Got Five! Review - Logic, Deduction & Bright Candy Pieces!
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. And today I'm reviewing Got 5 from Blue Orange Games. Got 5 is a deduction game for two to four players in which players are trying to figure out the order of their sequence over here. Hopefully, you can see this over here. The order of their sequence before the other players can do so. The way they're going to do this is they're going to start by being able to see the other players' numbers. That means I can currently see that this player, for example, has an 8, 15, 16, 24, and 57. So, I'm going to go ahead I'm going to move this cuz you don't need this right now, but in theory you'd have it. I'm going to go ahead and mark off eight so we can go to this board. The eight is on the blue. We're going to mark that off. The 15, the 16, the 24, and then the 57. We're going to mark those off. Then I'm going to do the exact same thing with this player's numbers because I can see this player's numbers. Keeping in mind they can't.
Each player can see every other player's numbers. They cannot see their own. So, I'm going to go ahead and mark off a 17 over here. We're going to mark off 34. We're going to mark off 45. And then we're going to mark off 51. And then lastly, I can see the numbers on the table that are currently out. There's going to be one of each color to start the game off with. And I can see a three, five. So, our three is over here. We have our five of orange. We have our 11 of green, our 44, and our 47. So, 44 and 47. These numbers are marked off and none of mine are those numbers. Now, we can start taking turns, but before we do so, we can go ahead and deduce more information. For example, we know that our highest number is an orange. If our highest number is an orange, then we can go ahead and mark off some of the lower orange numbers that wouldn't possibly be viable. For example, an orange cannot be a 10 right now because if orange was a 10, we don't have five numbers that would make sense that would be lower.
You can't have this eight. In fact, we know that the orange has to be at least a 13 because the lowest the blue can be is currently a 13. Similarly, we can do the same exact thing on the reverse side over here. We know that this red cannot be 59 because if it was 59, you'd have to have a pink, a blue higher than that, and that's not possible if red is 59. In fact, we know that pink is not 57 and therefore pink is at most 52. So, the red has to be also lower than 52. So, we're going to go ahead and mark off this 54. The same logic applies to the green. The green cannot be the 56 because green would have to be higher than that. You can go ahead and try to figure out information as you go through. I'm not going to do all of it right now, but that's the general idea of what you're doing. Because of the fact that your row is ordered from lowest to highest and you can see a variety of numbers, you can start figuring out information. That's the basics of the game. But then from there, you're going to go ahead on your turn, you reveal a number. You go ahead and say, "Look, we have a 55. I can now mark off orange is not 55. It can still be 60, but it cannot be 55 because, well, there's a 55 in play." At which point I can go ahead and ask a player question.
So, for example, I can say, "I would like to know where you would put this 11 over here. Where would you put this 11 on my board?" Now, this is where I'm going to have to actually look at my numbers cuz I don't actually otherwise know, but it looks like the 11 is going to go over here. That's where it would go. It would go in between these the the six and the 14 over here. So, I know therefore that everything a red higher has to be 14 or greater. We can't have nine, we can't have four, we can't have the two, the seven. We already knew those the 14, the 11 over here. So, this could in theory the blue could in theory be 13, but that would be rough because if that's 13, the lowest red can be is 14, so blue can't be 13. Therefore as well, pink can't be 12 by the same logic. We know the 11 cannot be any of these because it has to be lower. Meaning the green has to be lower than 11 and we can start deducing information through a single question. You basically pick a number and you say, "Where in my board does it go?" Then the other players take their turns, they'll go ahead and reveal a number, you can go ahead and reveal it to the pool, they do the same thing, they have this, they put it there, we cross off numbers. Also, I see the 60. We now know the orange can't be 60, which gives us a lot of information because the highest orange can be now is 50. If the highest orange can be is 50, that's going to eliminate a bunch of these other numbers because we know they're orange they're they're lower than orange. So, blue cannot be 53 or 58, pink cannot be 52. That's the general puzzle. The other action you can do is when it gets back to my turn, I can reveal a new tile. I can mark off that 18 over there. That again gives me information cuz now the lowest eight lowest uh blue can be is 18, which means pink I don't actually know if that gives me that much information over there. Uh orange could still the orange can't be
20 because we can mark that off. Uh it could be 25 in theory, fine, whatever. Uh with with the these dots on the bottom, players can now ask other questions. So, you could for example say, "Okay, well, right now I know that green is either a one or a six." So, I'm going to say meaning uh one or a six over here are these two options. I can say, "Does the amount of dots on this match the amount of dots on that?" We're going to go ahead and check, and the answer is no, it does not. And so, we're going to put this on our board behind the board, tilt it sideways to remind us this does not match that. In this case, it doesn't actually matter because now we know that it's not a one, therefore it's a six. We've now marked off that this over here is a six. all happening behind our screen, but effectively you have two questions you can ask. Where in the number line does it go, and does the amount of dots match the amount of dots, which is a great way of eliminating other things and slowly piecing together more information. We have our red narrowed down to 14, 19, 29, 39, or 49.
49 seems impossible because if this be 49, that would have to be higher, so it's not 49. It could be 39 because then that that could jump to 42 and 48 and 50, so that's still possible. We're slowly pinpointing the various numbers. This is the puzzle you play when you play Got Five. What you're doing is you have a number line. You know the number line is in order, and you're going to be drawing various numbers which will slowly reduce the amount of options on your board. But as you do that, you're also asking questions as to where certain numbers go in order to break up your number line, as well as get exact matches through the number of dots on a number. At any point, you can go ahead, your turn or not your turn, at any point you can go ahead and say, "I got five." I don't actually know if you shout that out, but you You say I got five, or you could just say I'm going to go ahead and guess. At which point you can say, "Okay, well, I know this is lower, but I don't know how low. It's probably not a 39. I'm going to go ahead and say that this is a uh 14." I actually remember seeing that as 14. I don't remember the rest of the numbers here, so we're going to do the rest of this uh by by feel.
So, that's a 14. We're going to go over here and say this is I mean, this is a big gap. I would not have guessed this early. So, if our our our orange is up here, the chance of being a 50 are possible, but slim. I'm going to say the orange is 40. That's going to bring our our blue down to 30 33. We'll go with 33. I'm just literally guessing at this point. I would never do this this early, just for the record. And we'll put that as 27. Let's see how much my subconscious helped me. We have none of those right. Uh this was indeed 50. This is 43, 37, 14, which I knew, and six. We got one of those two of those right, and those are the two I had seen. But again, I normally wouldn't guess this early. That's how you play Got Five. You are slowly deducing information as you try to figure out what is on your board, and you try to do so sooner than the other players, and you try to make your guess either when you have perfect information, or when it seems other players might be too close to go ahead and make their own guesses, either through perfect information or taking that last shot, and see if you can win Got Five. Which brings me to a review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking in this game. Starting off with what I like. In general, the game has great components, very simple rule set, very easy to teach, great table presence. These are adorable little like, you know, eyes on the back.
That's a fun little like, you know, just a little neat quick trick that you're looking at the back over here and seeing a degree of degree of character on these tiles. And it has a charming accessibility to the gameplay. It's an excellent intro to deduction game. The game gives you just enough locked-in information. These numbers are out of play. That's perfect information. And it gives you just that little little extra bit of deductive aspect past that. Sure, I know it can't be a red 44 because that's out of play. But slowly, I can kind of piece together my board and make other deduction calls as far as, "Well, if this isn't that, then the order of the number line means that these things are out of play, and you are slowly to get piecing and pieces of information." It's not so much that it's overwhelming and it's not so little as to be meaningless. It's just the right amount in order to be a game that is not purely just, you know, bingo and crossing things off, but rather is a game of actually piecing together information and it does so with again a a great rule set and entry to a very accessible rule set as well as a charming degree of components and a light degree of accessibility to it. So overall, it's a light intro to a intro to deduction game. As far as what I don't like in the game, outside of that minor amount of deduction, it is mostly just crossing off numbers. Oh, that 16 is gone. Oh, that 22 is gone. That means the two, seven, and 12 are gone as well.
You are for the most part making a few judgment calls, but but for the most part, it's you see a few pieces of information, you make a few judgment calls, and you move on from there. While this game does a great job of being an intro to deduction game, the downside of that it means that there isn't a next level. I would have loved this game almost had a degree of extra strategy to it that you're like, okay, level one is this, but then level two is something else. I don't even know what that could have been. I'm not a designer. I'm just a critic over here. I think this nailed the intro to deduction, but it did so at the cost of having more more nuance to the gameplay once you master that aspect. The other criticism I have is that when you get to the end game, the late game so to speak, it does come down to either guessing with not enough information or doing a whole lot of this is a two. Is this the exact same number of dots as a two? Look at that, it's not. Okay, we can mark off these additional numbers because it's not a two. So you're going to have that little extra element as the late game being less fun deduction. The first the early game, it is fun to mark off large swaths of numbers through a degree of deductive reasoning. When you get to the late game, it's mostly like I have this narrowed down to these two numbers. This one is two dots. This one is three dots.
Ask the question or make a guess. And so the late game is less satisfying than the early game in this game. As far as I can see others not liking, there definitely is luck of the draw. You'll see people drawing numbers and being like, oh my gosh, that eliminates this and that gives me information. And meanwhile, you're like, that's useless. I knew that the red 44 was out of play 10 turns ago. And the information you got was helpful, the information I got wasn't. This definitely does have some degree of luck of the draw. And then also, it's still deduction. As much as a great as much as it's a great intro to deduction, if you don't like deduction as a general concept, I don't think this is going to change your mind. As far as final thoughts on Got 5, I find this game kind of charming. It's a charming game. It's fun. The first time I sat down to play this, I played it five times in a row. That's the kind of charm it has to it. Literally we all sat like, okay, let's do it again. Let's do it again. Let's do it again. I think it has a great degree of gateway deduction. I've said this so many times in the video, but I'm going to stick with that aspect. I think this is great for gateway deduction. I don't think it is good for long-term deduction. I think it's the kind of game that I would keep either for the various gateway people and or family members who might prefer something on the lighter side, but I don't think it has longevity outside of that core group because it tops out once you've kind of played through that basic puzzle. There's a limit to the amount you can do with this game. There's a limit to the amount of strategic deduction you're actually making or the logical leaps you're trying to connect. It does a great job of being gateway, but does so at the cost of, well, everything else. I'm going to give it a 3.5 out of 5. It still is, again, a game that I sit down and play the first time and then immediately play it four times more and then return to it again the next week.
Like it is it is a good enough game and a fun enough game. Just know what you're getting out of this one. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Bomb Busters if you're looking for a very well-rated, well-reviewed a cooperative deduction game if you're looking for that instead. And check out Fugitive if you're looking for a similar kind of cross things out as you go with just enough deductive reasoning as well for a two-player head-to-head head-to-head hunt. It's a hunt. One player is kind of hiding, the other player is using that kind of crossing off to figure out where the player could be. I mentioned that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games from both All Play as well as various partner publishers. And if you're in the US, you can get all for $4 flat rate shipping. Check out A Message from the Stars if you're looking for a game that definitely takes you very quickly to the next level. Like this is not intro to deduction. This one has a lot going on, but check out a message from the stars if you're looking for a cooperative or head-to-head deduction game in which you're trying to communicate with aliens and cross things out and use a whole lot of word play along the way. And in any case until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you found this review helpful and as always, I hope you have a good one.