Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ra - Board Game Review - Too Much Wood To Handle

Transcript 17:52

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.com many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audio is over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so on today's quick Tour episode we're taking a look at Ron this is going back to this hole I'm trying to play the classics you know the classics that I've missed out on trying to get these to the table and see whether the cult of the old can still measure up to the cold of the new which to be fair a lot of them still can I've played a few older games lately and I'm like yeah these still hold up over time this is going back quite a bit though this is 1999 when this first this is the new 25th Century uh revised Edition in O'Toole's artwork and all the you know the extra wood and believe me we'll get into that in a minute but you know this one is now a new refurbished copy and thanks to kinder for the review copy this one is enabling me to you know finally test out if this is any good now

auction games are not my favorite genre I will stipulate this I like quick bidding auction games so biblios and high society and stuff like that I enjoy those auction games stuff like power grid though I'd like to see burn in the seventh layer of hell wow that was pretty brutal even by my standards it can go to drawn out auctions and be really dull boring and those ones I don't like I like quick Snappy auctions and this one at least has those but you know is that enough I mean it's just a straight up auction game is there enough in this game to keep me entertained and to keep others entertained well let's find out so ra as I mentioned a straight up auction game and yes we'll get on to the components um eventually yeah just a big giant bag here but essentially what happens is you have an auction board so auction board in the middle and what you do is you take it in terms to draw tiles out of this bag and there's a ton of these tiles loads of different types loads of different effects but you're essentially drawing them out and you're placing them below this board to represent kind of like what people are gunning for now voluntarily people can ask to invoke ra which means that they start an auction for what tiles are there or you might draw a red tile out of here that does it automatically how you bid though is with these sun disk tokens so these sun disk tokens have got different values from 1 to 13 and the idea is that you only have three on your board well three or four depending on the pay account on your board and around and so what you do is

that you effectively bid with these so they're fixed value and you can see what everybody else has so you know that there's a chance that other people might outbid you but it's like well they won't they for what's out there but in addition one of these discs will be on the board itself so when you have made your bid for example let's say I win this auction with a five I exchange that with the disc class there and put this face down on my board I won't be able to use it until next round but now I've got a 12 when I gave up a five so that's like a 7 boost in currency effectively there's a little timer for this marker where if you draw red tiles at the bag this moves the lawn and could end the round prematurely but otherwise it's when people have used up all their Sun disks once that's all said and done you essentially have three rounds of scoring where the tiles go on each side of this raw board and depending what tile it is it scores in different ways so gold is straight up Point uh gold tiles which you can spend to take things in the auction trial are two points each water is a point each providing you get a flood tile to go with it civilization tiles you need different ones but if you don't get any you lose five points uh Pharaoh tiles Whoever has the most Whoever has the least uh you know monuments gets sets diversity or get more of the same you know there's various stuff like that you've seen in every other game and at the very end there's also a kind of like a sushi go dessert menu type thing where you add up all your remaining Sun disks and whoever has the highest gets points Whoever has the lowest losers points I like that mechanic and it's quite cool because it gives you a reason to care about these in the final round when otherwise you wouldn't so that's kind of like a general gist of the game there's not a huge amount to it you get you tote like

the victory points at the end and see who wins so when we first talk about the component side because yeah holy freaking guy holy God of RA this is an insane production here I mean the board's already you know chunky and good quality these Sun discs are thick wood I mean I'm only holding six of them there and you can see how much space they take up in my between my two fingers here these are chunky easy to read easy clear I love these these are a good thing to have as the currency but if you thought that was ridiculous oh my God I mean this sun marker is already pretty thick in terms of its wood component right what the hell is this ridiculous Suits You incredible it's not too far off being thicker than my own arm it's kind of ridiculous do you think maybe he's compensating for something this is a massive well oversized I've never seen so much wood on a component before it's insane and yes when you play this game the amount of wood jokes that are going to come through when grabbing this piece and say grab me grab me the piece of I mean trust me they're gonna happen you know depending on how immature your group is wood jokes are gonna come up plenty here but then oh my God this giant back this is stuffed with tiles so that's a smooth selection of what's in

there there's a ton more where that came from and these are all thick chunky they've got you know standard artwork on them and oh my God this reduction is insane now there is a downside to this it doesn't fit in the Box very easily you've got to really be good at the tetrising to get it in there you got to get your boards in a particular line you've got to stack your um you know pieces next to each other the wood pieces next to each other fold up the board and then the annoying thing is that with this bag you have to put all the tiles back in the bag and then you have to kind of lay it out on top leave it open so occasionally if you slip out but then while doing that you have to kind of flatten it on top so that the lid just goes on it's not easy it's not always foolproof and it's just annoying that they couldn't have just made the Box a tiny bit taller to accommodate the bag easier or maybe just scale down the production slightly so it wouldn't have this problem the rules are very simple to learn as well I mean you literally only have this very thin you know linen finished rule book which doesn't have a lot of pain pages in it it's got pictorial examples as well as a bit of text but then it's also got a very good quick reference on the back this is a good little flow chart to say the free actions you can do and you know which route you go down depending whether the auction track is full or whether you drew a red tile or in boat dry yourself it's very easy to literally remember all the rules of this game pretty much by that yeah really straightforward but then you obviously need to know how all the like the tiles score great just go to this double page spread and you'll find them faith in that read your board

because as much as I don't go Google gaga every time you know tool it you know puts his artwork on stuff because email tools artwork is I love this functionality of his of his designs he's fantastic at graphic design he makes things clear as day to read does a great job with the vtown asserters I don't look at games that he illustrates though and call them beautiful though he's not a thing he's not about art and Beauty he's about function and design and for that this works this board tells you everything you need to know about how the things score and it's really easy to read it tells you everything you would could possibly know no FAQ moment should come from this other than possibly what happens with tie Breakers but other than that clear as a day the rules to this are not complicated it is an easy game great and it goes from two to five was it two to five or is it three but yeah two to five players although honestly this isn't a game I would want to play with too and even with three I'm a little bit hesitant four or five seems to be a better way of doing this because with two or three not enough tiles really come out of the bag you know they come out and you'll get a few auctions but because there's a lot of these red tiles in here in fact I dare say there's probably too many of these red tiles in here that trigger the auctions I find that with two players there's just not enough really going on overall three players is not too bad but again I feel like more tiles should come out four and five seems to to fix that problem and the game will scale for player count so you will have I think three discs if you're using like too many players and four discs if you've got less maybe even

five or two is it is it five or two let me check uh no four four three three so yeah it does go down as you scale up the players but I find this one's a bit more entertaining with more players but it does scale reasonably well I don't think it's broken at any particular Play account but having more players especially with the auctions I think is a bit more interesting there are some gameplay elements though that do get a little bit annoying quite quickly though I mean you know the tile's drawn out great but drawing out a red tile and starting out an auction is not fun if you're the player who keeps drawing them you know I've had players where they've drawn three times in a row they've drawn these out and it's not fun for them to basically not contribute to the auction track and just simply start off an auction where there's only one or two pieces out there they feel like they're not doing anything constructive in the game and it has diminished the enjoyment for some people I've noticed in games because they just draw the these red tiles all the time but the other thing that's annoying is that as much as this bag is great you've got to pass this to players before they take their turn so I go right I'll draw a tile there it goes past the bag there you do it pass the bag they do it pass the bag they do it this gets very annoying having to pass this bag around constantly it's like hang on you take it right draw a card your hands that's like a baby's toy now you could just say let somebody do it for you fine and honestly that might be the best way to do it but the problem is this also dictates whose turn it is if you have one person holding the bag you don't have a way to track Turn order and

you quickly forget whose turn it is this just gets really annoying playing this past the bomb thing around everyone constantly bearing in mind that these turns are fast the auctions don't take long to resolve which is great but your turn is either draw a tile invoke an auction or use a god tile most people won't even have a god tile so that's out you're not always going to be triggering an auction so that's only part of your return so really mainly you're drawing tiles out in the bag and it's just constant passing around of this wretched bag and that gets really annoying really fast it's one of those irks during the game especially like if you're getting nearer to the end of the ocean it's like oh you just draw something all right all right join another red one right okay let's do this one all right yeah I just wish there was an easier way to dispense the tiles but there's a lot of them I don't quite see how you would do it just accept it the gameplay itself though is good fun I particularly like the way that the sun disk currency is used because you can see what numbers you have compared to others there's an incentive to go on an auction just to get a higher disc for the next round and especially at the end of the game where you get those point scorings but it's also not so much oh I have more money and you all outbid you it's more I'm gonna go in with a low disc because if you want these tiles you're gonna have to go in the much higher distance than me and you might not want to use that higher disc so maybe I can go You by just putting in a four in front of me are you really gonna put in a nine for you know for this side of the tiles are you really gonna outbid by four and it's not just simply auction and bidding it's also an element not so much a bluffing but kind of goading but like what I said

in District Noir where you're trying to go to your opponent to draw the cards earlier than they should you're almost trying to go to players into not going against you or maybe going against you you might be like well you know if I win it I'm not too fast but if I do get you to use your big tile before we get to an auction I really really want that's another cool thing that that's a neat little system I do like the way this works I like the fact you can see the one in the middle that you're going to get so you know if you're giving up a 13 or 14 I guess they go a bit higher than 13 but well 16 even I guess it's I guess you need to play with certain player counts I forget but you know giving up a 16 for a five that's gonna hurt I mean you're gonna really want those tiles because you know that yes I could win all these but that's my 16 for a five that hurts oh that hurts and it's just another one of those cool little decisions that you make now the game is pretty heavy on the randomness Factor because you are just drawing tiles out of a bag you may draw the tiles you really want you may draw tiles that you don't want the timing of the Red Towers might happen I mean this is a you know uh you don't necessarily know when the round's gonna win but sometimes the the thing barely moves and then it goes at Rocket speed you when you least expect it so you definitely have to go into this knowing that this is a light random game game where you have some interesting decisions to make but you're not really in full control of the situation it's a case of right what am I stuck with what's the deal react to that and I do like tactical games where they do that you know the tribes of the wind and things where you can't strategize until the end you have to think well what's here now live in the moment the

now the present what do I want to do with the things I've got and so that works pretty well so Rama itself is a neat game but it's not one that I would want to play like over and over again it does the job and it gives me an interesting Dynamic but the tile variety is a little lacking I mean you know as much as there's like six different ways that you can score on this board or one two three four five six seven actually technically in the end game they are quite similar there's not a huge amount of variety in the tiles and it is mainly just set collection at the end of the day the player scaling mainly is better with more players and it is less I don't see this being a two-player game three player maybe but four and five seems to be the way to go which is fair enough you don't get many five games at work but drawing these red tiles does irk a few people like they don't feel like they're contributing by drawing these these almost feel like a wasted term when this happens um but there is a lot of good stuff to say the component quality and you know graphic design is excellent cannot fault that I do love the way that the sun disks work as the currency I think this is an ingenious way of doing you know auction currency by not having to have loads of money and have people going well hang on if he bids 24 and then I could go free higher maybe 27 or 28 I don't know that draws out auctions these at least are quick and snappy and you know pretty neat I think it's probably maybe a product of its time it does feel like a 1999 game I feel like if this was redesigned now with like a second edition with new revamped rules there would be a few tweaks to this to maybe

curb some of that Randomness or maybe just add a little bit more like variety and interesting tiles like maybe you could take out one set of tiles and replace with a different lot although I would hate to go through that bag and try and sort them out that's for certain so right overall gets a 7 out of 10 for me it's a good game and I do recommend it particularly if you're an auction fan although people are saying this is like one of the best auction games in existence I'm not seeing that I'm seeing a good auction game here but best ever I'm not quite going to that level you know it's decent it's fun there's a few things that get annoying over time whether it's passing the bag or you know the drawing of towels or having turns that feel like a waste and I'd probably rather just play some of the more quicker snappier auction games anyway I mean this is a rhino kanitzia game and auctions tend to be his thing I'd rather play High Society over this it's quicker it's snappier and it has that elimination mechanic at the end High Society I think beats out raw biblios quick bidding with the two-phase cycle of the game I'd rather play videos than this one so this one is still a neat the auction game and probably one of the better ones I've played but not quite top tier you know not quite top level 10 out of 10 best auction game ever that some people are saying and honestly as much as this has come out I haven't seen anybody really buy it and play it I'm the only person that I know in any of the groups I've got locally who has this and I've played it with multiple different people and the reaction I tend to get is either that's cool or that's a game nobody is really saying this is

amazing I love it I really want my own copy and that's gotta speaks some volumes but maybe this is the auction game for you so that's it for me on this episode of The Book of people if you like what you see then please thumbs up on YouTube but thumb enough on Board Game Geek as well when I put the video on the page obviously let me know your comments down below is this a game that you've had since 1999 do you love it is it your favorite auction game why is it what is it about this game that makes it the top tier for you let me know your thoughts obviously check out all the other content I've been doing the smorgasborder reviews I've been doing there's loads of them but we will get back to top tens very soon until next time remember regardless of how chunky you want your pieces to be there's still only a game but man that is a ladder wood see you next time

foreign

Progress saved