Expanding Ahoy - Four new releases from Leder Games - TCbH Review
Transcript
Yahar, excuse me, excuse me. Uh, Yahar, good day. A Hoy is a delightful curiosity, an asymmetric battler that is overshadowed by the overwhelming success of its older brother, Root. Well, not quite as asymmetric, quite as intricate, quite as mamalian. It's leaner. It's poppier. It gets into some funkier board states. Not to mention, it manages to have a better, albeit still limited out of the box two-player experience. But if you're here, chances are that you already know this. So, we're here to talk about expansions. A leader has for us four new Ohoy boxes. So, let's get cracking. Get it cracking. Now, if you're like me, the first thing on your mind with a game like this is new factions. And two of the new boxes focus on just that. Rivals and Renegades introduces the Blackfish Brigade and Shellfire Rebellion, functioning similar in purpose, military contention, and region control to the Blue Fins and Mollisk Union. Whereas Fang and Fortune offers the Leviathan and Coralcat pirates that can be used interchangeably with smugglers in three and four players, acting as greater deviation from the base game counterparts, but fulfilling the same broader purpose of gumming up the works of the more militant factions, increasing values of regions they act within, and adding another lane of pressure through non-controlbased point accumulation. The
least game-changing, but no less welcome of the four new releases, is the upgrade pack, including really beautiful screen printed tokens for the base factions, which are more in line with the details on the new factions along with maybe the heftiest gold coins this side of the seven seas. Like seriously, when you think chunky, these are more like Chono 3000. And then there's the treasure pack, which is a super easy to integrate set of cards that you draw two and pick one at the beginning of the game to just give your faction a little zest, a little pepper. Aside from two that can't be used by the Leviathan, which are clearly marked, they're fully compatible with all factions. And it's kind of bonkers in a game with a bunch of asymmetry how easy implemented these are. Some have extra components like the ghostly gang which gives you an extra die during your first turn each round but damages the action used to the jar of land and sea to add or remove sand bars from the board. Others from the deck of fate to bountiful booty just modify existing rules. This is nice slightly wacky but given the intended weight of the game they work well to spice things up. I wouldn't break them out with noobs but fully intend on using them otherwise.
Okay, so let's talk factions. Broadly speaking, Ahoy remains an odd duck in that regard. Even more so than Root, it relies on specific factions being involved to add the right kind of tension in order for the game to not just wholly collapse. With Root's introduction of new factions, eventually, as long as you have the right reach, you could mix and match to your heart's content. A Hoy on the other hand takes a different approach which I'm going to be honest I don't love but I get super respect in that unless you are playing the 2v2 team mode you are always required to have exactly one blue faction and one yellow faction. And then in games with higher player counts, the Leviathan, Cortal, Cat, Pirates, and Smugglers can be swapped around interchangeably. It gives the game a somewhat rigid feel, especially if you're predominant gaming is done with two players, but it does go ways to explain why these new factions were separated into two different boxes released at the same time. And it shows a degree of commitment, maybe a lack of compromise to really be the game that the team wants it to be rather than softening the edges so that it can appeal to a broader range of play groups. Once you're past that though,
the factions, they're really cool. The Blackfish Brigade makes me happy. Yes, cuz I'm Alaskan and they're orcas, but also because their whale pod token is absolutely the coolest. Unlike the blue fins, they don't have strongholds, but what they lack in fortifications they make up for in deployment. Their actions build up basic and more powerful veteran patrols on the pod board, which then can be deployed in corresponding orientation as it migrates. and their surge action to Mass Effect style Vanguard rush their narwhal ship in a straight line to one of their patrols, destroying any and all comrades between gives them a little bit of a positional puzzle to work with and is so cool when you pull it off. Speaking of which, the Shellfire Rebellion adds a more logistical layer to the Yellow Faction with your main way of getting comrades onto islands being to launch them in a straight line at the end of turns. Though, they have to be loaded into your catapult ships first.
Like the Mollisks, they have a slow start, but grow in power as they go through tricky cards they draw into, though they lack the same versatility and specialty ships of their shellfish cousins. The Leviathan is the most cinematic Ahoy faction, period. Slinking across the board, potentially with multiple heads, it's the most versatile and potentially challenging faction to play. Rounds start with an appetite card outlining your potential interests and cards from the market you can consume from corresponding islands for listed rewards, often increasing the value of the region. These can give you more tokens in the supply, increasing your movement and combat capabilities, and let you access more game-changing evolutions, all in service of getting points at the end of each round for your largest chain of heads and bodies. Of note, the Leviathan is the only faction to not have cannons or an analog. Though they gain great rewards from winning battles, always add their fang numbers to their role and can strike battling a distance based on the dice used, which creates an interesting challenge when choosing how to prey on your opponents.
Lastly are the Coral Cap Pirates, who are just kind of a mess, but in the best sort of way. Again, a significantly more flexible and complex faction. They send their flagship to islands and recruit crew to make corresponding frig which all have their own powers and each are trying to move about the board to go to specified islands which in turn fill their job slots making their powers become more lucrative and adding point tokens to count at the end of the game. Of all the new factions, these are inherently the least combative, though they still hold their own and can even profit some points for some mercenary work here and there. These are super rad, though the hardest to get a beat on how much you should interfere with their operations. As an aquatic Tom Waits might ask, what are they building over there? Okay, so lots of new Ahoy. And I'm a Okay, so lots of new Aahoy. And I'm an Ahoy boy, so that makes me really happy. But Ahoy remains the difficult game to recommend. I like playing it at two, but it really doesn't truly shine and come into its own until you get to at least three players. And it remains as quirky as it is strategic with those game states from holes in the center of the ocean to weird value distribution.
And how to take advantage of those is a big part of the appeal. But if that does appeal to you, then these new expansions are really going to be up your alley. As a fan, I kind of wish that all the new stuff came in one box, particularly one big enough to hold all of my Ahoy without sacrificing the convenience of the original insert. And while it's not so egregious that it's out of control, the new factions, particularly the Coralcat Pirates and the Leviathan, are a substantial amount of complexity above the pre-existing factions. not imbalanced, at least not so far as players can't tune that themselves by making sure that they're cognizant of who's in the lead, who's doing what. I'm just saying that anyone playing senior snackman is going to have a good deal more considerations on their turn than a working class blue fin. But they are all so cool, all four of them. And I just want to play them to mix them and match them. I feel at home in Ahoy and they really embrace the spirit of the game but add a layer of creativity which makes the game have more interesting weird game states which is a big part of the appeal and it somehow in retrospect makes the smugglers feel even more distinct and given that there's just less investment needed to get a hoy to the table while still leaning into a
heavy dose of asymmetry especially now with albeit a bit limited mix and match nature of the factions and adding in the treasure pack which heck even spices up two-player games. A hoy is starting to rival my passionate love for root. And that's our review. But let me know what is your favorite faction to play in a hoy and what is your favorite highly ate symmetric game? Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such an awesome community.