Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shallow Sea Board Game Review

Transcript 9:15

Hello, welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, don't do playthroughs anymore, sadly, but today we're going to be looking at a toll line game. We're going to be looking at Shallow Sea. And in this game, you'll be putting tiles onto a board, hoping to connect fish with their habitats in order to give you victory points that will hopefully allow you to win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, telling you what we do like, what we don't like, and we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Shallow Sea is worth your time. and bother today and in the future. So remember, if you're new here, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, all that YouTube [ __ ] See you after this,

B. So, Shallow Sea, how do you play this game? So, Shallow Sea is a very, very basic tile laying game. Yeah, you're going to do something that you've probably already done in a game called Cascadia. You're going to stick some different colored fish tokens in the center of the table. You put some coral tiles up above them and then you'll put some sea life tiles below them. And basically on your turn, you're going to do just a couple of easy peasy things. You're going to choose a fish from the display and then you'll get to choose either a coral tile or a sea life tile from the bottom display. Right. You'll then put the fish and the selected tile in your ocean, which is your playerboard. Yeah. Doesn't really matter which order you do. You could put the fish on first, or you could put the tile on first. It's up to you. They must be placed front side up.

So, you can't put the completed side down first, obviously, cuz you haven't [ __ ] completed it yet, have you? And they must be placed adjacent to a tile that already exists in your ocean. Also, get to rotate the tile in any direction. So, you could put a yellow on a yellow if you wanted. Fish, on the other hand, have to go on one of them little bubble things around the tile spaces. Yeah, just chuck them on there and they'll be like a bubbleishious, won't they? So once you've done that, if any of the tiles on your board have met the scoring condition, then you're going to flip them over and score them. Right? A coral tile is completed when all the different colored sides have fish of that color on them. You'll take a fish off of the board, flip the tile over, and you'll stick that fish on that coral. Yeah. And as a reward, you will gain a [ __ ] sea shell just like the one out of demolition man.

You got this little shelf with three sea shells on it.

Completing a sea tile, on the other hand, is a little bit more complicated, but not really. There's loads of different sea off tiles for you to complete. Not going to go through all of them, but you might see ones with some arrows going off to one side, and it will tell you that you need to have fish that are the same color or maybe like the different color going off in those directions for that number of tiles, right? So, if you got two arrows going off in the northwest or northeast, then you'll have to have two, say, red fish on two tiles going that way, right? You flip the tile over and you will gain that many points and you'll get a sea shell for that. Yeah, you can use sea shells for a number of different things. You can give up a sea shell to refresh one of the free pools like the fish, the coral tiles, all the sea life tiles. You can spend a sea shell to choose which tile you want by not being bound by the fish that you choose, right? And you can also spend two sea shells to move an incomplete fish. So, if you got a red fish over here and you want it to complete something over here, you spend two sea shells to pick it up and dump it in front of a [ __ ] Norwegian troller.

Right. So, you keep doing this until each player has got four empty spaces left on their board. Then you do a little bit of final scoring, right? You'll score an ecosystem card at the beginning of the game. You're going to draw two. Or if you're using the expansion, then you'll only have one. You'll score victory points for all the tiles you completed and some of the incomplete ones that you didn't complete. Two victory points for each different sea life tile that you completed and one victory point for each incomplete fish adjacent to a completed coral tile. Right. Little word about the expansion. Right. There's an expansion for this called uh feeding grounds or something. Basically gives you more [ __ ] You got a side board with some extra scoring opportunities. So, it might be the first player to do this will be able to put one of their turtles on the high scoring spot. And then the second player to do that will put it on the second one. There's three of these. They're all random. There's shitloads of them. And it just adds even more scoring opportunities to a game that provides a plethora of scoring opportunities. So, when that is over, the player with the most victory points will be the winner of Shallow Sea. So, what do we like about Shallow Sea?

So, the first thing that we like about this is the insane amount of variety. I mean, there's like three [ __ ] trays of different tiles that you can [ __ ] about with you got the expansion. It's going to add even more into the mix. So, you're going to choose a number of these dependent on the player count, dump them in a bag, and then you're going to draw them out randomly. Right. There are so many different types of tiles in this game. I've kind of lost count. I mean, because of this, each game is going to be completely different. Yeah, there's no one overriding strategy aside from maybe putting your seed off of tiles in the best position. Usually the center, I would imagine, depending on what it is, of course. Yeah, there's no real one strategy that you're going to be able to use to win this game. You're going to have to adapt yet. And I suppose this does favor players that have played the game multiple times. But then again, if you haven't played it multiple times, then that's on you in it. Put your finger out your [ __ ] [ __ ] and get on it. So, the second thing that we quite like about this is that this is yet another stunning production from Bad Comet. Yeah, this looks absolutely [ __ ] fantastic. The ocean tile is a little bit bland. Then after a few turns, it comes to life grimming with color. The fish tokens a little bit fiddly, but they're functional. They're really nice. And you got the obligatory silk style bags are going to be used to hold all the fish and all that. Yeah.

So, I can't fault the production. The artwork's [ __ ] fantastic. Bad Comet hit the ball out of the park yet again with their stunning production values. So, the final thing that we really like about this is the way the game makes each tile have various permutations based on where you place it. Yeah, you can rotate the tile any which way you want. So, you can match up certain colors that are going to allow you to utilize fish twice, for instance. Yeah. But you can set it up so that assuming that the tile that you want or the fish that you want stays in the market, you can set it up so that on your next turn once you've taken that fish away, you can place another fish there to score another tile. Yeah, it's a very, very clever design. it is a bit of a brain burner. Yeah. So, if you're looking for something that doesn't make your head implode after being fooled by the very very simple mechanics, then probably avoid this one. But for me, I quite enjoy that mind-numbing sensation where you're sort of juggling loads of things in your brain at once. Right. Don't we like a shallow sea?

So, the first thing that we don't like about it is that towards the end of the game, you kind of know when you have lost yet. And that means that the final couple of turns are largely inconsequential. Both for the players that know that they're far behind or that they've lost or even for the player that is far ahead because they're thinking doesn't really matter what I do now because I know I've spanked my opponent's asses with a proverbial baking tray. So yeah, there's not really any kind of surprises at the end of this. Every game we played of this has led to me either celebrating my win early or just shrug my shoulders and go, it's a [ __ ] lost cause. Yeah. So really this game only exists in my mind for the first two/3s dependent on where you are towards the end. Dictates your mood at the end. So the final thing and the biggest pain in the ass about this game is when you are done putting all the tiles back into their respective slots in the trays is one of the biggest pains in the ass while. Yeah. If you look at the tiles, yeah, they've all got little codes on.

The rule book does give you a guide as to how to pull these out. And putting them back into their little slots means you're going to have to sort them out into A1, A2, A3, B3, B7, and all that sort of thing. Stack them all up and then put them back individually. And the code is in white. So, it's very difficult to see. At my venerable age, I was pulling what's left of my hair out of my [ __ ] head, trying to sort this [ __ ] out. Yeah. for a very simple short game. The amount of effort you've got to go to to pack it away so that it's ready for the next one is it's a [ __ ] ball. But to summarize, is Shallow Sea worth your time and bother today and in the future? We're going to say maybe, maybe not. Shallow Sea is a decent game. Yeah, it offers a decent brain burning experience contained within yet another lavish production from Bad Comet. It just doesn't hit the heights of their other offerings like Life of the Amazonia or Wondrous Creatures. The expansion is functional. It adds some extra scoring opportunities, but it doesn't really add that much more. I don't know if that's a good or a bad thing. Maybe it could have added a little bit more complexity, but then I suppose this game's up against other similar stuff like Cascadia and Harmonies and all that. So, it didn't want to push the boat out too far, no pun included, because of this. I suppose, you know, it's just an average game in it. You're either going to like it or you're not. There's not really much in here to grab people's attention.

I think it's going to sort of just sail on by, spring a leak, and sink to the bottom of the seabed in the same time that it took to appear on the shelf. So, there you go. That is a shallow sea. Remember, if you're new here, then consider subscribing to the channel. If you're already subscribed, then go and [ __ ] eat a scone, not a scone. And we'll see you next time.

Progress saved