Skip to main content
Loading video...

Whistle Mountain Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:33

hi everyone today i'm talking about whistle mountain which is a 2020 release board game designed by scott caputo and luke laurie this one accommodates two to four players takes about 90 minutes to play and was published by bezier games now the main mechanism in this game is worker placement as you have this this main board here and you have your own little player board with your little pieces and the idea is you're trying to get as many points as you can in different ways including building to the scaffolding adding machines onto the scaffolding and sending your workers off to this um this kind of side ladder here um the game is boiled down into two pretty simple actions and i've just set up the board here just as an example it's not going to start looking like this but i thought it'd be a good way to explain how everything works so the main action of your game is going to be to collect resources where you are going to place one of your three pieces which represented by these three different hot air balloons of different sizes so you've got your large one you've got your medium-sized one and you've got your little one here now just because it's smaller doesn't necessarily mean it's worse um because it can actually manage to do things that the big ones can't do but let's uh let's show how you actually collect your resources so for example i'll use this big one here and i can place it anywhere on the board either on one of these machines which are these tiles here or next to one of these scaffoldings so for example if i place my piece here it covers up three squares and then whatever i'm touching i'm going to get those resources so in this example i'm going to get a whistle a gold and i'm going to get one of these water drops as well

now if i wanted to place it somewhere else i wanted to place it here like this then i would get a whistle a whistle and because i'm touching this machine i would also get to use the ability of that machine if i wanted to place it on the machine here like this i would not only get that ability by being able to trans transmute a tools logo into a building action but also get a whistle a point because i'm touching it and also get another whistle there so it's a little bit of a spatial puzzle and because i said you know the little ones can be a bit more flexible for example this one here could sneak into this little spot right here and get myself you know four decent actions um by simple placement you know by getting a water a gold another water and by using that machine so that's going to be how the actual placement works in terms of placing on the main board but you've also got these different actions that go around the side of the board which lets you kind of collect resources and cards and different upgrades and so on so let's talk through them so if i was to place a machine here then i would get to collect one of these these bigger machines by paying the uh the resources so for example here it's going to cost me three tools and two coal in order to do so and and i'll put this into my kind of supply ready to be placed later if i was to go here it works exactly the same but you're placing a medium-sized one so you've not got the the kind of the the big scale of the larger buildings but they only they cost fewer materials

and the small buildings there's two options to do so but the second option is a little bit more expensive uh you know if you if someone beats you to it you've also got the ability to draw cards either by drawing one for free and paying a resource to get another another card or paying two resources to get two additional cards and they do different things you know such as giving you abilities to you know convert gold into a building action or um you know convert three goals three tools into a medium machine i think if you you can use those cards as a bonus action once per turn the spot over here is one of my favorite spots where you get to upgrade your player board so you would come here and you select one of these um one of these upgrades so for example here i might choose this one by paying the resources on it so to water in this example and then i'd place it onto my player board here like so meaning that i have this ability for the rest of the game so here i would be have the ability to be able to trade in one of these scaffolding pieces in order to take a build action and i could do that once uh once per turn and and at the end of the game they'd also grant me additional points and you have the ability to build six of these upgrades and once you do so you're pretty much stuck with what you're left with uh the the final action you can take or the sort of the second last action you could take is to actually pick up scaffolding pieces and add them to your supply so you can either take one for free you can take two by paying one whistle or take three by playing two whistles and you've got three different shapes here you've got the kind of zigzag shape the the t shape and the l shape and

depending on how many pieces you've got you're again going to put them into your supply ready for use later now once you've kind of um spent your workers or your hot air balloons and you've collected an amount of goods then you can choose to do this action forge and take all your machinery back like so putting them back on their respective spaces and then you can choose to take build actions and in order to build actions you the first one you're going to get for free the second one you're going to have to pay one water and to get a third one you're going to have to pay another water additionally you can pay gold to either move these people that start on this rung here um onto somewhere on the scaffolding so let's see i do that which again i'll explain later and you can even pay two gold in order to move someone out of this whirlpool here and again place them on the scaffolding somewhere and the importance of that is because anybody left in the whirlpool at the end of the game is going to score you negative five points now something i should have said as well in your player board here is you you do have a capacity for storing resources so at any time you can only ever score at any of a store four of each resource and if you ever get more than that then it's going to be wasted so you've got to be wary of that at all times so let's um let's have a look at some additional rules about how you're going to score points by building things so when you when you start building or contributing to the scaffolds you can orientate these in any direction you

want and place them onto the board and then you're going to score a point for every edge of that tile you've just placed and what matches up to another so in this example i just got one point two points three points four points so it's additional four points that i have in my kitty at the end of the game but when i build a machine um say for example you know when i collected um let's say i collected one of these and i get to place this onto the board i would do like so placing it on somewhere where there is um you can cover up these logos if you want to and you can even cover up your player pieces and when you cover up your player pieces they're going to follow on from the row they were covered up on and get here at the end of the game to eventually get you points so the higher you get up this track the more points you're going to get and you're also going to get one of these rosettes which can give you um little bonuses throughout the game you know such as you know whistles or buildings or building actions or pure points and so on so there are a lot of different things to um to weigh up there and obviously you're trying to get as high as you can to get as many points as you can now the game is going to start coming to an end whenever you start building buildings above this bridge symbol here and whenever you build a building like i just have you are going to take this um this strip of water and you're going to lay the next one down like so covering up the bottom kind of the bottom or bottom row of of actions and if if there's ever a worker on that spot

then they're going to end up going into the whirlpool so let's say i i built another building and put that on there this this worker would end up going into the whirlpool because it's been covered up by water now naturally when you start building stuff some of the buildings that you build are going to get covered in water meaning meaning that they are now out of use and not available to use unless you have a certain technology which allows you to do so so there's this real kind of um racing of trying to get up the track as fast as you can not only to get the best kind of ascendancy bonuses here on the side but you don't want to get your workers to drown which means that they're going to cost you negative points and ultimately start costing you gold in order to get them out of the whirlpool there is an additional spot here as well which you can use to get rid of these people from the whirlpool but it's going to be a bit slower to do so and that's basically going to be how the game works until all the water is spent and then points are tied up at the end of the game based on how many buildings you've made how many you know people are in the whirlpool left the side bonuses here and and so on so that's going to be the flow of the game it's pretty simple once you get your head around it and um it's uh you know it works pretty pretty well in terms of rules mechanisms so let's talk about um how i actually feel about the game so first off i really do like this um kind of method of constructing the board and the worker placement areas as the game goes on you know each game the the the board can lay out completely differently

creating you know more spots and opportunities to collect resources different machinery comes up each game and so on so there's a real cool spatial element there not only for the building and tetris kind of style but also the the fact that your actual workers the way you collect things are of different shapes and can't physically fit in certain areas so i really do like that i think that works well you know i like the the way that the uh the scaffolding tiles fit together and you get points for matching them up i like having to build higher and higher in order to get your workers into these better spots here and i also really like the uh the use of the player boards here so it has a real nice forward motion where you get more powerful as the game goes on collecting better and better um abilities and more abilities which sometimes synergise with each other i also like the fact that you have a unique player power which you know you get a good amount in this book in this game and they're all just interesting enough to you know to to keep your interest but not overly game-changing and game breaking that you have to constantly worry about what your opponent can do better than you can but um yeah i really like that i also really like the fact that you can't um completely stockpile on resources uh you know having that capacity on your board just keeps it you know it's an extra decision to to weigh up i mean you can't just keep going to the same spots over and over again because it would be probably wasteful to do so and so on so there's quite a lot of interesting decisions here and i like the um the ongoing tension as well of having to um get your workers onto the

scaffolding and make the most of your buildings before the water starts gobbling up all these spots and ultimately making your your workers suffer negative points at the end of the game if they are still stuck in that pool so there's yeah there's quite a lot going on here for a relatively simple game and so in terms of meaningful decisions there is there is quite a lot to weigh up you know do you want the cards to get a little benefit from them you know do you want to focus on getting the upgrades early and hopefully that pays off throughout the game do you want to build higher and higher and higher and try to get to these really high spots here are you going to focus on just get collecting as much scaffolding as you can and kind of contributing to the actual scaffolding itself to get adjacency bonuses and just by matching up those polyaminos are you gonna just focus on getting these big meaty buildings that give you a lot of points um or you know or just building lots of little ones that can do you good so there is a lot to think about and all these work placement spots are valuable the the balance of the game as well i mean i think you're gonna you're gonna dip your toe in all these different fields um you know naturally you're gonna end up getting higher and higher on the scaffolding because you know if you don't start placing your workers down they're just going to drown which is quite a significant knock on points at the end of the game if you don't do anything about it but you know it's it's it's not a game where you can completely deep dive into a certain path or anything like that that it really is a a kind of a wider game where you just have to do everything really um in terms of the time investment the game plays you know in in that time stamp it advertises you know about 90 minutes it feels about

right for this one and the the up time as well is is quick there's not really any um there's not too much scope for analysis paralysis or just bogging turns down um maybe when you end up taking the um the forge action and you want to do the whole three buildings maybe and pay for your um pay for your workers to move up the scaffolding whatever and of course if you want to play cards or rosettes as well that's additionally more time so sometimes sometimes can be longer than others but it's certainly not a game that's um gonna lose your interest or you're gonna be bored when it's someone else's turn um the replayability is really good with this one to be fair there is lots of buildings as you can see and of course not all of them are going to show up in each game a big deck of cards there with special abilities the upgrade tiles there's a whole stack of those and those are really interesting in fact i really do like the way that some of these work you know let's take a look at some of them here you know so you can convert cards into coal golds are now a wild resource and so on you know you whenever you send a worker um i think you get an additional ribbon and so on so there's lots of different things you can go on and as i said they do sometimes combine with each other to give you very powerful benefits so yeah there's there's some good variability there um the interaction in the game as well there is a little bit of um you know getting to places quicker than others or other players that is because i said some of these some of these spots become particularly good um for certain sizes of um of your

workers and getting in there before other players can sometimes be valuable so um you know for example here you know i might want to if that work wasn't there that spot's particularly good because i can use both machines and use getter tools as well and even get a whistle so some spots do become very inviting and you know even if if that's starting to benefit one player more than another you can end up just adding to the um you know adding to the scaffolding and trying to maybe nullify it a bit so i do like that aesthetically i think the game looks nice and bright and vibrant and you know full of life i do like the the graphic design here it's nice and crisp and clean um you know a different kind of approach to a game like this you know these worker placement games is normally a bit more of a dusty euro feel whereas this one's nice and bright and alive and just pretty light-hearted and i do like the graphic design here it's nice and um nice and simple but it works well and component quality is really good here i like the um i like i love the worker pieces you know these are nice chunky wooden blocks the all the scaffolding fits together well it all just comes together nicely yeah these these um water strips kind of work well as well so you know there's nothing really here that i can complain about uh you know the player boards particularly i really like the way that everything fits together and just um it just just it's just a nice production overall without being completely overdone and certainly um you know it certainly isn't anything to worth complaining about even though even the resources you know they

all work really well the only thing i would complain about is that the points themselves um are tokens and i you know i'd rather have a score track and you end up just completely just taking so many of these points and converting them to each other and it's a bit of a faff but no real issue there the theme is slightly different as well as i said it works with the with the aesthetic of the game this kind of steam punky um vibe i don't really quite get it but it works and they set up and tear down time as well not too much of an issue um you know just just like setting up the buildings and scaffolding and things but if you prepare them in their own bags then it's um certainly not going to be an issue um the progression in the game i mean i mean two minds about so so first off i love the way that the board develops as the game goes on so create constantly creating new work replacement spots getting more and more powerful abilities by your upgrades here so i do like that sensor progression the only thing that i found in my personal experience is that i find that as the game goes on it's quite forgiving in terms of giving you loads and loads of resources and you never really have that struggle of trying to build things now maybe somebody else has a different experience for me and it's just the way that things have played out when i've played it but i found that you know when you kind of meet reach that halfway slash 75 percent way through the game your engine is so efficient that you just end up wanting to constantly build and build and build and build and you you always have the resources to do so but you know maybe because the layout of the

board it's going to play out differently each time but just a slight observation i had there and um the the scalability as well works perfectly fine at all player counts um obviously the board is going to be a bit tighter but um you know you're gonna just building building the scaffolding wider and um filling up all those gaps and comparison wise yeah this is a pretty standard work placement game in a lot of ways but that extra element of constructing the board as you go this as i said this kind of polyamino mechanism the the spatial element just makes this game a step better than the average worker placement games because i really do find work placement games are just almost like a rinse and repeat style game where you just stick a different skin on it and maybe change the resources up a bit and it's just the same game over and over again you know collect collect collect build but this one with that extra wrinkle the extra element of the engine building i think does take a step above and it certainly does have a certain quality about it which a lot of these mediocre games don't have and um that's that's it pretty much i mean i i really did enjoy this game i think it certainly um warranted the attention it's got in terms of people being surprised about how well this one plays i mean i love the the welcoming look of it it's so it's nice light and easy to play but it still hasn't been interesting decisions now i particularly like this water aspect when you have the pressure of trying to get your workers up and um you know promote them into onto the scaffolding to get underground points i love the um i said they love the

engine style here which you can really focus on getting these cool tiles so yeah it all together it comes together really well for me and um you know not traditionally something i would go for or maybe by myself but i certainly wouldn't turn down a game with this and would put it so much higher on on my list of work replacement games than um a lot of the other titles out there which people seem to love so i think if you if you want like a gateway plus level game you know something to take you to that next level maybe around the weight of wingspan then i would certainly recommend giving this one a go and i have no doubt that this is going to be a monster hit because it's just it just has all everything going for it really and um nothing to kind of unwelcome people to it are nothing to there's no real barrier here to prevent lesser experienced players enjoying it but it also has a lot of things going on on it that that's more than enough to satisfy maybe more salty gamers so uh certainly against my seal of quality there's again it's it's a well put together game um and takes that work placement level to where it needs to be to keep my interest so that is uh whistle mountain um i hope you've enjoyed the review if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved