card that's going to be the end of it the time investment of allegory is pretty damn good i mean this does say on the box it takes 30 to 50 minutes i would argue that it's a bit quicker than that it does scale from two to six players which is going to impact the um of course the length of the game you know if there's six players there's going to be six cards in the middle which is going to be a lot more uh paralyzed and have a lot more thought in your decisions where in the three-player game it's going to be a bit more concise um however it does scale well at all the player counts and the flow of the play is good it's pretty snappy you know just raising your beard or passing and taking the card with the um you know with the most chips on them so it doesn't really have much scope for analysis paralysis and you are just bidding and not bidding on particular cars it does flow pretty well uh the player interaction of course

is um is meaningful because you know you don't want to leave tokens to really help play you know even though you're you might be putting on tokens on cards that you that you want for yourself you've got to be careful that you know other people are going to have their turn before you take yours so they're probably going to take the card that you put the most tokens on so generally um as a rule you want to be putting tokens on negative cards but again at the same time people might be i'll have a lows on the um of a certain suit so if i had you know i've got um you know nine points here on my yellow i can really afford to take a negative yellow cards and just take the tokens on them so but at the same time that's going to contribute to one of my 10 cards so it really is a balancing act and it does have some pretty good interaction here and you've got to not only consider about what you're doing but what you're leaving your opponent as well and the components and artwork of this of this game are pretty good i like these these bidding tokens they're nice and um you know they're nice and robust the actual cards themselves are of a reasonably good stock and the artwork on them i think fits the game quite well it does have this kind of um fairy tale style artwork it's almost like tarot tarot card style artwork it looks quite cool you know they're double ended like playing cards and i do like the vibe of the game it does feel quite different it's quite got quite unique art style which i think fits pretty well um and the setup and teardown time is lightning fast you just give each player um their 15 tokens just set up the cards in the center and give each player one of those bonus rolls all these hidden hidden um hidden scoring cards and you're pretty

much good to go so this isn't going to be a game that's going to be difficult to get to the table or to put back in the box so overall i think that allegory is a pretty solid game so of course i generally i like um bidding and auction games anyway and set collection games and this one just has enough going on to keep it interesting particularly with the way you distribute those winning bids amongst the other cards add a little bit more um thought space there and of course spinning the plates of your scoring and only scoring your lowest is always an interesting um idea and a way to implement interesting scoring so i do like that um i suppose the one thing that works against allegory is the fact that this is competing in the same kind of space as a lot of amazing designs and amazing card driven auction games you know games like for sale games like um high society you know is this one as good as those classics i don't think it is to be honest however despite that i think there's just enough going on here to make it unique enough to make sure it hit this hits the table it does break through every now and then so i do think it's just different enough to um to maybe warrant having all of them but i i do think it's not as strong as those other kind of aforementioned games but still a solid design one that i'd happily played it's pretty quick yes it is a game of small games you do have to um you know be careful how you pace yourself and kind of be cognizant of the fact that you're not going to score many points anyway but still it's fun it scales pretty well pretty fast and it's just a solid all round games that is allegory thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least

somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time

Progress saved