Skip to main content
Loading video...

Don't Buy Lord of Loot Until You Watch This! (board game review)

Transcript 10:17

If the words loot goblin, handpainted minis, and punch a volcano in the face make your heart beat like frosted dice in a dice tower, you're about to love this. Welcome to Board Game Critique. I'm Eve, that voice in your head that says, "Draw from the red bag, you coward." And I'm Adam, your friendly neighborhood dice brick layer, because apparently I build walls out of blank rolls. Today we're reviewing Lord of Loot, a fantasy co-op where the guards are too busy napping to help, so you and your friends do all the heavy lifting.

Quick disclosure before we get spicy. We got a prototype to test from a friend. Shout out to Brian whose bags are tragically small and whose cat tried to steal our beard. We played multiple times at three and four players. And we're going to be very honest. This video may hurt feelings. If it's bad, we'll say so. No sugar coating. Kickstarter stats for the number nerds. It's already smashed past 106K on a target of $11,625 with plenty of days left. 1 to five players 60 to 90 minutes from PKB Games, the folks behind Trench Club and Aces and Armor. But you're not here for hype. You're here to find out if this deserves a spot on your shelf.

What is it? It's a co-op RPG light modular map, cloth loot bags. You level from wooden scrub to gold weapon legend, and you fight two bosses, each with a puzzly quest you have to solve before you can actually hurt them. And yes, the guards literally snooze while we sprint around doing side quests like medieval Uber Eats.

We'll talk mechanics, but we're not here to do a full tutorial. If you want to teach, check the link in the description. This is about buy or skip. So, core loop, every turn starts with hunger. If you're in a blue circle building, tavern blacksmith, you get fed. Otherwise, eat a food token or lose a heart. Brown stamina hearts first, then red injury hearts. It's clean and surprisingly thematic. You feel that pressure to plan routes.

Then you get four actions. Move, explore, exploit, collect items, trade, fight, repeat any of them. I love that you can just sprint four spaces if you want or exploit a tile four times like a goblin at a buffet. The wormkin character gets five actions. She's basically the board's parkour champion. After you act, the monster phase happens. Draw a card. Bosses lurch toward the nearest hero. Monsters swarm. Day night shifts spawn fields. And you roll a d12 to decide which flavor of pain pops out. Goblins, orcs, trolls, ghosts, vampires, skeletons.

With four to five players, monsters only activate every other turn, tracked with a flip token, which keeps it moving. Combat is dice chucking candy. Orange dice for attack, blue for defense, violet for monsters. Weapons give you different dice against different creature types. My wooden club was heroic against green hordes, goblins, and orcs, but did absolutely nothing against purple magic creatures, so you actually care about what's in your hand when the monster face hits. Potions and spells let you add sword or shield icons after you see the roll. Those clutch moments matter. In one boss fight, I rolled three blanks. Classic Atom, then slapped a spell for two shields to avoid getting KO'ed by Volcanis. We still lost that session, but I died later and more dramatically.

Progressions the dopamine engine. Beat enemies above your level to level up. Wood to iron to gold weapons. You feel the power curve. There was a run where I went from scraping by with a fish and a stick, real items, to demolishing a troll with a frostedged gold sword rolling three orange dice plus bonuses. I actually pumped my fist and woke the cat. Backpack Tetris deserves its own standing ovation. Dual layered boards, cutout backpacks, and you literally need your stuff to fit. No abstract I carry 10 items nonsense. We had a full-blown sitcom moment of me trying to fit a massive gold sword, three potions, a fish, and a coin. I traded Eve the fish just to squeeze in a fire item to herd the doggy for the petnapper quest.

Speaking of quests, bosses are invincible until you solve their thing. The petnapper made us return three pets. The chubby cat was chill. You just carry it. And the beard followed food, but the doggy hurting with fire or fighting it toward Rascal. Adam kept trying to shepherd it with a torch while goblins ignored him like he owed them money.

Draarax, the horde accountant dragon, was my nemesis. You have to drop five precious objects at his home base. He belines toward whoever's chunked with bling. I had three coins and a gold weapon, and he chased me like I was a walking receipt. Eve was screaming, "Drop the cash." while I tried to squeeze past a vampire and rolled two blanks. Gravestone marker time.

And Stumplestick walking tree with anger issues. You can't damage him if you're holding any wooden items. Adam showed up with half a forest in his backpack and wondered why he was tickling the boss for zero. We literally paused to purge his lumber inventory on a tavern floor like a yard sale.

Volcanis is a speed check. Defeat four gnomes before they reach the volcano tile or instant loss. Our four player run had two of us on gome duty, two managing the map and upgrades. It forced coordination without letting anyone quarterback. You handle your four actions and it's fast enough that no one micromanages.

Okay, let's hit components. Dual layered boards. Great chunky standees for monsters and bosses. Colorful and table friendly, even if they're not miniatures. Our friend's prototype had a frayed matte edge, so production quality is something we're watching. Cloth bags fun, but one was small enough that our big-handed buddy could barely rummage. Please fix bag size.

Dice are fine in the base. Frosted dice in the deluxe look nicer. Hand painted minis in the deluxe tier. That's a legit upgrade. And there's a Kickstarter exclusive dice tower plus two exclusive end bosses. We didn't have those exclusives to test, but mathematically speaking, more bosses equals more replay.

Pledge tiers quickly. Base is €39. 1 to four players, decent value. Fifth player at 55 if you must go five, but we found three to four is the sweet spot anyway. The All-In Deluxe at €69 is our recommendation if you care about table presence and replay. The handpainted minis and exclusive bosses sell it. It's a $50 savings versus MSRP.

Pros from our plays. One, the power fantasy lands hard. You feel stronger, your dice pools grow, and it's tactile. Two, boss quest variety actually changes the game. Pet coraling versus gold hoarding versus wood purging pushes different strategies. Three, quick turns, almost no downtime, even with four of us. Four, the communication is natural. Trading items, splitting duties without anyone turning into captain back seat.

Five, scalable difficulty. Boss picks matter, and that advanced rule adding imps to occupied spawn fields ramps pressure nicely. Six, loot bags are fun. That 5-second draw timer is hilarious chaos. I literally yelled fish once and it turned out to matter two turns later. The game invites those moments. Cons, and pay attention because this might be a dealbreaker for some of you. One, dice luck can be brutal. If your group hates variants, skip. My cold streak during Draarax made the whole table grown. Yes, spells and potions mitigate, but RNG is the co-designer. Two, the midame farming can drag. At 90 minutes, the middle third sometimes felt like we were grinding gear, waiting for quests to unlock. Three, monster AI is basic. Move to nearest hero. Smack. It's fine for families. It's not solving puzzles for hardcore co-op fans. Four. Setup and tearown. Lots of tokens. Lots of sorting. First play. We spent 10 minutes finding the right bags. Five. Player count sweet spot is narrow. Solo loses that fun trading puzzle. Five can become does the monster phase trigger now?

Brain fog. Three or four. Absolutely sings.

Six. Prototype component concerns. We saw minor fraying. Bag size was too small. Not catastrophic, but we want updates from PKB about production improvements. That said, their track record for fulfillment is solid. And two campaigns delivered early, so confidence is decent.

Stories that sold us. The time Adam dropped coins to bait Draarax and instead got pinned between a troll and a vampire. He drank a potion, rolled two swords, blocked one with a blue dye, survived with a single red heart, and we squeaked the win after completing the quest. That sequence was tense, loud, and unforgettable.

And the go sprint, we split the board diagonally. Eve took Wormkin and parcled across three tiles in one turn. Five actions, baby. explored, exploited, snagged a fire item from the red bag and intercepted the fourth gnome one space pre volcano. We high-fived so hard the stand fell over. That's the kind of tempo the game rewards.

So, who should buy? Families and casual co-op groups who enjoy dice chucking but want decisions to matter. If you love loot progression, backpack Tetris, and puzzly quests, this hits the sweet spot between Chronicles of Aval and heavier dungeon crawls. Who should skip? Dice haters, narrative purists, and players wanting deep AI or Euro level crunch. If you crave Spirit Island style planning or Gloom Haven's card tactics, Lord of Loot will feel light. And if 90 minutes sounds long for this weight, you'll notice the Midgame sag.

Progress saved